The Chinese University of Hong Kong Department of Marketing, CUHK Business School MKTG3010A: MARKETING RESEARCH



Similar documents
COURSE OUTLINE - Marketing Research BUS , Fall 2015

PSYC 1000A General Psychology , 1 st Term Department of Psychology The Chinese University of Hong Kong

: Applied Marketing Research ( First Term)

MKTG 330 FLORENCE: MARKET RESEARCH Syllabus Spring 2011 (Tentative)

INFS5873 Business Analytics. Course Outline Semester 2, 2014

The University of North Carolina at Greensboro CRS 605: Research Methodology in Consumer, Apparel, and Retail Studies (3 Credits) Spring 2014

IS Management Information Systems

Business Computer Applications CGS 1100 Course Syllabus. Course Title:

THE UNIVERSITY OF HONG KONG FACULTY OF BUSINESS AND ECONOMICS

OBJECTIVES: After this course, you:

Accounting : Accounting Information Systems and Controls. Fall 2015 COLLEGE OF BUSINESS AND INNOVATION

GGR272: GEOGRAPHIC INFORMATION AND MAPPING I. Course Outline

MARKETING ANALYSIS & DECISION MAKING MTKG 3222 Section 1 Fall 2015 M 3:30-6:15 FRIDAY 122

Geza Bottlik ISE310L Facilities and Logistics Fall /09/13 Instructor:

MARSHALL SCHOOL OF BUSINESS University of Southern California. FBE 555: Investment Analysis and Portfolio Management

MBA K731 (E) Project Management Winter 2014 Course Outline. Information Systems Area DeGroote School of Business McMaster University

Introduction to Business Course Syllabus. Dr. Michelle Choate Office # C221 Phone: Mobile Office:

College of Business San Francisco State University

MKTG MARKETING RESEARCH 2010 INSTRUCTOR INFORMATION

MKTG , Marketing Research and Information Technology Course Syllabus, Spring :30-11:00 a.m. MW

FUNDAMENTALS OF NEGOTIATIONS Purdue University Fall 2014 CSR CRN Tuesday and Thursday 7:30 AM - 8:45 AM Krannert Building G016

DIGITAL PRODUCTION AND GAME DESIGN (DPGD)

Investment Management Course

GET 114 Computer Programming Course Outline. Contact: Office Hours: TBD (or by appointment)

Marketing for Hospitality and Tourism Course Syllabus. Dr. Michelle Choate Office # C221 Phone: Mobile Office:

INFO 2130 Introduction to Business Computing Fall 2014

Management 352: Human Resource Management Spring 2015 Syllabus

College of Charleston School of Business DSCI : Management Information Systems Fall 2014

Northwestern University BUS_INST 239 Marketing Management Fall Department of Psychology University Hall, Room 102 Swift Hall (2029 Sheridan Rd.

GGR272: GEOGRAPHIC INFORMATION AND MAPPING I. Course Outline

advertising research methods

A Class Project in Survey Sampling

MKT 403: Electronic Marketing, Class 38724

UNIVERSITY OF DAYTON MANAGEMENT AND MARKETING DEPARTMENT MKT 315: RETAIL MARKETING Course Syllabus Winter 2008, Section 01

ISMT527 - SPRING 2003 DATA MINING TOOLS AND APPLICATIONS

IT 415 Information Visualization Spring Semester

VIRGINIA COMMONWEALTH UNIVERSITY Department of Biology BIOL : HUMAN ANATOMY FOR BIOLOGY MAJORS Fall 2016 SYLLABUS

Course Outline 2016 MKTG 202: MARKETING RESEARCH (15 POINTS) Summer Semester (1160)

George Mason University Electrical and Computer Engineering Department ECE 201: Introduction to Signal Analysis Syllabus Fall 2015

BUAD 310 Applied Business Statistics. Syllabus Fall 2013

UNIVERSITY OF BRIDGEPORT School of Engineering COURSE SYLLABUS. TCMG-555-6T1 Project Management

Research Methods in Advertising and Public Relations COMM 420 Spring Earth & Eng. Sci. W/F 12:20 PM to 2:15 PM

Geza Bottlik ISE310L Facilities and Logistics Spring /21/2009 Pre-Requisites: Test Schedule

HKUST Course Syllabus Outline (experimental only)

BA in Management Program Summer Semester, 2015 MKTG 410 Social Media and Search Marketing Analytics

The guidelines for Major Projects in the College of Liberal Arts are brief:

Hong Kong University of Science and Technology School of Business and Management Spring 2015

INTS 3100 INTERDISCIPLINARY STUDIES (3 credits) FALL 2011 MWF am Sec 1 CRN # T pm Sec 50 CRN #43665 NPLAZA 113B

MARK3220 MARKETING RESEARCH

Quantitative Analysis in International Affairs American University School of International Service SIS Fall 2008

Course: ISYS 4373 Application Development with Java Prerequisite: ISYS 3293

MOUNT SAINT MARY S UNIVERSITY Los Angeles MBA PROGRAM SYLLABUS. Foundations. BUS 206: Essentials of Marketing

Technology and Online Computer Access Requirements: Lake-Sumter State College Course Syllabus

Faculty of Management Marketing Research MGT 3220 Y Fall 2015 Tuesdays, 6:00pm 8:50pm Room: S4027 Lab: N637

Physics 21-Bio: University Physics I with Biological Applications Syllabus for Spring 2012

Completed/Your Grade. Weekly Work 25% Discussion Board 15% Document Paper 15% Midterm Exam 1 15% Midterm Exam 2 15% Final Exam 15%

Marketing Area DeGroote School of Business McMaster University

ISQS 3358 BUSINESS INTELLIGENCE FALL 2014

GGR462/JPG1914: GIS RESEARCH PROJECT. Course Outline

School of Business ACCT2105/BUSI0027 (Subclasses A, B, C) Introduction to Management Accounting/ Management Accounting I Course Syllabus

ANT 2330: Cross-Cultural Communication. Tues / Thurs 6:30pm 7:45pm in WC 230

MIS 140 Management Information Systems Course Syllabus for Fall Quarter 2013

Introduction to Organizational Behavior (Business 260)

Florida Gulf Coast University Lutgert College of Business Marketing Department MAR3503 Consumer Behavior Spring 2015

General Psychology. Course Syllabus

Cross-Cultural Communication COM450

Los Angeles Pierce College. SYLLABUS Math 227: Elementary Statistics. Fall 2011 T Th 4:45 6:50 pm Section #3307 Room: MATH 1400

Course Syllabus BUS233E SOCIAL MARKETING

Course Syllabus: Marketing Research

COURSE NUMBER AND TITLE: Management Information Systems Concepts

WARRINGTON COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ART AND SCIENCE OF NEGOTIATION (MAN 6447)

Psychology 472: Experimental Analysis of Behavior Fall 2014

George Washington University Department of Psychology PSYC 001: General Psychology

MARK 228: Communication & Digital Media

How To Gain Competitive Advantage With Big Data Analytics And Visualization

OBJECTIVES OF THE COURSE

Sociology 328A: Social Statistics (3.0 Credits) Department of Sociology, University of British Columbia Winter Term I, Sep 03 Nov 28, 2013

WESTERN UNIVERSITY LONDON CANADA Department of Psychology Fall Distance 2014 Psychology 3301F Online Clinical Psychology

Strategic Use of Information Technology (CIS ) Summer /

Required Materials: Babbie, Earl The Basics of Social Research (6 th ed.). Belmont: Cengage

INTRODUCTION TO SMALL BUSINESS MANAGEMENT MANAGEMENT 103 (52356) 3 semester credits Summer Semester 2014

UNIVERSITY OF LETHBRIDGE FACULTY OF MANAGEMENT Mgt 2400A Management Accounting Fall 2014

EMPORIA STATE UNIVERSITYSCHOOL OF BUSINESS Department of Accounting and Information Systems. IS213 A Management Information Systems Concepts

BUSSTAT 207 Introduction to Business Statistics Fall 2015

INDUSTRIAL/ORGANZATIONAL PSYCHOLOGY MWF 10:00-10:50, Thach 202

INFO 2130 Introduction to Business Computing Spring 2013 Self-Paced Section 006

Agricultural Accounting AECO 2200 Course Outline. : relad@abac.edu Other times by appointment

MSIS 630 Project and Change Management (Fall 2014) Course Syllabus

Digital Communication Southwest College

Fall, Alternating: Friday, 11 am - 2 pm Tuesday, 11 am - 1 pm. Location, NB. Advance confirmation always preferred;

OPMG 5811 LOGISTICS MANAGEMENT. Course Outline* Semester 2, 2012

Course Overview and Objectives

Management 3050 Y Human Resource Management

Program Development Project Management (PDPM) Syllabus

English 1302 Writing Across the Curriculum Spring 2016

School of Kinesiology Faculty of Health Sciences Western University. KIN 2032b Research Design in Human Movement Science January to April 2016

UNIVERSITY OF LA VERNE COLLEGE OF LAW NEGOTIATION DAY CLASS CRN Spring 2015 Syllabus

Central Michigan University College of Business Administration Online MBA Program. MBA 620 Online: Managerial Accounting: A Management Perspective

Any additional readings will be available as pdf documents on our course website.

Transcription:

The Chinese University of Hong Kong Department of Marketing, CUHK Business School MKTG3010A: MARKETING RESEARCH Meeting time: Tue 14:30 17:15 Meeting period: Sep 8, 2015 Dec 1, 2015 Meeting place: CYT 410 Instructors: Office Hour: Teaching Assistant: Prof. Mandy Hu Rm1105, 11/F, Cheng Yu Tung Building, CUHK MandyHu@baf.cuhk.edu.hk Tel: 3943-5908 14:00 16:00 (Friday) or by appointment Miss DANG, Chu (Ivy) Rm1149-1151, 11/F, Cheng Yu Tung Building, CUHK dangchu@baf.cuhk.edu.hk Tel: 6436-0831 Description of the course The main objective of this course is to equip students with the key concepts, process and methods of marketing research, and learn how to apply those tools to solve reallife business problems. This course puts more emphasis on quantitative research methods to prepare students for the newest development in the field. We cover the technical aspects of marketing research (both qualitative and quantitative research methods) through lectures and discuss real life applications using various articles and cases. An important element of this course is a marketing research project (more details under the Marketing Research Project section below) where students identify and solve a real business problem using marketing research methods. Learning objectives 1. To develop an appreciation for the potential contributions and limitations of marketing research. 2. To learn about the steps in the marketing research process, which include problem definition, research design (exploratory, descriptive and causal), data collection methods, questionnaire design, sampling schemes, and data analysis. 3. To operationalize several key marketing concepts such as customer preference, segmentation, targeting, positioning and new product development. 1

Learning outcomes On successfully completing this course, students should be able to: 1. Understand the basic concepts, processes and techniques of marketing research. 2. Apply the knowledge to solve real business problems. 3. Appreciate the fundamental role marketing research plays in developing a credible marketing plan and supporting a company s short-term and long-term objectives. Prerequisite Courses MKTG 2010 Class Requirements & Grading Class commitment: 20% Group Project: 30% Midterm Exam: 20% Final Exam: 30% Required materials Required Textbook: Marketing Research: An Applied Orientation, 6th ed., by Naresh K. Malhotra, Pearson, 2009 Required software: IBM SPSS Statistics 18 or above (You may also access SPSS using Computer Lab), Microsoft EXCEL (version 2007 or newer) Reading materials: You may download all the reading materials/video from Blackboard. 1. Backward Market Research * 2. The Science of Shopping (section 1, 2 &3) 3. Ethnographic Research: How Americans Eat (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qbdpuqyjxmg) 4. Boost Your Marketing ROI with Experimental Design 5. Mining the Mind 6. Self-Reports: How the Questions Shape the Answers * 7. Market Research The Inside Story (BBC Documentary) * (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eirq6hdijbu) 8. The TED talk of Malcolm Gladwell on Spaghetti Sauce (http://www.ted.com/talks/malcolm_gladwell_on_spaghetti_sauce?language= en) 2

Detailed Class Requirements Class commitment (20%) Given that marketing research is an applied subject where participation and discussion is essential for learning, I encourage class participation and interaction as much as possible. Class participation is mainly evaluated by the following criteria: Electronics Policy You may not use electronic devices (laptops, ipads, tablets, mobile phones, Blackberries, etc.) in class unless directed to do so. Classroom Etiquette Attendance and Punctuality: Class will begin on time. Please make every effort to arrive for class on time as late entries are distracting to your classmates. If you are unable to arrive on time or must leave early, please enter/exit the room as quietly as possible so as not to disturb your fellow students. If you are unable to attend class for any reason, please notify me in advance (or as soon as possible) by email. There are exceptions in accordance with CUHK policy for religious holidays, funeral, and student/dependent hospitalizations, weddings, interviews, etc. Students are expected to remain in class for the entirety of the session. Beverages and Snacks: You are welcome to bring something to drink to class. Please don t bring food into class. Class Sessions Rather than merely rehashing concepts developed in the textbook, class sessions will be devoted to extending and applying the concepts. I will assume that all of you have completed the reading assignments (both chapters in the textbook and articles assigned) before coming to class. If you all come to class well prepared, we will be able to spend time on class exercises that simulate real world problems. You should be prepared to discuss and present in class the readings and/or problems that have been assigned for that session. In-class Exercises Starting from Week 3, you will spend the second half of the classes working on exercises. You will work in groups. There are two types of exercises. One is about assigned readings and videos. The readings will be uploaded to Blackboard in the beginning of the semester. The links to the videos are provided in the course outline. The star indicates that the material is difficult so the team who chooses that will have 2 bonus points automatically. Each group will present one of the readings/videos (15 minutes) and raise three questions 3

about the reading to the class. The other teams email the answers to the questions to the focal team voluntarily and the instructor (cc TA) by Friday of that week. The answers will be graded by the focal team. The focal team will send the grades to the instructor and TA by Sunday of that week. All the answers will be posted to Blackboard. On the other hand, the quality of the presentation and the raised questions of the focal team will be evaluated by the rest of the class. Each one has to fill up a short evaluation form on Blackboard right after the class. The other type of exercises is short answer/calculation questions. They serve to facilitate your learning process by summarizing the key points you just learned and applying them to real business problems. You will be working in groups to answer those questions. The group performance on the exercises will count toward your class commitment grade. The team with the best performance will have full marks. The score of other teams will be normalized according to the formula in Appendix. Midterm Exam (20%) and Final Exam (30%) The purpose of the exams is to assess your analytic skills and technical competence. The exam will cover materials presented in textbook, lectures and articles discussed in class. Exams are closed book. Midterm Exam is optional. You can let me know your decision even after you take the midterm exam but before I start grading. If you opt out, your final exam will count for 50% of your total grade. Marketing Research Project (30%) The objective of the research project is to provide students with experience in applying the concepts and methods learned in class to a real world problem. Group Formation and Choice of Research Problem The project is to be done in groups of 5 to 6 students. You are required to send the names, student IDs and pictures of group members to the TA before the deadline in week 2. Please also indicate the week and date that you want to present the reading material. The group submission form can be downloaded from Blackboard. You are not allowed to change group members after the course add/drop period. A good team is formed based on mutual interests among its members instead of pure friendship. So everyone has to submit a research problem by the end of the first week through blackboard. We will compile a list of research problems for the class. In the second week, everyone will be given a chance to introduce yourself and talk about the topic you choose. This will help you get to know each other and form the group. 4

Project Management The project has been broken into different tasks (please refer to the course schedule for the deadlines). To keep track of the progress, we will let each team report its progress in the beginning of each class starting from week 3. Notes on Survey An important point to keep in mind is that respondents in the survey should have the right to remain anonymous. This means that the data collected in the survey must be stored in a manner such that individuals identities cannot be linked to their responses. Respondents must be assured before you collect data that their responses will be treated as confidential and will be anonymously analysed. Under no circumstances should you give to your sponsor or anyone else your completed questionnaires, names and contact information of people you have interviewed, or other material that may reveal the identity of your respondents without their prior explicit approval. Respondents should also be provided with the name and contact information of either the client or a group member in case they have questions regarding the research. When conducting your survey, you should do one of the following: 1. Represent yourself as CUHK students working on a class project and provide contact information with your CUHK email address in case respondents would like to ask about the research. 2. Represent yourself as CUHK students working on a class project for a client (identify the client) and provide contact information of one of the group member and/or the client. To the extent feasible, please also indicate how you obtain the contact information of the respondents you are contacting. Please be reminded that you are at all times expected to respect and protect the privacy rights of the respondents. You should also not misrepresent the School or your client in any fashion or form. Evaluation Your final group project report is due in Week 13. To help you manage the project, I have broken it into five tasks: 1. The research proposal You should have a brief description of the client background, the business problem, research objectives, and how they follow from the business problem. Outline a research design and briefly justify the choice (e.g., interviews + web survey, focus groups + phone survey, on-site observations + survey, etc.). Discuss potential problems in the research design. 2. An exploratory research 5

This part should include secondary data analyses and qualitative research. Your secondary data analyses may include analysing industry reports, economic trends, input from existing data sources (e.g., company data, census, trendwatching.com, etc.); your qualitative research may include one-on-one interviews, focus groups, observations, etc. You are welcome to make videos of focus groups or on-spot observations. This part typically takes 3-5 pages in length in your report. In the exploratory research report, please: 1. Describe the insights gained from secondary data (include proper citations) 2. Describe the qualitative research that you conducted and the key findings 3. Discuss how these findings may be used to refine your research objective and identify the target population. 4. Include in the appendix any tables and figures, as well as guiding questions used in the qualitative research. 3. Draft questionnaire and sampling strategy: 1. Define planned target population for data collection. If you are considering online surveys with panel respondents, please be precise (e.g., Females 18 65 who purchase yogurt at least once a week). 2. Your sampling strategy and sample size (if using a random sample) 3. A draft questionnaire that you have developed to address the research objective and research questions that you have identified. The questionnaire should include: An introduction (who you are, what the survey is about, how long it is going to take, any compensation/incentive, and reasons why they should complete this) The questions A thank you section Contact information in case the respondents have questions about the research and/or the survey The accompanying cover letter/email/verbal script A few suggestions: 1. Try to show professionalism in wording, formatting and sequencing the questions. 6

2. For each question in the questionnaire, think about how it will help you answer the bigger research questions and what type of analysis you are planning to use on the responses to that question (set of questions). 3. Given the time constraints you face, I encourage but do not require a random sampling procedure. If you follow non-random sampling, appropriate caveats for the use/interpretation of your results must be stated. 4. Data Analysis and Final report You are required to collect at least 100 completed survey responses if you decide to use survey to collect data. If you want to use some other ad hoc approach, please talk to me first. The final report should be 12-point font, 1- inch margin and should not be longer than 20 double-spaced pages, excluding tables and figures and the final questionnaire. Please note that if your client does not wish the contents of the report to be made public, make sure that you put CONFIDENTIAL on the front cover of the report. Please submit a zip file that contains a copy of the i) Final Report and ii) the data file (in excel). Your final report should follow this structure: 1. An executive Summary. Describe in one paragraph the business problem, the research methodology, the main findings, the conclusions and your recommendation to the client. The purpose of the executive summary is to allow really busy CEOs to get a good grasp of what you have done, and digest the most essential information without reading every sentence in the report. 2. Background. Define the problem to be studied and the purpose to be served by the research (What is the benefit to the client? What is the value of the research project?). This is what you did in the first task. 3. The research strategy. Define the population and the sampling frame. Describe your sampling method as well as the size and profile of your sample. If secondary data are used, identify the sources. This is what you did in the first task. 4. Briefly describe the exploratory research you conducted. The insights you generated and how that led to the design of your questionnaire. This is what you did in the second task. 5. Include the final version of your questionnaire in the Appendix so that I know exactly what questions were asked and what scales were used in the questionnaire. You also need to talk about your sampling strategy in the report 7

which should include all the components I introduced in class. This is what you did in the third task. 6. Report your findings. You need to show how you analyse the data, the results and your interpretation of the results. Discuss the implications of these findings for your client. You can either use the data analysis methods you learned in this class or from other classes. However, a successful application of the methods from this class will be evaluated more favourably. 7. Finally, your recommendations what should the client do? Make sure that your recommendations are supported by the research findings. 8. Appendix 9. List of references. 5. Presentation All groups have to submit your presentation PowerPoint in week 11 to TA via email. You are not allowed to change after that. You will make a 30-minute presentation of your project in class. Your presentation should be based on your research report and have the following structure. a) Introduce the business problem b) Define the research objective c) Insights from exploratory research d) Link c) to your questionnaire design e) Describe your sampling method and the size of your sample f) Data analysis and key findings g) Your recommendation General presentation guidelines: 1. All the members of the group should make the presentation. 2. Time limit: 30 minutes (with another 5 min Q&A). The group marks will be deducted 1 point (out of the total 30 points) per 1 minute overdue. 3. Q & A 5 minutes. Be prepared to answer questions from the Client. Students may be randomly selected to ask questions and give comments. 4. Evaluation. The marking is based on: The evaluation of rest of the class (including the instructor) (70%). The weight is the same. Self-evaluation (30%) which is calculated based on how close your own evaluation is with the evaluation of the rest of the class. 8

Other Class Related Issues Course Website: All relevant material related to the course will be posted on Blackboard. Schedules, reading material, cases, and class notes will be made available in class. Grading: You can only appeal a grade if there is a clear misreading of what you wrote. I can give you suggestions for improving your work, but will not respond to emotional appeals. Due dates: All due dates are strictly enforced without valid reason and prior permission. Late assignments will not be accepted. Feedback: If at any point during the course you have any questions regarding the materials covered in class or regarding preparation for assignments or cases, please raise them either in class so others may also benefit, or via email, or in person. Group member Review: Group members can evaluate each other s performance on the assignment and project using a peer review form available on Blackboard. If no evaluation is turned in, I will assume that everybody in the group contributed equally. Individual project grades may be adjusted up or down depending on the evaluations by all the other group members. Plagiarism: Attention is drawn to University policy and regulations on honesty in academic work, and to the disciplinary guidelines and procedures applicable to breaches of such policy and regulations. Details may be found at http://www.cuhk.edu.hk/policy/academichonesty/. To uphold the University's policy on plagiarism, please submit your written assignment through VeriGuide (https://veriguide1.cse.cuhk.edu.hk/cuhk/). When turn in a hard copy, please attach a signed "Academic Honesty Declaration Statement" to it. 9

Class Schedule Week 1 (Sep 8) Course Overview Research Question Skim: Chapter 1-2, 14 Submit (ind) Please submit your research question/interest to the TA as well as your name, student ID and email address through Blackboard. Week 2 (Sep 15) Research Designs: Exploratory, Descriptive & Causal Research Group formation Read: Chapter 3 Skim: Chapters 4-5 Submit (gr) Please submit your Group Form as well as the presentation date to TA by email (due 8pm on Sep 16). Week 3 (Sep 22) Descriptive & Causal Research Read: Chapter 6 7 Reminder: We will start reporting project progress from this week. We will start to have presentation and exercises from this week. Week 4 (Sep 29) Topics: Types of Scales and Attitude Measurement Questionnaire Design 10

Read: Chapter 8-9 Skim: Chapters 10 Reminder: Project Proposal should be done. Week 5 (Oct 6) Sampling & Sample Size Read: Chapters 11-12 Skim: Chapters 13-14 Week 6 (Oct 13) Designing New Products (Conjoint Analysis) Read: Chapter 21 Skim: Reminder: New Way to Measure Consumers Judgements Exploratory research should be done. Week 7 Midterm Exam Week 8 (Oct 27) Frequency Distribution, Cross Tabulation, and Hypothesis Testing Read: Chapters 15 Case 3.1 in the textbook, P. 820-824 Reminder: Questionnaire and Sample Strategy should be done. 11

9 (Nov 3) Regression Read: Chapters 17 Case 3.1 in the textbook, P. 820-824 Week 10 (Nov 10) Factor Analysis Read: Chapter 19 Case 3.1 in the textbook, P. 820-824 Week 11 (Nov 17) Group Presentation -1 Submit (gr) Final Project Presentation Slides (due 8pm on Nov 16) Week 12 (Nov 25) Group Presentation -2 Week 13 (Dec 1(Tue), time= TBD venue = TBD) Final Exam Week 14 Submit (gr) Final Project Report (due 8pm on Dec 8) Please submit a zip file that contains your i) final report, and ii) data file (in excel). 12

Appendix: Evaluation Method 1. For group project ( ) 2. For exercise 3. Forget to submit peer evaluation? We will automatically assume that you give the highest score to the other team. 4. Individual Score ( ) 5. Strategic Grading Some of the students will be very strategic when they evaluate the other teams. They tend to give low grade no matter what. To encourage fair play, for each presentation if the average grade of peer evaluation differs from the instructor s grade by 2 standard deviation, we will award the top 3 students whose evaluation is closest to the instructor s and the discrepancy is within 1 standard deviation by 2 bonus points. 13