YEŞİLIRMAK BASIN DEVELOPMENT PROJECT (AMASYA, ÇORUM, SAMSUN, TOKAT) CURRENT SITUATION AND ANALYSIS ANNEXES

Transcription

1

2

3 T. R. PRIME MINISTRY STATE PLANNING ORGANIZATION SPO T. R. PRIME MINISTRY STATE PLANNING ORGANIZATION General Directorate of Regional Development and Structural Adjustment YEŞİLIRMAK BASIN DEVELOPMENT PROJECT (AMASYA, ÇORUM, SAMSUN, TOKAT) CURRENT SITUATION AND ANALYSIS ANNEXES An environmentally sensitive, competitive, rapidly developing region, which has become Turkey s gateway to the Black Sea and which has raised its quality of life DOLSAR Engineering Limited December 2004 Ankara

4 Y E Ş İ L I R M A K B A S I N D E V E L O P M E N T P R O J E C T Published: Ankara, 2006

5 MEMBERS OF ACCEPTANCE COMMITTEE, GUIDANCE AND EVALUATION COMMITTEE OF THE YEŞİLIRMAK BASIN DEVELOPMENT PROJECT AND CONTRIBUTORS FROM STATE PLANNING ORGANIZATION* ACCEPTANCE COMMITTEE Ahmet YAMAN General Director of Regional Development and Structural Adjustment Cevdet YILMAZ General Director of Relations with EU Mehmet ÇIRAK Head of Monitoring and Evaluation Department Ömer BİLEN Head of Monitoring and Evaluation Department Dr. Cahit BAĞCI Undersecretariat Advisor MEMBERS OF GUIDANCE AND EVALUATION COMMITTEE (CONTROL ORGANIZATION) Cemalettin KAYMAK Head of Priority Regions for Development Department Nevin SORGUÇ Head of Regional Development Department Deniz AKKAHVE Head of EU Regional Development Programs Department Cumhur BOZ Head of State Economic Enterprises and Social Security Department Ayşenur GÖNÜL Head of Financial Markets Department Ahmet ÇELENKOĞLU Head of Economic Evaluation Department Aziz BABACAN Head of Agriculture Department Mehmet TARAKÇIOĞLU Head of Agriculture Department Murat Ş. YAZAN Head of Agriculture Department Abdüllatif TUNA Head of Department of Industry Hülya TOKGÖZ Head of Infrastructure and Services Department Yılmaz ILGIN Head of Project, Investment Analysis and Evaluation Department İlyas ÇELİKOĞLU Head of Social Policies Department Yılmaz TUNA Head of Human Resources Development Department Sedat ÇETİK Head of Social Physical Infrastructure Department Niyazi İLTER Head of Social Physical Infrastructure Department Mehmet TEKİN Head of Social Researches Department Kamil AYANOĞLU Head of Social Researches Department C U R R E N T S I T U A T I O N A N A L Y S I S A N N E X E S GENERAL DIRECTORATE OF REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT AND STRUCTURAL ADJUSTMENT Ahmet KINDAP Planning Expert Rasim AKPINAR Planning Expert Ayşe ÖZÇÖREKÇİ Contracted Employee Metin ÖZASLAN Planning Expert Hasan ŞANALMIŞ Assistant Planning Expert Mehmet Emin ÖZSAN Assistant Planning Expert Nuri Barış TARTICI Assistant Planning Expert Murat KARA Assistant Planning Expert Mesut AKBAŞ Assistant Planning Expert Ahmet TAMER Assistant Planning Expert * According to their positions during the execution of the project. i

6 LOCAL PARTICIPATION PROVIDED FOR THE YEŞİLIRMAK BASIN DEVELOPMENT PLAN Y E Ş İ L I R M A K B A S I N D E V E L O P M E N T P R O J E C T ORGANIZATIONS AND ESTABLISHMENTS Governorates of Amasya, Çorum, Samsun and Tokat, Yeşilırmak Basin Development Union Provincial planning directorates of Amasya, Çorum, Samsun and Tokat Provincial directorate of industry and commerce of Amasya, Çorum, Samsun and Tokat Provincial agricultural directorates of Amasya, Çorum, Samsun and Tokat Special provincial administrations of Amasya, Çorum, Samsun and Tokat Provincial directorates for rural services of Amasya, Çorum, Samsun and Tokat Provincial directorates of culture and tourism of Amasya, Çorum, Samsun and Tokat Provincial directorates of health of Amasya, Çorum, Samsun and Tokat Provincial directorates of national education of Amasya, Çorum, Samsun and Tokat Provincial directorates of environment and forests of Amasya, Çorum, Samsun and Tokat Amasya, Çorum, Samsun and Tokat Tax Offices Provincial directorates of title deeds and cadastre of Amasya, Çorum, Samsun and Tokat Municipalities of Amasya, Çorum and Tokat, Metropolitan Municipality of Samsun Municipalities of Amasya Merzifon, Suluova, Taşova, Çorum-Alaca, Osmancık, Sungurlu, Samsun- Bafra, Çarşamba, Havza, Terme, Tekkeköy, Vezirköprü, Tokat- Erbaa, Niksar, Turhal, Zile Chambers of commerce and industry of Merzifon, Suluova, Gümüşhacıköy, Taşova, Çorum- Sungurlu, Samsun- Havza, Terme, Çarşamba, Bafra, Tokat- Turhal, Zile, Niksar, Erbaa Chambers of tradesmen and artisans of Amasya, Çorum, Terme and Taşova DSİ section directorates of Amasya, Çorum, Samsun and Tokat Irrigation unions cooperatives of Amasya, Çorum, Samsun and Tokat Stud cattle breeding unions of Amasya, Çorum, Samsun and Tokat Amasya Suluova agricultural development directorates OIZ Directorates of Amasya, Çorum, Samsun, Tokat ve Merzifon, Erbaa, Niksar SIE Directorates of Amasya, Çorum, Samsun and Tokat Amasya, İskilip Vocational Education Directorates Foundations and associations: SAMSİAD, ÇORUMSİAD, TOSİAD İskilip Public Training Center Chambers of profession of Amasya, Çorum, Samsun and Tokat (those affiliated with TMMOB, chambers of physicians, chambers of accountants etc.) Banks in the provinces of Amasya, Çorum, Samsun and Tokat Financial and intermediary establishments of Amasya, Çorum, Samsun and Tokat Industrial exploitations in the provinces of Amasya, Çorum, Samsun and Tokat Samsun Ondokuzmayıs University. Tokat Gaziosmanpaşa University Central Anatolian Exporters Unions Samsun Foreign Trade Regional Directorate Samsun Customs Directorate Çorum Customs Directorate VII. Regional Directorate of DSI/Samsun Karadeniz (Black Sea) Agricultural Research Institute/Samsun Local media establishments of Amasya, Çorum, Samsun and Tokat PARTICIPATION PROVIDED BY USING PARTICIPATORY DATA COLLECTION TECHNIQUES Focused Group Interview (FGI) in the provinces of Amasya, Çorum, Samsun and Tokat 12 women and families FGI meetings Amasya seasonal female workers FGI meetings Çorum bricks tiles workers FGI meetings Samsun tobacco workers FGI meetings Tokat construction workers FGI meetings 14 poverty FGI meetings Forest Operation Chiefs FGI meetings Meetings Regional parliament members awareness meetings Merzifon Industrial Planning and Coordination Meeting Samsun III. City Congress Samsun Provincial Development Strategy Meetings (SABEK A.Ş.) Samsun Special Provincial Strategically Draft Plan Meeting Irrigation unions and cooperations in Amasya, Çorum and Tokat provinces Provincial agricultural directorates of Amasya, Çorum, Samsun and Tokat Provincial food control laboratories Çorum, Samsun and Tokat Merzifon Stud Cattle Breeders Union Amasya Yedikır Dam Water Products Production Station Amasya Regional Forestry Directorate Forestry head offices of Amasya, Taşova, Çorum, Kargı, İskilip Samsun, Bafra Vezirköprü, Çarşamba, Salıpazarı, Tokat, Almus, Erbaa, Niksar and village headmen under said head offices Surveys Survey on Consolidation of Women and Families Survey on Poverty, Social Security and Labor Survey on Manufacturing Industry (large scale entrepreneurs, 10+) Survey on Manufacturing Industry (small scale entrepreneurs, 10-) Survey on Business Survey on Transportation Survey on Ranking of Settlements SWOT Analysis Meetings Çarşamba Niksar Merzifon Zile Osmancık SCENARIO ANALYSIS MEETINGS Amasya Merzifon (with the participation of Gümüşhacıköy, Suluova) Samsun (with the participation of Tekkeköy) Bafra (with the participation of Alaçam, Ondokuzmayıs) Çarşamba (with the participation of Terme, Salıpazarı, Ayvacık) Çorum (with the participation of Laçin) Alaca (with the participation of Boğazkale, Ortaköy, Mecitözü) Osmancık (with the participation of Kargı, İskilip, Oğuzlar, Dodurga) Sungurlu Tokat Turhal (with the participation of Pazar, Zile) Niksar (with the participation of Erbaa, Almus) MEETINGS RELATED TO DEBATES ON CURRENT SITUATION ANALYSIS and STRATEGY and RESTRUCTURING SCENARIOS REPORTS Çorum (with the participation of Amasya, Samsun, Tokat) MEETINGS RELATED TO DEBATES ON DRAFT MASTER PLAN Governorate of Amasya Amasya Municipality Merzifon Municipality Taşova Municipality Governorate of Çorum Çorum Municipality Governorate of Samsun Samsun Metropolitan Municipality Bafra Municipality Governorate of Tokat Tokat Municipality Erbaa Municipality Turhal Municipality ii

7 DOLSAR ENGINEERING YEŞİLIRMAK BASIN DEVELOPMENT PROJECT PROJECT TEAM M. Sinan AKER Project Director Akın ATAUZ Project Coordinator Rıfat TÜRKKAN Deputy Project Coordinator Doğan PEKÇAĞLIYAN Deputy Project Coordinator Şahin BEKİŞOĞLU Group Manager for Economic Structure Doç. Dr. Feryal TURAN Group Manager for Social Structure Sadettin ZORLUTUNA Group Manager for Urban and Rural Infrastructure (Infrastructure) Hüseyin ÇİÇEK Group Manager for Urban and Rural Infrastructure (Urbanization) Sevgi ARSLAN Group Manager for Environment C U R R E N T S I T U A T I O N A N A L Y S I S A N N E X E S Sermet ADIGÜZEL Burhan ARIÖZ Baki ARSLAN Hüsamettin ATEŞ Yalçın Kaya AYDOS Adil BACAK Hakan DAMAR Nihan DERİNÖZ Ali Osman ERDEM Bilge Çınar ERTEM Ümit GİRİŞ İzzet KARACAGİL Şükrü KAYA Ercüment KOYUNCU Nusret KUTLU Ali Onur KUYUCAK Mesut ÖNER Ertuğrul ÖZBEK Kağan SOLMAZ Murat ŞAHİN Sezin ÜSKENT Prof. Dr. Cüneyt ELKER Prof. Dr. Gazi ÖZHAN Prof. Dr. Fersun PAYKOÇ Prof. Dr. Gencay ŞAYLAN Prof. Dr. Hüseyin TATLIDİL Prof. Dr. Levent TURAN Doç. Dr. Selim ÇAĞATAY Doç. Dr. Alper GÜZEL Doç. Dr. Meral ÖZHAN Doç. Dr. Turgay ÜNALAN Doç. Dr. Asuman TÜRKÜN Dr. Aydın AKBULUT Dr. Murat BUKET Dr. Ufuk COŞGUN Dr. Tayfun PEKÇAĞLIYAN Dr. İdris TOSUN Dr. Sarp ÜNER Melih ARAL Haşim ALTINÖZLÜ Nejat DURA Nilgün PEKÇAĞLIYAN ADVISORY BOARD Prof. Dr. Servet MUTLU Prof. Dr. Ayda ERAYDIN Prof. Dr. Bahattin AKŞİT Prof. Dr. Süleyman KODAL Doç. Dr. Melih PINARCIOĞLU iii

8 Y E Ş İ L I R M A K B A S I N D E V E L O P M E N T P R O J E C T iv

9 Contents CONTENTS 1 INSTRUMENTS FOR THE EUROPEAN UNION PRE-ACCESSION FINANCIAL ASSISTANCES NUTS CLASSIFICATION NUTS LEVEL 2 INDICATORS AND COMPARISONS THE RANGE OF TR83 REGION DISTRICTS IN TERMS OF SOCIO ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT THE DATA OF POPULATION, EDUCATION, EMPLOYMENT, AGRICULTURE AND GROSS NATIONAL PRODUCT 5-1 C U R R E N T S I T U A T I O N A N A L Y S I S A N N E X E S 6 INSTITUTIONALIZATION CURRENT ORGANIZATION OF PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION CENTRAL ADMINISTRATION DEVELOPMENT AGENCIES LOCAL ADMINISTRATIONS Special Provincial Administration Villages METROPOLITAN MUNICIPALITY LOCAL ADMINISTRATION UNIONS AN OVERVIEW TO LAWS WHICH DETERMINE THE LOCAL ADMINISTRATION ONCE MORE LOCAL ADMINISTRATION UNIONS WHICH ARE CURRENT IN THE REGION UNION OF SAMSUN MUNICIPALITIES YEŞILIRMAK BASIN DEVELOPMENT UNION The Goal Of the Union Mode Of Operation The Bodies of the Union Incomes of the Union Expenditures of The Union The Budget of The Union 6-27 v

10 Contents Activities To Build A Vision INSTITUTIONAL STRUCTURES WHICH ARE EFFECTIVE IN REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT THE PRELIMINARY PROPOSAL FOR INSTITUTIONALIZATION SWOT ANALYSES INTRODUCTION MERZIFON DISTRICT STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES OPPORTUNITIES THREATS OSMANCIK DISTRICT STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES OPPORTUNITIES THREATS 7-10 Y E Ş İ L I R M A K B A S I N D E V E L O P M E N T P R O J E C T 7.4 ÇARŞAMBA DISTRICT STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES OPPORTUNITIES THREATS NİKSAR DISTRICT STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES OPPORTUNITIES THREATS ZİLE DISTRICT STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES OPPORTUNITIES THREATS 7-19 vi

11 Contents 7.7 TR83 REGION STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES OPPORTUNITIES THREATS OTHER SWOT ANALYSIS VEGETABLE CULTIVATION ANALYSIS IRRIGATION SWOT ANALYSIS URBAN SETTLEMENTS SWOT ANALYSIS 7-27 BIBLIOGRAPHY B-1 C U R R E N T S I T U A T I O N A N A L Y S I S A N N E X E S vii

12 Y E Ş İ L I R M A K B A S I N D E V E L O P M E N T P R O J E C T viii

13 List of Tables LIST OF TABLES Annex Table 2.1 NUTS Level 1, Level 2 and Level 3 Regions 2-2 Annex Table 3.1 NUTS 2 Demographic Indicators and Comparisons 3-2 Annex Table 3.2 NUTS 2 Employment Indicators and Comparisons 3-3 Annex Table 3.3 NUTS 2 Education Indicators and Comparisons 3-4 Annex Table 3.4 NUTS 2 Health Indicators and Comparisons 3-5 Annex Table 3.5 NUTS 2 Industry Indicators and Comparisons 3-6 Annex Table 3.6 NUTS 2 Agriculture Indicators and Comparisons 3-7 Annex Table 3.7 NUTS 2 Construction and Infrastructure Indicators and Comparisons 3-8 Annex Table 3.8 NUTS 2 Financial Indicators and Comparisons (1/2) 3-9 Annex Table 3.9 NUTS 2 Financial Indicators and Comparisons (2/2) 3-10 Annex Table 3.10 NUTS 2 Other Welfare Indicators and Comparisons 3-11 Annex Table 4.1 TheRanging of TR83 Region Districts in Their Provinces in Terms of Socio-Economic Development (1/2) 4-2 Annex Table 4.1 The Ranging of TR83 Region Districts in Their Provinces in Terms of Socio-Economic Development (2/2) 4-3 Annex Table 4.2 The Ranging of TR83 Region Districts in Turkey in terms of Socio-Economic Development (1/2) 4-4 Annex Table 4.3 The Ranging of TR83 Region Districts in Turkey in terms of Socio-Economic Development (2/2) 4-5 Annex Table 5.1 Age Dependancy Rates - Provinces, TR83 Region and Turkey, Annex Table 5.2 Age Dependancy Rates - Provinces, TR83 Region and Turkey, Annex Table 5.3 Age Dependancy Rates - Provinces, TR83 Region and Turkey, Annex Table 5.4 Age Dependancy Rates - Provinces, TR83 Region and Turkey, Annex Table Literacy and Distribution of the Schools Graduated from in Respect of Gender According to the General Population Census 5-6 Annex Table 5.6 The Population of Amasya Province in Terms of Literacy and Educational Background, Annex Table 5.7 The Population of Çorum Province in Terms of Literacy and Educational Background, Annex Table 5.8 The Population of Samsun Province in Terms of Literacy and Educational Background Annex Table 5.9 The Population of Tokat Province in Terms of Literacy and Educational Background Annex Table 5.10 The Population of Turkey in Terms of Literacy and Educational Background, Annex Table 5.11 The Distribution of Provinces, TR83 Region and Employment in Turkey According to Educational Background, Annex Table 5.12 The Distribution of Provinces, TR83 Region and Employment in Turkey According to Educational Background and Gender, Annex Table 5.13 The Distribution of Provinces, TR83 Region and Employment in Turkey According to Education in Sectoral Basis and Gender, C U R R E N T S I T U A T I O N A N A L Y S I S A N N E X E S ix

14 List of Tables Y E Ş İ L I R M A K B A S I N D E V E L O P M E N T P R O J E C T Annex Table 5.14 Provinces, TR83 Region and the Employment in Turkey According to Education and Gender, Annex Table 5.15 Provinces, TR83 Region and the Employment in Turkey According to Educational Background, Annex Table 5.16 The Growth Rate of Employment According to Sectors in Years - Provinces, TR83 Region and Turkey, Annex Table 5.17 The Change of Sectoral Shares in Total Employment in Provinces, TR83 Region and Turkey, Annex Table 5.18 The Change of Sectoral Employment Shares of Provinces and TR83 Region in Turkey, Annex Table 5.19 GDP and Employment Relationship, Annex Table 5.20 The Development of GDP in Terms of Sectors in Years - Provinces, TR83 Region and Turkey, (1/3) 5-21 Annex Table 5.21 The Development of GDP in Terms of Sectors in Years, - Provinces, TR83 Region and Turkey, (2/3) 5-22 Annex Table 5.22 The Development of GDP in Terms of Sectors in Years, - Provinces, TR83 Region and Turkey, (3/3) 5-23 Annex Table 5.23 The Shares of Sectors in GDP in Terms of Years - Provinces, TR83 Region and Turkey, (1/2) 5-24 Annex Table 5.24 The Shares of Sectors in GDP in Terms of Years - Provinces, TR83 Region and Turkey, (2/2) 5-25 Annex Table 5.25 The Shares of Sectors in the GDP of Turkey in Years - Provinces, TR83 Region and Turkey (1/2) 5-26 Annex Table 5.26 The Shares of Sectors in the GDP of Turkey in Years - Provinces, TR83 Region and Turkey (2/2) 5-27 Annex Table 5.27 The Development of GDP in Years in Terms of Sectors - Provinces, TR83 Region and Turkey, (1/3) 5-28 Annex Table 5.28 The Development of GDP in Years in Terms of Sectors - Provinces, TR83 Region and Turkey, (2/3) 5-29 Annex Table 5.29 The Development of GDP in Years in Terms of Sectors - Provinces, TR83 Region and Turkey, (3/3) 5-30 Annex Table 5.30 The Growth Rate of GDP in Years in Terms of Sectors - Provinces, TR83 Region and Turkey (1/2) 5-31 Annex Table 5.31 The Growth Rate of GDP in Years in Terms of Sectors - Provinces, TR83 Region and Turkey (2/2) 5-32 Annex Table 5.32 The Distribution of Plantations in Districts in Terms of Product Line, Annex Table 6.1 The Number of Convocators of TR83 Provincial Council 6-9 Annex Table 6.2 TR83 Region Specialized Committee of the Provincial Council 6-9 Annex Table 6.3 TR83 Region Year 2006 Budget Data of The Special Provincial Administration 6-9 Annex Table 6.4 Municipality and Village Population in Annex Table 6.5 Laws Which Was Enacted After 2005 In Accordance With The Localization and Their Potential Effects on The Implementation of Regional Plans and The Way They are Used 6-18 x

15 List of Tables Annex Table 6.6 Member Municipalities of Samsun Union of Municipalities and Population Growth 6-23 Annex Table 7.1 SWOT/TOWS Matrix 7-4 Annex Table 7.2 SWOT Matrix 7-8 Annex Table 7.3 SWOT Matrix 7-11 Annex Table 7.4 SWOT Matrix 7-14 Annex Table 7.5 SWOT Matrix 7-17 Annex Table 7.6 SWOT Matrix 7-20 Annex Table 7.7 SWOT Matrix 7-22 Annex Table 7.8 City of Amasya SWOT Analysis 7-27 Annex Table 7.9 City of Merzifon SWOT Analysis 7-28 Annex Table 7.10 City of Suluova SWOT Analysis 7-28 Annex Table 7.11 City of Çorum SWOT Analysis 7-29 Annex Table 7.12 City of Alaca SWOT Analysis 7-29 Annex Table 7.13 City of Osmancık SWOT Analysis 7-30 Annex Table 7.14 City of Sungurlu SWOT Analysis 7-30 Annex Table 7.15 City of Samsun SWOT Analysis 7-31 Annex Table 7.16 City of Bafra SWOT Analysis 7-32 Annex Table 7.17 City of Çarşamba SWOT Analysis 7-32 Annex Table 7.18 City of Terme SWOT Analysis 7-32 Annex Table 7.19 City of Vezirköprü SWOT Analysis 7-33 Annex Table 7.20 City of Tokat SWOT Analysis 7-33 Annex Table 7.21 City of Erbaa SWOT Analysis 7-33 Annex Table 7.22 City of Niksar SWOT Analysis 7-34 Annex Table 7.23 City of Turhal SWOT Analysis 7-34 Annex Table 7.24 City of Zile SWOT Analysis 7-35 C U R R E N T S I T U A T I O N A N A L Y S I S A N N E X E S xi

16 Y E Ş İ L I R M A K B A S I N D E V E L O P M E N T P R O J E C T xii

17 List of Figures LIST OF FIGURES Annex Figure 6.1 Organization Chart of General Provincial Administration Organizations 6-2 Annex Figure 6.2 A Sample for Organization Chart of the Associations Organized As Regional Associations (DSİ Organization Chart) 6-3 Annex Figure 6.3 A Sample Organization Chart of Centrally Organized Institutions (Ministry Public Works) 6-3 Annex Figure 6.4 Organizational Structure of the Development Agencies 6-6 Annex Figure 6.5 Organization Chart of the Special Provincial Administration 6-7 Annex Figure 6.6 Organization Chart of District, First Level and Township 6-11 Annex Figure 6.7 Organization Chart of Metropolitan Municipality 6-13 Annex Figure 6.8 Population Size and Geographical Distribution of Members of Union of Samsun Municipalities 6-22 C U R R E N T S I T U A T I O N A N A L Y S I S A N N E X E S xiii

18 List of Figures Y E Ş İ L I R M A K B A S I N D E V E L O P M E N T P R O J E C T xiv

19 Abbreviations ABBREVIATIONS AYKOME Infrastructure Coordination Center NUTS Nomenclature of Territorial Units for Statistics CCI Chambers of Commerce and Industry OIZ Organized Industrial Zone DA Development Agency PC Provincial Council DAP Doğu Anadolu Projesi (The Eastern Anatolia Project) PHARE Poland and Hungary Action for the Reconstructing of the Economy DC Development Council PIU Project Implementation Unit DİE Devlet İstatistik Enstitüsü (State Institute of PNDP Preliminary National Development Plan Statistics) PTP Provincial Territorial Plan DPT Devlet Planlama Teşkilatı Müsteşarlığı (State RPC Research, planning coordination Planning Organization) SAPARD Special Accession Program for Agriculture and DSİ Devlet Su İşleri Genel Müdürlüğü (General Rural Development) Directorate of State Hydraulic Works) SME Small and Medium Scale Enterprise DSYB Damızlık Sığır Yetiştiricileri Merkez Birliği (Cattle SPA Special Provincial Administration Breeders Association of Turkey) SWOT Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities and EC Executive Committee Threats EU European Union TBMM Grand National Assembly of Turkey FGI Focus Group Interview THB Halk Bank GAP Güneydoğu Anadolu Projesi (Southeastern Anatolia TKB Development Bank of Turkey Project) TOBB Türkiye Odalar ve Borsalar Birliği (Union of GAP BKİ Başbakanlık Güneydoğu Anadolu Projesi Bölge Chambers and Commodity Exchanges of Turkey) Kalkınma İdaresi (Southeastern Anatolia Project TR Turkey Regional Development Administration) TSE Turkish Standards Institution GAP-GİDEM GAP- Girişimci Destekleme ve Yönlendirme Merkezi TSKB Türkiye Sınai Kalkınma Bankası (Entrepreneur Support Centre) TTGV Türkiye Teknoloji Geliştirme Vakfı (Technology GDP Gross Domestic Product Development Foundation of Turkey) GIS Geographical Information System TÜBİTAK-MAM Türkiye Bilimsel ve Teknik Araştırma Kurumu GNP Gross National Product - Marmara Araştırma Merkezi (The Scientific and GS Secretary of General Technological Research Council of Turkey-Marmara İGEME İhracatı Geliştirme Etüt Merkezi (Turkish Export Research Centre) Promotion Center) TÜİK Turkish Statistical Institute İŞKUR Türkiye İş Kurumu (Turkish Employment Agency) UKOME Transportation Coordination Center KGM Karayolları Genel Müdürlüğü (General Directorate VAS Vocational Advanced School of Highways) YBDP Yeşilırmak Basin Development Project (Yeşilırmak KHGM Köy Hizmetleri Genel Müdürlüğü (General Havza Gelişim Projesi) Directorate for Rural Affairs) YHKB Yeşilırmak Havzası Kalkınma Birliği (Yeşilırmak KOSGEB Küçük ve Orta Ölçekli Sanayi Geliştirme ve Destekleme İdaresi Başkanlığı (Small and Medium Industry Development and Support Agency) Basin Development Union) MPM Milli Prodüktivite Merkezi (National Productivity Centre) MWh Megawatt hour NGO Non-Governmental Organization C U R R E N T S I T U A T I O N A N A L Y S I S A N N E X E S xv

20 Y E Ş İ L I R M A K B A S I N D E V E L O P M E N T P R O J E C T xvi

21 1 INSTRUMENTS FOR THE EUROPEAN UNION PRE-ACCESSION FINANCIAL ASSISTANCES C U R R E N T S I T U A T I O N A N A L Y S I S A N N E X E S 1-1

22 Instruments for the European Union Pre-Accession Financial Assistances Y E Ş İ L I R M A K B A S I N D E V E L O P M E N T P R O J E C T The European Union provides certain fi nancial instruments in the framework of the accession partnership. With pre-accession fi nancial assistances, it is aimed to contribute to the development of candidate countries before membership realisation and to reduce the disparities between these regions and other member countries of the Union. In the future, the use of these funds, which are described below, to fi nance the projects which will be executed in Turkey may be discussed. i ii The PHARE program: To accomodate to the Acquis Communautaire, it is aimed to increase the institutional capacity and the administrative structures in the candidate countries. Moreover, the support of infrastructural investments, projects related to regional development and the projects of Small and Medium size Enterprises is handled within the framework of these goals. (Referans Gazetesi, 2005). The targets of these funds are same as the targets of structural funds. Despite the fact that the target of the programme undergoes certain alterations, currently it has two key priorities: o Institutionalization/ (institution building) which aims to invigorate the institutional capacity of the applicant countries and o Investment aid which aims to make fi rms and infrastructure come closer to the EU standards. The SAPARD program: Agricultural and rural development programs, which aim at helping the candidate countries to adjust to the common agricultural program, are supported with this fund. Agriculture and agro-industry development projects, including the rural development projects, are supported. Especially agricultural product processing plants, marketing channels and food safety inspection are primary fields. (Referans Gazetesi, 2005). iii ISPA program: Financial and technical assistances in the fi elds of environment and transportation infrastructures are provided by this program. It gives technical assistance for the construction of infrastructures for transportation ( for the development of Trans-European roads) and environment (for coming closer to the EU standards in the submitted field). The use of this fund is similar to the use of the Structural Adjustment Fund. With the use of this fund and by developing partnerships between private and public sector (Public Private Partnership-PPP) in the production of infrastructures, it is thought that the quality and efficiency of public services will be increased. (Referans Gazetesi, 2005). Turkey draws benefi t from the funds which are gathered under the heading of European Union s Pre-Accession Financial Assistance for Turkey. PNDP (Preliminary National Development Plan) is prepared to provide a frame for the programming of pre-accession fi nancial assistances related to the Turkey s economic and social adjustment of Turkey to EU standards and to benefi t from these funds. Institutional capacity, which is developed to draw benefi t from EU resources, aims to ensure that the region will take full advantage of the amount which is reserved for itself in the framework of the preaccession fi nancial assistance by Turkey make use of other EU credits and Grant resources besides regional development funds which take place in Preliminary National Development Plan. MEDA and 6 th Frame Program are the leading ones of these funds. Turkey has taken advantage of MEDA funds which were established in 1995, for the actualization of projects in many different 1-2

23 Instruments for the European Union Pre-Accession Financial Assistances fi elds and it continues to benefi t from MEDA II in period. The use of 6 th Frame Program has not became prevalent and has not turned into practise yet. Although the number of projects that make application is low (By the end of 2004, Turkey s Project application rate is 1 percent, accepted application rate is about 0,5 percent ), 6 th Frame Program is an available source for district universities and for Small and Medium size Enterprises. C U R R E N T S I T U A T I O N A N A L Y S I S A N N E X E S 1-3

24 Y E Ş İ L I R M A K B A S I N D E V E L O P M E N T P R O J E C T 1-4

25 2 NUTS CLASSIFICATION C U R R E N T S I T U A T I O N A N A L Y S I S A N N E X E S 2-1

26 NUTS Classification Annex Table 2.1 NUTS Level 1, Level 2 and Level 3 Regions Y E Ş İ L I R M A K B A S I N D E V E L O P M E N T P R O J E C T Code NUTS1 NUTS2 NUTS3 TR1 İstanbul TR10 İstanbul TR100 İstanbul TR2 West Marmara TR21 Tekirdağ TR211 Tekirdağ TR212 Edirne TR213 Kırklareli TR22 Balıkesir TR221 Balıkesir TR222 Çanakkale TR3 Aegean TR31 İzmir TR310 İzmir TR32 Aydın TR321 Aydın TR322 Denizli TR323 Muğla TR33 Manisa TR331 Manisa TR332 Afyon TR333 Kütahya TR334 Uşak TR4 East Marmara TR41 Bursa TR411 Bursa TR412 Eskişehir TR413 Bilecik TR42 Kocaeli TR421 Kocaeli TR422 Sakarya TR423 Düzce TR424 Bolu TR425 Yalova Code NUTS1 NUTS2 NUTS3 TR5 West Anatolia TR51 Ankara TR510 Ankara TR52 Konya TR521 Konya TR522 Karaman TR6 Mediterranean TR61 Antalya TR611 Antalya TR612 Isparta TR613 Burdur TR62 Adana TR621 Adana TR622 Mersin TR63 Hatay TR631 Hatay TR632 Kahramanmaraş TR633 Osmaniye TR7 Central Anatolia TR71 Kırıkkale TR711 Kırıkkale TR712 Aksaray TR713 Niğde TR714 Nevşehir TR715 Kırşehir TR72 Kayseri TR721 Kayseri TR722 Sivas TR723 Yozgat 2-2

27 NUTS Classification Code NUTS1 NUTS2 NUTS3 TR8 West Black Sea TR81 Zonguldak TR811 Zonguldak TR812 Karabük TR813 Bartın TR82 TR821 TR822 TR823 TR83 TR831 TR832 TR833 TR834 TR9 TR90 TR901 TR902 TR903 TR904 TR905 TR906 TRA TRA1 TRA11 TRA12 TRA13 TRA2 TRA21 TRA22 TRA23 TRA24 East Black Sea North-eastern Anatolia Kastamonu Samsun Trabzon Erzurum Ağrı Kastamonu Çankırı Sinop Samsun Tokat Çorum Amasya Trabzon Ordu Giresun Rize Artvin Gümüşhane Erzurum Erzincan Bayburt Ağrı Kars Iğdır Ardahan Code NUTS1 NUTS2 NUTS3 TRB Mid-east Anatolia TRB1 Malatya TRB11 Malatya TRB12 Elazığ TRB13 Bingöl TRB14 Tunceli TRB2 Van TRB21 Van TRB22 Muş TRB23 Bitlis TRB24 Hakkari TRC TRC1 TRC11 TRC12 TRC13 TRC2 TRC21 TRC22 TRC3 TRC31 TRC32 TRC33 TRC34 South-eastern Anatolia Gaziantep Şanlıurfa Mardin Gaziantep Adıyaman Kilis Şanlıurfa Diyarbakır Mardin Batman Şırnak Siirt C U R R E N T S I T U A T I O N A N A L Y S I S A N N E X E S Source: DPT (2003), İllerin ve Bölgelerin Sosyo-Ekonomik Gelişmişlik Sıralaması Araştırması. 2-3

28 Y E Ş İ L I R M A K B A S I N D E V E L O P M E N T P R O J E C T 2-4

29 3 NUTS LEVEL 2 INDICATORS AND COMPARISONS C U R R E N T S I T U A T I O N A N A L Y S I S A N N E X E S 3-1

30 NUTS Level 2 Indicators and Comparisons Y E Ş İ L I R M A K B A S I N D E V E L O P M E N T P R O J E C T Annex Table 3.1 NUTS 2 Demographic Indicators and Comparisons No Total Population (Person) Urbanization Rate (Percent) Annual Population Growth Rate (Per mille) Population Density (Person/km 2 ) Fertility Rate (Number of child) Average of household (Person) 1 TR10-İstanbul TR10-İstanbul 90,69 TR10-İstanbul 33,10 TR10-İstanbul 1 928,16 TRC3-Mardin 5,84 TRB2-Van 7,77 2 TR51-Ankara TR51-Ankara 88,34 TR61-Antalya 31,25 TR31-İzmir 280,62 TRB2-Van 5,48 TRC3-Mardin 7,74 3 TR62-Adana TR31-İzmir 81,07 TRC2-Şanlıurfa 29,09 TR51-Ankara 163,45 TRC2-Şanlıurfa 4,67 TRC2-Şanlıurfa 6,84 4 TR31-İzmir TR41-Bursa 76,43 TRB2-Van 25,47 TR42-Kocaeli 134,55 TRA2-Ağrı 4,09 TRA2-Ağrı 6,63 5 TR90-Trabzon TRC1-Gaziantep 70,32 TRC3-Mardin 23,38 TRC1-Gaziantep 132,45 TRC1-Gaziantep 3,68 TRA1-Erzurum 5,55 6 TR33-Manisa TR62-Adana 68,47 TR41-Bursa 22,61 TR62-Adana 119,08 TR63-Hatay 3,15 TRC1-Gaziantep 5,51 7 TR41-Bursa TR21-Tekirdağ 60,20 TR31-İzmir 22,39 TR63-Hatay 116,53 TRA1-Erzurum 3,11 TRB1-Malatya 5,44 8 TR83-Samsun TRC3-Mardin 59,61 TR62-Adana 21,75 TR81-Zonguldak 107,96 TR52-Konya 2,89 TR63-Hatay 5,21 9 TRC2-Şanlıurfa TRC2-Şanlıurfa 59,15 TR51-Ankara 21,38 TR41-Bursa 105,91 TR72-Kayseri 2,74 TR90-Trabzon 5,11 10 TR42-Kocaeli TR52-Konya 58,91 TR52-Konya 21,32 TR90-Trabzon 89,03 TR83-Samsun 2,65 TR72-Kayseri 5,07 11 TR63-Hatay TRB1-Malatya 58,85 TRC1-Gaziantep 20,33 TRC2-Şanlıurfa 82,97 TRB1-Malatya 2,64 TR83-Samsun 4,97 12 TR32-Aydın TR72-Kayseri 58,81 TR42-Kocaeli 17,70 TR83-Samsun 79,94 TR71-Kırıkkale 2,63 TR52-Konya 4,90 13 TR72-Kayseri TRA1-Erzurum 57,27 TR32-Aydın 16,26 TR32-Aydın 77,67 TR62-Adana 2,53 TR71-Kırıkkale 4,83 14 TR61-Antalya TR42-Kocaeli 57,25 TR21-Tekirdağ 13,55 TR21-Tekirdağ 72,58 TR90-Trabzon 2,40 TR62-Adana 4,60 15 TR52-Konya TR61-Antalya 55,33 TR63-Hatay 12,82 TR61-Antalya 69,48 TR33-Manisa 2,33 TR82-Kastamonu 4,57 16 TRC1-Gaziantep TR71-Kırıkkale 53,01 TRB1-Malatya 11,06 TR33-Manisa 68,23 TR82-Kastamonu 2,31 TR81-Zonguldak 4,44 17 TRB2-Van TR63-Hatay 52,65 TR71-Kırıkkale 10,07 TRC3-Mardin 68,18 TR32-Aydın 2,08 TR42-Kocaeli 4,28 18 TRC3-Mardin TR33-Manisa 52,02 TR33-Manisa 9,99 TR22-Balıkesir 63,61 TR42-Kocaeli 2,08 TR33-Manisa 4,23 19 TRB1-Malatya TR83-Samsun 51,53 TR90-Trabzon 9,32 TR71-Kırıkkale 54,22 TR61-Antalya 2,03 TR61-Antalya 4,02 20 TR71-Kırıkkale TR22-Balıkesir 51,46 TR22-Balıkesir 9,15 TR52-Konya 51,04 TR81-Zonguldak 2,01 TR10-İstanbul 3,85 21 TR22-Balıkesir TR90-Trabzon 49,37 TR72-Kayseri 8,73 TRB1-Malatya 49,30 TR10-İstanbul 1,97 TR41-Bursa 3,84 22 TR21-Tekirdağ TRB2-Van 49,35 TRA1-Erzurum 7,43 TRB2-Van 47,08 TR41-Bursa 1,90 TR51-Ankara 3,82 23 TRA1-Erzurum TR82-Kastamonu 47,80 TR83-Samsun 5,19 TR72-Kayseri 41,88 TR51-Ankara 1,90 TR21-Tekirdağ 3,74 24 TRA2-Ağrı TR32-Aydın 46,71 TRA2-Ağrı 5,05 TRA2-Ağrı 38,50 TR22-Balıkesir 1,82 TR32-Aydın 3,68 25 TR81-Zonguldak TRA2-Ağrı 44,61 TR82-Kastamonu -7,33 TRA1-Erzurum 33,22 TR31-İzmir 1,75 TR31-İzmir 3,58 26 TR82-Kastamonu TR81-Zonguldak 44,50 TR81-Zonguldak -7,41 TR82-Kastamonu 32,96 TR21-Tekirdağ 1,73 TR22-Balıkesir 3,41 TURKEY TURKEY 64,90 TURKEY 18,29 TURKEY 88,10 TURKEY 2,53 TURKEY 4,50 Source: DPT (2003-2), Bölgesel Gelişme Stratejisi, Hedef ve Operasyonel Programlar. 3-2

31 NUTS Level 2 Indicators and Comparisons Annex Table 3.2 NUTS 2 Employment Indicators and Comparisons No Proportion of Agricultural Workers to Total Employment (Percent) Proportion of Industrial Workers to Total Employment (Percent) Proportion of Commercial Workers to Total Employment (Percent) Proportion of Finnancial Workers to Total Employment (Percent) Proportion of Wage Earners to Total Employment (Percent) Proportion of Woman Wage Earners to Total Employment (Percent) Proportion of Employees to Total Employment (percent) 1 TRA2-Ağrı 71,76 TR10-İstanbul 32,15 TR10-İstanbul 18,73 TR51-Ankara 8,79 TR10-İstanbul 75,95 TR10-İstanbul 19,39 TR10-İstanbul 5,97 2 TRB2-Van 70,26 TR41-Bursa 25,56 TR31-İzmir 14,54 TR10-İstanbul 8,16 TR51-Ankara 72,06 TR51-Ankara 16,86 TR31-İzmir 3,99 3 TR82-Kastamonu 69,61 TR31-İzmir 20,58 TR61-Antalya 14,34 TR31-İzmir 4,59 TR31-İzmir 61,98 TR31-İzmir 16,28 TR51-Ankara 3,93 4 TR90-Trabzon 68,51 TR21-Tekirdağ 19,03 TR51-Ankara 13,81 TR41-Bursa 2,82 TR41-Bursa 55,25 TR41-Bursa 12,78 TR41-Bursa 3,15 5 TRC2-Şanlıurfa 68,50 TR42-Kocaeli 15,82 TR41-Bursa 11,10 TR61-Antalya 2,75 TR21-Tekirdağ 47,85 TR21-Tekirdağ 10,17 TR61-Antalya 2,65 6 TR71-Kırıkkale 66,94 TRC1-Gaziantep 14,89 TR62-Adana 10,57 TR62-Adana 2,75 TR42-Kocaeli 44,92 TR32-Aydın 9,84 TR62-Adana 2,49 7 TR83-Samsun 66,89 TR81-Zonguldak 14,34 TR32-Aydın 10,09 TR42-Kocaeli 2,31 TR62-Adana 41,88 TR62-Adana 9,00 TR32-Aydın 2,46 8 TR33-Manisa 64,83 TR51-Ankara 13,41 TR42-Kocaeli 8,78 TR32-Aydın 2,08 TRC1-Gaziantep 39,82 TR61-Antalya 8,34 TRC1-Gaziantep 2,46 9 TRA1-Erzurum 63,31 TR62-Adana 11,05 TRC1-Gaziantep 8,75 TR22-Balıkesir 2,00 TR61-Antalya 39,50 TR42-Kocaeli 7,38 TR42-Kocaeli 2,23 10 TR63-Hatay 62,87 TR32-Aydın 10,87 TR22-Balıkesir 8,34 TR21-Tekirdağ 1,99 TR32-Aydın 38,04 TR22-Balıkesir 6,65 TR52-Konya 2,14 11 TR52-Konya 62,70 TR33-Manisa 10,31 TR21-Tekirdağ 8,25 TR52-Konya 1,85 TR22-Balıkesir 36,40 TR33-Manisa 5,52 TR22-Balıkesir 1,99 12 TR72-Kayseri 62,15 TR52-Konya 9,27 TR52-Konya 6,72 TRC1-Gaziantep 1,70 TR81-Zonguldak 35,13 TR81-Zonguldak 5,43 TR21-Tekirdağ 1,90 13 TRB1-Malatya 61,74 TR72-Kayseri 9,18 TR63-Hatay 6,24 TR72-Kayseri 1,57 TRC3-Mardin 33,41 TRC1-Gaziantep 5,03 TR72-Kayseri 1,80 14 TRC3-Mardin 61,54 TR22-Balıkesir 8,82 TR83-Samsun 6,21 TR81-Zonguldak 1,48 TRB1-Malatya 32,75 TR63-Hatay 4,47 TR33-Manisa 1,50 15 TR81-Zonguldak 58,76 TR63-Hatay 8,72 TR71-Kırıkkale 6,16 TR90-Trabzon 1,47 TR72-Kayseri 31,92 TR83-Samsun 4,19 TR63-Hatay 1,50 16 TR32-Aydın 56,98 TR61-Antalya 6,36 TR81-Zonguldak 6,10 TRB1-Malatya 1,47 TR63-Hatay 31,37 TR71-Kırıkkale 4,17 TR71-Kırıkkale 1,48 17 TR22-Balıkesir 56,50 TR83-Samsun 6,29 TR72-Kayseri 6,04 TR83-Samsun 1,40 TRA1-Erzurum 31,07 TR90-Trabzon 4,16 TR83-Samsun 1,46 18 TR61-Antalya 52,19 TR71-Kırıkkale 6,28 TR33-Manisa 5,99 TR71-Kırıkkale 1,39 TR33-Manisa 30,71 TR72-Kayseri 4,00 TR90-Trabzon 1,46 19 TRC1-Gaziantep 51,70 TR82-Kastamonu 5,74 TR90-Trabzon 5,82 TR33-Manisa 1,34 TR52-Konya 29,56 TRB1-Malatya 3,75 TRA1-Erzurum 1,41 20 TR62-Adana 50,62 TR90-Trabzon 5,26 TRC2-Şanlıurfa 5,49 TRA1-Erzurum 1,31 TR71-Kırıkkale 28,22 TR82-Kastamonu 3,71 TR81-Zonguldak 1,35 21 TR42-Kocaeli 46,87 TRB1-Malatya 5,14 TRA1-Erzurum 5,48 TR82-Kastamonu 1,28 TRC2-Şanlıurfa 28,11 TR52-Konya 3,67 TRB1-Malatya 1,35 22 TR21-Tekirdağ 44,33 TRA1-Erzurum 3,71 TRB1-Malatya 5,36 TR63-Hatay 1,27 TR83-Samsun 26,61 TRC2-Şanlıurfa 3,57 TR82-Kastamonu 1,23 23 TR41-Bursa 34,89 TRC2-Şanlıurfa 3,64 TR82-Kastamonu 4,45 TRC2-Şanlıurfa 1,04 TRB2-Van 25,84 TRA1-Erzurum 2,91 TRC2-Şanlıurfa 1,19 24 TR31-İzmir 28,54 TRC3-Mardin 3,07 TRC3-Mardin 4,28 TRC3-Mardin 0,72 TR82-Kastamonu 24,98 TRC3-Mardin 2,37 TRA2-Ağrı 0,88 25 TR51-Ankara 16,21 TRB2-Van 2,05 TRA2-Ağrı 3,54 TRA2-Ağrı 0,70 TR90-Trabzon 24,81 TRA2-Ağrı 2,06 TRC3-Mardin 0,85 26 TR10-İstanbul 8,13 TRA2-Ağrı 1,72 TRB2-Van 3,28 TRB2-Van 0,67 TRA2-Ağrı 24,30 TRB2-Van 1,84 TRB2-Van 0,72 TURKEY 48,38 TURKEY 13,35 TURKEY 9,67 TURKEY 3,11 TURKEY 43,52 TURKEY 8,81 TURKEY 2,61 Source: DPT (2003-2), Bölgesel Gelişme Stratejisi, Hedef ve Operasyonel Programlar. C U R R E N T S I T U A T I O N A N A L Y S I S A N N E X E S 3-3

32 NUTS Level 2 Indicators and Comparisons Y E Ş İ L I R M A K B A S I N D E V E L O P M E N T P R O J E C T Annex Table 3.3 NUTS 2 Education Indicators and Comparisons No Proportion of Litrate Population (Percent) Proportion of Liteerate Female Population to Total Population (Percent) Proportion of University Graduates to School Finishers (Percent) Rate of Schooling in Primary Education (Percent) Rate of Schooling in High School (Percent) Rate of Schooling in Vocational High Schools (Percent) 1 TR10-İstanbul 93,39 TR10-İstanbul 89,49 TR51-Ankara 16,86 TR10-İstanbul 121,97 TR51-Ankara 59,91 TR21-Tekirdağ 36,02 2 TR51-Ankara 93,26 TR51-Ankara 89,32 TR10-İstanbul 11,92 TR31-İzmir 110,32 TR31-İzmir 47,74 TR41-Bursa 35,39 3 TR41-Bursa 92,00 TR41-Bursa 87,68 TR31-İzmir 11,47 TR51-Ankara 108,19 TR22-Balıkesir 45,78 TR42-Kocaeli 33,09 4 TR31-İzmir 91,86 TR21-Tekirdağ 87,47 TR61-Antalya 10,53 TR42-Kocaeli 106,86 TRB1-Malatya 43,70 TR81-Zonguldak 31,55 5 TR21-Tekirdağ 91,75 TR31-İzmir 87,41 TR32-Aydın 8,04 TR41-Bursa 105,83 TR62-Adana 43,22 TR31-İzmir 29,41 6 TR61-Antalya 91,66 TR61-Antalya 86,90 TR62-Adana 8,03 TR22-Balıkesir 105,76 TR63-Hatay 42,74 TR51-Ankara 28,45 7 TR42-Kocaeli 91,22 TR42-Kocaeli 85,92 TR41-Bursa 7,99 TR21-Tekirdağ 103,58 TR21-Tekirdağ 42,40 TR10-İstanbul 27,30 8 TR52-Konya 90,04 TR52-Konya 84,76 TR21-Tekirdağ 7,75 TRC1-Gaziantep 102,21 TR10-İstanbul 41,96 TR82-Kastamonu 25,72 9 TR32-Aydın 89,67 TR32-Aydın 83,85 TRB1-Malatya 7,44 TR81-Zonguldak 101,97 TR41-Bursa 40,46 TR22-Balıkesir 24,64 10 TR22-Balıkesir 88,70 TR22-Balıkesir 83,51 TR22-Balıkesir 7,07 TR62-Adana 99,35 TR32-Aydın 39,64 TR33-Manisa 23,44 11 TR62-Adana 87,96 TR62-Adana 81,96 TR42-Kocaeli 6,81 TR32-Aydın 99,23 TR61-Antalya 39,63 TR32-Aydın 22,62 12 TR33-Manisa 87,54 TR33-Manisa 80,90 TRA1-Erzurum 6,72 TR63-Hatay 99,16 TR81-Zonguldak 39,56 TR90-Trabzon 20,77 13 TR71-Kırıkkale 87,52 TR71-Kırıkkale 80,52 TR72-Kayseri 6,33 TRC3-Mardin 98,06 TRC1-Gaziantep 35,66 TR72-Kayseri 20,37 14 TR72-Kayseri 87,09 TR72-Kayseri 80,14 TR52-Konya 6,31 TR83-Samsun 95,49 TR42-Kocaeli 35,61 TR83-Samsun 19,73 15 TR81-Zonguldak 86,94 TR81-Zonguldak 80,08 TR90-Trabzon 6,21 TRA2-Ağrı 92,67 TR83-Samsun 35,31 TR61-Antalya 18,59 16 TR90-Trabzon 85,79 TR83-Samsun 78,97 TR63-Hatay 6,07 TR61-Antalya 92,59 TR72-Kayseri 34,27 TR62-Adana 17,83 17 TR83-Samsun 85,59 TR90-Trabzon 77,53 TR81-Zonguldak 6,04 TR33-Manisa 90,58 TR71-Kırıkkale 33,16 TR71-Kırıkkale 17,42 18 TR63-Hatay 85,07 TR63-Hatay 77,37 TR71-Kırıkkale 5,86 TR72-Kayseri 88,63 TR33-Manisa 31,61 TR52-Konya 13,70 19 TRA1-Erzurum 84,69 TRA1-Erzurum 76,06 TR83-Samsun 5,79 TRB1-Malatya 88,60 TR52-Konya 30,12 TR63-Hatay 13,45 20 TR82-Kastamonu 83,56 TR82-Kastamonu 76,04 TRC1-Gaziantep 5,23 TR71-Kırıkkale 88,46 TR90-Trabzon 27,51 TRA1-Erzurum 13,15 21 TRB1-Malatya 82,60 TRC1-Gaziantep 73,38 TR33-Manisa 5,18 TRC2-Şanlıurfa 86,52 TRA1-Erzurum 27,43 TRC1-Gaziantep 10,82 22 TRC1-Gaziantep 82,36 TRB1-Malatya 73,32 TR82-Kastamonu 5,06 TR82-Kastamonu 84,38 TR82-Kastamonu 24,64 TRB1-Malatya 10,73 23 TRA2-Ağrı 75,41 TRA2-Ağrı 62,46 TRC2-Şanlıurfa 5,00 TRB2-Van 83,88 TRC2-Şanlıurfa 24,45 TRA2-Ağrı 8,16 24 TRC3-Mardin 69,71 TRC3-Mardin 54,14 TRB2-Van 4,80 TRA1-Erzurum 81,75 TRA2-Ağrı 22,45 TRB2-Van 6,62 25 TRB2-Van 69,57 TRC2-Şanlıurfa 53,76 TRA2-Ağrı 4,74 TR52-Konya 81,21 TRC3-Mardin 22,01 TRC3-Mardin 6,33 26 TRC2-Şanlıurfa 68,60 TRB2-Van 53,63 TRC3-Mardin 4,64 TR90-Trabzon 73,86 TRB2-Van 13,98 TRC2-Şanlıurfa 3,68 TURKEY 87,30 TURKEY 80,62 TURKEY 8,42 TURKEY 98,01 TURKEY 36,92 TURKEY 20,49 Source: DPT (2003-2), Bölgesel Gelişme Stratejisi, Hedef ve Operasyonel Programlar. 3-4

33 NUTS Level 2 Indicators and Comparisons Annex Table 3.4 NUTS 2 Health Indicators and Comparisons No Infant Mortality Rate (Permill) Number of Doctors per Ten Thousand People (Persons) Number of Dentists per Ten Thousand People (Persons) Number of Pharmacies per Ten Thousand People (Number) Number of Hospital Bads per Ten Thousand People (Hospital Beds) 1 TRA2-Ağrı 63,00 TR51-Ankara 31,57 TR51-Ankara 6,04 TR31-İzmir 4,73 TR51-Ankara 37,71 2 TRB2-Van 55,75 TR31-İzmir 22,71 TR10-İstanbul 4,77 TR51-Ankara 4,47 TR10-İstanbul 34,14 3 TRC3-Mardin 51,75 TR10-İstanbul 20,58 TR31-İzmir 4,57 TR10-İstanbul 4,38 TR31-İzmir 29,01 4 TRA1-Erzurum 48,67 TR41-Bursa 12,89 TR32-Aydın 2,77 TR32-Aydın 3,93 TR82-Kastamonu 29,01 5 TR83-Samsun 47,75 TR61-Antalya 12,87 TR61-Antalya 2,75 TR61-Antalya 3,53 TRA1-Erzurum 27,27 6 TRC2-Şanlıurfa 47,00 TR21-Tekirdağ 12,38 TR22-Balıkesir 2,34 TR22-Balıkesir 3,51 TR81-Zonguldak 25,86 7 TR72-Kayseri 46,67 TR32-Aydın 12,06 TR41-Bursa 2,22 TR21-Tekirdağ 3,23 TR61-Antalya 25,17 8 TR82-Kastamonu 46,00 TR62-Adana 11,18 TR42-Kocaeli 1,96 TR41-Bursa 3,17 TR41-Bursa 24,57 9 TRC1-Gaziantep 44,67 TRB1-Malatya 10,83 TR81-Zonguldak 1,62 TR62-Adana 3,03 TRB1-Malatya 24,14 10 TR62-Adana 44,50 TRA1-Erzurum 10,60 TR52-Konya 1,51 TR33-Manisa 2,66 TR22-Balıkesir 22,95 11 TR42-Kocaeli 43,00 TR72-Kayseri 9,77 TR21-Tekirdağ 1,34 TR52-Konya 2,57 TR72-Kayseri 22,51 12 TRB1-Malatya 42,50 TR81-Zonguldak 9,49 TR33-Manisa 1,25 TR42-Kocaeli 2,54 TR21-Tekirdağ 22,22 13 TR33-Manisa 42,00 TR83-Samsun 9,43 TR71-Kırıkkale 1,21 TR71-Kırıkkale 2,38 TR83-Samsun 22,03 14 TR81-Zonguldak 41,67 TR42-Kocaeli 9,35 TR82-Kastamonu 1,06 TR83-Samsun 2,36 TR90-Trabzon 21,80 15 TR52-Konya 41,50 TR71-Kırıkkale 9,30 TRB1-Malatya 1,01 TRC1-Gaziantep 2,27 TR33-Manisa 21,29 16 TR71-Kırıkkale 41,40 TR22-Balıkesir 9,08 TR90-Trabzon 0,99 TR82-Kastamonu 2,26 TR62-Adana 20,85 17 TR41-Bursa 40,33 TR33-Manisa 8,35 TR83-Samsun 0,93 TR81-Zonguldak 2,15 TR42-Kocaeli 19,79 18 TR31-İzmir 40,00 TR52-Konya 8,30 TR62-Adana 0,90 TR90-Trabzon 2,05 TR32-Aydın 17,47 19 TR10-İstanbul 39,00 TR82-Kastamonu 8,12 TRC1-Gaziantep 0,87 TR63-Hatay 1,98 TRC1-Gaziantep 16,95 20 TR32-Aydın 37,67 TR90-Trabzon 7,97 TR63-Hatay 0,78 TR72-Kayseri 1,95 TR71-Kırıkkale 16,70 21 TR22-Balıkesir 37,50 TRC1-Gaziantep 6,87 TRA1-Erzurum 0,54 TRC2-Şanlıurfa 1,88 TRC2-Şanlıurfa 14,77 22 TR21-Tekirdağ 37,00 TR63-Hatay 6,04 TRA2-Ağrı 0,47 TRB1-Malatya 1,69 TR52-Konya 14,68 23 TR63-Hatay 37,00 TRC2-Şanlıurfa 5,61 TR72-Kayseri 0,40 TRC3-Mardin 1,34 TRB2-Van 11,17 24 TR51-Ankara 36,00 TRB2-Van 4,48 TRB2-Van 0,38 TRA2-Ağrı 1,31 TR63-Hatay 10,58 25 TR90-Trabzon 35,50 TRA2-Ağrı 4,06 TRC3-Mardin 0,37 TRA1-Erzurum 1,09 TRA2-Ağrı 7,96 26 TR61-Antalya 32,33 TRC3-Mardin 3,72 TRC2-Şanlıurfa 0,35 TRB2-Van 0,78 TRC3-Mardin 6,68 TURKEY 43,00 TURKEY 12,70 TURKEY 2,22 TURKEY 2,94 TURKEY 23,04 Source: DPT (2003-2), Bölgesel Gelişme Stratejisi, Hedef ve Operasyonel Programlar. C U R R E N T S I T U A T I O N A N A L Y S I S A N N E X E S 3-5

34 NUTS Level 2 Indicators and Comparisons Y E Ş İ L I R M A K B A S I N D E V E L O P M E N T P R O J E C T Annex Table 3.5 NUTS 2 Industry Indicators and Comparisons No Number of Organized Industrial Zone Parcel (Parcels) Number of Small Industrial Estate Work Place (Number) Number of Manufacturing Industry Work Place (Number) Annual Average Number of Manufacturing Industry Employees (Persons) Installed Capacity in Manufacturing Industry (HP) Electricity Consumption per Capita in Manufaturing Industry (kwh) Value Added per Capita in Manufacturing Industry (Million TL) 1 TR51-Ankara TR33-Manisa TR10-İstanbul TR10-İstanbul TR42-Kocaeli TR42-Kocaeli 1827,93 TR42-Kocaeli 1 375,98 2 TR41-Bursa TR83-Samsun TR31-İzmir TR41-Bursa TR10-İstanbul TR81-Zonguldak 1611,96 TR21-Tekirdağ 1 029,73 3 TR33-Manisa TR52-Konya TR41-Bursa 989 TR42-Kocaeli TR41-Bursa TR31-İzmir 1583,63 TR31-İzmir 817,37 4 TR31-İzmir TR31-İzmir TR51-Ankara 850 TR31-İzmir TR31-İzmir TR21-Tekirdağ 1390,38 TR41-Bursa 764,06 5 TR52-Konya TR72-Kayseri TR42-Kocaeli 830 TR21-Tekirdağ TR81-Zonguldak TR41-Bursa 1293,93 TR10-İstanbul 578,72 6 TRC1-Gaziantep 893 TR61-Antalya TR32-Aydın 533 TR51-Ankara TR63-Hatay TR63-Hatay 840,26 TR71-Kırıkkale 416,16 7 TR71-Kırıkkale 832 TRC1-Gaziantep TR33-Manisa 415 TR32-Aydın TR62-Adana TR62-Adana 719,99 TR62-Adana 404,70 8 TR83-Samsun 793 TR63-Hatay TR21-Tekirdağ 413 TR62-Adana TR21-Tekirdağ TR52-Konya 666,13 TR22-Balıkesir 278,24 9 TR72-Kayseri 769 TR71-Kırıkkale TR62-Adana 369 TR33-Manisa TR33-Manisa TR22-Balıkesir 658,46 TR51-Ankara 263,96 10 TR21-Tekirdağ 636 TR41-Bursa TR52-Konya 287 TR72-Kayseri TR52-Konya TRC1-Gaziantep 549,31 TR33-Manisa 229, ,14 225,47 TR62-Adana TR62-Adana TRC1-Gaziantep TRC1-Gaziantep TR51-Ankara TRB1-Malatya TR81-Zonguldak 12 TR10-İstanbul 625 TR90-Trabzon TR83-Samsun 248 TR52-Konya TR22-Balıkesir TR10-İstanbul 414,90 TR32-Aydın 222,87 13 TR42-Kocaeli 597 TR21-Tekirdağ TR90-Trabzon 214 TR90-Trabzon TR71-Kırıkkale TR32-Aydın 408,91 TRC1-Gaziantep 191,35 14 TRC2-Şanlıurfa 566 TRB1-Malatya TR72-Kayseri 212 TR63-Hatay TR32-Aydın TR33-Manisa 323,78 TR72-Kayseri 190,75 15 TR32-Aydın 530 TR10-İstanbul TR61-Antalya 146 TR83-Samsun TR83-Samsun TR72-Kayseri 316,05 TR52-Konya 128,45 16 TR22-Balıkesir 517 TR22-Balıkesir TR63-Hatay 143 TR81-Zonguldak TRC1-Gaziantep TR61-Antalya 261,35 TR83-Samsun 111,11 17 TRB1-Malatya 359 TR51-Ankara TR22-Balıkesir 126 TR22-Balıkesir TR90-Trabzon TR71-Kırıkkale 260,06 TR63-Hatay 102,49 18 TRA1-Erzurum 344 TR42-Kocaeli TR81-Zonguldak 111 TR71-Kırıkkale TR72-Kayseri TR83-Samsun 224,70 TRB1-Malatya 87,21 19 TR63-Hatay 334 TR32-Aydın TR71-Kırıkkale 91 TRB1-Malatya TR61-Antalya TR51-Ankara 188,90 TR82-Kastamonu 84,44 20 TR61-Antalya 330 TRC2-Şanlıurfa TRB1-Malatya 76 TR61-Antalya TRB1-Malatya TR82-Kastamonu 122,36 TR90-Trabzon 84,30 21 TRC3-Mardin 274 TR82-Kastamonu TR82-Kastamonu 71 TR82-Kastamonu TR82-Kastamonu TR90-Trabzon 108,73 TR61-Antalya 75,35 22 TR90-Trabzon 270 TRA1-Erzurum TRC2-Şanlıurfa 66 TRA1-Erzurum TRC3-Mardin TRC3-Mardin 68,56 TRC3-Mardin 28,30 23 TR82-Kastamonu 238 TR81-Zonguldak TRA1-Erzurum 38 TRC2-Şanlıurfa TRA1-Erzurum TRA2-Ağrı 46,79 TRA1-Erzurum 26,53 24 TR81-Zonguldak 160 TRB2-Van TRC3-Mardin 21 TRB2-Van TRA2-Ağrı TRA1-Erzurum 42,77 TRC2-Şanlıurfa 16,20 25 TRB2-Van 100 TRA2-Ağrı 915 TRB2-Van 19 TRA2-Ağrı TRB2-Van TRC2-Şanlıurfa 20,96 TRB2-Van 13,92 26 TRA2-Ağrı 68 TRC3-Mardin 568 TRA2-Ağrı 14 TRC3-Mardin TRC2-Şanlıurfa TRB2-Van 17,73 TRA2-Ağrı 13,26 TURKEY TURKEY TURKEY TURKEY TURKEY TURKEY 550,35 TURKEY 350,11 Source: DPT (2003-2), Bölgesel Gelişme Stratejisi, Hedef ve Operasyonel Programlar. 3-6

35 NUTS Level 2 Indicators and Comparisons Annex Table 3.6 NUTS 2 Agriculture Indicators and Comparisons No Production of Field Crops Production of Vegetables Production of Fruit Value of Agricultural Production in National Total (Ton) (Percent) (Ton) (Percent) (Ton) (Percent) (Million TL) Share of Value of Agricultural Production in National Total (Percent) 1 TR52-Konya ,81 TR61-Antalya ,98 TR62-Adana ,42 TR22-Balıkesir 1 929,01 TR33-Manisa 6,93 2 TR71-Kırıkkale ,80 TR62-Adana ,99 TR32-Aydın ,60 TR31-İzmir 1 816,24 TR83-Samsun 6,40 3 TR83-Samsun ,39 TR41-Bursa ,35 TR33-Manisa ,97 TR41-Bursa 1 802,67 TR32-Aydın 5,99 4 TR72-Kayseri ,61 TR83-Samsun ,57 TR61-Antalya ,87 TR51-Ankara 1 640,65 TR52-Konya 5,93 5 TR33-Manisa ,59 TR32-Aydın ,76 TR90-Trabzon ,81 TR21-Tekirdağ 1 600,22 TR62-Adana 5,67 6 TRC2-Şanlıurfa ,42 TR22-Balıkesir ,66 TR63-Hatay ,65 TR52-Konya 1 584,08 TR42-Kocaeli 5,51 7 TR51-Ankara ,94 TR31-İzmir ,60 TR31-İzmir ,02 TR71-Kırıkkale 1 471,53 TR22-Balıkesir 5,40 8 TR41-Bursa ,77 TR33-Manisa ,23 TR71-Kırıkkale ,46 TR62-Adana 1 373,88 TR61-Antalya 4,92 9 TR21-Tekirdağ ,61 TR63-Hatay ,92 TR22-Balıkesir ,27 TR42-Kocaeli 1 268,77 TR41-Bursa 4,81 10 TR62-Adana ,38 TRC2-Şanlıurfa ,53 TR52-Konya ,88 TR33-Manisa 1 266,84 TR71-Kırıkkale 4,37 11 TR63-Hatay ,88 TR51-Ankara ,61 TR41-Bursa ,49 TR32-Aydın 1 196,05 TR31-İzmir 4,33 12 TR61-Antalya ,63 TR52-Konya ,43 TR42-Kocaeli ,38 TR61-Antalya 1 184,09 TRC2-Şanlıurfa 4,19 13 TR42-Kocaeli ,55 TRC1-Gaziantep ,25 TR83-Samsun ,22 TR83-Samsun 1 177,33 TR63-Hatay 4,18 14 TR32-Aydın ,54 TR21-Tekirdağ ,12 TRC1-Gaziantep ,14 TR82-Kastamonu 1 156,40 TR90-Trabzon 4,10 15 TRC3-Mardin ,25 TR42-Kocaeli ,77 TRB1-Malatya ,96 TRC1-Gaziantep 1 025,76 TR72-Kayseri 3,94 16 TRA1-Erzurum ,21 TR71-Kırıkkale ,77 TRC2-Şanlıurfa ,53 TR72-Kayseri 1 024,13 TR21-Tekirdağ 3,23 17 TRC1-Gaziantep ,14 TRC3-Mardin ,60 TRC3-Mardin ,24 TRA1-Erzurum 991,98 TR51-Ankara 2,87 18 TR22-Balıkesir ,12 TRB1-Malatya ,59 TR72-Kayseri ,16 TRC2-Şanlıurfa 978,19 TRB2-Van 2,67 19 TRA2-Ağrı ,99 TR82-Kastamonu ,50 TR21-Tekirdağ ,85 TRB1-Malatya 972,59 TRB1-Malatya 2,65 20 TR82-Kastamonu ,80 TR72-Kayseri ,33 TR51-Ankara ,84 TRA2-Ağrı 930,63 TRC1-Gaziantep 2,30 21 TRB2-Van ,73 TRA1-Erzurum ,32 TR82-Kastamonu ,71 TR63-Hatay 869,82 TRA2-Ağrı 2,23 22 TRB1-Malatya ,54 TRB2-Van ,25 TR81-Zonguldak ,51 TRB2-Van 721,62 TRA1-Erzurum 2,14 23 TR31-İzmir ,30 TR10-İstanbul ,23 TRA1-Erzurum ,49 TR90-Trabzon 690,89 TR82-Kastamonu 1,97 24 TR90-Trabzon ,20 TR90-Trabzon ,19 TRB2-Van ,31 TRC3-Mardin 612,80 TRC3-Mardin 1,65 25 TR10-İstanbul ,43 TRA2-Ağrı ,17 TRA2-Ağrı ,14 TR81-Zonguldak 414,91 TR81-Zonguldak 0,88 26 TR81-Zonguldak ,36 TR81-Zonguldak ,13 TR10-İstanbul ,07 TR10-İstanbul 215,73 TR10-İstanbul 0,75 TURKEY ,00 TURKEY ,00 TURKEY ,00 TURKEY 1 124,08 TURKEY 100,00 Source: DPT (2003-2), Bölgesel Gelişme Stratejisi, Hedef ve Operasyonel Programlar. C U R R E N T S I T U A T I O N A N A L Y S I S A N N E X E S 3-7