DISTRICT PLAN REVIEW SUBCOMMITTEE PUBLIC EXCLUDED AGENDA

Transcription

1 DISTRICT PLAN REVIEW SUBCOMMITTEE PUBLIC EXCLUDED AGENDA WEDNESDAY 2 SEPTEMBER AM AM COUNCIL CHAMBER, LEVEL 2, CIVIC OFFICES, 53 HEREFORD STREET Subcommitt: Th Mayor (Chairprso) Coucillors Vicki Buck, Jimmy Ch, Phil Clarwatr, Pauli Cottr, David East, Jami Gough, Yai Johaso, Ali Jos, Gl Livigsto, Paul Losdal, Raf Maji, Tim Scadrtt ad Adrw Turr Pricipal Advisr Brigitt d Rod Tlpho: Committ Advisr Chris Turr Tlpho PART A - MATTERS REQUIRING A COUNCIL DECISION PART B - REPORTS FOR INFORMATION PART C - DELEGATED DECISIONS INDEX ITEM NO. DESCRIPTION PAGE NO. PART C 1. APOLOGIES 1 PART B 2. DECLARATION OF INTEREST 1 PART C 3. CHRISTCHURCH CITY COUNCIL SUBMISSION TO STAGE 3 DISTRICT PLAN REVIEW PROPOSALS, MAPS AND S32 DOCUMENTS 3 PART B 4. MAIL SITE UPDATE 45

2

3 DISTRICT PLAN REVIEW SUBCOMMITTEE PUBLIC EXCLUDED 1 1. APOLOGIES Coucillor Adrw Turr 2. DECLARATION OF INTEREST Mmbrs ar rmidd of th d to b vigilat to stad asid from dcisio makig wh a coflict ariss btw thir rol as a mmbr ad ay privat or othr xtral itrst thy might hav.

4 2

5 3 Christchurch City Coucil Submissio to Stag 3 District Pla viw Proposals, Maps ad S32 Documts frc: 15/ Cotact: Brigitt d Rod 1. Purpos ad Origi of port Purpos of port Brigitt.drod@ccc.govt.z Pho: Th purpos of this rport is for th District Pla viw Sub Committ to approv th draft CCC Submissio, s Attachmts 1 to Stag 3 of th proposd Christchurch placmt District Pla as otifid o 25 July Th Stag 3 submissio priod closs o 4 Sptmbr Origi of port 1.2. This rport is staff gratd. 2. Sigificac 2.1. Th dcisio(s) i this rport rat as low sigificac i rlatio to th Christchurch City Coucil s Sigificac ad Egagmt Policy. 3. Staff commdatios That th District Pla viw Subcommitt: 3.1. Approv th draft submissio attachd as Attachmts 1-6 to this rport to b lodgd as a Coucil submissio to th Stag 3 proposals of th District Pla. 4. Ky Poits 4.1. This rport supports th Coucil's Log Trm Pla ( ): Activity: District Plaig Lvl of Srvic: Prpar th placmt District Pla i two stags 4.2. Th followig fasibl optios hav b cosidrd: Optio 1 - adopt ad lodg th draft CCC Stag 3 submissio (with amdmts as agrd by th Subcommitt) Optio 2 - Do othig (do ot submit a CCC submissio o Stag 3 proposals) 4.3. Optio Summary - Advatags ad Disadvatags (Prfrrd Optio) Th advatags of this optio iclud: that it provids crty to othr partis i kowig what th Coucil is proposig with rgard to ay chags th Coucil wishs to mak to its' proposals Th disadvatags of this optio iclud: Thr ar o. Th officrs who hav had iput ar awar of th d for various chags to improv cosistcy ad clarity.

6 4 5. Cotxt/Backgroud 5.1 Th coucil is rviwig its District Pla (which icluds th oprativ City Pla ad Baks Pisula District Pla). Th procss for th rviw is st out i th Ordr of Coucil (OiC) titld "Catrbury Earthquak placmt District Pla) Ordr Th third ad fial st of Coucil proposals was otifid o 25 July for submissios. Submissios clos o 4 Sptmbr. Udr th OiC, Schdul 1 Claus 6, th Coucil ad ay prso may mak a submissio to th harigs pal o th proposal/s withi th allottd timfram. Th draft submissio poits ca b foud i Attachmt 1 - Tabl of Submissios whil th backgroud iformatio ad maps ca b foud i Attachmts 2 to 6). By far th largst umbr of proposd submissios dal with corrctios to isur accuracy of schduld hritag itms ad sttigs icludig ladscaps ad mattrs of cosistcy amogst othr proposals. 5.2 It should b otd that th shadd draft submissios rlat to mior poits oly. 5.3 Pag 3, itm 8, icluds chags to Hazard ovrlays o maps rlatig to th formr FLFMAs ow Flood Maagmt Aras du to dcisios rcivd o th Stag 1 atural hazards proposal. Maps ar also amdd i som aras for high flood hazard aras, ad flood podig aras. 5.4 Subdivisio ruls hav b trasfrrd from th SPZ (Flat Lad covry) to th subdivisio ad Earthworks chaptr (proposal) 8 i ordr to b cosistt with th layout of othr chaptrs (Pag 5, itm 17). 5.5 A additioal ovrlay of Aras of Charactr i th Coastal Eviromt, which was iadvrttly lft out, is to b addd to assist with th itrprtatio of objctivs, policis ad ruls. Pag 7, itm 25). 5.6 Som rsidtial aras i th wst of th Port Hills hav b icludd i th Outstadig Fatur ad Ladscap ovrlay, which if lft as it, would impos rstrictiv ladscap ruls o futur rsidtial subdivisio (Pags 11, 12, itms 39 ad 40). Whil this is idtifid as a 'mior poits', it is a good xampl of a submissio poit that is dd to sur itgratio across chaptrs. 5.7 Nw coditios ar rcommdd to b addd to two of th sigatios o Stat Itgratd Schools - Catholic Primary School i Mairhau ad Middlto Grag School about acoustic fcig, hritag buildigs ad schduld trs (Pag 27, itm 87). 5.8 I proposal 13 Ctral city - it is rcommdd that furthr assssmt critria b addd for th sidtial zo (sit dsity) ad Trasport vhicl accss ruls. Thr ar a umbr of othr miscllaous amdmts across th Ctral City zos (Pags 29-32).

7 5 5.9 Thr ar o draft submissios icludd at this stag rlatig to th coastal hazards ovrlays (coastal iudatio maagmt aras 1 ad 2 ad th coastal rosio maagmt aras 1 ad 2) or th batchs to b rmovd at Taylors Mistak, Bouldr Bay ad Hobso's Bay. A rqust has go to th Chair of th Idpdt Harigs Pal, accompaid by a lgal mmo, to hav th submissios timfram xtdd for aothr 6 wks for ths two mattrs ( which rlat to part oly of Proposal 5 - Hazards (coastal) ad all of Proposal 19 Coastal Eviromt). It is ot itdd to iclud ay submissios o ths mattrs subjct to rcivig approval by th Chair to th xtsios. Thr will b opportuity to lodg a CCC submissio to ths mattrs durig th xtdd timfram if cssary. Plas ot that 6 hard copis of Attachmts 2-6 will b mad availabl at th subcommitt mtig. Thy hav ot b pritd ad courird to you du to th larg cott of thos attachmts. 6. Optio 1 - Adopt th staff rcommdatio (with amdmts as agrd with th Subcommitt) Optio scriptio 6.1. As abov Sigificac 6.2. Th lvl of sigificac of this optio is low. Impact o Māori 6.3. This optio dos ot ivolv a sigificat dcisio i rlatio to lad or a body of watr or othr lmts of itrisic valu, thrfor this dcisio dos ot spcifically impact Māori, thir cultur ad traditios ay mor tha ay othr party. Commuity Viws ad Prfrcs 6.4. Ths proposd submissios hav ot b out for cosultatio ad for th most part oly clarify aspcts of th Stag 3 proposals. Th coucil's submissio will ot b mad public util th submissio is lodgd. Aligmt with Coucil Plas ad Policis 6.5. This optio is cosistt with Coucil s Plas ad Policis Fiacial Implicatios 6.6. Cost of Implmtatio, o Maitac / Ogoig Costs. o 6.8. Fudig sourc - th District Pla viw budgt for officr tim. Lgal Implicatios 6.9. No chags ca b mad by officrs to th Stag 3 proposals without approval by th subcommitt through a formal submissio. Risks ad Mitigatios Thr ar fw risks with ths submissios as for th most part thy improv th proposals by addig furthr clarity ad cosistcy. Implmtatio Implmtatio dpdcis. Whthr ths submissios ar accptd or ot will dpd o th Idpdt Harigs Pal ad will b dtrmid through harigs o th stag 3 chaptrs.

8 Implmtatio timfram. Th tir District Pla rviw must b compltd by April 2016 udr th Ordr i Coucil. Optio Summary - Advatags ad Disadvatags Th advatags of this optio iclud: Improvig clarity, cosistcy Th disadvatags of this optio iclud: No 7. Optio 2 - Do othig (lodg o submissio) Optio scriptio 7.1. As abov Sigificac 7.2. Th lvl of sigificac of this optio is low cosistt with sctio 2 of this rport. No gagmt rquird outsid of th mdiatios ad IHP procss for harigs. Impact o Māori 7.3. This optio dos ot ivolv a sigificat dcisio i rlatio to lad or a body of watr or othr lmts of itrisic valu, thrfor this dcisio dos ot spcifically impact Māori, thir cultur ad traditio ay mor or lss tha ay mmbr of th public. Commuity Viws ad Prfrcs 7.4. Not applicabl. Aligmt with Coucil Plas ad Policis 7.5. Not applicabl. Fiacial Implicatios 7.6. Cost of Implmtatio - o 7.7. Maitac / Ogoig Costs - o 7.8. Fudig sourc - o Lgal Implicatios 7.9. Mor tim is spt i mdiatios or o rvisd proposals through vidc writig to iclud ths mattrs for cosidratio ad xplaatio. By puttig i a submissio othr partis will kow what th Coucil itds to do to furthr clarify ad improv cosistcy across th proposals. Risks ad Mitigatios S abov Implmtatio Implmtatio dpdcis - o Implmtatio timfram - o Optio Summary - Advatags ad Disadvatags Th advatags of this optio iclud: o

9 Th disadvatags of this optio iclud: That th mattrs will still d to b raisd through mdiatios or harigs. A submissio will giv crty to othr partis to kow what th Coucil is itdig. Cofirmatio of Statutory Compliac Compliac with Statutory cisio-makig quirmts (ss Local Govrmt Act 2002). (a) This rport cos: (i) sufficit iformatio about all rasoably practicabl optios idtifid ad assssd i trms of thir advatags ad disadvatags; ad (ii) adquat cosidratio of th viws ad prfrcs of affctd ad itrstd prsos barig i mid ay proposd or prvious commuity gagmt. (b) Th iformatio rflcts th lvl of sigificac of th mattrs covrd by th rport, as dtrmid i accordac with th Coucil's sigificac ad gagmt policy. Sigatoris Author Approvd By Nam Brigitt d Rod Nam Kathri Harbrow Nam Brigitt d Rod Nam Mik Thl Titl City Plaig Uit Maagr Fiac Maagr Uit Maagr City Plaig Chif Plaig Officr

10 8

11 9 CCC Submissio Stag 3 Attachmt 1 Tabl 1

12 10 f r Attachmt 1 Tabl 1 - CCC Submissio Stag 3 Spcific Provisio Submissio asos cisio Sought cisio Poit Codig Proposal Claus o./map o. Map Supp Opp Am asos ort os d 1. 2 fiitios fiitio of Altratio of a hritag itm Th proposd amdmt xcluds w or rplacmt hadstos, plaqus or pals i church gravyards ad cmtris othr tha closd cmtris. This will rduc costig rquirmts for w burials ad crmatios i church gravyards ad op cmtris which ar hritag itms. Th day-to-day us of church gravyards ad op cmtris will b simplr, with limitd pottial for impact o hritag valus fiitios fiitio of Earthworks A amdmt is rquird to th dfiitio of "arthworks" to xclud th Spcific Purpos (Burwood Lad ad sourc covry Park) Zo from th arthworks-rlatd provisios i th Subdivisio, vlopmt ad Earthworks Proposal. Th disposal of arthquak wast matrial o sit is ot cosidrd to fall withi th dfiitio of arthworks activity, so this xclusio maks it clar that th arthworks provisios do ot apply to this disposal activity. (Not: Th dfiitio of "arthworks" has volvd through th Stag 1 harigs, with th Coucil's rcommdd wordig for th dfiitio (as attachd to th Coucil's closig submissios o th fiitios harig datd 23 July 2015) has b usd as a bas to show th proposd amdmt). lt Add th followig to th d of th dfiitio: Altratio of a hritag itm mas ay modificatio or additio to a hritag itm, which impacts o hritag fabric. Altratio of a hritag itm icluds: a. prmat modificatio of, additio to, or prmat rmoval of, xtrior or itrior hritag fabric which is ot dcayd or damagd ad icluds partial dmolitio of a hritag itm; b. chags to th xistig surfac fiish through rpoitig or us of abrasiv or high prssur claig tchiqus, such as sad or watr blastig; c. prmat additio of fabric to th xtrior or itrior; ad d. rstoratio. I rlatio to a buildig, structur or fatur which forms part of a op spac hritag itm, altratio icluds:. modificatios or additios to buildigs, structurs or faturs; f. prmat modificatio or additio to gard or ladscapig layout, paths, pavig, circulatio or o-sit accss, walk or cycl ways; g. arthworks which chag th profil of th ladform (othr tha arthworks approvd by subdivisio cost); h. rmoval or trasplatig of matur trs; i. i rlatio to cmtris, w platig o, or immdiatly adjoiig, plots; ad j. w buildigs, structurs or faturs. Altratio of a hritag itm xcluds w or rplacmt hadstos, plaqus or pals i church gravyards ad cmtris othr tha closd cmtris. Add th followig to th d of th dfiitio of 'arthworks': Earthworks mas ay fillig, xcavatio, dpositio of or othr disturbac of arth, rock or soil o a sit, icludig: a. that which raiss groud lvl or chags th profil of th ladform; or b. that which ivolvs th iclusio or isrtio of othr matrials ito th groud for th purposs of rpairig a sit damagd by arthquaks or strgthig a sit i prparatio for th costructio of a buildig; or c. i rlatio to th istallatio of srvics or utilitis; or d. th costructio of tracks, firbraks ad ladigs; or. root rakig ad bladig. Earthworks do ot iclud th disposal of arthquak wast o a sit withi th Spcific Purpos (Burwood Ladfill ad sourc covry Park) Zo. DEF Altratio of a hritag itm DEF. Earthworks Attachmt 1 - Pag 1

13 11 f r Spcific Provisio Submissio asos cisio Sought cisio Poit Codig Proposal Claus o./map o. Map Supp Opp Am asos ort os d 3. 2 fiitios ad Proposal 9 ad Cultural 4. 2 fiitios Ay dfid trms b likd whr thy hav ot b i th otifid Proposals. fiitio of itm mov crmatorium from th dfiitio. A amdmt is rquird bcaus, i th cas of th crmatoria protctd i th Schdul of Sigificat Historic Placs, th buildigs ar listd as hritag itms whras th associatd op spacs ar listd as hritag sttigs. Op spac associatd with a crmatorium is thrfor icorrctly icludd i th dfiitio of 'hritag itm'. Thr is a d for a hyprlik btw th trm ad th dfid trm. Som may hav b missd. lt as follows: itm mas a try i th Schdul of Sigificat Historic Placs which mts th sigificac thrshold for listig i th District Pla. itms ca b: a. a buildig, buildigs or group of itrrlatd buildigs; b. a structur or fatur such as a bridg, moumt, gu mplacmt, whal pot or lamp stad; ad c. a op spac such as a squar, park, gard, or cmtry or crmatorium. No spcific amdmt sought. DEF. itm DEF Gral 5. Proposal 2 fiitios ad 9 ad Cultural Prmittd Activitis Tabl Claus P3 stadard a. (ii) To assist with clarity ad to avoid itrprtatio issus, th dfiitio of "improvd pastur" from th Oprativ Baks Pisula District Pla should b icludd i th prdp. To bttr clarify Rul Prmittd Activity Claus P3 stadard a. (ii) iclud th followig dfiitio i Chaptr 2: Improvd pastur mas a ara of pastur whr: a) xotic spcis ar visually th prdomiat vgtatio covr; ad b) th ara has b modifid or hacd by big subjctd to ithr cultivatio, irrigatio, ovr-sowig, topdrssig, or dirct drillig. DEF. Improvd pastur 6. 2 fiitios ad 9 ad Cultural 7. 5 Hazards (part) 8. 5 Hazards (part) fiitio of Sit of Ngāi Tahu cultural sigificac Ruls , 5.8.5, ad All plaig maps with atural hazard ovrlays mt is rquird to corrct sytax withi th dfiitio. Esurs us of trmiology i Stag 3 Hazard is cosistt with cisio 6 o th Stag 1 Hazard proposal. Th scod Hazard dcisio of th Harigs Pal rlatig to th plaig maps as follows: Sit of Ngāi Tahu cultural sigificac mas ay sit or ara idtifid: a. ay sit or ara idtifid as a ara of Statutory Ackowldgmt i th Ngāi Tahu Claims Sttlmt Act 1998; b. ay sit or ara vstd i th owrship of T Rūaga o Ngāi Tahu udr th Ngāi Tahu Claims Sttlmt Act 1998; c. lad which is hld as Māori lad or Māori rsrv lad; d. ay sit protctd i a atioal watr cosrvatio ordr as big outstadig i its cultural sigificac to Ngāi Tahu; or. ay othr sit idtifid i th District Pla or rgioal pla or show o th plaig maps of th District Pla or rgioal pla as big a culturally sigificat ladscap, a sit of wāhi tapu or wāhi taoga, or a sit which th Coucil holds iformatio o as big a silt fil. ruls 5.8.4, 5.8.5, ad by rplacig th trm "Floor Lvl ad Fill Maagmt Ara" with "Flood Maagmt Ara"; ad mak othr cosqutial amdmts to mak th trmiology usd i mappig lgds for activitis cosistt with that usd o cisio 6 o th Stag 1 Hazard Proposal. all plaig maps with atural hazard ovrlays to smooth dgs of all atural hazard floodig aras icludig Floor Lvl ad Fill Maagmt DEF. Sit of Ngāi Tahu cultural sigificac Rul Rul Rul Rul All affctd plaig maps Attachmt 1 - Pag 2

14 12 f r Spcific Provisio Submissio asos cisio Sought cisio Poit Codig Proposal Claus o./map o. Map Supp Opp Am asos ort os d 9. 5 Hazards (part) Hazards (part) Ruls d, ad a.vi.B fiitio of "ifrastructur" icludd a dirctio to smooth th dgs of Floor Lvl ad Fill Maagmt Aras ad Flood Podig Maagmt Aras to rmov 'zig-zag' dgs. This sam procss should b udrtak for mappig of all Stag 3 atural hazard floodig, podig ad coastal iudatio ovrlays o th mappig maps to sur cosistcy across both parts of th proposal, ad to mor accuratly rflct th atural boudaris of modlld floodabl aras.. Th us of "critical ifrastructur" i th ruls capturs a widr rag of activitis tha itdd ad could pottially iclud ifrastructur withi privatly owd sits. This dfiitio also ds to apply to coastal hazard maagmt aras.. ig th dfiitio of "ifrastructur" as usd i Rul to also iclud th us of this trm i rul for coastal hazard maagmt aras rstricts th applicatio of this rul ad avoids capturig a widr rag of activitis tha itdd such as ifrastructur withi privatly owd sits. lt Aras, Flood Podig Maagmt Aras, High Flood Hazard Maagmt Aras ad Coastal Iudatio Maagmt Aras. ruls d, ad a.vi.B by rplacig "critical ifrastructur" with "ifrastructur". dfiitio for "Ifrastructur" to stat: "For th purposs of Ruls ad , mas watr mais, swrag mais, pump statios ad rsrvoirs, lctricity tworks ad sub-statios, tlcommuicatio tworks, th stratgic road tworks, othr roads, rail ad bulk ful storag facilitis ad associatd piplis, but dos ot iclud srvics from th strt to rsidtial uits." Rul d Rul Rul a.vi DEF Ifrastructur Hazards (part) Hazards (part) Rul P7 Th Activity Spcific Stadard for rul P7, icorrctly stats "100m 2 " wh it should stat "100m 3 ". Rul , P7 I rul , P7 - th trms "rsidtial buildig platforms" hav ot b likd lctroically to dfiitio of this trm. rul P7 as follows: "Th maximum volum of fillig shall b 20m 3 pr sit ad a maximum volum of fillig of m 2 100m 3 pr sit withi ay cotiuous priod of 10 yars." rul , P7 to lik th trm "rsidtial buildig platforms" to th dfiitio of this trm i th fiitios chaptr. Rul Rul (P7) Hazards (part) Rul frc to Prohibitd Activitis i rul has b omittd i rror. rul as follows: Cotrolld ad Prohibitd Activitis Rul Not: Thr ar o cotrolld or prohibitd activitis i rspct of Rul Attachmt 1 - Pag 3

15 13 f r Spcific Provisio Submissio asos cisio Sought cisio Poit Codig Proposal Claus o./map o. Map Supp Opp Am asos ort os d Hazards (part) Rul , RD1 Rul , RD1 should b dltd as this rul was iadvrtdly carrid ovr from th oprativ Christchurch City Pla. lt lt rul RD1 ad txt statig "Mattrs blow ar from oprativ pla ad to b rviwd" as follows: Rul RD1 Activity Th Coucil's discrtio shall b limitd to th followig mattrs: RD1 Fillig, up to a total ara of 1000m 2 for th purposs of dvlopig a rsidtial uit ad ay associatd accssory buildigs, outdoor livig ad srvic aras ad vhicular accss Ay applicatio arisig from this rul will ot rquir writt approvals ad shall ot b publicly or limitd otifid. Mattrs blow ar from oprativ pla ad to b rviwd Mak cosqutial amdmts to rumbr ruls RD2 ad RD3 to RD1 ad RD2 rspctivly Hazards (part) Rul , NC1 Rul , NC1 icorrctly rfrs to ruls wh it should rfr to rul This was a draftig rror which should b corrctd. Rul , NC1 by rplacig with as follows: Activity NC1 Ay fillig or xcavatio activity listd i that dos ot comply with th Activity Spcific Stadards, or ay fillig or xcavatio activity ot listd i or , ulss othrwis spcifid i th District Pla as a prmittd, rstrictd discrtioary, discrtioary, or prohibitd activity. Rul NC1 Attachmt 1 - Pag 4

16 14 f r Spcific Provisio Submissio asos cisio Sought cisio Poit Codig Proposal Claus o./map o. Map Supp Opp Am asos ort os d Hazards (part) Rul A rviw of th tchical iformatio supportig High Hazard Flood Maagmt Aras at Sumr hav idtifid iaccuracis that ma th mappig caot b supportd ad must b rmovd. lt Plaig Map 48 ad Hazards Plaig Map 48 by dltig all mappig of High Hazard Flood Maagmt Aras Subdivisio Spcific Purpos (Flat Lad covry) Zo Rul Rul RD9 Rul NC5 Subdivisio activitis ar listd i th Spcific Purpos (Flat Lad covry) Zo proposal as rstrictd discrtioary ad o-complyig activitis. It is cosidrd that th provisios associatd with subdivisio ar bst placd withi th subdivisio chaptr. mts ar sought to itroduc a w rul udr Zo spcific ruls - Subdivisio ad dvlopmt (Rul 8.4.3) to addrss subdivisio withi th Spcific Purpos (Flat Lad covry) Zo. Th w ruls would b th quivalt rstrictd discrtioary ad ocomplyig activitis currtly st out i Chaptr Cosqutial dltios of th subdivisio provisios withi th Spcific Purpos (Flat Lad covry) Zo proposal (21.11) will b rquird. Isrt w ruls ito th Subdivisio Chaptr as follows: Rul Spcific Purpos (Flat Lad covry) Zo Rul strictd Discrtioary Activitis: RD1 - Subdivisio that ivolvs covrsio of th typ of tur from uit titl or cross las to f simpl; boudary adjustmts; altratio of cross lass, compay lass ad uit titls; ad whr it is proposd to subdivid off lad withi th Flat Lad covry Zo from a ara of lad ot withi th Flat Lad covry Zo. Ay applicatio arisig from o compliac with this ruls will ot rquir writt approvals ad shall ot b publicly or limitd otifid. Rul No-complyig Activitis NC1 - Subdivisio, ulss providd for as a rstrictd discrtioary activity. lt ruls otifid withi chaptr rlatig to subdivisio as follows: Rul strictd Discrtioary Activitis RD9 - Subdivisio that ivolvs covrsio of th typ of tur from uit titl or cross las to f simpl; boudary adjustmts; altratio of cross lass, compay lass ad uit titls; ad whr it is proposd to subdivid off lad withi th Flat Lad covry Zo from a ara of lad ot withi th Flat Lad covry Zo. 4 dcisio poits Rul 8.4 Rul RD9 Rul NC5 Ay applicatio arisig from o compliac with this ruls will ot rquir writt approvals ad shall ot b publicly or limitd otifid. Rul No-complyig Activitis NC5 - Subdivisio, ulss providd for as a rstrictd discrtioary activity Subdivisio Rul Rul strictd discrtioary activitis - ad Cultural rquirs clarificatio i rlatio to which aras idtifid RD5 Subdivisio of lad withi or partly withi a Sigificat Ladscap (othr tha i Baks Pisula wards), Outstadig Ladscap, A idtifid buildigo dcisio ara must b idtifid poit o ay allotmt Rul cratd. Attachmt 1 - Pag 5

17 15 f r Spcific Provisio Submissio asos cisio Sought cisio Poit Codig Proposal Claus o./map o. Map Supp Opp Am asos ort os d Subdivisio Proposal Idigous Biodivrsity ad Ecosystms 21. Chaptr Idigous Biodivrsity ad Ecosystms 22. Chaptr Idigous Biodivrsity ad Ecosystms 23. Chaptr Idigous Biodivrsity ad Ecosystms SES/A/20 - Waiui / Carws Pak, Akaroa cological district. Map 75R8. SES/H/20 - Wstr Slops of Mid Prics Vally, Hrbrt cological district. Map R Prmittd Activitis tabl; Claus P4: Platig ad sd gathrig withi a Sit of Ecological Sigificac or vgtatio idtifid i Rul D2 Plaig map No 41 (associatd with Appdix Schdul of Sits of Ecological Sigificac; schdul umbr SES/LP/6) i Proposal 9 ar subjct to th proposd additioal mattrs of discrtio. Earthworks - Applicatio of ths ruls Proposal (4), Proposal (4), ad subdivisio RD4 rfr to th Historic Placs Act Ths rfrcs should b to Part 3, s42 of th Nw Zalad Pouhr Taoga Act R8 SES/A/20 boudary adjustmt to xclud two small aras of xotic vgtatio from idtifid SES. R4 SES/H/20 boudary adjustmt to xclud small ara at southr d of idtifid SES. Th amdmt is rquird to clarify that th idigous spcis should b sourcd from th cological district whr th platig is takig plac. 41 boudary of Sit of Ecological Sigificac LP6 to xclud privat proprty That part of th SES dos ot mt th sigificac critria as it icluds dwlligs, buildigs, ad gards / backyard aras. lt Outstadig Faturs, Ara of Outstadig Charactr, Ara of Vry High Charactr, or Ara of High Charactr or Importat Ridgli Earthworks - ruls (4), 8.3.7, (4) ad RD4 to rfr to Part 3, s42 of th Nw Zalad Pouhr Taoga Act 2014 ot th Historic Placs Act boudaris as show o attachd Map. boudaris as show o attachd Map. Rul Prmittd Activity Claus P4 to mor clarly dfi whr idigous vgtatio is to b sourcd from as follows: a. Platig shall b with idigous spcis sourcd from withi th rlvat cological district withi which th platig is to tak plac. Not - cological districts ar idtifid i Appdix Plaig map 41 (associatd with Appdix Schdul of Sits of Ecological Sigificac) to xclud alog Rockighors Road a portio of a umbr of privat proprty sits from th SES as ths aras co dwlligs, buildigs, ad gards / backyard aras. Th amdmt sought is show o th attachd Map. Proprtis affctd by this SES is big amdd ar: 183B Rockig Hors Road 183D Rockig Hors Road 183E Rockig Hors Road 187B Rockig Hors Road 187C Rockig Hors Road 191B Rockig Hors Road 193B Rockig Hors Road 195B Rockig Hors Road 197B Rockig Hors Road 199C Rockig Hors Road 203B Rockig Hors Road 215 Rockig Hors Road 220 Rockig Hors Road Four dcisio poits Rul (4), Rul 8.3.7, Rul (4) ad Rul RD4 SES/A/20 Boudary SES/H/20 Boudary Rul P4 Plaig Map 41 LP6 Attachmt 1 - Pag 6

18 16 f r Spcific Provisio Submissio asos cisio Sought cisio Poit Codig Proposal Claus o./map o. Map Supp Opp Am asos ort os d 24. Chaptr Idigous Biodivrsity ad Ecosystms 25. Chaptr Outstadig Faturs ad Ladscaps, Sigificat Faturs ad Ladscaps ad Aras of Charactr i th Coastal Eviromt 26. Chaptr Outstadig Faturs ad Ladscaps, Sigificat Faturs ad Ladscaps ad Aras of Charactr i th Coastal Eviromt 27. Chaptr Outstadig Faturs ad Ladscaps, Sigificat Faturs ad Ladscaps ad Aras of Charactr i th Coastal Eviromt Prmittd Activitis P1 - Idigous vgtatio clarac withi a Sit of Ecological Sigificac Plaig maps R1 - R9, H30 - H37, T5-T6. Plaig maps R1 - R9, H30 - H37, T5-T6 This provisio is itdd to allow for grazig withi a Sit of Ecological Sigificac. Th currt wordig rfrcs th broadr dfiitio of a 'sit' which will ot cssarily corrlat to a idtifid Sit of Ecological Sigificac, ad may b ithr smallr, largr or across th boudaris of multipl sits. ig th provisio will clarify th itt ad rduc itrprtatio issus. Sctio 9.2 Objctivs, policis ad ruls rfr to 'aras of atural charactr i th coastal viromt'. O th plaig maps withi th coastal viromt li (CE li), aras of at last high atural charactr ad outstadig atural charactr ar show as ovrlays. charactr aras that ot idtifid as at last high or outstadig atural charactr ar ot currtly show. To assist with itrprtig ths objctivs, policis ad ruls this 'ovrlay' ds to b show o th plaig maps. Baks Pisula SL1.0 sigificat ladscap ovrlay xtds dow to th coast. This will ovrlap with aras of atural charactr withi th coastal viromt. Susabl maagmt of this ara is primarily addrssd through th objctivs, policis ad ruls i Chaptr aras of atural charactr i th coastal viromt. ig both ovrlays will mak it difficult to distiguish btw ovrlays ad pottially duplicat rgulatio. Plaig maps tbc Mior map corrctios ar proposd o Baks Pisula to corrct small misaligmts with th ladscap ad coastal atural charactr ovrlays ad proprty boudaris. Ths d to b rplacd with th sigificat ladscap layr. lt Activity Spcific Stadard a. vi. for Rul P1 as follows: vi. grazig whr th sit Sit of Ecological Sigificac has b usd for grazig o or withi 12 moths prior to 25 July 2015 Iclud as a ovrlay o th plaig maps aras of 'rmaiig' atural charactr dscribd as "Aras of Charactr i th coastal viromt" (i.. ara btw CE li ad MHWS). This will xclud aras alrady idtifid as at last high or outstadig atural charactr, ad aras that ar withi urba viromts. Plaig maps to b attachd. mappig of ovrlay SL 1.0, Baks Pisula Sigificat ladscap to rmov aras that ar locatd withi th coastal viromt (i.. btw CE li ad MHWS). Plaig maps to b attachd. plaig maps at th locatios as show, to rduc th Outstadig Ladscap ad Coastal Charactr Aras Ovrlays as show, ad to rplac with th Sigificat ladscap ovrlay Activity Spcific Stadard a. vi. Plaig Maps to show Charactr aras btw CE li ad MHWS. SL1.0 Plaig Maps Attachmt 1 - Pag 7

19 17 f r Spcific Provisio Submissio asos cisio Sought cisio Poit Codig Proposal Claus o./map o. Map Supp Opp Am asos ort os d 28. Chaptr Outstadig Faturs ad Ladscaps, Sigificat Faturs ad Ladscaps ad Aras of Charactr i th Coastal Eviromt Outstadig Faturs ad Ladscaps, Sigificat Faturs ad Ladscaps ad Aras of Charactr i th Coastal Eviromt Outstadig Faturs ad Ladscaps, Sigificat Faturs ad Ladscaps ad Aras of Charactr i th Coastal Eviromt Outstadig Faturs ad Ladscaps, Sigificat Faturs ad Ladscaps ad Aras of Charactr i Plaig maps tbc Mior map corrctios ar proposd to corrct small misaligmts with th ladscap ad coastal atural charactr ovrlays ad proprty boudaris. Ths d to b rplacd with th sigificat ladscap layr. Plaig Maps tbc Corrctio of locatio of th ovrlay for proprtis icludd as Coastal Charactr Aras is rquird. This ovrlay was icludd ovr som proprtis outsid of th Coastal Eviromt i rror. Coastal Charactr Aras ovrlays ar oly Coastal Eviromt rlatd Ths aras d to b rplacd with th Sigificat Ladscap ovrlay. Plaig Maps tbc Corrctio of locatio of th ovrlay for proprtis icludd as Coastal Charactr Aras is rquird. This ovrlay was icludd ovr som proprtis outsid of th Coastal Eviromt i rror. Coastal Charactr Aras ovrlays ar oly Coastal Eviromt rlatd. Ths aras do ot d to b rplacd with a ovrlay. Plaig Maps tbc Th Sigificat Ladscap ovrlay for Baks Pisula SL1.0 wr ot icludd i th otifid proposal ovr som proprtis. Thy wr xcludd i rror. lt plaig maps, at th locatios as show, to rduc th Outstadig Ladscap ad Coastal Charactr Aras Ovrlays as show, with o rplacmt ovrlay rquird. th plaig maps, at th locatios as show, to rduc Coastal Charactr Aras Ovrlays that ar outsid of th Coastal Eviromt, ad rplac with th Sigificat Ladscap ovrlay. th plaig maps, at th locatios as show, to rduc Coastal Charactr Aras that ar outsid of th Coastal Eviromt, with o rplacmt ovrlay rquird. plaig maps, at th locatios as show, to iclud th Sigificat Ladscap 1.0 ovrlay (i.. th Sigificat Ladscap for Baks Pisula) Plaig Maps Plaig Maps Plaig Maps Plaig Maps Attachmt 1 - Pag 8

20 18 f r Spcific Provisio Submissio asos cisio Sought cisio Poit Codig Proposal Claus o./map o. Map Supp Opp Am asos ort os d th Coastal Eviromt 32. Chaptr Outstadig Faturs ad Ladscaps, Sigificat Faturs ad Ladscaps ad Aras of Charactr i th Coastal Eviromt 33. Chaptr Outstadig Faturs ad Ladscaps, Sigificat Faturs ad Ladscaps ad Aras of Charactr i th Coastal Eviromt Plaig map 78 At Birdligs Flat, th outstadig atural ladscap, high atural charactr ad outstadig atural charactr ovrlays xtd ito proprtis withi th Birdligs Flat sttlmt ara. A mior corrctio to ths ovrlays is proposd to corrct this misaligmt. Appdix Schduls of aras of outstadig ad high atural charactr i th coastal viromt. Appdix cos two schduls: Schdul of Aras of At Last High Charactr i th Coastal Eviromt ad Schdul of Aras of Outstadig Charactr i th Coastal Eviromt. I additio to mappig aras of atural charactr i th coastal viromt a schdul ds to b addd to iclud dls (ID umbr, am ad/or locatio by charactr ara ad dscriptio). This is coctd to th submissio for Sctio 9.2 plaig maps R1- R9, 49-78, H30-H37, ad T5-T6 which sks to show this ovrlay o th plaig maps for aras of Charactr i th Coastal Eviromt. lt Alig th outstadig atural ladscap, high atural charactr ad outstadig atural charactr ovrlays at Birdligs Flat with th proprty / sttlmt boudaris. Plaig map 78 to b attachd. Appdix to add a w Schdul of aras of atural charactr i th Coastal Eviromt as follows: Appdix Schdul of Charactr i th Coastal Eviromt ID r NC1.0 Plaig Map r R1-R H30-H37 T5-T6 Nam ad/or Locatio by Charactr Ara Charactr i th Coastal Eviromt scriptio Aras i th Coastal Eviromt that ar ot idtifid as at last High Charactr or Outstadig Charactr or i urba sttlmts Plaig map Chaptr Outstadig Faturs ad Ladscaps, Sigificat Faturs ad Ladscaps ad Aras of Charactr i th Coastal Eviromt Appdix Schdul frc Map - Coastal atural charactr aras (Christchurch City) Th Schdul rfrc map illustrats th aras listd i th schdul. Th Christchurch City map (at Appdix ) ds to b updatd for th rasos giv udr th submissio poit immdiatly abov. Cosqutial amdmt to rumbr otifid appdics for Charactr i th Coastal Eviromt. Schdul frc Map to show aras of atural charactr i th Coastal Eviromt. Schdul frc Map Attachmt 1 - Pag 9

21 19 f r Spcific Provisio Submissio asos cisio Sought cisio Poit Codig Proposal Claus o./map o. Map Supp Opp Am asos ort os d 35. Chaptr Outstadig Faturs ad Ladscaps, Sigificat Faturs ad Ladscaps ad Aras of Charactr i th Coastal Eviromt 36. Chaptr Outstadig Faturs ad Ladscaps, Sigificat Faturs ad Ladscaps ad Aras of Charactr i th Coastal Eviromt 37. Chaptr Outstadig Faturs ad Ladscaps, Sigificat Faturs ad Ladscaps ad Aras of Charactr i th Coastal Eviromt 38. Chaptr Outstadig Faturs ad Ladscaps, Appdix Schdul frc Map - Coastal atural charactr aras ad Sigificat Ladscap This map shows both th coastal atural charactr aras ad sigificat ladscap ovrlay. Th Baks Pisula sigificat ladscap is also show o Appdix Schdul frc Map. It would b clarr if this ovrlay was ot duplicatd o both maps. With th additio of aras of atural charactr withi th coastal viromt to th schdul (rasos as pr submissio poit two rows abov) th map ds to b updatd to visually show th ara, alog with th ky. Plaig maps R1 to R9 SL1.0 sigificat ladscap Baks Pisula xtds ovr som aras that ar 'urba' ad do ot mt th thrshold for big a sigificat ladscap. Th ovrlay ds to b adjustd aroud th dgs to xclud ths aras. Plaig maps ad Appdix - Schdul frc Maps ad Policy b. sidtial activitis i. 2, 4, 5, 6, 10, 11, 12, 13, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 37, 38, 39, 40, 41, 44, 45, 46, 47, 48. Th sigificat ladscaps ad faturs hav b aotatd o th plaig maps, ad o th Schdul rfrc maps, with "SL". A portio of ths ar sigificat faturs ad should b pr-fixd by a "SF", a abbrviatio for "sigificat fatur". Maagig th ffcts of rsidtial activitis withi ladscap ad coastal ovrlay aras is critical to th outcoms sought i th objctivs. O of th mthods usd i th pla is th idtificatio of idtifid buildig lt lt Baks Pisula - Sigificat Ladscap (SL) from Appdix map ad ky. Add aras of atural charactr withi th coastal viromt oto Appdix map ad ky. SL1.0 ovrlay o plaig maps: Attach maps plac th pr-fix "SL" with "SF" for th followig sigificat faturs: 8.1, 5.0, 7.0, 3.0, 4.0, 10, 9.1, 9.2, 6.0, 2.0, 8.2, ad 8.3 o th plaig maps ad Appdix - Schdul frc Maps ad word policy to provid clarr dirctio i rspct of rsidtial activitis for Policy as follows: Spcific activitis i Outstadig Faturs ad Ladscaps, Sigificat Faturs ad Ladscaps ad Aras of Charactr i th Coastal Eviromt Appdix SL1.0 Schdul frc Maps ad Policy Attachmt 1 - Pag 10

22 20 f r Spcific Provisio Submissio asos cisio Sought cisio Poit Codig Proposal Claus o./map o. Map Supp Opp Am asos ort os d Sigificat Faturs ad Ladscaps ad Aras of Charactr i th Coastal Eviromt 39. Chaptr Outstadig Faturs ad Ladscaps, Sigificat Faturs ad Ladscaps ad Aras of Charactr i th Coastal Eviromt 40. Chaptr Outstadig Faturs ad Ladscaps, Sigificat Faturs ad Ladscaps Ruls Tabl 1, Colum 8 - ONL Port Hills 38.3 Kdy's Bush RLL zo oly Ruls Tabl 2, Colum 7 - SL 11.2 Port Hills Worsly's Spur sidtial Hills Zo oly. aras at th tim of subdivisio. This policy rquirs mior rwordig to provid clarr dirctio i rspct of rsidtial activitis. ONL 38.3 is locatd at th wstr d of th Port Hills. Th majority of this ovrlay is zod Rural Port Hills or Op Spac, xcpt for a small ara o th Kdy's Bush Spur which is zod sidtial Larg Lot (RLL). sidtial subdivisio ad dvlopmt is aticipatd i th proposd RLL zo. This RLL zod spur sits withi a largr ONL ad th optio of rmovig this ara basd o th proposd zoig was rjctd i favour of xmptig th ara from ladscap ruls. A spcific colum was addd to Tabl listig th ruls for buildigs ad rsidtial uits, (a. to c.) as /a (rul ot applicabl). Ruls d. to k. apply, which is th sam as for th majority of ONL Th subdivisio procss i a RLL Zo provids opportuity to addrss similar mattrs such as w roads ad th mattrs of discrtio provid for cosidratio of ladscap qualitis. Th ladscap ruls i d. to k. hav th pottial to ucssarily rsult i duplicat rgulatio. It is thrfor proposd that th ruls i d. to k. b listd as /a. This will rsult i o ladscap spcific ruls applyig to this gographic ara. Th optio of a xmptio udr how to us th ruls was rjctd i favour of rig th Kdy s Bush colum with a list of /a ruls. This is cosidrd th clarst way of showig th xtt of th ONL o th plaig maps but that o ladscap spcific ruls apply to th spur that is zod RLL. SL11.2 is locatd at th wstr d of th Port Hills o th lowr Slops. Th majority of this ovrlay is zod Rural Port Hills or Op Spac, xcpt with a small ara o Worsly's Spur which is zod sidtial Hills (RH). sidtial subdivisio ad dvlopmt is aticipatd i th proposd RH zo. This RZ zod spur sits withi a larg SL ad th optio of rmovig this ara basd o th proposd lt b. sidtial activitis i. quir a I Idtifid buildig aras at th tim of subdivisio ad udrtak a ladscap assssmt of th shall b limitd i trms of locatio, dsity ad scal of buildigs vlop to sur futur dvlopmt will ot rsult i advrs ffcts o th ladscap qualitis, i particular aturalss ad opss of outstadig atural faturs ad ladscaps. ii. Limit rsidtial uits ad associatd accss ad platig to a scal, form, dsig, fiish (colours ad matrials) that itgrat with th ladscap Ruls Tabl 1, Colum 8 - ONL Port Hills 38.3 Kdy's Bush RLL zo oly - dlt activitis listd udr d. to k. ad rplac with /a = rul ot applicabl. umbr subsqut activitis Ruls Tabl 2, Colum 7 - SL 11.2 Port Hills Worsly's Spur sidtial Hills Zo oly - dlt activitis listd udr h. to k. ad rplac with /a = rul ot applicabl. umbr subsqut activitis. Rul Tabl 1, Colum 8 - ONL Port Hills 38.3 Kdy's Bush RLL zo Rul Tabl 2, Colum 7 - SL 11.2 Port Hills Worsly's Spur sidtial Hills Zo Attachmt 1 - Pag 11

23 21 f r Spcific Provisio Submissio asos cisio Sought cisio Poit Codig Proposal Claus o./map o. Map Supp Opp Am asos ort os d ad Aras of Charactr i th Coastal Eviromt 41. Chaptr Outstadig Faturs ad Ladscaps, Sigificat Faturs ad Ladscaps ad Aras of Charactr i th Coastal Eviromt 42. Chaptr Ruls Tabl 2 - Colum 9 - SL1.0 Baks Pisula Papakaiga zos oly Historic Prmittd Activitis Itms ad Sttigs - High Sigificac (Group 1) ad Sigificat (Group 2) zoig was rjctd i favour of xmptig th ara from ladscap ruls. A spcific colum was addd to Tabl 2. listig th ruls a. to g. for buildigs ad rsidtial uits - /a (rul ot applicabl). Ruls h. to k. howvr apply ar th sam as for th majority of SL11.1 to 11.6 Port Hills. Th subdivisio procss i a RLL zo provids opportuity to addrss similar activitis such as w roads ad Mattrs of Discrtio provid for cosidratio of ladscap qualitis. Th ladscap ruls i h. to k. hav th pottial to ucssarily rsult i duplicat rgulatio. It is thrfor proposd that th ruls i h. to k. b listd as /a. This would rsult i o ladscap spcific ruls i applyig to this gographic ara. Th optio of a xmptio udr how to us th ruls was rjctd i favour of rig th Worsly s Spur colum with a list of /a ruls. This is cosidrd th clarst way of showig th xtt of th SL o th plaig maps but that o ladscap spcific ruls apply to th spur that is zod RH. O Baks Pisula thr ar a umbr of aras that ar idtifid as a Papakaiga zo with topic spcific objctivs ad policis. A built form stadard is proposd to addrss buildigs ad accordigly claus a. is /a. Th subsqut listig of activitis i b. to f. ar spcific xmptios i rlatio to a. I this cas as a. dos ot apply it would b clarr if b. to f. wr listd as /a. /a To provid for th rplacmt of o-listd buildigs without th d for a rsourc cost whr a) th rplacmt buildigs rus th xistig floor pad ad b) ar locatd withi a hritag sttig, or a op spac, ad c) wr damagd i th Catrbury arthquaks of 2010 ad lt Ruls Tabl 2 - Colum 9 - SL1.0 Baks Pisula Papakaiga zos oly - dlt activitis listd udr b. to f. ad rplac with /a = rul ot applicabl. umbr subsqut activitis. th Prmittd Activitis tabl to iclud a w prmittd activity as follows: P9 - placmt of buildigs i a hritag sttig or a op spac hritag itm, (which ar ot listd as a hritag itm), ad whr th rplacmt is rquird as a rsult of damag susd i th Catrbury arthquaks of 2010 ad Buildigs may rus th xistig floor pad ad foudatios or hav upgradd or w foudatios. Activity spcific stadards - a. Th buildig is to rus th xistig floor pad ad foudatios, or hav upgradd or w foudatios. b. Th buildigs must b of th sam locatio, footprit, form, scal, ad oritatio as th damagd buildig. Buildigs must b of compatibl matrials ad colours with th damagd buildig. Rul Tabl 2 - Colum 9 - SL1.0 Baks Pisula Papakaiga zos Prmittd Activity Tabl add a w P9 Attachmt 1 - Pag 12

24 22 f r Spcific Provisio Submissio asos cisio Sought cisio Poit Codig Proposal Claus o./map o. Map Supp Opp Am asos ort os d 43. Chaptr Historic Prmittd Activitis Itms ad Sttigs - High Sigificac (Group 1) ad Sigificat (Group 2) HID 1367 HID 351 HID H31 52 R1 To provid for as a prmittd activity, ad thrfor ot subjct to th ruls rlatig to th Itm, dvlopmt (whr it will ot hav a impact o th schduld Itm) o thos sits locatd abov thr schduld udrgroud Itms. lt th Prmittd Activitis tabl to iclud a w prmittd activity as follows: P10 - vlopmt (i.. buildigs ad arthworks) o sits locatd abov Mocks Cav (HID 1367), Moa Bo Poit Cav (HID 351), ad th Lyttlto Rail tul (HID 760) is ot subjct to th Historic Ruls of sctio 9.3 whr th followig activity stadards ar mt. Activity spcific stadards - vlopmt of th sit must avoid dirct or idirct (i.. vibratio) impact o th udrgroud schduld Itm. Prmittd Activity Tabl add a w P Chaptr 9 Plaig maps ad Appdix Schdul frc Maps - Sigificat historic hritag itms ad sttigs arial maps (Christchurch City ad Baks Pisula) H31 52 R1 th plaig maps to rflct that schduld Itms 1367, 351, ad 760 ar udrgroud. This will provid clarity ad is cosistt with th proposd w prmittd activity P10. th followig plaig maps to rflct that schduld Itms 1367, 351, ad 760 ar udrgroud through otatig th Itm outli by way of a dash: plaig map 47 - to b attachd. plaig map 48 - to b attachd. plaig map H31 - to b attachd. plaig map 52 - to b attachd. plaig map R1 - to b attachd. Plaig Maps 47, 48, H31, 52, ad R1 45. Chaptr Chaptr Chaptr 9 HID 1367 HID 351 HID Ruls -Historic strictd Discrtioary Activitis - Itms ad Sttigs - High Sigificac (Group 1) ad Sigificat (Group 2) RD Mattrs of Discrtio Historic Altratio of a Itm - High Sigificac (Group 1) ad Sigificat (Group 2) Itms - b Mattrs of Discrtio Historic Altratio of a Sttig - Nw Buildigs i Sttigs - High Sigificac (Group 1) ad Sigificat /a Th amdmt to RD6 is sought to provid cosistcy with what is prmittd i P4 ad P5 which cocrs ot oly hritag sttigs, but also hritag itms which ar op spac. Nocompliac with P4 ad P5 activity stadards is th triggr to RD6.I additio, th st of gral mattrs of discrtio at should also apply to RD6 as thy ar rlvat to th assssmt of proposals. Thy wr xcludd i rror from th otifid vrsio. /a Th mattr of discrtio for altratio should b i coctio with th hritag itm, ot spcifically th locatio of th hritag itm. movig th words "ad locatio" from towards th d of th mattr of discrtio will improv th clarity. This icluds that th locatio of th altratio, such as at th rar of frot of th buildig is also importat to b assssd. /a Th mattr of discrtio should rlat to both mattrs (subordiat to, ad compatibl with) as opposd to iclusio of th word "or". This also provids cosistcy with a similar claus for th altratio of a hritag itm udr b RD6: a. High Sigificac (Group 1) ad Sigificat (Group 2) hritag itms ad hritag sttigs a - l. b. Tmporary Evt Structurs Withi High Sigificac (Group 1) ad Sigificat (Group 2) h ssttigs, ad Withi a Itm which is a Op Spac a ad b. Mattr of discrtio i b: b. Whthr th altratio, icludig th locatio of th altratio, is subordiat to, ad compatibl with th form, scal, mass, matrials, colour, dsig (icludig th ratio of solid to void), dlig (icludig th apparac ad profil of matrials usd), ad locatio of th hritag itm. Mattr of discrtio i a: a. How th w buildig will rlat to th hritag itm(s), icludig whthr th w buildig is subordiat to, or ad compatibl with, th form, scal, mass, matrials, colour, dsig, dlig ad locatio of hritag itms withi th sttig, whil also big idtifiabl as w work RD6 Mattr of discrtio i b Mattr of discrtio i a Attachmt 1 - Pag 13

25 23 f r Spcific Provisio Submissio asos cisio Sought cisio Poit Codig Proposal Claus o./map o. Map Supp Opp Am asos ort os d 48. Chaptr Chaptr Chaptr Chaptr Chaptr Chaptr Chaptr 9 (Group 2) Sttigs - a Mattrs of Discrtio Historic Altratio of a Sttig - Nw Buildigs i Sttigs - High Sigificac (Group 1) ad Sigificat (Group 2) Sttigs - b Mattrs of Discrtio Historic Nw Buildigs, Structurs ad Faturs Withi Op Spac Itms - High Sigificac (Group 1) ad Sigificat (Group 2) Itms - a Mattrs of Discrtio Historic Tmporary Evt Structurs Withi High Sigificac (Group 1) ad Sigificat (Group 2) Sttigs Appdics Appdix Christchurch City ad Baks Pisula Exmptios Appdics Appdix Christchurch City ad Baks Pisula Exmptios Appdics Appdix Ctral City Exmptios Plaig maps ad /a Mattr of discrtio b. is a rptitio of mattr of discrtio a. ad has b icludd i rror. /a Th mattr of discrtio should rlat to both mattrs (subordiat to, ad compatibl with) as opposd to iclusio of th word "or". This also provids cosistcy with a similar claus for th altratio of a hritag itm udr b. /a Th amdmt is sought to provid cosistcy with what is prmittd i P4 ad P5 which cocrs ot oly hritag sttigs, but also hritag itms which ar op spac. This liks to th submissio poit rqust for associatd chag to RD6. /a Th xmptio should apply to oly part (i) ad ot th whol of th stadard RD5 This is a corrctio of a rror. This would provid cosistcy with othr xmptios. /a Th additioal wordig sought was xcludd i rror from th otifid proposal. Th additio of th wordig "scal of activity" to th Typ of Exmptio dscriptio mor accuratly rflcts th atur of th rul to which th xmptio rlats. This corrspods with th atur of th oprativ hritag xmptios i rsidtial zos ad improvs cosistcy with th dscriptio of othr proposd xmptios from scal of activity ruls. /a umbrig of xmptios to sur cosistcy with otifid mthod of claus umbrig withi sidtial Chaptr to which ths xmptios rlat. 31 ad H6 Extd hritag itm at 83 Hato Strt to iclud trac way. Etracway is trlid with trs of sam ag ad typ as th park lt lt mattr of discrtio b. ad cosqutial r-umbrig of c. to f. mattr of discrtio i a: a. Whthr th w buildig, structurs ad/or faturs will b subordiat to, or ad compatibl with, th form, scal, mass, matrials, colour, dsig, dlig ad locatio of hritag itm(s) withi th op spac, whil also big idtifiabl as w work. Mattr of Discrtio : Tmporary Evt Structurs Withi High Sigificac (Group 1) ad Sigificat (Group 2) h ssttigs, ad Withi a Itm which is a Op Spac a. Th duratio th tmporary vt structur will rmai withi th hritag sttig., or withi th hritag itm. th fial listd xmptio i Appdix so that th activity colum rfrcs rfrs as show: RD5 (i) th rfrc to Chaptr 14 sidtial, Typ of xmptio listd to Zo - sidtial Gust Accommodatio zo, with rlatd Activity spcifid as P2(i) ad listd as 'Acillary food ad bvrag outlt so that th typ of xmptio is show as: l / scal of activity th xmptios listd udr th titl of Ctral City sidtial, so that thy iclud roma umrals at th d of ach activity listd as opposd to lttrs. Exampl show of: P2b(ii), ad P7b(ii) plaig map 31 to b attachd. arial map 672 to b attachd. Mattr of discrtio b. ad cosqutial r-umbrig of c. to f. Mattr of discrtio i a Mattr of Discrtio Appdix P2(i) th xmptios listd at rows udr th titl of Ctral City sidtial. Plaig Map 31 Attachmt 1 - Pag 14

26 24 f r Spcific Provisio Submissio asos cisio Sought cisio Poit Codig Proposal Claus o./map o. Map Supp Opp Am asos ort os d Appdix Schdul frc Maps - Sigificat historic hritag itms ad sttigs arial maps (Christchurch City ad Baks Pisula) primtr. Iclusio of tracway alog with th rst of th park was a ovrsight. lt Arial map Chaptr Chaptr 9 HID 246 Arial map 672 Plaig maps ad Appdix Schdul frc Maps - Sigificat historic hritag itms ad sttigs arial maps (Christchurch City ad Baks Pisula) HID 189 Arial map 44 HID 208 Arial map 41 Plaig maps ad Appdix Schdul frc Maps - Sigificat historic hritag itms ad sttigs arial maps (Ctral City) HID 316 Arial map ad H8 32 ad H16 Extd hritag sttig of 5 St Barabas La ad rduc th hritag sttig of 12 Gladovy Road to bttr rflct ara of hritag valus. Mappig rror - sttig of o lad parcl of 5 St Barabas La was mappd as sttig of adjact 12 Gladovy Road i rror. Ths proprtis ar i diffrt owrship. Corrctig th rror will sur that th sttigs rlat to th corrct hritag itm ad th owrship of th rlativ hritag itms. Th sttig to th rar of 228 Kilmor Strt is proposd to b xtdd to bttr rflct th ara of hritag valu. Sttigs hav oly b mappd as rstrictd to th buildig footprit whr th buildig footprit occupis th full sit. It was a ovrsight, ad ot cosistt with th rst of th mappig that th sttig was rstrictd to th buildig footprit i this cas. plaig map 31 to b attachd. arial map 41 to b attachd. arial map 44 to b attachd. plaig map 32 to b attachd. arial map 300 to b attachd. Plaig map 31 Arial map 41 Arial map 44 Plaig map 32 Arial map Chaptr Chaptr 9 Plaig maps ad Appdix Schdul frc Maps - Sigificat historic hritag itms ad sttigs arial maps (Ctral City) HID 415 Arial map 225 Plaig maps ad Appdix Schdul frc Maps - Sigificat historic hritag itms ad 32 ad H16 32 ad H16 Extd th hritag sttig of 159 Oxford Trrac across Worcstr Strt. Th buildig is locatd o a promit corr sit thrfor thr is pottial for advrs ffcts i this ara of road rsrv. Extd th hritag sttig of th Provicial Coucil Buildigs at 280 Durham Strt to bridg li ad updat map (2014 vrsio) for HID 638. Du to a mappig rror a 'void' was uittioally cratd i th mappig. plaig map 32 to b attachd. arial map 225 to b attachd. plaig map 32 to b attachd. arial map 638, 725 ad to b attachd. Plaig map 32 Arial map 225 Plaig map 32 Arial map 638 Arial map 725 Attachmt 1 - Pag 15