A MULTIPLE VIEWS SYSTEM TO EXPLORATORY DATA ANALYSIS



Similar documents
THREE-DIMENSIONAL CARTOGRAPHIC REPRESENTATION AND VISUALIZATION FOR SOCIAL NETWORK SPATIAL ANALYSIS

GEO-VISUALIZATION SUPPORT FOR MULTIDIMENSIONAL CLUSTERING

O Papel dos Sistemas Analíticos no Processo de Decisão

USING SELF-ORGANIZING MAPS FOR INFORMATION VISUALIZATION AND KNOWLEDGE DISCOVERY IN COMPLEX GEOSPATIAL DATASETS

Guidelines for Designing Web Maps - An Academic Experience

Geovisual Analytics Exploring and analyzing large spatial and multivariate data. Prof Mikael Jern & Civ IngTobias Åström.

TEACHING CALCULUS USING E-LEARNING IN A MOODLE PLATFORM

Tracking System for GPS Devices and Mining of Spatial Data

Utilizing spatial information systems for non-spatial-data analysis

Implementation of a Flow Map Demonstrator for Analyzing Commuting and Migration Flow Statistics Data

A comparative study of social network analysis tools

Geovisualization. Geovisualization, cartographic transformation, cartograms, dasymetric maps, scientific visualization (ViSC), PPGIS

DESIGN PATTERNS OF WEB MAPS. Bin Li Department of Geography Central Michigan University Mount Pleasant, MI USA (517)

An Esri White Paper October 2010 Esri Production Mapping Product Library: Spatially Enabled Document Management System

EXTERNAL DOSE RATES IN COASTAL URBAN ENVIRONMENTS IN BRASIL

Architecture and Applications. of a Geovisual Analytics Framework

DATA VISUALIZATION GABRIEL PARODI STUDY MATERIAL: PRINCIPLES OF GEOGRAPHIC INFORMATION SYSTEMS AN INTRODUCTORY TEXTBOOK CHAPTER 7

GEOENGINE MSc in Geomatics Engineering, Master Thesis Gina Campuzano

NakeDB: Database Schema Visualization

Visual Mining of Multi-Modal Social Networks at Different Abstraction Levels

A Process and Environment for Embedding The R Software

Using bibliometric maps of science in a science policy context

PERSONALIZED WEB MAP CUSTOMIZED SERVICE

TerraLAB Using Free Software for Earth System Research and Free Software Development

GEOGRAPHIC INFORMATION SYSTEMS

HIGH SPATIAL RESOLUTION IMAGES - A NEW WAY TO BRAZILIAN'S CARTOGRAPHIC MAPPING

Developing and assessing light-weight data-driven exploratory geovisualization tools for the web

IMPLEMENTATION OF A MANAGEMENT AND QUALITY CONTROL SYSTEM UNDER ISO STANDARDS 9001:2000, 19113, 19114,19138 AND IN CARTOGRAPHIC PRODUCTION

Geographic Information Systems GIS at UCSD. Here to help you explore our world

One approach to the use of the practices of CMMI- DEV V1.3 level 2 in a process of development of Embedded Systems

SuperViz: An Interactive Visualization of Super-Peer P2P Network

GIS Initiative: Developing an atmospheric data model for GIS. Olga Wilhelmi (ESIG), Jennifer Boehnert (RAP/ESIG) and Terri Betancourt (RAP)

Understanding customers to identify penetration and expansion opportunities

PARTICIPATION IN RESEARCH GROUPS AND OPPORTUNITY FOR GROWTH AND VISIBILITY OF ENFERMAGEM 1

GUIDELINES AND FORMAT SPECIFICATIONS FOR PROPOSALS, THESES, AND DISSERTATIONS

Analyse, Collaborate and Publish Statistics for Measuring Progress in our Society using Storytelling

Getting Started With Mortgage MarketSmart

Interactive information visualization in a conference location

There are various ways to find data using the Hennepin County GIS Open Data site:

Network-Based Tools for the Visualization and Analysis of Domain Models

MicroStrategy Desktop

gvsig: A GIS desktop solution for an open SDI.

HydroDesktop Overview

Report Options - GIS. Report Options Toolbar. What can MIDAS do for you? How does MIDAS improve municipal management? MIDAS Report Graph Samples

Marcelo L. Braunstein Business Development Manager IBM Latin America

Knowledge-Based Visualization to Support Spatial Data Mining

Exploratory Data Analysis for Ecological Modelling and Decision Support

Abstract Number: Critical Issues about the Theory Of Constraints Thinking Process A. Theoretical and Practical Approach

VISUALIZATION STRATEGIES AND TECHNIQUES FOR HIGH-DIMENSIONAL SPATIO- TEMPORAL DATA

THE ISSUE OF PERMANENCE AT AN ONLINE CLASS: an analysis based upon Moodle platform s accesses

Applications of Dynamic Representation Technologies in Multimedia Electronic Map

Graph/Network Visualization

Curriculum Vitae. Sílvia Barcellos Southwick

ADVANCED GEOGRAPHIC INFORMATION SYSTEMS Vol. II - Using Ontologies for Geographic Information Intergration Frederico Torres Fonseca

GENERATION OF TOPOGRAPHIC

E-learning Curricula Search in Geographical Information Systems and Science

DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION OF A WEB INTERACTIVE THEMATIC CARTOGRAPHY METHOD BASED ON A WEB SERVICE CHAIN

Scientific Visualization of Occupation Data for Spatial Analysis of Animal Behavior Using OpenGL

SUMMER SCHOOL ON ADVANCES IN GIS

HISTORICAL DEVELOPMENTS AND THEORETICAL APPROACHES IN SOCIOLOGY Vol. I - Social Network Analysis - Wouter de Nooy

A Geographical Information System for Spatial Data Analysis Based on the Scalable Vector Graphics Standard.

Editing Common Polygon Boundary in ArcGIS Desktop 9.x

DEVELOPMENT OF THE PLANETARY CARTOGRAPHY WEB-SITE WITH OPEN SOURCE CONTENT MANAGEMENT SYSTEM

EXPLORING SPATIAL PATTERNS IN YOUR DATA

A Study on the application of Data Mining Methods in the analysis of Transcripts

GEOGRAPHIC INFORMATION SYSTEMS CERTIFICATION

QUALITY KNOWLEDGE INTEGRATION: A BRAZILIAN COMPARISON ANALYSIS

NEW TECHNOLOGIES TO IMPROVE SALES MANAGEMENT FOR ROMANIAN RETAIL COMPANIES. Ruxandra Badea, PhD Candidate. Vlad Voicu, PhD Candidate

Consumption of OData Services of Open Items Analytics Dashboard using SAP Predictive Analysis

SimplyMap Canada Tutorial

Instituto Superior Técnico. Theme 1: Transport networks design and evaluation Case study presentation and synthesis

GIS Supporting Data Gathering and Fast Decision Making in Emergencies Situations

Spatial Data Analysis

A THREE-TIERED WEB BASED EXPLORATION AND REPORTING TOOL FOR DATA MINING

What is Visualization? Information Visualization An Overview. Information Visualization. Definitions

Office hours: 1:00 to 3:00 PM on Mondays and Wednesdays, and by appointment.

User s Guide to ArcView 3.3 for Land Use Planners in Puttalam District

Figure 2: System Flow Diagram for Workflow Management

Dissemination of environmental and socioeconomical information on the web using a model based on free tools

A model of multilingual digital library

How to use PGS: Basic Services Provision Map App

Figure 1. Basic Petri net Elements

An Introduction to KeyLines and Network Visualization

The UCC-21 cognitive skills that are listed above will be met via the following objectives.

TIBCO Spotfire Business Author Essentials Quick Reference Guide. Table of contents:

Training in Cartography: e-learning Courses in Thematic Cartography

FOSSGIS: What is the future of Geonetwork? What changes are planned?

An example. Visualization? An example. Scientific Visualization. This talk. Information Visualization & Visual Analytics. 30 items, 30 x 3 values

Web Map Context Service for Adaptive Geospatial Data Visualization

Levee Assessment via Remote Sensing Levee Assessment Tool Prototype Design & Implementation

Spotfire v6 New Features. TIBCO Spotfire Delta Training Jumpstart

Using Geospatial Data to Generate One-line Diagrams of Electrical Power Systems

Digital Cadastral Maps in Land Information Systems

Mining On-line Newspaper Web Access Logs

Técnicas y Herramientas de Apoyo a la investigación (THA) II. Técnicas de Investigación Cualitativa. Social network analysis (SNA)

Data Visualization and Team Collaboration. Michael Paulos Business Analyst Marketing, Cannery Casino Resorts June 5, :30-2:15 PM

Location Analytics for Financial Services. An Esri White Paper October 2013

EvolTrack: A Plug-in-Based Infrastructure for Visualizing Software Evolution

GIS and Mapping Solutions for Developers. ESRI Developer Network (EDN SM)

Activity: Using ArcGIS Explorer

Transcription:

p. 001-008 A MULTIPLE VIEWS SYSTEM TO EXPLORATORY DATA ANALYSIS LUCIENE STAMATO DELAZARI 1 CLAUDIA ROBBI SLUTER 1 CRISTOPHER CHIRSTMANN 2 EDUARDO SILVERIO DA SILVA 2 SAMIRA KAUCHAKJE 3 1 Universidade Federal do Paraná - UFPR Programa de Pós-graduação em Ciências Geodésicas - PPGCG Departamento de Geomática {luciene, robbi}@ufpr.br 2 Universidade Federal do Paraná - UFPR Curso de Graduaçao em Engenharia Cartográfica chrmann@yahoo.com.br eduardosilverio@hotmail.com.br 2 Pontifícia Universidade Católica do Paraná - PUCPR Programa de Pós-graduação em Gestão Urbana skauchakje@gmail.com ABSTRACT - A proposal for a multiple views system for cartographic representation of a social network is presented in this paper. Considering that social network analysis need to be based on graphs, the main issue is how to establish a digital data structure and thematic representation for these networks in order to preserve the spatial positions and relations of the network actors. The proposed solution for this research problem is to combine different representations of the phenomena in a computational system with multiple views: a traditional thematic map at a suitable scale depicting a whole network whose actors are located in Curitiba - Parana State - the correspondent graph, tables and charts. The system allows users to explore data and representations, to interact with them and provides interactively linked views. RESUMO Este artigo apresenta uma proposta de um sistema com múltiplas vistas para representação cartográfica de redes sociais. Considerando-se que as análises sobre as redes sociais são baseadas em grafos, a principal questão consiste em estabelecer uma estrutura digital para a representação cartográfica destas redes, de modo a preservar as posições e relações espaciais dos seus atores. A solução proposta nesta pesquisa consiste em combinar diferentes representações do fenômeno em um sistema computacional com múltiplas vistas: um mapa temático em uma escala que represente a rede como um todo (município de Curitiba), os grafos, tabelas e gráficos correspondentes. O sistema permitirá aos usuários explorar os dados e as representações, por meio da interação proporcionada pelas vistas conectadas interativamente. 1 INTRODUCTION This paper describes the design and implementation of a multiple views system for social network analysis. Social networks consist of individuals, groups of people or institutions, called actors that are connected to each other. Commonly, social scientists use graphs and matrices in order to analyze these networks. Graphs are formed by nodes and arcs, which represent, respectively, network actors and their relationships. Graphs representations or matrices structures, however, do not take into account the spatial location of actors and their relationships. Consequently, the network attributes are not spatially represented and so it is not possible to analyze and understand their spatial structure. The use of graphs as social network representation has two known problems: (1) nodes are not spatially located and (2) symbols for nodes and arcs are not suitable to represent attributes of the graphs elements. The representation of spatial location is needed to analyze actors proximity and neighborhood relationships. Moreover, the

p. 002-008 attributes (characteristics) of the graphs elements must be depicted in order to make possible to analyze clusters, dispersions, tendencies and influence areas. These problems have been solved by the map design for social networks presented for papers and for computer screens. The use of thematic maps allowed the social scientists to understand the dynamics of the network relations and consequently the existence of regions characterized by cultural, political and economical influence. However, after some experiences with these thematic maps, the social scientists noticed the need for tools which would provide geovisualization capabilities for analyzing graphs, tables and maps by a set of linked views. Some of those needs are: a) To identify actors proximity and neighborhood relationships which are possible through cartographic visualization; b) To identify actor's concentration in specific regions, what can lead to important conclusions about why some geographic regions are better assisted than others, and consequently, to plan the location of some new actors in regions without social assistance; c) To identify the actors characteristics related to different geographic locations and which regions are supported by governmental or non-governmental organizations, or both; d) To visualize the distances and orientations between actors based on the geographic representation of their links; e) To identify the geographic concentration of the network actors related to different geographic levels: municipal, state, national or even worldwide; f) To compare the distribution of actors on graphs and thematic maps in order to identify the concentration in both representations; g) To have access to actors and links attributes. When the knowledge on thematic mapping and geovisualization is applied to cartographic representation of social networks, it is possible to develop data exploration in order to know about the proximities of actors and their neighboring relations. Moreover, the thematic mapping of actors attributes allows the analysis of clustering and diffusion, tendencies, regions of influence, and so on. The importance of spatial analysis for social network studies leads to our main research objective which is to propose a system with multiple linked views. This system provides ways to dynamically manipulate and explore different graphic representations. 2 APPROACH AND METHODS 2.1 Social Network Analysis Social networks are difficult to visualize, navigate, and analyze and it is considerably difficult to find relevant patterns on networks. Network analysts focus on relationships instead of the individual elements which can explain social, cultural, or economic phenomena, but how the elements are connected is just as important as the elements themselves. Using newer techniques analysts can find patterns in the structure and learn how individuals are influenced by their surroundings (PERER, 2008). Using visualizations to assist in Social Network Analysis (SNA) is not a new concept for sociologists. Visual images can be used to examine the patterns of network data, as described in Freeman (2004). A history of the use of visual images in social networks is described in Freeman (2000) and includes one of the earliest known examples of social network visualization from Jacob Moreno in1934. Usually social scientists use two different ways to represent social networks: graphs and matrices (Figure 1). These two forms of representation are generated by using statistical and visualization techniques software for network analysis. Two of the most popular tools used by social scientists are UCINET and Pajek. Each of these tools has a set of feature to measure social networks, grounded in the theory and techniques of sociologists. UCINET probably is the most known and frequently used SNA software. It contains a large set of features applied to networks analysis as centrality, proximity and so on. The software also allows graphic functions to generate scatterplots, dendograms and trees (http://www.analytictech.com/ucinet/). Pajek, accordingly to its authors (http://vlado.fmf.uni-lj.si/pub/networks/doc/pajek.pdf) has as main goals: to support abstraction by factorization of a large network into several smaller networks that can be treated further using more sophisticated methods; to provide the user with some powerful visualization tools; and to implement a selection of efficient algorithms for analysis of large networks. Although both software have graphical capabilities that allow change in shape, color and size of networks, there s no spatial reference associated to any kind of process.

p. 003-008 Figure 1 Graph and table related to a network Another software developed to help social scientists is called SocialAction, which integrates statistical and visualization techniques (Figure 2) (PERER, 2008) but also does not employ any spatial reference of actors. SocialAction embeds statistical algorithms to detect important individuals, relationships, and clusters. Instead of presenting statistical results in a typical tabular form, results are integrated as a network s visualization while providing meaningful computed attributes of the nodes and edges. Along with computed attributes, users can easily and dynamically filter nodes and edges to discover interesting data characteristics (PERER, 2008). Figure 2 (a) SocialAction network representation; (b) Colored polygons surround the subgroups of the network. Source: Perer and Shneiderman (2006) Social Network Analysis is similar to geospatial data analysis since both are made through visual map analysis and queries in a Geographic Information System (GIS). Therefore graphic solutions used in social networks representations must be prepared in accordance to technical-scientific knowledge of Cartography science. 3 MULTIPLE VIEW SYSTEM THEORETICAL CONSIDERATIONS In 1990 Dibiase proposed a visualization model of the role of maps in scientific visualization. In this model, map functions are related to stages of analysis and planning processes, which are exploration, confirmation, synthesis and presentation. An exploratory geovisualization system allows users to investigate possibilities and test scenarios. In the exploration stage a user can change visualization parameters, use different views in order to make comparisons with

p. 004-008 different parameters or compare different representations of the same data, as maps, graphics and tables. In this case, those views must be linked for allowing the user to analyze the data by using combined navigation or brushing, as presented in Figure 3. Figure 3 GAV Multiple View System (GeoAnalytics Visualization) Source: Jern et al (2007) In Figure 3 one of the views represents spatial data and the others are parallel coordinate graphics that present several variables simultaneously, allowing comparisons. When users point out a polygon in the map, the line correspondent to each one of the variables in those parallel coordinate is highlighted. There are others systems with the same functionalities. For example, GEOVIZ tool, developed in GeoVista Center, at Pennsylvania University, enables multidimensional geographic data visualization. Its components are related meaning selecting a set of variables will reflect in further components in use. GEOVIZ is used for spatial, temporal and attributes analysis. The application focus is potentially health, socioeconomic and demographic data (ROBERTS, 2007). The CommonGIS project was originated from IRIS (Information Retrieval Intelligent System), developed in C++ in the 1990s. Later it was renamed Descartes, an internet system developed in Java, and finally, in 1999 became CommonGIS. Its functions include remote access through internet, manipulation, exploration and data analysis tools, automatic map generation, and maps modification using direct data manipulation (ANDRIENKO e ANDRIENKO, 2003). It can be observed that systems found in the literature are developed mostly focusing on health and demographic applications. Almost all of them use statistical data aggregated over previously defined regions (states, councils, census sectors), and remaining data are scatterplots, parallel coordinates and tables. The peculiarity of social network data constitutes a new proposition in the context of multiple view systems because it has been verified the need of an analysis through graphs and maps. On the other hand, software developed for network analysis does not work with spatial data reference. 4 MULTIPLE VIEW SYSTEM PROPOSITION 4.1 Social Network Spatial Representation The social networks that have been studied so far take place in Curitiba (KAUCHAKJE, 2007; DELAZARI, 2008, BRANDALIZE, 2009), and these studies include sociology, map design, cyberspace and cartography. Such researches were developed employing empirical techniques comprising the following steps: - Data collection: user interviews, document analysis, and internet content exploration; - Design and presentation of the social networks representation (spatial and non spatial) using UCINET, TOUCHGRAPH, ARCGIS and GOOGLE EARTH;

p. 005-008 - Analysis of the results and evaluation of the cartographic process efficiency for the proposed representation through users interviews. The referred methodology was applied to represent and analyze a series of social networks regarding individual s social rights in Brazil. According the Brazilian Constitution of 1988, the individual s social rights comprise Housing, Health, Education, Labor, Food Security and Social Assistance. The data necessary to establish these networks were collected through interviews, questionnaires and the Internet. Curitiba, capital of Parana State, Brazil, was used as the geographic main location for the establishment of the networks analyzed in this study. Concerning the referred networks, the main social agents of each network, their partnerships and links were identified, characterized and mapped, first using conventional social network software, like UCINET. Afterwards, the results from these applications were exported to ARCGIS software to proceed with the geographic analyses. The cartographic language was applied to the representation of networks (social agents and their connections) based on the organizational characteristics of the social agents (governmental, non-governmental, third sector) and their connections (if ideological, by project, and so on) (DELAZARI; KAUCHAKJE; PENNA, 2005) (BRANDALIZE, 2009). The resulted map representations were presented to users in order to verify its efficiency. Users were asked to analyze representations taking into consideration the following points: a) Is it possible to identify actor s neighborhood or proximity from network spatial location? b) Is it possible to identify actors classification (governmental, non-governmental, companies)? c) Is it possible to identify clusters of actors belonging to different levels of government (city, state, federal)? d) Is it possible to identify links direction? 4.2 Multiple View System Design Using networks representations, the users were capable of understanding some geographic aspects of them. However, after some experiences with the maps, it was noticed that the users need extra functionalities that allow more data exploration, like maps, graphs and tables in connected views. The proposed system is being developed in Java, using NetBeans 6.9 and GeoTools. The NetBeans project consists of an open-source Integrated Development Environment (IDE) and an application platform that enable developers to create web, enterprise, desktop, and mobile applications using the Java platform. GeoTools is an opensource Java library that provides tools for geospatial data. Considering users inexperience with software usage, it was decided to design a clear interface in order to avoid misunderstandings and incorrect choices. Thus, the first research task comprised the system conceptual model design which includes the interface design and all the necessary tools that permit to the user interactively handle maps, graphs and tables as well as visually analyze their relationships. The result of the interface design comprises two display panels: an interactive map and the correspondent graph, both linked to each other, as presented in Figure 4. There are two menus: File and Network. The menu File enables to open the spatial database that are Curitiba neighborhood limits, a layer of points that represent actors and a layer of lines representing connections. As mentioned previously, the data was collected regarding six different social rights: Housing, Health, Education, Labor, Food Security and Social Assistance. Therefore, there are six different layers of points and lines, one for each theme mentioned.

p. 006-008 Figure 4 Initial Interface for Multiple View System The Menu Network (Figure 5) allows opening the corresponding social right graph. Each actor in the graph has a code that is the same code used in the spatial representation. When an actor is selected, in the map for instance, the correspondent actor in the graph is highlighted, and vice-versa, when a graph's node is selected the matched element in the map is also highlighted. Figure 5 Detail of Network Menu Navigation and information buttons allows necessary tools for accessing the details of actors and their connections. Navigation buttons are used to navigate both in the map as in the graph. Information button is used to point out an element in the map or graph and its correspondent elements in the graph and table (at the bottom in the interface) are highlighted (Figure 6).

p. 007-008 Figure 6 Different elements connected 5 PRELIMINARY RESULTS AND FUTURE WORK The first version of the proposed system is already developed. The basic interface was designed and data regarding social networks, in spatial representation and graphs were inserted. Basic navigation tools (zoom in, zoom out and pan) and query functions were also implemented. The interactivity that allows linking the existing views is being developed. One of the research challenges is how to embody cyberspace network representation to the proposed system. This is a difficult task due different levels of detail presented by the data and also because actors in cyberspace may present relationships with other actors located outside the actual geographic reference. So, different scales need to be managed in order to provide this representation. Another issue concerning cyberspace representations regards its dynamicity, which sometimes is very difficult to follow. With the use of the system users will realize their analysis more easily considering that all different data representation can be visualized simultaneously. Moreover, new data can be introduced, for instance, census data, in order to allow other analysis. As a result we believe that an interactive geovisualization system provides additional insight into underlying information about social networks. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS To CNPq for fellowship research - Process 308892/2008-9, IC - Process 506956/2010-5 e PIBIC-CNPq (UFPR). Special thanks to Roberto Santos for your help in development of the system. REFERENCES ANDRIENKO, N.; ANDRIENKO, G. Coordinated Views for Informed Spatial Decision Making. In: Coordinated and Multiple Views in Exploratory Visualization, International Conference on, 2003. Anais Zurich, Switzerland. IEEE Computer Society Press. 2003. pp. 44-54.

p. 008-008 BRANDALIZE, M. C. B. Metodologia de Mapeamento da Rede de Direito Social Terra e Habitação no Município de Curitiba. VI COLÓQUIO BRASILEIRO EM CIÊNCIAS GEODÉSICAS, 2009, Curitiba. Resumos...Curitiba: Programa de Pós-graduação em Ciências Geodésicas, 2009. DELAZARI, L. S. Visualização Cartográfica aplicada a análise de redes sociais. 2008. (Relatório de pesquisa) DELAZARI, L. S.; KAUCHAKJE, S.; PENNA, M. C. (2005). Sistema de Informação Geográfica da Política de Assistência Social do Paraná. In: XXII CONGRESSO BRASILEIRO DE CARTOGRAFIA, 2005, Macaé. Anais... Macaé: Sociedade Brasileira de Cartografia, 2005. FREEMAN, L. C. Graphic Techniques for Exploring Social Network Data. In: Models and Methods in Social Network Analysis., P. J. CARRINGTON, J. SCOTT AND S. WASSERMAN. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2004. FREEMAN, L. C. Visualizing Social Networks. Journal of Social Structure, 1, 1, 2000. JERN, M. et al. The GAV Toolkit for Multiple Linked Views. In: Coordinated and Multiple Views in Exploratory Visualization, International Conference on, 2007. Anais Zurich, Switzerland. IEEE Computer Society Press. 2007. pp. 85-97. KAUCHAKJE, S. Rede sociotécnica de asseguramento de direitos na cidade: proteção social com suporte tecnológico em Curitiba. 2007. (Relatório de pesquisa). PERER, A. Integrating Statistics And Visualization To Improve Exploratory Social Network Analysis. Dissertation submitted to the Faculty of the Graduate School of the University of Maryland, 2008. PERER, A.; SHNEIDERMAN, b. Orderly Analysis of Social Visualizations. Social Visualization Workshop at CHI, 2006. KAUCHAKJE, S. et al. Redes Sócio-Técnicas y Participación Ciudadana: Propuestas Conceptuales y Analíticas para el Uso de las TICs. REDES. Revista Hispana para el Análisis de Redes Sociales, v. 11, pp. 1-26, 2006. ROBERTS, J. C. State of the Art: Coordinated & Multiple Views in Exploratory Visualization. In: Coordinated and Multiple Views in Exploratory Visualization, International Conference on, 2007. Anais Zurich, Switzerland. IEEE Computer Society Press. 2007. pp. 61-71. WASSERMAN, S. et al. Models and Methods in Social Network Análisis. New York: Cambridge University Press, 2005. 344p.