Miniature Circuit Breakers

Similar documents
Mini Circuit Breakers, Fuse Blocks, and Electronic Circuit Protection

R.C.C.B. s two-pole LEXIC

Low voltage Direct Current Network. Compact NSX DC PV. Circuit breakers and switch disconnectors for solar application.

Unified requirements for systems with voltages above 1 kv up to 15 kv

The complete range of consumer switchboards and switchgear

DOMESTIC ELECTRICAL INSTALLATION CERTIFICATE (Requirements for Electrical Installations BS 7671 IEE Wiring Regulations)

SURGE PROTECTIVE DEVICES

Bulletin 1489 Circuit Breakers. Selection Guide

PROTECTION AGAINST ELECTRIC SHOCK by John Ware

12 SOLAR PHOTOVOLTAIC POWER SUPPLY SYSTEMS by John Ware. PV modules are current-limiting

Circuit Breakers. Next Generation of Protection Capabilities

Breaking and protection devices

BRITISH STYLE SEMICONDUCTOR PROTECTION FUSES

Molded Case Circuit Breakers, Motor Protection Circuit Breakers, and Motor Circuit Protectors. Technical Data

Technical Redline ED.03

CIRCUIT BREAKER INTERRUPTING CAPACITY AND SHORT-TIME CURRENT RATINGS

3.1.1 Full Type Tests & Routine Tests according to Clause 8 2 & Instructions For Installation, Operation & Maintenance

Molded Case Circuit Breaker Specifications Bulletin Number 140U-D

ISL Insulation monitoring devices Continuous monitoring of IT systems from photovoltaic to industrial applications.

Residual Current Circuit Breaker

SENTRON Switching and Protection Devices Air Circuit Breakers

Protection catalogue 15

Sentron Series Circuit Breakers

Tmax MCCBs. Molded case circuit breakers. Tmax

Technical guide Protection against earth faults with Residual Current Devices

Bulletin 150 SMC Flex Smart Motor Controller Specifications

Fundamentals of Power

NZECP 14: 1995 ISSN COVER PAGE

ELECTRICAL INSTALLATION CONDITION REPORT (Requirements for Electrical Installations BS 7671 IEE Wiring Regulations)

Manual motor starter MS116

Trade of Electrician. Three-phase Distribution Boards And Socket Circuits

Low Voltage Products. Switches Automatic Transfer Switches

Miniature circuit 3.2 breakers 6kA type B SP. Miniature circuit 3.3 breakers curve B,C&D 10kA and 15kA. Protection Devices

A B Brown. This sheet forms part of *Inspection Report Number/*Certificate Number NA/ * EC/ * PIR *Delete as applicable DB

Thermal-Magnetic Circuit Breaker M1-..

Electronic overload relay EF65, EF96 and EF146

SUBJECT: How to wire a motor starter Number: AN-MC-004 Date Issued: 2/08/2005 Revision: Original

Electrical auxiliaries 0 For i DPN (DPN), C60 and C120

5SV Residual Current Protective Devices

Digital Energy ITI. Instrument Transformer Basic Technical Information and Application

High Speed Fuses. High Speed Fuses

Application Switchgear for industrial and commercial applications. U e V AC 230/ (per pole)

Type: DILM115(RAC240) Article No.: Sales text Contactor,55kW/400V,AC operated. Ordering information

Electronic Trip Circuit Breaker Basics Circuit Breaker Application Guide Class 0600

SIRCOVER. Manual changeover switches from 125 to 3200 A. Changeover switches. Function. Advantages. The solution for.

CATALOGUE SURGE PROTECTION LOW VOLTAGE

Bimetallic Overload Relay Specifications

Positive-guided relay outputs: 3 safety contacts (N/O), instantaneous. 1 auxiliary contact (N/C), instantaneous

Electronic overload relay EF19 and EF45

Guide to the Selection & Use of Residual Current Devices

Product and functional description

Uncompromising safety and comfort The next generation of miniature circuit breakers MCB S 200/S 200 M

MEDIUM VOLTAGE CE-BF SWITCHBOARDS. UP TO 40.5 kv. CE - BF - C - en - REV

6 ELECTRICAL PARAMETERS

Reverse-feed applications for circuit breakers

Safety technique. Emergency stop module BO 5988 safemaster

6.0 Electrical Installations

SELECTION OF FINAL CIRCUIT PROTECTION

System pro M compact Miniature Circuit Breaker S 200/S 200 M

Submit shop drawings for equipment provided under this section Shop drawings shall indicate:

Dimensions, Inches (mm) No. of Poles Width Height Depth 2, (210) 16 (407) 5.5 (140) (283) 16 (407) 5.5 (140)

Type: DILM50(230V50HZ,240V60HZ) Article No.:

What are the basic electrical safety issues and remedies in solar photovoltaic installations?

Bussmann. All-In-One Module. Bussmann Power Module Switch. How to configure Part Numbers: Step 1: Select Switch Amperage 1

LC1D65AM7 TeSys D contactor - 3P(3 NO) - AC-3 - <= 440 V 65 A V AC coil

Installation instructions for mains wire-in protectors ESP D1, D1R, D1/LCD and D1R/LCD variants

Magnetic and Hydraulic-Magnetic Circuit Breaker 8340-G2...

White paper. ABB solutions for switching and protection of low speed wind turbines

Circuit Breakers Supplementary Protectors Manual Motor Controllers

Criteria for Selecting a Residual-Current Device

E-STOP relays, safety gate monitors

Residual Current Protective Devices

Spare parts Catalogue

Circuit Breaker. Description

How can a charging station for electric vehicles be set up simply and safely?

Current and voltage measuring relays

Type: DILM9 10(24VDC) Article No.:

RM17TE V AC. Main. Product or component type. Product specific application. Relay monitored parameters 250 V DC 5 A DC

IZM ACB/Circuit-breakers. Robust safety. Extract from Main Catalogue HPL2010 IZM26 Circuit-breakers IN26 Switch-disconnectors

LV MCC LOW VOLTAGE SWITCHGEAR MOTOR CONTROL CENTRE PRODUCT GUIDE

ABB 1. Three-phase monitoring relay CM-PFS. Data sheet. Features. Approvals. Marks. Order data. Order data - Accessories. Application.

Mini Motor Contactor J7KNA Main contactor Accessories Approved Standards Standard Guide No (US,C) Ordering Information tage Model Number Legend gear

Current valve. for AC 24 V pulse/pause control of electrical loads up to 30 kw

British BS 88 Fuses. Introduction

Voltage monitoring relays CM-ESS.2 For single-phase AC/DC voltages

Low Voltage Switchgear

ABB 1 NEW. Three-phase monitoring relay for grid feeding CM-UFS.1. Data sheet. Features. Approvals. Marks. Order data. Order data - Accessories

Instruction Bulletin. MCS025 Sync-Check Module Installation Sheet

Vario-Series Accessories

Eaton s E-Series protective relay family

Product and Applications Description. Application Programs. Example of Operation. GAMMA instabus Technical Product-Information.

Type: DILM32 10(24V50HZ) Article No.:

CHAPTER 2 EXAMPLES AND TABLES

CAPACITOR BANK TESTING SWP

CONDUCTOR SHORT-CIRCUIT PROTECTION

Guidelines on the Short Circuit Current Rating for Industrial Control Panels

EARTHING SYSTEM CALCULATION

Permissible ambient temperature Operation Storage, transport

Bulletin 150 Smart Motor Controllers SMC-3 Smart Motor Controller

TWENTIES WORKSHOP, EWEA 2012 Unveiling the future energy system: full scale demonstrations to reach 2020 targets. 17th April 2012

Transcription:

Miniature Circuit Breakers Reliable solutions for protection of installations against over-current phenomenon Advantages for you : Bi-connect terminals for simultaneous termination of bus bar & wires Unique pull up terminals design with safety shutters for enhanced safety of users Positive contact indicator Line-load reversibility Low watt losses, saves energy High electrical life Wide range of accessories eg U/V release, over-voltage release, shunt release, Aux & trip alarm conatcts Technical data : Conforms to IEC 60898-1, IS/IEC 60898-1:2002 Ratings 0.5 to 63 A No. of poles 1P, 2P, 3P & 4P Tripping characteristics B, C & D curves Breaking capacity 10kA (as per IS/IEC 60898-1:2002) Suitable for Isolation as per IEC 60947 CE and RoHS compliant

Expert tips Positive contact indicator Red : ON Green : OFF more safety to the user positive contact indication indicates actual contact position User friendly terminal design bi-connect terminal pull-up design safety shutter (IP2X) 10kA breaking capacity with energy limitation class 3 high breaking capacity better protection of cables and equipments low let through energy line load reversible Wide range of accessories overvoltage release MZ209 undervoltage release shunt release auxiliary contact & trip alarm contact for on-off & trip indication

Miniature circuit breakers 10kA type NB, NC, ND Description Protects circuits against overload & short circuit faults Provides isolation to downstream circuits Technical data Conforms to IEC 60898-1:2002 IS/IEC 60898-1:2002 Ratings - 0.5 to 63 A No. of poles - 1P, 2P, 3P & 4P Tripping curves - B, C & D Breaking capacity 10kA (as per IEC 60898-1) 15kA (as per IEC 60947) Suitable for isolation as per IEC 60947 Features & benefits Positive contact indicator on front face 10kA breaking capacity with class 3 energy limitation Bi-connect terminals with pull-up design Finger proof (IP2X) terminal with safety shutters Line-load reversible RoHS compliant, Green product Wide range of accessories are available Connection 25sq mm rigid cables 16sq mm flexible cables Description Modules In (Amp) B Curve C Curve D Curve NC110N NC220N NC316N NC432N 1P 1 0.5 NC100N ND100N 1 1 NC101N ND101N 1 2 NC102N ND102N 1 3 NC103N ND103N 1 4 NC104N ND104N 1 6 NB106N NC106N ND106N 1 10 NB110N NC110N ND110N 1 16 NB116N NC116N ND116N 1 20 NB120N NC120N ND120N 1 25 NB125N NC125N ND125N 1 32 NB132N NC132N ND132N 1 40 NB140N NC140N ND140N 1 50 NB150N NC150N ND150N 1 63 NB163N NC163N ND163N 2P 2 0.5 NC200N ND200N 2 1 NC201N ND201N 2 2 NC202N ND202N 2 3 NC203N ND203N 2 4 NC204N ND204N 2 6 NB206N NC206N ND206N 2 10 NB210N NC210N ND210N 2 16 NB216N NC216N ND216N 2 20 NB220N NC220N ND220N 2 25 NB225N NC225N ND225N 2 32 NB232N NC232N ND232N 2 40 NB240N NC240N ND240N 2 50 NB250N NC250N ND250N 2 63 NB263N NC263N ND263N 3P 3 0.5 NC300N ND300N 3 1 NC301N ND301N 3 2 NC302N ND302N 3 3 NC303N ND303N 3 4 NC304N ND304N 3 6 NB306N NC306N ND306N 3 10 NB310N NC310N ND310N 3 16 NB316N NC316N ND316N 3 20 NB320N NC320N ND320N 3 25 NB325N NC325N ND325N 3 32 NB332N NC332N ND332N 3 40 NB340N NC340N ND340N 3 50 NB350N NC350N ND350N 3 63 NB363N NC363N ND363N 4P 4 0.5 NC400N ND400N 4 1 NC401N ND401N 4 2 NC402N ND402N 4 3 NC403N ND403N 4 4 NC404N ND404N 4 6 NB406N NC406N ND406N 4 10 NB410N NC410N ND410N 4 16 NB416N NC416N ND416N 4 20 NB420N NC420N ND420N 4 25 NB425N NC425N ND425N 4 32 NB432N NC432N ND432N 4 40 NB440N NC440N ND440N 4 50 NB450N NC450N ND450N 4 63 NB463N NC463N ND463N 40

Miniature circuit breakers 80-125A, 10kA type HLF Description Protects circuits against overload & short circuit faults Provides isolation to downstream circuits Technical data Conforms to IEC 60898-1 IEC 60947 Ratings 80A,100A &125A No. of poles - 1P, 2P, 3P & 4P Tripping curve - C Breaking capacity - 10kA (as per IEC 60898 & 60947) Suitable for isolation as per IEC 60947 Features & benefits: MCBs handle can be locked in "off" position Large terminal capacity- upto 70 sq mm Steel reinforcement plate to improve terminal strength Serrations on jaws to provide better grip on cables Line-load reversible RoHS compliant, Green product Wide range of accessories are available Connection capacity 35 sq mm flexible wire (50 sq mm possible with some cable end-caps) 70 sq mm rigid wire IP2X terminals Description In (Amp) Modules Catalogue No. 1P 80 1.5 HLF180S 100 1.5 HLF190S 125 1.5 HLF199S HLF199S 2P 80 3 HLF280S 100 3 HLF290S 125 3 HLF299S HLF299S 3P 80 4.5 HLF380S 100 4.5 HLF390S 125 4.5 HLF399S HLF399S 4P 80 6 HLF480S 100 6 HLF490S 125 6 HLF499S HLF499S 41

Circuit protection principle (R 1 +R 2 ) - where R 1 is the resistance of the phase conductor within the installation and R 2 is the resistance of the circuit protective conductor. These two components constitute the loop impedance within the installation. Therefore : Z s = Z e +(R 1 +R 2 ) Once the value of Z s has been established a suitable overcurrent protective device has to be selected to ensure disconnection of an earth fault within the specified time. The times are : 5 seconds for fixed equipment For portable equipment and for fixed equipment installed outside the equipotential bonding zone, the disconnection times are dependent on the nominal voltage to earth, i.e. 220 to 277 volts = 0.4 seconds. Z s by calculation To establish whether the relevant disconnection time can be achieved a simple calculation must be made, based on Ohm's law : l f (fault current) = Uo (open circuit voltage)* Z s (earth fault loop) *voltage between phase and earth (240V) The fault current (lf) must be high enough to cause the circuit protective device to trip in the specified time. This can be established by consulting the time/current characteristic for the protective device. If the maximum trip time for the fault current calculated is less than or equal to the relevant value (5s) for fixed equipment; 0.4s for portable equipment) then compliance is achieved. Z s by tables The above procedure can be used for any type of protective device providing a time/current characteristic curve is available. Frequently, however, a much simpler method is available using tables listing maximum Z s values which have been interpreted from the characteristic curves for the relevant devices. Providing the system Z s is equal to or less than the value given in the table, compliance is achieved. Z s too high If the system Z s value is too high to achieve rapid enough disconnection with the Overcurrent protective devices available then it is necessary to use one of the two following methods: fit a cable with a large cross-section and consequently a lower impedance. This may be a very expensive solution especially when the installation is completed before the problem is discovered. use a Hager residual current device (RCD). Subject to certain conditions being met this provides a simple and economical solution. Example Fig. shows a fixed circuit with an earth loop impedance Z s of 0.7 ohms protected with an NC 132. The fault current (l f ) will therefore be U o /Z s = 240/0.7 = 343A By referring to the characteristic for NC 132 it can be seen that the breaker will disconnect in 0.02 seconds for this current. The breaker therefore easily satisfies the requirement for disconnection in 5 seconds. If the circuit Z s was 2.0 ohms that the fault current would be : 240/2-120A and the disconnection time would be 10 seconds, in which case compliance would not be achieved. Fig. 3 Protection against overcurrent Overcurrent - "A current exceeding the rate value. For conductors the rated value is the current-carrying capacity". Overload current - "An overcurrent occurring in a circuit which is electrically sound". Short-circuit current - "An overcurrent resulting from a fault of negligible impedance between live conductors having a difference in potential under normal operating conditions." Protection against overload current For the protection against overload current, protective devices must be provided in the circuit to break any overload current flowing in the circuit conductors before it can cause a temperature rise which would be detrimental to insulation, joints, terminations or the surrounding of the conductors. In order to achieve this protection the normal current of the protective device l n should not be less than the design current of the circuit l b and that l n should not exceed the current-carrying capacity of the conductors l z, and that the current causing effective operation of the protective device l 2 does not exceed 1.45 times the current-carrying capacity of the conductor l z, expressed as l b < l n < l z l 2 <1.45l z Protection against short-circuit current Protective devices must be provided to break any short-circuit current before it can cause danger due to thermal and mechanical (elector-dynamic) effects produced in the conductors and connections. The breaking capacity of the protective device shall not be less than the prospective short-circuit current at the point at which the device is installed. However lower breaking capacity is permitted provided that a properly co-ordinated back-up device having the necessary breaking capacity is installed on the supply side. Positioning of overcurrent devices An earth fault current of 343A causes a trip of the magnetic protection in 20mS. An earth fault current of 120A causes a trip of the thermal protection in 10 seconds. Devices for the protection against overload and short-circuit must be placed at the point where a reduction occurs in the current-carrying capacity of the conductors. This reduction could be caused by a change in the environmental conditions as well as the more obvious change in the cross-sectional area of the cable. There are of course exceptions to the general rule which relate to a very few special applications. 108

Circuit protection principle Standardised Earthing Schemes In all countries, LV networks and load are earthed for safety reasons to guarantee protection against electric current for persons. Additionally, the Earthing System affects the choice of protection devices employed in some cases. The TT- Scheme : The transformer neutral is earthed. The frames of the electric load are also connected to an earth connection. The earthing schemes characterise the method of earthing the LV neutral point of the HV/LV transformer (or of any source) and the means of earthing exposed conductive parts of the related LV installation. The three earthing system internationally standardised and currently adopted in many national standards are : The TN system : The transformer neutral is earthed. The frames of the electrical loads are connected to the neutral. Several versions of TN schemes are : TN-C scheme : The neutral conductor is also used as a protective conductor and is referred to as a PEN (Protective Earth and Neutral) conductor. This scheme is not permitted for PEN conductor of less than 10mm 2 and for the portable equipment. The IT-Scheme : The transformer neutral is not earthed theoretically. In practice, it is earthed via high impedance = 1500 Ohms. The frames of the electrical loads are connected to the earth. TN-S scheme : TN-C scheme The protective conductor and the neutral conductor are separate. The use of PE and N conductors is mandatory for circuits of cross section less than 10mm 2. First Fault TN-S scheme TN-CS scheme : In some installation the TN-C and TN-S schemes can be used together. Such scheme are known as TN-CS. However, it is not allowed to use the TN-C downstream of TN-S. Second Fault 109

Miniature circuit breakers Characterist ics ML NB NC ND HLF Poles SP+N SP DP TP FP SP DP TP FP SP DP TP FP SP DP TP FP Rated operational 230 230/415 230/415 230/415 230/415 voltage U e(v) Nominal Current 6-40A 6-63A 0.5-63A 0.5-63A 80-100-125A Breaking capacity 6kA 10kA 10kA 10kA 10kA to IEC 60 898 Breaking capacity - 15kA 15kA 15kA 10kA to IEC 60 947-2 Rated insulation 500V 500V 500V 500V 500V voltage U i(v) Rated impulse 4000V 4000V 4000V 6000V 6000V voltage U imp (kv) Electrical endurance 0.5 to 32A 10000 20000 20000 20000 40 to 63A 10000 10000 10000 80 to 125A 4000 Power loss The power loss of MCB's is closely controlled by the standards and is calculated on the basis of the voltage drop across the main terminals measured at rated current. The power loss of Hager circuit breakers is very much lower than that required by the Standard, so in consequences run cooler and are less affected when mounted together. The table below gives the watts loss per pole at rated current MCB rated 0.5 1 2 3 4 6 10 16 20 25 32 40 50 63 80 100 125 current (A) Watts loss 1.3 1.5 1.7 2.1 2.4 2.7 1.8 2.6 2.8 3.3 3.9 4.3 4.8 5.2 5 5.5 8 per pole (W) For use with DC Because of their quick make and break design and excellent arc quenching capabilities Hager circuit breakers are suitable for DC applications. The following parameters must be considered. 1. system voltage: Determined by the number of poles connected in series 2. short-circuit current: 3. tripping characteristics: - the thermal trip remains unchanged - the magnetic trip will become less sensitive requiring derating by 2 the ac value. No. of poles 1 pole 2 poles in series Range Max Breaking capacity Max Breaking capacity voltage L/R=15ms voltage L/R=15ms NB, NC, ND 60V 10kA 125V 10kA HLF 60V 15kA 125V 15kA NB, NC, ND Characteristic curve B C D Magnetic trip 50Hz dc 50Hz dc 50Hz dc Irm1 3 In 4.5 In 5 In 7.5 In 10 In 15 In Irm2 5 In 7.5 In 10 In 15 In 20 In 30 In HLF (IEC 60-898) Characteristic curve C Magnetic trip 50Hz dc Irm1 5 In 7.1 In Irm2 10 In 14.1 In 110

Miniature circuit breakers Latest national & international standards covering Low Voltage Circuit Breakers provide the user with a better assurance of quality and performance by taking into account the actual operating conditions of the breaker. New definitions and symbols have been introduced which should be committed to memory. Some of those most frequently used are: U e : rated service voltage U i : rated insulation voltage (>Uemax) U imp : rated impulse withstand l cm : rated short circuit making capacity l cn : rated short circuit capacity l cs : rated service short circuit breaking capacity l cu : rated ultimate short circuit breaking capacity l n : rated residual operating current (often called residual sensitivity) l n : rated current = maximum value of current used for the temperature rise test. t : trip delay of residual current devices In addition, IEC 60898 sets out to provide a greater degree of safety to the uninstructed users of circuit breakers. It is interesting to note that the description "miniature circuit breaker" or MCB is not used at all in the standard, but no doubt both manufacturers and users will continue to call circuit breakers complying with IEC 60898 miniature circuit breakers or MCBs for some time to come. The scope of this standard is limited to ac air break circuit breakers for operation at 50Hz or 60Hz, having a rated current not exceeding 125A and a rated short-circuit capacity not exceeding 25kA. A rated service short-circuit breaking capacity l cs is also included which is equal to the rated short-circuit capacity l cn for short-circuit capacity values up to and including 6kA, and 50% of lcn above 6kA with a minimum value of 7.5kA. as the circuit-breakers covered by this standard are intended for household and similar use, lcs is of academic interest only. The rated short-circuit capacity of a MCB (l cn) is the alternating component of the prospective current expressed by its r.m.s. value, which the MCB is designed to make, carry, for its opening time and to break under specified conditions. l cn is shown on the MCB label in a rectangular box with the suffix 'A' and is the value which is used for application purposes. lcn (of the MCB) should be equal to or greater than the prospective short-circuit current at the point of application. You will see from the curves that the inverse time delay characteristic which provides overload protection is the same on all three. This is because the standards required the breaker to carry 1.13 times the rated current without tripping for at least one hour and when the test current is increased to 1.45 times the rated current, it must trip within one hour, and again from cold if the last current is increased to 2.55 times the rated current the breaker must trip between 1 and 120 seconds. The inverse time delay characteristic of all MCBs claiming compliance with IEC 60898 must operate within these limits. should be used and for desk top co-ordination studies, both lower and upper limits have to be taken into account. Energy limiting Energy is measured in Joules. *James Prescott Joule proved that thermal energy was produced when an electric current flowed through a resistance for a certain time, giving us the formula :- Joules = l 2 x R x t or because we know that watts = l 2 R Joules = watts x seconds Therefore we can say that : One Joule = one watt second or energy = watts x seconds = l 2 R t If the resistance (R) remains constant or is very small compared with the current (I) as in the case of short-circuit current, then energy becomes proportional to l 2 t. Which is why the energy let-through of a protective device is expressed in ampere squared seconds and referred to as l 2 t. l 2 t (Joule Integral) is the integral of the square of the current over a given time interval (t 0, t 1 ) The l 2 t characteristic of a circuit breaker is shown as a curve giving the maximum values of the prospective current as a function of time. Manufacturers are required by the Standard to produce the l 2 t characteristic of their circuit breakers. The energy limiting characteristics of modern MCBs greatly reduce the damage that might otherwise be caused by short-circuits. They protect the cable insulation and reduce the risk of fire and other damage. Knowledge of the energy limiting characteristic of a circuit breaker also helps the circuit designer calculate discrimination with other protective devices in the same circuit. Because of the importance energy limiting characteristic the Standards for circuit breakers for household and similar installations suggests three energy limiting classes based on the permissible l 2 t (let-through) values for circuit breakers up to 32A; class 3 having the highest energy limiting performance. All Hager MCBs are well within the limits of energy let-through set by IEC 60898 for energy limiting class 3. The circuit breaker can have the line\load connected to either top or bottom terminals. The difference between the three types of characteristic curves designated 'B', 'C' and 'D' concerns only the magnetic instantaneous trip which provides short-circuit protection. * For type 'B' the breaker must trip between the limits of 3 to 5 times rated current * For type 'C' the breaker must trip between the limits of 5 to 10 times rated current, and * For type 'D' the breaker must trip between the limits of 10 to 20 times rated current Often manufacturers publish their MCB tripping characteristics showing the limits set by the standard and guarantee that any breakers that you purchase will operate within these limits. So great care should be taken when working with characteristics curves showing lower and higher limits - on no account should you take a mean point for application design purposes. For cable protection applications you should take the maximum tripping time and some manufacturers publish single line characteristics curves which show the maximum tripping time. If the design problem is nuisance tripping then the minimum tripping time 111