Transcription

1 LLOHYl\KWHLV W+HOVLQJLQSXURMHQYHGHQODDGXQ NXYDDMDQD 1RHO5LVFRMD DWMDHOOLNND 6LVlOO\V <KWHHQYHWR 6DPPDQGUDJ 6XPPDU\ 5HVXPHQ -RKGDQWR 7XWNLPXVDOXHHW 0lWlMRNL 5HNRODQRMD 9LLNNL,Wl+HOVLQNL 0HOOXQN\OlQSXUR %URlQGDQSXUR $LQHLVWRMDPHQHWHOPlW 1l\WWHHQRWWR 1l\WWHLGHQNlVLWWHO\MDSLLOHYLHQODMLPllULW\V,QGHNVLWMDOXRNLWWHOXW 9HVLQl\WWHHW 7XORNVHWMDWXORVWHQWDUNDVWHOX 0lWlMRNL 5HNRODQRMD 9LLNNL 6l\QlVODKGHQSXUR 9LLNLQRMD,Wl+HOVLQNL 0HOOXQN\OlQSXUR %URlQGDQSXUR -RKWRSllW NVHW LUMDOOLVXXV

2 +HOVLQJLQNDXS\PSlULVW NHVNMXONDLVXMD5LVFR1 HOOLNND <KWHHQYHWR 9LUWDYHVLlRQ+HOVLQJLVVlSHULQWHLVHVWLVHXUDWWXOlKLQQlI\VLNDDOLVNHPLDOOLVLOOD PHQHWHOPLOOl 1lLGHQ PHQHWHOPLHQ RQJHOPDQD RQ OXRWHWWDYDQ MD NDWWDYDQ WLH GRQVDDPLQHQVHOODLVHVWD\PSlULVW VWlMRNDPXXWWXXQRSHDVWLYLUWDDPDQYDLK GHOOHVVD(XURRSDQ8QLRQLQYHVLSXLWHGLUHNWLLYLNRURVWDDYLUWDYHVLHQELRPRQLWR URLQWLDMRWHQELRORJLVWHQPHQHWHOPLHQNl\WW WXOHHWRGHQQlN LVHVWLMDWNRVVDOL VllQW\PllQ 7lVVl WXWNLPXNVHVVD WHVWDWWLLQ SLLOHYl\KWHLV MHQ VRYHOWXYXXWWD YHGHQ ODDGXQ NXYDDMLNVL+HOVLQJLQVHXGXQSXURLVVDLLOHYl\KWHLV WHLYlWYDLKWHOHNRYLQ QR SHDVWL PXWWD NXLWHQNLQ ULLWWlYlQ KHUNlVWL KHLMDVWDPDDQ YLUWDYHGHQ YHGHQ ODD GXVVDWDSDKWXYLDPXXWRNVLD7XWNLPXNVHQWXORNVHQDOXRWLLQYLVXDDOLVHVWLVHONHl WDSDNXYDWDNDXSXQNLSXURMHQYHGHQODDWXDMDVHOYLWHWWLLQSXURMHQWLODDQYDLNXW WDYLDVHLNNRMD 7lVVl WXWNLPXNVHVVD RWHWWLLQ SLLOHYlQl\WWHLWl NLLQWHLOWl DOXVWRLOWD NXXGHVWD SX URVWD 1l\WWHLVWl WHKWLLQ NHVWRSUHSDUDDWLW MD SLLOHYlW DQDO\VRLWLLQ SUHSDUDDWHLVWD PLNURVNRRSSLVHVWL$LQHLVWRQWDUNDVWHOXVVDNl\WHWWLLQYHGHQSLODDQWXQHLVXXWWDMD UHKHY\\WWlNXYDDYLDLQGHNVHMlMRWNDODVNHWWLLQSLLOHYLHQLQGLNDDWWRULDUYRMHQSH UXVWHHOOD,QGLNDDWWRULU\KPLHQ VXKWHHOOLVLD RVXXNVLD SLLOHYl\KWHLV VVl VHOYLWHW WLLQ HNRORJLVWHQ OXRNLWXVWHQ SHUXVWHHOOD VDSURELD WURILD W\SSLPHWDEROLD VHNl KDSSLYDDWLPXV 5HNRODQRMDQ MD 6l\QlVODKGHQRMDQ YHGHQ ODDWX ROL SLLOHYlDQDO\\VLHQ PXNDDQ YlOWWlYl0lWlRMDQ9LLNLQRMDQMD0HOOXQN\OlQSXURQYHGHQODDWXROLW\\G\WWlYl MD%URlQGDQSXURQHULQRPDLQHQ DLNNLHQSXURMHQYHGHQODDWXYDLKWHOLSXURQHUL RVLVVD LLOHYlPHQHWHOPl RVRLWWDXWXL Nl\WW NHOSRLVHNVL MD PRQLYlULNDUWDW YLVXDDOLVHVWL VHONHLNVL7XWNLPXNVHVVDWXOLLOPLSXURMDOLNDDYLDSllVW OlKWHLWlMRWNDRQV\\Wl SRLVWDD6HXUDQWDSLLOHYlPHQHWHOPlOOl ROLVL K\Yl ODDMHQWDD NRVNHPDDQ PllUl YXRVLQDNDLNNLD+HOVLQJLQSXURMD

3 +HOVLQJLQNDXS\PSlULVW NHVNMXONDLVXMD 5LVFR1 HOOLNND LVHODOJHUVRPLQGLNDWRUHUI UYDWWHQNYDOLWHWHQL +HOVLQJIRUVElFNDU 6DPPDQGUDJ 0RQLWRUHULQJHQ DY VPn YDWWHQGUDJ KDU L +HOVLQJIRUV WUDGLWLRQHOOW VNHWW PHG KMlOSDYI\VLNDOLVNDRFKNHPLVNDPHWRGHU0HGKMlOSDYGHVVDPHWRGHUlUGHW GRFN VYnUW DWW In IUDP SnOLWOLJ RFK WlFNDQGH LQIRUPDWLRQ RP PLOM HU VRP I UlQGUDV VQDEEW Gn IO GHW YDULHUDU (XURSHLVND XQLRQHQV UDPGLUHNWLY I U YDWWHQSROLWLN EHWRQDU ELRPRQLWRUHULQJ DY ULQQDQGH YDWWHQGUDJ RFK ELRORJLVND PHWRGHUNRPPHUVDQQROLNWDWWDQYlQGDVPHULIUDPWLGHQ, GHQQD VWXGLH WHVWDGHV NLVHODOJHUQDV OlPSOLJKHW VRP LQGLNDWRUHU I U YDWWHQNYDOLWHWHQ L ElFNDU VPn ULQQDQGH YDWWHQGUDJ L +HOVLQJIRUVWUDNWHQ LVHODOJVVDPKlOOHQD I UlQGUDV LQWH YLGDUH KDVWLJW PHQ lu lqgn WLOOUlFNOLJW NlQVOLJD I U DWW I UlQGULQJDU L YDWWHQNYDOLWHWHQ VNDOO UHIOHNWHUDV L GHP 0HG KMlOS DY VWXGLHQV UHVXOWDW VNDSDGHV HWW NODUW YLVXHOOW V\VWHP I U DWW EHVNULYD ElFNDUQDVYDWWHQNYDOLWHWRFKVDPWLGLJWNODUODJGHVYLONDIDNWRUHUVRPLQYHUNDU SnElFNDUQDVDOOPlQWLOOVWnQG, VWXGLHQ WRJV NLVHODOJVSURYHU IUnQ IDVWD XQGHUODJ L VH[ ElFNDU HUPDQHQWD SUHSDUDWIUDPVWlOOGHVDYSURYHQRFKNLVHODOJVIORUDQDQDO\VHUDGHVPHGKMlOSDY PLNURVNRS, JUDQVNQLQJHQ DY PDWHULDOHW DQYlQGHV LQGH[ I U YDWWQHWV I URUHQLQJVJUDG RFK WURILVND VWDWXV VRP XWUlNQDGHV Sn EDVHQ DY NLVHODOJHUQDV LQGLNDWRUYlUGHQ 'HQ UHODWLYD I UHNRPVWHQ DY ROLND LQGLNDWRUJUXSSHU L NLVHODOJVVDPKlOOHW NODUODJGHV PHG KMlOS DY HNRORJLVND NODVVLILNDWLRQVV\VWHP VDSURELWURILVNJUDGW\SPHWDEROLRFKV\UHEHKRY 9DWWHQNYDOLWHWHQ L 5lFNKDOVElFNHQ RFK,GYLNVElFNHQ YDU HQOLJW NLVHODOJVDQDO\VHQ Q MDNWLJ, 5XWLnQ 9LNVElFNHQ RFK 0HOOXQJVE\ElFNHQ YDU YDWWQHWV NYDOLWHW WLOOIUHGVVWlOODQGH RFK L %URlQGD ElFN P\FNHW JRG 9DWWHQNYDOLWHWHQYDULHUDGHLGHROLNDGHODUQDDYGHUHVSHNWLYHYDWWHQGUDJHQ LVHODOJVPHWRGHQ YLVDGH VLJ YDUD DQYlQGEDU RFK GH XWIRUPDGH PnQJIlUJDGH NDUWRUQDYLVXHOOWNODUD 6WXGLHQ DYVO MDGH I URUHQLQJVNlOORU VRP SnYHUNDU GH VWXGHUDGHYDWWHQGUDJHQRFKVRPE UDYOlJVQDV'HWVNXOOHYDUDEUDDWWXWYLGJD GHWWDVODJDYPRQLWRUHULQJPHGKMlOSDYNLVHODOJHUVnDWWGHQVNXOOHWlFNDDOOD ElFNDUL+HOVLQJIRUVDOWHUQHUDQGHnU

4 +HOVLQJLQNDXS\PSl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l\QlVODKGHQSXUR,Q0lWlRMD9LLNLQRMDDQG0HOOXQN\OlQSXURWKHZDWHU TXDOLW\ZDVVDWLVIDFWRU\DQGLQ%URlQGDSXURH[FHOOHQW7KHTXDOLW\RIWKHZDWHU YDULHGLQWKHGLIIHUHQWSDUWVRIWKHUHVSHFWLYHEURRNV 7KHGLDWRPPHWKRGSURYHGWREHXVHIXODQGWKHSURGXFHGPXOWLFRORXUHGPDSV ZHUHYLVXDOO\FOHDU7KHVWXG\DOVRUHYHDOHGSROOXWLRQVRXUFHVZKLFKDIIHFWWKH EURRNVDQGVKRXOGEHUHPRYHG0RQLWRULQJEDVHGRQWKHGLDWRPPHWKRGVKRXOG EHH[WHQGHGWRLQFOXGHDOOVPDOOEURRNVLQ+HOVLQNLRQDOWHUQDWH\HDUV

5 +HOVLQJLQNDXS\PSlULVW NHVNMXONDLVXMD 5LVFR1 HOOLNND /DVFRPXQLGDGHVGHGLDWRPHDVSDUDGHWHUPLQDUOD FDOLGDGGHODJXDGHORVDUUR\RVGH+HOVLQNL 5HVXPHQ (O VHJXLPLHQWR GH ORV UtRV GH +HOVLQNL VH KD UHDOL]DGR WUDGLFLRQDOPHQWH PHGLDQWH ORV PpWRGRV ItVLFRTXtPLFRV(O SUREOHPD GH HVWRV PpWRGRV HVWi HQ SRGHU REWHQHU XQD LQIRUPDFLyQ DPSOLD \ SUHFLVD GH XQ PHGLR TXH FDPELD UiSLGDPHQWHVHJ~QORVFDPELRVGHFDXGDO/D'LUHFWLYD0DUFRGHO$JXDGHOD 8QLyQ(XURSHDHQIDWL]DHQODQHFHVLGDGGHOVHJXLPLHQWRELROyJLFRGHORVUtRV SRUORTXHHOXVRGHHVWRVPpWRGRVLUiHQDXPHQWR (QHVWHHVWXGLRVHSUREyODFRQYHQLHQFLDGHOXVRGHGLDWRPHDVSDUDGHWHUPLQDU ODFDOLGDGGHODJXDGHORVDUUR\RVGHODUHJLyQGH+HOVLQNL/DVFRPXQLGDGHVGH GLDWRPHDV QR YDUtDQ UiSLGDPHQWH SHUR Vt OR VXILFLHQWH FRPR SDUD UHIOHMDU FODUDPHQWH ORV FDPELRV TXH SXHGDQ RFXUULU HQ OD FDOLGDG GH ODV DJXDV&RPR UHVXOWDGR GHO HVWXGLR VH FUHR XQD IRUPD YLVXDOPHQWH FODUD SDUD GHVFULELU OD FDOLGDGGHODJXD\VHGHWHUPLQDURQORVIDFWRUHVTXHDIHFWDEDQHOHVWDGRGHHVWRV DUUR\RV (QHVWHHVWXGLRVHWRPDURQPXHVWUDVGHGLDWRPHDVGHVXSHUILFLHVVyOLGDVHQVHLV DUUR\RV/DVPXHVWUDVWRPDGDVIXHURQGHSXUDGDVPRQWDGDV \ DQDOL]DGDV EDMR HO PLFURVFRSLR (Q HO DQiOLVLV GHO PDWHULDO VH XWLOL]DURQ YDULRV tqglfhv TXH GHVFULEHQ HO QLYHO WUyILFR \ GH FRQWDPLQDFLyQ GHO DJXD ORV FXDOHV IXHURQ FDOFXODGRVDSDUWLUGHYDORUHVLQGLFDGRUHVGHODVGLDWRPHDV/DUHODFLyQGHORV JUXSRV GH LQGLFDGRUHV GHQWUR GH OD FRPXQLGDG GH GLDWRPHDV IXH GHWHUPLQDGD PHGLDQWH ODV FODVHV HFROyJLFDV VDSURELD WURILD PHWDEROLVPR GHO QLWUyJHQR \ GHPDQGDGHR[tJHQR /DFDOLGDGGHODJXDGHORVDUUR\RV5HNRODQRMD\6l\QlVODKGHQSXURUHVXOWyVHU PDODVHJ~QORVDQiOLVLVGHODVGLDWRPHDV6LQHPEDUJRODFDOLGDGGHODJXDGH ORV DUUR\RV 0lWlRMD 9LLNLQRMD \ 0HOOXQN\OlQSXUR IXH VDWLVIDFWRULD \ OD GHO %URlQGDQSXURPX\EXHQD/DFDOLGDGGHODJXDGHWRGRVORVDUUR\RVYDULyHQODV GLIHUHQWHVSDUWHVGHOFXUVR /RV UHVXOWDGRV GHPRVWUDURQ OR DSURSLDGR GHO PpWRGR GH ODV GLDWRPHDV \ OR YLVXDOPHQWH FODUR TXH UHVXOWDQ ORV PDSDV GH FRORUHV (Q HO HVWXGLR VH GHWHFWDURQ SXQWRV FRQWDPLQDQWHV TXH GHEHUtDQ VHU HOLPLQDGRV (Q HO IXWXUR VHUtDEXHQRDPSOLDUHOVHJXLPLHQWRPHGLDQWHHOPpWRGRGHODVGLDWRPHDVKDVWD OOHJDUDFXEULUWRGRVORVUtRVGH+HOVLQNLHQORVSUy[LPRVDxRV

6 +HOVLQJLQNDXS\PSlULVW NHVNMXONDLVXMD5LVFR1 HOOLNND -RKGDQWR +HOVLQJLQ DOXHHOOD RQ \OL HUL NRNRLVWD SXURD 9DUKDLVLPPDW WXWNLPXNVHW QLLVWlRQWHKW\MDOXNXMHQYDLKWHHVVD &DMDQGHUOXYXQ DOXVVD+HOVLQJLQNDXSXQNLSXURWROLYDWXVHLQYLHPlULMDNDDWRSDLNNDYHVLHQSL ODDPLDPXWWDQLLGHQWLODSDUDQLYLHPlULYHUNRVWRQODDMHQWXHVVD5XWK 7LNND QHQ 1\N\LVLQ SXURW RYDW DUYRNNDLWD YLUNLVW\V MD PDLVHPDNRKWHLWD MRL GHQNXQQRVWXVWD+HOVLQJLQNDXSXQJLQUDNHQQXVYLUDVWRRQDORLWWDQXW DVYHLOOH MDHOlLPLOOHSXURWMDQLLGHQUDQQDWRYDWHOLQDOXHLWDVHNlNXONXMDOHYLlPLVUHLW WHMl DXSXQNLSXURW HURDYDW OXRQQRQSXURLVWD VLLQl HWWl YLHPlU LQQLQ WDNLD QLLGHQ YDOXPDDOXHLWD RQ YDLNHD PllULWWll 1H RYDW P\ V OXRQQRQSXURMD DOWWLLPSLD LKPLVHQWRLPLQQDVWDDLKHXWXYDOOHNXRUPLWXNVHOOHVLOOlQLLGHQYDOXPDDOXHLVWD VXXULRVDRQUDNHQQHWWXDNDXSXQNLMDWHROOLVXXV\PSlULVW l8vhlqndxsxqnlsx URWRYDWRVDYLUNLVW\VWDLOXRQQRQVXRMHOXDOXHWWD5DNHQWDPLVHQMDPXXQPDDQ SLQQDQ ULNNRPLVHQ \KWH\GHVVl SXURLKLQ MRXWXX UXQVDDVWL NLLQWRDLQHWWD $VIDO WRLGXLOWD SLQQRLOWD VDGHYHVL YLUWDD QRSHDVWL VDGHYHVLYLHPlUHLKLQ MD HGHOOHHQ RMLLQKXXKWRHQPXNDDQVDNLLQWRDLQHVWD7lPlQMRKGRVWDSXURLOOHRQW\\SLOOLVWl YLUWDDPDQMDNLLQWRDLQHSLWRLVXXGHQVXXULMDQRSHDYDLKWHOX DXSXQNLSXURWRQ XVHLQ RKMDWWX NXONHPDDQ WXQQHOHLVVD RMLVVD WDL NDQDYLVVD XURMHQ XRPLD RQ VXRULVWHWWXMDUXRSDWWXMRWHQVDGHYHGHWNXONHYDWQRSHDVWLSRLVSXURVWD7lPlRQ DLNDDQVDDQXWYLUWDDPDQMDYHVLPllUlQQRSHDQYDLKWHOXQMDNHVlLVHQ³YlKlQYH GHQ RQJHOPDQ 6XRPHVVDYLUWDYHVLHQELRPRQLWRURLQWLVHXUDQWDELRORJLVLQPHQHWHOPLQRQNH KLWW\Q\WYLLPHLVWHQYXRGHQDLNDQD8XVLDPHQHWHOPLlRQNRNHLOWXPXWWDI\ VLNDDOLVNHPLDOOLVWHQPHQHWHOPLHQNl\WW RQ\KlWDYDOOLVLQWDSDVHXUDWDSXURMHQ YHGHQODDWXD9LUWDYHVLHQI\VLNDDOLVNHPLDOOLQHQVHXUDQWDRQYDLNHDDWRWHXWWDD QLLQHWWlVDDGXWWXORNVHWROLVLYDWOXRWHWWDYLDMDNDWWDYLDWXORNVHWNXYDDYDWYDLQ YHGHQ KHWNHOOLVWl ODDWXD NRVND SXURLVVD YHGHQ ODDWX YRL PXXWWXD QRSHDVWL MD HSlVllQQ OOLVHVWL HVlOOl MD WHVWDWWLLQ SLLOHYl\KWHLV MHQ VRYHOWX YXXWWDYHGHQODDGXQNXYDDMLNVLNXXGHVVD+HOVLQJLQVHXGXQSXURVVD7DYRLWWHH QDROLSLLOHYlLQGHNVLHQDYXOODVHOYLWWllSXURMHQYHGHQODDWXMDPDKGROOLVHW VLL KHQYDLNXWWDYDWWHNLMlW 7XWNLPXNVHVVD ROL WDUNRLWXNVHQD NXYDWD NDXSXQNLSXURMHQ YHGHQ ODDWX SLLOHYl PHQHWHOPlOOl YLVXDDOLVHVWL 0HQHWHOPll RQ DLHPPLQNLQ Nl\WHWW\ 6XRPHVVD HVLP (ORUDQWD (ORUDQWD $QGHUVVRQ (ORUDQWD D (ORUDQWD E (ORUDQWD ZDQGUDQV 0HQHWHOPl VRYHOWXX K\YLQ I\VLNDDOLV NHPLDOOLVHQVHXUDQQDQWXHNVLNRVNDSLLOHYl\KWHLV WHLYlWYDLKWHOHNRYLQQRSH DVWL PXWWD KHLMDVWDYDW NXLWHQNLQ ULLWWlYlQ KHUNlVWL MRNLYHVLVW Q YHGHQ WLODVVD WDSDKWXYLDPXXWRNVLD(ORUDQQDQDPXNDDQSLLOHYl\KWHLV UHDJRLYHGHQ ODDGXQPXXWRNVHHQPXXWDPDQSlLYlQWDLYLLNRQNXOXHVVD0HQHWHOPlRQP\ V YDUVLQ QRSHD MD KHOSSR WRWHXWWDD MRWHQ VH RQ SHULQWHLVLl VHXUDQWDPHQHWHOPLl HGXOOLVHPSL-DWNRVVDWlOOlPHQHWHOPlOOlYRLVLNDUWRLWWDDMDVHXUDWDNDXSXQNLSX URMHQWLODDNDWWDYDVWL

7 +HOVLQJLQNDXS\PSlULVW NHVNMXONDLVXMD 5LVFR1 HOOLNND 7XWNLPXVDOXHHW 7XWNLWXW SXURW ROLYDW 0lWlMRNL 5HNRODQRMD 0HOOXQN\OlQSXUR %URlQGDQSXUR 6l\QlVODKGHQSXUR MD 9LLNLQRMD HVlQ WXORNVHW RYDW RVD +HOVLQJLQ \OL RSLVWRQ /LPQRORJLDQ MD \PSlULVW QVXRMHOXQ ODLWRNVHQ SUR JUDGX W\ Wl 5LVFR MDNHVlQWXORNVHW+HOVLQJLQ\PSlULVW NHVNXNVHQRPDDWXWNLPXVWD XURWVLMDLWVHYDW+HOVLQJLVVlOXNXXQRWWDPDWWD5HNRODQRMDDMRNDODVNHH HUD YDQMRNHHQ 9DQWDDOOD 0XXW SXURW ODVNHYDW +HOVLQJLQ PHUHQODKWLLQ %URlQGDQ SXUR\KW\\0HOOXQN\OlQSXURRQOlKHOOl9DUWLRN\OlQODKGHQSRKMXNNDD 0lWlMRNL 0lWlMRNLVLMDLWVHH/lQVL+HOVLQJLVVl<NVLVHQKDDURLVWDVDDDONXQVD9DQWDDOOD MD \NVL (VSRRVVD NXYD 0lWlMRNL RQ YDOXPDDOXHHOWDDQ MD YLUWDDPDOWDDQ +HOVLQJLQ VXXULQ SXUR XURQ YDOXPDDOXH RQ NP MD VH RQ VXXULPPDOWD RVDOWDDQ+HOVLQJLQNDXSXQJLQDOXHHOOD0lWlMRHQSllXRPDDONDD9DQWDDQ DL XYD0lWlMRHQYDOXPDDOXHMDKDYDLQWRSDLNDW

8 +HOVLQJLQNDXS\PSlULVW NHVNMXONDLVXMD5LVFR1 HOOLNND YRNVHODVWD MD YLUWDD HWHOllQ VRLVHQ DOXHHQ OlSL 0\\UPlHQ RKL NRKWL 0DOPLQ NDUWDQRD0DOPLQNDUWDQRVVDSXURYLUWDDOlSLVLLUWRODSXXWDUKDDOXHHQMRVVDSXUR RQODDMHQQHWWXDOWDDNVL0DWDODQDOWDDQNHVNHOOHRQWHKW\VDDUL7lPlQMlONHHQ SXUR YLUWDD /DVVLODQ OlQVLRVDQ MD LWlMlQPlHQ WHROOLVXXVDOXHHQ KDONL LWlMlQ PlHVVl SXUR NXONHH RVLWWDLQ WXQQHOLVVD 0lWlMRNL ODVNHH,VR+XRSDODKWHHQ 9LUWDDPDSXURVVDYDLKWHOLYXRVLQD±±OVMDYHGHQNLLQWRDLQHSLWRL VXXV ± PJO 9XRGHVWD 0lWlMRHQ YLUWDDPDD RQ OLVlWW\ MXRNVXWWD PDOODOLVlYHWWlVLLKHQ6LOYRODQWHNRDOWDDVWD5XWK0lWlMRNHDNXYDLOODDQ P\ V-DODYDQMXONDLVXVVD 5HNRODQRMD 5HNRODQRMDQYDOXPDDOXHRQNP (NKROPMDVHNXXOXX9DQWDDQ MRHQYHVLVW DOXHHVHHQNXYDXURVDDDONXQVD7XXVXODVVDVLMDLWVHYDVWDOlK WHHVWlMDVHYLUWDDHQVLQNRKWLLWllMDNllQW\\P\ KHPPLQHWHOlVXXQWDDQNXONLHQ +HOVLQNL±5LLKLPlNLUDGDQ YDUWWD RUVRQ 5HNRODQ MD RLYXN\OlQ DVXWXVDOXHL GHQ OlSL 9DQWDDOOD 9DQWDDQ +LHNNDKDUMXVVD 5HNRODQRMDQ XRPD NllQW\\ XX GHOOHHQLWllQ7llOOlSXURYLUWDDSHOWRMHQKDONLMD\KW\\ORSXOWD HUDYDQMRNHHQ XURQ YLUWDDPD ± OV MD YHGHQ NLLQWRDLQHSLWRLVXXV ± PJO YDLKWHOHYDWSDOMRQ XYD5HNRODQRMDYDOXPDDOXHMDKDYDLQWRSDLNDW

9 +HOVLQJLQNDXS\PSlULVW NHVNMXONDLVXMD 5LVFR1 HOOLNND 9LLNNL 6l\QlVODKGHQSXURVWD MD 9LLNLQRMDVWD RQ WDUNND NXYDXV -DODYDQ MXONDL VXVVD9LLNLQ/DWRNDUWDQRQDVXWXVDOXHMD\OLRSLVWRQXXGHWUDNHQQXNVHWRQNXL WHQNLQUDNHQQHWWXMXONDLVXQWHRQMlONHHQMDNXPPDQNLQSXURQVLMDLQWLMD\PSl ULVW RYDW RVLQ PXXWWXQHHW 6l\QlVODKGHQSXUR MD 9LLNLQRMDQ OlQVLKDDUD VDDYDW DONXQVD KDUMXDOXHHOWD 0DOPLQ KDXWDXVPDDQ HWHOlRVDVWD MD /DKGHQYl\OlQ YDU UHOWD NXYD 0ROHPPDW SXURW ODVNHYDW 9LLNLQ OXRQQRQVXRMHOXDOXHHOOH 9DQ KDQNDXSXQJLQODKWHHQ9LLNLQRMDQLWlKDDUDOlKWHH LYLNRQDVXQWRDOXHHOWDMRQND UDNHQWDPLQHQ ROL NHVlOOl YLHOl NHVNHQ MD NXONHH 0DOPLQ DPSXPDUDWD DOXHHQKDONLMD HKl,QDOLWVH6HQYLUWDDPDRQOlQVLKDDUDDKXRPDWWDYDVWLVXX UHPSL,Wl+HOVLQNL 0HOOXQN\OlQSXUR 0HOOXQN\OlQSXURQYDOXPDDOXHNP VLMDLWVHH,Wl+HOVLQJLVVlMDRVLWWDLQ P\ V9DQWDDQDOXHHOODNXYDXURVDDDONXQVD6OnWWPRVVHQLQVXRDOXHHOWDMD YLUWDDSLHQHQVLLUWRODSXXWDUKDDOXHHQVHNl5DMDN\OlQ 9HVDODQMD 0HOOXQN\OlQ NDXSXQJLQRVLHQ OlSL HWHOllQ XUR RQ RKMDWWX VXXUHOWD RVLQ YLHPlULSXWNLLQ MD NHLQRWHNRLVLLQ XRPLLQ (QQHQ 9DUWLRN\OlQODKGHQ SRKMXNNDD 0HOOXQN\OlQSX URRQ \KW\\ VLWl SLHQHPSL %URlQGDQSXUR HWRODQ PXNDDQ YLUWDDPD ±OVMDYHGHQNLLQWRDLQHSLWRLVXXV±PJOYDLKWHOHYDWSXURVVD K\YLQSDOMRQVDGDQQDVWDULLSSXHQ9DOXPDDOXHHVWDRQVDYHDMRNDOlSlL VHHKXRQRVWLYHWWl0HOOXQN\OlQSXURRQNXYDWWXP\ V-DODYDQMXONDLVXV VD %URlQGDQSXUR 0HOOXQN\OlQSXURQ VXXULQ VLYXXRPD%URlQGDQSXUR NXYD RQ SLWXXGHOWDDQ NP NRUNHXVHURD PHUHQ SLQQDVWD NHUW\\ P MD VHQ YDOXPDDOXH RQ NP HWROD XURXRPD VDD DONXQVD LOPHLVHVWL OlKWHHVWl 9DQWDDQ NDXSXQJLQ/lQVLPlHVVlMDYLUWDDVXRUDYLLYDLVHVWL0HOOXQN\OlQOXKWDQLLWW\DOXHHQ KDONL\KW\HQ0HOOXQN\OlQSXURRQYlKlQHQQHQ9DUWLRN\OlQODKWHD%URlQGDQSX URQ\PSlULVW RQWlUNHllLWlKHOVLQNLOlLVWlYLUNLVW\VDOXHWWD

10 +HOVLQJLQNDXS\PSlULVW NHVNMXONDLVXMD5LVFR1 HOOLNND XYD0HOOXQN\OlQSXURQYDOXPDDOXHMDKDYDLQWRSDLNDW $LQHLVWRMDPHQHWHOPlW 7XWNLPXVPHQHWHOPlWRYDWQRXGDWWDQHHWSllRVLQYXRQQDMXONDLVWXD\KWHLV HXURRSSDODLVWDVWDQGDUGLHVLW\VWl HOO\\P 1l\WWHHQRWWR 1l\WWHHWNHUlWWLLQNHVlDLNDDQNXQYLUWDDPDSXURLVVDROLSLHQLWDXOXNRVVDHVL WHW\LOWl KDYDLQWRSDLNRLOWD 7lOO LQ SLVWHNXRUPLWXNVHVWD WXOHYDQ RUJDDQLVHQ DL QHHQMDUDYLQWHLGHQYDLNXWXVYRLGDDQKDYDLWDSLLOHYLVVlVHONHlPPLQNXLQVXXUHQ YLUWDDPDQ DLNDDQ (ORUDQWD $QGHUVVRQ LLOHYlQl\WWHHW RWHWWLLQ NLLQ WHLOWlDOXVWRLOWDNHVlKHLQlNXXVVDMDKHLQlNXXVVD<OHHQVlDOXVWDROL NLYLPXWWDNDKGHOODKDYDLQWRSDLNDOODSLLOHYlQl\WWHHWRWHWWLLQSXXSDODOWDXXRQ DOXVWDQDQLXNNDUDYLQWHLQHQMRWHQVHQHLROHWHWWXYDLNXWWDYDQWXORNVLLQ1l\WWHHW NHUlWWLLQ NRNRRPDQl\WWHLQl MRWWD PDKGROOLVHW SLHQ\PSlULVW LKLQ OLLWW\YlW HURW WXORNVLVVD VDDWLLQ PLQLPRLGXLNVL LLOHYlW LUURWHWWLLQ DOXVWRLOWD KDUMDDPDOOD MD Ql\WWHHWNHUlWWLLQHGXVWDYLOWDSDLNRLOWDQRLQFPVXXUXLVLOWDNLYLOWlMRLWDYD OLWWLLQ KDYDLQWRDOXHHOWD VDWXQQDLVHVWL DLQDNLQ YLLVL NDSSDOHWWD 0HQHWHOPlQ OXRQWHHQDQVLRVWDNYDQWLWDWLLYLQHQQl\WWHHQRWWRHLROHWDUSHHQ PXWWD PXLVWLLQ SDQRLVVDMDQl\WWHHQRWRVVDSLWllROODSHUXVWHHOOLQHQ(ORUDQWD

11 +HOVLQJLQNDXS\PSlULVW NHVNMXONDLVXMD 5LVFR1 HOOLNND 1l\WWHLGHQNlVLWWHO\MDSLLOHYLHQODMLPllULW\V LLOHYlQl\WWHHWNlVLWHOWLLQMDODMLVWRPllULWHWWLLQ+HOVLQJLQ \OLRSLVWRQ /LPQROR JLDQ MD \PSlULVW QVXRMHOXQ ODLWRNVHOOD LLOHYlQl\WWHHW SXKGLVWHWWLLQ HORSHUlL VHVWlDLQHNVHVWDKDSSRNHLWROOD DDGXLVWDQl\WWHLVWlGH NDQWRLWLLQ KDSSRMllPlW MD YDOPLVWHWWLLQ NHVWRSUHSDUDDWLW PLNURVNRRSSLVWD DQD O\\VLl YDUWHQ 0HQHWHOPlQ WDUNHPSL NXYDXV RQ VHORVWHWWX 5LVFRQ SUR JUDGX W\ VVl -RNDLVHVWD Ql\WWHHVWl PllULWHWWLLQ MD ODVNHWWLLQ SLLOHYlQ NXRUWD YDORPLNURVNRRSLOOD ±NHUWDLVHOOD VXXUHQQXNVHOOD IDDVLNRQWUDV WLRSWLLNNDDNl\WWlHQ,QGHNVLWMDOXRNLWWHOXW $LQHLVWRQ NlVLWWHO\VVl Nl\WHWWLLQ K\YlNVL 2PQLGLDWLHWRNDQWDD /HFRLQWH \P MRNDVLVlOWllSLLOHYLVWlNHUlW\QHNRORJLVHQWLHGRQMDODVNHHMRXNRQHULODL VLDYHGHQWLODDNXYDDYLDOLNDDQWXPLVLQGHNVHMlHNRORJLVLDOXRNLWWHOXMDMDPXLWD WXQQXVOXNXMD $LQHLVWRQ WDUNDVWHOXXQ SDUKDDNVL WRGHWXW (ORUDQWD (OR UDQWD $QGHUVVRQ(ORUDQWD(ORUDQWD ZDQGUDQV 5LVFR SLLOHYlLQGHNVLWROLYDWRUJDDQLVWDNXRUPLWXVWDNXYDDYD,6LQGHNVLRO OXWLRQ6HQVLWLYLW\,QGH[&(0$*5()MRVWDNl\WHWllQWlVVlQLPLW\VWl SLODDQWXQHLVXXVLQGHNVL VHNl UHKHY\\VWDVRD NXYDDYD 7',LQGHNVL 7URSKLF 'LDWRP,QGH[ HOO\ :KLWWRQ9HUWDLOXMHQKHOSRWWDPLVHNVLLQGHNVLHQ DUYRWPXXQQHWWLLQVDPDDQDVWHLNNRRQ±,6LQGHNVLQDUYRNXYDDSDUDVWD YHGHQODDWXDWDXOXNNRMD7',LQGHNVLQDUYRNXYDDVXXULQWDUHKHY\\VWD VRDYHGHVVlWDXOXNNR/LVlNVLWDUNDVWHOWLLQLQGLNDDWWRULU\KPLHQVXKWHHOOLVLD RVXXNVLD 9DQ 'DP \P SLLOHYl\KWHLV LVVl 7lVVl W\ VVl Nl\WHWWLLQ RU JDDQLVWDNXRUPLWXVWDMDKDMRWXVWRLPLQQDQRVXXWWDNXYDDYDDVDSURELDOXRNLWXVWD WDXOXNNRWXRWWDYXXWWDMDUDYLQWHLVXXWWDNXYDDYDDWURILDOXRNLWXVWDVHNlW\S SLPHWDEROLDD MD KDSSLYDDWLPXVWD NXYDDYLD OXRNLWXNVLD 9HGHVVl RQ DLQD SLLOH YlODMHMD MRWND S\VW\YlW WRLVLD SDUHPPLQ K\ G\QWlPllQ PP MlWHYHVLVVl UXQ VDDPSLQDROHYLDRUJDDQLVLDW\SSL\KGLVWHLWlNXQWDDVQLXNDVWLNXRUPLWHWXLVVDMD UXQVDVKDSSLVLVVD YHVLVVl YDOOLWVHYDW ODMLW MRWND Nl\WWlYlW KDSHWWXQHLWD HSlRU JDDQLVHQW\SHQPXRWRMD(ORUDQWDE 9HVLQl\WWHHW 9XRQQD\PSlULVW NHVNXNVHQRPDQWXWNLPXNVHQ\KWH\GHVVlRWHWWLLQSLL OHYlQl\WWHLGHQOLVlNVL P\ V YHVLQl\WWHHW 6l\QlVODKGHQSXURVWD 9LLNLQRMDVWD MD %URlQGDQSXURVWD MRWND DQDO\VRLWLLQ +HOVLQJLQ NDXSXQJLQ \PSlULVW NHVNXNVHQ \PSlULVW ODERUDWRULRVVD WDXOXNNR 9HVLQl\WWHHW RWHWWLLQ VDPDOOD YLLNROOD NXLQ SLLOHYlQl\WWHHW,QGLNDDWWRULEDNWHHUHLVWD PllULWHWWLLQ OlPS NHVWRLVWHQ NR OLPXRWRLVWHQ EDNWHHULHQ OXNXPllUl MRLGHQ VXXUL PllUl LQGLNRL XORVWHSHUlLVWl NXRUPLWXVWD

12 +HOVLQJLQNDXS\PSlULVW NHVNMXONDLVXMD5LVFR1 HOOLNND 7DXOXNNR XURMHQ SLLOHYlKDYDLQWRSDLNDW MD QLLGHQ VLMDLQWL NDUWWDNRRUGLQDD WLVWRMlUMHVWHOPlOOlNHVlOOlMD6LYXXRPLHQKDYDLQWRSDLNNDNRRGHLVVD RQQXPHURQOLVlNVLNLUMDLQ +DYDLQWR 1l\WWHHQ 6LMDLQWL - SDLNND 1LPL RWWRDLND 0b 0lWlMRNL±0\\UPlNL 0b 0lWlMRNLNDXSXQJLQUDMD 0b$ +DNXQLQPDDQRMD 0b 0lWlMRNL DQQHOPlNL 0b$ 0DOPLQNDUWDQRQRMD 0b% RQDODQRMD 0b& /DVVLODQRMD 0b 0lWlMRNL/DVVLOD 0b 0lWlMRNLLWlMlQPlNL 0b 0lWlMRNL7DOL 0b$ DMDPlHQRMD 0b 0lWlMRNL,VR+XRSDODKWL 5( 5HNRODQRMD6LHSSRULQQH 5( 5HNRODQRMD6DYLPDDQWLH 5( 5HNRODQRMD RUVR 5($ XORPlNL 5( 5HNRODQRMD5HNROD 5( 5HNRODQRMD RLYXN\Ol 5( 5HNRODQRMD+LHNNDKDUMX 5( 5HNRODQRMD-RNLQLHPL 6l\QlVODKGHQSXUR/DWRNDUWDQRQNDDUHQ DODSXROHOOD 6l\QlVODKGHQSXUR*DUGHQLD 6l\QlVODKGHQSXUR 9LLNLQRMD0DOPLQKDXWDXVPDDOWDWXOHYD SXURKDDUD 9LLNLQRMD LYLNRVWDWXOHYDSXURKDDUD 9LLNLQRMD 0( 0HOOXQN\OlQSXUR5DMDN\Ol 0( 0HOOXQN\OlQSXURNDXSXQJLQUDMD 0( 0HOOXQN\OlQSXUR$DUUHSXLVWR 0($ 8QWDPDODWLH 0(% 0HOOXQN\Ol5HNLWLH 0( 0HOOXQN\OlQSXUR2MDSXLVWR 0( 0HOOXQNSXUR7DQNRYDLQLRQWLH 0($ %URlQGDQSXUR0HODWLH 0( 0HOOXQN\OlQSXUR9DUMDNDQSXLVWR %URlQGDQSXUR1LLQLVDDUHQWLH 0($ %URlQGDQSXUR0HODWLHQVLOWD 0( %URlQGDQSXUR0HOOXQN\OlQSXURQ\K W\PlNRKGDQDODSXROHOOD

13 +HOVLQJLQNDXS\PSlULVW NHVNMXONDLVXMD 5LVFR1 HOOLNND 7DXOXNNR 9HGHQ ODDGXQ OXRNLWXV SLLOHYl\KWHLV LKLQ SHUXVWXYDOOD SLODDQWX QHLVXXVLQGHNVLOOl,6(ORUDQWDMD6RLQLQHQ 9HGHQODDWX,6 (ULQRPDLQHQ +\Yl 7\\G\WWlYl 9lOWWlYl +XRQR! ± ± ± 7DXOXNNR 9HGHQ ODDGXQ OXRNLWXV SLLOHYl\KWHLV LKLQ SHUXVWXYDOOD UHKH Y\\VLQGHNVLOOl7',(ORUDQWDMD6RLQLQHQ 5HKHY\\VWDVR 1LXNNDWXRWWRLQHQHOLYlKlUDYLQWHLQHQHOL ROLJRWURILQHQ 2OLJRPHVRWURILQHQ 0HVRWURILQHQ 0HVRHXWURILQHQ 5XQVDVWXRWWRLQHQHOLUXQVDVUDYLQWHLQHQHOL HXWURILQHQ 7', ± ± ±! 7DXOXNNRLLOHYlODMLHQVDSURELDQLQGLNDDWWRULW\\SLW 6DSURELDW\\SSL 2OLJRVDSUREL 0HVRVDSUREL RO\VDSUREL 6HOLWH 9lKlVVlRUJDDQLVHQDLQHHQPllUlVVlYLLKW\Yl HVNLPllUlLVHVVlRUJDDQLVHQDLQHHQPllUlV VlYLLKW\Yl 5XQVDDVVDRUJDDQLVHQDLQHHQPllUlVVlYLLK W\Yl 7DXOXNNR+HOVLQJLQNDXSXQJLQ\PSlULVW NHVNXNVHQ\PSlULVW ODERUDWRULRV VDWHKG\WYHVLDQDO\\VLW $QDO\\VL 0HQHWHOPl OlPS WLOD OlPS PLWWDUL S+ 6)6 KDSHQSLWRLVXXV 6)6 MRKWRN\N\ 6)6(1 YlULOXNX 6)6(1,62 NLLQWRDLQH 6)6(1 DONDDOLWHHWWL 6)6(1,62 &2' 0Q 6)6 W\SHQNRNRQDLVSLWRLVXXV +DSHWXV12 NVLNDOLXPSHURNVR GLVXOIDDWLOODDXWRNODDYLVVD IRVIRULQNRNRQDLVSLWRLVXXV +DSHWXV2 NVLNDOLXPSHURNVR GLVXOIDDWLOODDXWRNODDYLVVD 2 IRVIRULQSLWRLVXXV 6)6 OlPS NHVWRLVWHQNROLPXRWRLVWHQ 6)6 EDNWHHULHQWLKH\V

14 +HOVLQJLQNDXS\PSlULVW NHVNMXONDLVXMD5LVFR1 HOOLNND 7XORNVHWMDWXORVWHQWDUNDVWHOX 7lVVl W\ VVl Nl\WHWW\MHQ,6 MD 7',SLLOHYlLQGHNVLHQ YlOLQHQ NRUUHODDWLR RQ WLODVWROOLVHVWLHULWWlLQPHUNLWVHYlU Q S RUUHODDWLRRQQH JDWLLYLQHQ NRVND 7',LQGHNVLQ DUYR SLHQHQHH MD,6LQGHNVLQ DUYR VXXUHQHH YHGHQODDGXQSDUDQWXHVVD 0lWlMRNL 0lWlMRHQ YHGHQ ODDWX ROL SLLOHYlWXWNLPXNVHQ SHUXVWHHOOD W\\G\WWlYl MD WLODQQH NXPPDQNLQLQGHNVLQSHUXVWHHOODYDUVLQVDPDQODLQHQNXYDW±9HGHQODDWX KXRQRQLSLODDQWXQHLVXXVLQGHNVLQ,6MDUDYLQWHLVXXWWDNXYDDYDQ7',LQGHNVLQ SHUXVWHHOOD KLWDDVWL 7DOLD NRKWL KDYDLQWRSDLNND 0b XPPDQNLQ LQGHNVLQ SHUXVWHHOOD0lWlMRNHHQODVNHYDWVLYXXRPDWROLYDWSllKDDUDDKHLNNRODDWXLVHP SLD OXNXXQ RWWDPDWWD YDUVLQ K\YlNXQWRLVWD +DNXQLQPDDQRMDD 7',LQGHNVLVVl QlN\\ VHOYlVWL UDYLQWHLGHQ YlKHQHPLQHQ SXURYHGHVWl 7DOLQ DOXHHOOD DMDPl HQRMDQ \KG\WW\l 0lWlMRNHHQ 7DOLQ MlONHHQ OlKHOOl,VR+XRSDODKWHD 0lWlMRHQ YHGHQODDWX ODDWX KXRQRQL XXGHOOHHQ 7DOLQ YDQKDQ NDDWRSDLNDQ YDOXPDYHGHW WRGHQQlN LVHVWL DLKHXWWLYDW SXURYHGHQ ODDGXQ KHLNNHQHPLVHQ,6LQGHNVLQ NHVNLDUYRROLSXURVVDW\\G\WWlYlMD7',LQGHNVLQPHVRWURILQHQHOL NHVNLPllUlLQHQWXRWWDYXXV 0lWlMRHQ SllXRPDVVD KDOOLWVHYDQD ODMLQD ROL K\Yll YHGHQ ODDWXD LQGLNRLYD $FKQDQWKHV PLQXWLVVLPD ± KDYDLQWRSDLNNRMD 0b MD 0b OXNXXQ RWWDPDWWD WDXOXNNR /DML RQ NXLWHQNLQ K\YLQ \OHLQHQ MD HNRORJLVLOWD YDDWL PXNVLOWDDQODDMDDODLQHQ0bOODHVLLQW\LUXQVDLPSDQD1DYLFXODPLQLPD MD0bOOD1JUHJDULDMRWNDPROHPPDWRYDWKXRQRQYHGHQODDGXQ LQGLNDDWWRUHLWD1 JUHJDULD ROL \OHLQHQ P\ V KXRQRNXQWRLVLVVD VLYXSXURLVVD +\YlNXQWRLVHVVD+DNXQLQPDDQRMDVVD0b$HVLLQW\LUXQVDDQD$PLQXWLVVL PDQ OLVlNVL )UDJLODULD FDSXFLQDD MRND RQ P\ VNLQ HNRORJLVLOWD YDDWLPXNVLO WDDQODDMDDODLQHQ 7DUNDVWHOWDHVVD SLLOHYl\KWHLV MHQ MDNDXWXPLVWD HUL WURILDOXRNNLLQ RQ 0lWlMRHQ \OlMXRNVXOODMRSDYLLGHVRVDSLLOHYLVWlROLJRWURILDQLQGLNDDWWRUHLWDMDHXWUR ILDQLQGLNDDWWRUHLWDNXYD0XLOODKDYDLQWRSDLNRLOODROLJRWURILDQLQGLNDDWWR UHLWD ROL K\YLQ YlKlQ /DVVLODQRMDQ MD /DVVLODQ KDYDLQWRSDLNRLOOD ROLJRWURILDQ LQGLNDDWWRUHLWDHLKDYDLWWXODLQNDDQ 6DSURELDOXRNLWXNVHQ PXNDDQ YDOWDRVD SLLOHYLVWl ROL PHVRVDSUREHMD PXWWD SR O\VDSUREHMDROL±NXYD 9DOWDRVD 0lWlMRHQ SLLOHYl\KWHLV LVWl ROL NRUNHDVVD YHGHQ KDSSLSLWRLVXXGHVVD YLLKW\YLlOXNXXQRWWDPDWWD0DOPLQNDUWDQRQRMDQ0b$MD RQDODQRMDQ0b %KDYDLQWRSDLNNRMDMRLVVDYDOWDRVDSLLOHYLVWlROLDOKDLVHVVDYHGHQKDSSLSLWRL VXXGHVVDYLLKW\YLlNXYD7lPlRVRLWWDDP\ VNLQQlLGHQVLYXXRPLHQKXR QRNXQWRLVXXWWD

15 +HOVLQJLQNDXS\PSlULVW NHVNMXONDLVXMD 5LVFR1 HOOLNND 7\SSLPHWDEROLDOWDDQ 0lWlMRHQ SLLOHYl\KWHLV W ROLYDW VXXUHOWD RVLQ W\SHQ VXK WHHQDXWRWURIHMDHLYlWWDUYLWVHRUJDDQLVWDW\SSHlYDLNNDIDNXOWDWLLYLVHVWLKHWH URWURILVLDNLQ SLLOHYLl HVLLQW\L SDLNRLQ YDUVLQ SDOMRQ NXYD )DNXOWDWLLYLVHW KHWHURWURILWYRLYDWNl\WWllK\YlNVHHQRUJDDQLVLDW\SSL\KGLVWHLWl XYD0lWlMRHQOXRNLWXVNDUWWD,6LQGHNVLQ PXNDDQNHVlOOl XYD0lWlMRHQOXRNLWXVNDUWWD7',LQGHNVLQ PXNDDQNHVlOOl

16 +HOVLQJLQNDXS\PSlULVW NHVNMXONDLVXMD5LVFR1 HOOLNND 7DXOXNNR0lWlMRHQKDYDLQWRSDLNRLOWDODVNHWWXMHQSLLOHYlODMLHQUXQVDXV7DXOXNRVVDRQ HVLWHWW\QlQHODMLWMRLGHQVXKWHHOOLQHQRVXXVROL LLOHYlODML +DYDLQWRSDLNDW $ $ % & $ $FKQDQWKHVPLQXWLVVLPD K &\PEHOODKXVWHGWLL K )UDJLODULDFDSXFLQD KÃU *RPSKRQHPDSDUYXOXP S 1DYLFXODJUHJDULD U 1PLQLPD S 1VHPLQXOXP S 1LW]VFKLDDPSKLELD SÃU 1SDOHD S 1WXELFROD 5KRLFRVSKHQLDDEEUHYLDWD KÃU 6XULUHOODEUHELVVRQLL U 7DEHOODULDIORFFXORVD K K K\YlQ YlKlQRUJDDQLVWDDLQHWWD YHGHQ ODDGXQ LQGLNDDWWRUL S KXRQRQ asdomrqrujddqlvwd DLQHWWD YHGHQ ODDGXQ LQGLNDDWWRUL,6LQGHNVLHQPXNDDQVHNlU UHKHYlQYHGHQLQGLNDDWWRULMD WROHUDQWWL+RIIPDQQLQPXNDDQ 5HNRODQRMD 5HNRODQRMDROL,6LQGHNVLQSHUXVWHHOODYlOWWlYlVVlNHVNLDUYRLOPDQKD YDLQWRSDLNNDD 5( $ NXQQRVVD NXYD LLOHYlLQGHNVLHQ PXNDDQ YHVL ROL KHLNNRODDWXLVWD MR HQVLPPlLVHOOl KDYDLQWRSDLNDOOD 6LHSSRULQWHHVVl MD 1LV VLQRMDQWXRPDKXRQRODDWXLQHQYHVLKXRQRQVLVLWlHGHOOHHQ XORPlHQRMDQ5( $ DQVLRVWD 5HNRODQRMDQ YHGHQ ODDWX SDUDQL SXURQ NHVNLYDLKHLOOD 7', LQGHNVLQ PXNDDQ SXUR ROL UHKHYl NHVNLDUYR LOPDQ KDYDLQWRSDLNNDD 5( $MD XORPlHQRMDVWDYLUUDQQXWPHONRYlKlUDYLQWHLQHQYHVL7',LQGHNVL HLMXXULNDDQSDUDQWDQXWSllXRPDQYHGHQODDWXDNXYD 5HNRODQRMDVVDROLYDW\OHLVLlUXQVDVUDYLQWHLVXXWWDVXRVLYDW1DYLFXODVXYXQODMLW 1JUHJDULD1ODQFHRODWD1PLQLPD1VDSURSKLOD MD 1 VHPLQXOXP WDX OXNNR1lLVWlUXQVDLQROL1DYLFXODPLQLPD+DYDLQWRSDLNDOOD5( XORPl HQRMDQVLYXKDDUDQDODSXROHOODROLKDOOLWVHYDQDK\YlQYHGHQODDGXQLQGLNDDWWRUL $FKQDQWKHV ODQFHRODWD MRND HVLLQW\L \OHLVHQl P\ V PXLOOD KDYDLQWRSDLNRLOOD +\YlNXQWRLVHVVD XORPlHQRMDVVDHVLLQW\LYlWUXQVDLQD$FKQDQWKHVPLQXWLVVLPD MD&\PEHOODPLQXWDMRWNDRYDWK\YlQYHGHQODDGXQLQGLNDDWWRUHLWD ± 5HNRODQRMDQ SLLOHYl\KWHLV MHQ VROXLVWD ROL HXWURILDQ LQGLNDDWWRUHLWD NXYD 0XXW WXWNLWXW SXURW HLYlW ROOHHW QlLQ VHONHlVWL SLLOHYl\KWHLV OWllQ UHKHYlQYHGHQLQGLNDDWWRUHLWD+\YlNXQWRLVHQVLYXKDDUDQ XORPlHQRMDQSLL OHYl\KWHLV ROLSllKDDUDVWDSRLNNHDYDMDVLHOOlHXWURILDQLQGLNDDWWRUHLGHQRVXXV ROLQRLQ 6DSURELDOXRNLWXNVHOWDDQ 5HNRODQRMDQ SLLOHYl\KWHLV LVWl SXROHW ROL SRO\VDSUR EHMD NXYD 7lPl ROL WXWNLWXLVWD SXURLVWD VXXULQ SRO\VDSURELVWHQ RVXXV MD

17 +HOVLQJLQNDXS\PSlULVW NHVNMXONDLVXMD 5LVFR1 HOOLNND NHUWRRSXURYHGHQVXXUHVWDRUJDDQLVHQDLQHHQPllUlVWl XORPlHQRMDSRLNNHVL P\ VWlPlQRPLQDLVXXGHQVXKWHHQMDVLHOOlSRO\VDSUREHMDROLYDLQ 9lKlKDSSLVHVVDYHGHVVlYLLKW\YLlSLLOHYLlROL5HNRODQRMDVVD\OlMXRNVXOODYDO WDRVD NXQ WDDV DODMXRNVXOOD QLLQ NHVNLPllUlLVLVVl NXLQ NRUNHLVVD KDSSLSLWRL VXXNVLVVDYLLKW\YLlSLLOHYLlROLVDPDQYHUUDQNXYD 5HNRODQRMDQSLLOHYLVWlYDLQDOOHSXROHWROLW\SSLPHWDEROLDOWDDQDXWRWURIHMDNX YD+HWHURWURIHMDWDUYLWVHYDWRUJDDQLVWDW\SSHlROLYlKlQPXWWDIDNXOWDWLL YLVHVWLKHWHURWURIHMDROLOlKHVSXROHWMRNDROLHQHPPlQNXLQPXLVVDWXWNLWXLVVD SXURLVVD XYD5HNRODQRMDQOXRNLWXVNDUWWD,6LQGHNVLQ PXNDDQNHVlOOl XYD5HNRODQRMDQOXRNLWXVNDUWWD7', LQGHNVLQPXNDDQNHVlOOl

18 +HOVLQJLQNDXS\PSlULVW NHVNMXONDLVXMD5LVFR1 HOOLNND 7DXOXNNR 5HNRODQRMDQ KDYDLQWRSDLNRLOWD ODVNHWWXMHQ SLLOHYlODMLHQ UXQVDXV 7DXOXNRVVDRQHVLWHWW\QlQHODMLWMRLGHQVXKWHHOOLQHQRVXXVROL 8 LLOHYlODML +DYDLQWRSDLNDW $ $FKQDQWKHVODQFHRODWD K $PLQXWLVVLPD K &\PEHOODPLQXWD K 1DYLFXODJUHJDULD U 1ODQFHRODWD U 1PLQLPD S 1VDSURSKLOD S 1VHPLQXOXP S K K\YlQ YlKlQRUJDDQLVWDDLQHWWDYHGHQODDGXQLQGLNDDWWRULS KXRQRQaSDOMRQRUJDDQLVWDDLQHW WDYHGHQODDGXQLQGLNDDWWRUL,6LQGHNVLHQPXNDDQVHNlU UHKHYlQYHGHQLQGLNDDWWRULMD WROHUDQWWL +RIIPDQQLQPXNDDQ 9LLNNL 6l\QlVODKGHQSXUR 6l\QlVODKGHQSXURQYHGHQODDWXYDLKWHOLSXURQHULRVLVVD,6MD7',LQGHNVLHQ DUYRLVVDNXYDW±QlN\\VDPDQODLQHQYHGHQODDGXQSDUDQHPLQHQDODYLUWDDQ 9HGHQ SLODDQWXQHLVXXWWD RUJDDQLVHQ DLQHHQ PllUl VDSURELD NXYDDYDQ,6 LQGHNVLQ NHVNLDUYR ROL YlOWWlYl MD YHGHQ UHKHY\\WWl NXYDDYDQ 7', LQGHNVLQ PHVRHXWURILQHQ /DKGHQYl\OlQ HWHOlSXROHOOD,6 LQGHNVLQ PXNDDQ SXURQ YHGHQ ODDWX ROL KXRQR PLNl YLLWWDD VXXUHHQ RU JDDQLVHHQNXRUPLWXNVHHQ*DUGHQLDQNRKGDOODYHGHQODDWXROLKLHPDQSDUHPSL,6LQGHNVL W\\G\WWlYl$ODMXRNVXOODYHGHQODDWXROL,6LQGHNVLQPX NDDQ HGHOOLVWl KLHPDQ KXRQRPSL 7',LQGHNVLQ PXNDDQ YHVL ROL \OlMXRNVXOOD K\YLQ UHKHYll *DUGHQLDQ NRKGDOOD PHONR UHKHYll MD OlKHOOl 9DQKDQNDXSXQ JLQODKWHDPHVRWURILVWD +\YlQYHGHQODDGXQLQGLNDDWWRUL$FKQDQWKHVPLQXWLVVLPDROLKDOOLWVHYDQDODMLQD KDYDLQWRSDLNRLOOD MD WDXOXNNR PXWWD YDLQ PXXWDPLD VROXMD ODV NHWWLLQ KDYDLQWRSDLNDOOD /DWYDSLVWHHVVl KDOOLWVHYLD ODMHMD ROLYDW KXRQRQYHGHQODDGXQLQGLNDDWWRULW1DYLFXODJUHJDULD1VHPLQXOXPMD1VDS URSKLOD*DUGHQLDQNRKGDQKDYDLQWRSDLNDOODHVLLQW\L$FKQDQWKHVPLQXWLV VLPDQ OLVlNVL P\ V KXRQRD YHGHQ ODDWXD LQGLNRLYDW 1DYLFXOD JUHJDULD MD 1 VDSURSKLOD $ODMXRNVXOOD $FKQDQWKHV PLQXWLVVLPD ROL DLQRD KDOOLWVHYD ODML PXWWD YLLGHQ KXRQRQ YHGHQ ODDGXQ LQGLNDDWWRULQ UXQVDXV KXRQRQVL SLLOH YlLQGHNVLDUYRD7lOOlKDYDLQWRSDLNDOODWDYDWWLLQMRLWDNLQVXRODLVWDYHWWlVXRVLYLD ODMHMD 6l\QlVODKGHQSXURVVD PHVRVDSURELDOXRNDOOD ROL VXXULQ RVXXV MD ROLJRVDSURELD OXRNDOODROLK\YLQSLHQLRVXXVNXYD*DUGHQLDQKDYDLQWRSDLNDOODPH VRVDSURELDOXRNDQ RVXXV ROL VXXUHPSL NXLQ NDKGHOOD PXXOOD KDYDLQWRSDLNDOOD RO\VDSURELVWHQODMLHQRVXXVYlKHQLODWYDKDYDLQWRSDLNDOWDSXURQNHVNLYDLKHHOOH WXOWDHVVDMDSRO\VDSURELVWHQODMLHQRVXXVNDVYRLXXGHVWDDQNRKWLDODMXRNVXD

19 +HOVLQJLQNDXS\PSlULVW NHVNMXONDLVXMD 5LVFR1 HOOLNND XYD6l\QlVODKGHQSXURQMD9LLNLQRMDQOXRNLWXVNDUWWD,6LQGHNVLQPXNDDQ NHVlOOl (XWURILDQLQGLNDDWWRULODMLHQRVXXVVROXLVWDROLSXURQODWYDKDYDLQWRSDLNDOOD MDYDVWRLQRGRWXNVLDRVXXVVXXUHQL*DUGHQLDQNRKGDOOHWXOWDHVVDNXYD $ODMXRNVXOOD HXWURILDQ LQGLNDDWWRULHQ RVXXV ROL 5HKHYlVVl YHGHVVl YLLKW\YLHQ SLLOHYLHQ RVXXV ROL OlKHV \KWl VXXUL NXLQ KXRQRNXQWRLVHVVD 5HNR ODQRMDVVD XURQ ODWYDKDYDLQWRSDLNDOOD DOKDLVLD KDSSLSLWRLVXXNVLD VXRVLYLHQ ODMLHQ PllUl ROLVXXULMDYDVWDDYDVWLNRUNHDDKDSSLSLWRLVXXWWDVXRVLYLDODMHMDROLYlKlQNXYD +DSSLWLODQQHYDLNXWWDLVLSDUDQHYDQWDVDLVHVWLDODYLUWDDQ DLNLOOD KDYDLQWRSDLNRLOOD \OL SXROHW SLLOHYLVWl ROL W\SSLPHWDEROLDOWDDQ 1 DXWRWURIHMD NXYD 1LLGHQ RVXXV ROL VDPD NXLQ 5HNRODQRMDVVD )DNXOWDWLL YLVWHQ 1KHWHURWURILHQ RVXXV S\V\L VXKWHHOOLVHQ VXXUHQD NDLNLOOD KDYDLQWRSDL NRLOODMD1KHWHURWURILHQPllUlNDNVLQNHUWDLVWXLDODMXRNVXQKDYDLQWRSDLNDOOD 6l\QlVODKGHQSXURQXRPDQVLMDLQQLQMDYDOXPDDOXHHQSHUXVWHOODYRLGDDQROHW WDD HWWl SXURD NXRUPLWWDYDW HQLWHQ 0DOPLQ KDXWDXVPDDQ HWHOlSllVWl WXOHYDW YHGHW6LHOOlOlPS NHVWRLVWHQNROLPXRWRLVWHQEDNWHHULHQWLKH\VROLP\ VVXXUL MRWHQ SXURRQ SllVHH LOPHLVHVWL YLHPlULYHWWl 9HVLNHPLDOOLVWHQ WXORVWHQ SHUXV WHHOODIRVIRULSLWRLVXXVROLDODMXRNVXQKDYDLQWRSDLNDOODKXRPDWWDYDVWLNRUNHDPSL NXLQ\OlMXRNVXQKDYDLQWRSDLNRLOODWDXOXNNRMRWHQIRVIRULDRQOXXOWDYDVWL

20 +HOVLQJLQNDXS\PSlULVW NHVNMXONDLVXMD5LVFR1 HOOLNND XYD6l\QlVODKGHQSXURQMD9LLNLQRMDQOXRNLWXVNDUWWD7',LQGHNVLQPXNDDQ NHVlOOl 7DXOXNNR 6l\QlVODKGHQSXURQ KDYDLQWRSDLNRLOWD ODVNHWWXMHQ SLLOHYlODMLHQ UXQVDXV7DXOXNRVVDRQHVLWHWW\QlQHODMLWMRLGHQVXKWHHOOLQHQRVXXVROL 8 LLOHYlODML +DYDLQWRSDLNDW $FKQDQWKHVODQFHRODWD K $PLQXWLVVLPD K 1DYLFXODJUHJDULD U 1PLQLPD S 1VDSURSKLOD S 1VHPLQXOXP S 1LW]VFKLDSDOHD S K K\YlQ YlKlQRUJDDQLVWDDLQHWWDYHGHQODDGXQLQGLNDDWWRULS KXRQRQaSDOMRQRUJDDQLVWDDLQHW WDYHGHQODDGXQLQGLNDDWWRUL,6LQGHNVLHQPXNDDQVHNlU UHKHYlQYHGHQLQGLNDDWWRULMD WROHUDQWWL +RIIPDQQLQPXNDDQ

21 +HOVLQJLQNDXS\PSlULVW NHVNMXONDLVXMD 5LVFR1 HOOLNND 7DXOXNNR9HVLNHPLDOOLVWHQDQDO\\VLHQWXORNVHW6l\QlVODKGHQSXURVWDYLLNROODKHLQl NXXVVD +DYDLQWR SDLNND S+ 2 -RKWR N\N\ 9lUL LLQWR DLQH $ONDOL WHHWWL &2' 0Q RN1 RN 2 /lps NHVW NROLEDNW PJO P6P PJWO PJO PPROO PJO JO JO JO SP\PO WXOOXW9LLNLQNRHWLODQOlQVLSXROHLVHQSHOORQYDOXPDYHVLVWl RUNHDWRUJDDQLVHQ DLQHHQ MD UDYLQWHLGHQ PllUlW NXOXYDW PDWNDQ DLNDQD ELRORJLVLLQ WRLPLQWRLKLQ 7lPlQSXURQYHGHQODDWXDNDQQDWWDDVHXUDWDMDWNRVVDNLQPllULWWllNXRUPLWXV OlKWHHWMD\ULWWllYlKHQWllUDYLQQHNXRUPLWXVWD(UlVPDKGROOLVXXVSDUDQWDDYH GHQODDWXDRQUDNHQWDDYlOLDOWDLWDMRLVVDUDYLQWHHWNXOXYDWELRORJLVHHQWXRWDQ WRRQ 6l\QlVODKGHQSXURQYHVLNHPLDOOLVLDWXORNVLDWDXOXNNRYHUUDWWLLQP\ V6XR PHQ \PSlULVW NHVNXNVHQ YHVLHQ \OHLVHQ Nl\WW NHOSRLVXXVOXRNLWXNVHQ OXRNND UDMRLKLQ+DYDLQWRSDLNDOODYHVLROLYlULQPXNDDQODDGXOWDDQHULQRPDLVWDMD PXLOOD KDYDLQWRSDLNRLOOD YlOWWlYll±KXRQRD RNRQDLVIRVIRULSLWRLVXXGHQ PX NDDQYHVLROL*DUGHQLDQNRKGDOODYlOWWlYllMDPXLOODKDYDLQWRSDLNRLOODKXRQRD 6XROLVWRSHUlLVWHQ EDNWHHULHQ PllUlQ SHUXVWHHOOD SXURYHVL ROL KXRQRODDWXLVWD l\ww NHOSRLVXXVOXRNLWXVMDSLLOHYlPHQHWHOPlDQWDYDW6l\QlVODKGHQSXURQYH GHQODDGXVWDWlOOHDMDQNRKGDOOHOlKHVVDPDQODLVHQNXYDQ 9LLNLQRMD 9LLNLQRMDQNDLNLOODKDYDLQWRSDLNRLOODYHGHQOLNDDQWXPLVLQGHNVL,6ROLOXRNNDD W\\G\WWlYlNHVNLDUYRNXYD5HKHY\\VLQGHNVLQ7',NHVNLDUYRROL PHVRWURILQHQ MD UHKHY\\V NDVYRL 9LLNLQWLHQ HWHOlSXROHOOD ROHYDOOH KDYDLQWR SDLNDOOH WXOWDHVVD LYLNRVWD WXOHYDQ LWlLVHQ KDDUDQ YLUWDDPD ROL VXXUHPSL MD YHGHQ ODDWX SDUHPSL YHUUDWWXQD 0DOPLQ KDXWDXVPDDOWD SlLQ WXOHYDDQ SXURQ KDDUDDQ 9HGHQ ODDGXQ KHLNNHQHPLQHQ DODMXRNVXD NRKWL MRKWXL LOPHLVLPPLQ 9LLNLQ NRHWLODQ SRKMRLVSXROHOOD ROHYLVWD SHOORLVWD VHNl 0DOPLQ KDXWDXVPDDOWD WXOHYDVWDKXRQRODDWXLVHVWDYHGHVWl +DOOLWVHYLQDODMHLQDROLYDWK\YlQYHGHQODDGXQLQGLNDDWWRULW$FKQDQWKHVPLQX WLVVLPD $ REORQJHOOD MD )UDJLODULD FDSXFLQD VHNl W\\G\WWlYlQ YHGHQ ODDGXQ LQGLNDDWWRUL 1DYLFXOD JUHJDULD WDXOXNNR +DYDLQWRSDLNDOOD YHGHQ ODDWXROLKLHPDQSDUHPSLNXLQPXLOODKDYDLQWRSDLNRLOOD$FKQDQWKHVREORQJHOOD! DNVLNROPDVRVDDSLLOHYLVWlROLKDYDLQWRSDLNRLOODMDPHVRVDSUREHMD NXYD LYLNRQ KDDUDQ KDYDLQWRSDLNDOOD ROL VDPDQ YHUUDQ ROLJRVDSUREHMD PLNl NHUWRR SXURQ K\YlNXQWRLVXXGHVWD WlOOl SDLNDOOD RO\VDSUREHMD ROL Yl KHPPlQNXLQPXLVVDWXWNLWXLVVDSXURLVVDNHVNLPllULQ

22 +HOVLQJLQNDXS\PSlULVW NHVNMXONDLVXMD5LVFR1 HOOLNND 5HKHYlVVlYHGHVVlYLLKW\YLlSLLOHYLlROL9LLNLQRMDVVDYlKHPPlQNXLQ6l\QlV ODKGHQSXURVVDNXYD(QLWHQHXWURILDQLQGLNDDWWRUHLWDWDYDWWLLQKDYDLQWRSDL NRLOODMD+\YlNXQWRLVHVVD LYLNRQKDDUDVVDROLMRSDSLLOHYLVWl YlKlUDYLQWHLVHVVDYHGHVVlYLLKW\YLl 9DOWDRVDSLLOHYLVWlYDDWLNRUNHDDYHGHQKDSSLSLWRLVXXWWDMDQHROLYDWW\SHQVXK WHHQDXWRWURIHMDNXYD 7DXOXNNR 9LLNLQRMDQ KDYDLQWRSDLNRLOWD ODVNHWWXMHQ SLLOHYlODMLHQ UXQVDXV 7DXOXNRVVDRQHVLWHWW\QlQHODMLWMRLGHQVXKWHHOOLQHQRVXXVROL 8 LLOHYlODML +DYDLQWRSDLNDW $FKQDQWKHVPLQXWLVVLPD K $REORQJHOOD K )UDJLODULDFDSXFLQD ÃKÃU 1DYLFXODJUHJDULD U K K\YlQ YlKlQRUJDDQLVWDDLQHWWDYHGHQODDGXQLQGLNDDWWRULS KXRQRQaSDOMRQRUJDDQLVWDDLQHW WDYHGHQODDGXQLQGLNDDWWRUL,6LQGHNVLHQPXNDDQVHNlU UHKHYlQYHGHQLQGLNDDWWRULMD WROHUDQWWL +RIIPDQQLQPXNDDQ 7DXOXNNR9HVLNHPLDOOLVWHQDQDO\\VLHQWXORNVHW9LLNLQRMDVVDYLLNROODKHLQlNXXVVD +DYDLQWR SDLNND S+ 2 -RKWR N\N\ 9lUL LLQWR DLQH $ONDOL WHHWWL &2' 0Q RN1 RN 2 /lps NHVW NROLEDNW PJO P6P PJWO PJO PPROO PJO JO JO JO SP\PO 9LLNLQRMDQ YHVLNHPLDOOLVLD WXORNVLD WDXOXNNR YHUUDWWLLQ YHVLHQ \OHLVHHQ Nl\WW NHOSRLVXXVOXRNLWXNVHHQ 9lULQ SHUXVWHHOOD SXURYHVL ROL KDYDLQWRSDLNDOOD K\Yll MD PXLOOD KDYDLQWRSDLNRLOOD YlOWWlYll±KXRQRD RNRQDLVIRVIRULQ PXNDDQQYHVLROLHULQRPDLVWD LYLNRQKDDUDQYHVLW\\G\WWlYllMD Q YHVL KXRQRD /lps NHVWRLVWHQ NROLPXRWRLVWHQ EDNWHHULHQ PllUlQ PX NDDQSXURYHVLRQNDLNLOODKDYDLQWRSDLNRLOODKXRQRD9HVLNHPLDOOLVWHQDQDO\\VL HQ SHUXVWHHOOD LYLNRQ SXURKDDUDVWD WXOHYD YHVL ROL KXRQRODDWXLVHPSDD NXLQ 0DOPLQKDXWDXVPDDOWD SlLQ WXOHYDQ SXURKDDUDQ YHVL LLOHYlWXWNLPXNVHQ PX NDDQ WLODQQH Ql\WWlLVL NXLWHQNLQ ROHYDQ SlLQYDVWRLQ 7XORVWHQ HULODLVXXWWD YRL VHOLWWllVHHWWlSLLOHYlWUHDJRLYDWYHGHQODDGXQPXXWRNVHHQPXXWDPDQSlLYlQ MlONHHQ NXQ WDDV YHVLNHPLDOOLQHQ DQDO\\VL NXYDD SXURYHGHQ KHWNHOOLVWl WLODQ QHWWD

23 +HOVLQJLQNDXS\PSlULVW NHVNMXONDLVXMD 5LVFR1 HOOLNND,Wl+HOVLQNL 0HOOXQN\OlQSXUR 0HOOXQN\OlQSXURQODWYDRVDROL,6LQGHNVLQPXNDDQK\YlVVlNXQQRVVDPXWWD SXURQYHGHQODDWXKHLNNHQLNRKWL9DUWLRN\OlQODKWHDOlKLQQl\OlMXRNVXOODVLMDLW VHYDQ VLLUWRODSXXWDUKDQ MD DVXWXVDOXHHQ YDOXPDYHVLHQ MD VLYXXRPLHQ WXRPDQ KHLNNRODDWXLVHPPDQYHGHQWDNLDNXYD9LLPHLVHQVLYXXRPDQ%URlQGDQ SXURQWXRPDYHVLROLNXLWHQNLQ0HOOXQN\OlQSXURQYHWWlSDUHPSLODDWXLVWD7', LQGHNVL DQWDPDW WXORNVHW ROLYDW VDPDQVXXQWDLVHW NXYD,6LQGHNVLQ NHV NLDUYRROLSXURVVDW\\G\WWlYlMD7',LQGHNVLQROLJRPHVRWURILQHQ XURVVDHVLLQW\LYDOWDODMLQD$FKQDQWKHVPLQXWLVVLPDWDXOXNNR-RQNLQYHU UDQHVLLQW\LP\ VUHKHYlQYHGHQLQGLNDDWWRULD1DYLFXODJUHJDULDDMRNDROLVL YXXRPDQKDYDLQWRSDLNDOOD$YDOWDODML HVlOOl0HOOXQN\OlQSXURQ DOD MXRNVXOODYDOWDODMLQDROL&\PEHOODVLOHVLDFD MRND RQ K\YlQ YHGHQ ODD GXQLQGLNDDWWRUL 9DOWDRVDQRLQ0HOOXQN\OlQRMDQSLLOHYLVWlNXXOXLPHVRVDSURELDOXRNNDDQ NXYD HVlOOlWLODQQHROLOlKHVVDPDKDYDLQWRSDLNDOOD 0( NXYD (XWURILVLVVD RORLVVD HOlYLHQ SLLOHYLHQ RVXXV NDVYRL SXURQ DODMXRNVXD NRKWL MD QLLGHQRVXXVROLVXXULQKXRQRNXQWRLVLVVDVLYXKDDURLVVDNXYD HVlOOl HXWURILVWHQOHYLHQRVXXVROLODVNHQXWLLQNXYDNXQVHHGHOOLVHQlNH VlQlROLQRLQKDYDLQWRSDLNDOOD0( <OlMXRNVXOODNROPDVRVDSLLOHYLVWlYLLKW\LPDWDODVVDYHGHQKDSSLSLWRLVXXGHVVD PXWWD DODMXRNVXOOD DOOH NXYD 6LYXKDDUDQ KDYDLQWRSDLNDOOD 0( % SXROHWSLLOHYLVWlYLLKW\LPDWDODVVDKDSSLSLWRLVXXGHVVD HVlOOlNRUNHDVVD KDSSLSLWRLVXXGHVVDYLLKW\YLHQRVXXVROLSLHQHQW\Q\WMDNRUYDXWXQXWNHVNLPll UlLVLVVl KDSSLRORLVVD YLLKW\YLOOl OHYLOOl KDYDLQWRSDLNDOOD 0( NXYD 0HOOXQN\OlQRMDQSLLOHYLVWlW\SSLPHWDEROLDOWDDQDXWRWURIHMDROLQRLQNXYD

24 +HOVLQJLQNDXS\PSlULVW NHVNMXONDLVXMD5LVFR1 HOOLNND XYD0HOOXQN\OlQSXURQOXRNLWXVNDUWWD,6 LQGHNVLQPXNDDQNHVlOOl XYD0HOOXQN\OlQSXURQOXRNLWXVNDUWWD7', LQGHNVLQPXNDDQNHVlOOl 7DXOXNNR 0HOOXQN\OlQSXURQ KDYDLQWRSDLNRLOWD ODVNHWWXMHQ SLLOHYlODMLHQ UXQVDXVNHVlOOl7DXOXNRVVDRQQHODMLWMRLGHQVXKWHHOOLQHQRVXXVROL +DYDLQWRSDLNNRMHQMDVLMDLQWLRQVDPD LLOHYlODML +DYDLQWRSDLNDW $ % $ $FKQDQWKHVPLQXWLVVLPD K $REORQJHOOD K &\PEHOODVLOHVLDFD K &VLQXDWD K )UDJLODULDFDSXFLQD ÃKÃU *RPSKRQHPDSDUYXOXP S 1DYLFXODJUHJDULD U 1PLQLPD S 1VHPLQXOXP S K K\YlQ YlKlQRUJDDQLVWDDLQHWWDYHGHQODDGXQLQGLNDDWWRULS KXRQRQaSDOMRQRUJDDQLVWDDLQHW WDYHGHQODDGXQLQGLNDDWWRUL,6LQGHNVLHQPXNDDQVHNlU UHKHYlQYHGHQLQGLNDDWWRULMD WROHUDQWWL +RIIPDQQLQPXNDDQ WXORNVHWKDYDLQWRSDLNDOWDRYDWNHVlOWl

25 +HOVLQJLQNDXS\PSlULVW NHVNMXONDLVXMD 5LVFR1 HOOLNND %URlQGDQSXUR %URlQGDQSXURQYHVLROL,6LQGHNVLQPXNDDQHULQRPDLVWD\OlMXRNVXOODMDK\Yll SXURQ \KW\HVVl 0HOOXQN\OlQSXURRQ NXYDW 7DVDLVHQ NRUNHDW,6DUYRW YLLWWDDYDW VLLKHQ HWWl SXURRQ HL WXOH PDWNDOOD RUJDDQLVWD NXRUPLWXVWD 7', LQGHNVLQ DUYRW VXXUHQHYDW DODYLUWDDQ PHQWlHVVl MRWHQ UDYLQWHLWD WXOHH PDWNDQ YDUUHOWD<OlMXRNVXOODSXURRQROLJRWURILQHQMDDODMXRNVXOODROLJRPHVRWURILQHQ %URlQGDQSXUR ROL WXWNLWXLVWD SXURLVWD SLLOHYlLQGHNVLHQ PXNDDQ DUYLRLWXQD YH GHQ ODDGXOWDDQ SDUDV 9HUUDWWDHVVD KDYDLQWRSDLNDOOD 0( $ NHVlQ WXORNVLD VHXUDDYDDQ NHVllQ ROL SDLNND NHVlOOl LQGHNVLDUYRMHQ PX NDDQKLHPDQKXRQRPPDVVDNXQQRVVD %URlQGDQSXURQ KDYDLQWRSDLNRLOOD ROL NDNVL VHOYlVWL KDOOLWVHYDD ODMLD MRLGHQ RVXXVROL\OLNDLNLVWDSLLOHYLVWl+DOOLWVHYDWODMLW$FKQDQWKHVPLQXWLVVLPD $FKQDQWKHV REORQJHOOD MD&\PEHOOD VLOHVLDFD RYDW K\YlQ YHGHQ ODDGXQ LQGL NDDWWRUHLWDWDXOXNNR 7XWNLWWXMHQ SXURMHQ KDYDLQWRSDLNRLVWD OOD ROL VXXULQ ROLJRVDSUR ELVWHQ NXYD MD ROLJRWURILVWHQ SLLOHYLHQ RVXXV PLNl NHUWRR SXURQ K\YlVWlNXQQRVWD HVlOOlROLJRVDSURELVLDSLLOHYLlROLYDLQNXQPH VRVDSURELVLDROLVHXUDDYDDNHVllSDOMRQHQHPPlQNXYD2OLJRWURILVLDROL NHVlOOl <OLSLLOHYLVWlYDDWLNRUNHDDYHGHQKDSSLSLWRLVXXWWDMDOHYLVWlROLW\SSLPH WDEROLDOWDDQDXWRWURIHMDQLLQNHVlOOlNXLQNXYDW± 9HVLNHPLDOOLVWHQDQDO\\VLHQSHUXVWHHOODUDYLQQHSLWRLVXXGHWVXXUHQHYDWKDYDLQ WRSDLNDQ MlONHHQ WDXOXNNR 7lPl YRL MRKWXD SXURQ YLHUHVVl ROHYDQ VLLUWRODSXXWDUKDQYDOXPDYHVLVWl/lPS NHVWRLVWHQNROLEDNWHHULHQPllUlQRXVHH M\UNlVWLHQVLPPlLVHQKDYDLQWRSDLNDQMlONHHQ-DWNRVVDNDQQDWWDLVLVHO YLWWll%URlQGDQSXURRQWXOHYLHQYLHPlULHQMDRMLHQYHGHQODDWXVLOOlEDNWHHUL WXORVWHQSHUXVWHHOODSXURRQWXOHHXORVWHSHUlLVWlNXRUPLWXVWD 9lULOXYXQ PXNDDQ \OlMXRNVXQ KDYDLQWRSDLNND NXXOXX YHVLHQ \OHLVHQ Nl\WW NHOSRLVXXVOXRNLWXNVHQ PXNDDQ ODDGXOWDDQ HULQRPDLVHHQ OXRNNDDQ MD PXXW KDYDLQWRSDLNDW K\YllQ RNRQDLVIRVIRULSLWRLVXXGHQ PXNDDQ NDLNNL KD YDLQWRSDLNDW NXXOXYDW OXRNNDDQ YlOWWlYl /lps NHVWRLVWHQ NROLIRUPLVWHQ EDN WHHULHQPllUlQSHUXVWHHOOD \OlMXRNVXNXXOXXOXRNNDDQW\\G\WWlYlMDPXXWKD YDLQWRSDLNDW OXRNNDDQ KXRQR %URlQGDQSXUR ROL Nl\WW NHOSRLVXXVOXRNLWXNVHQ PXNDDQ KXRQRPPDVVD NXQQRVVD NXLQ SLLOHYlPHQHWHOPlQ SHUXVWHHOOD 7lKlQ VDDWWRLYDLNXWWDDVHHWWlYHVLNHPLDOOLVLLQWXORNVHWNHUWRYDWSXURYHGHQKHWNHOOL VHVWl ODDGXVWD DLNNLD Nl\WW NHOSRLVXXVOXRNLWXNVHHQ NXXOXYLD PXXWWXMLD HL P\ VNllQROOXWNl\WHWWlYLVVlHLNlOXRNLWXNVHHQNXXOXNXLQRVDWXWNLWXLVWDYHVL NHPLDOOLVLVWDDQDO\\VHLVWl0HUNLWWlYLQWlOLHQHHNXLWHQNLQVHHWWlNl\WW NHOSRL VXXVOXRNLWXVRQWDUNRLWHWWXMlUYLMRNLMDPHULYHVLHQOXRNLWWHOXXQMDVHQNl\WW SXURYHVLHQYHGHQODDGXQDUYLRLQWLLQRQHSlYDUPDD

26 +HOVLQJLQNDXS\PSlULVW NHVNMXONDLVXMD5LVFR1 HOOLNND 7DXOXNNR %URlQGDQSXURQ KDYDLQWRSDLNRLOWD ODVNHWWXMHQ SLLOHYlODMLHQ UXQ VDXV7XORNVHWKDYDLQWRSDLNRLOOD±RYDWNHVlOWlPXXWNH VlOWl+DYDLQWRSDLNDW$MDVHNlMDRYDWVLMDLQQLOWDDQVDPR MD7DXOXNRVVDRQQHODMLWMRLGHQVXKWHHOOLQHQRVXXVROL LLOHYlODML +DYDLQWRSDLNDW $ $FKQDQWKHVPLQXWLVVLPD K $REORQJHOOD K &\PEHOODVLOHVLDFD K 1DYLFXODJUHJDULD U K K\YlQ YlKlQRUJDDQLVWDDLQHWWDYHGHQODDGXQLQGLNDDWWRULS KXRQRQaSDOMRQRUJDDQLVWDDLQHW WDYHGHQODDGXQLQGLNDDWWRUL,6LQGHNVLHQPXNDDQVHNlU UHKHYlQYHGHQLQGLNDDWWRULMD WROHUDQWWL +RIIPDQQLQPXNDDQ 7DXOXNNR9HVLNHPLDOOLVWHQDQDO\\VLHQWXORNVHW%URlQGDQSXURVVDYLLNROODKHLQlNXXVVD +DYDLQWR SDLNND S+ 2 -RKWR N\N\ 9lUL LLQWR DLQH $ONDOL WHHWWL &2' 0Q RN1 RN 2 /lps NHVW NROLEDNW PJO P6P PJWO PJO PPROO PJO JO JO JO SP\PO

27 +HOVLQJLQNDXS\PSlULVW NHVNMXONDLVXMD 5LVFR1 HOOLNND XYD %URlQ GDQSXURQ OXRNLWXV NDUWWD,6LQGHNVLQ PXNDDQ NHVlOOl

28 +HOVLQJLQNDXS\PSlULVW NHVNMXONDLVXMD5LVFR1 HOOLNND XYD%URlQGDQSX URQOXRNLWXVNDUWWD7', LQGHNVLQ PXNDDQ NH VlOOl

29 +HOVLQJLQNDXS\PSlULVW NHVNMXONDLVXMD 5LVFR1 HOOLNND XYD0lWlMRHQ0b0HOOXQN\OlQSXURQ 0(MD5HNRODQRMDQ5(SLLOHYl\KWHLV MHQ MDNDXWXPLQHQWURILDOXRNNLLQ9DQ'DP\P NHVlQWXORVWHQPXNDDQ XYD0lWlMRHQ0b0HOOXQN\OlQSXURQ 0(MD5HNRODQRMDQ5(SLLOHYl\KWHLV MHQ MDNDXWXPLQHQVDSURELDOXRNNLLQ9DQ'DP \PNHVlQWXORVWHQPXNDDQ HXWURI PHVRWURI ROLJRWURI ÃÈ ÃÈ ÃÈ ÃÈ ÃÈ SRO\VDSU PHVRVDSU ROLJRVDSU ÃÈ ÃÈ ÃÈ ÃÈ ÃÈ Ã XYD 6l\QlVODKGHQSXURQ 9LLNLQRMDQ MD %URlQGDQSXURQ SLLOHYl\KWHLV MHQ MDNDXWXPLQHQ WURILDMDVDSURELDOXRNNLLQ9DQ'DP\PNHVlQWXORVWHQPXNDDQ

30 +HOVLQJLQNDXS\PSlULVW NHVNMXONDLVXMD5LVFR1 HOOLNND XYD0lWlMRHQ0b0HOOXQN\OlQSXURQ 0(MD5HNRODQRMDQ5(SLLOHYl\KWHLV MHQ MDNDXWXPLQHQKDSSLYDDWLPXVWHQVXKWHHQ9DQ 'DP\PNHVlQWXORVWHQPXNDDQ XYD0lWlMRHQ0b0HOOXQN\OlQSXURQ 0(MD5HNRODQRMDQ5(SLLOHYl\KWHLV MHQ MDNDXWXPLQHQW\SSLPHWDEROLDQVXKWHHQ9DQ 'DP\PNHVlQWXORVWHQPXNDDQ ORZ PRGHUDWH KLJK ÃÈ ÃÈ ÃÈ ÃÈ ÃÈ ÃÈ 1KHWHURWURI IDNÃ1KHWHURWURI 1DXWRWURI ÃÈ ÃÈ ÃÈ ÃÈ ÃÈ ÃÈ XYD6l\QlVODKGHQSXURQ9LLNLQRMDQMD%URlQGDQSXURQSLLOHYl\KWHLV MHQMDNDXWXPLQHQ OXRNNLLQKDSSLYDDWLPXVWHQMDW\SSLPHWDEROLDQVXKWHHQ9DQ'DP\PNHVlQWXORVWHQ PXNDDQ

31 +HOVLQJLQNDXS\PSlULVW NHVNMXONDLVXMD 5LVFR1 HOOLNND -RKWRSllW NVHW LLOHYlPHQHWHOPlOOlVDDGXWWXORNVHWYDLNXWWLYDWOXRWHWWDYLOWDMDPHQHWHOPlWRL PLYDOWD6DDGXWPRQLYlULNDUWDWROLYDWYLVXDDOLVHVWLVHONHLWlMDKHOSRVWL\PPlU UHWWlYLl 0HQHWHOPlQ Nl\WW YDDWLL NXLWHQNLQ WDLWRD WXQQLVWDD VDWRMD SLLOHYLl PLNURVNRRSSLVHVWLMDNRUNHDODDWXLVHQPLNURVNRRSLQ LLOHYlPHQHWHOPlRQNHKLWHWW\SllDVLDVVDXONRPDLOODMRWHQVHHLNDLNLOWDRVLQ VRYHOOX6XRPHQRORLKLQ6XRPHVVDSLLOHYlPHQHWHOPllRQWHVWDWWXYLUWDYHVLVVl PXWWDWXWNLPXNVLDPXLVWDNDXSXQNLSXURLVWDHLROHYLHOlWHKW\ 9LUWDYHVLVVlYHGHQODDWXYRLPXXWWXDQRSHDVWLPXXQPXDVVDVlLGHQMDNXRUPL WXNVHQPXXWWXHVVD)\VLNDDOLVNHPLDOOLVHWDQDO\\VLWNHUWRYDWKHWNHOOLVHVWlYHGHQ ODDGXVWD ROPHVWDSXURVWDRWHWWLLQYHVLQl\WWHLWlMDSXURQYHGHQODDWXDS\ULWWLLQ DUYLRLPDDQ P\ V YHVLHQ Nl\WW NHOSRLVXXVOXRNLWXNVHQ DYXOOD 7XORNVHW HLYlW DLQD YDVWDQQHHW SLLOHYlPHQHWHOPlOOl VDDWXD NXYDD SXURYHGHQ WLODVWD 9HUWDLOX ROLNXLWHQNLQODDMXXGHOWDDQQLLQVXSSHDHWWlPLWllQMRKWRSllW NVLlPHQHWHOPL HQHURLVWDHLYRLWXMRKWDD LLOHYl\KWHLV W UHDJRLYDW YHGHQ ODDGXVVD WDSDKWXQHHVHHQ PXXWRNVHHQ YLLNRQ± SDULQ DLNDMlQWHHOOl XQ Ql\WWHHQRWWR DMRLWHWDDQ YlKlQ YHGHQ DLNDDQ VDDGDDQ SLVWHNXRUPLWWDMLHQYDLNXWXVYHGHQODDWXXQHVLOOH+DMDNXRUPLWXNVHQYDLNXWXVWD YRLVLPDKGROOLVHVWLWXWNLDHULNVHHQWXWNLPXNVHOODNHYlWPDNVLPLQDLNDDQ -DWNRVVDWXWNLPXNVHVVDHVLLQWXOOHHWSXURMHQSllVW OlKWHHWWXOLVLSRLVWDDMDVHX UDQWDDODDMHQWDDNRVNHPDDQPllUlYXRVLQDNDLNNLD+HOVLQJLQSXURMD LUMDOOLVXXV &DMDQGHU+XURMDRMDYHVLWXWNLPXNVHW±5DSRUWWLNDWXUDNHQQXV SllOOLN OOH-XONDLVHPDWRQ+HOVLQJLQNDXSXQNL &(0$*5()(WXGHGHVPpWKRGHVELRORJLTXHVTXDQWLWDWLYHVGiSSUpFLDWL RQ GH OD TXDOLWp GHV HDX[ 5DSSRUW'LYLVLRQ 4XDOLWp GHV(DX[/\RQ $JHQFH ILQDQFLqUHGH%DVVLQ5KRQH0HGLWHUUDQpH&RUVHLHUUH%HQLWHV (NKROP06XRPHQYHVLVW DOXHHW±9HVLMD\PSlULVW KDOOLQQRQMXONDL VXMD$V (ORUDQWD 8VH RI DOJDH IRU PRQLWRULQJ ULYHUV LQ )LQODQG 7HRNVHVVD :KLWWRQ%$5RWW()ULHGULFK*WRLP8VHRI$OJDHIRU0RQLWRULQJ5L YHUV,QVWLWXWI U%RWDQLN8QLYHUVLWlW,QQVEUXFN± (ORUDQWDD$SSOLFDWLRQVRIGLDWRPLQGLFHVLQ)LQQLVKULYHUV7HRNVHV VDU\JLHO-:KLWWRQ%$ %XNRZVND-WRLP8VHRIDOJDHIRUPRQLWR ULQJULYHUV,,,$JHQFHGHO (DX$UWRLVLFDUGLH'RXDL± (ORUDQWD E %LRORJLQHQ PRQLWRURLQWLPHQHWHOPl 9DQWDDQMRHQ YHGHQ ODDGXQNXYDDMDQD±9HVLWDORXV± (ORUDQWD6XRPHQPDNHDYHGHQSLLOHYlWMDQLLGHQNl\WW YHVLHQPRQL WRURLQQLVVD 2SHWXVPRQLVWH +HOVLQJLQ \OLRSLVWR /LPQRORJLDQ MD \PSlULVW Q VXRMHOXQODLWRV+HOVLQNL

32 +HOVLQJLQNDXS\PSlULVW NHVNMXONDLVXMD5LVFR1 HOOLNND (ORUDQWD $QGHUVVRQ 'LDWRPLQGLFHVLQZDWHUTXDOLW\PRQLWRULQJ RIVRPH6RXWK)LQQLVKULYHUV9HUK,QWHUQDW9HUHLQ/LPQRO± (ORUDQWD ZDQGUDQV - %LRORJLQHQ PRQLWRURLQWLPHQHWHOPl 9DQ WDDQMRHQYHGHQODDGXQNXYDDMDQD9HVLWDORXV± (ORUDQWD 6RLQLQHQ-(FRORJLFDOVWDWXVRIVRPH)LQQLVKULYHUVHYD OXDWHGXVLQJEHQWKLFGLDWRPFRPPXQLWLHV-$SSOK\FRO± -DODYD + +HOVLQJLQ SXURW ± +HOVLQJLQ NDXSXQJLQ \PSlULVW QVXRMHOX ODXWDNXQQDQMXONDLVXV HOO\0 :KLWWRQ%$7KH7URSKLF'LDWRP,QGH[DQHZLQGH[IRU PRQLWRULQJHXWURSKLFDWLRQLQULYHUV-$SSOK\FRO± HOO\0*&D]DXERQ$&RULQJ('HOOC8RPR$(FWRU/*ROGVPLWK %*XDVFK++ UOLPDQQ--DUOPDQ$ DZHFND% ZDQGUDQV-/DX JDVWH5/LQGVWU P($/HLWDR00DUYDQDGLViN-LSS(U\ JLHO-5RWW(6DEDWHU6YDQ'DP+ 9L]LQHW-5HFRPPHQGD WLRQVIRUWKHURXWLQHVDPSOLQJRIGLDWRPVIRUZDWHUTXDOLW\DVVHVVPHQWVLQ(X URSH±-$SSOK\FRO± HWROD 7 9HGHQ ODDWX MD DLQHNXOMHWXV 0HOOXQN\OlQSXURVVD,Wl +HOVLQJLVVl +HOVLQJLQ NDXSXQJLQ \PSlULVW NHVNXNVHQ MXONDLVXMD +HO VLQNLV /HFRLQWH & &RVWH 0 U\JLHO - 201,',$ $ VRIZDUH IRU WD [RQRP\FDOFXODWLRQRIGLDWRPLQGLFHVDQGLQYHQWRULHVPDQDJHPHQW+\GUR ELRORJLD± 5LVFR18VHRIEHQWKLFGLDWRPVWRHYDOXDWHWKHZDWHUTXDOLW\RIWKUHH FLW\ EURRNV RI +HOVLQNL 0lWlMRNL 0HOOXQN\OlQSXUR DQG 5HNRODQRMD UR JUDGXW\ +HOVLQJLQ\OLRSLVWR/LPQRORJLDQMD\PSlULVW QVXRMHOXQODLWRV+HO VLQNL 5XWK20lWlMRNL±QLPHllQSDUHPSL±+HOVLQJLQNDXSXQJLQ\PSlULV W NHVNXNVHQMXONDLVXMDV 5XWK 2 7LNNDQHQ 0 XURMHQ +HOVLQNL ± 9LUWDDYD YHVL NDXSXQJLQ NDKOHLVVD±7HRNVHVVD/DDNNRQHQ6\PWRLP1lN NXOPLD+HOVLQJLQ\P SlULVW KLVWRULDDQ DXSXQJLQ\PSlULVW QPXXWRVMDOXYXLOOD(GLWD 2\M+HOVLQNL 9DQ'DP+0HUWHQV$ 6LQNHOGDP-$FRGHGFKHFNOLVWDQGHFROR JLFDO LQGLFDWRU YDOXHV RI IUHVKZDWHU GLDWRPV IURP WKH 1HWKHUODQGV 1HWKHU ODQGV-$TXDW(FRO±