Today s managers are very interested in predicting the future purchasing patterns of their customers, which


 Stephany Magdalene Cain
 2 years ago
 Views:
Transcription
1 Vol. 24, No. 2, Spring 25, pp issn eissn X informs doi /mksc INFORMS Couning Your Cusomers he Easy Way: An Alernaive o he Pareo/NBD Model Peer S. Fader The Wharon School, Universiy of Pennsylvania, 749 Hunsman Hall, 373 Walnu Sree, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania , Bruce G. S. Hardie London Business School, Regen s Park, London NW1 4SA, Unied Kingdom, Ka Lok Lee Caalina Healh Resource, Blue Bell, Pennsylvania 19422, Today s managers are very ineresed in predicing he fuure purchasing paerns of heir cusomers, which can hen serve as an inpu ino lifeime value calculaions. Among he models ha provide such capabiliies, he Pareo/NBD couning your cusomers framework proposed by Schmilein e al. (1987) is highly regarded. However, despie he respec i has earned, i has proven o be a difficul model o implemen, paricularly because of compuaional challenges associaed wih parameer esimaion. We develop a new model, he beageomeric/nbd (BG/NBD), which represens a sligh variaion in he behavioral sory associaed wih he Pareo/NBD bu is vasly easier o implemen. We show, for insance, how is parameers can be obained quie easily in Microsof Excel. The wo models yield very similar resuls in a wide variey of purchasing environmens, leading us o sugges ha he BG/NBD could be viewed as an aracive alernaive o he Pareo/NBD in mos applicaions. Key words: cusomer base analysis; repea buying; Pareo/NBD; probabiliy models; forecasing; lifeime value Hisory: This paper was received Augus 11, 23, and was wih he auhors 7 monhs for 2 revisions; processed by Gary Lilien. 1. Inroducion Faced wih a daabase conaining informaion on he frequency and iming of ransacions for a lis of cusomers, i is naural o ry o make forecass abou fuure purchasing. These projecions ofen range from aggregae sales rajecories (e.g., for he nex 52 weeks), o individuallevel condiional expecaions (i.e., he bes guess abou a paricular cusomer s fuure purchasing, given informaion abou his pas behavior). Many oher relaed issues may arise from a cusomerlevel daabase, bu hese are ypical of he quesions ha a manager should iniially ry o address. This is paricularly rue for any firm wih serious ineres in racking and managing cusomer lifeime value (CLV) on a sysemaic basis. There is a grea deal of ineres, among markeing praciioners and academics alike, in developing models o accomplish hese asks. One of he firs models o explicily address hese issues is he Pareo/NBD couning your cusomers framework originally proposed by Schmilein e al. (1987), called hereafer SMC. This model describes repeabuying behavior in seings where cusomer dropou is unobserved: I assumes ha cusomers buy a a seady rae (albei in a sochasic manner) for a period of ime, and hen become inacive. More specifically, ime o dropou is modelled using he Pareo (exponenialgamma mixure) iming model, and repeabuying behavior while acive is modelled using he NBD (Poissongamma mixure) couning model. The Pareo/NBD is a powerful model for cusomerbase analysis, bu is empirical applicaion can be challenging, especially in erms of parameer esimaion. Perhaps because of hese operaional difficulies, relaively few researchers acively followed up on he SMC paper soon afer i was published (as judged by ciaion couns). However, i has received a seadily increasing amoun of aenion in recen years as many researchers and managers have become concerned abou issues such as cusomer churn, ariion, reenion, and CLV. While a number of researchers (e.g., Balasubramanian e al. 1998, Jain and Singh 22, Mulhern 1999, Niraj e al. 21) refer o he applicabiliy and usefulness of he Pareo/NBD, only a small handful claim o have acually implemened i. Neverheless, some of hese papers (e.g., Reinarz and Kumar 2, Schmilein and Peerson 1994) have, in urn, become quie popular and widely cied. 275
2 276 Markeing Science 24(2), pp , 25 INFORMS The objecive of his paper is o develop a new model, he beageomeric/nbd (BG/NBD), which represens a sligh variaion in he behavioral sory ha lies a he hear of SMC s original work, bu is vasly easier o implemen. We show, for insance, how is parameers can be obained quie easily in Microsof Excel, wih no appreciable loss in he model s abiliy o fi or predic cusomer purchasing paerns. We develop he BG/NBD model from firs principles and presen he expressions required for making individuallevel saemens abou fuure buying behavior. We compare and conras is performance o ha of he Pareo/NBD via a simulaion and an illusraive empirical applicaion. The wo models yield very similar resuls, leading us o sugges ha he BG/NBD should be viewed as an aracive alernaive o he Pareo/NBD model. Before developing he BG/NBD model, we briefly review he Pareo/NBD model ( 2). In 3 we ouline he assumpions of he BG/NBD model, deriving he key expressions a he individual level and for a randomly chosen individual, in 4 and 5, respecively. This is followed by he aforemenioned simulaion and empirical analysis. We conclude wih a discussion of several issues ha arise from his work. 2. The Pareo/NBD Model The Pareo/NBD model is based on five assumpions: (i) While acive, he number of ransacions made by a cusomer in a ime period of lengh is disribued Poisson wih mean. (ii) Heerogeneiy in he ransacion rae across cusomers follows a gamma disribuion wih shape parameer r and scale parameer. (iii) Each cusomer has an unobserved lifeime of lengh. This poin a which he cusomer becomes inacive is disribued exponenial wih dropou rae. (iv) Heerogeneiy in dropou raes across cusomers follows a gamma disribuion wih shape parameer s and scale parameer. (v) The ransacion rae and he dropou rae vary independenly across cusomers. The Pareo/NBD (and, as we will see shorly, he BG/NBD) requires only wo pieces of informaion abou each cusomer s pas purchasing hisory: his recency (when his las ransacion occurred) and frequency (how many ransacions he made in a specified ime period). The noaion used o represen his informaion is (X x x T), where x is he number of ransacions observed in he ime period T and x ( < x T ) is he ime of he las ransacion. Using hese wo key summary saisics, SMC derive expressions for a number of managerially relevan quaniies, such as: EX, he expeced number of ransacions in a ime period of lengh (SMC, Equaion (17)), which is cenral o compuing he expeced ransacion volume for he whole cusomer base over ime. PX x, he probabiliy of observing x ransacions in a ime period of lengh (SMC, Equaions (A4), (A43), and (A45)). EYX x x T, he expeced number of ransacions in he period T T + for an individual wih observed behavior X x x T (SMC, Equaion (22)). The likelihood funcion associaed wih he Pareo/NBD model is quie complex, involving numerous evaluaions of he Gaussian hypergeomeric funcion. Besides being unfamiliar o mos researchers working in he areas of daabase markeing and CRM analysis, muliple evaluaions of he Gaussian hypergeomeric are very demanding from a compuaional sandpoin. Furhermore, he precision of some numerical procedures used o evaluae his funcion can vary subsanially over he parameer space (Lozier and Olver 1995); his can cause major problems for numerical opimizaion rouines as hey search for he maximum of he likelihood funcion. To he bes of our knowledge, he only published paper reporing a successful implemenaion of he Pareo/NBD model using sandard maximum likelihood esimaion (MLE) echniques is Reinarz and Kumar (23), and he auhors commen on he associaed compuaional burden. As an alernaive o MLE, SMC proposed a hreesep mehodofmomens esimaion procedure, which was furher refined by Schmilein and Peerson (1994). While simpler han MLE, he proposed algorihm is sill no easy o implemen; furhermore, i does no have he desirable saisical properies commonly associaed wih MLE. In conras, he BG/NBD model, o be inroduced in he nex secion, can be implemened very quickly and efficienly via MLE, and is parameer esimaion does no require any specialized sofware or he evaluaion of any unconvenional mahemaical funcions. 3. BG/NBD Assumpions Mos aspecs of he BG/NBD model direcly mirror hose of he Pareo/NBD. The only difference lies in he sory being old abou how/when cusomers become inacive. The Pareo iming model assumes ha dropou can occur a any poin in ime, independen of he occurrence of acual purchases. If we assume insead ha dropou occurs immediaely afer a purchase, we can model his process using he beageomeric (BG) model. More formally, he BG/NBD model is based on he following five assumpions (he firs wo of
3 Markeing Science 24(2), pp , 25 INFORMS 277 which are idenical o he corresponding Pareo/NBD assumpions): (i) While acive, he number of ransacions made by a cusomer follows a Poisson process wih ransacion rae. This is equivalen o assuming ha he ime beween ransacions is disribued exponenial wih ransacion rae, i.e., f j j 1 e j j 1 j > j 1 (ii) Heerogeneiy in follows a gamma disribuion wih pdf f r r r 1 e > (1) r (iii) Afer any ransacion, a cusomer becomes inacive wih probabiliy p. Therefore he poin a which he cusomer drops ou is disribued across ransacions according o a (shifed) geomeric disribuion wih pmf Pinacive immediaely afer jh ransacion p1 p j 1 j (iv) Heerogeneiy in p follows a bea disribuion wih pdf fp a b pa 1 1 p b 1 p 1 (2) Bab where Bab is he bea funcion, which can be expressed in erms of gamma funcions: Bab ab/a + b. (v) The ransacion rae and he dropou probabiliy p vary independenly across cusomers. 4. Model Developmen a he Individual Level 4.1. Derivaion of he Likelihood Funcion Consider a cusomer who had x ransacions in he period T wih he ransacions occurring a 1 2 x : 1 2 T We derive he individuallevel likelihood funcion in he following manner: he likelihood of he firs ransacion occurring a 1 is a sandard exponenial likelihood componen, which equals e 1. he likelihood of he second ransacion occurring a 2 is he probabiliy of remaining acive a 1 imes he sandard exponenial likelihood componen, which equals 1 pe 2 1. This coninues for each subsequen ransacion, unil: he likelihood of he xh ransacion occurring a x is he probabiliy of remaining acive a x 1 x imes he sandard exponenial likelihood componen, which equals 1 pe x x 1. Finally, he likelihood of observing zero purchases in x T is he probabiliy he cusomer became inacive a x, plus he probabiliy he remained acive bu made no purchases in his inerval, which equals p + 1 pe T x. Therefore, L p 1 2 x T e 1 1 pe pe x x 1 {p + 1 pe } T x p1 p x 1 x e x + 1 p x x e T As poined ou earlier for he Pareo/NBD, noe ha informaion on he iming of he x ransacions is no required; a sufficien summary of he cusomer s purchase hisory is (X x x T). Similar o SMC, we assume ha all cusomers are acive a he beginning of he observaion period; herefore, he likelihood funcion for a cusomer making purchases in he inerval T is he sandard exponenial survival funcion: L X T e T Thus, we can wrie he individuallevel likelihood funcion as L p X xt 1 p x x e T where x> 1ifx>, oherwise. + x> p1 p x 1 x e x (3) 4.2. Derivaion of PX x Le he random variable X denoe he number of ransacions occurring in a ime period of lengh (wih a ime origin of ). To derive an expression for he PX x, we recall he fundamenal relaionship beween inereven imes and he number of evens: X x T x, where T x is he random variable denoing he ime of he xh ransacion. Given our assumpion regarding he naure of he dropou process, PXx Pacive afer xh purchase PT x and T x+1 >+ x> Pbecomes inacive afer xh purchase PT x Given he assumpion ha he ime beween ransacions is characerized by he exponenial disribuion, PT x and T x+1 > is simply he Poisson probabiliy
4 278 Markeing Science 24(2), pp , 25 INFORMS ha Xx, and PT x is he Erlangx cdf. Therefore, PXxp 1 p x x e + x! x> p1 p x 1 x 1 ] [1 e j (4) j! 4.3. Derivaion of EX Given ha he number of ransacions follows a Poisson process, EX is simply if he cusomer is acive a. For a cusomer who becomes inacive a, he expeced number of ransacions in he period is. However, wha is he likelihood ha a cusomer becomes inacive a? Condiional on and p, j P>Pacive a p 1 p j j e j! j e p This implies ha he pdf of he dropou ime is given by g ppe p. (Noe ha his akes on an exponenial form. However, i feaures an explici associaion wih he ransacion rae, in conras wih he Pareo/NBD, which has an exponenial dropou process ha is independen of he ransacion rae.) I follows ha he expeced number of ransacions in a ime period of lengh is given by EXp P>+ g pd 1 p 1 p e p (5) 5. Model Developmen for a Randomly Chosen Individual All he expressions developed above are condiional on he ransacion rae and he dropou probabiliy p, boh of which are unobserved. To derive he equivalen expressions for a randomly chosen cusomer, we ake he expecaion of he individuallevel resuls over he mixing disribuions for and p, as given in (1) and (2). This yields he following resuls. Taking he expecaion of (3) over he disribuion of and p resuls in he following expression for he likelihood funcion for a randomly chosen cusomer wih purchase hisory (X x x T ): Lrab X x x T Bab+x r+x r Bab r+t r+x + x> Ba+1b+x 1 Bab r+x r (6) r+ x r+x The four BG/NBD model parameers (rab) can be esimaed via he mehod of maximum likelihood in he following manner. Suppose we have a sample of N cusomers, where cusomer i had X i x i ransacions in he period T i, wih he las ransacion occurring a xi. The sample loglikelihood funcion is given by N LLrab ln [ Lrab X i x i xi T i ] (7) i1 This can be maximized using sandard numerical opimizaion rouines. Taking he expecaion of (4) over he disribuion of and p resuls in he following expression for he probabiliy of observing x purchases in a ime period of lengh : PXxrab Bab+x Bab r+x rx! Ba+1b+x 1 + x> Bab [ ( ) r { x ( ) r ( ) x + + j r+j rj! ( ) j } ] (8) + Finally, aking he expecaion of (5) over he disribuion of and p resuls in he following expression for he expeced number of purchases in a ime period of lengh : EXrab a+b 1 a 1 [ 1 ( ) r + 2F 1 (rba+b 1 + )] where 2 F 1 is he Gaussian hypergeomeric funcion. (See he appendix for deails of he derivaion.) Noe ha his final expression requires a single evaluaion of he Gaussian hypergeomeric funcion, bu i is imporan o emphasize ha his expecaion is only used afer he likelihood funcion has been maximized. A single evaluaion of he Gaussian hypergeomeric funcion for a given se of parameers is relaively sraighforward, and can be closely approximaed wih a polynomial series, even in a modeling environmen such as Microsof Excel. In order for he BG/NBD model o be of use in a forwardlooking cusomerbase analysis, we need o obain an expression for he expeced number of ransacions in a fuure period of lengh for an individual wih pas observed behavior X x x T. (9)
5 Markeing Science 24(2), pp , 25 INFORMS 279 We provide a careful derivaion in he appendix, bu here is he key expression: EYX x x T rab a+b+x 1 a 1 [ 1 ( ) +T r+x ( +T + 2F 1 r +xb+xa+b+x 1 1+ x> a b+x 1 ( +T + x ) r+x +T + (1) Once again, his expecaion requires a single evaluaion of he Gaussian hypergeomeric funcion for any cusomer of ineres, bu his is no a burdensome ask. The remainder of he expression is simple arihmeic. 6. Simulaion While he underlying behavioral sory associaed wih he proposed BG/NBD model is quie similar o ha of he Pareo/NBD, we have no ye provided any assurance ha he empirical performance of he wo models will be closely aligned wih each oher. In his secion, herefore, we discuss a comprehensive simulaion sudy ha provides a horough undersanding of when he BG/NBD can (and canno) serve as a close proxy o he Pareo/NBD. More specifically, we creae a wide variey of purchasing environmens (by manipulaing he four parameers of he Pareo/NBD model) o look for limiing condiions under which he BG/NBD model does a poor job of capuring he underlying purchasing process Simulaion Design To creae hese simulaed purchasing environmens, we chose hree levels for each of he four Pareo/NBD parameers, hen generaed a fullfacorial design of differen worlds. For he wo shape parameers (r and s) we used values of.25,.5, and.75; for each of he wo scale parameers ( and ) we used values of 5, 1, and 15. When we ranslae hese various combinaions ino meaningful summary saisics i becomes easy o see he wide variaion across hese simulaed worlds. For insance, buyer peneraion (i.e., he number of cusomers who make a leas one purchase, or 1 P) varies from a low of 13% o a high of 76%. Likewise, average purchase frequency (i.e., mean number of purchases among buyers, or EX/1 P) ranges from 2.1 up o 8.2 purchases per period. I is worh noing ha his broad range covers he observed values from he original Schmilein and Peerson (1994) applicaion as well as he acual daase used in our empirical analysis (o be discussed in he nex secion). For each of he 81 simulaed worlds, we creaed a synheic panel of 4, households, hen simulaed he Pareo/NBD purchase (and dropou) process for a period of 14 weeks. We hen ran he BG/NBD model on he firs 52 weeks for each of hese daases, ) ] and used he esimaed parameers o generae forecass for a holdou period covering he remaining 52 weeks. We evaluae he performance of he BG/NBD based on he mean absolue percen error (MAPE) calculaed across his 52week forecas sales rajecory. If he MAPE value is a low number (below, say, 5%), we have faih in he applicabiliy of he BG/NBD for ha paricular se of underlying parameers; oherwise, we need o look more carefully o undersand why he BG/NBD is no doing an adequae job of maching he Pareo/NBD sales projecion Simulaion Resuls In general, he BG/NBD performed quie well in his holdouforecasing ask. The average value of he MAPE saisic was 2.68%, and he wors case across all 81 worlds was a reasonably accepable 6.97%. However, upon closer inspecion we noiced an ineresing, sysemaic rend across he worlds wih relaively high values of MAPE. In Table 1 we summarize he relevan summary saisics for he 1 wors simulaed worlds in conras wih he remaining 71 worlds. Noice ha he BG/NBD forecass end o be relaively poor when peneraion and/or purchase frequency are exremely low. Upon furher reflecion abou he differences beween he wo model srucures, his resul makes sense. Under he Pareo/NBD model, dropou can occur a any ime even before a cusomer has made his firs purchase afer he sar of he observaion period. However, under he BG/NBD, a cusomer canno become inacive before making his firs purchase. If peneraions and/or buying raes are fairly high, hen his difference becomes relaively inconsequenial. However, in a world where acive buyers are eiher uncommon or very slow in making heir purchases, he BG/NBD will no do such a good job of mimicking he Pareo/NBD. Beyond his one source of deviaion, here do no appear o be any oher paerns associaed wih higher versus lower values of MAPE. For insance, he Pearson correlaion beween MAPE and peneraion for he 71 worlds wih good behavior is a modes.142. (In conras, across all 81 worlds, his correlaion is.379.) Therefore, when we se aside he worlds wih sparse buying, he BG/NBD appears o be very robus. I would be a simple maer o exend he BG/NBD model o allow for a segmen of hard core nonbuyers. This would require only one addiional Table 1 Summary of Simulaion Resuls Average purchase MAPE Peneraion frequency Wors 1 worlds % 2.6 Oher 71 worlds % 3.8
6 28 Markeing Science 24(2), pp , 25 INFORMS parameer and would likely overcome his problem compleely, bu we do no see he likelihood or severiy of his problem o be exreme enough o warran such an exension as par of he basic model. Neverheless, we encourage managers o coninually monior summary saisics such as peneraion and purchase frequency; for many firms his is already a rouine pracice. Having esablished he robusness (and an imporan limiing condiion) of he BG/NBD, we now urn o a more horough invesigaion of is performance (relaive o he Pareo/NBD) in an acual daase. 7. Empirical Analysis We explore he performance of he BG/NBD model using daa on he purchasing of CDs a he online reailer CDNOW. The full daase focuses on a single cohor of new cusomers who made heir firs purchase a he CDNOW websie in he firs quarer of We have daa covering heir iniial (rial) and subsequen (repea) purchase occasions for he period January 1997 hrough June 1998, during which he 23,57 Q1/97 riers bough nearly 163, CDs afer heir iniial purchase occasions. (See Fader and Hardie 21 for furher deails abou his daase.) For he purposes of his analysis, we ake a 1/1h sysemaic sample of he cusomers. We calibrae he model using he repea ransacion daa for he 2,357 sampled cusomers over he firs half of he 78week period and forecas heir fuure purchasing over he remaining 39 weeks. For cusomer i (i ), we know he lengh of he ime period during which repea ransacions could have occurred (T i 39 ime of firs purchase), he number of repea ransacions in his period (x i ), and he ime of his las repea ransacion ( xi ). (If x i, xi.) In conras o Fader and Hardie (21), we are focusing on he number of ransacions, no he number of CDs purchased. Maximum likelihood esimaes of he model parameers (rab) are obained by maximizing he loglikelihood funcion given in (7) above. Sandard numerical opimizaion mehods are employed, using he Solver ool in Microsof Excel, o obain he parameer esimaes. (Idenical esimaes are obained using he more sophisicaed MATLAB programming language.) To implemen he model in Excel, we rewrie he loglikelihood funcion, (6), as where Lrab X x x T A 1 A 2 A 3 + x> A 4 A 1 r+xr A r 2 a+bb+x ba+b+x ( ) 1 r+x )( ) a 1 r+x A 3 A +T 4 ( b+x 1 + x This is very easy o code in Excel see Figure 1 for complee deails. (A noe on how o implemen he model in Excel, along wih a copy of he complee spreadshee, can be found a hp://brucehardie.com/ noes/4/.) The parameers of he Pareo/NBD model are also obained via MLE, bu his ask could be performed only in MATLAB due o he compuaional demands of he model. The parameer esimaes and corresponding loglikelihood funcion values for he wo models are repored in Table 2. Looking a he loglikelihood funcion values, we observe ha he BG/NBD model provides a beer fi o he daa. In Figure 2, we examine he fi of hese models visually: The expeced numbers of people making, 1 7+ repea purchases in he 39week model calibraion period from he wo models are compared o he acual frequency disribuion. The fis of he wo models are very close. On he basis of he chisquare Figure 1 Screensho of Excel Workshee for Parameer Esimaion B r alpha a b LL SUM(E8:E2364) A C D E F G H I GAMMALN(B$1+ B8) GAMMALN(B$1) + B$1*LN(B$2) IF(B8>, LN(B$3) LN(B$4 + B8 1) (B$1+ B8)* LN(B$2 + C8),) (B$1+B8)*LN(B$2 + D8) ID x _x T ln(.) ln(a_1) ln(a_2) ln(a_3) ln(a_4) F8+G8+LN(EXP(H8)+(B8>)*EXP(I8)) GAMMALN(B$ B$4) + GAMMALN(B$4+B8) GAMMALN(B$4) GAMMALN(B$3+B$4+B8)
7 Markeing Science 24(2), pp , 25 INFORMS 281 Table 2 Model Esimaion Resuls Figure 3 Condiional Expecaions BG/NBD Pareo/NBD r a 793 b 2426 s LL goodnessoffi es, we noe ha he BG/NBD model provides a beer fi o he daa ( , p 19) han he Pareo/NBD, , (p 7). The performance of hese models becomes more apparen when we consider how well he models rack he acual number of (oal) repea ransacions over ime. During he 39week calibraion period, he racking performance of he BG/NBD and Pareo/ NBD models is pracically idenical. In he subsequen 39week forecas period, boh models rack he acual (cumulaive) sales rajecory, wih he Pareo/NBD performing slighly beer han he BG/NBD (underforecasing by 2% versus 4%), bu boh models demonsrae superb racking/forecasing capabiliies. Our final and perhaps mos criical examinaion of he relaive performance of he wo models focuses on he qualiy of he predicions of individuallevel ransacions in he forecas period (Weeks 4 78) condiional on he number of observed ransacions in he model calibraion period. For he BG/NBD model, hese are compued using (1). For he Pareo/NBD, as noed earlier, he equivalen expression is represened by Equaion (22) in SMC. In Figure 3, we repor hese condiional expecaions along wih he average of he acual number of ransacions ha ook place in he forecas period, broken down by he number of calibraionperiod repea Figure 2 Frequency 1,5 1, 5 Prediced Versus Acual Frequency of Repea Transacions Acual BG/NBD Pareo/NBD # Transacions Expeced # Transacions in Weeks Acual BG/NBD Pareo/NBD # Transacions in Weeks 1 39 ransacions. (For each x, we are averaging over cusomers wih differen values of x.) Boh he BG/NBD and Pareo/NBD models provide excellen predicions of he expeced number of ransacions in he holdou period. I appears ha he Pareo/NBD offers slighly beer predicions han he BG/NBD, bu i is imporan o keep in mind ha he groups owards he righ of he figure (i.e., buyers wih larger values of x in he calibraion period) are exremely small. An imporan aspec ha is hard o discern from he figure is he relaive performance for he very large zero class (i.e., he 1,411 people who made no repea purchases in he firs 39 weeks). This group makes a oal of 334 ransacions in Weeks 4 78, which comprises 18% of all of he forecas period ransacions. (This is second only o he 7+ group, which accouns for 22% of he forecas period ransacions.) The BG/NBD condiional expecaion for he zero class is.23, which is much closer o he acual average (334/1,411.24) han ha prediced by he Pareo/NBD (.14). Neverheless, hese differences are no necessarily meaningful. Taken as a whole across he full se of 2,357 cusomers, he predicions for he BG/NBD and Pareo/NBD models are indisinguishable from each oher and from he acual ransacion numbers. This is confirmed by a hreegroup ANOVA (F ), which is no significan a he usual 5% level. The means repored in Figure 3 mask he variabiliy in he individuallevel numbers. Consider, for example, he 1 cusomers who made hree repea ransacions in he calibraion period. In he course of he 39 week forecas period, his group of cusomers made anywhere beween and 1 repea ransacions, wih an average of 1.56 ransacions. The individuallevel BG/NBD condiional expecaions vary from.4 o
8 282 Markeing Science 24(2), pp , 25 INFORMS Table 3 Correlaions Beween Forecas Period Transacion Numbers Acual BG/NBD Pareo/NBD Acual 1. BG/NBD Pareo/NBD , wih an average of 1.52; he Pareo/NBD condiional expecaions vary from.9 o 2.84, wih an average of Table 3 repors he correlaions beween he acual number of repea ransacions and he BG/NBD and Pareo/NBD condiional expecaions, compued across all 2,357 cusomers. We observe ha he correlaion beween he acual number of forecas period ransacions and he associaed BG/NBD condiional expecaions is.626. Is his high or low? To he bes of our knowledge, no oher researchers have repored such measures of individuallevel predicive performance, which makes i difficul for us o assess wheher his correlaion is good or bad. (We hope ha fuure research will shed ligh on his issue.) Given he objecives of his research, i is of greaer ineres o compare he BG/NBD predicions wih hose of he Pareo/NBD model. The differences are negligible: The correlaion beween hese wo ses of numbers is an impressive.996. This analysis demonsraes he high degree of validiy of boh models, paricularly for he purposes of forecasing a cusomer s fuure purchasing, condiional on his pas buying behavior. Furhermore, i demonsraes ha he performance of he BG/NBD model mirrors ha of he Pareo/NBD model. 8. Discussion Many researchers have praised he Pareo/NBD model for is sensible behavioral sory, is excellen empirical performance, and he useful managerial diagnosics ha arise quie naurally from is formulaion. We fully agree wih hese posiive assessmens and have no misgivings abou he model whasoever, besides is compuaional complexiy. I is simply our inenion o make his ype of modeling framework more broadly accessible so ha many researchers and praciioners can benefi from he original ideas of SMC. The BG/NBD model arises by making a small, relaively inconsequenial, change o he Pareo/NBD assumpions. The ransiion from an exponenial disribuion o a geomeric process (o capure cusomer dropou) does no require any differen psychological heories, nor does i have any noeworhy managerial implicaions. When we evaluae he wo models on heir primary oucomes (i.e., heir abiliy o fi and predic repea ransacion behavior), hey are effecively indisinguishable from each oher. As Albers (2) noes, he use of markeing models in acual pracice is becoming less of an excepion, and more of a rule, because of spreadshee sofware. I is our hope ha he ease wih which he BG/NBD model can be implemened in a familiar modeling environmen will encourage more firms o ake beer advanage of he informaion already conained in heir cusomer ransacion daabases. Furhermore, as key personnel become comforable wih his ype of model, we can expec o see growing demand for more complee (and complex) models and more willingness o commi resources o hem. Beyond he purely echnical aspecs involved in deriving he BG/NBD model and comparing i o he Pareo/NBD, we have aemped o highligh some imporan managerial aspecs associaed wih his kind of modeling exercise. For insance, o he bes of our knowledge, his is only he second empirical validaion of he Pareo/NBD model he firs being Schmilein and Peerson (1994). (Oher researchers e.g., Reinarz and Kumar 2, 23; Wu and Chen 2, have employed he model exensively, bu do no repor on is performance in a holdou period.) We find ha boh models yield very accurae forecass of fuure purchasing, boh a he aggregae level as well as a he level of he individual (condiional on pas purchasing). Besides using hese empirical ess as a basis o compare models, we also wan o call more aenion o hese analyses wih paricular emphasis on condiional expecaions as he proper yardsicks ha all researchers should use when judging he absolue performance of oher forecasing models for CLVrelaed applicaions. I is imporan for a model o be able o accuraely projec he fuure purchasing behavior of a broad range of pas cusomers, and is performance for he zero class is especially criical, given he ypical size of ha silen group. In using his model, here are several implemenaion issues o consider. Firs, he model should be applied separaely o cusomer cohors defined by he ime (e.g., quarer) of acquisiion, acquisiion channel, ec. (Blaberg e al. 21). (For a very maure cusomer base, he model could be applied o coarse RFMbased segmens.) Second, if we are using one cohor s parameers as he basis for, say, anoher cohor s condiional expecaion calculaions, we mus be confiden ha he wo cohors are comparable. Third, we mus acknowledge an implici assumpion when using he forecass generaed using a model such as ha developed in he paper: We are assuming ha fuure markeing aciviies argeed a he group of cusomers will basically be he same as hose observed in he pas. (Of course, such models can be used o provide a baseline agains which we can
9 Markeing Science 24(2), pp , 25 INFORMS 283 examine he impac of changes in markeing aciviy.) Finally, as wih he Pareo/NBD, he BG/NBD mus be augmened by a model of purchase amoun before i can be used as he basis for CLV calculaions. Two candidae models are he normalnormal mixure (Schmilein and Peerson 1994) and he gammagamma mixure (Colombo and Jiang 1999). A naural saring poin for any such exension would be o assume ha purchase amoun is independen of purchase iming (Schmilein and Peerson 1994). The BG/NBD easily lends iself o relevan generalizaions, such as he inclusion of demographics or measures of markeing aciviy. (In fac, some poenial end users of models such as he BG/NBD and he Pareo/NBD may view he inclusion of such variables as a necessary condiion for implemenaion.) However, grea care mus be exercised when underaking such exensions: To he exen ha cusomer segmens have been formed on he basis of pas behavior (e.g., using he RFM framework) and hese segmens have been argeed wih differen markeing aciviies (Elsner e al. 24), we mus be aware of economeric issues such as endogeneiy bias (Shugan 24) and sample selecion bias. If such exensions are underaken, he BG/NBD in is basic form would sill serve as an appropriae (and hardobea) benchmark model and should be viewed as he righ saring poin for any cusomerbase analysis exercise in a nonconracual seing (i.e., where he opporuniies for ransacions are coninuous and he ime a which cusomers become inacive is unobserved). Acknowledgmens The firs auhor acknowledges he suppor of he Wharon SMU (Singapore Managemen Universiy) Research Cener. The second auhor acknowledges he suppor of ESRC Gran R and he London Business School Cenre for Markeing. Appendix In his appendix, we derive he expressions for EX and EYX x x T. Cenral o hese derivaions is Euler s inegral for he Gaussian hypergeomeric funcion: 1 2F 1 abcz b 1 1 c b 1 1 z a d Bbc b c>b Derivaion of EX To arrive a an expression for EX for a randomly chosen cusomer, we need o ake he expecaion of (5) over he disribuion of and p. Firs we ake he expecaion wih respec o, giving us EXrp 1 p p+p r The nex sep is o ake he expecaion of his over he disribuion of p. We firs evaluae 1 p p a 1 1 p b 1 Bab r dp a+b 1 a 1 Nex, we evaluae r p a 1 1 p b 1 dp p+p r Bab r 1 p a 2 1 p b 1 +p r dp Bab leing q 1 p (which implies dp dq) ( ) r 1 ( q b 1 1 q a 2 1 ) r + Bab + q dq which, recalling Euler s inegral for he Gaussian hypergeomeric funcion ( ) r ) Ba 1b + Bab 2F 1 (rba+b 1 + I follows ha EXrab a+b 1 a 1 [ 1 ( ) r ( + 2F 1 rba+b 1 + )] Derivaion of EYX x x T Le he random variable Y denoe he number of purchases made in he period T T +. We are ineresed in compuing he condiional expecaion EYX x x T, he expeced number of purchases in he period T T + for a cusomer wih purchase hisory X x x T. If he cusomer is acive a T, i follows from (5) ha EYp 1 p 1 p e p (A1) Wha is he probabiliy ha a cusomer is acive a T? Given our assumpion ha all cusomers are acive a he beginning of he iniial observaion period, a cusomer canno drop ou before he has made any ransacions; herefore, Pacive a T X T p1 For he case where purchases were made in he period T, he probabiliy ha a cusomer wih purchase hisory X x x T is sill acive a T, condiional on and p, is simply he probabiliy ha he did no drop ou a x and made no purchase in x T, divided by he probabiliy of making no purchases in his same period. Recalling ha his second probabiliy is simply he probabiliy ha he cusomer became inacive a x, plus he probabiliy he remained acive bu made no purchases in his inerval, we have Pacive a T X x x T p 1 pe T x p+1 pe T x Muliplying his by 1 p x 1 x e x /1 p x 1 x e x gives us Pacive a T X x x T p 1 px x e T Lp X x x T (A2) where he expression for Lp X x x T is given in (3). (Noe ha when x, he expression given in (A2) equals 1.)
10 284 Markeing Science 24(2), pp , 25 INFORMS Muliplying (A1) and (A2) yields EYX x x T p 1 px x e ( T 1/p 1/pe p /p ) Lp X x x T p 1 1 p x x e T p 1 1 p x x T +p e (A3) LpX x x T (Noe ha his reduces o (A1) when x, which follows from he resul ha a cusomer who made zero purchases in he ime period T mus be assumed o be acive a ime T.) As he ransacion rae and dropou probabiliy p are unobserved, we compue EYX x x T for a randomly chosen cusomer by aking he expecaion of (A3) over he disribuion of and p, updaed o ake ino accoun he informaion X x x T : EYX x x T rab EYX x x T p f p rabx x x T ddp (A4) By Bayes heorem, he join poserior disribuion of and p is given by f p rabx x x T Lp X x xt frf p ab (A5) Lrab X x x T Subsiuing (A3) and (A5) in (A4), we ge EYX x x T rab where and A Ba 1b+x Bab A B LrabX x x T p 1 1 p x x e T frf p abddp r+x r r+t r+x B p 1 1 p x x e T +p frf p abddp { p a 2 1 p b+x 1 } r r+x 1 +T +p e d dp Bab r r+xr 1 p a 2 1 p b+x 1 +T +p r+x dp rbab leing q 1 p (which implies dp dq) r+x r rbab+t + r+x ) q b+x 1 1 q (1 a 2 r+x +T + q dq (A6) (A7) which, recalling Euler s inegral for he Gaussian hypergeomeric funcion, r+x r r+t + r+x 2F 1 (r +xb+xa+b+x 1 +T + Ba 1b+x Bab ) (A8) Subsiuing (6), (A7), and (A8) in (A6) and simplifying, we ge EYX x x T rab [ a+b+x 1 1 ( ) +T r+x ( a 1 +T + 2F 1 r +xb+xa+b+x 1 References 1+ x> a b+x 1 ( +T + x ) r+x +T + Albers, Sönke. 2. Impac of ypes of funcional relaionships, decisions, and soluions on he applicabiliy of markeing models. Inerna. J. Res. Markeing 17(2 3) Balasubramanian, S., S. Gupa, W. Kamakura, M. Wedel Modeling large daases in markeing. Saisica Neerlandica 52(3) Blaberg, Rober C., Gary Gez, Jacquelyn S. Thomas. 21. Cusomer Equiy. Harvard Business School Press, Boson, MA. Colombo, Richard, Weina Jiang A sochasic RFM model. J. Ineracive Markeing 13(Summer) Elsner, Ralf, Manfred Kraff, Arnd Huchzermeier. 24. Opimizing Rhenania s direc markeing business hrough dynamic mulilevel modeling (DMLM) in a mulicaalogbrand environmen. Markeing Sci. 23(2) Fader, Peer S., Bruce G. S. Hardie. 21. Forecasing repea sales a CDNOW: A case sudy. Par 2 of 2. Inerfaces 31(May June) S94 S17. Jain, Dipak, Siddharha S. Singh. 22. Cusomer lifeime value research in markeing: A review and fuure direcions. J. Ineracive Markeing 16(Spring) Lozier, D. W., F. W. J. Olver Numerical evaluaion of special funcions. Waler Gauschi, ed. Mahemaics of Compuaion : A HalfCenury of Compuaional Mahemaics. Proc. Sympos. Appl. Mah. American Mahemaical Sociey, Providence, RI. Mulhern, Francis J Cusomer profiabiliy analysis: Measuremen, concenraion, and research direcions. J. Ineracive Markeing 13(Winer) Niraj, Rakesh, Mahendra Gupa, Chakravarhi Narasimhan. 21. Cusomer profiabiliy in a supply chain. J. Markeing 65(July) Reinarz, Werner, V. Kumar. 2. On he profiabiliy of longlife cusomers in a nonconracual seing: An empirical invesigaion and implicaions for markeing. J. Markeing 64(Ocober) Reinarz, Werner, V. Kumar. 23. The impac of cusomer relaionship characerisics on profiable lifeime duraion. J. Markeing 67(January) Schmilein, David C., Rober A. Peerson Cusomer base analysis: An indusrial purchase process applicaion. Markeing Sci. 13(Winer) Schmilein, David C., Donald G. Morrison, Richard Colombo Couning your cusomers: Who are hey and wha will hey do nex? Managemen Sci. 33(January) Shugan, Seven M. 24. Endogeneiy in markeing decision models. Markeing Sci. 23(1) 1 3. Wu, Couchen, HsiuLi Chen. 2. Couning your cusomers: Compounding cusomer s insore decisions, inerpurchase ime, and repurchasing behavior. Eur. J. Oper. Res. 127(1) ) ]
Chapter 8: Regression with Lagged Explanatory Variables
Chaper 8: Regression wih Lagged Explanaory Variables Time series daa: Y for =1,..,T End goal: Regression model relaing a dependen variable o explanaory variables. Wih ime series new issues arise: 1. One
More informationPROFIT TEST MODELLING IN LIFE ASSURANCE USING SPREADSHEETS PART ONE
Profi Tes Modelling in Life Assurance Using Spreadshees PROFIT TEST MODELLING IN LIFE ASSURANCE USING SPREADSHEETS PART ONE Erik Alm Peer Millingon 2004 Profi Tes Modelling in Life Assurance Using Spreadshees
More informationPerformance Center Overview. Performance Center Overview 1
Performance Cener Overview Performance Cener Overview 1 ODJFS Performance Cener ce Cener New Performance Cener Model Performance Cener Projec Meeings Performance Cener Execuive Meeings Performance Cener
More informationDuration and Convexity ( ) 20 = Bond B has a maturity of 5 years and also has a required rate of return of 10%. Its price is $613.
Graduae School of Business Adminisraion Universiy of Virginia UVAF38 Duraion and Convexiy he price of a bond is a funcion of he promised paymens and he marke required rae of reurn. Since he promised
More informationARCH 2013.1 Proceedings
Aricle from: ARCH 213.1 Proceedings Augus 14, 212 Ghislain Leveille, Emmanuel Hamel A renewal model for medical malpracice Ghislain Léveillé École d acuaria Universié Laval, Québec, Canada 47h ARC Conference
More informationMACROECONOMIC FORECASTS AT THE MOF A LOOK INTO THE REAR VIEW MIRROR
MACROECONOMIC FORECASTS AT THE MOF A LOOK INTO THE REAR VIEW MIRROR The firs experimenal publicaion, which summarised pas and expeced fuure developmen of basic economic indicaors, was published by he Minisry
More informationSPEC model selection algorithm for ARCH models: an options pricing evaluation framework
Applied Financial Economics Leers, 2008, 4, 419 423 SEC model selecion algorihm for ARCH models: an opions pricing evaluaion framework Savros Degiannakis a, * and Evdokia Xekalaki a,b a Deparmen of Saisics,
More informationIndividual Health Insurance April 30, 2008 Pages 167170
Individual Healh Insurance April 30, 2008 Pages 167170 We have received feedback ha his secion of he e is confusing because some of he defined noaion is inconsisen wih comparable life insurance reserve
More informationThe naive method discussed in Lecture 1 uses the most recent observations to forecast future values. That is, Y ˆ t + 1
Business Condiions & Forecasing Exponenial Smoohing LECTURE 2 MOVING AVERAGES AND EXPONENTIAL SMOOTHING OVERVIEW This lecure inroduces imeseries smoohing forecasing mehods. Various models are discussed,
More informationMorningstar Investor Return
Morningsar Invesor Reurn Morningsar Mehodology Paper Augus 31, 2010 2010 Morningsar, Inc. All righs reserved. The informaion in his documen is he propery of Morningsar, Inc. Reproducion or ranscripion
More informationMeasuring macroeconomic volatility Applications to export revenue data, 19702005
FONDATION POUR LES ETUDES ET RERS LE DEVELOPPEMENT INTERNATIONAL Measuring macroeconomic volailiy Applicaions o expor revenue daa, 1970005 by Joël Cariolle Policy brief no. 47 March 01 The FERDI is a
More informationJournal Of Business & Economics Research September 2005 Volume 3, Number 9
Opion Pricing And Mone Carlo Simulaions George M. Jabbour, (Email: jabbour@gwu.edu), George Washingon Universiy YiKang Liu, (yikang@gwu.edu), George Washingon Universiy ABSTRACT The advanage of Mone Carlo
More informationDYNAMIC MODELS FOR VALUATION OF WRONGFUL DEATH PAYMENTS
DYNAMIC MODELS FOR VALUATION OF WRONGFUL DEATH PAYMENTS Hong Mao, Shanghai Second Polyechnic Universiy Krzyszof M. Osaszewski, Illinois Sae Universiy Youyu Zhang, Fudan Universiy ABSTRACT Liigaion, exper
More informationTerm Structure of Prices of Asian Options
Term Srucure of Prices of Asian Opions Jirô Akahori, Tsuomu Mikami, Kenji Yasuomi and Teruo Yokoa Dep. of Mahemaical Sciences, Risumeikan Universiy 111 Nojihigashi, Kusasu, Shiga 5258577, Japan Email:
More informationForecasting, Ordering and Stock Holding for Erratic Demand
ISF 2002 23 rd o 26 h June 2002 Forecasing, Ordering and Sock Holding for Erraic Demand Andrew Eaves Lancaser Universiy / Andalus Soluions Limied Inroducion Erraic and slowmoving demand Demand classificaion
More informationTEMPORAL PATTERN IDENTIFICATION OF TIME SERIES DATA USING PATTERN WAVELETS AND GENETIC ALGORITHMS
TEMPORAL PATTERN IDENTIFICATION OF TIME SERIES DATA USING PATTERN WAVELETS AND GENETIC ALGORITHMS RICHARD J. POVINELLI AND XIN FENG Deparmen of Elecrical and Compuer Engineering Marquee Universiy, P.O.
More informationA Note on Using the Svensson procedure to estimate the risk free rate in corporate valuation
A Noe on Using he Svensson procedure o esimae he risk free rae in corporae valuaion By Sven Arnold, Alexander Lahmann and Bernhard Schwezler Ocober 2011 1. The risk free ineres rae in corporae valuaion
More informationANALYSIS AND COMPARISONS OF SOME SOLUTION CONCEPTS FOR STOCHASTIC PROGRAMMING PROBLEMS
ANALYSIS AND COMPARISONS OF SOME SOLUTION CONCEPTS FOR STOCHASTIC PROGRAMMING PROBLEMS R. Caballero, E. Cerdá, M. M. Muñoz and L. Rey () Deparmen of Applied Economics (Mahemaics), Universiy of Málaga,
More informationGraphing the Von Bertalanffy Growth Equation
file: d:\b1732013\von_beralanffy.wpd dae: Sepember 23, 2013 Inroducion Graphing he Von Beralanffy Growh Equaion Previously, we calculaed regressions of TL on SL for fish size daa and ploed he daa and
More informationPrincipal components of stock market dynamics. Methodology and applications in brief (to be updated ) Andrei Bouzaev, bouzaev@ya.
Principal componens of sock marke dynamics Mehodology and applicaions in brief o be updaed Andrei Bouzaev, bouzaev@ya.ru Why principal componens are needed Objecives undersand he evidence of more han one
More informationChapter 1.6 Financial Management
Chaper 1.6 Financial Managemen Par I: Objecive ype quesions and answers 1. Simple pay back period is equal o: a) Raio of Firs cos/ne yearly savings b) Raio of Annual gross cash flow/capial cos n c) = (1
More informationNiche Market or Mass Market?
Niche Marke or Mass Marke? Maxim Ivanov y McMaser Universiy July 2009 Absrac The de niion of a niche or a mass marke is based on he ranking of wo variables: he monopoly price and he produc mean value.
More informationAppendix D Flexibility Factor/Margin of Choice Desktop Research
Appendix D Flexibiliy Facor/Margin of Choice Deskop Research Cheshire Eas Council Cheshire Eas Employmen Land Review Conens D1 Flexibiliy Facor/Margin of Choice Deskop Research 2 Final Ocober 2012 \\GLOBAL.ARUP.COM\EUROPE\MANCHESTER\JOBS\200000\22348900\4
More informationThe Real Business Cycle paradigm. The RBC model emphasizes supply (technology) disturbances as the main source of
Prof. Harris Dellas Advanced Macroeconomics Winer 2001/01 The Real Business Cycle paradigm The RBC model emphasizes supply (echnology) disurbances as he main source of macroeconomic flucuaions in a world
More informationA Brief Introduction to the Consumption Based Asset Pricing Model (CCAPM)
A Brief Inroducion o he Consumpion Based Asse Pricing Model (CCAPM We have seen ha CAPM idenifies he risk of any securiy as he covariance beween he securiy's rae of reurn and he rae of reurn on he marke
More informationMathematics in Pharmacokinetics What and Why (A second attempt to make it clearer)
Mahemaics in Pharmacokineics Wha and Why (A second aemp o make i clearer) We have used equaions for concenraion () as a funcion of ime (). We will coninue o use hese equaions since he plasma concenraions
More informationHouse Price Index (HPI)
House Price Index (HPI) The price index of second hand houses in Colombia (HPI), regisers annually and quarerly he evoluion of prices of his ype of dwelling. The calculaion is based on he repeaed sales
More informationChapter 7. Response of FirstOrder RL and RC Circuits
Chaper 7. esponse of FirsOrder L and C Circuis 7.1. The Naural esponse of an L Circui 7.2. The Naural esponse of an C Circui 7.3. The ep esponse of L and C Circuis 7.4. A General oluion for ep and Naural
More informationDistributing Human Resources among Software Development Projects 1
Disribuing Human Resources among Sofware Developmen Proecs Macario Polo, María Dolores Maeos, Mario Piaini and rancisco Ruiz Summary This paper presens a mehod for esimaing he disribuion of human resources
More informationChabot College Physics Lab RC Circuits Scott Hildreth
Chabo College Physics Lab Circuis Sco Hildreh Goals: Coninue o advance your undersanding of circuis, measuring resisances, currens, and volages across muliple componens. Exend your skills in making breadboard
More informationSinglemachine Scheduling with Periodic Maintenance and both Preemptive and. Nonpreemptive jobs in Remanufacturing System 1
Absrac number: 050407 Singlemachine Scheduling wih Periodic Mainenance and boh Preempive and Nonpreempive jobs in Remanufacuring Sysem Liu Biyu hen Weida (School of Economics and Managemen Souheas Universiy
More informationPrice elasticity of demand for crude oil: estimates for 23 countries
Price elasiciy of demand for crude oil: esimaes for 23 counries John C.B. Cooper Absrac This paper uses a muliple regression model derived from an adapaion of Nerlove s parial adjusmen model o esimae boh
More informationThe Application of Multi Shifts and Break Windows in Employees Scheduling
The Applicaion of Muli Shifs and Brea Windows in Employees Scheduling Evy Herowai Indusrial Engineering Deparmen, Universiy of Surabaya, Indonesia Absrac. One mehod for increasing company s performance
More informationRandom Walk in 1D. 3 possible paths x vs n. 5 For our random walk, we assume the probabilities p,q do not depend on time (n)  stationary
Random Walk in D Random walks appear in many cones: diffusion is a random walk process undersanding buffering, waiing imes, queuing more generally he heory of sochasic processes gambling choosing he bes
More informationHedging with Forwards and Futures
Hedging wih orwards and uures Hedging in mos cases is sraighforward. You plan o buy 10,000 barrels of oil in six monhs and you wish o eliminae he price risk. If you ake he buyside of a forward/fuures
More informationVector Autoregressions (VARs): Operational Perspectives
Vecor Auoregressions (VARs): Operaional Perspecives Primary Source: Sock, James H., and Mark W. Wason, Vecor Auoregressions, Journal of Economic Perspecives, Vol. 15 No. 4 (Fall 2001), 101115. Macroeconomericians
More informationUSE OF EDUCATION TECHNOLOGY IN ENGLISH CLASSES
USE OF EDUCATION TECHNOLOGY IN ENGLISH CLASSES Mehme Nuri GÖMLEKSİZ Absrac Using educaion echnology in classes helps eachers realize a beer and more effecive learning. In his sudy 150 English eachers were
More informationInformation Theoretic Evaluation of Change Prediction Models for LargeScale Software
Informaion Theoreic Evaluaion of Change Predicion Models for LargeScale Sofware Mina Askari School of Compuer Science Universiy of Waerloo Waerloo, Canada maskari@uwaerloo.ca Ric Hol School of Compuer
More informationWorking Paper No. 482. Net Intergenerational Transfers from an Increase in Social Security Benefits
Working Paper No. 482 Ne Inergeneraional Transfers from an Increase in Social Securiy Benefis By Li Gan Texas A&M and NBER Guan Gong Shanghai Universiy of Finance and Economics Michael Hurd RAND Corporaion
More informationThe Transport Equation
The Transpor Equaion Consider a fluid, flowing wih velociy, V, in a hin sraigh ube whose cross secion will be denoed by A. Suppose he fluid conains a conaminan whose concenraion a posiion a ime will be
More informationAn empirical analysis about forecasting Tmall airconditioning sales using time series model Yan Xia
An empirical analysis abou forecasing Tmall aircondiioning sales using ime series model Yan Xia Deparmen of Mahemaics, Ocean Universiy of China, China Absrac Time series model is a hospo in he research
More informationRelative velocity in one dimension
Connexions module: m13618 1 Relaive velociy in one dimension Sunil Kumar Singh This work is produced by The Connexions Projec and licensed under he Creaive Commons Aribuion License Absrac All quaniies
More informationINTRODUCTION TO FORECASTING
INTRODUCTION TO FORECASTING INTRODUCTION: Wha is a forecas? Why do managers need o forecas? A forecas is an esimae of uncerain fuure evens (lierally, o "cas forward" by exrapolaing from pas and curren
More informationTEACHER NOTES HIGH SCHOOL SCIENCE NSPIRED
Radioacive Daing Science Objecives Sudens will discover ha radioacive isoopes decay exponenially. Sudens will discover ha each radioacive isoope has a specific halflife. Sudens will develop mahemaical
More informationChapter 6: Business Valuation (Income Approach)
Chaper 6: Business Valuaion (Income Approach) Cash flow deerminaion is one of he mos criical elemens o a business valuaion. Everyhing may be secondary. If cash flow is high, hen he value is high; if he
More information11/6/2013. Chapter 14: Dynamic ADAS. Introduction. Introduction. Keeping track of time. The model s elements
Inroducion Chaper 14: Dynamic DS dynamic model of aggregae and aggregae supply gives us more insigh ino how he economy works in he shor run. I is a simplified version of a DSGE model, used in cuingedge
More informationSPECIAL REPORT May 4, Shifting Drivers of Inflation Canada versus the U.S.
Paul Ferley Assisan Chief Economis 4169747231 paul.ferley@rbc.com Nahan Janzen Economis 4169740579 nahan.janzen@rbc.com SPECIAL REPORT May 4, 2010 Shifing Drivers of Inflaion Canada versus he U.S.
More informationDETERMINISTIC INVENTORY MODEL FOR ITEMS WITH TIME VARYING DEMAND, WEIBULL DISTRIBUTION DETERIORATION AND SHORTAGES KUNSHAN WU
Yugoslav Journal of Operaions Research 2 (22), Number, 67 DEERMINISIC INVENORY MODEL FOR IEMS WIH IME VARYING DEMAND, WEIBULL DISRIBUION DEERIORAION AND SHORAGES KUNSHAN WU Deparmen of Bussines Adminisraion
More informationReporting to Management
CHAPTER 31 Reporing o Managemen Inroducion The success or oherwise of any business underaking depends primarily on earning revenue ha would generae sufficien resources for sound growh. To achieve his objecive,
More informationYTM is positively related to default risk. YTM is positively related to liquidity risk. YTM is negatively related to special tax treatment.
. Two quesions for oday. A. Why do bonds wih he same ime o mauriy have differen YTM s? B. Why do bonds wih differen imes o mauriy have differen YTM s? 2. To answer he firs quesion les look a he risk srucure
More informationUsefulness of the Forward Curve in Forecasting Oil Prices
Usefulness of he Forward Curve in Forecasing Oil Prices Akira Yanagisawa Leader Energy Demand, Supply and Forecas Analysis Group The Energy Daa and Modelling Cener Summary When people analyse oil prices,
More information23.3. Even and Odd Functions. Introduction. Prerequisites. Learning Outcomes
Even and Odd Funcions 23.3 Inroducion In his Secion we examine how o obain Fourier series of periodic funcions which are eiher even or odd. We show ha he Fourier series for such funcions is considerabl
More informationINTEREST RATE FUTURES AND THEIR OPTIONS: SOME PRICING APPROACHES
INTEREST RATE FUTURES AND THEIR OPTIONS: SOME PRICING APPROACHES OPENGAMMA QUANTITATIVE RESEARCH Absrac. Exchangeraded ineres rae fuures and heir opions are described. The fuure opions include hose paying
More informationPresent Value Methodology
Presen Value Mehodology Econ 422 Invesmen, Capial & Finance Universiy of Washingon Eric Zivo Las updaed: April 11, 2010 Presen Value Concep Wealh in Fisher Model: W = Y 0 + Y 1 /(1+r) The consumer/producer
More informationA Robust Exponentially Weighted Moving Average Control Chart for the Process Mean
Journal of Modern Applied Saisical Mehods Volume 5 Issue Aricle 005 A Robus Exponenially Weighed Moving Average Conrol Char for he Process Mean Michael B. C. Khoo Universii Sains, Malaysia, mkbc@usm.my
More informationEntropy: From the Boltzmann equation to the Maxwell Boltzmann distribution
Enropy: From he Bolzmann equaion o he Maxwell Bolzmann disribuion A formula o relae enropy o probabiliy Ofen i is a lo more useful o hink abou enropy in erms of he probabiliy wih which differen saes are
More informationEconomics 140A Hypothesis Testing in Regression Models
Economics 140A Hypohesis Tesing in Regression Models While i is algebraically simple o work wih a populaion model wih a single varying regressor, mos populaion models have muliple varying regressors 1
More informationRepresenting Periodic Functions by Fourier Series. (a n cos nt + b n sin nt) n=1
Represening Periodic Funcions by Fourier Series 3. Inroducion In his Secion we show how a periodic funcion can be expressed as a series of sines and cosines. We begin by obaining some sandard inegrals
More informationMath 201 Lecture 12: CauchyEuler Equations
Mah 20 Lecure 2: CauchyEuler Equaions Feb., 202 Many examples here are aken from he exbook. The firs number in () refers o he problem number in he UA Cusom ediion, he second number in () refers o he problem
More informationcooking trajectory boiling water B (t) microwave 0 2 4 6 8 101214161820 time t (mins)
Alligaor egg wih calculus We have a large alligaor egg jus ou of he fridge (1 ) which we need o hea o 9. Now here are wo accepable mehods for heaing alligaor eggs, one is o immerse hem in boiling waer
More informationMarket Liquidity and the Impacts of the Computerized Trading System: Evidence from the Stock Exchange of Thailand
36 Invesmen Managemen and Financial Innovaions, 4/4 Marke Liquidiy and he Impacs of he Compuerized Trading Sysem: Evidence from he Sock Exchange of Thailand Sorasar Sukcharoensin 1, Pariyada Srisopisawa,
More informationOptimal Stock Selling/Buying Strategy with reference to the Ultimate Average
Opimal Sock Selling/Buying Sraegy wih reference o he Ulimae Average Min Dai Dep of Mah, Naional Universiy of Singapore, Singapore Yifei Zhong Dep of Mah, Naional Universiy of Singapore, Singapore July
More informationRealtime Particle Filters
Realime Paricle Filers Cody Kwok Dieer Fox Marina Meilă Dep. of Compuer Science & Engineering, Dep. of Saisics Universiy of Washingon Seale, WA 9895 ckwok,fox @cs.washingon.edu, mmp@sa.washingon.edu Absrac
More informationDEMAND FORECASTING MODELS
DEMAND FORECASTING MODELS Conens E2. ELECTRIC BILLED SALES AND CUSTOMER COUNTS Sysemlevel Model Counylevel Model Easside King Counylevel Model E6. ELECTRIC PEAK HOUR LOAD FORECASTING Sysemlevel Forecas
More informationANALYSIS FOR FINDING AN EFFICIENT SALES FORECASTING METHOD IN THE PROCESS OF PRODUCTION PLANNING, OPERATION AND OTHER AREAS OF DECISION MAKING
Inernaional Journal of Mechanical and Producion Engineering Research and Developmen (IJMPERD ) Vol.1, Issue 2 Dec 2011 136 TJPRC Pv. Ld., ANALYSIS FOR FINDING AN EFFICIENT SALES FORECASTING METHOD IN
More informationCan Individual Investors Use Technical Trading Rules to Beat the Asian Markets?
Can Individual Invesors Use Technical Trading Rules o Bea he Asian Markes? INTRODUCTION In radiional ess of he weakform of he Efficien Markes Hypohesis, price reurn differences are found o be insufficien
More informationUNDERSTANDING THE DEATH BENEFIT SWITCH OPTION IN UNIVERSAL LIFE POLICIES. Nadine Gatzert
UNDERSTANDING THE DEATH BENEFIT SWITCH OPTION IN UNIVERSAL LIFE POLICIES Nadine Gazer Conac (has changed since iniial submission): Chair for Insurance Managemen Universiy of ErlangenNuremberg Lange Gasse
More informationWhy Did the Demand for Cash Decrease Recently in Korea?
Why Did he Demand for Cash Decrease Recenly in Korea? Byoung Hark Yoo Bank of Korea 26. 5 Absrac We explores why cash demand have decreased recenly in Korea. The raio of cash o consumpion fell o 4.7% in
More informationPart 1: White Noise and Moving Average Models
Chaper 3: Forecasing From Time Series Models Par 1: Whie Noise and Moving Average Models Saionariy In his chaper, we sudy models for saionary ime series. A ime series is saionary if is underlying saisical
More informationPATHWISE PROPERTIES AND PERFORMANCE BOUNDS FOR A PERISHABLE INVENTORY SYSTEM
PATHWISE PROPERTIES AND PERFORMANCE BOUNDS FOR A PERISHABLE INVENTORY SYSTEM WILLIAM L. COOPER Deparmen of Mechanical Engineering, Universiy of Minnesoa, 111 Church Sree S.E., Minneapolis, MN 55455 billcoop@me.umn.edu
More informationRisk Modelling of Collateralised Lending
Risk Modelling of Collaeralised Lending Dae: 4112008 Number: 8/18 Inroducion This noe explains how i is possible o handle collaeralised lending wihin Risk Conroller. The approach draws on he faciliies
More informationTHE FIRM'S INVESTMENT DECISION UNDER CERTAINTY: CAPITAL BUDGETING AND RANKING OF NEW INVESTMENT PROJECTS
VII. THE FIRM'S INVESTMENT DECISION UNDER CERTAINTY: CAPITAL BUDGETING AND RANKING OF NEW INVESTMENT PROJECTS The mos imporan decisions for a firm's managemen are is invesmen decisions. While i is surely
More informationComplex Fourier Series. Adding these identities, and then dividing by 2, or subtracting them, and then dividing by 2i, will show that
Mah 344 May 4, Complex Fourier Series Par I: Inroducion The Fourier series represenaion for a funcion f of period P, f) = a + a k coskω) + b k sinkω), ω = π/p, ) can be expressed more simply using complex
More informationSetting Accuracy Targets for. ShortTerm Judgemental Sales Forecasting
Seing Accuracy Targes for ShorTerm Judgemenal Sales Forecasing Derek W. Bunn London Business School Sussex Place, Regen s Park London NW1 4SA, UK Tel: +44 (0)171 262 5050 Fax: +44(0)171 724 7875 Email:
More informationStochastic Optimal Control Problem for Life Insurance
Sochasic Opimal Conrol Problem for Life Insurance s. Basukh 1, D. Nyamsuren 2 1 Deparmen of Economics and Economerics, Insiue of Finance and Economics, Ulaanbaaar, Mongolia 2 School of Mahemaics, Mongolian
More information23.3. Even and Odd Functions. Introduction. Prerequisites. Learning Outcomes
Even and Odd Funcions 3.3 Inroducion In his Secion we examine how o obain Fourier series of periodic funcions which are eiher even or odd. We show ha he Fourier series for such funcions is considerabl
More informationChapter 4: Exponential and Logarithmic Functions
Chaper 4: Eponenial and Logarihmic Funcions Secion 4.1 Eponenial Funcions... 15 Secion 4. Graphs of Eponenial Funcions... 3 Secion 4.3 Logarihmic Funcions... 4 Secion 4.4 Logarihmic Properies... 53 Secion
More informationThe Greek financial crisis: growing imbalances and sovereign spreads. Heather D. Gibson, Stephan G. Hall and George S. Tavlas
The Greek financial crisis: growing imbalances and sovereign spreads Heaher D. Gibson, Sephan G. Hall and George S. Tavlas The enry The enry of Greece ino he Eurozone in 2001 produced a dividend in he
More informationSegmentation, Probability of Default and Basel II Capital Measures. for Credit Card Portfolios
Segmenaion, Probabiliy of Defaul and Basel II Capial Measures for Credi Card Porfolios Draf: Aug 3, 2007 *Work compleed while a Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia Dennis Ash Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia
More informationA Reexamination of the Joint Mortality Functions
Norh merican cuarial Journal Volume 6, Number 1, p.166170 (2002) Reeaminaion of he Join Morali Funcions bsrac. Heekung Youn, rkad Shemakin, Edwin Herman Universi of S. Thomas, Sain Paul, MN, US Morali
More informationTime Series Analysis Using SAS R Part I The Augmented DickeyFuller (ADF) Test
ABSTRACT Time Series Analysis Using SAS R Par I The Augmened DickeyFuller (ADF) Tes By Ismail E. Mohamed The purpose of his series of aricles is o discuss SAS programming echniques specifically designed
More informationINVESTIGATION OF THE INFLUENCE OF UNEMPLOYMENT ON ECONOMIC INDICATORS
INVESTIGATION OF THE INFLUENCE OF UNEMPLOYMENT ON ECONOMIC INDICATORS Ilona Tregub, Olga Filina, Irina Kondakova Financial Universiy under he Governmen of he Russian Federaion 1. Phillips curve In economics,
More informationThe Grantor Retained Annuity Trust (GRAT)
WEALTH ADVISORY Esae Planning Sraegies for closelyheld, family businesses The Granor Reained Annuiy Trus (GRAT) An efficien wealh ransfer sraegy, paricularly in a low ineres rae environmen Family business
More informationOn the degrees of irreducible factors of higher order Bernoulli polynomials
ACTA ARITHMETICA LXII.4 (1992 On he degrees of irreducible facors of higher order Bernoulli polynomials by Arnold Adelberg (Grinnell, Ia. 1. Inroducion. In his paper, we generalize he curren resuls on
More informationII.1. Debt reduction and fiscal multipliers. dbt da dpbal da dg. bal
Quarerly Repor on he Euro Area 3/202 II.. Deb reducion and fiscal mulipliers The deerioraion of public finances in he firs years of he crisis has led mos Member Saes o adop sizeable consolidaion packages.
More informationAP Calculus BC 2010 Scoring Guidelines
AP Calculus BC Scoring Guidelines The College Board The College Board is a noforprofi membership associaion whose mission is o connec sudens o college success and opporuniy. Founded in, he College Board
More informationCredit Index Options: the noarmageddon pricing measure and the role of correlation after the subprime crisis
Second Conference on The Mahemaics of Credi Risk, Princeon May 2324, 2008 Credi Index Opions: he noarmageddon pricing measure and he role of correlaion afer he subprime crisis Damiano Brigo  Join work
More informationSupplementary Appendix for Depression Babies: Do Macroeconomic Experiences Affect RiskTaking?
Supplemenary Appendix for Depression Babies: Do Macroeconomic Experiences Affec RiskTaking? Ulrike Malmendier UC Berkeley and NBER Sefan Nagel Sanford Universiy and NBER Sepember 2009 A. Deails on SCF
More informationDOES TRADING VOLUME INFLUENCE GARCH EFFECTS? SOME EVIDENCE FROM THE GREEK MARKET WITH SPECIAL REFERENCE TO BANKING SECTOR
Invesmen Managemen and Financial Innovaions, Volume 4, Issue 3, 7 33 DOES TRADING VOLUME INFLUENCE GARCH EFFECTS? SOME EVIDENCE FROM THE GREEK MARKET WITH SPECIAL REFERENCE TO BANKING SECTOR Ahanasios
More informationPRACTICES AND ISSUES IN OPERATIONAL RISK MODELING UNDER BASEL II
Lihuanian Mahemaical Journal, Vol. 51, No. 2, April, 2011, pp. 180 193 PRACTICES AND ISSUES IN OPERATIONAL RISK MODELING UNDER BASEL II Paul Embrechs and Marius Hofer 1 RiskLab, Deparmen of Mahemaics,
More informationWhy Do Real and Nominal. InventorySales Ratios Have Different Trends?
Why Do Real and Nominal InvenorySales Raios Have Differen Trends? By Valerie A. Ramey Professor of Economics Deparmen of Economics Universiy of California, San Diego and Research Associae Naional Bureau
More informationHotel Room Demand Forecasting via Observed Reservation Information
Proceedings of he Asia Pacific Indusrial Engineering & Managemen Sysems Conference 0 V. Kachivichyanuul, H.T. Luong, and R. Piaaso Eds. Hoel Room Demand Forecasing via Observed Reservaion Informaion aragain
More informationMTH6121 Introduction to Mathematical Finance Lesson 5
26 MTH6121 Inroducion o Mahemaical Finance Lesson 5 Conens 2.3 Brownian moion wih drif........................... 27 2.4 Geomeric Brownian moion........................... 28 2.5 Convergence of random
More informationModeling a distribution of mortgage credit losses Petr Gapko 1, Martin Šmíd 2
Modeling a disribuion of morgage credi losses Per Gapko 1, Marin Šmíd 2 1 Inroducion Absrac. One of he bigges risks arising from financial operaions is he risk of counerpary defaul, commonly known as a
More informationChapter 8 Student Lecture Notes 81
Chaper Suden Lecure Noes  Chaper Goals QM: Business Saisics Chaper Analyzing and Forecasing Series Daa Afer compleing his chaper, you should be able o: Idenify he componens presen in a ime series Develop
More informationRevisions to Nonfarm Payroll Employment: 1964 to 2011
Revisions o Nonfarm Payroll Employmen: 1964 o 2011 Tom Sark December 2011 Summary Over recen monhs, he Bureau of Labor Saisics (BLS) has revised upward is iniial esimaes of he monhly change in nonfarm
More informationForecasting Sales: A Model and Some Evidence from the Retail Industry. Russell Lundholm Sarah McVay Taylor Randall
Forecasing Sales: A odel and Some Evidence from he eail Indusry ussell Lundholm Sarah cvay aylor andall Why forecas financial saemens? Seems obvious, bu wo common criicisms: Who cares, can we can look
More information4.8 Exponential Growth and Decay; Newton s Law; Logistic Growth and Decay
324 CHAPTER 4 Exponenial and Logarihmic Funcions 4.8 Exponenial Growh and Decay; Newon s Law; Logisic Growh and Decay OBJECTIVES 1 Find Equaions of Populaions Tha Obey he Law of Uninhibied Growh 2 Find
More informationMachine Learning in Pairs Trading Strategies
Machine Learning in Pairs Trading Sraegies Yuxing Chen (Joseph) Deparmen of Saisics Sanford Universiy Email: osephc5@sanford.edu Weiluo Ren (David) Deparmen of Mahemaics Sanford Universiy Email: weiluo@sanford.edu
More informationPredicting Stock Market Index Trading Signals Using Neural Networks
Predicing Sock Marke Index Trading Using Neural Neworks C. D. Tilakarane, S. A. Morris, M. A. Mammadov, C. P. Hurs Cenre for Informaics and Applied Opimizaion School of Informaion Technology and Mahemaical
More information