arxiv: v1 [physics.socph] 26 Mar 2019


 Barnaby George
 11 days ago
 Views:
Transcription
1 Crossscle coopertion enles sustinle use of commonpool resource Andrew K. Ringsmuth 1,, Steven J. Lde 1,2 nd Mj Schlüter 1 rxiv: v1 [physics.socph] 26 Mr 2019 Astrct In socilecologicl systems (SESs, socil nd iophysicl dynmics interct within nd etween structurl levels seprted y sptil nd temporl scles. Crossscle interctions (CSIs re interdependences etween processes t different scles, generting ehviour unpredictle t single scles. Understnding CSIs is importnt for improving SES governnce ut they remin understudied. Theoreticl models re needed, which cpture essentil fetures while eing simple enough to yield insights into mechnisms. In stylised model, we study CSIs in twolevel system of wekly intercting communities hrvesting commonpool resource. Community memers dptively conform to, or defect from, norm of socilly optiml hrvesting, enforced through socil snctioning oth within nd etween communities. Ech susystem s dynmics depend sensitively on the other despite interctions eing much weker etween susystems thn within them. When interction is purely iophysicl, stly high coopertion in one community cn cuse coopertion in the other to collpse. However, even wek socil interction cn prevent collpse of coopertion nd insted cuse collpse of defection. We identify conditions under which susystemlevel coopertion produces desirle systemlevel outcomes. Our findings expnd evidence tht collortion is importnt for sustinly mnging shred resources, showing its importnce even when resource shring nd socil reltionships re wek. Index Terms socilecologicl system, coopertion, multiscle nlysis, crossscle interctions, commonpool resource, resource mngement I. INTRODUCTION In socilecologicl systems (SESs, socil nd iophysicl dynmics interct within nd etween levels of orgnistion seprted y sptil nd temporl scles. The Anthropocene is chrcterised y glol chnges emerging from locl chnges in humnenvironment interctions. Glol chnges in turn cuse locl impcts nd most ttempts to mnge them lso must e deployed loclly [1]. The multiscle nture of SES dynmics nd governnce mkes theoreticl chrcteristion of crossscle dynmics importnt, to help understnd how chnges implemented t given level will propgte cross scles [2] [10]. According to hierrchy theory, when levels re seprted y scle, complex system is qusiseprle into semiindependent levels; when modelling one level, vriles t other levels my e treted s constnt oundry conditions [10], [11]. In such systems, cuses of nonliner ehviour t one level, such s threshold ehviour, must lie t the sme level. However, SESs re not seprle in this wy. If vrile t some level pproches criticl threshold, even smll perturtion from n interction with vrile t nother level my drive it over the threshold, cusing nonliner ehviour such s regime shift [10], [12], [13]. Such 1 Stockholm Resilience Centre, Stockholm University, Kräftriket 2B, 10691, Stockholm, 2 Fenner School of Environment & Society, The Austrlin Ntionl University, Building 141, Linneus Wy, Cnerr, ACT, 2601, Austrli sensitive dependence etween processes t different scles, which genertes ehviour unpredictle from ehviour t single scles, is known s crossscle interction (CSI [13]. Mny reserchers hve qulittively descried CSIs in SESs, conceptully [7], [10], [12], [14] [18] nd in specific cse studies (recently, [2], [19] [22]. CSIs hve een sttisticlly quntified in different systems, from dt t multiple scles. Brondizio et l [23] nlysed Amzon deforesttion dt t different length scles, showing tht understnding deforesttion trjectories requires differentiting cuses t different scles. Sornno nd collortors [4] quntified CSIs using multiscle dt nd Byesin hierrchicl sttisticl models. Applying this method to study of lke wter qulity cross different regions of North Americ, they identified scle mismtch etween qulity vrition nd wter mngement. To dte, however, there hve een few ttempts to theoreticlly model CSIs in SESs in terms of underlying mechnisms. Peters et l [9] proposed mthemticl frmework for nonliner dynmics in ctstrophic events in terms of ptternprocess reltionships, including feedcks, cross scles. They pplied this frmework to chrcterise events such s the spred of wildfires, infectious diseses nd insect outreks, finding tht strtegies for mitigting risks of such events must ccount for CSIs nd will often e counterintuitive. Recently, Lnsing nd coworkers reported [24] n gentsed model of wter resource nd pest control mngement in Bli s ncient rice terrces, to help explin shifts from individulistic fieldlevel prctices to coopertive regionllevel prctices. Modelling gent interctions nd mngement decisions using evolutionry gme theory on sptilly emedded lttice model showed tht longestlished sptil ptterns oservle in the rice terrces cn e creted y feedck etween frmers decisions nd the ecology of the pddies, triggering trnsition from individulistic to coopertive prctices. In the theoreticl middle ground etween generic frmeworks nd detiled cse models lies potentil for stylised, miniml models. These im to cpture essentil system fetures while eing simple enough to yield insights into mechnisms. This is helpful for guiding thought experiments relting CSIs to underlying mechnisms, nd for interpreting empiricl cse study results. Here, we develop stylised model of resource mngement y socil pressure in multilevel SES, ccounting for CSIs. Focusing on commonpool resource mngement, we extend prior work y Tvoni, Schlüter nd Levin (TSL [25], who used evolutionry gme theory to model community of gents hrvesting renewle commonpool resource s sis for economic production. Agents dptively chose whether to conform to, or defect from, norm of socilly optiml hrvesting, enforced through socil snctioning. Schlüter et l [26] extended the TSL model, using gentsed methods to test the roustness of normdriven coopertion to environmentl vritions. One ws the introduction of neighouring community nd resource pool, with diffusive 1
2 resource trnsfer etween the pools. Results showed tht stly high coopertion in one community could cuse coopertion in the other to collpse ecuse dded resource vilility due to the pools coupling incresed the pyoff for norm defectors. However, the communities did not djust their norms for dded resource vilility, nd no socil interctions etween communities were considered. We extend this nlysis of intercting SESs with two types of socil interction nd chrcterise how locllevel ehviours interct to produce outcomes t the system level. First, we consider how communiction etween communities while setting hrvesting norms cn djust the norms for dded resource vilility due to iophysicl coupling. Second, we dd ongoing socil coupling such tht normcoopertive gents cn snction defectors in oth communities. We ssume seprtion of scles etween the strengths of interctions within nd etween susystems. This enles us to quntify how nonliner chnges in susystem ehviour (ppernce or disppernce of dynmicl ttrctors rise from iophysicl nd socil CSIs etween the two susystems. We identify conditions under which susystemlevel coopertion gives rise to desirle systemlevel outcomes, nd conditions which prevent this. The exct system model is nlyticlly insolule nd we use perturtion theory [27] to derive n pproximte model in the wek coupling (multiscle regime. This model closely pproximtes numericl solutions of the exct model. Solving our model with comintion of nlyticl nd numericl methods llows more efficient chrcteristion of the prmeter spce thn purely numericl methods, nd the derived equtions shed light on mechnisms. This dul pproch is lso sis for future development using more dvnced multiscle nlyticl methods from dynmicl systems theory nd sttisticl physics, which hve elucidted wide rnge of complex systems [28] [32]. We envisge tht, in future, comintion of mthemticl nd gentsed stylised multiscle models my enle n effective theory of CSIs in SESs, complementing sttisticl nd qulittive nlyses from multiscle empiricl studies. This my help to guide empiricl reserchers in quntifying CSIs nd mechnisms underlying them, reveling new leverge points for governnce of rel systems. II. MODEL We consider the twolevel model schemtised in figure 1, comprising two intercting socilecologicl susystems, ech of which, in isoltion, is descried y the TSL model [25]. In ech, community of gents hrvests commonpool resource. Ech gent dptively conforms to, or defects from, socil norm of socilly optiml hrvesting, choosing strtegy sed on resource vilility nd the utilities of strtegies chosen y other gents. The iophysicl vriles of interest re the resource stocks, nd socil vriles the normcoopertive frctions of the susystem popultions. The two re directly coupled only within ech susystem (gents hrvest only loclly, ut the iophysicl nd socil vriles re coupled etween susystems. Socil interction etween susystems comprises two steps: first, communities my choose to shre informtion out their resources while estlishing hrvesting norms; second, coopertors ostrcise defectors to enforce the norms. System Susystem 1 Susystem 2 Replenishment Loss Biophysicl Loss Replenishment interction Common pool Resource trnsfer Common pool resource ρ(1(τ resource ρ(2(τ Coupling = δ Extrction Extrction Socil interctions Community Norm estlishment Defector ostrcism Community E*(1, c μ(1, (1(τ E*(2, c μ(2, (2(τ Coupling = λ Agent Socil Agent Agent Socil Agent interction interction c d c d c d c d Fig. 1. Model system with socil nd iophysicl interctions etween symmetricl susystems. In ech, community of gents extrcts renewle common pool resource nd ech dptively chooses etween coopertive (low nd defective (high extrction effort levels, constrined y socil norm of nonexcessive hrvesting (quntified y Ec (i. Coopertors enforce the norm y ostrcising defectors. Biophysicl coupling (strength δ permits resource trnsfer etween susystems. Communities my choose to shre resource informtion while setting norms; we ssume tht this communiction is either perfect or nonexistent. Ongoing socil coupling (strength λ enles coopertors to ostrcise defectors in oth communities. A. Biophysicl dynmics We model susystem resource dynmics s the sum of locl processes nd susystem interctions. Following TSL [25], [26], the resource stock of, for exmple, susystem 1 (R (1 (t is replenished y its environment t constnt rte (c (1 nd lost t rte tht depends on the squre of the resource occuption (rtio of the stock to its mximum vlue, R (1 m, determined y limits such s the cpcity of reservoir. Resource is lso hrvested y the susystem community of n (1 gents, collectively exerting effort E (1 (t. Resource is trnsferred diffusively etween susystems such tht the rte depends linerly on the difference etween their resource occuptions. Under the comined ction of these processes, susystem 1 s resource stock chnges ccording to the firstorder, nonliner ordinry differentil eqution, ( 2 Ṙ (1 (t = c (1 d (1 R (1 (t R (1 qe (1 (tr (1 (t m ( R (2 (t + r R (2 R(1 (t m R (1. (1 m Here, d (1 is coefficient prticulr to given system nd q (the technology fctor is constnt. In rel systems, resource trnsfer coupling, r my depend on flow direction due to, for exmple, constrints of geogrphy or institutionl regultions. However, for simplicity we ssume tht r is independent of flow direction nd tht oth susystems hve equl resource cpcities, nd replenishment nd dissiption coefficients (R (i m R m, c (i c, d (i d. So tht the effects of iophysicl nd socil susystem interctions my e compred firly, we define dimensionless vriles, ρ (i = R (i /R m nd τ = (d/r m t, nd rewrite (1 s ρ (1 (τ = c d ρ(1 (τ 2 qr m d E(1 (τρ (1 (τ + r d (ρ(2 (τ ρ (1 (τ. (2 2
3 In given system, it my e possile to quntify how coupling strength depends on spce nd time. For exmple, if communities hrvest wter from connected odies, the mechnics of wter trnsfer etween them will depend on geogrphicl prmeters such s distnce. However, for generlity, we impose seprtion of scles etween susystemnd systemlevel interction strengths phenomenologiclly, y invoking wek coupling prmeter, δ r d, 0 δ 1. This llows us to tret systemlevel resource trnsfer s smll perturtion to susystemlevel dynmics nd, therefore, using regulr perturtion theory [27], to ssume tht (2 hs solutions of the form ρ (1 (τ = ρ (1 0 (τ + δρ(1 1 (τ + δ2 ρ (1 2 (τ +... (3 Sustituting (3 into (2 nd truncting t first order in δ yields differentil equtions for the isolted susystem resource dynmics nd perturtion due to systemlevel resource trnsfer, respectively: ρ (1 0 (τ = c d ρ(1 0 (τ2 qr m d E(1 (τρ (1 0 (τ, (4 ρ (1 1 (τ = ρ (2 0 (τ ρ(1 0 (τ(1 + 2ρ(1 1 (τ qr m d E(1 (τρ (1 1 (τ. (4 In the supporting informtion (SI, we show tht this description very closely pproximtes the complete description (2 (see fig. S2. Perturtion theory mkes the system mthemticlly trctle nd lso links it to core concepts of socilecologicl resilience [5], which my e defined s the cpcity of SES to sor perturtions while mintining structure nd function [3], [5]. Our nlysis directly ssesses susystem resilience to crossscle perturtions. B. Socil dynmics Totl community extrctive effort is the sum of ll coopertors nd defectors efforts. For susystem 1, ( E (1 (τ = n (1 (1 e c µ (1 + (1 µ (1 (1 (τ. (5 Here, 0 (1 (τ 1 is the popultion frction mde up of norm coopertors, who ech extrct t socilly optiml (lower effort level, e c (1, while the remining defectors exert (higher e d (1. We define µ (1 = e d (1 /e c (1. Community productivity is ssumed to tke CoDougls form in effort nd resource [25]: f (1 (τ = γ[e (1 (t] α [R (1 (t] β = γr β m[e (1 (τ] α [ρ (1 (τ] β, (6 where γ is the totl fctor productivity nd α, β re constnts. Pyoffs for coopertors (c nd defectors (d re [25] ( π (1 (1 f (1 (τ x (τ = e x E (1 (τ w, x = c, d, (7 where w is the cost of production. Ech defector experiences socil snctioning ( ostrcism from the coopertive frctions of oth communities, weighted y susystem popultions nd socil couplings, λ (ij : ( ω (1 (τ = s n (1 e Teg(1 (τ + λ (21 n (2 e Teg(2 (τ, (8 where s is the mximl snctioning tht n individul cn pply. We ssume symmetricl community popultions nd socil couplings (n (i n; λ (ij λ, ut note tht in rel systems they my differ for mny resons. Mechnisms underlying socil coupling re prticulr to given system. For generlity, we gin impose seprtion of scles y ssuming tht couplings re much weker etween individuls in seprte communities thn in the sme community (0 λ 1. Figure 2 plots the ostrcism experienced y defector in susystem 1 due to coopertors in oth susystems. The dependences on (1 nd (2 re oth nonliner, with threshold ehviour t (i. The curve, ω (1 = ω (1 ( (1 t (2 = 0 is identicl to tht shown in figure 2 of [25]. Although the nonliner fctors of oth terms in (8 re identiclly prmeterised, ω (1 depends more wekly on (2 thn (1 ecuse the second term is scled y the wek socil coupling. The ostrcism components from the two communities dd, producing effects not seen when ostrcism is only locl. Defectors in community i experience nonzero ostrcism even when (i is elow its threshold, provided (j (j = i is ove its threshold ( (i (j. Moreover, when coopertors dominte oth communities ( (i 0.5, defectors in ech experience higher level of ostrcism thn cn e pplied y their locl communities lone. ω (1 (τ (2 (τ (1 (τ Fig. 2. Ostrcism experienced y defectors in susystem 1 due to the coopertive frctions of the susystem 1 nd 2 popultions. Prmeters: n = 50, λ =, s = 4/n = , T = 150, g = 10. The s vlue is derived from the vlue ssumed in [25] for the mximum snctioning pplicle y the whole community, h = 4. The coopertive frction of ech susystem s popultion evolves ccording to menfield replictor dynmics [33]. For susystem 1, this is written s in [25] ut using our dimensionless vriles: (1 R m (τ = d (1 (τ(1 (1 (τ ( π d (1 (τ π c (1 (τ π d (1 (τ C. Cses for modelling coupled system (ω (1 (τ π d (1 (τ.(9 When δ = λ = 0, the originl TSL model [25] descries ech susystem. In section SA, we summrise its fetures s enchmrk for susystem ehviour. In the sections elow, we investigte how iophysicl nd socil perturtions due to susystem couplings shift susystem fixed points, reltive to n isolted susystem, in different cses. First, we quntify how iophysicl coupling ffects ech susystem s norm of socilly optiml hrvesting when communities shre resource informtion during norm setting. Two scenrios re otined, in which norms respectively re nd re not djusted for coupling. We compute susystem 1 s iophysicl nd socil 3
4 fixed points for oth scenrios, in cses where coupling is purely iophysicl, purely socil, or comintion of the two. We fix coupling strengths such tht interctions etween susystems re t lest twice s wek s interctions within them (0 δ 0.5, 0 λ 0.5 nd lso fix the coopertordefector effort multiplier for susystem 2, µ (2 ritrrily t 75% of the rnge of µ vlues in n isolted susystem (µ (2 = 0.75(µ N = This is ecuse the rnge of µ depends on the iophysicl coupling strength, so vries cross the prmeter spce (see section IIIA. For consistency, therefore, µ (2 is fixed reltive to the isolted cse. Prior nlysis [26] simulted the full coupled susystem dynmics for ech prmeter comintion. Initil conditions were chosen ( (2 (0 lwys 0.9, (1 (0 vried nd the system numericlly evolved to equilirium. Here, since we ssume equilirium nd nlyse the stility lndscpe, we insted fix the longtime ehviour of susystem 2 nd ignore its trnsient ehviour, which my originte nywhere in the chosen equilirium s sin of ttrction. For ech scenrio of norms nd couplings, we consider cses in which susystem 2 equilirtes t ech of its monomorphic fixed points ( (2 = 0, 1. Although the stilities of these fixed points vry cross the prmeter spce, they re lwys ccessile through n pproprite choice of initil conditions. This is not true for the mixed fixed points, which vry in oth coordintes nd stility. For ech cse, we ddress two questions: 1 is susystem 1 resilient to crossscle perturtions from susystem 2 or do they cuse it to undergo stility phse trnsition; 2 does the longtime ehviour of susystem 2 promote or prevent similr longtime ehviour in susystem 1 nd, therefore, the overll system (oth susystems together? III. RESULTS A. Norm scenrios in coupled system In ech susystem, the effort level stisfying (S2 when the resource is t equilirium quntifies the socilly optiml hrvesting norm. To compute susystem 1 s resource equiliri, we ssume tht oth susystems zeroth nd firstorder resource dynmics hve equilirted. Setting ρ (1 1 (τ = ρ (2 1 (τ = 0 yields ρ (1 1 = = d(ρ (2 0 (1 ρ 0 R m E (1 + 2dρ (1 (10 0 R m (E (1 E (2 S(E (1 + S(E (2 2S(E (1. (10 When multiplied y δ, this gives the shift in susystem 1 s resource equilirium due to trnsfer etween susystems (reltive to ρ (1 0. Sustituting (10 nd (S1 into (3 gives ρ (1 ρ (1 (1 0 + δρ 1 1 ( 2S(E (1 4cd + R m E (1 (R m E (1 S(E (1 d + δd(r m (E (1 E (2 S(E (1 + S(E (2. (11 Empiricl studies hve shown tht communiction leding to normsed collortion etween common pool resource hrvesters cn strongly improve resource sustinility compred with cses of no communiction [6]. We consider two scenrios for norm setting, clled uncollortive nd collortive. In the former, communities set norms without communicting, s if the susystems were isolted (Ec E c0 = 83 nd E N E N0 = 1.83; µ N = E N0 /E c0 µ N 0 = 3.78, s clculted in section SA. In the collortive scenrio, communities perfectly communicte nd set norms using resource informtion from oth susystems. Sustituting (11 into (6, nd the result into (S2 nd (S2, gives shifted Ec nd E N vlues. Numericlly solving for these vlues cross the wek coupling rnge (0 δ 0.5 yields distriutions tht re very well pproximted y liner fits from lestsqures regression (Person correltion, r > for oth: E c (δ = E c δ µ N (δ = µ N δ. (12 In the collortive scenrio, these shifts must e included in oth ρ (i 0 nd ρ(i 1 to clculte ρ(i. B. Purely iophysicl coupling We first study cses in which 0 < δ 0.5, λ = 0. Evluting (10 determines shifts in iophysicl equiliri cross the prmeter spce (see fig. S3. As (10 mkes cler, ρ (1 1 vries in proportion to the difference in zerothorder resource equiliri; when ρ (1 (2 0 is higher thn ρ 0, the firstorder dynmics trnsfer resource from susystem 1 to 2, nd conversely. In turn, this difference depends on the socil fixed point t which susystem 2 is ssumed to equilirte. When (2 = 0 (fig. S3,, susystem 2 is purely defective, the corresponding high level of extrctive effort results in lower ρ (2 0, nd the equilirium firstorder dynmics persistently trnsfer resource from susystem 1 to 2. Conversely, when (2 = 1 (fig. S3c, d, the correspondingly low extrctive effort gives higher ρ (2 0 nd the firstorder equilirium persistently trnsfers resource from susystem 2 to 1. Solving (9 when (1 = 0 yields monomorphic socil fixed points t (1 = 0, 1, nd shifted mixed socil fixed points on loci generlly defined y ω (1 ( (1, (2 = π (1 d (e c, µ (1, (1, ρ (1. More explicitly, hn (e Teg(1 + λe Teg(2 (13 [ = e c µ (γ (1 E (1] [ α 1 R m 2Q(E (1 ( ( δ 2(E (1 E (2 Q(E (1 + Q(E (2 + 2Q(E (1 (Q(E (1 2E (1] β w, where Q(E (i = 1 + 4E (i2. Figure S4 plots ω (1 ( (1, (2 nd π (1 d (e c, µ (1, (1, ρ (1, with curve intersections corresponding to mixed socil fixed points ecuse (1 (τ = 0 when ω (1 (τ = π (1 d (τ in (9; the ostrcism nd defector pyoff lnce. Figure 3 shows shifted iophysicl nd socil fixed points in susystem 1 under purely iophysicl susystem coupling. Results re shown for the upper ound of the wek coupling rnge (δ = 0.5, which we cll moderte coupling, for oth norm scenrios, when susystem 2 hs equilirted t its purely coopertive socil equilirium ( (2 = 1. When 4
5 (2 = 0 insted, susystem 1 shows qulittively similr ehviour to n isolted susystem nd is therefore resilient to the crossscle iophysicl perturtion (see fig. S7. However, figure 3i shows stility phse trnsition; when µ(1 & 2.9, there re no mixed socil fixed points ecuse defector pyoff exceeds ostrcism for ll vlues of (1 (see fig. S4. Intuitively, this is ecuse iophysicl coupling gives susystem 1 gents ccess to extr resource from susystem 2, incresing their defector pyoff, while without socil coupling, susystem 2 cnnot provide extr ostrcism to lnce this pyoff. Only the purely defective fixed point is stle in this region, so for ny (1 (0 < 1, collpse of coopertion is inevitle. This constitutes CSI, since the wek perturtion from systemlevel dynmics genertes phse trnsition in susystem 1, from multistle to monostle ehviour, nd this cnnot e predicted y nlysing either susystem in isoltion. This is consistent with [26], in which this shift ws descried using gentsed methods1. Notly, coopertion never collpses in the collortive norm scenrio; operting under norm set with the enefit of communiction etween susystems preserves coopertion where it otherwise fils. Moreover, under oth susystem 2 equiliri ((2 = 0, 1, the C equilirium in susystem 1 is more coopertive, for given µ(1 vlue, in the collortive scenrio. i Uncollortive * (2 = 1 Collpse of coopertion μ(1 i (1 5 μ(1 We now consider cses in which 0 < λ 0.5 nd δ = 0. Although one my question why communities tht do not shre resources would snction ech other for violting resource use norms, it is instructive to study such cses efore comining socil nd iophysicl coupling. When δ = 0, (1 (3 reduces to ρ(1 (τ = ρ0 (τ, so the resource equilirtes s in n isolted susystem nd the uncollortive nd collortive scenrios re identicl. Moreover, the mixed socil fixed points re independent of µ(2 when δ = 0 in (13. Figure S5 shows the intersections of ω (1 ((1, (2 (1 nd πd (ec, µ(1, (1, ρ(1 (the mixed socil fixed points for purely socil coupling. Figure 3 shows how moderte purely socil coupling (λ = 0.5, δ = 0 shifts system 1 s fixed points for ech of susystem 2 s monomorphic socil equiliri. When (2 = 0, susystem 1 s ehviour is qulittively similr to n isolted susystem nd is therefore resilient to the crossscle socil perturtion. However, when (2 = 1, susystem 1 undergoes stility phse trnsition. There is mixed socil equilirium with strong defector mjority for µ( For µ(1 & 2.9, there is single mixed socil equilirium with strong coopertor mjority. In the intervening region (2.6. µ(1. 2.9, ostrcism exceeds defector pyoff for ll vlues of (1 nd only the purely coopertive fixed point is stle. Intuitively, this is ecuse socil coupling exposes susystem 1 defectors to dditionl ostrcism from susystem 2 coopertors, while the sence of iophysicl coupling prevents susystem 2 from incresing the susystem 1 defector pyoff through dded resource vilility. In this region, collpse of defection is inevitle in susystem 1 for ny (1 (0 > 0. We see tht the wek perturtion provided y socil coupling etween susystems cn produce two C. Purely socil coupling 0.0 (1 * ii (2 = δ = 0.0 λ = 0.5 * (2 = ii Collortive (2 = μ(2= 2.88 δ = 0.5 λ = 0.0 (1 D 5 Collpse of defection 0.0 (1 Fig. 3.. Shifted iophysicl (lue, purple nd socil (ornge fixed points in susystem 1 under purely iophysicl, moderte (δ = 0.5 susystem coupling. Results shown for the purely coopertive socil equilirium in susystem 2 ((2 = 1, in the uncollortive (pnel i nd collortive (ii norm scenrios. Dshed nd solid ornge loci respectively comprise unstle nd stle socil fixed points. Defector pyoff overwhelms ostrcism in the red region in pnel i.. Shifted susystem 1 fixed points under purely socil, moderte (λ = 0.5 susystem coupling. Results shown for the purely defective (pnel i nd purely coopertive (ii socil equilirium in susystem 2 ((2 = 0, 1 respectively. Ostrcism overwhelms defector pyoff in the green region in pnel ii.  mixed, defector The previously unseen socil ttrctor is lelled: D dominted. kinds of stility phse trnsitions t the susystem level, from multistle to monostle phse nd etween two different multistle phses. D. Comined iophysicl nd socil coupling Finlly, we study interply etween wek iophysicl nd socil couplings ( 0 < δ 0.5, 0 < λ 0.5. This represents scenrio in which two communities with wek socil reltionship wekly shre common pool resource nd enforce socil norms within nd etween communi ties. Figure S6 shows the intersections of ω (1 ((1, (2 (1 (1 (1 (1 nd πd (ec, µ,, ρ (the mixed socil fixed points for eqully moderte iophysicl nd socil couplings (δ = λ = 0.5. Figure 4 plots vritions in susystem 1 s fixed points for susystem 2 s purely coopertive socil equili rium ((2 = 1. The collpse of susystem 1 coopertion seen with purely iophysicl coupling in the uncollortive scenrio (fig. 3i is prevented. Moreover, within smll prmeter rnges (2.9. µ(1. 3 in pnel i nd. µ(1. 3 in ii, defection collpses insted. This shows tht when iophysicl nd socil coupling re eqully moderte, nd susystem 2 equilirtes in fully coopertive stte, dded 1 Due to smll differences in model formultion, δ in [26] (introduced in eqution (4.1 is equl to one qurter of δ here. e.g. δ = 0.5 here is equivlent to δ = in [26]. 5
6 ostrcism experienced y susystem 1 defectors overwhelms extr pyoff ville due to dded resource ccess. The net result is stility phse trnsition for susystem 1, which does not occur without socil coupling. Importntly, the longtime results of socil interctions etween susystems overwhelm the effects of their iophysicl interctions even when socil nd iophysicl couplings re equl in strength. 0 μ (1 Socil coupling (λ i Uncollortive (2 = 1 δ = 0.5 λ = 0.5 μ (2 = (1 (1 (1 (2 (2 μ = 2.9, μ = 2.88, * = 1 i Uncollortive Collortive ii C DC C Collortive (2 = 1 * * 5 Collpse of defection DC D DC Biophysicl coupling (δ 5 Collpse of defection DC DC DC Biophysicl coupling (δ Fig. 4.. Shifted iophysicl (lue, purple nd socil (ornge fixed points in susystem 1 under comined iophysicl nd socil susystem coupling. Results shown for eqully moderte couplings (δ = λ = 0.5, for the purely coopertive socil equilirium in susystem 2 ( (2 = 1. Ostrcism overwhelms defector pyoff in the green regions.. Phse plots showing how susystem 1 socil stility phse depends on socil nd iophysicl coupling strengths, when µ (1 = 2.9, µ (2 = 2.88, (2 = 1. Results shown for 500 vlues, ech, of δ nd λ ( 10 5 comintions per plot. Five stility phses re lelled, ech comprising lndscpe with either one or two of the four socil ttrctor types descried. The phse structure vries significntly cross the (µ (1, µ (2, (2 prmeter spce; vlues chosen here provide n illustrtive exmple. i. Uncollortive scenrio, contining five phses. The D phse ppers only in smll region t the lower right of pnel (δ 7 nd is mgnified in the inset. ii. Collortive scenrio, contining four phses. The results revel importnt differences etween norm scenrios. Susystem coopertivities re much more mutully sensitive in the uncollortive scenrio. Wek perturtions from susystem 2 cn cuse opposing types of socil stility phse trnsitions in susystem 1; collpse of coopertion when coupling is purely iophysicl nd collpse of defection when socil coupling is present. Conversely, in the collortive scenrio, susystems do not risk collpse of coopertion due to perturtions from wek iophysicl coupling. Socil coupling cn cuse collpse of defection lso in this cse, however. Furthermore, susystem 1 s C equilirium is more coopertive in the collortive scenrio, s previously seen ii for purely iophysicl coupling. Figure 4 shows how susystem 1 s socil stility lndscpe depends on socil nd iophysicl coupling strengths cross the wekcoupling prmeter suspce. Five stility phses re lelled, ech with different comintion of socil ttrctors. There is cler symmetry etween how socil coupling nd iophysicl coupling determine the stility phse. Wheres chnges in socil coupling strength cuse phse trnsitions for every vlue of iophysicl coupling in oth scenrios, the inverse is not true; for most socil coupling vlues, no chnge in iophysicl coupling cuses phse trnsition. Pnel i shows phse plot for the uncollortive scenrio. The collpse of coopertion seen in figure 3 is restricted to smll prmeter region t the lower right corner. At the opposite extreme, where socil coupling is moderte, lies the purely coopertive phse nd this extends cross the rnge of wek iophysicl couplings. The spectrum of other stility phses lie etween these extremes. In section SD, we riefly descrie mechnisms underlying the ehviour of ech phse. The overll trend is tht incresing the socil coupling cuses successive phse trnsitions in the susystem 1 stility lndscpe, grdully incresing its coopertivity. The collortive scenrio (fig. 4ii shows the sme rod fetures except tht the D phse is sent, for resons explined in section IIIC. Additionlly, wheres the phse oundries increse monotoniclly with iophysicl coupling in the uncollortive scenrio, they decrese monotoniclly in the collortive scenrio. Thus, for given level of resource shring, communiction during norm setting will llow lower levels of socil coupling to cuse stility phse trnsitions in susystem 1. Collortive norm setting is therefore n investment which cn lter increse the power of socil pressure s resourcesustining mechnism. In sum, the results show the importnce of collortion etween communities, oth in estlishing norms nd enforcing those norms through socil snctioning, even when iophysicl nd socil coupling re much weker etween susystems thn within ech. IV. DISCUSSION Our results show tht socil nd iophysicl CSIs cn profoundly ffect how intercting communities mnge common pool resource, nd how their susystemlevel ehviours interct to produce systemlevel outcomes. Even wek socil interctions etween communities cn produce longtime ehviour significntly more coopertive thn tht which eventutes in their sence. This is importnt for governnce ecuse it revels mechnism y which resource mngers cn help to ensure tht susystemlevel efforts produce desired systemlevel outcomes. When coupling is purely iophysicl nd t lest moderte in strength (δ 0.5, nd norms re estlished without communiction, pursuing socilly optiml resource use is effectively zerosum gme etween communities. In this perverse sitution, desire for systemlevel sustinility expressed through efforts t the susystem level is selfdefeting; success for the susystem gurntees filure for the system. However, enforcing norms etween communities resolves this ecuse incresed coopertion in one community encourges coopertion in the other, llowing them to cooperte s whole communities. This systemlevel coopertion depends strongly on the socil coupling strength, even within the wek rnge. Strengthening 6
7 the coupling produces successively higher levels of coopertion through trnsitions etween stility phses (fig. 4. Moreover, communities tht shre informtion during norm setting protect themselves ginst collpse of coopertion t the susystem level, nd increse the power of intercommunity socil pressure to increse coopertion t the system level. Methodologiclly, our dul nlyticl/numericl pproch offers powerful complement to purely numericl, gentsed methods [26]. In the dul pproch, finding nlyticl expressions for susystem fixed points enles their direct evlution, circumventing the need for full dynmicl simultion nd drsticlly ccelerting chrcteristion of the stility lndscpe cross the prmeter spce. However, this comes t the cost of sttisticl ehviour outside the men field, which is preserved y gentsed methods. There is lso smll ccurcy cost incurred y the perturtive iophysicl model (see section SB, though this cn in principle e reduced y truncting (3 t higher order, notwithstnding ssocited increses in mthemticl difficulty. In ddition to efficiently chrcterising twolevel system, our dul pproch is well suited to future study of lrger systems, including more susystem interction mechnisms nd/or more hierrchicl levels. Powerful methods hve een developed within the theory of dynmicl systems nd sttisticl physics, for nlysing interply etween structure nd dynmics t different scles in mnyody systems. Singulr perturtion theory [30] nd renormlistion [29], for exmple, were first developed s refinements to the regulr perturtion theory on which our iophysicl model (4, 4 is sed. Renormlistion theory ws refined into technique for corsegrining the sttisticl description of systems with mny length nd time scles, concisely explining reltionships etween ehviour t different scles. This hs provided deep insight into criticl trnsitions in vriety of systems. Although it is cknowledged tht dynmicl systems methods re useful for modelling SESs, nd tht there is need to etter understnd the multiscle ehviour of SESs nd how this reltes to their criticl trnsitions, such multiscle methods hve yet to e pplied in this field. The formlism developed here is nturlly suited to extension through such methods, which we suggest for future reserch. We foresee complementry roles for dul nlyticl/numericl dynmicl systems methods nd gentsed simultion, with the ltter providing computtionl lortory in which to test the former in smll prototypic systems efore ppliction to systems imprcticlly lrge for full simultion. Even efore extending the model to lrger systems, there re mny options for refinement. One is to modify the socil interction model y pplying results from psychology. Reserch on ingroup is suggests tht memers of community (ingroup re likely to snction memers of nother community (outgroup more hrshly thn ingroup memers for norm violtion [35]. This could e incorported into our model s dependence of the prmeters controlling the curvture nd mximum of the ostrcism experienced y outgroup defectors (h, T nd g in the second term of (8 on the socil coupling etween communities (λ. Furthermore, psychologicl limits to humn socil network size nd structure [36] could e incorported y limiting the socil connectedness ville to ech gent nd, therefore, their cpcity to ostrcise nd e ostrcised y others. Other interesting results my come from reking the prmetric symmetries ssumed to exist etween susystems in this study. Ultimtely, more relistic representtions of SESs will come from using refined susystem model s uilding lock in lrger, multilevel, multiscle systems with prmeteristions sttisticlly distriuted cross susystems. The multiscle nlysis methods descried ove re well suited to such system. Used in comintion with sttisticl nd qulittive nlyses from multiscle empiricl studies, such modelling methods offer strong potentil for etter understnding nd mnging CSIs in SESs. Our work rises fundmentl questions out wht is ment y scle in SESs, nd how est to model it. Different usge of the term cross nturl nd socil sciences influencing SES reserch hs produced tension in the literture [7], [10], which must e nvigted if coherent theory of CSIs is to e developed. Nturl sciences usully define scles s orders of mgnitude in sptil nd temporl seprtions. Socil sciences typiclly define scles s levels of orgnistion in hierrchicl socil systems, though there hs lso een interest in how sptil emeddedness ffects socil systems [37] [39]. In modelling studies, CSIs re commonly posed s interctions etween quntities which vry over different sptil nd temporl scles ut precisely how such interctions depend on spce nd time is often not considered. In this study, we considered interctions cross scles in the strengths of iophysicl nd socil couplings within nd etween susystems. One possiility for interpreting our results in terms of conventionl sptiotemporl frming of CSIs is to determine how iophysicl nd socil couplings depend on spce nd time. However, given the vst rnge of resource pool types nd socil systems which my e studied, this is nontrivil undertking. Intuitively, one my expect coupling strengths to vry inversely with sptiotemporl seprtion nd this my indeed e the cse in some systems. However, in glolised, digitlly connected world, couplings cn depend counterintuitively on, or e effectively independent from, sptiotemporl seprtions, s is the cse for soclled teleconnections [17]. Recent work on socilecologicl network nlysis [40] [42] hs egun to quntify how the sptiotemporl emeddedness of socil nd iophysicl dynmics ffects SES resilience. We propose tht further reserch in this direction, cross rod rnge of systems nd contexts, my e n importnt step towrds more generl nd rodly pplicle theory of CSIs. V. AUTHORS CONTRIBUTIONS All uthors jointly designed the reserch. AKR developed the nlysis nd interpreted the results under dvice from SJL nd MS. AKR wrote, nd SJL nd MS criticlly revised, the mnuscript. All uthors gve finl pprovl for puliction. VI. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS AKR thnks Alessndro Tvoni, Sonj Rdosvljevic nd Supriy Krishnmurthy for helpful discussions. VII. FUNDING This project received funding from the Europen Reserch Council (ERC under the Europen Unions Horizon 2020 reserch nd innovtion progrmme (grnt greement No 7
8 MUSES, nd Swedish Reserch Council Forms project grnt REFERENCES [1] P. H. Verurg, J. A. Dering, J. G. Dyke, S. v. d. Leeuw, S. Seitzinger, W. Steffen, nd J. Syvitski, Methods nd pproches to modelling the Anthropocene, Glol Environmentl Chnge, vol. 39, pp , [2] S. A. McGuire nd T. J. Ehlinger, Anlysis of socilecologicl dynmics driving conflict in linked surfcegroundwter systems, Ecology nd Society, vol. 23, no. 4, [3] B. C. Chffin nd L. H. Gunderson, Emergence, institutionliztion nd renewl: Rhythms of dptive governnce in complex socilecologicl systems, Journl of Environmentl Mngement, vol. 165, pp , [4] P. A. Sornno, K. S. Cheruvelil, E. G. Bissell, M. T. Bremign, J. A. Downing, C. E. Fergus, C. T. Filstrup, E. N. Henry, N. R. Lottig, E. H. Stnley, C. A. Stow, P.N. Tn, T. Wgner, nd K. E. Wester, Crossscle interctions: quntifying multiscled cuseeffect reltionships in mcrosystems, Frontiers in Ecology nd the Environment, vol. 12, no. 1, pp , [5] C. Folke, S. R. Crpenter, B. Wlker, M. Scheffer, T. Chpin, nd J. Rockström, Resilience Thinking: Integrting Resilience, Adptility nd Trnsformility, Ecology nd Society, vol. 15, no. 4, [6] E. Ostrom, A generl frmework for nlyzing sustinility of socilecologicl systems, Science, [7] D. Csh, W. N. Adger, F. Berkes, P. Grden, L. Leel, P. Olsson, L. Pritchrd, nd O. Young, Scle nd crossscle dynmics: governnce nd informtion in multilevel world, Ecology nd society, vol. 11, no. 2, [8] C. Folke, T. Hhn, P. Olsson, nd J. Norerg, Adptive governnce of socilecologicl systems, Annul Review of Environment nd Resources, vol. 30, no. 1, [9] D. P. C. Peters, R. A. Pielke, B. T. Bestelmeyer, C. D. Allen, S. MunsonMcGee, nd K. M. Hvstd, Crossscle interctions, nonlinerities, nd forecsting ctstrophic events, Proceedings of the Ntionl Acdemy of Sciences, vol. 101, pp , [10] C. C. Gison, E. Ostrom, nd T.K. Ahn, The concept of scle nd the humn dimensions of glol chnge: survey, Ecologicl economics, vol. 32, no. 2, pp , [11] M. Gimpietro, Using hierrchy theory to explore the concept of sustinle development, Futures, vol. 26, no. 6, pp , [12] B. H. Wlker, S. R. Crpenter, J. Rockström, A.S. Crépin, nd G. D. Peterson, Drivers, Slow Vriles, Fst Vriles, Shocks, nd Resilience, Ecology nd Society, vol. 17, no. 3, p. rt30, [13] D. P. C. Peters, B. T. Bestelmeyer, nd M. G. Turner, Cross Scle Interctions nd Chnging PtternProcess Reltionships: Consequences for System Dynmics, Ecosystems, vol. 10, no. 5, pp , [14] F. Isell, A. Gonzlez, M. Loreu, J. Cowles, S. Díz, A. Hector, G. M. Mce, D. A. Wrdle, M. I. O Connor, J. E. Duffy, L. A. Turnull, P. L. Thompson, nd A. Lriguderie, Linking the influence nd dependence of people on iodiversity cross scles, Nture, vol. 546, no. 7656, pp , [15] G. S. Cumming, C. R. Allen, N. C. Bn, D. Biggs, H. C. Biggs, D. H. M. Cumming, A. De Vos, G. Epstein, M. Etienne, K. Mciejewski, R. Mthevet, C. Moore, M. Nendovic, nd M. Schoon, Understnding protected re resilience: multiscle, socilecologicl pproch, Ecologicl Applictions, vol. 25, [16] K. Mciejewski, A. De Vos, G. S. Cumming, C. Moore, nd D. Biggs, Crossscle feedcks nd scle mismtches s influences on culturl services nd the resilience of protected res, Ecologicl Applictions, vol. 25, no. 1, pp , [17] R. Scholes, B. Reyers, R. Biggs, M. Spierenurg, nd A. Duripph, Multiscle nd crossscle ssessments of socilecologicl systems nd their ecosystem services, Current Opinion in Environmentl Sustinility, vol. 5, no. 1, pp , [18] E. S. Brondizio, E. Ostrom, nd O. R. Young, Connectivity nd the Governnce of Multilevel SocilEcologicl Systems: The Role of Socil Cpitl, Annul Review of Environment nd Resources, vol. 34, no. 1, pp , [19] S. Niirnen, A. Richter, T. Blenckner, L. Stige, M. Vlmn, nd A.M. Eikeset, Glol connectivity nd crossscle interctions crete uncertinty for Blue Growth of Arctic fisheries, Mrine Policy, vol. 87, pp , [20] A. De Vos, G. Cumming, nd D. Roux, The relevnce of crossscle connections nd sptil interctions for ecosystem service delivery y protected res: Insights from southern Afric, Ecosystem Services, vol. 28, pp , [21] M. Cox, Applying SocilEcologicl System Frmework to the Study of the Tos Vlley Irrigtion System, Humn Ecology, vol. 42, no. 2, pp , [22] T. Heikkil, E. Schlger, nd M. W. Dvis, The Role of Cross Scle Institutionl Linkges in Common Pool Resource Mngement: Assessing Interstte River Compcts, Policy Studies Journl, vol. 39, no. 1, [23] E. S. Brondizio nd E. F. Morn, Leveldependent deforesttion trjectories in the Brzilin Amzon from 1970 to 2001, Popultion nd Environment, vol. 34, no. 1, pp , [24] J. S. Lnsing, S. Thurner, N. N. Chung, A. CoudurierCurveur, C. Krks, K. A. Fesenmyer, nd L. Y. Chew, Adptive selforgniztion of Bli s ncient rice terrces, Proceedings of the Ntionl Acdemy of Sciences, vol. 114, no. 25, pp , [25] A. Tvoni, M. Schlüter, nd S. Levin, The survivl of the conformist Socil pressure nd renewle resource mngement, Journl of Theoreticl Biology, vol. 299, no. C, pp , [26] M. Schlüter, A. Tvoni, nd S. Levin, Roustness of normdriven coopertion in the commons, Proceedings of the Royl Society B: Biologicl Sciences, vol. 283, no. 1822, p , [27] B. K. Shivmoggi, Perturtion methods for differentil equtions. Birkhäuser, [28] P. Attrd, Nonequilirium Thermodynmics nd Sttisticl Mechnics: Foundtions nd Applictions. OUP Oxford, [29] W. McCom, Renormliztion Methods: A Guide For Beginners. OUP Oxford, [30] J. Kevorkin nd J. Cole, Multiple Scle nd Singulr Perturtion Methods. Springer New York, [31] M. Pesenson nd H. Schuster, Multiscle Anlysis nd Nonliner Dynmics: From Genes to the Brin, ser. Annul Reviews of Nonliner Dynmics nd Complexity (VCH. Wiley, [32] G. Longo nd M. Montévil, Perspectives on Orgnisms: Biologicl time, Symmetries nd Singulrities, ser. Lecture Notes in Morphogenesis. Springer Berlin Heidelerg, [33] J. Hofuer nd K. Sigmund, Evolutionry Gmes nd Popultion Dynmics. Cmridge University Press, [34] P. Dsgupt nd G. Hel, Economic Theory nd Exhustile Resources, ser. Cmridge economic hndooks. J. Niset, [35] K. McAuliffe nd Y. Dunhm, Group is in coopertive norm enforcement, Philosophicl Trnsctions of the Royl Society B: Biologicl Sciences, vol. 371, no. 1686, p , [36] A. Sutcliffe, R. Dunr, J. Binder, nd H. Arrow, Reltionships nd the socil rin: Integrting psychologicl nd evolutionry perspectives: Reltionships nd the socil rin, British Journl of Psychology, vol. 103, no. 2, pp , [37] J. R. Logn, Mking Plce for Spce: Sptil Thinking in Socil Science, Annul Review of Sociology, vol. 38, no. 1, pp , [38] C. T. Butts, R. M. Acton, J. R. Hipp, nd N. N. Ngle, Geogrphicl vriility nd network structure, Socil Networks, vol. 34, no. 1, pp , [39] G. Drgnov, P. Pttison, J. Koskinen, B. Mitchell, A. Bill, M. Wtts, nd S. Bum, Networks nd geogrphy: Modelling community network structures s the outcome of oth sptil nd network processes, Socil Networks, vol. 34, no. 1, pp. 6 17, [40] J. S. Syles nd J. A. Bggio, Socilecologicl network nlysis of scle mismtches in estury wtershed restortion, Proceedings of the Ntionl Acdemy of Sciences, vol. 114, no. 10, pp. E1776 E1785, [41] J. A. Bggio, S. B. BurnSilver, A. Arens, J. S. Mgdnz, G. P. Kofins, nd M. De Domenico, Multiplex socil ecologicl network nlysis revels how socil chnges ffect community roustness more thn resource depletion, Proceedings of the Ntionl Acdemy of Sciences, vol. 113, no. 48, pp ,
9 [42] O. Bodin nd M. Tengö, Disentngling intngile socilecologicl systems, Glol Environmentl Chnge, vol. 22, no. 2, pp ,
10 S. SUPPORTING INFORMATION A. Isolted susystem: originl TSL model When δ = λ = 0, the originl TSL model [25] descries ech susystem. Dropping lels for revity, we summrise its fetures s enchmrk for ssessing effects of perturtions due to iophysicl nd socil couplings in the coupled system. TSL clculted iophysicl nd socil fixed points for rnge of initil socil conditions, (0 nd prmeters, µ. Setting ρ(τ = 0, (4 gives iophysicl fixed points s function of totl community effort: ρ0 = q 2d ( E R m + S(E, (S1 where S(E = 4cd + E 2 R 2 m nd sterisks denote fixedpoint vlues. Sustitution into (6 gives socilly optiml (coopertive nd individully optiml (Nsh effort levels (Ec, E N, conditions for which re [34] respectively w = w = d f de nd (S2 f E 1 ( f n E d f de. (S2 It is ssumed tht 1 < µ µ N, where µ N = E N /E c. Using prmeters from [25] (n = 50, q = 1, c = 50, d = 50, R m = 200, α =, β =, γ = 10 gives Ec = 83, E N = 1.83 nd corresponding resource fixed points ρ0 c = 25, ρ0 N = Socilly optiml nd Nsh efforts for individul gents re e c = Ec /n = nd e N = E N /n = The former quntifies the norm of socilly optiml hrvesting. It is ssumed tht e c < e d e N, so 1 < µ 3.78, since e N /e c µ N = Setting (τ = 0 in (9 yields monomorphic socil fixed points ( = 0, 1 nd mixed socil fixed points on loci descried y ω( = π d (e c, µ,, ρ0. μ 0.15 D Fig. S1. Socil ( ornge nd iophysicl (ρ lue fixed points of n isolted TSL susystem, prmeterised y coopertive popultion frction ((τ nd defectorcoopertor effort multiplier (µ. Dshed nd solid ornge loci respectively comprise unstle socil fixed points nd stle socil fixed points (equiliri. The equiliri re lelled y type: D purely defective, C purely coopertive, C mixed, coopertor dominted. Prmeters: s = , T = 150, g = 10. See figure 3 in [25] for more informtion. Figure S1 overlys these on corresponding iophysicl fixed points (S1. The stle fixed points (equiliri re ttrctors towrd which the system evolves. The µ prmeter spce is divided into two socil stility phses (qulittively different stility lndscpes, ech persisting cross some C C prmeter rnge 2, chrcterised y different comintions of ttrctors. When µ, there re two socil ttrctors, one purely defective ( = 0 nd one mixed nd coopertordominted (0.5 < < 1. We lel these ttrctor types, respectively, D nd C. When µ, D nd purely coopertive ttrctor (C; = 1 re present. B. Assessment of perturtive pproximtion We pproximte the iophysicl dynmics in the coupled susystem model (2 with perturtion expnsion (3, truncted t first order. Here we ssess this pproximtion y compring it with the full numericl solution of the menfield replictor dynmics (2. Figure S2 compres oth the trnsient dynmics nd equiliri for rnge of coupling strengths. In ech cse, clcultions were run until the system converged sufficiently close to equilirium tht the following condition ws met: ρ (1 (τ + ρ (2 (τ + (1 (τ + (2 (τ < Γ, (S3 where Γ is tolernce which we set to Γ = 10 5, since this gve good lnce etween ccurcy nd prcticlity. We lel the lowest time t which (S3 is stisfied τ eq, nd define the reltive error in the resource equilirium otined from the perturtive pproximtion, ρ (1 = ρ(1 0 (τ eq + δρ (1 1 (τ eq ρ (1 (τ eq ρ (1, (S4 (τ eq where ρ (1 (τ eq is the numericl solution of the full resource dynmics (2. Similrly, we define the reltive error in the equilirium coopertive frction of the susystem 1 popultion, (1 = (1 p (τ eq (1 (τ eq (1, (S5 (τ eq where (1 p (τ eq is the coopertive frction otined when the perturtive pproximtion is used for the resource dynmics nd (1 (τ eq is the full numericl solution. These reltive errors re ssessed for ech cse in figure S2. The results show excellent greement etween the perturtive nd full solutions in the cses of very wek ( ρ (1 = , (1 = nd wek coupling ( ρ (1 = , (1 = Surprisingly, even though the strong coupling cse (pnel c violtes the wek coupling ssumption underpinning our perturtive tretment (0 < δ 1, the reltive errors in equilirium resource nd coopertive popultion levels re oth only 2% in this cse. Although this vries cross the prmeter spce, we found comprly smll errors cross wide rnge of prmeter vlues, suggesting tht the perturtive tretment is more roust under strong iophysicl coupling thn might e expected. We leve elucidtion of the resons for this unexpected roustness to future work. 2 A fmilir exmple of phses comes from thermodynmics, in which sustnces such s wter show the phses, solid, liquid nd gs cross different rnges of temperture nd pressure. S1
EQUATIONS OF LINES AND PLANES
EQUATIONS OF LINES AND PLANES MATH 195, SECTION 59 (VIPUL NAIK) Corresponding mteril in the ook: Section 12.5. Wht students should definitely get: Prmetric eqution of line given in pointdirection nd twopoint
More information** Dpt. Chemical Engineering, Kasetsart University, Bangkok 10900, Thailand
Modelling nd Simultion of hemicl Processes in Multi Pulse TP Experiment P. Phnwdee* S.O. Shekhtmn +. Jrungmnorom** J.T. Gleves ++ * Dpt. hemicl Engineering, Ksetsrt University, Bngkok 10900, Thilnd + Dpt.hemicl
More informationReasoning to Solve Equations and Inequalities
Lesson4 Resoning to Solve Equtions nd Inequlities In erlier work in this unit, you modeled situtions with severl vriles nd equtions. For exmple, suppose you were given usiness plns for concert showing
More informationOr more simply put, when adding or subtracting quantities, their uncertainties add.
Propgtion of Uncertint through Mthemticl Opertions Since the untit of interest in n eperiment is rrel otined mesuring tht untit directl, we must understnd how error propgtes when mthemticl opertions re
More informationPolynomial Functions. Polynomial functions in one variable can be written in expanded form as ( )
Polynomil Functions Polynomil functions in one vrible cn be written in expnded form s n n 1 n 2 2 f x = x + x + x + + x + x+ n n 1 n 2 2 1 0 Exmples of polynomils in expnded form re nd 3 8 7 4 = 5 4 +
More informationExperiment 6: Friction
Experiment 6: Friction In previous lbs we studied Newton s lws in n idel setting, tht is, one where friction nd ir resistnce were ignored. However, from our everydy experience with motion, we know tht
More informationNQF Level: 2 US No: 7480
NQF Level: 2 US No: 7480 Assessment Guide Primry Agriculture Rtionl nd irrtionl numers nd numer systems Assessor:.......................................... Workplce / Compny:.................................
More informationTechniques for Requirements Gathering and Definition. Kristian Persson Principal Product Specialist
Techniques for Requirements Gthering nd Definition Kristin Persson Principl Product Specilist Requirements Lifecycle Mngement Elicit nd define business/user requirements Vlidte requirements Anlyze requirements
More informationTreatment Spring Late Summer Fall 0.10 5.56 3.85 0.61 6.97 3.01 1.91 3.01 2.13 2.99 5.33 2.50 1.06 3.53 6.10 Mean = 1.33 Mean = 4.88 Mean = 3.
The nlysis of vrince (ANOVA) Although the ttest is one of the most commonly used sttisticl hypothesis tests, it hs limittions. The mjor limittion is tht the ttest cn be used to compre the mens of only
More information2 DIODE CLIPPING and CLAMPING CIRCUITS
2 DIODE CLIPPING nd CLAMPING CIRCUITS 2.1 Ojectives Understnding the operting principle of diode clipping circuit Understnding the operting principle of clmping circuit Understnding the wveform chnge of
More informationAn Undergraduate Curriculum Evaluation with the Analytic Hierarchy Process
An Undergrdute Curriculum Evlution with the Anlytic Hierrchy Process Les Frir Jessic O. Mtson Jck E. Mtson Deprtment of Industril Engineering P.O. Box 870288 University of Albm Tuscloos, AL. 35487 Abstrct
More informationJaERM SoftwareasaSolution Package
JERM SoftwresSolution Pckge Enterprise Risk Mngement ( ERM ) Public listed compnies nd orgnistions providing finncil services re required by Monetry Authority of Singpore ( MAS ) nd/or Singpore Stock
More informationEnterprise Risk Management Software Buyer s Guide
Enterprise Risk Mngement Softwre Buyer s Guide 1. Wht is Enterprise Risk Mngement? 2. Gols of n ERM Progrm 3. Why Implement ERM 4. Steps to Implementing Successful ERM Progrm 5. Key Performnce Indictors
More informationBasic Analysis of Autarky and Free Trade Models
Bsic Anlysis of Autrky nd Free Trde Models AUTARKY Autrky condition in prticulr commodity mrket refers to sitution in which country does not engge in ny trde in tht commodity with other countries. Consequently
More informationAppendix D: Completing the Square and the Quadratic Formula. In Appendix A, two special cases of expanding brackets were considered:
Appendi D: Completing the Squre nd the Qudrtic Formul Fctoring qudrtic epressions such s: + 6 + 8 ws one of the topics introduced in Appendi C. Fctoring qudrtic epressions is useful skill tht cn help you
More informationUse Geometry Expressions to create a more complex locus of points. Find evidence for equivalence using Geometry Expressions.
Lerning Objectives Loci nd Conics Lesson 3: The Ellipse Level: Preclculus Time required: 120 minutes In this lesson, students will generlize their knowledge of the circle to the ellipse. The prmetric nd
More informationClearPeaks Customer Care Guide. Business as Usual (BaU) Services Peace of mind for your BI Investment
ClerPeks Customer Cre Guide Business s Usul (BU) Services Pece of mind for your BI Investment ClerPeks Customer Cre Business s Usul Services Tble of Contents 1. Overview...3 Benefits of Choosing ClerPeks
More informationA.7.1 Trigonometric interpretation of dot product... 324. A.7.2 Geometric interpretation of dot product... 324
A P P E N D I X A Vectors CONTENTS A.1 Scling vector................................................ 321 A.2 Unit or Direction vectors...................................... 321 A.3 Vector ddition.................................................
More informationFAULT TREES AND RELIABILITY BLOCK DIAGRAMS. Harry G. Kwatny. Department of Mechanical Engineering & Mechanics Drexel University
SYSTEM FAULT AND Hrry G. Kwtny Deprtment of Mechnicl Engineering & Mechnics Drexel University OUTLINE SYSTEM RBD Definition RBDs nd Fult Trees System Structure Structure Functions Pths nd Cutsets Reliility
More informationUtilization of Smoking Cessation Benefits in Medicaid Managed Care, 20092013
Utiliztion of Smoking Cesstion Benefits in Medicid Mnged Cre, 20092013 Office of Qulity nd Ptient Sfety New York Stte Deprtment of Helth Jnury 2015 Introduction According to the New York Stte Tocco Control
More informationSmall Businesses Decisions to Offer Health Insurance to Employees
Smll Businesses Decisions to Offer Helth Insurnce to Employees Ctherine McLughlin nd Adm Swinurn, June 2014 Employersponsored helth insurnce (ESI) is the dominnt source of coverge for nonelderly dults
More informationGraphs on Logarithmic and Semilogarithmic Paper
0CH_PHClter_TMSETE_ 3//00 :3 PM Pge Grphs on Logrithmic nd Semilogrithmic Pper OBJECTIVES When ou hve completed this chpter, ou should be ble to: Mke grphs on logrithmic nd semilogrithmic pper. Grph empiricl
More informationOperations with Polynomials
38 Chpter P Prerequisites P.4 Opertions with Polynomils Wht you should lern: Write polynomils in stndrd form nd identify the leding coefficients nd degrees of polynomils Add nd subtrct polynomils Multiply
More informationExample 27.1 Draw a Venn diagram to show the relationship between counting numbers, whole numbers, integers, and rational numbers.
2 Rtionl Numbers Integers such s 5 were importnt when solving the eqution x+5 = 0. In similr wy, frctions re importnt for solving equtions like 2x = 1. Wht bout equtions like 2x + 1 = 0? Equtions of this
More information2. Transaction Cost Economics
3 2. Trnsction Cost Economics Trnsctions Trnsctions Cn Cn Be Be Internl Internl or or Externl Externl n n Orgniztion Orgniztion Trnsctions Trnsctions occur occur whenever whenever good good or or service
More information1. In the Bohr model, compare the magnitudes of the electron s kinetic and potential energies in orbit. What does this imply?
Assignment 3: Bohr s model nd lser fundmentls 1. In the Bohr model, compre the mgnitudes of the electron s kinetic nd potentil energies in orit. Wht does this imply? When n electron moves in n orit, the
More informationDlNBVRGH + Sickness Absence Monitoring Report. Executive of the Council. Purpose of report
DlNBVRGH + + THE CITY OF EDINBURGH COUNCIL Sickness Absence Monitoring Report Executive of the Council 8fh My 4 I.I...3 Purpose of report This report quntifies the mount of working time lost s result of
More informationEconomics Letters 65 (1999) 9 15. macroeconomists. a b, Ruth A. Judson, Ann L. Owen. Received 11 December 1998; accepted 12 May 1999
Economics Letters 65 (1999) 9 15 Estimting dynmic pnel dt models: guide for q mcroeconomists b, * Ruth A. Judson, Ann L. Owen Federl Reserve Bord of Governors, 0th & C Sts., N.W. Wshington, D.C. 0551,
More informationAll pay auctions with certain and uncertain prizes a comment
CENTER FOR RESEARC IN ECONOMICS AND MANAGEMENT CREAM Publiction No. 12015 All py uctions with certin nd uncertin prizes comment Christin Riis All py uctions with certin nd uncertin prizes comment Christin
More informationSection 54 Trigonometric Functions
5 Trigonometric Functions Section 5 Trigonometric Functions Definition of the Trigonometric Functions Clcultor Evlution of Trigonometric Functions Definition of the Trigonometric Functions Alternte Form
More informationFactoring Polynomials
Fctoring Polynomils Some definitions (not necessrily ll for secondry school mthemtics): A polynomil is the sum of one or more terms, in which ech term consists of product of constnt nd one or more vribles
More informationIn addition, the following elements form an integral part of the Agency strike prevention plan:
UNITED STTES DEPRTMENT OF GRICULTURE Wshington, DC 20250 Federl Grin Inspection Service FGIS Directive 4711.2 6/16/80 STRIKE PREVENTION ND STRIKE CONTINGENCY PLNS I PURPOSE This Instruction: Estlishes
More informationWhy is the NSW prison population falling?
NSW Bureu of Crime Sttistics nd Reserch Bureu Brief Issue pper no. 80 September 2012 Why is the NSW prison popultion flling? Jcqueline Fitzgerld & Simon Corben 1 Aim: After stedily incresing for more thn
More informationBayesian Updating with Continuous Priors Class 13, 18.05, Spring 2014 Jeremy Orloff and Jonathan Bloom
Byesin Updting with Continuous Priors Clss 3, 8.05, Spring 04 Jeremy Orloff nd Jonthn Bloom Lerning Gols. Understnd prmeterized fmily of distriutions s representing continuous rnge of hypotheses for the
More informationA Study on Autonomous Cooperation between Things in Web of Things
A Study on Autonomous Coopertion etween Things in We of Things Jehk Yu, Hyunjoong Kng, HyoChn Bng, MyungNm Be 2 Electronics nd Telecommunictions Reserch Institute, 38 Gjeongno, Yuseonggu, Dejeon, 305700,
More informationLINEAR TRANSFORMATIONS AND THEIR REPRESENTING MATRICES
LINEAR TRANSFORMATIONS AND THEIR REPRESENTING MATRICES DAVID WEBB CONTENTS Liner trnsformtions 2 The representing mtrix of liner trnsformtion 3 3 An ppliction: reflections in the plne 6 4 The lgebr of
More informationEcon 4721 Money and Banking Problem Set 2 Answer Key
Econ 472 Money nd Bnking Problem Set 2 Answer Key Problem (35 points) Consider n overlpping genertions model in which consumers live for two periods. The number of people born in ech genertion grows in
More informationCHAPTER 11 Numerical Differentiation and Integration
CHAPTER 11 Numericl Differentition nd Integrtion Differentition nd integrtion re bsic mthemticl opertions with wide rnge of pplictions in mny res of science. It is therefore importnt to hve good methods
More informationSPH simulation of fluidstructure interaction problems
Diprtimento di ingegneri idrulic e mientle SPH simultion of fluidstructure interction prolems C. Antoci, M. Gllti, S. Siill Reserch project Prolem: deformtion of plte due to the ction of fluid (lrge displcement
More information1. Find the zeros Find roots. Set function = 0, factor or use quadratic equation if quadratic, graph to find zeros on calculator
AP Clculus Finl Review Sheet When you see the words. This is wht you think of doing. Find the zeros Find roots. Set function =, fctor or use qudrtic eqution if qudrtic, grph to find zeros on clcultor.
More informationUNIVERSITY OF NOTTINGHAM. Discussion Papers in Economics STRATEGIC SECOND SOURCING IN A VERTICAL STRUCTURE
UNVERSTY OF NOTTNGHAM Discussion Ppers in Economics Discussion Pper No. 04/15 STRATEGC SECOND SOURCNG N A VERTCAL STRUCTURE By Arijit Mukherjee September 004 DP 04/15 SSN 10438 UNVERSTY OF NOTTNGHAM Discussion
More informationAPPLICATION NOTE Revision 3.0 MTD/PS0534 August 13, 2008 KODAK IMAGE SENDORS COLOR CORRECTION FOR IMAGE SENSORS
APPLICATION NOTE Revision 3.0 MTD/PS0534 August 13, 2008 KODAK IMAGE SENDORS COLOR CORRECTION FOR IMAGE SENSORS TABLE OF FIGURES Figure 1: Spectrl Response of CMOS Imge Sensor...3 Figure 2: Byer CFA Ptterns...4
More informationRotating DC Motors Part II
Rotting Motors rt II II.1 Motor Equivlent Circuit The next step in our consiertion of motors is to evelop n equivlent circuit which cn be use to better unerstn motor opertion. The rmtures in rel motors
More informationMathematics. Vectors. hsn.uk.net. Higher. Contents. Vectors 128 HSN23100
hsn.uk.net Higher Mthemtics UNIT 3 OUTCOME 1 Vectors Contents Vectors 18 1 Vectors nd Sclrs 18 Components 18 3 Mgnitude 130 4 Equl Vectors 131 5 Addition nd Subtrction of Vectors 13 6 Multipliction by
More informationJ4.12 REGIONAL HYDROLOGICAL CYCLE AND WEATHER AND CLIMATE IN THE CONTIGUOUS UNITED STATES
J4.12 REGIONAL HYDROLOGICAL CYCLE AND WEATHER AND CLIMATE IN THE CONTIGUOUS UNITED STATES 1. INTRODUCTION i Hu 1 nd Song Feng Climte nd BioAtmospheric Sciences rogrm School of Nturl Resource Sciences
More informationCorporate Compliance vs. EnterpriseWide Risk Management
Corporte Complince vs. EnterpriseWide Risk Mngement Brent Sunders, Prtner (973) 2364682 November 2002 Agend Corporte Complince Progrms? Wht is EnterpriseWide Risk Mngement? Key Differences Why Will
More informationAdditional Protocol to the Convention on Human Rights and Biomedicine concerning Genetic Testing for Health Purposes
Council of Europe Trety Series  No. 203 Additionl Protocol to the Convention on Humn Rights nd Biomedicine concerning Genetic Testing for Helth Purposes Strsourg, 27.XI.2008 2 CETS 203 Humn Rights nd
More informationCS99S Laboratory 2 Preparation Copyright W. J. Dally 2001 October 1, 2001
CS99S Lortory 2 Preprtion Copyright W. J. Dlly 2 Octoer, 2 Ojectives:. Understnd the principle of sttic CMOS gte circuits 2. Build simple logic gtes from MOS trnsistors 3. Evlute these gtes to oserve logic
More information5 a LAN 6 a gateway 7 a modem
STARTER With the help of this digrm, try to descrie the function of these components of typicl network system: 1 file server 2 ridge 3 router 4 ckone 5 LAN 6 gtewy 7 modem Another Novell LAN Router Internet
More informationNote: Principal version Modification Amendment Equivalence list Consolidated version from October 1 2014
Note: The following curriculum is consolidted version. It is leglly noninding nd for informtionl purposes only. The leglly inding versions re found in the University of Innsruck Bulletins (in Germn).
More informationHomework 3 Solutions
CS 341: Foundtions of Computer Science II Prof. Mrvin Nkym Homework 3 Solutions 1. Give NFAs with the specified numer of sttes recognizing ech of the following lnguges. In ll cses, the lphet is Σ = {,1}.
More informationIntroduction. Teacher s lesson notes The notes and examples are useful for new teachers and can form the basis of lesson plans.
Introduction Introduction The Key Stge 3 Mthemtics series covers the new Ntionl Curriculum for Mthemtics (SCAA: The Ntionl Curriculum Orders, DFE, Jnury 1995, 0 11 270894 3). Detiled curriculum references
More informationSan Mateo County ACCEL AdultEducation College and Career Educational Leadership AB 86 Adult Education Consortium Project Management Plan 24, 2014 
A Sn Mteo County ACCEL AdultEduction College nd Creer Eductionl Ledership AB 86 Adult Eduction Consortium Project Mngement Pln  Februry 24, 2014  This project mngement pln presents ACCEL s process frmework
More informationFirm Objectives. The Theory of the Firm II. Cost Minimization Mathematical Approach. First order conditions. Cost Minimization Graphical Approach
Pro. Jy Bhttchry Spring 200 The Theory o the Firm II st lecture we covered: production unctions Tody: Cost minimiztion Firm s supply under cost minimiztion Short vs. long run cost curves Firm Ojectives
More informationThe Determinants of Private Medical Insurance Prevalence in England
The Determinnts of Privte Medicl Insurnce Prevlence in Englnd Derek R. King, Elis Mossilos LSE Helth nd Socil Cre, London School of Economics nd Politicl Science LSE Helth nd Socil Cre Discussion Pper
More information9 CONTINUOUS DISTRIBUTIONS
9 CONTINUOUS DISTIBUTIONS A rndom vrible whose vlue my fll nywhere in rnge of vlues is continuous rndom vrible nd will be ssocited with some continuous distribution. Continuous distributions re to discrete
More informationResearch Article Competition with Online and Offline Demands considering Logistics Costs Based on the Hotelling Model
Mthemticl Problems in Engineering Volume 4, Article ID 678, pges http://dx.doi.org/.55/4/678 Reserch Article Competition with Online nd Offline Demnds considering Logistics Costs Bsed on the Hotelling
More informationSmall Business Networking
Why Network is n Essentil Productivity Tool for Any Smll Business TechAdvisory.org SME Reports sponsored by Effective technology is essentil for smll businesses looking to increse their productivity. Computer
More information. At first sight a! b seems an unwieldy formula but use of the following mnemonic will possibly help. a 1 a 2 a 3 a 1 a 2
7 CHAPTER THREE. Cross Product Given two vectors = (,, nd = (,, in R, the cross product of nd written! is defined to e: " = (!,!,! Note! clled cross is VECTOR (unlike which is sclr. Exmple (,, " (4,5,6
More informationVector differentiation. Chapters 6, 7
Chpter 2 Vectors Courtesy NASA/JPLCltech Summry (see exmples in Hw 1, 2, 3) Circ 1900 A.D., J. Willird Gis invented useful comintion of mgnitude nd direction clled vectors nd their higherdimensionl counterprts
More informationSimulation of operation modes of isochronous cyclotron by a new interative method
NUKLEONIKA 27;52(1):29 34 ORIGINAL PAPER Simultion of opertion modes of isochronous cyclotron y new intertive method Ryszrd Trszkiewicz, Mrek Tlch, Jcek Sulikowski, Henryk Doruch, Tdeusz Norys, Artur Srok,
More informationAssessing authentically in the Graduate Diploma of Education
Assessing uthenticlly in the Grdute Diplom of Eduction Dr Mree DinnThompson Dr Ruth Hickey Dr Michelle Lsen WIL Seminr JCU Nov 12 2009 Key ides plnning process tht embeds uthentic ssessment, workintegrted
More informationHillsborough Township Public Schools Mathematics Department Computer Programming 1
Essentil Unit 1 Introduction to Progrmming Pcing: 15 dys Common Unit Test Wht re the ethicl implictions for ming in tody s world? There re ethicl responsibilities to consider when writing computer s. Citizenship,
More informationRegular Sets and Expressions
Regulr Sets nd Expressions Finite utomt re importnt in science, mthemtics, nd engineering. Engineers like them ecuse they re super models for circuits (And, since the dvent of VLSI systems sometimes finite
More informationPROF. BOYAN KOSTADINOV NEW YORK CITY COLLEGE OF TECHNOLOGY, CUNY
MAT 0630 INTERNET RESOURCES, REVIEW OF CONCEPTS AND COMMON MISTAKES PROF. BOYAN KOSTADINOV NEW YORK CITY COLLEGE OF TECHNOLOGY, CUNY Contents 1. ACT Compss Prctice Tests 1 2. Common Mistkes 2 3. Distributive
More informationMultilevel Fuzzy Approach to the Risk and Disaster Management
Act Polytechnic Hungric Vol. 7, No. 4, 21 Multilevel Fuzzy Approch to the Risk nd Disster Mngement Márt Tkács John von Neumnn Fculty of Informtics, Óbud University Bécsi út 96/b, H134 Budpest, Hungry
More informationHealth insurance exchanges What to expect in 2014
Helth insurnce exchnges Wht to expect in 2014 33096CAEENABC 02/13 The bsics of exchnges As prt of the Affordble Cre Act (ACA or helth cre reform lw), strting in 2014 ALL Americns must hve minimum mount
More informationEffect of viscosity on C sugar in Beet sugar factories
ANNUAL TRANSACTIONS OF THE NORDIC RHEOLOGY SOCIETY, VOL. 16, 2008 Effect of on C sugr in Beet sugr fctories Mohmmd Hojjtoleslmy 1, Rez Shokrni 2 nd Ahmd Krsi 3 1 Deprtment of food technology, College of
More informationCOMPONENTS: COMBINED LOADING
LECTURE COMPONENTS: COMBINED LOADING Third Edition A. J. Clrk School of Engineering Deprtment of Civil nd Environmentl Engineering 24 Chpter 8.4 by Dr. Ibrhim A. Asskkf SPRING 2003 ENES 220 Mechnics of
More informationAnswer, Key Homework 10 David McIntyre 1
Answer, Key Homework 10 Dvid McIntyre 1 This printout should hve 22 questions, check tht it is complete. Multiplechoice questions my continue on the next column or pge: find ll choices efore mking your
More information4.11 Inner Product Spaces
314 CHAPTER 4 Vector Spces 9. A mtrix of the form 0 0 b c 0 d 0 0 e 0 f g 0 h 0 cnnot be invertible. 10. A mtrix of the form bc d e f ghi such tht e bd = 0 cnnot be invertible. 4.11 Inner Product Spces
More informationLearneroriented distance education supporting service system model and applied research
SHS Web of Conferences 24, 02001 (2016) DOI: 10.1051/ shsconf/20162402001 C Owned by the uthors, published by EDP Sciences, 2016 Lerneroriented distnce eduction supporting service system model nd pplied
More informationMath 135 Circles and Completing the Square Examples
Mth 135 Circles nd Completing the Squre Exmples A perfect squre is number such tht = b 2 for some rel number b. Some exmples of perfect squres re 4 = 2 2, 16 = 4 2, 169 = 13 2. We wish to hve method for
More informationRevisions published in the University of Innsbruck Bulletin of 18 June 2014, Issue 31, No. 509
Plese note: The following curriculum is for informtion purposes only nd not leglly inding. The leglly inding version is pulished in the pertinent University of Innsruck Bulletins. Originl version pulished
More informationSpace Vector Pulse Width Modulation Based Induction Motor with V/F Control
Interntionl Journl of Science nd Reserch (IJSR) Spce Vector Pulse Width Modultion Bsed Induction Motor with V/F Control Vikrmrjn Jmbulingm Electricl nd Electronics Engineering, VIT University, Indi Abstrct:
More informationP.3 Polynomials and Factoring. P.3 an 1. Polynomial STUDY TIP. Example 1 Writing Polynomials in Standard Form. What you should learn
33337_0P03.qp 2/27/06 24 9:3 AM Chpter P Pge 24 Prerequisites P.3 Polynomils nd Fctoring Wht you should lern Polynomils An lgeric epression is collection of vriles nd rel numers. The most common type of
More information0.1 Basic Set Theory and Interval Notation
0.1 Bsic Set Theory nd Intervl Nottion 3 0.1 Bsic Set Theory nd Intervl Nottion 0.1.1 Some Bsic Set Theory Notions Like ll good Mth ooks, we egin with definition. Definition 0.1. A set is welldefined
More informationTITLE THE PRINCIPLES OF COINTAP METHOD OF NONDESTRUCTIVE TESTING
TITLE THE PRINCIPLES OF COINTAP METHOD OF NONDESTRUCTIVE TESTING Sung Joon Kim*, DongChul Che Kore Aerospce Reserch Institute, 45 EoeunDong, YouseongGu, Dejeon, 35333, Kore Phone : 824286231 FAX
More informationA Network Management System for PowerLine Communications and its Verification by Simulation
A Network Mngement System for PowerLine Communictions nd its Verifiction y Simultion Mrkus Seeck, Gerd Bumiller GmH UnterschluerscherHuptstr. 10, D90613 Großhersdorf, Germny Phone: +49 9105 996051,
More informationHealth insurance marketplace What to expect in 2014
Helth insurnce mrketplce Wht to expect in 2014 33096VAEENBVA 06/13 The bsics of the mrketplce As prt of the Affordble Cre Act (ACA or helth cre reform lw), strting in 2014 ALL Americns must hve minimum
More informationPhysics 6010, Fall 2010 Symmetries and Conservation Laws: Energy, Momentum and Angular Momentum Relevant Sections in Text: 2.6, 2.
Physics 6010, Fll 2010 Symmetries nd Conservtion Lws: Energy, Momentum nd Angulr Momentum Relevnt Sections in Text: 2.6, 2.7 Symmetries nd Conservtion Lws By conservtion lw we men quntity constructed from
More informationIntroducing Kashef for Application Monitoring
WextWise 2010 Introducing Kshef for Appliction The Cse for Reltime monitoring of dtcenter helth is criticl IT process serving vriety of needs. Avilbility requirements of 6 nd 7 nines of tody SOA oriented
More informationValue Function Approximation using Multiple Aggregation for Multiattribute Resource Management
Journl of Mchine Lerning Reserch 9 (2008) 20792 Submitted 8/08; Published 0/08 Vlue Function Approximtion using Multiple Aggregtion for Multittribute Resource Mngement Abrhm George Wrren B. Powell Deprtment
More informationUnderstanding Basic Analog Ideal Op Amps
Appliction Report SLAA068A  April 2000 Understnding Bsic Anlog Idel Op Amps Ron Mncini Mixed Signl Products ABSTRACT This ppliction report develops the equtions for the idel opertionl mplifier (op mp).
More informationRadius of the Earth  Radii Used in Geodesy James R. Clynch February 2006
dius of the Erth  dii Used in Geodesy Jmes. Clynch Februry 006 I. Erth dii Uses There is only one rdius of sphere. The erth is pproximtely sphere nd therefore, for some cses, this pproximtion is dequte.
More informationCOVER CROP VARIETY AND SEEDING RATE EFFECTS ON WINTER WEED SEED PRODUCTION
COVER CROP VARIETY AND SEEDING RATE EFFECTS ON WINTER WEED SEED PRODUCTION Nthn S. Boyd nd Eric B. Brennn, USDAARS, Orgnic Reserch Progrm, 1636 E. Alisl Street, Slins, CA 93905 Astrct Weed mngement is
More informationg(y(a), y(b)) = o, B a y(a)+b b y(b)=c, Boundary Value Problems Lecture Notes to Accompany
Lecture Notes to Accompny Scientific Computing An Introductory Survey Second Edition by Michel T Heth Boundry Vlue Problems Side conditions prescribing solution or derivtive vlues t specified points required
More informationTest Management using Telelogic DOORS. Francisco López Telelogic DOORS Specialist
Test Mngement using Telelogic DOORS Frncisco López Telelogic DOORS Specilist Introduction Telelogic solution for Requirements Mngement DOORS Requirements mngement nd trcebility pltform for complex systems
More informationAntiSpyware Enterprise Module 8.5
AntiSpywre Enterprise Module 8.5 Product Guide Aout the AntiSpywre Enterprise Module The McAfee AntiSpywre Enterprise Module 8.5 is n ddon to the VirusScn Enterprise 8.5i product tht extends its ility
More informationThis paper considers two independent firms that invest in resources such as capacity or inventory based on
MANAGEMENT SCIENCE Vol. 5, No., December 006, pp. 93 99 issn 005909 eissn 56550 06 5 93 informs doi 0.87/mnsc.060.0574 006 INFORMS Strtegic Investments, Trding, nd Pricing Under Forecst Updting Jiri
More informationThe Velocity Factor of an Insulated TwoWire Transmission Line
The Velocity Fctor of n Insulted TwoWire Trnsmission Line Problem Kirk T. McDonld Joseph Henry Lbortories, Princeton University, Princeton, NJ 08544 Mrch 7, 008 Estimte the velocity fctor F = v/c nd the
More informationWeek 7  Perfect Competition and Monopoly
Week 7  Perfect Competition nd Monopoly Our im here is to compre the industrywide response to chnges in demnd nd costs by monopolized industry nd by perfectly competitive one. We distinguish between
More informationModule 2. Analysis of Statically Indeterminate Structures by the Matrix Force Method. Version 2 CE IIT, Kharagpur
Module Anlysis of Stticlly Indeterminte Structures by the Mtrix Force Method Version CE IIT, Khrgpur esson 9 The Force Method of Anlysis: Bems (Continued) Version CE IIT, Khrgpur Instructionl Objectives
More informationSmall Business Networking
Why network is n essentil productivity tool for ny smll business Effective technology is essentil for smll businesses looking to increse the productivity of their people nd processes. Introducing technology
More informationSmall Business Networking
Why network is n essentil productivity tool for ny smll business Effective technology is essentil for smll businesses looking to increse the productivity of their people nd business. Introducing technology
More informationUnit 6: Exponents and Radicals
Eponents nd Rdicls : The Rel Numer Sstem Unit : Eponents nd Rdicls Pure Mth 0 Notes Nturl Numers (N):  counting numers. {,,,,, } Whole Numers (W):  counting numers with 0. {0,,,,,, } Integers (I): 
More informationRTL Power Optimization with Gatelevel Accuracy
RTL Power Optimiztion with Gtelevel Accurcy Qi Wng Cdence Design Systems, Inc Sumit Roy Clypto Design Systems, Inc 555 River Oks Prkwy, Sn Jose 95125 2903 Bunker Hill Lne, Suite 208, SntClr 95054 qwng@cdence.com
More informationThe International Association for the Properties of Water and Steam. Release on the Ionization Constant of H 2 O
The Interntionl Assocition for the Properties of Wter nd Stem Lucerne, Sitzerlnd August 7 Relese on the Ioniztion Constnt of H O 7 The Interntionl Assocition for the Properties of Wter nd Stem Publiction
More information6.2 Volumes of Revolution: The Disk Method
mth ppliction: volumes of revolution, prt ii Volumes of Revolution: The Disk Method One of the simplest pplictions of integrtion (Theorem ) nd the ccumultion process is to determine soclled volumes of
More information