PEERE Towards an interdisciplinary approach to peer review: theory, models and data

Transcription

1 PEERE Towards an interdisciplinary approach to peer review: theory, models and data TD COST Action TD1306 PEERE New Frontiers of Peer Review October 14-15, 2014 Corvinus University of Budapest

2 The aim of this meeting is to review the state of the art of peer review in various domains, define available and missing links between theory, models and data and identify the main challenges for studying and improving peer review. Invited speakers are: Michèle Lamont (Harvard University) Tom Jefferson (The Cochrane Collaboration) Brad Wible (Science) Participants include: Aliaksandr Birukou (Springer-Verlag) Fiona Hutton (Wiley-Blackwell) Joris Van Rossum (Elsevier) PEERE New Frontiers of Peer Review Chair and scientific contact: Flaminio Squazzoni University of Brescia Local organization: Károly Takács MTA TK Lendület RECENS and Corvinus University of Budapest

3 Towards an interdisciplinary approach to peer review Monday, October 13 18:45 Meeting at Kálvin tér, in front of the church for informal dinner Tuesday, October 14, Main Building, Auditorium III 8:00 Registration 8:30 Welcome 8:40 The PEERE Action Flaminio Squazzoni, Chair 9:00 Peer review and fairness for all: under what conditions? Michèle Lamont, Harvard University 10:00 Opening the black box of peer review Tom Jefferson, Cochrane Collaboration 11:00 Coffee break 11:30 Peer review research as a scientific discipline: History of Peer Review Congresses ( ) Ana Marušic, University of Split 11:50 How competition impacts innovation, diversity and fairness of peer review Stefano Balietti, ETH Zurich 12:10 Simulating peer review: a few bad apples are enough Francisco Grimaldo, University of Valencia 12:30 Mathematical models of three aspects of peer review Nikolay K. Vitanov and Zlatinka I. Dimitrova, Bulgarian Academy of Sciences 13:00 Lunch, Soul Café Restaurant, Ráday utca :30 Peer review in practice and evolution at Science magazine Brad Wible, Science 15:30 Quality of science vs. quality of peer review Elise Brezis, Bar-Ilan University 15:50 Peer review experiments at Elsevier Joris Van Rossum, Elsevier 16:10 Coffee break 16:30 Roundtable and debate 17:30 Closing 18:45 Meeting in front of the Main Building (Danube side) 19:00 Meeting at Kálvin tér, in front of the church for workshop dinner 1

4 PEERE: New Frontiers of Peer Review Wednesday, October Working groups (three parallel sessions) Locations: Working Group 1: New Building: Room 510 Working Group 2: New Building, Room Aquarium of the Main Library Working Group 3: Main Building: Room Coffee break, in front of Auditorium III (Main Building) Working groups (three parallel sessions) Locations: Working Group 1: New Building: Room 510 Working Group 2: New Building, Room Aquarium of the Main Library Working Group 3: Main Building: Room :00 Lunch, Soul Café Restaurant, Ráday utca Working groups (three parallel sessions) Locations: Working Group 1: New Building: Room 510 Working Group 2: New Building, Room 428 (note the change) Working Group 3: Main Building: Room WG reports in plenary, Main Building, Auditorium III Coffee break Management Committee meeting, Main Building, Auditorium III Closing 19:00 Dinner, IF Restaurant, Ráday utca 19 2

5 Towards an interdisciplinary approach to peer review The Main Building, location of the plenary sessions The location of the plenary sessions is Auditorium III in the Main Building of the Corvinus University of Budapest. The address is: Budapest, Fővám tér 8. Auditorium III is located on the ground floor. When you enter into the building from the Danube side, walk through the hall and you will find the auditorium on your right. The New Building of the Corvinus University of Budapest Two parallel sessions take place in the New Building. The address is: Közraktár utca 4-6. Room C510 is on the 5 th floor and the Aquarium Room is on the 1 st floor. You will need to enter the Main Library door in order to get into the Aquarium Room. 3

6 PEERE: New Frontiers of Peer Review How to get from the Airport to the city center and back Budapest has one airport: Ferenc Liszt International Airport. All major airlines and low-cost airlines have this airport as a destination. To get into the city from the airport you could use a taxi (approx. 22 euro), a minibus (approx. 12 euro), or public transport. If you opt for public transport, take the 200E bus first till the end and then get on the blue metro line 3 from Kőbánya Kispest till Kálvin tér metro station (approx euro=3 euro). For further information about the airport and how to get into the city, please, consult this webpage: How to find your way to the workshop location The Corvinus University Campus has two large buildings. The older Main Building is at Fővám tér. The New Building is found to the south of the Main Building (and south of the Main Market Hall) at Közraktár utca 4-6. Internet WiFi: workshop-wifi Password: 2001corv14 4

7 Lunch & Dinner Locations Kálvin tér/kalvin square, meeting place for Monday and Tuesday dinners Tuesday workshop dinner: in a historical flat restaurant, 20 EUR Soul Café Restaurant, Tuesday and Wednesday lunch, 13.00, 4000 HUF (13 EUR)

8 if Jazz Café Restaurant, Wednesday dinner, 19.00