Sc i e n c e a n d t e a c h i n g:


 Susanna McDonald
 1 years ago
 Views:
Transcription
1 Dikuionpapierreihe Working Paper Serie Sc i e n c e a n d e a c h i n g: Tw o d i m e n i o n a l i g n a l l i n g in he academic job marke Andrea Schneider Nr./ No. 95 Augu 2009 Deparmen of Economic Fächergruppe Volkwirchaflehre
2 Auoren / Auhor Andrea Schneider Helmu Schmid Univeriä Hamburg / Helmu Schmid Univeriy Hamburg Iniu für Finanzwienchaf / Iniue of Public Finance Holenhofweg Hamburg Germany Redakion / Edior Helmu Schmid Univeriä Hamburg / Helmu Schmid Univeriy Hamburg Fächergruppe Volkwirchaflehre / Deparmen of Economic Eine elekroniche Verion de Dikuionpapier i auf folgender Inerneeie zu finden/ An elecronic verion of he paper may be downloaded from he homepage: hp://fgvwl.huhh.de/wpvwl Koordinaor / Coordinaor Kai Hielcher
3 Helmu Schmid Univeriä Hamburg / Helmu Schmid Univeriy Hamburg Fächergruppe Volkwirchaflehre / Deparmen of Economic Dikuionpapier Nr. 95 Working Paper No. 95 SCIENCE AND TEACHING: TWODIMENSIONAL SIGNALLING IN THE ACADEMIC JOB MARKET ANDREA SCHNEIDER Zuammenfaung / Abrac Podoc ignal heir abiliy o do cience and eaching o ge a enure giving univeriie he poibiliy of eparaing highly alened agen from he low alened one. However eparaing ha mean ignalling effor for he highly alened become even more imporan in a wodimenional ignalling cae. Thi arac noice o ime conrain. Under weak condiion eparaing equilibria do no exi if ime conrain are binding. The exiing equilibria are more coly bu wihou addiional informaion compared o he onedimenional cae. Conidering hi, he efficiency of he curren wodimenional academic job marke ignalling can be improved by wiching o a onedimenional one. JELKlaifikaion / JELClaificaion: I23, D82, J41 Schlagwore / Keyword: Mulidimenional ignalling, Academic job marke, Teaching and Reearch
4 1 Inroducion No laer han he 19h cenury he German know he concep of he uniy of reearch and eaching. Thi idea of Wilhelm von Humbold ha mainly influenced epecially he German higher educaion yem and i ill preen oday. On he oher hand podoc and profeor ofen rail again he double burden of uch a yem. Thee conflicing argumenaion in mind economi udy he opimal deign of he univeriy yem (e.g. Del Rey 2001, De Fraja and Valbonei 2008 or Gauier and Wauhy 2007) a well a heir opimal labour conrac behaviour (Walckier 2008). In line wih he econd par of lieraure he preen paper analye he poibiliy of eparaing highly producive agen from he lowproducive one in a model where podoc can ignal heir abiliy o do cience and eaching o ge a enure. Argumening in line wih a job marke inalling model i i neceary o menion he work of Michael Spence. Spence a he faher of ignalling model how educaion can be an efficien ignal o correc aymmeric informaion in he job marke. I due o him ha we know abou he exience of ignalling equilibria (Spence 1973; Spence 1974). 1 In conra o Spence who mainly deal wih he exience of equilibria Cho and Krep (1987) rank equilibria. They implemen an inuive crierion o eliminae equilibria ha are buil on unplauible ouofequilibrium belief. Thi ronger equilibrium concep i finally he baic equilibrium concep of he preen paper. Up o here all concep work in a onedimenional world. Thu, agen end a onedimenional ignal. Since fuure profeor produce a wodimenional oupu coniing of cience and eaching a mulidimenional e up i needed. Unforunaely, paper on mulidimenional ignalling are rare. One of he fir i by Roche and Quinzii (1985). Thi paper analye in a formal way he difference beween he one and mulidimenional ignalling e up. Auming a eparable co rucure hey give neceary condiion for he exience of a eparaing equilbrium. In he ame kind of model Enger (1987) focue on pareodominan eparaing equilibria. Armrong and Roche (1999) implify condiion ha are neceary o enure a eparaing equilibrium by auming a dicree ype diribuion. Thi alo i an aumpion of my model. A curren paper by Kim (2007) i of inere a well becaue i analye ime binding conrain in a wodimenional job marke ignalling 1 While Spence fir paper focue on he general exience of ignalling equilibria he econd paper highligh he differen marke form. 2
5 model. The aim of hi paper i o analye eparaing equilibria in a wodimenional ignalling model ha decribe he academic job marke. Podoc ha differ in heir abiliy o do reearch and eaching can ignal boh alen o ge a enure. A one reul eparaing equilibria of he wodimenional cae can vanih wih ime binding conrain. Thi alway happen if eaching (cience) produciviy of he highly alened i higher han he cience (eaching) produciviy of he lowalened. Neverhele, implying he concep of parial eparaing equilibria i can be hown ha under weak condiion here i a lea one parial eparaing equilibrium. More preciely, agen ha are highly producive in boh oupu end he ame ignal like he ype ha i highalened wih repec o he oupu ha i more prefered by he univeriie. Wha i mporan for policiy implicaion i ha he ignalling effor in he parial eparaing equilibrium  alhough i i maller han in he wodimenional eparaing equilibrium  i higher han in he onedimenional eparaing equilibrium. Thi i of inere if ignalling only ha an effec on co bu no on produciviy a i i he cae in Spence (1973) and alo in he preen model. Thu, if ime conrain are binding in he academic job marke i could be more efficien o le podoc only ignal on he oupu ha i more prefered by he univeriie. Under ime binding conrain univeriie can only diinguih highly producive from lowproducive ype in one dimenion ju like in he onedimenional cae. Having hi in mind here i no argumen for he wodimenional ignalling proce ha i currenly oberved in realiy. I ju implie addiional co. Only weak condiion concerning he ranking of he produciviy parameer are neceary o make a eparaing equilibrium under ime binding conrain impoible in he wodimenional cae. Thu, agen ha are highlyalened in boh oupu can no be idenified by univeriie. The remaining paper i rucured a follow: Secion 2 e he baic model. The exience of equilibria i analyed in ecion 3. While ecion 3.1 focue on he onedimenional cae ha goe in line wih Spence (1973) ecion 3.2 exend he analyi o he wodimenional cae. In hi par I alo diinguih beween a iuaion where ime conrain are no binding reuling in he unique eparaing equilibrium i mo efficien for he univeriie and a iuaion where ime conrain are binding which may lead o he vanihing of he eparaing equilibrium. In he econd cae he exience of parial eparaing equilibria where ome ype of agen can be eparaed while oher play he ame ragey i analyed. Secion 4 conclude. 3
6 2 The model Aume a compeiive academic job marke wih a uni ma of academic. Each univeriy graduae produce cience and eaching which require pecific unobervable abiliie. 2 Scieni a well a oher labourer are no idenical bu vary in heir abiliie. There are four ype ij {HH, HL, LH, LL} of fuure profeor. 3 While i denoe reearch produciviy j decribe he eaching produciviy. Boh produciviie can be high (H) or low (L). Fuure profeor can ignal boh abiliie: Science ij and eaching ij, i, j {L, H}. A in Spence (1973) ignal do no have any influence on produciviy. Agen ue he ignal o influence he univeriie belief on heir abiliie. Thu, he preenure reearch and eaching oupu funcion a a ignal for poenure produciviie. However, here i a ime binding conrain ij + ij = l. Signalling effor can no be higher han he available ime and herefore i limied. I aume he agen ij co funcion depending on hi ype i: c ij ( ij, ij ) = ij θ i + ij, (1) θj where θi and θj, i, j{l, H}, are he produciviie of cience and eaching repecively. Clearly, k > θk L, k {, } hold. For impliciy I alo aume k 1, k {, }. Implicily I aume ha he reearch (eaching) produciviy i independen of he abiliy o each (reearch). The fracion of ype ij agen in he populaion i denoed by α ij. The diribuion of he ype i common knowledge. Univeriie compee on propecive profeor. However, hey face aymmeric informaion and can only form belief on he agen abiliie via ignal. The profi of a univeriy i π((θ i, θ j ), w) = θi + θj w, where w i he wage paid o he agen. The compeiion of he academic job marke implie ha univeriie make a profi of zero and herefore wage are given by produciviie. Thu, he equilibrium wage offered by he univeriie i w where E i he expecaion operaor. w E[α ij (θ i + θ j)] (2) 2 In he remaining paper reearch, cience and publihing are ynonymouly ued. 3 Thi noaion follow Walckier (2008). 4
7 Alhough preenure publihing and eaching do no influence he produciviy univeriie can condiion wage offer on he preenure cience and eaching oupu. The opimal deciion of a propecive profeor of ype ij i max U ij = E[w ij ( ij ij, ij θi + ij )]. (3) θj ubjec o ij + ij l. In ecion 3 I will analye equilibria of hi ignalling model. 3 Signalling in he academic job marke Fir I focu on ignalling equilibria when univeriie are only inereed in cience (ecion 3.1). Thi analyi goe in line wih he ignalling model of Spence (1973). Aferward in ecion 3.2 I analye a wodimenional ignalling model where agen ignal on cience and eaching. In boh cae he main queion i if here are eparaing equilibria where ignalling can help o olve inefficien reul caued by aymmeric informaion. Therefore, pooling equilibria are only analyed in he margin. Under incomplee informaion here i need for a definiion of a perfec Bayeian equilibrium. Definiion 1 Perfec Bayeian Equilibrium (PBE): A PBE i a e ha coni of a ignal ( ij, ij ) for each ype of agen ij {HH, HL, LH, LL} and a wage offer w ij ( ij, ij) ued by he univeriie. For each ignal ( ij, ij) he univeriie make zero profi given he belief µ(ij ( ij, ij )) abou which ype could have en ( ij, ij ). Each ype ij maximie hi uiliy by chooing ( ij, ij) given he wage offer w ij of he univeriy. The univeriy belief mu be conien wih Baye rule and wih he agen raegy: µ(ij ( ij, ij )) = α ij P ij α ij Therefore, one can diinguih beween a eparaing equlibrium and a pooling equilibrium. In he fir cae all ype end differen ignal, i.e. ( ij, ij) ( i j, i,j ) if ij i j. In he econd cae he ignal i idenical for 5.
8 all ype, i.e. ( ij, ij), i, j {H, L}. In conra o a model e up wih wo differen ype of agen ha i normally ued, in he preen model here i alo he poibiliy for an equilibrium in which ome bu no all agen end he ame ignal. Such a perfec Bayeian equilibrium will be called a parial eparaing equilibrium. 3.1 Onedimenional ignalling Le u aume for he momen univeriie are only inereed in cience and no in eaching. In hi cae here i no value of eaching and herefore no agen end a eaching ignal. Thu, ype HH and HL can be inerpreed a one ype denoed by H. The ame apllie o LH and LL. Thi low produciviy ype i denoed by L. 4 Then he fracion of he high produciviy ype i α H α HH + α HL and he fracion of agen wih low produciviy i α L α LH + α LL. Under complee informaion he high produciviy ype would earn a wage of while he ype wih low produciviy ge θ L < θ H. Since preenure publihing only implie a co effec bu no effec on produciviy boh ype do no publih anyhing under complee informaion. Under incomplee informaion one can diinguih beween a pooling and a eparaing euilibrium. However, he parial eparaing equilibrium i irrelevan in he cae of wo differen ype of agen. Propoiion 1 Given a wo ype ignalling game where fuure profeor can have high or low produciviy of publihing ( or θ L ) and he univeriie wage offer w() depending on he reearch ignal here i he unique eparaing equilibrium H = θ L(θ H θ L), L = 0 w( H) = θ H, w( L) = θ L µ(h H) = 1, µ(l < H) = 1. 4 Clearly, in hi wo ype cae he co and wage rucure aifie he well known SpenceMirrlee ingle croing propery condiion, i.e. he woype w i indifference curve wih i {H, L} have only one poin of inerecion. 6
9 The deailed proof of propoiion 1 can be found in appendix A page 17. The moivaion of he reul i a follow: In a epearing equilibrium here i no incenive for he ype wih low produciviy o inve in publihing becaue hi ha ju a co effec bu no impac on produciviy. Therefore, an agen wih high produciviy mu publih exacly he amoun ha enure ype L doe no mimic him. However, i i poible ha he ime conrain i binding, i.e. H > l. Then he agen wih he high produciviy can no publih enough o preven mimicing of he lowproducive ype. In addiion here i alo a unique pooling equilibrium where nobody ignal. 5 Thi i a andard reul whenever ignal do no have an effec on produciviy. In hi cae nobody ha an incenive o inve in ignaling playing = 0. Noe, if he ime conrain i binding, only he pooling equilibrium peri. However, hi paper focue on efficien eparaing equilibria. Of coure, all reul peri if univeriie are olely inereed in eaching. In hi cae ju replace by in he previou analyi and redefine α H α HH + α LH and α L α HL + α LL repecively. 3.2 Twodimenional ignalling A higher load of eaching (and alo adminiraive work) reduce publicaion oupu ince ime o do reearch can no be ued o each (Michell and Rebne 1995). Alhough eaching can enhance reearch (Becker and Kennedy 2005) here i no general evidence ha good reearcher are alo good eacher. In conra economi prefer doing reeach o eaching (Allgood and Walad 2005). Since reul of he inerdependency of cience and eaching i unclear I do no make any addiional aumpion on he diribuion of he four ype of agen. 6 Neverhele noe, if boh alen are ubiue (complemen) α HL and α LH are high (mal) while α HH and α LL are mall (high). 7 5 For he explici noaion of he pooling PBE and for he proof of i exience ee appendix A page Alhough here i no clear evidence ha reearch and eaching are complemen on he individual perpecive level boh ac complemenary on he univeriy level. For a meaanalyi on hi opic ee Haie and Marh (1996). 7 Golieb and Keih (1997) find in heir udy ha he connecion beween reearch and eaching i no ju ubiuive or complemenary bu more complex. In deail hey how ha reearch can poiively affec reearch bu aribue of eaching negaively impac 7
10 In ubecion 3.1 we have already een ha he ime conrain can have an imporan influence on he exience of PBE. In he onedimenional cae ime conrain can lead o a iuaion where only he pooling equilibrium exi. Now, under wodimenional ignalling I how ha he eparaing equilibrium i even more likely deroyed by ime conrain. However, wih wo dimenion here i he poibiliy of parial eparaing equilibria. Fir, I analye he eparaing equilbrium in he wodimenional cae. Then I how ha under ome condiion (more preciely, if aumpion 1 hold) ime conrain make a eparaing equilibrium impoible. Neverhele, if agen end a wodimenional ignal here i alway a lea one parial eparaing equilibrium. In hi equilibrium ype HH end he ame ignal like he ype ha i highly alened wih repec o he oupu ha i more prefered by he univeriie. Time conrain no binding Propoiion 2 If agen ignal cience and eaching abiliy via ( ij, ij ), univeriie offer wage w( ij, ij ) and he ime conrain i no binding, i.e. ij + ij l, here i a eparaing equilibrium ij = { θ L (θ H θ L ), i = H 0, i = L and ij = { θ L (θ H θ L ), w( ij, ij) = θ i + θ j, i, j {H, L} j = H 0, j = L µ(i, j = H k ij θ k L(θ k H θ k L)) = 1 and µ(i, j = L k ij < θ k L(θ k H θ k L)) = 1 where k {, }. The deailed proof of propoiion 2 i given in appendix B page 19. The baic idea i o derive condiion under which ype ij ha no incenive o mimic ype i j for all i, i, j, j {H, L}. Alhough hee condiion are fulfiled by a coninuum of ignal combinaion ( ij, ij ) here i only a unique ignal for each ype ha maximie uiliy. Caued by addiive lineariy of co and produciviie he ignal in he wodimenional PBE equal in each of he wo componen he ignal ariing in he onedimenional cae. To illurae he deciion figure 1 how he incenive compaibiliy conrain of he reearch. 8
11 differen ype of agen. 8 (a) HL (b) LH LH 2 1 HL HL HL LH LH (c) HH HH HH HH Figure 1: (a) Incenive compaibiliy conrain ha preven ype HL from mimicing LL and vice vera, (b) Incenive compaibiliy conrain ha preven ype LH from mimicing LL and vice vera, (c) Incenive compaibiliy conrain ha preven ype HH from mimicing HL or LH and vice vera The grey riangle in par (a) of he figure how all combinaion ha preven HL from mimicing LL and vice vera. The co minimal combinaion ha fulfil hee incenive compaibiliy condiion i ( HL, HL ). Analogouly, par (b) of he figure give he incenive compaibiliy conrain ha 8 The figure refer o he parameer eing θ L = 2, θ H = 3, θ L = 3 and θ H = 4. 9
12 preven LH from mimicing LL and vice vera. Here, ( LH, LH ) i opimal raegy for ype LH. The grey riangle in par (c) coni of all raegie ha preven HH from mimicing LH and HL and vice vera. The opimal raegy of ype HH i hen ( HH, HH ) which i in boh componen equal o he eparaing raegy of he highalened ype in he onedimenional cae. The ame argumenaion a in he onedimenional cae lead o a pooling PBE where nobody ignal, i.e. all agen raegy i ( = 0, = 0). 9 There i alo he poibiliy for parial eparaing PBE in he preen cae. However, univeriie are inereed in he real ype of he agen. So, he mo efficien iuaion i he eparaing one. I pay more aenion o he parial eparaing PBE in he nex ubecion where ime conrain play a crucial role. Time conrain binding Now, I ry o anwer he queion: Wha happen if ime conrain are binding, i.e. if ype HH can no play hi raegy of he eparaing equilibrium of propoiion 2. More formally, HH + HH > l hold. For impliciy I aume ha k (θk H θk L ) l, k {, }, hold. Thi guranee ha he equilibria of he onedimenional cae exi. If hi i no fulfiled only he pooling equilibrium remain. A a key mechanim of a eparaing equilibrium he highly alened agen eparae himelf by ignalling o much ha here i no incenive of he lowalened agen o mimic him. Thi i poible becaue of he difference in co. However, if here are no only one bu wo ignal he ignalling effor increae 10 and may become oo high o be realied in he ime given. Before dicuing he main reul of hi ecion I make an aumpion abou he ranking of he produciviy parameer ha i crucial for he remaining analyi. Aumpion 1 The ranking of he produciviy parameer fulfil θ H θ L 9 For he deailed proof ee appendix B page In he preen model he ignalling effor in he wodimenional cae i exacly he um of he wo onedimenional ignalling model where he agen ignal on eaching or cience. However, hi reul i driven by he addiive rucure of produciviy and co. 10
13 and θ H θ L. By definion k > θk L, k {, } alway hold. So, for boh aciviie he highly alened agen i more producive han he agen wih low produciviy. However, nohing i known of he ranking of he produciviy parameer comparing boh aciviie. Aumpion 1 require ha agen ha are highly producive doing one aciviy are more producive han agen doing he oher aciviy wih low alen. Or, he oher way round, aumpion 1 i violaed if he univeriie benefi from one oupu i o high ha producing hi oupu by a lowproducive agen i beer han producing he oher oupu by a highproducive agen. Propoiion 3 If agen ignal heir abiliie o do cience ( ij ) and each( ij ), univeriie offer wage w( ij, ij ), he ime conrain i binding, i.e. if in propoiion 2 HH + HH > l, and aumpion 1 hold, here i no eparaing equilibrium. If aumpion 1 doe no hold he eparaing equilibrium from propoiion 2 i deroyed bu here i again he poibiliy of eparaing he four ype in equilibrium. HH HH HH HH Figure 2: Incenive compaibiliy conrain for ype HH when aumpion 1 hold. 11
14 For an illuraion of he iuaion where aumpion 1 hold ee figure The figure decribe he incenive compaibily conrain of ype HH. All raegie in he lighgrey riangle preven HH from mimicing LH and vice vera. The darkgrey riangle coni of all combinaion ha preven HH from mimicing HL and vice vera. The black riangle herefore give all raegie ha fulfil boh condiion. The raegy ( HH, HH ) i he equilibrium raegy. The key idea here i a follow: Becaue of he pure co effec of ignalling HH realie a co minimal combinaion ha i angen o he black riangle a i lower bound. The lower bound of he lighgrey riangle ha a lope of ( /θ L ). The lower bound of he darkgrey riangle ha a lope of ( /θ H ). Since he lope of HH co funcion i (θ H /θ H ) and herefore mee he condiion ( /θ L ) < (θ H /θ H ) < (θ L /θ H ) raegy ( HH, HH ) become he co minimal raegy ha fulfil boh incenive compaibiliy conrain. However, if ( HH, HH ) i he euqilibrium raegy of ype HH and ime conrain are binding here i no raegy ha lie ouhwe of ( HH, HH )  which i neceary o mee he ime conrain  and i locaed in he black riangle  which i neceary o fulfil he incenive compaibiliy conrain of ype HH. So, if aumpion 1 hold here i no pearaing PBE. HH HH 1 HH 2 _ l 1 _ l HH Figure 3: Incenive compaibiliy conrain for ype HH when aumpion 1 i no fulfiled. 11 The figure refer o parameer eing θ L = 2, θ H = θ L = 3 and θ H = 4. 12
15 Figure 3 how a iuaion in which aumpion 1 doe no hold. 12 The grey area decribe all raegie of HH ha fulfil boh incenive compaibiliy conrain. Conrary o figure 2 a decreae in he available ime from l 1 o l 2 hif he eparaing PBE from HH 1 o HH 2. Thu here i ill he poibiliy of eparaing he differen ype of agen. Propoiion 4 If agen ignal heir abiliie o do cience ( ij ) and each ( ij ), univeriie offer a wage w( ij, ij ) equal o he expeced produciviy here are wo parial eparaing equilibria. If θ H θ H θ L hold here i a parial PBE where raegie of he propecive profeor are: wih C1 LH,HH ( LL, LL) = (0, 0), ( HL, HL) = (θ L(θ H θ L), 0) and ( (LH,HH), (LH,HH)) = (0, θ LC1 (LH,HH) ) α HH α LH +α HH (1 α LH α LH +α HH ) + θ H θ L. If θ L θ L θ H hold here i a parial eparaing PBE where raegie of he propecive profeor are: ( LL, LL) = (0, 0), ( LH, LH) = (0, θ L(θ H θ L)) and wih C1 (HL,HH) = θ H θ L + ( (HL,HH), (HL,HH)) = (θ LC1 (HL,HH), 0) α HH α HL +α HH (1 α HL α HL +α HH ). In caue of clear arrangemen propoiion 4 only denoe raegie of he propecive profeor. 13 The wage eing of he univeriie i for he eparaed ype equal o he wage eing of propoiion 2. The pooled ype are paid by average produciviie. Thu in he fir parial eparaing PBE α i i w (LH,HH) = LH α LH +α HH + α HH α LH +α HH + θ H and in he econd parial eparaing equilibrium i i w (HL,HH) = + α HL α HL +α HH + α HH α HL +α HH. 12 The figure refere o he parameer eing θ L = 1, θ H = 2, θ L = 3 and θ H = Propoiion 4 only decribe wo parial eparaing equilibria. There i alo he poibiliy of oher parial eparaing equilibria, e.g. of ((LL, LH), HL, HH). Neverhele, univeriie ry o idenify he highly producive agen. Thu he parial eparaing PBE of propoiion 4 are he one of inere. 13
16 The deailed proof can be found in he appendix C page 26. In he fir parial eparaing PBE univeriie can diinguih beween LL, HL and (LH, HH), i.e. hey can no eparae ype LH from HH. In he econd parial eparaing PBE univeriie can eparae LL from LH and (HL, HH) bu no ype HL and HH. The key arrangemen of he proof of he fir parial eparaing PBE (and analogouly of he econd one) i a follow: Type LL doe no ignal becaue of he pure co effec. Type HL playe hi raegy from he onedimenional cae o preven LL from mimicing. Then he incenive compaibiliy conrain of (LH, HH) no o mimic LL or HL and vice vera are calculaed. Thi reul in he equilibrium raegy for (LH, HH). (a) HH (LH,HH) 2 1 (b) HH LH c HH 2 HH c LH HH HH c LH c HH Figure 4: Incenive compaibiliy conrain for (LH, HH) in he fir parial eparaing PBE (a) when θ H θ H θ L hold and (b) if hi condiion i no fulfiled 14
17 To illurae he neceary condiion of he exience of he fir parial eparaing PBE (LL, HL, (LH, HH)), i.e. o illurae he neceiy of θ H θ H θ L, look a figure 4.14 In par (a) of figure 4 i i θ H θ H θ L and boh minimal co funcion of he pooled ype, i.e. c LH and c HH, are angen o he black array ha coni of all raegie which mee he incenive compaibiliy conrain a poin (LH, HH). 15 Thi combinaion i he raegy LH and HH play in he fir parial eparaing equilibrium. In par (b) i i θ H < θ H θ L.16 Thu, he co funcion of HH, i.e. c HH, run oo fla. The minimal co funcion of ype HH i angen o he black area where he incenive compaibiliy conrain are fulfiled a poin HH. Since he minimal co funcion of ype LH i angen o he black array a poin LH here i no pooling equilibrium raegy for boh ype and o no parial eparaing PBE. A a fir reul one can ee ha boh parial eparaing PBE can only coexi if θ L = θ L θ H hold. One example for uch a iuaion i he ymmeric cae, where low (high) produciviy of cience equal low (high) produciviy of eaching, i.e. = θ H and θ L = θ L. Thu, univeriie do no have a clear preference for he one or he oher oupu. Auming ha he highly producive agen are he criical one and herefore normaliing he produciviie of he lowalened o one, i.e. = θ L = 1, he fir parial eparaing PBE only exi if eaching produciviy of he highly alened i higher han hi reearch produciviy. Analogouly, if he conrary appraiemen hold he econd parial eparaing PBE appear. In general an angen ha i good in eaching and cience poole wih he ype ha i highlyalened in he oupu ha i more prefered by he univeriie. Thi renghen he argumen of Becker (1975) and (1979) ha he profeor reearch and eaching oupu poiively reac on an increae in pecuniary reurn. Secondly, i i clear ha wihou ime conrain alway a lea one of he parial PBE exi. However, in hi cae hey are le inereing becaue he eparaing PBE i more efficien. 14 Clearly, an analogou argumenaion hold for condiion θ L θ L θ H and he econd parial eparaing PBE. 15 Par (a) of he figure refer o parameer value = θ L = 1, θ H = 2 and θ H = 3. More preciely, opimal raegie hould be labeled ( (LH,HH), (LH,HH)). However, caued by clarificaion I label he raegy wih he ype. 16 Par (b) of figure 4 refer o = 1, θ H = θ L = 2 and θ H = 3. 15
18 Thirdly, propoiion 4 how ha if he ime conrain i oo rong here i even no poibiliy for a parial eparaing equilibrium bu only for he pooling one. Thu, in boh parial eparaing equilibria he ime conrain i relaxed compared o he eparaing cae bu no removed. More preciely, he ime invemen of ype HH in he fir parial eparaing equilibrium i C1 (LH,HH) = α HH α LH +α HH ( θ L ) + θ L (θ H θ L ). Thi i clearly higher han he invemen in he onedimenional cae, i.e. (θ H θ L ).17 So, ime conrain can ill be binding. They are weakend o he wodimenional eparaing equilibrium where ime inpu i (θ H θ L ) + θ L (θ H θ L ) if and only if α HH /(α LH + α HH ) < /θ L. Thi i alway fulfiled if θ L θ L and herefore epecially in he cae where low produciviie are normalied o one. By he ame argumenaion ime conrain of he econd parial PBE i weaker han in he wodimenional eparaing PBE if and only if α HH /(α HL + α HH ) < /θ L hold. A ufficien condiion for hi purpoe i θ L. 4 Concluion The oupu of podoc and profeor coni, beide he adminiraive one ha i no menioned here, of cience and eaching. In general univeriie are inereed in boh oupu and aign a enure conrac only o hoe podoc ha are highly alened in boh aciviie. However, ince alen i a privae informaion a job marke ignalling model la Spence arie. Podoc ignal heir abiliy of cience and eaching o ge a enure. A Spence (1973) ha hown in he onedimenional cae ignalling can alo in he wodimenional cae eparae highly alened and low alened agen. So i olve he inefficiency problem of aymmeric informaion. Unforunaely, he highly producive agen need a ignalling effor o eparae hemelve from he lowproducive ype and hi effor increae in he wodimenional cae. Conidering hi, ime conrain arac noice. If ime conrain are binding and he cience (eaching) produciviy of he highalened i higher han he eaching (cience) produciviy of he ype wih low alen a eparaing equilibrium can no exi in he wodimenional 17 Acually, I can no be ure ha hi onedimenional equilibrium implie he ronger ime conrain, i.e. ha (θ H θ L ) > θ H (θ H θ L ) hold. Neverhele, hi i rue if he highproducive agen are of mo inere and low produciviie are normalied o one. 16
19 cae. The required aumpion i quie weak a i ju ay ha univeriie hould no prefer one oupu over he oher regardle weher he fir i creaed by a high or lowproducive peron. In addiion I how ha even if he eparaing equilibrium i deroyed by ime conrain here i alway a lea one parial eparaing equilibrium where ome ype can be eparaed while oher pool on he ame raegy. More preciely, if he univeriy prefer cience o eaching a parial eparaing equilibrium exi where univeriie can eparae ype wih high or low reearch produciviy. However, hey do no know if an agen wih high reearch produciviy i alo highly alened in eaching. Thi i he ame reul a in he onedimenional cae. Regreably, he ignalling effor ha only implie a pure co effec i higher in he wodimenional parial eparaing equilibrium han in he onedimenional eparaing one. Correponding o real life, he wodimenional ignalling yem ha i currenly ued in academic admiion procee i inefficien if ime conrain are binding. In uch a iuaion univeriie can no idenify boh alen of he podoc bu only one. The idenifiable alen i he one hey value more. Then univeriie can eae requiremen on podoc and can le hem  wihou looing informaion  ju ignal on cience or eaching. Appendix Par A: Onedimenional cae Proof of propoiion 1: Separaing equilibrium: Since preenure publihing implie co bu ha no effec on produciviy here i no incenive for a Lype o inve in publihing in a eperaing equilibrium. Therefore, i i L = 0. In addiion any equilibrium mu aify wo incenive compaibiliy condiion: On he one hand ype H mu no have an incenive o mimic he Lype, i.e. w( H ) c H ( H ) w( L ) c H ( L ) θ H H θ H L. (4) 17
20 On he oher hand he Lype mu no have an incenive o mimic he Hype, i.e. w( L ) c L ( L ) w( H ) c L ( H ) L θ H H. (5) Taking ino accoun ha he equilibrium raegy of he Lype i o publih nohing, i.e. L = 0, inequaion (4) reul in H (θ H θ L ). Analogouly, olving inequaion (5) by H I ge H (θ H θ L ). Boh incenive compaibiliy condiion ogeher imply ha (θ H θ L ) H (θ H θ L ) i a neceary condiion of a eparaing equilibrium. Since he univeriie never pay a wage higher han only he lower bound of he inerval, i.e. H = θ L (θ H θ L ), maximie uiliy of ype H. However, if H > l hold he eparaing equilibrium vanihe. Having he opimal deciion of he agen in mind univeriie belief ha hey focu on an agen of ype H whenever H and ha hey focu on an agen of ype L whenever < H. Pooling equilibrium: The pooling equilbrium in he onedimenional cae i = H = L = 0 w( ) = α H θ H + α L θ L µ(h α H (θ L(θ H θ L))) = α H, µ(l α H θ L(θ H θ L)) = α L µ(l > α H (θ L(θ H θ L))) = 1 if he ime conrain i no binding, i.e. i l, i {H, L}. The argumenaion i a follow: In every pooling equilibrium agen end idenical ignal, i.e. H = L =. Since univeriie canno diinguih beween boh ype hey e a unique wage ha equal average valuaion of he univeriie, i.e. w() = α H θ H + α L θ L. (6) In a pooling equilibrium boh ype mu no ge lower uiliy han wihou ignaling geing θ L, i.e. θ L w() c H () θ L α H θ H + α L θ L θ H 18 (7)
21 and w() c L () α H + α L. (8) Wih > θ L only condiion (8) become criical. I implie ha in every pooling equilibrium α H + α L ) ( αh (1 α L ) } {{ } =α H α H (θ H ) (9) mu hold. However, ince publihing only implie a co effec boh ype prefer he ignal H = L = = 0. Thi i a pooling perfec Bayeian equilibrium and in addiion alway aifie he ime conrain l. Par B: Twodimenional cae wihou ime conrain Proof of propoiion 2: In a eparaing PBE univeriie pay an agen ij a wage equal o hi produciviy. Thu, w( ij, ij) = θi + θj hold. Thi direcly give ( LL, LL ) = (0, 0) a equilibrium ignal of ype LL. In a nex ep, ignal of ype HL and LH mu mee he incenive compaibiliy conrain o ha boh ype have no incenive o mimic LL and vice vera. Thi auomaically preven HH from mimicing LL. Type HL doe no mimic LL if w( LL, LL) c HL ( LL, LL) w( HL, HL ) c HL ( HL, HL ) + + HL 1 HL + 1 HL HL θ L 19
22 hold. Analogouly, LL doe no mimic HL whenever w( LL, LL) c LL ( LL, LL) w( HL, HL ) c LL ( HL, HL ) + + HL 1 HL + 1 HL HL θ L hold. Therefore he incenive compaibiliy conrain ha preven HL from mimicing LL and vice vera i 1 θ H HL + 1 HL 1 HL + 1 HL. A ignal ha maximie uiliy of ype HL mu lie on he lower bound which one can rewrie a HL = (θ H ) θ L HL. Type HL will now chooe he ignal ha fulfil hi condiion and minimie co. Since co are (aking he la equaion ino accoun) c HL, HL = HL θ H + HL θ L = θ L (θ H θ L ) θ H = θ L (θ H θ L ) θ H θ L θ H θ L + (1 θ L HL + 1 HL θ H ) 1 θ L } {{ } >0 he minimal co combinaion i HL = 0 and herefore HL = θ L (θ H θ L ). Type HL raegy in he eparaing PBE i ( HL, HL ). In he ame way ype LH doe no mimic ype LL if HL w( LL, LL) c LH ( LL, LL) w( LH, LH ) c LH ( LH, LH ) + + LH 1 LH + 1 LH 20 LH θ H
23 hold. Type LL doe no mimic ype LH if w( LL, LL) c LL ( LL, LL) w( LH, LH ) c LL ( LH, LH ) + + LH 1 LH + 1 LH LH θ L i fulfiled. Taking boh condiion ogeher ype LH ha no incenive o mimic ype LL and vice vera if 1 θ L LH + 1 LH 1 LH + 1 LH hold. Again LH chooe a ignal on he lower bound given by he econd par of he condiion. Thu i i LH = (θ H ) θ L LH. Thi in mind co of ype HL are given by c LH ( LH, LH ) = LH θ L + LH θ H = θ L (θ H θ L ) θ H = (1 θ L θ H ) 1 θ L } {{ } >0 + 1 LH θ L LH θ H LH + θ L (θ H θ L ). To minimie co and herefore maximie uiliy given he wage +θ H ype LH play LH = 0 and LH = θ L (θ H θ L ) in equilbrium. Wih ( HL, HL ) and ( LH, LH ) ype HL ha no incenive o mimic ype LH and vice vera caue w( LH, LH) c HL ( LH, LH) w( HL, HL) c HL ( HL, HL) + θ L (θ H θ L ) θ H + θ L (θ H θ L ) 0 ( ) 2 21
24 and w( HL, HL) c LH ( HL, HL) w( LH, LH) c LH ( LH, LH) + θ L (θ H θ L ) θ L + θ L (θ H θ L ) 0 ( ) 2 are alway fulfiled. In a la ep one ha o make ure ha HH doe neiher mimic HL nor LH and vice vera. Type HH doe no mimic HL whenever w( HL, HL) c HH ( HL, HL) w( HH, HH ) c HH ( HH, HH ) + θ L (θ H θ L ) θ H + HH HH HH + θ H HH (θ H ) + (θ H ) hold. Analogouly, ype HL ha no incenive o mimic HH if w( HH, HH ) c HL ( HH, HH ) w( HL, HL) c HL ( HL, HL) + HH HH θ H + θ L (θ H θ L ) HH + θ H HH (θ H ) + (θ H ) i fulfiled. Boh condiion ogeher are he incenive compaibiliy condiion ha preven HH from mimicing HL and vice vera. Becaue of he pure co effec of ignalling he lower bound of he econd condiion, i.e. HH + θ H HH = (θ H ) + (θ H ) HH = (θ H ) + (θ H ) θ H HH (10) i a necaary condiion for a eparaing PBE. However addiionally, ype 22
25 HH doe no have an incenive o mimic ype LH and vice vera. Therefore, and w( LH, LH) c HH ( LH, LH) w( HH, HH ) c HH ( HH, HH ) + θ L (θ H θ L ) θ H + HH HH θ H HH + HH (θ H ) + (θ H ) w( HH, HH ) c LH ( HH, HH ) w( LH, LH) c LH ( LH, LH) + HH HH θ L + θ L (θ H θ L ) θ H HH + HH (θ H ) + (θ H ) mu hold. Boh condion ogeher are he incenive compaibiliy conrain ha preven HH from mimicing LH and vice vera. Caue of he pure co effec of ignalling he lower bound of he econd condiion, i.e. HH + HH = (θ H ) + (θ H ) HH = θ L(θ H θ L) + (θ H θ L )θ L θ L θ H θ L HH (11) i a neceary condiion for a PBE. In a eparaing PBE ype HH neiher mimic HL nor LH. Thu, condiion (10) and (11) mu hold. Boh linear funcion decribe he lower bound of he area ha fulfil boh incenive compaibiliy conrain. Becaue of he pure co effec of ignalling he opimal raegy i elemen of hi lower bound. To make ure ha he opimal aregy i unique he lope of hi lower bound mu be unequal o he lope of he co funcion of HH. 18 The co funcion of ype HH i c HH ( HH, HH ) = ( HH / )+( HH/ ). So, he lope of hi funcion in a  area i ( /θ H ). A he lope of equaion (10) in uch an area i (θ L /θ H ) and he lope of equaion (11) i ( /θ L ) here i a unique opimal raegy 18 If hi condiion i no fulfiled he minimal co combinaion would be angen o he area ha fullfiile he incenive compaibiliy conrain on a whole ecion repreened by a par of he linear funcion (10) or (11) and no o a unique poin. 23
26 of HH ha i given by he poin of inerecion of he linear combinaion (10) and (11). Calculaing hi poin of inerecion lead o (θ H ) + (θ H ) θ H HH = (θ H ) + (θ H θ L )θ L θ L θ L HH θ H(θ H ) θ L(θ H ) = θ H θ H θ L θ L HH (θ H θ L)(θ H ) = θ H θ H θ L θ L HH HH = (θ H ). Inering hi in equaion (10) give he fir par of he equilibrium ignal = (θ H θ L ). The pooling PBE in he wodimenional cae: The pooling PBE in he wo dimeniona cae i (, ) ( ij, ij) = (0, 0) i, j {H, L} w(, ) = ij α ij (θ i + θ j) ( µ ij (, ) = ( I (α HH +α HL )(θ H )), J (α HH +α LH )(θ H ) )) = α ij where I = 1 if i = H and 0 oherwie and J = 1 if j = H and 0 oherwie. The proof of hi reul i a follow: Univeriie wage eing eeing he pooled ignal (, ) i w(, ) = ij α ij (θ i + θ j). Since each agen ij can alway ge he lowe wage θ L + θ L uiliy wih 24
27 he pooled ignal mu be higher han hi reward, i.e. θ L + θ L w(, ) c ij (, ) θ L + θ L ij θ i θ i θ i + θ j + θ j + θ j α ij (θ i + θ j) θ i θ j (α LL + α LH 1)θ L + (α HH + α HL )θ H + (α LL + α HL 1)θ L + (α HH + α LH )θ H (α HH + α HL )θ L + (α HH + α HL )θ H (α HH + α LH )θ L + (α HH + α LH )θ H (α HH + α HL )(θ H θ L) + (α HH + α LH )(θ H θ L) (α HH + α HL )( )θ j + (α HH + α LH )( )θ j θ j. θi Thi i ju a linear equaion in. Clearly ype LL i he rericing ype. Thu every linear combinaion of (, ) for which θ L + θ L (α HH + α HL )(θ H θ L) + (α HH + α LH )(θ H θ L) hold mee he incenive compaibiliy conrain. However, he pure co effec of ignalling make (, ) = (0, 0) he unique pooling PBE. The incenive condiion ha preven agen from breaking ou of he pooling PBE are illuraed in figure 5. I refer o he ymmeric cae wih = θ H = 2, θ L = θ L = 1 and α ij = 1 i, j {H, L}. The grey area decribe all combinaio ha preven LL  and herefore alo he oher ype  4 from breaking ou of he pooling PBE. However, only (, ) = (0, 0) implie minimum co and herefore i PBE. 25
28 2 Type HH Type LH 1 Type HL Type LL 1 2 Figure 5: Incenive compaibiliy conrain of ype LL in a pooling PBE of wo dimenion Par C: Twodimenional cae wih ime conrain Proof of propoiion 4: The equence of he proof of he parial eparaing PBE (LL, HL, (LH, HH)) i a follow: Fir of all I find he opimal raegy for HL ha preven him from mimicing LL. Secondly I give he incenive compaibiliy conrain ha preven LL from mimicing (LH, HH) and vice vera. Thirdly, I give he incenive compaibiliy conrain ha preven HL from mimicing (LH, HH) and vice vera. Sep wo and hree ogeher reul in an opimal raegy for (LH, HH). In a PBE where LL i eparaed he ha no icenive o ignal. Thu, ( LL, LL ) = (0, 0). Then refering o he fir ep HL ignal ( HL, HL ) = ( (θ H θ L ), 0) o preven LL from mimicing him. Thi raegy direcly reul from he eparaing PBE. 26
29 To make ure ha in a econd ep LL doe no mimic (LH, HH) w LL c LL ( LL, LL) w (LH,HH) c LL ( (LH,HH), (LH,HH)) + α LH θ α HH L + + α LH + α HH α LH + α HH (LH,HH) θ L + (LH,HH) θ L (LH,HH) α HH (LH,HH) θ L α LH (1 ) +. α LH + α HH α LH + α } {{ HH } C1 (LH,HH) mu hold. Analogouly, LH and herefore (LH, HH) doe no mimic LL if w LL c LH ( LL, LL) w (LH,HH) c LH ( (LH,HH),LH,HH ) + α LH θ α HH L + + α LH + α HH α LH + α HH (LH,HH) θ L + (LH,HH) θ H (LH,HH) α HH (LH,HH) θ H α LH (12) (1 ) +. α LH + α HH α LH + α } {{ HH } =C1 (LH,HH) i fulfiled. Since ignal can no be negaive a neceary condiion for he exience of he parial eparaing PBE i C1 (LH,HH) > 0. I will come o hi laer on. To preven HL from mimicing (LH, HH) (hird ep) he following condiion mu hold: w HL c HL ( HL, HL) w (LH,HH) c HL ( (LH,HH), (LH,HH) ) θ H + θ L θ L (θ H θ L ) θ H (LH,HH) θ H + (LH,HH) θ L α LH θ α HH L + + α LH + α HH α LH + α HH (LH,HH) θ H 27 (LH,HH) θ L
30 α HH α LH (1 ) + (1 + ) + (θ L )2 α LH + α HH α LH + α HH } {{ } C2 (LH,HH) Analogouly, o preven HH and herefore (LH, HH) from mimicing HL w HL c HH ( HL, HL) w (LH,HH) c HH ( (LH,HH), (LH,HH) ) θ H + θ L θ L (θ H θ L ) θ H LH,HH θ H α HH + (LH,HH) θ H α LH θ α HH L + + α LH + α HH α LH + α HH (LH,HH) θ H α LH (LH,HH) θ H (1 ) + (1 + ) + (θ L )2 α LH + α HH α LH + α HH } {{ } =C2 (LH,HH) (13) mu hold. A neceary condiion for he exience of he parial eparaing PBE i again ha C2 (LH,HH) > 0 i fulfiled. Thi condiion i even ronger han C1 (LH,HH) from above becaue C2 (LH,HH) C1 (LH,HH) = θ H + 2θ L (θ L )2 θ H = (θ H )2 + 2θ H θ L (θ L )2 θ H = (θ H θ L )2 θ H hold. Alhough C2 (LH,HH) < C1 (LH,HH) i fulfiled one can no direcly ee if equaion (12) or equaion (13) i he ronger condiion becaue of he differen LHS. If you compare boh condiion you find ha he relaionhip depend on he exac parameer value. However, I how ha he opimal  co minimal  behavior for ype LH and HH i he ame regardle wheher equaion (12) or equaion (13) i he ronger condiion. Thu aume ha equaion (12) i ronger han equaion (13) hen < 0 28
31 (LH,HH) = θ L C1 (LH,HH) θ L θ L (LH,HH) hold. Thi in mind co of LH are (LH,HH) θ L + (LH,HH) θ H = 1 θ L (1 θ L ) } {{ } >0 (LH,HH) + θ L C1 (LH,HH). Since co increae in (LH,HH) he opimal raegy of LH i (LH,HH) = 0. Analogouly, co of HH are (LH,HH) θ H + (LH,HH) θ H = ( 1 θ H θ L θ L θ H ) + θ L C1 (LH,HH). 1 If θ L 0 hold he opimal raegy i o maximie (LH,HH). However, hen he parial eparaing PBE i deroyed. Type LH and HH θ H do no play he ame raegy. Therefore 1 θ H θ L θ L θ H 0 mu hold o enure he decribed PBE. If equaion (12) i he ronger condiion one θ L θ H θ H θ L become a neceary condiion of he parial eparaing PBE. Now aume ha inead of equaion (12) equaion (13) i he ronger condiion hen (LH,HH) = C2 (LH,HH) θ L θ (LH,HH) hold and co of ype H LH are (LH,HH) θ L + (LH,HH) θ H = ( 1 θ L θ H θ H ) (LH,HH) + θ L C2 (LH,HH) = ( θ H θ H θ L θ L ) (LH,HH) + θ L C2 θ L θ H } {{ } (LH,HH). >0 Again i i opimal for ype LH o play (LH,HH) = 0. Analogouly, co of ype HH are (LH,HH) θ H + (LH,HH) θ H = 1 (1 θ L ) (LH,HH) + θ L C2 (LH,HH). A co increae in (LH,HH) ype HH e (LH,HH) = 0. Summariing, under boh aumpion (LH,HH) = 0 i an opimal raegy for boh pooling ype. Thi reduce condiion (12) o (LH,HH) = C1 LH,HH 29
32 and condiion (13) o (LH,HH) = θ L C2 (LH,HH). Wih C1 (LH,HH) > C2 (LH,HH) from he above condiion (12) become he crucial condiion for he exience of he parial eparaing PBE. The equilibrium raegy of (LH, HH) i ( (LH,HH), (LH,HH) ) = (0, θ L C1 (LH,HH)). A neceary condiion for he exience of he equilibrium i θ L θ H > θ H θ L. Finally, he proof of he econd parial PBE, i.e. of (LL, LH, (HL, HH)) i analogou and i herefore no pecified here. Reference Allgood, Sam and Wiliam B. Walad (2005). View of eaching and reearch in economic and oher dicipline. American Economic Review Paper and Proceeding 95 (2), Armrong, Mark and JeanCharle Roche (1999). Mulidimenional creening: A uer guide. European Economic Review 43, Becker, William E. (1975). The univeriy profeor a a uiliy maximizer and producer of learning, reearch, and income. Journal of Human Reource 10, Becker, William E. (1979). Profeorial behavior given a ochaic reward rucure. The American Economic Review 69 (5), Becker, William E. and Peer E. Kennedy (2005). Doe eaching enhance reearch in economic? American Economic Review Paper and Proceeding 95 (2), Cho, InKoo and David M. Krep (1987). Signaling game and able equilibria. The Quarerly Journal of Economic 102 (2), De Fraja, Gianni and Paola Valbonei (2008). The deign of he univeriy yem. CEPR Dicuion Paper no Del Rey, Elena (2001). Teaching veru reearch: A model of ae univeriy compeiion. Journal of Urban Economic 49, Enger, Maxim (1987). Signalling wih many ignal. Economerica 55 (3),
33 Gauier, Axel and Xavier Wauhy (2007). Teaching veru reearch: The role of inernal financing rule in mulideparmen univeriie. European Economic Review 51, Golieb, Eher E. and Bruce Keih (1997). The academic reearcheaching nexu in eigh advancedindurialized counrie. Higher Educaion 34, Haie, John and H. W. Marh (1996). The relaionhip beween reearch and eaching: A meaanalyi. Review of Educaional Reearch 66 (4), Kim, JeongYoo (2007). Mulidimenional ignaling in he labor marke. Mancheer School 75 (1), Michell, John E. and Dougla S. Rebne (1995). Nonlinear effec of eaching and conuling on academic reearch produciviy. SocioEconomic Planning Science 29 (1), Roche, JeanCharle and Marine Qunizii (1985). Mulidimenional ignalling. Journal of Mahemaical Economic 14, Spence, Michael (1973). Job mark ignalling. The Quarerly Journal of Economic 87 (3), Spence, Michael (1974). Compeiive and opimal repone o ignal: An analyi of efficiency and diribuion. Jounral of Economic Theory 7, Walckier, Alexi (2008). Mulidimenional conrac wih akpecific produciviy: An applicaion o univeriie. Inernaional Tax and Public Finance 15,
34
35 DISKUSSIONSPAPIERE DER FÄCHERGRUPPE VOLKSWIRTSCHAFTSLEHRE DISCUSSION PAPERS IN ECONOMICS Die komplee Lie der Dikuionpapiere i auf der Inerneeie veröffenlich / for full li of paper ee: hp://fgvwl.huhh.de/wpvwl Schneider, Andrea. Science and eaching: Twodimenional ignalling in he academic job marke, Augu Krue, Jörn. Da GovernanceDilemma der demokraichen Wirchafpoliik, Augu Hackmann, Johanne. Ungereimheien der radiionell in Deuchland vorherrchenden Rechferigunganäze für da Ehegaenpliing, Mai Schneider, Andrea; Klau W. Zimmermann. Mehr zu den poliichen Segnungen von Föderalimu, April Beckmann, Klau; Schneider, Andrea. The ineracion of publicaion and appoinmen  New evidence on academic economi in Germany, März Beckmann, Klau; Schneider, Andrea. MeinProf.de und die Qualiä der Lehre, Februar Berlemann, Michael; Hielcher, Kai. Meauring Effecive Moneary Policy Conervaim, February Horgo, Daniel. The Elaiciy of Subiuion and he Secor Bia of Inernaional Ouourcing: Solving he Puzzle, February Rundhagen, Bianca; Zimmermann, Klau W.. BuchananKooperaion und Inernaionale Öffenliche Güer, Januar Thoma, Tobia. Queionable Luxury Taxe: Reul from a Maing Game, Sepember Dluhoch, Barbara; Zimmermann, Klau W.. Adolph Wagner und ein Geez : einige päe Anmerkungen, Augu Zimmermann, Klau W.; Horgo, Daniel. Inere group and economic performance: ome new evidence, Augu Beckmann, Klau; Gerri, Caren. Armubekämpfung durch Redukion von Korrupion: eine Rolle für Unernehmen?, Juli Beckmann, Klau; Engelmann, Denni. Seuerwebewerb und Finanzverfaung, Juli Thoma, Tobia. Fragwürdige Luxueuern: Saureben und demonraive Konumverhalen in der Gechiche ökonomichen Denken, Mai Krue, Jörn. Hochchulen und langfriige Poliik. Ein ordnungpoliicher Eay zu zwei Reformuopien, Mai Krue, Jörn. Mobile Terminaion Carrier Selecion, April Dewener, Ralf; Haucap, Juu. Webewerb al Aufgabe und Problem auf Medienmärken: Falludien au Sich der Theorie zweieiiger Märke, April Krue, Jörn. PareienMonopol und Dezenraliierung de demokraichen Saae, März Beckmann, Klau; Gake, Suan. Sau preference and opimal correcive axe: a noe, February Krue, Jörn. InerneÜberla, Nezneuraliä und ServiceQualiä, Januar Dewener, Ralf. Nezneuraliä, Dezember Beckmann, Klau; Gerri, Caren. Making ene of corrupion: Hobbeian jungle, bribery a an aucion, and DUP aciviie, December Krue, Jörn. CrowdingOu bei Überla im Inerne, November Beckmann, Klau. Why do perol price flucuae o much?, November Beckmann, Klau. Wa will Du armer Teufel geben?  Bemerkungen zum Glück in der Ökonomik, November 2007.
36
How has globalisation affected inflation dynamics in the United Kingdom?
292 Quarerly Bullein 2008 Q3 How ha globaliaion affeced inflaion dynamic in he Unied Kingdom? By Jennifer Greenlade and Sephen Millard of he Bank Srucural Economic Analyi Diviion and Chri Peacock of he
More information2.4 Network flows. Many direct and indirect applications telecommunication transportation (public, freight, railway, air, ) logistics
.4 Nework flow Problem involving he diribuion of a given produc (e.g., waer, ga, daa, ) from a e of producion locaion o a e of uer o a o opimize a given objecive funcion (e.g., amoun of produc, co,...).
More information6.003 Homework #4 Solutions
6.3 Homewk #4 Soluion Problem. Laplace Tranfm Deermine he Laplace ranfm (including he region of convergence) of each of he following ignal: a. x () = e 2(3) u( 3) X = e 3 2 ROC: Re() > 2 X () = x ()e d
More informationTopic: Applications of Network Flow Date: 9/14/2007
CS787: Advanced Algorihm Scribe: Daniel Wong and Priyananda Shenoy Lecurer: Shuchi Chawla Topic: Applicaion of Nework Flow Dae: 9/4/2007 5. Inroducion and Recap In he la lecure, we analyzed he problem
More informationHow Much Can Taxes Help Selfish Routing?
How Much Can Taxe Help Selfih Rouing? Tim Roughgarden (Cornell) Join wih Richard Cole (NYU) and Yevgeniy Dodi (NYU) Selfih Rouing a direced graph G = (V,E) a ource and a deinaion one uni of raffic from
More informationChapter 13. Network Flow III Applications. 13.1 Edge disjoint paths. 13.1.1 Edgedisjoint paths in a directed graphs
Chaper 13 Nework Flow III Applicaion CS 573: Algorihm, Fall 014 Ocober 9, 014 13.1 Edge dijoin pah 13.1.1 Edgedijoin pah in a direced graph 13.1.1.1 Edge dijoin pah queiong: graph (dir/undir)., : verice.
More informationState Machines: Brief Introduction to Sequencers Prof. Andrew J. Mason, Michigan State University
Inroducion ae Machines: Brief Inroducion o equencers Prof. Andrew J. Mason, Michigan ae Universiy A sae machine models behavior defined by a finie number of saes (unique configuraions), ransiions beween
More informationA Comparative Study of Linear and Nonlinear Models for Aggregate Retail Sales Forecasting
A Comparaive Sudy of Linear and Nonlinear Model for Aggregae Reail Sale Forecaing G. Peer Zhang Deparmen of Managemen Georgia Sae Univeriy Alana GA 30066 (404) 6514065 Abrac: The purpoe of hi paper i
More informationRobust Bandwidth Allocation Strategies
Robu Bandwidh Allocaion Sraegie Oliver Heckmann, Jen Schmi, Ralf Seinmez Mulimedia Communicaion Lab (KOM), Darmad Univeriy of Technology Merckr. 25 D64283 Darmad Germany {Heckmann, Schmi, Seinmez}@kom.udarmad.de
More informationSubsistence Consumption and Rising Saving Rate
Subience Conumpion and Riing Saving Rae Kenneh S. Lin a, HiuYun Lee b * a Deparmen of Economic, Naional Taiwan Univeriy, Taipei, 00, Taiwan. b Deparmen of Economic, Naional Chung Cheng Univeriy, ChiaYi,
More informationSAMPLE LESSON PLAN with Commentary from ReadingQuest.org
Lesson Plan: Energy Resources ubject: Earth cience Grade: 9 Purpose: students will learn about the energy resources, explore the differences between renewable and nonrenewable resources, evaluate the environmental
More informationDividend taxation, share repurchases and the equity trap
Working Paper 2009:7 Deparmen of Economic Dividend axaion, hare repurchae and he equiy rap Tobia Lindhe and Jan Söderen Deparmen of Economic Working paper 2009:7 Uppala Univeriy May 2009 P.O. Box 53 ISSN
More informationHeat demand forecasting for concrete district heating system
Hea demand forecaing for concree diric heaing yem Bronilav Chramcov Abrac Thi paper preen he reul of an inveigaion of a model for horerm hea demand forecaing. Foreca of hi hea demand coure i ignifican
More information17 Laplace transform. Solving linear ODE with piecewise continuous right hand sides
7 Laplace ransform. Solving linear ODE wih piecewise coninuous righ hand sides In his lecure I will show how o apply he Laplace ransform o he ODE Ly = f wih piecewise coninuous f. Definiion. A funcion
More informationNew Evidence on Mutual Fund Performance: A Comparison of Alternative Bootstrap Methods. David Blake* Tristan Caulfield** Christos Ioannidis*** and
New Evidence on Muual Fund Performance: A Comparion of Alernaive Boorap Mehod David Blake* Trian Caulfield** Chrio Ioannidi*** and Ian Tonk**** June 2014 Abrac Thi paper compare he wo boorap mehod of Koowki
More informationExplore the Application of Financial Engineering in the Management of Exchange Rate Risk
SHS Web o Conerence 17, 01006 (015) DOI: 10.1051/ hcon/01517 01006 C Owned by he auhor, publihed by EDP Science, 015 Explore he Applicaion o Financial Engineering in he Managemen o Exchange Rae Rik Liu
More informationFortified financial forecasting models: nonlinear searching approaches
0 Inernaional Conference on Economic and inance Reearch IPEDR vol.4 (0 (0 IACSIT Pre, Singapore orified financial forecaing model: nonlinear earching approache Mohammad R. Hamidizadeh, Ph.D. Profeor,
More informationCHAPTER 11 NONPARAMETRIC REGRESSION WITH COMPLEX SURVEY DATA. R. L. Chambers Department of Social Statistics University of Southampton
CHAPTER 11 NONPARAMETRIC REGRESSION WITH COMPLEX SURVEY DATA R. L. Chamber Deparmen of Social Saiic Univeriy of Souhampon A.H. Dorfman Office of Survey Mehod Reearch Bureau of Labor Saiic M.Yu. Sverchkov
More informationThe Twin Agency Problems in Corporate Finance  On the basis of Stulz s theory 
The Twin Agency Problem in Corporae Finance  On he bai of Sulz heory  Von der Fakulä für Machinenbau, Elekroechnik und Wirchafingenieurween der Brandenburgichen Technichen Univeriä Cobu zur Erlangung
More informationA Brief Introduction to the Consumption Based Asset Pricing Model (CCAPM)
A Brief Inroducion o he Consumpion Based Asse Pricing Model (CCAPM We have seen ha CAPM idenifies he risk of any securiy as he covariance beween he securiy's rae of reurn and he rae of reurn on he marke
More informationPROFIT TEST MODELLING IN LIFE ASSURANCE USING SPREADSHEETS PART TWO
Profi Tes Modelling in Life Assurance Using Spreadshees, par wo PROFIT TEST MODELLING IN LIFE ASSURANCE USING SPREADSHEETS PART TWO Erik Alm Peer Millingon Profi Tes Modelling in Life Assurance Using Spreadshees,
More informationTwoGroup Designs Independent samples ttest & paired samples ttest. Chapter 10
TwoGroup Deign Independen ample e & paired ample e Chaper 0 Previou e (Ch 7 and 8) Ze z M N e (oneample) M N M = andard error of he mean p. 989 Remember: = variance M = eimaed andard error p. 
More informationYTM is positively related to default risk. YTM is positively related to liquidity risk. YTM is negatively related to special tax treatment.
. Two quesions for oday. A. Why do bonds wih he same ime o mauriy have differen YTM s? B. Why do bonds wih differen imes o mauriy have differen YTM s? 2. To answer he firs quesion les look a he risk srucure
More informationPhysical Topology Discovery for Large MultiSubnet Networks
Phyical Topology Dicovery for Large MuliSubne Nework Yigal Bejerano, Yuri Breibar, Mino Garofalaki, Rajeev Raogi Bell Lab, Lucen Technologie 600 Mounain Ave., Murray Hill, NJ 07974. {bej,mino,raogi}@reearch.belllab.com
More informationOn the Connection Between MultipleUnicast Network Coding and SingleSource SingleSink Network Error Correction
On he Connecion Beween MulipleUnica ework Coding and SingleSource SingleSink ework Error Correcion Jörg Kliewer JIT Join work wih Wenao Huang and Michael Langberg ework Error Correcion Problem: Adverary
More informationChapter 8 Natural and Step Responses of RLC Circuits
haper 8 Naural an Sep Repone of R ircui 8. The Naural Repone of a Parallel R ircui 8.3 The Sep Repone of a Parallel R ircui 8.4 The Naural an Sep Repone of a Serie R ircui Key poin Wha o he repone curve
More information4. International Parity Conditions
4. Inernaional ariy ondiions 4.1 urchasing ower ariy he urchasing ower ariy ( heory is one of he early heories of exchange rae deerminaion. his heory is based on he concep ha he demand for a counry's currency
More informationBanking, Inside Money and Outside Money
Banking, Inide Mone and Ouide Mone Hongfei Sun Deparmen of Economic Univeri of Torono (Job Marke Paper) Abrac Thi paper preen an inegraed heor of mone and banking. I addre he following queion: when boh
More informationThe Chase Problem (Part 2) David C. Arney
The Chae Problem Par David C. Arne Inroducion In he previou ecion, eniled The Chae Problem Par, we dicued a dicree model for a chaing cenario where one hing chae anoher. Some of he applicaion of hi kind
More informationJava Semantics. The Stack and Heap. Primitive Types. Semantics and Specifying Procedures. David Evans
univeriy of virginia fall 2006 Semanic and Specifying Procedure Java Semanic David Evan www.c.virginia.edu/c205 2 The Sack and Heap Sring = new Sring (); Sring i a ype in he Java API for repreening equence
More informationEconomics Honors Exam 2008 Solutions Question 5
Economics Honors Exam 2008 Soluions Quesion 5 (a) (2 poins) Oupu can be decomposed as Y = C + I + G. And we can solve for i by subsiuing in equaions given in he quesion, Y = C + I + G = c 0 + c Y D + I
More informationNewton's second law in action
Newon's second law in acion In many cases, he naure of he force acing on a body is known I migh depend on ime, posiion, velociy, or some combinaion of hese, bu is dependence is known from experimen In
More informationOPTIMAL BATCH QUANTITY MODELS FOR A LEAN PRODUCTION SYSTEM WITH REWORK AND SCRAP. A Thesis
OTIMAL BATH UANTITY MOELS FOR A LEAN ROUTION SYSTEM WITH REWORK AN SRA A Thei Submied o he Graduae Faculy of he Louiiana Sae Univeriy and Agriculural and Mechanical ollege in parial fulfillmen of he requiremen
More informationA Note on Using the Svensson procedure to estimate the risk free rate in corporate valuation
A Noe on Using he Svensson procedure o esimae he risk free rae in corporae valuaion By Sven Arnold, Alexander Lahmann and Bernhard Schwezler Ocober 2011 1. The risk free ineres rae in corporae valuaion
More informationCSE202 Greedy algorithms
CSE0 Greedy algorihm . Shore Pah in a Graph hore pah from Princeon CS deparmen o Einein' houe . Shore Pah in a Graph hore pah from Princeon CS deparmen o Einein' houe Tree wih a mo edge G i a ree on n
More informationLong Term Spread Option Valuation and Hedging
Long Term Spread Opion Valuaion and Hedging M.A.H. Demper, Elena Medova and Ke Tang Cenre for Financial Reearch, Judge Buine School, Univeriy of Cambridge, Trumpingon Sree, Cambridge CB 1AG & Cambridge
More informationInfrastructure and Evolution in Division of Labour
Infrarucure and Evoluion in Diviion of Labour Mei Wen Monah Univery (Thi paper ha been publihed in RDE. (), 906) April 997 Abrac Thi paper udie he relaionhip beween infrarucure ependure and endogenou
More information11/6/2013. Chapter 14: Dynamic ADAS. Introduction. Introduction. Keeping track of time. The model s elements
Inroducion Chaper 14: Dynamic DS dynamic model of aggregae and aggregae supply gives us more insigh ino how he economy works in he shor run. I is a simplified version of a DSGE model, used in cuingedge
More informationPerformance Center Overview. Performance Center Overview 1
Performance Cener Overview Performance Cener Overview 1 ODJFS Performance Cener ce Cener New Performance Cener Model Performance Cener Projec Meeings Performance Cener Execuive Meeings Performance Cener
More informationThe Transport Equation
The Transpor Equaion Consider a fluid, flowing wih velociy, V, in a hin sraigh ube whose cross secion will be denoed by A. Suppose he fluid conains a conaminan whose concenraion a posiion a ime will be
More informationReputation and Social Network Analysis in MultiAgent Systems
Repuaion and Social Neork Analyi in MuliAgen Syem Jordi Sabaer IIIA  Arificial Inelligence Reearch Iniue CSIC  Spanih Scienific Reearch Council Bellaerra, Caalonia, Spain jabaer@iiia.cic.e Carle Sierra
More informationEquity Valuation Using Multiples. Jing Liu. Anderson Graduate School of Management. University of California at Los Angeles (310) 2065861
Equiy Valuaion Uing Muliple Jing Liu Anderon Graduae School of Managemen Univeriy of California a Lo Angele (310) 2065861 jing.liu@anderon.ucla.edu Doron Niim Columbia Univeriy Graduae School of Buine
More informationChapter 6: Business Valuation (Income Approach)
Chaper 6: Business Valuaion (Income Approach) Cash flow deerminaion is one of he mos criical elemens o a business valuaion. Everyhing may be secondary. If cash flow is high, hen he value is high; if he
More informationAppendix A: Area. 1 Find the radius of a circle that has circumference 12 inches.
Appendi A: Area workedou s o OddNumbered Eercises Do no read hese workedou s before aemping o do he eercises ourself. Oherwise ou ma mimic he echniques shown here wihou undersanding he ideas. Bes wa
More informationCalculation of variable annuity market sensitivities using a pathwise methodology
cuing edge Variable annuiie Calculaion of variable annuiy marke eniiviie uing a pahwie mehodology Under radiional finie difference mehod, he calculaion of variable annuiy eniiviie can involve muliple Mone
More informationChapter 7. Response of FirstOrder RL and RC Circuits
Chaper 7. esponse of FirsOrder L and C Circuis 7.1. The Naural esponse of an L Circui 7.2. The Naural esponse of an C Circui 7.3. The ep esponse of L and C Circuis 7.4. A General oluion for ep and Naural
More informationCircuit Types. () i( t) ( )
Circui Types DC Circuis Idenifying feaures: o Consan inpus: he volages of independen volage sources and currens of independen curren sources are all consan. o The circui does no conain any swiches. All
More informationFair games, and the Martingale (or "Random walk") model of stock prices
Economics 236 Spring 2000 Professor Craine Problem Se 2: Fair games, and he Maringale (or "Random walk") model of sock prices Sephen F LeRoy, 989. Efficien Capial Markes and Maringales, J of Economic Lieraure,27,
More informationDifferential Equations. Solving for Impulse Response. Linear systems are often described using differential equations.
Differenial Equaions Linear sysems are ofen described using differenial equaions. For example: d 2 y d 2 + 5dy + 6y f() d where f() is he inpu o he sysem and y() is he oupu. We know how o solve for y given
More informationCrosssectional and longitudinal weighting in a rotational household panel: applications to EUSILC. Vijay Verma, Gianni Betti, Giulio Ghellini
Croecional and longiudinal eighing in a roaional houehold panel: applicaion o EUSILC Viay Verma, Gianni Bei, Giulio Ghellini Working Paper n. 67, December 006 CROSSSECTIONAL AND LONGITUDINAL WEIGHTING
More informationMarkit Excess Return Credit Indices Guide for price based indices
Marki Excess Reurn Credi Indices Guide for price based indices Sepember 2011 Marki Excess Reurn Credi Indices Guide for price based indices Conens Inroducion...3 Index Calculaion Mehodology...4 Semiannual
More informationUnderstanding Sequential Circuit Timing
ENGIN112: Inroducion o Elecrical and Compuer Engineering Fall 2003 Prof. Russell Tessier Undersanding Sequenial Circui Timing Perhaps he wo mos disinguishing characerisics of a compuer are is processor
More informationMorningstar Investor Return
Morningsar Invesor Reurn Morningsar Mehodology Paper Augus 31, 2010 2010 Morningsar, Inc. All righs reserved. The informaion in his documen is he propery of Morningsar, Inc. Reproducion or ranscripion
More informationThe Real Business Cycle paradigm. The RBC model emphasizes supply (technology) disturbances as the main source of
Prof. Harris Dellas Advanced Macroeconomics Winer 2001/01 The Real Business Cycle paradigm The RBC model emphasizes supply (echnology) disurbances as he main source of macroeconomic flucuaions in a world
More informationFourier series. Learning outcomes
Fourier series 23 Conens. Periodic funcions 2. Represening ic funcions by Fourier Series 3. Even and odd funcions 4. Convergence 5. Halfrange series 6. The complex form 7. Applicaion of Fourier series
More informationRandom Walk in 1D. 3 possible paths x vs n. 5 For our random walk, we assume the probabilities p,q do not depend on time (n)  stationary
Random Walk in D Random walks appear in many cones: diffusion is a random walk process undersanding buffering, waiing imes, queuing more generally he heory of sochasic processes gambling choosing he bes
More informationEfficient Risk Sharing with Limited Commitment and Hidden Storage
Efficien Risk Sharing wih Limied Commimen and Hidden Sorage Árpád Ábrahám and Sarola Laczó March 30, 2012 Absrac We exend he model of risk sharing wih limied commimen e.g. Kocherlakoa, 1996) by inroducing
More informationFormulating CyberSecurity as Convex Optimization Problems
Formulaing CyberSecuriy a Convex Opimizaion Problem Kyriako G. Vamvoudaki, João P. Hepanha, Richard A. Kemmerer, and Giovanni Vigna Univeriy of California, Sana Barbara Abrac. Miioncenric cyberecuriy
More informationDuration and Convexity ( ) 20 = Bond B has a maturity of 5 years and also has a required rate of return of 10%. Its price is $613.
Graduae School of Business Adminisraion Universiy of Virginia UVAF38 Duraion and Convexiy he price of a bond is a funcion of he promised paymens and he marke required rae of reurn. Since he promised
More informationRepresenting Periodic Functions by Fourier Series. (a n cos nt + b n sin nt) n=1
Represening Periodic Funcions by Fourier Series 3. Inroducion In his Secion we show how a periodic funcion can be expressed as a series of sines and cosines. We begin by obaining some sandard inegrals
More informationOptimal Path Routing in Single and Multiple Clock Domain Systems
IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON COMPUTERAIDED DESIGN, TO APPEAR. 1 Opimal Pah Rouing in Single and Muliple Clock Domain Syem Soha Haoun, Senior Member, IEEE, Charle J. Alper, Senior Member, IEEE ) Abrac Shrinking
More informationSection 7.1 Angles and Their Measure
Secion 7.1 Angles and Their Measure Greek Leers Commonly Used in Trigonomery Quadran II Quadran III Quadran I Quadran IV α = alpha β = bea θ = hea δ = dela ω = omega γ = gamma DEGREES The angle formed
More informationNoise Trading and the Effects of Monetary Policy Shocks on Nominal and Real Exchange Rates
Kiel Iniue for World Economic Dueernbrooker Weg 120 24105 Kiel (Germany) Kiel Working Paper No 1140 Noie Trading and he Effec of Moneary Policy Shock on Nominal and Real Exchange Rae by Chriian Pierdzioch
More informationAnalysis of Pricing and Efficiency Control Strategy between Internet Retailer and Conventional Retailer
Recen Advances in Business Managemen and Markeing Analysis of Pricing and Efficiency Conrol Sraegy beween Inerne Reailer and Convenional Reailer HYUG RAE CHO 1, SUG MOO BAE and JOG HU PARK 3 Deparmen of
More informationINTEREST RATE FUTURES AND THEIR OPTIONS: SOME PRICING APPROACHES
INTEREST RATE FUTURES AND THEIR OPTIONS: SOME PRICING APPROACHES OPENGAMMA QUANTITATIVE RESEARCH Absrac. Exchangeraded ineres rae fuures and heir opions are described. The fuure opions include hose paying
More informationNanocubes for RealTime Exploration of Spatiotemporal Datasets
Nanocube for RealTime Exploraion of Spaioemporal Daae Lauro Lin, Jame T Kloowki, and arlo Scheidegger Fig 1 Example viualizaion of 210 million public geolocaed Twier po over he coure of a year The daa
More informationII.1. Debt reduction and fiscal multipliers. dbt da dpbal da dg. bal
Quarerly Repor on he Euro Area 3/202 II.. Deb reducion and fiscal mulipliers The deerioraion of public finances in he firs years of he crisis has led mos Member Saes o adop sizeable consolidaion packages.
More informationUsefulness of the Forward Curve in Forecasting Oil Prices
Usefulness of he Forward Curve in Forecasing Oil Prices Akira Yanagisawa Leader Energy Demand, Supply and Forecas Analysis Group The Energy Daa and Modelling Cener Summary When people analyse oil prices,
More informationIndividual Health Insurance April 30, 2008 Pages 167170
Individual Healh Insurance April 30, 2008 Pages 167170 We have received feedback ha his secion of he e is confusing because some of he defined noaion is inconsisen wih comparable life insurance reserve
More informationOptimal Investment and Consumption Decision of Family with Life Insurance
Opimal Invesmen and Consumpion Decision of Family wih Life Insurance Minsuk Kwak 1 2 Yong Hyun Shin 3 U Jin Choi 4 6h World Congress of he Bachelier Finance Sociey Torono, Canada June 25, 2010 1 Speaker
More informationSinglemachine Scheduling with Periodic Maintenance and both Preemptive and. Nonpreemptive jobs in Remanufacturing System 1
Absrac number: 050407 Singlemachine Scheduling wih Periodic Mainenance and boh Preempive and Nonpreempive jobs in Remanufacuring Sysem Liu Biyu hen Weida (School of Economics and Managemen Souheas Universiy
More informationProcess Modeling for Object Oriented Analysis using BORM Object Behavioral Analysis.
Proce Modeling for Objec Oriened Analyi uing BORM Objec Behavioral Analyi. Roger P. Kno Ph.D., Compuer Science Dep, Loughborough Univeriy, U.K. r.p.kno@lboro.ac.uk 9RMW FKMerunka Ph.D., Dep. of Informaion
More informationPROFIT TEST MODELLING IN LIFE ASSURANCE USING SPREADSHEETS PART ONE
Profi Tes Modelling in Life Assurance Using Spreadshees PROFIT TEST MODELLING IN LIFE ASSURANCE USING SPREADSHEETS PART ONE Erik Alm Peer Millingon 2004 Profi Tes Modelling in Life Assurance Using Spreadshees
More informationJ. S. BACH GENERAL BASS RULES. Adapted from Niedt's Music Handbook Leipzig Edited by N. Schmidt Lausanne 2003
J. S. BACH GENERAL BASS RULES Adaped rom Nied' Muic Handbook Leipzig 1 Edied by N. Schmid Lauanne 200 1 Table o Conen Inroducion Baic Rule Harmonic Triad Wha o play when nohing i wrien over he Ba Rule
More informationSignal Rectification
9/3/25 Signal Recificaion.doc / Signal Recificaion n imporan applicaion of juncion diodes is signal recificaion. here are wo ypes of signal recifiers, halfwae and fullwae. Le s firs consider he ideal
More informationHANDOUT 14. A.) Introduction: Many actions in life are reversible. * Examples: Simple One: a closed door can be opened and an open door can be closed.
Inverse Funcions Reference Angles Inverse Trig Problems Trig Indeniies HANDOUT 4 INVERSE FUNCTIONS KEY POINTS A.) Inroducion: Many acions in life are reversible. * Examples: Simple One: a closed door can
More informationWHAT ARE OPTION CONTRACTS?
WHAT ARE OTION CONTRACTS? By rof. Ashok anekar An oion conrac is a derivaive which gives he righ o he holder of he conrac o do 'Somehing' bu wihou he obligaion o do ha 'Somehing'. The 'Somehing' can be
More informationChapter 8: Regression with Lagged Explanatory Variables
Chaper 8: Regression wih Lagged Explanaory Variables Time series daa: Y for =1,..,T End goal: Regression model relaing a dependen variable o explanaory variables. Wih ime series new issues arise: 1. One
More informationData Analysis Toolkit #7: Hypothesis testing, significance, and power Page 1
Daa Analyi Toolki #7: Hypohei eing, ignificance, and power Page 1 The ame baic logic underlie all aiical hypohei eing. Thi oolki illurae he baic concep uing he mo common e,  e for difference beween mean.
More informationFormulating CyberSecurity as Convex Optimization Problems Æ
Formulaing CyberSecuriy a Convex Opimizaion Problem Æ Kyriako G. Vamvoudaki,João P. Hepanha, Richard A. Kemmerer 2, and Giovanni Vigna 2 Cener for Conrol, Dynamicalyem and Compuaion (CCDC), Univeriy
More informationFourier Series Solution of the Heat Equation
Fourier Series Soluion of he Hea Equaion Physical Applicaion; he Hea Equaion In he early nineeenh cenury Joseph Fourier, a French scienis and mahemaician who had accompanied Napoleon on his Egypian campaign,
More informationGraphing the Von Bertalanffy Growth Equation
file: d:\b1732013\von_beralanffy.wpd dae: Sepember 23, 2013 Inroducion Graphing he Von Beralanffy Growh Equaion Previously, we calculaed regressions of TL on SL for fish size daa and ploed he daa and
More informationDistributing Human Resources among Software Development Projects 1
Disribuing Human Resources among Sofware Developmen Proecs Macario Polo, María Dolores Maeos, Mario Piaini and rancisco Ruiz Summary This paper presens a mehod for esimaing he disribuion of human resources
More informationEmpirical heuristics for improving Intermittent Demand Forecasting
Empirical heuriic for improving Inermien Demand Forecaing Foio Peropoulo 1,*, Konanino Nikolopoulo 2, Georgio P. Spihouraki 1, Vailio Aimakopoulo 1 1 Forecaing & Sraegy Uni, School of Elecrical and Compuer
More informationCurbing Emissions through a Carbon Liabilities Market: A note from a climate skeptic s perspective
201420 Curbing Emiion hrough a Carbon Liabiliie Marke: A noe from a climae kepic perpecive Eienne Billee de Villemeur, Juin Leroux Série Scienifique Scienific Serie Monréal Février 2014/February 2014
More information1 The basic circulation problem
2WO08: Graphs and Algorihms Lecure 4 Dae: 26/2/2012 Insrucor: Nikhil Bansal The Circulaion Problem Scribe: Tom Slenders 1 The basic circulaion problem We will consider he maxflow problem again, bu his
More informationA Reexamination of the Joint Mortality Functions
Norh merican cuarial Journal Volume 6, Number 1, p.166170 (2002) Reeaminaion of he Join Morali Funcions bsrac. Heekung Youn, rkad Shemakin, Edwin Herman Universi of S. Thomas, Sain Paul, MN, US Morali
More informationCVA calculation for CDS on super senior ABS CDO
MPRA Munich Personal RePEc Archive CVA calculaion for CDS on super senior AS CDO Hui Li Augus 28 Online a hp://mpra.ub.unimuenchen.de/17945/ MPRA Paper No. 17945, posed 19. Ocober 29 13:33 UC CVA calculaion
More informationCHARGE AND DISCHARGE OF A CAPACITOR
REFERENCES RC Circuis: Elecrical Insrumens: Mos Inroducory Physics exs (e.g. A. Halliday and Resnick, Physics ; M. Sernheim and J. Kane, General Physics.) This Laboraory Manual: Commonly Used Insrumens:
More informationAn empirical analysis about forecasting Tmall airconditioning sales using time series model Yan Xia
An empirical analysis abou forecasing Tmall aircondiioning sales using ime series model Yan Xia Deparmen of Mahemaics, Ocean Universiy of China, China Absrac Time series model is a hospo in he research
More informationMathematics in Pharmacokinetics What and Why (A second attempt to make it clearer)
Mahemaics in Pharmacokineics Wha and Why (A second aemp o make i clearer) We have used equaions for concenraion () as a funcion of ime (). We will coninue o use hese equaions since he plasma concenraions
More informationChapter 1.6 Financial Management
Chaper 1.6 Financial Managemen Par I: Objecive ype quesions and answers 1. Simple pay back period is equal o: a) Raio of Firs cos/ne yearly savings b) Raio of Annual gross cash flow/capial cos n c) = (1
More informationMaintenance scheduling and process optimization under uncertainty
Compuers and Chemical Engineering 25 (2001) 217 236 www.elsevier.com/locae/compchemeng ainenance scheduling and process opimizaion under uncerainy C.G. Vassiliadis, E.N. Piikopoulos * Deparmen of Chemical
More informationUSE OF EDUCATION TECHNOLOGY IN ENGLISH CLASSES
USE OF EDUCATION TECHNOLOGY IN ENGLISH CLASSES Mehme Nuri GÖMLEKSİZ Absrac Using educaion echnology in classes helps eachers realize a beer and more effecive learning. In his sudy 150 English eachers were
More informationcooking trajectory boiling water B (t) microwave 0 2 4 6 8 101214161820 time t (mins)
Alligaor egg wih calculus We have a large alligaor egg jus ou of he fridge (1 ) which we need o hea o 9. Now here are wo accepable mehods for heaing alligaor eggs, one is o immerse hem in boiling waer
More informationLECTURE: SOCIAL SECURITY HILARY HOYNES UC DAVIS EC230 OUTLINE OF LECTURE:
LECTURE: SOCIAL SECURITY HILARY HOYNES UC DAVIS EC230 OUTLINE OF LECTURE: 1. Inroducion and definiions 2. Insiuional Deails in Social Securiy 3. Social Securiy and Redisribuion 4. Jusificaion for Governmen
More informationINVESTIGATION OF THE INFLUENCE OF UNEMPLOYMENT ON ECONOMIC INDICATORS
INVESTIGATION OF THE INFLUENCE OF UNEMPLOYMENT ON ECONOMIC INDICATORS Ilona Tregub, Olga Filina, Irina Kondakova Financial Universiy under he Governmen of he Russian Federaion 1. Phillips curve In economics,
More informationStochastic Optimal Control Problem for Life Insurance
Sochasic Opimal Conrol Problem for Life Insurance s. Basukh 1, D. Nyamsuren 2 1 Deparmen of Economics and Economerics, Insiue of Finance and Economics, Ulaanbaaar, Mongolia 2 School of Mahemaics, Mongolian
More informationPROFITS AND POSITION CONTROL: A WEEK OF FX DEALING
PROFITS AND POSITION CONTROL: A WEEK OF FX DEALING Richard K. Lyon U.C. Berkeley and NBER Thi verion: June 1997 Abrac Thi paper examine foreign exchange rading a he dealer level. The dealer we rack average
More informationTrading Strategies for Sliding, Rollinghorizon, and Consol Bonds
Trading Sraegie for Sliding, Rollinghorizon, and Conol Bond MAREK RUTKOWSKI Iniue of Mahemaic, Poliechnika Warzawka, 661 Warzawa, Poland Abrac The ime evoluion of a liding bond i udied in dicree and
More information