The language of Science Swiss Science at the Crossroads Martin Vetterli, President of the National Research Council SUPRIO Generalversammlung, Bern, 16.1.2014 SNF 2 Who is Martin Vetterli? Education in Switzerland and the US (ETH Zürich, Stanford, EPF Lausanne) 10 years faculty member in the US (Columbia and UC Berkeley) Since 1995 at EPF Lausanne (Professor, Dean, Head of NCCR, VP International Affairs) Science Policy (SWTR/SSIC) SNF 3 SNF 4
From basic research to applications Overview Research flowing into start ups, i.e.: 1. Science and research in Switzerland 2. Main challenge: Career of young academics 3. Further challenges for Swiss science Collaborations with the industry: 4. Science Communication 5. SNSF World Network SNF 5 SNF 6 Imagine a circle that contains all of human knowledge Imagine By the time a circle you finish that contains elementary all of school, human you knowledge a little SNF 7 adapted from: http://matt.might.net/articles/phd-school-in-pictures/ SNF 8 adapted from: http://matt.might.net/articles/phd-school-in-pictures/
Imagine By the time a circle you finish that contains elementary high school, all of school, you human know you knowledge a bit more a little Imagine By With the a bachelor's time a circle you finish that degree, contains elementary high you school, all gain of school, you a human specialty know you knowledge a bit more a little SNF 9 adapted from: http://matt.might.net/articles/phd-school-in-pictures/ SNF 10 adapted from: http://matt.might.net/articles/phd-school-in-pictures/ Imagine By With A master's the a bachelor's time a circle degree you finish that degree, deepens contains elementary high you school, that all gain specialty of school, you a human specialty know you knowledge a bit more a little Imagine By With A Research master's the a bachelor's time a takes circle degree you you finish that degree, deepens to contains elementary high the you edge school, that all gain of specialty of school, human you a specialty know you knowledge a bit more a little SNF 11 adapted from: http://matt.might.net/articles/phd-school-in-pictures/ SNF 12 adapted from: http://matt.might.net/articles/phd-school-in-pictures/
Imagine By With A Research Once master's the a you're bachelor's time a takes circle degree you at the you finish that degree, deepens boundary, to contains elementary high the you edge school, that you all gain of specialty of focus school, human you a specialty know you knowledge a bit more a little Imagine By With A Research Once You master's the push a you're bachelor's time a at takes circle degree you the at the you finish that degree, deepens boundary, to contains elementary high the you for edge school, that you a all gain few of specialty of focus school, human you a years specialty know you knowledge a bit more a little SNF 13 adapted from: http://matt.might.net/articles/phd-school-in-pictures/ SNF 14 adapted from: http://matt.might.net/articles/phd-school-in-pictures/ Imagine By With A Research Once You Until master's the push a one you're bachelor's time a day, at takes circle degree you the at the you finish that degree, deepens boundary, to contains elementary high the you for edge school, that gives you a all gain few of specialty of focus way school, human you a years specialty know you knowledge a bit more a little Imagine By With A Research Once You Until And master's the push then, a one you're bachelor's time a day, takes that circle degree you the the dent you finish that degree, deepens boundary, to you've contains elementary high the you for edge made school, that gives you a all gain few of specialty of is focus way school, human you a years called specialty know you knowledge a Ph.D. a bit more a little SNF 15 adapted from: http://matt.might.net/articles/phd-school-in-pictures/ SNF 16 adapted from: http://matt.might.net/articles/phd-school-in-pictures/
Imagine By With A Research Once You Until And Of master's course, the push then, a one you're bachelor's time a day, takes that circle the degree you the the world dent you finish that degree, deepens boundary, to you've looks contains elementary high the you for edge different made school, that gives you a all gain few of specialty of is focus way school, human you a years to called specialty you know you knowledge a Ph.D. a bit more a little Imagine By With A Research Once You Until And Of But master's course, the don't push then, a one you're bachelor's time a day, takes forget that circle the degree you the the world dent you the finish that degree, deepens boundary, to you've bigger looks contains elementary high the you for edge different picture! made school, that gives you a all gain few of specialty of is focus way school, human you a years to called specialty you know you knowledge a Ph.D. a bit more a little SNF 16 adapted from: http://matt.might.net/articles/phd-school-in-pictures/ SNF 17 adapted from: http://matt.might.net/articles/phd-school-in-pictures/ Switzerland: A worldwide leader Switzerland: A worldwide leader SNF 19 Innovation Forschung Union schafft Scoreboard Wissen. 2011 SNF 20 Innovation Forschung Union schafft Scoreboard Wissen. 2011
ERC Grants for CH in FP7 Switzerland secret success ingredient SNF 21 Forschung schafft SERI, Wissen. 11/2013 SNF 22 N Engl J Med Forschung 2012; 367, schafft October Wissen. 18, 2012 However, we are not alone Internationality: a two-edged sword SNF 23 SNF 24 The fourth age Forschung of research, schafft nature, Wissen. 2013
Internationality: a two-edged sword Overview Immigration (%) Emigration? 1. Science and research in Switzerland 2. Main challenge: Career of young academics 3. Further challenges for Swiss science 4. Science Communication 5. SNSF World Network! strong increase in local competition SNF 25 GlobSci survey, Forschung Franzoni C. schafft et al., May Wissen. 2012 SNF 26 The issue of young academics 2. Young academics What happened? 2. Young academics 1990 Professors PostDocs 2400 4700-12 900 PhDs 11 700 Students 69 000 SNF 27 SNF 28 Forschung schafft Quelle: Wissen. BfS
2. Young academics 2. Young academics What happened? Peter Higgs Nobel Prize laureate 2013 Professors 3900 2012 Today I wouldn't get an academic job. It's as simple as that. I don't think I would be regarded as productive enough. PostDocs 9700-27 500 The Guardian, 6.12.2013 PhDs Students 22 700 109 000 " Prediction of Higgs-Boson in 1964 " Confirmation in 2012 SNF 29 Forschung schafft Quelle: Wissen. BfS SNF 30 Career funding @ SNSF 2. Young academics How the SNSF is structured 2. Young academics Division I (Humanities and Social sciences): The meaning of life Division II (Mathematics, Natural and Engineering): The Higgs boson Division III (Biology and Medicine): A cure for cancer Division IV (Programmes): Climate change SNF 31 SNF 32
2. Young academics 2. Young academics SNSF Professorships Newly introduced measures Erfolgsquoten bisher: Nicht berufen: 20% Plus: increased salaries, protected times for research, etc. SNF 33 SNF 34 work in progress 2. Young academics work in progress 2. Young academics Mas PhD PDoc Prof Exo Mas PhD Pdoc Prof Exo! Simples Modell mit bloss 8 Parametern SNF 35 SNF 36
2. Young academics Von einem stabilen Punkt zum anderen Overview 2. Änderungen 1. Endstatus definieren 1. Science and research in Switzerland 2. Main challenge: Career of young academics 3. Further challenges for Swiss science University of Rummidge 100 full time Professors State of Euphoria 90 full time Professors plus 20 PATT 4. Science Communication 5. SNSF World Network SNF 37 Changing Forschung Places, schafft D. Lodge, Wissen. 1975 SNF 38 Basic and applied science 3. Further challenges Basic science is useful 3. Further challenges Grundlegende Entdeckung? ja nein Bohrs Quadrant Grundlagenforschung Pasteurs Quadrant Edisons Quadrant Anwendungsorientierte Grundlagenforschung Angewandte Forschung nein ja Konkreter Nutzen? SNF 39 Pasteur s Quadrant, Forschung Donald E. schafft Stokes, Wissen. 1997 SNF 40
3. Further challenges 3. Further challenges Lack of entrepreneurship SNF 42 SNF 43 Result: Missed technologies 3. Further challenges Valley of death 3. Further challenges WE READ YOU! Basic research (SNSF) Application (KTI) SNF 44 SNF 45
3. Further challenges 3. Further challenges Big and small science Gender Share of women at the Swiss Universities CERN 3,900 employees Peter Higgs SNF 46 SNF 47 Reproducibility 3. Further challenges Quantification of research output 3. Further challenges - Need to improve the ways in which the outputs of scientific research are evaluated - Initiated by the American Society for Cell Biology (ASCB) together with a group of editors and publishers " over 200 original signers (individuals and organizations) " over 10 000 new signers (growing) SNF 48 SNF 49
3. Further challenges Open Data and Open Access Overview 1. Science and research in Switzerland 2. Main challenge: Career of young academics 3. Further challenges for Swiss science 4. Science Communication 5. SNSF World Network SNF 50 SNF 51 Science communication 4. Science communication Technology is making us antisocial 4. Science communication What?! New technologies need for a new way of communicating with the audience! SNF 52 SNF 53
Infographics 4. Science communication 4. Science communication 1973 2013 Wie breit müsste die Plantage an Biotreibstoffen sein? Prof. D. MacKay, Department of Energy and Climate Change England 8 Kilometer?! Used in the parliament Autofreie Sonntage (seit 1973) SNF 54 Energieflussdiagramm Forschung Schweiz, schafft BFE, Wissen. 2011 SNF 55 Data journalism and visualization 4. Science communication How to do science communication 4. Science communication! NZZ, The Guardian Data, NYT Lab, etc. SNF 56 SNF 59
5. SNSF World Network Overview The world (of science) is getting smaller 1. Science and research in Switzerland 2. Main challenge: Career of young academics 3. Further challenges for Swiss science 4. Science Communication 5. SNSF World Network SNF 61 SNF 62 The «SNSF World Network» 5. SNSF World Network First insights: numbers 5. SNSF World Network Please advertise @ your university to make Swiss Science more international! Launch in October 2012: Join and advertise! SNF 63! mirko.bischofberger@snf.ch for more infos SNF 64
5. SNSF World Network 5. SNSF World Network First insights: countries Example of a typical discussion SNF 65 SNF 66 Thank you!