VILLAGE OF DOWNERS GROVE REPORT FOR THE VILLAGE COUNCIL MEETING SEPTEMBER 2, 2014 AGENDA ITEM MOT 00-05679 SUBJECT: TYPE: SUBMITTED BY: Water System Leak Detection Services Resolution Ordinance Motion Discussion Only Nan Newlon, P.E. Director of Public Works SYNOPSIS A motion is requested authorizing the execution of a three-year contract for water system leak detection services with M.E. Simpson Co., Inc. of Valparaiso, Indiana in the amount of $135,840. STRATEGIC PLAN ALIGNMENT The goals for 2011 to 2018 identified Top Quality Infrastructure. FISCAL IMPACT The FY14 budget provides $45,000 in the Water Fund for water system leak detection services. Of this amount, $8,000 is budgeted for leak detection services to identify the location of water leaks prior to excavation and $37,000 for an annual leak detection survey. RECOMMENDATION Approval on the September 2, 2014 consent agenda. BACKGROUND Each year the Village conducts proactive leak detection of the entire water system. This program involves employing a technical service company to use highly accurate, state-of-the-art acoustic equipment to find subsurface water system leaks and other sources of water loss for the Village s entire 233 mile water distribution system. This program is important for the following reasons: 1) Reducing the cost of lost water through leakage 2) Monitoring potential system operation and maintenance problems 3) Conserving freshwater resources, and 4) Ensuring sound and reliable water service for the customer. The 2013 leak detection survey completed by M.E. Simpson pinpointed 33 leaks with an average daily water loss of 165,600 gallons per day. The repair of these leaks equates to a savings of $180,123 annually. In addition to the village-wide survey, the Public Works department also requests site-specific leak detection services during some watermain breaks and leaks. In many situations the exact location of an underground break or leak is difficult to determine because many factors influence the path the water takes before it ultimately surfaces. Using leak detection services prior to excavating shortens the length of time needed to find and repair the broken pipe and reduces the size of the excavation which minimizes the cost of restoration. Staff developed a Request for Proposals (RFP) seeking services from a qualified vendor to provide water system leak detection services for 2014-16 in accordance with established procurement procedures. Two proposals were received with pricing information summarized in the table below.
Three Year Price Summary for Leak Detection Survey Proposed Proposed Proposed 3-Year Service Provider Price Price Price Total 2014 2015 2016 M.E. Simpson Co., Inc., Valparaiso, IN $37,280 $37,280 $37,280 $106,015 Associated Technical Services, Villa Park, IL $36,900 n/a n/a n/a Disqualified Price Summary for Emergency Leak Detection Services Service Provider Regular After Business Hours Hours $375 1 st $500 1 st hour and hour and M.E. Simpson Co., Inc., Valparaiso, IN $195 each $215 each additional additional Associated Technical Services, Villa Park, IL $350 n/a Disqualified The proposal submitted by Associated Technical Services was disqualified because it did not contain the requested pricing information and did not contain any of the required, completed contract forms. M.E. Simpson s contract cost, which would remain the same for the three contract years, reflects a 3.2% increase from the 2013 contract cost. M.E. Simpson Company completed the prior three-year contract with good results. ATTACHMENTS Contract Documents Contractor Report Card 2
Village of Downers Grove Contractor Evaluation Contractor: M.E. Simpson Co. Project: Leak Detection Survey 2013 Primary Contact: Randy Lusk Phone: 1-800-255-1521 Time Period: July 29, 2013 to Sept 23, 2013 On Schedule (allowing for uncontrollable circumstances) Yes Provide details if early or late completion: Contractor completed the survey in a timely manner with no complaints from residents. All of their vehicles were marked with their company logo and used two man crews at all times. They were also responsible for traffic control while working in town Change Orders (attach information if needed): None Difficulties / Positives: The Overall project completed satisfactorily. Contractor provided reports that were accurate with locations of all the leaks detected. A total of 33 Leaks were located and 6 of those were main leaks, 3 Service Lines, 4 Valves and 20 Hydrants. Village crews had made all the repairs prior to the snow season. Interaction with public: Excellent (Attach information on any complaints or compliments) General Level of Satisfaction with work: Well Satisfied Reviewers: Dave Bird, Water Manager Date: 8/21/2014