# Correct Resolution of the Twin Paradox

Save this PDF as:

Size: px
Start display at page:

## Transcription

1 Correct Resolution of the Twin Paradox Michael Huemer In the following, I explain the Twin Paradox, which is supposed to be a paradoxical consequence of the Special Theory of Relativity (STR). I give the correct resolution of the paradox, explaining why STR is not inconsistent as it appears at first glance. I also debunk two common, incorrect responses to the paradox. This should help the reader to understand Special Relativity and to see how the theory is coherent. I. Background: Time and Length Dilation According to STR, different intertial reference frames (RF s) can disagree on the time that elapses between two events, as well as on the length of an object. These discrepancies are described by the Lorentz Transformation equations: Here, L 0 is the length an object has in a reference frame in which it is at rest, while L is the length the object has according to a reference frame in which it is moving at velocity v. Similarly, T 0 is the time between some pair of events in a reference frame in which the events take place at the same (spatial) place, whereas T is the time between those events according to a reference frame in which the events are separated by a path of velocity v (that is, the ratio of the spatial distance between the events to the temporal distance between the events is v). c is the speed of light. For example: suppose I m in a spaceship that s traveling at c/2 (half the speed of light) relative to the Earth. Suppose that in my reference frame, I measure my ship to be 100 feet long. So L 0 = 100 ft. Then observers on Earth are going to measure my spaceship to have a length of: Similarly, suppose that I have a clock in my spaceship. At the start of my journey, my clock reads 12:00. My clock measures elapsed time according to my reference frame (i.e., the reference frame 1

2 in which the spaceship is at rest). So when the clock strikes 1:00, 1 hour has passed in my reference frame. So T 0 = 1 hr. However, people on Earth will see the time between these two events (my clock striking 12:00 and my clock striking 1:00) as being: So people on Earth will perceive my spaceship as having shrunk (since it is 87 feet long, whereas it was 100 feet long when it was at rest), and they will perceive my clock as moving slower than normal (because it takes it 69 minutes, instead of 60 minutes, to register the passage of an hour). II. The Twin Paradox Here s a statement of the Twin Paradox, designed to make it seem paradoxical: Suppose that two identical twins start out on Earth, the same age. One of them gets in a spaceship and flies around really fast. Call this one Space Twin. The other twin, Earth Twin, stays on Earth the whole time. Finally, Space Twin comes home and meets up with Earth Twin. When they meet, which one will have aged more? Well, according to Earth Twin, Space Twin was moving around really fast, so Space Twin aged slower (like in the example above), so Space Twin is going to look younger. But according to Space Twin, it was Earth Twin who was moving the whole time (in Space Twin s reference frame, Space Twin was stationary). So Earth Twin was aging slower, so Earth Twin is going to look younger. According to STR, both reference frames are equally valid. But presumably, these answers can t both be true; when they see each other, it s not going to be that each of them looks younger than the other. So it looks as if STR with its time dilation postulate is incoherent. The above thinking is in fact wrong; time dilation is not incoherent. I ll explain why below. But first I want to clear the ground of some fallacious explanations. III. Two Wrong Responses to the Twin Paradox I have heard two wrong responses (or claims about the response) to the twin paradox. First, my high school physics teacher said that the resolution of the twin paradox had to do with General 2

3 Relativity, which was beyond the scope of his class. That s false. General Relativity is Einstein s theory of gravitational phenomena. The Twin Paradox has nothing to do with gravitation, nor has it anything to do with the spacetime curvature postulated in GR. As we ll see in section III, the resolution of the paradox can be given purely within a flat (Minkowski) spacetime. The second false resolution I have heard is that it is the Space Twin who will have aged slower, because it was he who had to accelerate in order to get up to his great speed. In STR, there is an objective distinction between accelerated and uniform (non-accelerated) motion. So it s an objective fact that Space Twin underwent acceleration while Earth Twin didn t. Therefore, Space Twin is the one who was really going fast, so he ll have aged slower. Now, how many things are wrong with this response? a. The response is profoundly un-relativistic. It supposes that Space Twin is the one who was really moving during his voyage, because he s the one who accelerated. (That s like what Newton says about absolute motion.) In relativity theory, there is no objective fact about who is moving at any given point in time; at any time, any given person or object is moving according to some RF s and stationary according to others, and all inertial RF s are equally legitimate. So the proposed response can t possibly be the resolution of the problem according to STR. b. There is no requirement, in STR, that there be some initial conditions in which everything starts out at relative rest. Thus, we may stipulate that Space Twin does not undergo any acceleration to get up to his great speed instead, suppose that Space Twin and Earth Twin just start out in relative motion. Space Twin is already going at near light speed (relative to Earth) at the start of our story. (Equivalently, Earth Twin is already going at near light speed relative to Space Twin at the start of the story.) c. There is no mechanism in STR for the past history of some state of motion (or of anything else, for that matter) to directly exert causal power on things now. The Lorentz Transformation Equations discussed in section I above, for example, do not in any way make use of any facts about past history to determine the amount of length or time dilation. Nor does anything in General Relativity do so. Nor, in fact, does any modern physical theory allow the past to directly influence the present (once the current state of the world is given, how we got to that state is irrelevant to what will happen next). So even if Space Twin had to undergo acceleration in the past to get to his current speed, that would be irrelevant to what effects his current speed has on him. d. Finally, notice that the Lorentz Equations do not take account of acceleration at all length dilation and time dilation are purely a function of the rest length (L 0 ) and rest time (T 0 ), the velocity v, and the speed of light c. Acceleration plays no role. Nor is this different in 3

4 General Relativity or any other theory (that is, no other theory gives any modified Lorentz transformations where acceleration appears in the equations). Given that, acceleration can t have anything to do with the solution to the paradox. IV. Correct Resolution of the Paradox There are two cases to consider: In one scenario, the two twins are in uniform motion throughout the story (they neither accelerate nor decelerate, nor change their direction of motion). In another scenario, Space Twin goes off into space for a while, then turns around (deceleration/acceleration) and comes back to Earth. A. The Case of Uniform Motion In the first case, the twins can only have one meeting without accelerating or decelerating, Space Twin will never return to Earth, so the meeting in which they finally see who has aged more will never happen. What does STR say about this scenario? It says that each twin will age slower, as measured by the other twin. How can this be? The secret lies in the relativity of simultaneity. Consider the space-time diagram in Figure 1. In this diagram, line t is the time axis, according to Earth Twin, while s is the space axis (or: a simultaneity slice) according to Earth Twin. Earth Twin thinks that he s always stationary, and thus that he remains on the t axis (he does not change his spatial location his position along s as time passes). He thinks that any path parallel to t is the path of a stationary object (that is, any such path is stationary in his reference frame). Also, Earth Twin would say that all the spacetime points that lie on s are simultaneous with each other, and all of them occur at (say) t = 0. Earth Twin would say that any line parallel to s also marks a collection of spacetime points that are simultaneous with each other. For instance, the horizontal line labeled t = 4 indicates all the spacetime points (or all the events) that occur at time 4. Earth Twin thinks that Space Twin is moving off to the right, on the path labeled t'. Things look different according to Space Twin. Space Twin says that t', not t, is the time axis. He would say that any path parallel to t' is the path of a stationary object. He would say that Earth Twin, who occupies line t, is moving uniformly to the left. Now here s a slightly surprising point: Space Twin s space axis is s', rather than s. (When you tilt your time axis to the right, you have to tilt your space axis toward your time axis. To see why this is true, consider the fact that the speed of light has to be a constant for all reference frames. The speed of light is the ratio of (spatial distance) to (temporal distance) along the path of the light ray. To keep that ratio constant, if you consider an RF whose time axis is tilted to the right, its space axis must be tilted up.) Space Twin would say that all events lying on s' (not the events lying on s) are simultaneous 4

5 Figure 1 with each other. He would likewise say that any line parallel to s' marks off a set of simultaneous spacetime points. For instance, the slanted line labeled t' = 4 represents everything that happens at time 4, according to Space Twin. Now, here s why both twins are aging slower, relative to each other. Consider the point where Earth Twin s clock strikes 4. I have marked this point with an X on the diagram. This is where Earth Twin is when 4 units of time have passed according to his reference frame. Now compare the point where Space Twin s clock strikes 4. This happens on the spaceship (so it s on path t'), and it happens when 4 units of time have passed in Space Twin s reference frame. I ve marked this point with an O. Finally, consider the question: which comes first in time: the X or the O? Well, in Earth Twin s RF, the X comes before the O, because the O appears above the t = 4 line on the diagram. But according to Space Twin s RF, the O comes before the X, because the X appears above the t' = 4 line in the diagram. Both RF s are equally good. So: each twin s clock strikes 4 after the other clock does, as measured by the other twin. 5

6 B. The Two-Meeting Case, from Earth s Reference Frame Now to the puzzling case: what happens if Space Twin comes back to Earth, and meets his brother who will be older at that point? To show precisely what STR predicts about this, we need to fill in some details of the scenario. Let s say that Space Twin took off away from Earth at.5c. Ten years later (as measured from Earth s RF), Space Twin turned around and headed back at.5c, until he got back to Earth. So, on Earth, 20 years elapse while Space Twin is away. Figure 2 shows how things look from Earth s frame of reference. Earth Twin just sits around on the t axis, while Space Twin takes the dotted path labeled. During his trip away from Earth (the first ten years), Space Twin s velocity as measured from Earth is.5c. The time that this half of the trip takes, as measured from Earth, is 10 years. So the Lorentz time dilation equation tells us: Figure 2 Note that I put in 10 for T, because 10 years is the time that that part of the trip takes as measured by a reference frame in which Space Twin is not at rest but is moving at velocity v (remember that that s what we said T stood for in the equation in section I). What we re solving for is T 0, the time that elapses according to a reference frame in which the path is stationary (again, that s what we said T 0 stood for in section I). Now, since Space Twin ages 8.66 years during the first half of his trip (because that s how much time passes in his reference frame), he ll age twice that much in the whole trip, or years. So Earth Twin, having aged 20 years, winds up looking older. 6

7 C. The Two-Meeting Case, from Space Twin s Original Reference Frame To see whether the Theory of Relativity is consistent, let s examine how things look from the reference frame in which the Earth is moving to the left at.5c. In this RF, Space Twin starts out stationary while Earth moves away from him at.5c. The Earth is in uniform motion (moving inertially), so it stays at.5c throughout the story, according to this RF. However, at some point Space Twin (again designated by the ) decides he wants to meet up with Earth Twin again, so he fires his rockets and goes extra fast to catch up to the Earth, which has been zooming away all this time. Figure 3, then, is how things look from the standpoint of this RF. Point A is the point where Earth Figure 3 Twin and Space Twin first part ways. Point B is the point where they reunite. Note that there is no reference frame in which Space Twin is at rest throughout the story: he can be moving to the right for the first half of the story then moving to the left for the second half, or he can be stationary at first and then move to the left, or he can be moving to the right at first and then stop. But he cannot be stationary throughout the story, according to any legitimate (inertial) RF. That s because, in relativity, even though there s no objective fact about how fast one is moving at any time, there is an objective fact about whether one accelerates, and at the point at which Space Twin is firing his rockets, he is accelerating (or decelerating) he s either doing it to turn around, or to move to the left to catch up to the Earth, or to slow down and stop so the Earth can catch up to him (this would be in the RF that has Earth and Space Twin both start out moving to the right, and then Space Twin stops). Now, the following, I claim, is what happens according to the reference frame of Figure 3: Earth travels to the left at.5c for 23.1 years. Space Twin sits on his spaceship, stationary, for 8.66 years. Then he fires up his rockets and travels at.8c to the left for years (= 23.1 yrs yrs.), after which he finally catches up to the Earth. 7

8 To see that everything is consistent (or at least the story about who s aging more than whom), let s see how much each twin should age according to this story. How much does Earth Twin age between point A and point B? Note that T is 23.1, because T is the time between A and B according to an RF in which the path between them is not stationary. T 0 is the time between A and B according to an RF in which the path is stationary. The result that T 0 = 20 years is what we want, because we already said (in section B above) that Earth Twin ages 20 years. (Don t get too excited about this, though I got the 23.1 figure in the first place by solving the above equation in reverse.) The real test is to see what happens to Space Twin how much will he age between point A and point B? Well, during the first part of the story, while he s stationary, he ages 8.66 years (there s no time dilation to calculate, since according to this RF, Space Twin is stationary during this time). Now what happens is that during the second part of the story the part where Space Twin is moving to the left at.8c he s going to age extra slowly, so that he ll wind up younger than Earth Twin at the end. Before calculating that, though, you might be wondering where I got the.8c figure. Well, Space Twin is going to catch up to the Earth after 23.1 years. He s already wasted 8.66 years just sitting around. So he s going to have to cover that distance in the remaining years. Now, the spatial distance he has to cover is just the distance that the Earth covers in the 23.1 years that pass between point A and point B. That spatial distance is given by the formula: So Space Twin is going to have to go a distance of 11.55c in years. So his speed will have to be: Now, how much will Space Twin age during this second part of our story? He s going at.8c for years. So the Time Dilation equation tells us: 8

9 Note that once again, we re solving for T 0, since we re interested in how much time passes on the spaceship, according to the RF in which the spaceship is at rest; that gives us how much the people on the ship age. Now, the total amount that Space Twin ages is: aging during first part of story + aging during second part of story = = yrs. This is exactly the amount of aging that was predicted using the first reference frame, in section B above. So the whole story is consistent. Space Twin ages years, while Earth Twin ages 20 years, no matter which reference frame you use. D. The Two-Meeting Case, from Space Twin s Final Reference Frame I mentioned that there s a third reference frame we could use: that s the RF in which Space Twin is stationary in the second half of the story. This RF looks like this (see Figure 4). Here, the calculations are pretty much the same as in section C above, so I won t bother repeating them. Here s what happens according to this third RF: Earth travels to the right at.5c for 23.1 years. At first, Space Twin is traveling to the right at.8c. He does this for years, after which he fires his rockets to stop and let the Earth catch up, which it does after an additional 8.66 years. During the first part of the story, even though Figure 4 9

10 14.44 years pass, Space Twin only ages 8.66 years because he s going so fast (.8c). During the second part of the story, he ages another 8.66 years, for a total of years. Also, although the whole story (between point A and point B) takes 23.1 years, people on Earth only age 20 years due to the fact that they re moving at.5c. And that s it. Whichever of the 3 RF s you choose, you get the same result as to how much Earth Twin ages and how much Space Twin ages even though the RF s disagree about almost everything else (e.g., who was moving at any given point in time, how much time passed between point A and point B, and what the spatial distance between point A and point B is). STR is designed to work this way. Anything that s clearly observable, all the RF s will agree on. How much someone has aged is observable. How much time has really passed, however, is not. That s why STR is designed to make the former invariant (it comes out the same no matter what RF you use), while the latter is not (it varies between reference frames). 10

### Special Theory of Relativity. A Brief introduction

Special Theory of Relativity A Brief introduction Classical Physics At the end of the 19th century it looked as if Physics was pretty well wrapped up. Newtonian mechanics and the law of Gravitation had

### Relativity and Rocketry. Basic Relativity

Relativity and Rocketry By Phil Charlesworth In 1905 a little known patent clerk and part-time scientist published three scientific papers that laid the foundations of modern physics. The first paper explained

### Chapter S3 Spacetime and Gravity

Chapter S3 Spacetime and Gravity What are the major ideas of special relativity? Spacetime Special relativity showed that space and time are not absolute Instead they are inextricably linked in a four-dimensional

### Einstein s Theory of Special Relativity Made Relatively Simple!

Einstein s Theory of Special Relativity Made Relatively Simple! by Christopher P. Benton, PhD Young Einstein Albert Einstein was born in 1879 and died in 1955. He didn't start talking until he was three,

### GENERAL RELATIVITY - Einstein 1915

GENERAL RELATIVITY - Einstein 1915 Starting problem: Special Relativity only applies to inertial reference frames, where no forces are involved. How to describe gravity then? [Note: some material in these

### Chapter One. Peculiar Consequences

Chapter One Peculiar Consequences Imagine that you are an astronaut on a trip to the moon. Actually, this is not too hard to imagine. You ve seen pictures of it happening in real life. But your trip is

### The speed of the ball relative to O, which we call u, is found. u u' O'

Einstein s Theory of relativity The theory of relativity has two parts. The Special Theory of Relativity relates the measurements of the same events made by two different observers moving relative to each

### Understanding the motion of the Universe. Motion, Force, and Gravity

Understanding the motion of the Universe Motion, Force, and Gravity Laws of Motion Stationary objects do not begin moving on their own. In the same way, moving objects don t change their movement spontaneously.

### Deformation of the Bodies by the Result of Length Contraction: A new Approach to the Lorentz Contraction

1 Deformation of the Bodies by the Result of Length Contraction: A new Approach to the Lorentz Contraction Bayram Akarsu, Ph.D Erciyes University Kayseri/ Turkiye 2 Abstract It has been more than a century

### Astronomy 102, Fall September 2009

Astronomy, Fall 009 15 September 009 Today in Astronomy : relativity, continued Einstein s procedures and results on the special theory of relativity. Formulas and numerical examples of the effects of

### The Theory of Relativity

The Theory of Relativity 1. THE SPECIAL THEORY In 1905, his annum mirabilis, Einstein revolutionized physics with, among other things, his special theory of relativity. With it he completely overturned

### 1. Coordinates (x, t) in one frame are related to coordinates (x, t ) in another frame by the Lorentz transformation formulas.

Physics 00 Problem Set 7 Solution Quick overview: Although relativity can be a little bewildering, this problem set uses just a few ideas over and over again, namely. Coordinates x, t in one frame are

### Understanding the motion of the Universe. Motion, Force, and Gravity

Understanding the motion of the Universe Motion, Force, and Gravity Laws of Motion Stationary objects do not begin moving on their own. In the same way, moving objects don t change their movement spontaneously.

### Newton s Law of Universal Gravitation

Newton s Law of Universal Gravitation The greatest moments in science are when two phenomena that were considered completely separate suddenly are seen as just two different versions of the same thing.

### SPEED, VELOCITY, AND ACCELERATION

reflect Look at the picture of people running across a field. What words come to mind? Maybe you think about the word speed to describe how fast the people are running. You might think of the word acceleration

### Some Special Relativity Formulas

Some Special Relativity Formulas 1 Introduction The purpose of this handout is simple: to give you power in using special relativity! Even though you may not, at this stage, understand exactly where all

### Chapter 4 Dynamics: Newton s Laws of Motion. Copyright 2009 Pearson Education, Inc.

Chapter 4 Dynamics: Newton s Laws of Motion Force Units of Chapter 4 Newton s First Law of Motion Mass Newton s Second Law of Motion Newton s Third Law of Motion Weight the Force of Gravity; and the Normal

### The Special Theory of Relativity explained to children

The Special Theory of Relativity explained to children (from 7 to 107 years old) Charles-Michel Marle marle@math.jussieu.fr Université Pierre et Marie Curie, Paris, France Albert Einstein Century International

### Graphing Motion. Every Picture Tells A Story

Graphing Motion Every Picture Tells A Story Read and interpret motion graphs Construct and draw motion graphs Determine speed, velocity and accleration from motion graphs If you make a graph by hand it

### Q: Who established the law of universal gravitation? A: Newton. Q: What is a spring scale used for? A: To measure weight

Q: Who established the law of universal gravitation? A: Newton Q: What is a spring scale used for? A: To measure weight Q: What is the Law of Universal Gravitation? A: Everything in the universe has gravity.

### 1 Speed of light is the maximal possible speed

1 Speed of light is the maximal possible speed We saw that the length of a moving object shrinks. If its length at rest was l 0, then when it is moving with velocity v its length becomes l = l 0 But what

### Newton s Laws. Newton s Imaginary Cannon. Michael Fowler Physics 142E Lec 6 Jan 22, 2009

Newton s Laws Michael Fowler Physics 142E Lec 6 Jan 22, 2009 Newton s Imaginary Cannon Newton was familiar with Galileo s analysis of projectile motion, and decided to take it one step further. He imagined

### Introduction to Special Relativity

Introduction to Special Relativity Dr. Bob Gardner Great Ideas in Science (PHYS 2018) Notes based on Differential Geometry and Relativity Theory: An Introduction by Richard Faber 1 Chapter 2. Special Relativity:

### It bends away from the normal, like this. So the angle of refraction, r is greater than the angle of incidence, i.

Physics 1403 Lenses It s party time, boys and girls, because today we wrap up our study of physics. We ll get this party started in a bit, but first, you have some more to learn about refracted light.

### Section 3 Newton s Laws of Motion

Section 3 Newton s Laws of Motion Key Concept Newton s laws of motion describe the relationship between forces and the motion of an object. What You Will Learn Newton s first law of motion states that

### Newton s Laws of Motion, Reference Frames and Inertia

Newton s Laws of Motion, Reference Frames and Inertia Chris O Loughlin 2 December 2011 Abstract The validity of Newton s Laws of Motion depends on the type of reference frame they act in. They are valid

### WRITING PROOFS. Christopher Heil Georgia Institute of Technology

WRITING PROOFS Christopher Heil Georgia Institute of Technology A theorem is just a statement of fact A proof of the theorem is a logical explanation of why the theorem is true Many theorems have this

### Instructor Now pick your pencils up and get this important equation in your notes.

Physics 605 Mechanical Energy (Read objectives on screen.) No, I haven t been playing with this toy the whole time you ve been gone, but it is kind of hypnotizing, isn t it? So where were we? Oh yes, we

### F ij = Gm im j r i r j 3 ( r j r i ).

Physics 3550, Fall 2012 Newton s Third Law. Multi-particle systems. Relevant Sections in Text: 1.5, 3.1, 3.2, 3.3 Newton s Third Law. You ve all heard this one. Actioni contrariam semper et qualem esse

### Special Relativity. Photo by Philippe Halsman. Used with permission from Mrs. P. Halsman.

Albert Einstein and the Miracle Year Special Relativity The year 1905 is often referred to as the Annus Mirabilis (or year of miracles). In this year, Albert Einstein, a 23-year old with an undergraduate

### The Seasons on a Planet like Earth

The Seasons on a Planet like Earth As the Earth travels around the Sun, it moves in a giant circle 300 million kilometers across. (Well, it is actually a giant ellipse but the shape is so close to that

### circular motion & gravitation physics 111N

circular motion & gravitation physics 111N uniform circular motion an object moving around a circle at a constant rate must have an acceleration always perpendicular to the velocity (else the speed would

### v v ax v a x a v a v = = = Since F = ma, it follows that a = F/m. The mass of the arrow is unchanged, and ( )

Week 3 homework IMPORTANT NOTE ABOUT WEBASSIGN: In the WebAssign versions of these problems, various details have been changed, so that the answers will come out differently. The method to find the solution

### 2.1 Force and Motion Kinematics looks at velocity and acceleration without reference to the cause of the acceleration.

2.1 Force and Motion Kinematics looks at velocity and acceleration without reference to the cause of the acceleration. Dynamics looks at the cause of acceleration: an unbalanced force. Isaac Newton was

### Chapter 4. Forces and Newton s Laws of Motion. continued

Chapter 4 Forces and Newton s Laws of Motion continued Clicker Question 4.3 A mass at rest on a ramp. How does the friction between the mass and the table know how much force will EXACTLY balance the gravity

### 356 CHAPTER 12 Bob Daemmrich

Standard 7.3.17: Investigate that an unbalanced force, acting on an object, changes its speed or path of motion or both, and know that if the force always acts toward the same center as the object moves,

### The Neo-classical Theory of Relativity

Toronto, Canada December 29, 2013 Second Edition 2013, Revision 2.1 The Neo-classical Theory of Relativity by Valentin T. Danci Introduction to the Neo-classical Theory of Relativity... 3 1. The conceptual

### Guiding Questions Activity 5. What is a force? What are Newton s laws of motion? Purpose: To define force and explore Newton s three laws of motion.

Guiding Questions Activity 5 What is a force? What are Newton s laws of motion? Purpose: To define force and explore Newton s three laws of motion. Note: Earlier we established through experimentation

### VELOCITY, ACCELERATION, FORCE

VELOCITY, ACCELERATION, FORCE velocity Velocity v is a vector, with units of meters per second ( m s ). Velocity indicates the rate of change of the object s position ( r ); i.e., velocity tells you how

### Force on Moving Charges in a Magnetic Field

[ Assignment View ] [ Eðlisfræði 2, vor 2007 27. Magnetic Field and Magnetic Forces Assignment is due at 2:00am on Wednesday, February 28, 2007 Credit for problems submitted late will decrease to 0% after

### INTRODUCTION TO MATHEMATICAL MODELLING

306 MATHEMATICS APPENDIX 2 INTRODUCTION TO MATHEMATICAL MODELLING A2.1 Introduction Right from your earlier classes, you have been solving problems related to the real-world around you. For example, you

### Time and Causation in Gödel s Universe.

Time and Causation in Gödel s Universe. John L. Bell In 1949 the great logician Kurt Gödel constructed the first mathematical models of the universe in which travel into the past is, in theory at least,

### AP1 Gravity. at an altitude equal to twice the radius (R) of the planet. What is the satellite s speed assuming a perfectly circular orbit?

1. A satellite of mass m S orbits a planet of mass m P at an altitude equal to twice the radius (R) of the planet. What is the satellite s speed assuming a perfectly circular orbit? (A) v = Gm P R (C)

### Invalidity in Predicate Logic

Invalidity in Predicate Logic So far we ve got a method for establishing that a predicate logic argument is valid: do a derivation. But we ve got no method for establishing invalidity. In propositional

### Phases of the Moon. Preliminaries:

Phases of the Moon Sometimes when we look at the Moon in the sky we see a small crescent. At other times it appears as a full circle. Sometimes it appears in the daylight against a bright blue background.

### Understanding Relativity. How to do Effective Thought Experiments

Introduction Understanding Relativity or How to do Effective Thought Experiments Ian M. Sefton School of Physics, The University of Sydney I.Sefton@physics.usyd.edu.au After some years absence, the topic

### QUESTIONS : CHAPTER-5: LAWS OF MOTION

QUESTIONS : CHAPTER-5: LAWS OF MOTION 1. What is Aristotle s fallacy? 2. State Aristotlean law of motion 3. Why uniformly moving body comes to rest? 4. What is uniform motion? 5. Who discovered Aristotlean

### Fry Instant Word List

First 100 Instant Words the had out than of by many first and words then water a but them been to not these called in what so who is all some oil you were her sit that we would now it when make find he

### Describe the relationship between gravitational force and distance as shown in the diagram.

Name Period Chapter 2 The Laws of Motion Review Describe the relationship between gravitational force and distance as shown in the diagram. Assess the information about gravity, mass, and weight. Read

### The Electric Force. From mechanics, the relationship for the gravitational force on an object is: m is the mass of the particle of interest,

. The Electric Force Concepts and Principles The Gravitational Analogy In introducing the concept of the electric field, I tried to illustrate it by drawing an analogy with the gravitational field, g.

### PUSD High Frequency Word List

PUSD High Frequency Word List For Reading and Spelling Grades K-5 High Frequency or instant words are important because: 1. You can t read a sentence or a paragraph without knowing at least the most common.

### Inertial reference frames. Inertial reference frames. Inertial reference frames. To cut a long story short:

PH300 Modern Physics SP11 Each ray of light moes in the coordinate system 'at rest' with the definite, constant elocity c, independent of whether this ray of light is emitted by a body at rest or a body

### Meeting People and Meeting People Again

Meeting People and Meeting People Again Stand up and go around roleplaying meeting people in the room, imagining it is the first time you have met (even you have had previous contact by email etc.) Do

### Book Review of Rosenhouse, The Monty Hall Problem. Leslie Burkholder 1

Book Review of Rosenhouse, The Monty Hall Problem Leslie Burkholder 1 The Monty Hall Problem, Jason Rosenhouse, New York, Oxford University Press, 2009, xii, 195 pp, US \$24.95, ISBN 978-0-19-5#6789-8 (Source

### Shooting Uphill and Downhill. Major John L. Plaster, USAR (ret) Of all the ways a precision rifleman must compensate when firing such as for distance,

Shooting Uphill and Downhill By Major John L. Plaster, USAR (ret) Of all the ways a precision rifleman must compensate when firing such as for distance, for wind and for target movement the most confounding

### Einstein, Relativity and Big Bang Cosmology

Einstein, Relativity and Big Bang Cosmology Einstein s s Principle of Relativity An inertial reference frame is one in which all freely moving particles (i.e. not acted upon by forces) move uniformly in

### Experiment 2: Conservation of Momentum

Experiment 2: Conservation of Momentum Learning Goals After you finish this lab, you will be able to: 1. Use Logger Pro to analyze video and calculate position, velocity, and acceleration. 2. Use the equations

### Special Relativity with Geometry Expressions

The Journal of Symbolic Geometry Volume 1 (2006) Special Relativity with Geometry Expressions Brian Beckman http://weblogs.asp.net/brianbec Abstract: Some aspects of special relativity are illustrated

### Friction and Gravity. Friction. Section 2. The Causes of Friction

Section 2 Friction and Gravity What happens when you jump on a sled on the side of a snow-covered hill? Without actually doing this, you can predict that the sled will slide down the hill. Now think about

### Duke Physics 55 Spring 2005 Lecture #31: Experimental Tests of General Relativity

Duke Physics 55 Spring 2005 Lecture #31: Experimental Tests of General Relativity ADMINISTRATIVE STUFF - Friday: Quiz 6, 15 minutes at beginning of class Material: BDSV Ch. 22,S2,S3 (focus on lecture WUN2K)

### 6. Vectors. 1 2009-2016 Scott Surgent (surgent@asu.edu)

6. Vectors For purposes of applications in calculus and physics, a vector has both a direction and a magnitude (length), and is usually represented as an arrow. The start of the arrow is the vector s foot,

### Lecture 7: Light Waves. Newton s Laws of Motion (1666) Newton s First Law of Motion

Lecture 7: Light Waves Isaac Newton (1643-1727) was born in the year Galileo died He discovered the Law of Gravitation in 1665 He developed the Laws of Mechanics that govern all motions In order to solve

### Rocketry for Kids. Science Level 4. Newton s Laws

Rocketry for Kids Science Level 4 Newton s Laws Victorian Space Science Education Centre 400 Pascoe Vale Road Strathmore, Vic 3041 www.vssec.vic.edu.au Some material for this program has been derived from

### STEM Fuse GAME:IT Unit 2

STEM Fuse GAME:IT Unit 2 Key formulas for math & physics calculations used in game development Definition of velocity Velocity is similar to speed but it has direction. Let's recap what a speed is. Speed

### Black Holes & The Theory of Relativity

Black Holes & The Theory of Relativity A.Einstein 1879-1955 Born in Ulm, Württemberg, Germany in 1879, Albert Einstein developed the special and general theories of relativity. In 1921, he won the Nobel

### Why is the Night Sky Dark?

Why is the Night Sky Dark? Cosmology Studies of the universe as a whole Today Brief history of ideas (Early Greeks Big Bang) The expanding universe (Hubble, Relativity, density & destiny) An alternative

### Lesson 26: Reflection & Mirror Diagrams

Lesson 26: Reflection & Mirror Diagrams The Law of Reflection There is nothing really mysterious about reflection, but some people try to make it more difficult than it really is. All EMR will reflect

### 2 Newton s First Law of Motion Inertia

2 Newton s First Law of Motion Inertia Conceptual Physics Instructor Manual, 11 th Edition SOLUTIONS TO CHAPTER 2 RANKING 1. C, B, A 2. C, A, B, D 3. a. B, A, C, D b. B, A, C, D 4. a. A=B=C (no force)

### Lecture 16. Newton s Second Law for Rotation. Moment of Inertia. Angular momentum. Cutnell+Johnson: 9.4, 9.6

Lecture 16 Newton s Second Law for Rotation Moment of Inertia Angular momentum Cutnell+Johnson: 9.4, 9.6 Newton s Second Law for Rotation Newton s second law says how a net force causes an acceleration.

### x 1 ' = x 1 vt 1 x 1 ' = 4.0 m t 1 = 1.0 s x 2 vt 2 ' = 4.0 m t 2 ' = x 2 = 3.0 s x 1 = x 2 x 1 ' + vt 1 ' + vt 2 v (t 1 t 2 ) = x 2 ' x 1 ' = x 2

Physics 2220 Module 16 Homework 01. A firecracker explodes in reference frame S at t 1 1.0 seconds. A second firecracker explodes at the same position at t 2 3.0 seconds. In reference frame S', which moves

### Physics of Sports. Goal: Explain the physics behind a particular aspect of your favorite sport.

Physics of Sports Goal: Explain the physics behind a particular aspect of your favorite sport. Overview: In this project, you will tie together all of the physics principles you ve learned about in order

### Simple Regression Theory I 2010 Samuel L. Baker

SIMPLE REGRESSION THEORY I 1 Simple Regression Theory I 2010 Samuel L. Baker Regression analysis lets you use data to explain and predict. A simple regression line drawn through data points In Assignment

### Lecture 6. Weight. Tension. Normal Force. Static Friction. Cutnell+Johnson: 4.8-4.12, second half of section 4.7

Lecture 6 Weight Tension Normal Force Static Friction Cutnell+Johnson: 4.8-4.12, second half of section 4.7 In this lecture, I m going to discuss four different kinds of forces: weight, tension, the normal

### ACTIVITY 6: Falling Objects

UNIT FM Developing Ideas ACTIVITY 6: Falling Objects Purpose and Key Question You developed your ideas about how the motion of an object is related to the forces acting on it using objects that move horizontally.

### Fry Instant Words High Frequency Words

Fry Instant Words High Frequency Words The Fry list of 600 words are the most frequently used words for reading and writing. The words are listed in rank order. First Hundred Group 1 Group 2 Group 3 Group

### Physics 112 Homework 5 (solutions) (2004 Fall) Solutions to Homework Questions 5

Solutions to Homework Questions 5 Chapt19, Problem-2: (a) Find the direction of the force on a proton (a positively charged particle) moving through the magnetic fields in Figure P19.2, as shown. (b) Repeat

### Chapter 4 Dynamics: Newton s Laws of Motion

Chapter 4 Dynamics: Newton s Laws of Motion Units of Chapter 4 Force Newton s First Law of Motion Mass Newton s Second Law of Motion Newton s Third Law of Motion Weight the Force of Gravity; and the Normal

### Physics: Principles and Applications, 6e Giancoli Chapter 2 Describing Motion: Kinematics in One Dimension

Physics: Principles and Applications, 6e Giancoli Chapter 2 Describing Motion: Kinematics in One Dimension Conceptual Questions 1) Suppose that an object travels from one point in space to another. Make

### 6. Block and Tackle* Block and tackle

6. Block and Tackle* A block and tackle is a combination of pulleys and ropes often used for lifting. Pulleys grouped together in a single frame make up what is called a pulley block. The tackle refers

### Lateral Acceleration. Chris Garner

Chris Garner Forward Acceleration Forward acceleration is easy to quantify and understand. Forward acceleration is simply the rate of change in speed. In car terms, the quicker the car accelerates, the

### Physics Kinematics Model

Physics Kinematics Model I. Overview Active Physics introduces the concept of average velocity and average acceleration. This unit supplements Active Physics by addressing the concept of instantaneous

### The Expanding Universe. Prof Jim Dunlop University of Edinburgh

The Expanding Universe Prof Jim Dunlop University of Edinburgh Cosmology: The Study of Structure & Evolution of the Universe Small & Hot Big & Cold Observational Evidence for the Expansion of the Universe

### Project II Using Body Temperature to Estimate Time Since Death

Project II Using Body Temperature to Estimate Time Since Death or A Solution to the Mystery Answer to questions in boldface must be in your final report 1 Part I. A Little History and One Method Though

### NONINERTIAL FRAMES. path of the pendulum across the. bearing. table

LAB 9b NONINERTIAL FRAMES EXPERIMENTAL QUESTION In this lab, you will explore the distinction between inertial and non-inertial reference frames. According to chapter N9, Newton s second law fails to hold

### Wind Turbines. Wind Turbines 2. Wind Turbines 4. Wind Turbines 3. Wind Turbines 5. Wind Turbines 6

Wind Turbines 1 Wind Turbines 2 Introductory Question Wind Turbines You and a child half your height lean out over the edge of a pool at the same angle. If you both let go simultaneously, who will tip

### CHARGE TO MASS RATIO OF THE ELECTRON

CHARGE TO MASS RATIO OF THE ELECTRON In solving many physics problems, it is necessary to use the value of one or more physical constants. Examples are the velocity of light, c, and mass of the electron,

### Chapter 2: Describing Motion

Chapter 2: Describing Motion 1. An auto, starting from rest, undergoes constant acceleration and covers a distance of 1000 meters. The final speed of the auto is 80 meters/sec. How long does it take the

### Session 7 Bivariate Data and Analysis

Session 7 Bivariate Data and Analysis Key Terms for This Session Previously Introduced mean standard deviation New in This Session association bivariate analysis contingency table co-variation least squares

### Map Patterns and Finding the Strike and Dip from a Mapped Outcrop of a Planar Surface

Map Patterns and Finding the Strike and Dip from a Mapped Outcrop of a Planar Surface Topographic maps represent the complex curves of earth s surface with contour lines that represent the intersection

### Fluid Mechanics Prof. S. K. Som Department of Mechanical Engineering Indian Institute of Technology, Kharagpur

Fluid Mechanics Prof. S. K. Som Department of Mechanical Engineering Indian Institute of Technology, Kharagpur Lecture - 20 Conservation Equations in Fluid Flow Part VIII Good morning. I welcome you all

### Chapter 13. Gravitation

Chapter 13 Gravitation 13.2 Newton s Law of Gravitation In vector notation: Here m 1 and m 2 are the masses of the particles, r is the distance between them, and G is the gravitational constant. G = 6.67

### Laws of Motion and Conservation Laws

Laws of Motion and Conservation Laws The first astrophysics we ll consider will be gravity, which we ll address in the next class. First, though, we need to set the stage by talking about some of the basic

### LAWS OF FORCE AND MOTION

reflect Does anything happen without a cause? Many people would say yes, because that often seems to be our experience. A cup near the edge of a table suddenly crashes to the fl oor. An apple falls from

### LAB 6: GRAVITATIONAL AND PASSIVE FORCES

55 Name Date Partners LAB 6: GRAVITATIONAL AND PASSIVE FORCES And thus Nature will be very conformable to herself and very simple, performing all the great Motions of the heavenly Bodies by the attraction

### STAAR Science Tutorial 25 TEK 8.6C: Newton s Laws

Name: Teacher: Pd. Date: STAAR Science Tutorial 25 TEK 8.6C: Newton s Laws TEK 8.6C: Investigate and describe applications of Newton's law of inertia, law of force and acceleration, and law of action-reaction

### The Physics and Math of Ping-pong and How It Affects Game Play. By: Connor Thompson & Andrew Johnson

The Physics and Math of Ping-pong and How It Affects Game Play 1 The Physics and Math of Ping-pong and How It Affects Game Play By: Connor Thompson & Andrew Johnson The Practical Applications of Advanced

### Gauss s Law for Gravity

Gauss s Law for Gravity D.G. impson, Ph.D. Department of Physical ciences and Engineering Prince George s Community College December 6, 2006 Newton s Law of Gravity Newton s law of gravity gives the force

### Simple Analysis for Brushless DC Motors Case Study: Razor Scooter Wheel Motor

Simple Analysis for Brushless DC Motors Case Study: Razor Scooter Wheel Motor At first glance, a brushless direct-current (BLDC) motor might seem more complicated than a permanent magnet brushed DC motor,