From the Field Living with Typhoons: Disaster Management in rural Taiwan

Similar documents
Landslides & Mudflows

Natural Disaster Impact on Business and Communities in Taiwan. Dr. Chung-Sheng Lee. NCDR Chinese Taipei

A disaster occurs at the point of contact between social activities and a natural phenomenon of unusual scale.

Landslides. Landslides-1. March 2007

GEOTECHNICAL ISSUES OF LANDSLIDES CHARACTERISTICS MECHANISMS PREPARDNESS: BEFORE, DURING AND AFTER A LANDSLIDE QUESTIONS FOR DISCUSSIONS

HOMEOWNER S GUIDE. to LANDSLIDES. and MITIGATION RECOGNITION, PREVENTION, CONTROL, Compiled by Dr. Scott F. Burns Tessa M. Harden Carin J.

School Disaster Management Planning Template

Hands on exercise Hazard Map and its application

2014 Polk County ESF #3 Public Works and Engineering: Damage Assessment Section

Emergency Management Audit For Businesses

Graduate School of Disaster Prevention Kangwon National University.

DEVELOPING FLOOD VULNERABILITY MAP FOR NORTH KOREA INTROUDUCTION

Siting and settlement: The most important way to protect shelter from floods is to build in a place that is unlikely to be flooded.

Tool 2.3.1: General information on the causes of rainfall-induced landslides

FACT SHEET: HAZARDOUS MATERIALS ACCIDENTS

Landslides & Mudslides

Local flood and landslide guide. Halls Gap HALLS GAP

Challenges. Estimated Damages from 100-Year Flood

Risks in School Safety Assessment

Best Practice of Flood Hazard Map in Japan

Emergency Management is responsible for coordinating the City of Houston s preparation for and response to emergency situations.

NEW DEVELOPMENT AND EMERGENCY FLOOD PLANS

Flash Flood Science. Chapter 2. What Is in This Chapter? Flash Flood Processes

Natural Hazard Risk Maps for Public Use in Rural Areas in Northern Tajikistan

Disaster Risk Management: prevention and urgent repair procedures for infrastructure and facilities

The Boscastle Flood 2004

All persons have a duty to do all they can to avoid harm to themselves or others.

5 Most Common Planning & Management Problems in Ontario County, Canada

ESTIMATING THE COSTS OF EMERGENCY SERVICES DURING FLOOD EVENTS

NATIONAL REPORT AUSTRIA

EMERGENCY PREPAREDNESS

Hazard Identification and Risk Assessment

OCPS Emergency Response Quick Reference Guide Orange County Public Schools Security Control Center

Flood Warning & Evacuation Plan

4.14 Netherlands. Interactive flood risk map of a part of the province of Gelderland in the Netherlands. Atlas of Flood Maps

Natural Hazards 1.1. Natural Hazards. Objective: Natural Hazards in Western Australia Are we at risk? Page 1. Natural Hazards Years 5-7

Draft Dapto Flood Management Plan

DISASTERS & EMERGENCIES

REPUBLIC OF TURKEY MINISTRY OF FORESTRY AND WATER AFFAIRS

Tornado/Severe Weather

Flooding Fast Facts. flooding), seismic events (tsunami) or large landslides (sometime also called tsunami).

CITY OF BELLEAIR BEACH, FLORIDA

CRS 610 Ventura County Flood Warning System Website

Maryland Emergency Operations Plan

HAZARD RISK ASSESSMENT, MONITORING, MAINTENANCE AND MANAGEMENT SYSTEM (HAMMS) FOR LANDSLIDE AND FLOOD. Mohd. Nor Desa, Rohayu and Lariyah, UNITEN

Comprehensive emergency plan for:

EMERGENCY ACTION PLAN (FIELD)

DISASTER COUNTERMEASURES BASIC ACT

MANAGING LANDSLIDE HAZARDS FROM THE WHAKATĀNE AND ŌHOPE ESCARPMENTS

Response and Recovery

11.4 Hazard register. Hazard identification. Steps to minimise. Isolate Yes No Yes No Yes No Yes No. Hazard

MONTANA STATE PARKS INCIDENT MANAGEMENT PLAN TEMPLATE

Outline Materials Time Conclusion

Appendix J Online Questionnaire

Promote Business Continuity Planning for Disaster Resiliency in Vietnamese economy

Natural Disasters & Assessing Hazards and Risk. Natural Hazards and Natural Disasters

WATER HARVESTING AND AQUACULTURE FOR RURAL DEVELOPMENT INTRODUCTION TO AQUACULTURE

Emergency and Contingency Planning

Pennsylvania Flood Safety Awareness Week March 6-10th, 2015

5.0 OVERVIEW OF FLOOD DAMAGE REDUCTION MEASURES

RISD Hurricane Preparedness

A Comprehensive Summary

Various options are discussed below.these low cost, low impact interventions can also be applied as general erosion control methods.

Climate Change Adaptation at European Railway Infrastructure Companies

Storm Ready: How to Prepare Your Business

Fire Risk Assessment Safety Checklist

My presentation will be on rainfall forecast alarms for high priority rapid response catchments.

A Self Assessment to Address Climate Change Readiness in Your Community Midwest Region

Table of Contents ESF

With a combination of soaking rain, flying debris, high winds, and tidal surges, Hurricanes and tropical storms can pack a powerful punch.

EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT PLANNING CRITERIA FOR HOSPITALS

PSPSOHS606A Develop and implement crisis management processes

Universal Soil Erosion Equation

Hurricane Preparedness in Pinellas County

Give your family the best chance of surviving a wildfire by evacuating early.

THE ECOSYSTEM - Biomes

BETTENDORF PUBLIC LIBRARY INFORMATION CENTER EMERGENCY RESPONSE AND FACILITY CLOSURE POLICY

Oregon. Climate Change Adaptation Framework

Emergency Preparedness Guidelines

The National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP)

DISASTER RISK DETECTION AND MANAGEMENT COURSES SETUP SCENARIO AT MAKERERE UNIVERSITY. Makerere University

DPAC- DLGSEM and MRT. Landslide planning matrix

Preparation. Preparation. Step 2 Prepare an emergency kit. Step 1 Prepare your emergency plan. Step 4 Tune into warnings

6. NATURAL AREAS FIRE MANAGEMENT

Major landslides and associated rehabilitation measures in urban areas of the Republic of Korea

Homeland Security Plan for Iowa State University Extension Field Offices

Annex B: City of Lewes Evacuation Plan

Application of Space Technology for Disaster monitoring and assessment current state in Vietnam

Burnt River Black River and Gull River Flood Contingency Plan

Flood After Fire Fact Sheet

A Guide to Hazard Identification and Risk Assessment for Public Health Units. Public Health Emergency Preparedness Protocol

RESTORATION PROCESS. Step 1 Empire s storm restoration team assesses the damage to the system. This assessment allows Empire. = Location of damage

Anchorage All-Hazard Mitigation Plan October 2004

PUBLIC SAFETY FIRE. Functional Coordinator: Fire Chiefs

Flood Emergency Response Planning: How to Protect Your Business from a Natural Disaster RIC005

Landslides. Working from the same page. PART B: Hazard-specific information. consistent messages for CDEM

Federal Assistance for Wildfire Response and Recovery

TSMC Typhoon Morakot Relief Project

NWS Melbourne Flood Briefing for Event Ending Today

ministry operations fire safety relocations designations evacuation bomb threat closure operations back-up of records weather policy

Transcription:

Evacuation is currently only ordered after 250 mm of precipitation. Considerable difficulties may arise if local residents don't evacuate the area until after 250mm of rainfall has fallen. Roads which at night will be in darkness may be blocked or washed away, and any body of people moving through the valley, or up the mountain to the evacuation centre in the midst of a typhoon would be more vulnerable and exposed to danger as a result. It is integral if a successful evacuation of local resident's is to succeed that all areas of human habitation are evacuated before the onset of any typhoon activity and not after. The evacuation centre (a school) for Maya village consists of two buildings (Fig. 52). The first building has large glass windows on four sides which would render it extremely dangerous in the event of a major typhoon. As it is unlikely that another suitable evacuation centre could be found within the area it is a recommendation that the majority of human evacuation activity should be conducted in the second building and not the first. The evacuation centre in Dakanua is at the bottom of extremely steep slopes that is prone to landslides (Fig. 53.). In addition, land above the evacuation centre has been planted with betel palm trees and the shallow root systems of these trees is believed to contribute to soil erosion, flooding and increase the severity of landslides.. Subsequently it is recommended that a new evacuation centre is found. In Taiwan the Soil and Water Conservation Bureau (SWCB) decide which area is most susceptible to debris flows and issues hazard risk maps and hold training courses teaching local residents the difference between the red (compulsory) and yellow (non-compulsory) evacuation alerts. (Mandatory evacuation is only enforced when the current precipitation levels surpass precaution levels. The precaution levels in Namasia and Maolin is 250mm). Creating hazard maps can be an effective form of risk communication but only if the population they are designed to assist can read and properly interpret them. The marking of high risk areas, assembly points, rest centres, and critical infrastructures are required to make the hazard map effective. At the national level, hazard maps are produced by a variety of different departments in charge of each individual hazard. As noted the SWCB is responsible for debris flows, the Ministry of Agriculture is responsible for landslides and the Ministry of Economics is responsible for flood hazard maps etc. Under The Disaster Prevention and Protection Act, local authorities are also required to produce hazard maps. (Radio Taiwan International 2012) reported that a number of criticisms of some of these maps which include (1) the indicators were not clear on the maps; (2) no clear road names, evacuation routes and directions. However by far the greatest problem, despite being an overtly complicated system of disseminating information there is also a distinct lack of a sharing mechanism between different organisations. (Community hazard maps were only shared by the National Fire Agency since June 2012) (Ministry of the Interior 2012). Here it is evident that if a universal disaster management body was in place with the responsibility of producing all disaster related mapping, the processes for disseminating information would clearer, and it is likely finances and resources would be saved and a greater number of affected residents would be assisted.

For those six participants who did not leave their houses, their responses to the research indicated that they were reluctant to leave their homes and/or didn't think the storm would be so heavy. In one instance the participant stated that he was not told about evacuation procedures (it can be concluded that the participant possibly lived in an isolated dwelling away from the main body of the other villages). These intransigent actions can probably be related to the fact that the six participants were all aged over 50 years of age and as Perry (1979) argued held opinions or views of particular traditional nature. Of the 50 people asked 28 did not answer or stated that they were not aware of any contingency plan for vulnerable persons during Morakot. Of the 23 people who replied in the affirmative that they were aware of contingency plans for vulnerable people it is unknown whether or not these contingency plans were in place during Morakot or have been subsequently put in place. The communities of Namasia did not report a particularly good understanding of the hazard maps (and one would assume the associated hazard risks) with only 5 participants of the 50 fully understanding a hazard map. Again these findings support Wu's conclusions. In relation to question 14, 'what changes would you like to see?' the participant s answers were varied encompassing a variety of different viewpoints. Answers centred on establishing more cooperation between local people and government authorities, a greater understanding of the dangerous features and increased awareness of how to prepare in advance for major typhoons and improved evacuation procedures.