Programme Environmental risk assessment of plant protection products at MS and EU level 26-29 September 2016 Orion, building nr 103 Campus Wageningen University & Research Wageningen, The Netherlands Version September 8 th Course leaders Wim Beltman Gertie Arts Jos Boesten
Course instructors P.I. (Paulien) Adriaanse MSc Dr G.H.P (Gertie) Arts W.H.J. (Wim) Beltman MSc Dr F. (Erik) van den Berg Dr J.J.T.I. (Jos) Boesten Dr T.C.M. (Theo) Brock Dr H.J. (Henk Jan) Holterman Dr. U. (Udo) Hommen M.M.S. (Mechteld) ter Horst MSc Wageningen Plant Research Fraunhofer Institute for Molecular Biology and Applied Ecology IME D.W.G. (Daniël) van Kraalingen MSc Dr I. (Ivo) Roessink Dr. N. (Nico) Tan Dr E.L. (Louise) Wipfler Board for the Authorisation of Plant Protection Products and Biocides (Ctgb) Programme coordination and management Hermance Bijl de Vroe Janine Quist MSc Wageningen Academy Wageningen Academy
Short overview course programme Monday, 26 September 19.50 Transport from Hotel Hof van Wageningen to Fletcher Hotel de Wageningsche Berg 20:00 22:00 Welcome drinks and get together Fletcher Hotel de Wageningsche Berg 22.00 Transport from Fletcher Hotel de Wageningsche Berg to Hotel Hof van Wageningen Tuesday, 27 September 2016: Day 1 8.30 Transport from Fletcher Hotel de Wageningsche Berg and Hotel Hof van Wageningen to Orion building, Wageningen Campus 9:00 11:30 Opening and introduction for exposure and effects 11.30 18:00 Parallel exposure and effects courses 18:00 Transport by bus of all participants to Kasteel Doorwerth Short guided tour followed by dinner 22.00 Transport by bus towards Hotel De Wageningsche Berg, Hotel Hof van Wageningen and optional Wageningen Campus Wednesday, 28 September 2016: Day 2 8.30 Transport from Fletcher Hotel de Wageningsche Berg and Hotel Hof van Wageningen to Orion building, Wageningen Campus 9.00 12:45 Parallel exposure and effects courses 13:15 Campus tour (optional) - walking 14:00-17:15 Parallel exposure and effects courses 17:15 Transport by bus to Sinderhoeve 17:45 Sinderhoeve experimental station: tour, drinks and snacks 19:30 Transport by bus to Hotel De Wageningsche Berg Buffet dinner 22.00 Transport by bus towards Hotel Hof van Wageningen and optional Wageningen Campus
Thursday, 29 September: Day 3 8.30 Transport from Fletcher Hotel de Wageningsche Berg and Hotel Hof van Wageningen to Orion building, Wageningen Campus 9:00 11:00 Parallel exposure and effects courses 11:15 12:30 Plenary exposure and effects closing session 12:30 13:00 Evaluation and closing 14:00 End of course
Programme Day 1, 27th of September 2016 PLENARY EXPOSURE AND EFFECTS SESSION FOR ALL PARTICIPANTS 9.15 11.30 Orion room C3033 Chairman: Wim Beltman 08:45 Registration and coffee 09:15 Welcome Wageningen University & Research Environmental Research Dr. Bram de Vos (managing director of the Environmental Sciences Group, Wageningen University & Research) 09.25 Organisational Wim Beltman and Janine Quist 09:30 Introductions of participants Wim Beltman 09:40 Role of effect assessment in risk assessment for organisms Theo Brock 10:10 Role of exposure assessment in risk assessment for organisms Jos Boesten 10:40 Break 10:55 Regulatory context in EU, Central zone and the Netherlands Nico Tan (Ctgb) 11.30 Splitting up PARALLEL MODULES ON EXPOSURE AND EFFECTS Module A: Exposure, room C4016 Module B: Effects, room C4042
Module A: Exposure of plant protection products in the environment Day 1, 27th of September 2016 Chairman: Jos Boesten 11.45-18.00 Orion: room C4016 11:45 Introduction/overview exposure course Jos Boesten Module B: Effects of plant protections products on aquatic ecosystems and linking exposure to effects Day 1, 27 th of September 2016 Chairman: Gertie Arts 11.45-18.00 Orion: room C4042 11:45 Introduction/overview effects course Gertie Arts # Soil leaching NL and EU # Tiered approach aquatic organisms 11:50 Introduction to PEARL for assessment of leaching to groundwater Jos Boesten 11:50 Principles of the tiered approach Theo Brock 12:30 Lunch (Orion building) 12:30 Lunch (Orion building) 13:30 Hands-on PEARL: Part 1: Effect of K om, DegT50 and N Part 2: Effect of adding aged-sorption Jos Boesten & Erik van den Berg 13:30 14:00 Current issues in insecticide risk assessment Theo Brock Current issues in herbicide risk assessment Gertie Arts 14.30 Break 14:30 Break 14:45 Guidance for degradation and sorption in soil: recent developments Jos Boesten 15:15 Hands-on PEARL: Part 1: Metabolites incl. formation fraction Part 2: Correcting Freundlich sorption parameters for degradation in batch experiments Erik van den Berg & Jos Boesten 14:45 Current issues in fungicide risk assessment Ivo Roessink 15:15 Hands-on Tier 1 and Tier 2 risk assessment Gertie Arts & Ivo Roessink
16.15 Break & Snack 16.15 Break & snack 16:30 GeoPEARL: basis (spatial schematisation), changes based on new map Erik van den Berg 17:15 Hands-on GeoPearl Erik van den Berg & Jos Boesten 17:45 Development of tool for central zone: EuroPEARL Erik van den Berg 16:30 Continuation hands-on until 17:30 Gertie Arts & Ivo Roessink 17:15 17:30 Plenary Hands-on Tier 1 and Tier 2 risk assessment Gertie Arts & Ivo Roessink 18:00 End of day 1 : transport of all participants to Kasteel Doorwerth for short guided tour followed by dinner 22.00 Transport by bus towards Hotel De Wageningsche Berg, Hotel Hof van Wageningen and optional Wageningen Campus
PARALLEL MODULES ON EXPOSURE AND EFFECTS Module A: Exposure of plant protection products in the environment Day 2, 28 th of September 2016 Chairman Jos Boesten Start 9:00 Orion: room C4015 9:00 Report back hands-on GeoPearl Erik van den Berg & Jos Boesten Module B: Effects of plant protections products on aquatic ecosystems and linking exposure to effects Day 2, 28 th of September 2016 Chairman Gertie Arts Start 9:00 Orion: room C4016 # Higher tier micro/mesocosm studies # Exposure aquatic organisms 9:00 Current practice in microcosm and mesocosm studies in ecological risk assessment: problems and approaches Ivo Roessink 9:30 TOXSWA and modelling formation of metabolites in water and in sediment Paulien Adriaanse and Wim Beltman 9:45 Statistical analysis of microcosm and mesocosm studies (a.o. MDD s): problems and approaches Udo Hommen (Frauenhofer Institute) 10:15 Break 10:30 Break 10.30 Managing substance properties using SPIN Daniel van Kraalingen 11:00 Ecological recovery option in micro- and mesocosm tests: problems and approaches Ivo Roessink 10:50 Hands-on TOXSWA and metabolites Wim Beltman & Paulien Adriaanse 11:50 Outlook developments TOXSWA Wim Beltman 11:45 Hands-on microcosm and mesocosm studies: Case study with MDD s Udo Hommen (Frauenhofer Institute), Ivo Roessink & Gertie Arts 12:00 Guidance for estimating degradation rates in cosm water Paulien Adriaanse
12:45 Lunch (Orion building) 12:45 Lunch (Orion building) 13.15 Campus tour (optional) 13.15 Campus tour (optional) 14:00 Hands-on: metabolites and DegT50 water Wim Beltman & Paulien Adriaanse 14:00 Continuation hands-on microcosm and mesocosm studies: Case with MDD s Udo Hommen (Frauenhofer Institute), Ivo Roessink & Gertie Arts 14:45 Dutch exposure scenario for sideways and upward spraying: surface water aspects Louise Wipfler 15:30 Break 15:30 Break 15:45 Dutch exposure scenario for sideways and upward spraying: spray drift Henk Jan Holterman 16.30 Greenhouse Emission Model: overview, demo a latest developments Louise Wipfler 15:45 Plenary case study hands-on microcosm and mesocosm studies Udo Hommen, Ivo Roessink & Gertie Arts 16.30 Future development in ecological risk assessment; modelling approaches Udo Hommen Programme until 17:15 h Programme until 17:15 h 17.15: bus to Sinderhoeve 17:45 Sinderhoeve experimental station: tour Drinks and snacks 19:30 bus to Hotel De Wageningse Berg: buffet dinner 22.00 Transport by bus towards Hotel Hof van Wageningen
PARALLEL MODULES ON EXPOSURE AND EFFECTS Module A: Exposure of plant protection products in the environment Day 3, 29 th of September 2016 Chairman Jos Boesten 9:00-10.30 Orion: room C4015 Module B: Effects of plant protections products on aquatic ecosystems and linking exposure to effects Day 3, 29 th of September 2016 Chairman Gertie Arts 9:00-10.30 Orion: room C4016 # Miscellaneous # Effects 9:00 9.45 Contributions of Wageningen Environmental Research to environmental risk assessment of PPP in China, Ethiopia and Myanmar Mechteld ter Horst 9:00 Outlook effects: panel discussion - Wrap-up of the two days 10.30 Break 10:30 Break 10.45 Coming together for plenary end session 10.45 Coming together for plenary end session PLENARY EXPOSURE AND EFFECTS CLOSING SESSION FOR ALL PARTICIPANTS Orion Room C3033
PLENARY EXPOSURE AND EFFECTS CLOSING SESSION FOR ALL PARTICIPANTS Chairman Wim Beltman 11.00 13.00 Orion: room C3033 11:00 Development of environmental scenarios 11.15 Examples of poor coherence between Specific Protection Goals and EAGs (Environmental Assessment Goals) Theo Brock & Jos Boesten 11.35 Discussion on integration exposure and effects in risk assessment Theo Brock / Jos Boesten 12.30 Evaluation and closing 13:00 Lunch (Orion building) 14:00 End of the course