airport urbanism airports, landscapes and cities 01
Direttore Laura Cipriani Università degli Studi di Trento Comitato scientifico Bernardo Secchi Università Iuav di Venezia Giovanni Corbellini Università degli Studi di Trieste Marino Lupi Università degli Studi di Pisa Charles Waldheim Harvard Design School, USA
airport urbanism airports, landscapes and cities The airplane, flying over forests, rivers, mountains, and seas and revealing supremely powerful laws, the simple principles which regulate natural phenomena, will arrive at the city of the new era of machine civilization. Le Corbusier The book series welcomes research works and research by design projects dealing with the airport landscape theme. The interdisciplinary approach aims to stimulate debate and knowledge of a topic which is still marginal in international scientific debate and the teaching field. La collana accoglie ricerca e sperimentazioni progettuali relativamente alla tematica aeroporti e paesaggio. L approccio interdisciplinare adottato intende stimolare il dibattito e la conoscenza su un tema ancora marginale nella formazione didattica e nel dibattito scientifico internazionale.
This volume presents a number of reflections on the airport landscape theme, fruit of a series of meetings between the researcher and the Veneto Region Department of Regional and Strategic Planning on Venice airport-city and the data collected and considerations matured by the researcher during the Marie Curie COFUND-PAT programme at Trento University. Trento University European Community Marie Curie Actions Cofund Autonomous Province of Trento The researcher is supported by the European Community and the Autonomous Province of Trento and co-funded by Marie Curie Actions. The work leading to this publication received funding under the 7th European Community Framework Programme 7 PQ/2007-2013 and from the Autonomous Province of Trento under Grant Agreement no. 226070 (notice researcher post-doc 2010 Incoming CALL 1 - Project Trentino - PCOFUND- GA-2008-226070 ).
ECOLOGICAL AIRPORT URBANISM AIRPORTS AND LANDSCAPES IN THE ITALIAN NORTH EAST Laura Cipriani
Copyright MMXIV ARACNE editrice S.r.l. www.aracneeditrice.it info@aracneeditrice.it via Raffaele Garofalo, 133/A B 00173 Roma (06) 93781065 i s b n 978 88 548 7436 7 I diritti di traduzione, di memorizzazione elettronica, di riproduzione e di adattamento anche parziale, con qualsiasi mezzo, sono riservati per tutti i Paesi. Non sono assolutamente consentite le fotocopie senza il permesso scritto dell Editore. I edizione: agosto 2014
ECOLOGICAL AIRPORT URBANISM AIRPORTS AND LANDSCAPES IN THE ITALIAN NORTH EAST Laura Cipriani
AUTHOR Laura Cipriani IMAGES Laura Cipriani TEXT Laura Cipriani TRANSLATOR Ter Centro Traduzioni PHOTOS Laura Cipriani, Denver Airport, Brian Robbins, Rui Sousa GRAPHIC DESIGN Laura Cipriani LAYOUT Laura Cipriani with Giorgia Anastasio (A4 Design) Copyright Laura Cipriani. All rights reser ved. No part of this book may be reproduced or transmitted in any form by any electronic or mechanical means (including photocopying, recording, or information storage and retrieval without permission in writing from the author. Users are not permitted to mount this file on any network servers.
CONTENTS ECOLOGICAL AIRPORT URBANISM AIRPORTS AND LANDSCAPES IN THE ITALIAN NORTH EAST 10 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS 12 INTRODUCTION 16 AIRPORTS, CITIES AND THE LANDSCAPE 28 THE AIRPORT LANDSCAPE OF ITALY 40 ONE, NONE AND ONE-HUNDRED THOUSAND NORTHEAST CITIES 58 VENICE AIRPORT 61 The Role of the Airport: Studies and Future Scenarios 70 Landscape Transformations 82 Obstacles Plan 84 Noise Contours 86 Flood Risk and Flood Risk Scenarios
Special Conser vation Areas and Special Protection Areas Birds and Impact Emissions 90 92 97 SCENARIOS 2030 Scenarios Constants Variables 2100 Scenarios 102 107 108 109 121 ATLAS BELLUNO Belluno Airfield BERGAMO Bergamo Orio al Serio International Airport BERGAMO Bergamo Valbrembo Airfield BOLZANO Bolzano Dolomiti Airport 128 130 134 136 138
140 BRESCIA Brescia Montichiari Airport 142 GORIZIA Gorizia Airfield 146 INNSBRUCK Innsbruck Kranebitten Airport 148 MILAN Milan Bresso Airfield 150 MILAN Milan Linate International Airport 152 MILAN Milan Malpensa International Airport 154 PADUA Padua Airport 158 TRENTO Trento Mattarello Airport 162 TREVISO Treviso Airport 168 TREVISO Treviso Istrana Airport 172 TRIESTE Trieste Ronchi dei Legionari Airport 176 UDINE Udine Campoformido 180 UDINE Udine Rivolto Airport 184 VENICE Venice San Nicolò Airfield 186 VENICE Venice Tessera International Airport 190 VERONA Verona Boscomantico Airfield 194 VERONA Verona Villafranca International Airport
VICENZA Vicenza Asiago Airfield VICENZA Vicenza Airport VICENZA Vicenza Thiene Airfield 198 202 208 DESIGN STRATEGIES AND DEVICES Noise Air Energy Permeability Water Denver International Airport, Denver, Usa Montreal International Airport, Montreal, Canada Zurich Airport, Zurich, Switzerland Amsterdam Schipol Airport, Amsterdam, The Netherlands 212 219 221 222 223 225 226 230 234 236 REFERENCES 240
ECOLOGICAL AIRPORT URBANISM AIRPORTS AND LANDSCAPES IN THE ITALIAN NORTH EAST Laura Cipriani
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS This volume presents a number of reflections on the airport landscape theme, fruit of the study matured by the researcher during the Marie Curie Cofund- PAT programme at Trento University and of a series of meetings between the researcher and the Veneto Region Department of Regional and Strategic Planning on Venice airport-city. Firstly, I would like to thank the Marie Curie Cofund Programme and Trento Province for having given me the opportunity to study the airport and landscape topic in depth. Without the experience and knowledge acquired during the threeyear research programme, this publication would never have seen the light of day. My thanks to Trento University and in particular to Prof. Pino Scaglione for his hospitality and generosity of spirit during these research years. My thanks to Stefania Staniscia, Chiara Rizzi, Ilaria di Carlo and Vincenzo Cribari for their constant support and friendship and to Paolo Dal Piaz, Cristina Chiriac, Elena Uber for their continuous help and excellent organizational work. My thanks to the Veneto Region Department of Regional and Strategic Planning and in particular to its director Romeo Toffano for having shared with me his opinions and ideas for reflection and to Alberto Miotto for his enduring help over the years. My thanks to all the people I met in the airport world. In particular, I would like to express my extreme gratitude to Lea Bodossian of the Airport Regions Conference for her constant appreciation of my work and the warmth demonstrated at many international events and to Marcus Nicolescu for his kindness and remarkable 10 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
management at ARC meetings. My thanks to Passenger Terminal Expo for letting me promote my work in many conferences worldwide. My thanks to all the people and universities I have been in contact with over the years and who have kindly hosted my presentation: to Jörg Schröeder, professor in urbanism at Leibniz Universität Hannover; to Laura Martinez, professor in design at IE University; to all the people I worked with in the international workshop in Zadar, Anica Èuka of the University of Zadar Department of Geography, Vlatka Colic, Cristian Cannaos, Giuseppe Onni of Sassari University Alghero Department of Architecture, Giovanni Corbellini, Alessandra Marin and Claudia Marcon of Trieste University Department of Architecture; to Venice University IUAV for giving me the opportunity to teach airport urbanism ; to Enrique Limon professor in architecture at Pratt University for letting me promote my research work and to Kelly Shannon professor in landscape urbanism at Oslo School of Architecture and Design for her useful insights. My thanks to Giorgia Anastasio for all the helping work done into the layout phase. A special thanks must also go to the libraries I was in contact with to retrieve texts and information to Trento Librar y and to the interlibrar y shipping ser vices, to the IUAV Venice University Institute of Architecture Librar y and to the Interdepartmental Center for Sur vey, Mapping and Processing (CIRCE) for the invaluable cartographic material. My thanks to ever yone. ECOLOGICAL AIRPORT URBANISM 11
INTRODUCTION ECOLOGICAL AIRPORT URBANISM
INTRODUCTION By their nature, use, form and size, airports are often considered as spaces extraneous to the landscape and difficult to integrate into the local context. Yet airport infrastructure is playing an ever more important role in local development, modifying not just the aspect, but also the social structure, economy and environmental quality of the surrounding area. Infrastructure on this scale benefits society as a whole, but the environmental effects are a particularly heavy burden on the communities directly involved. How is the landscape modified by air transportation? What is meant by ecological airport urbanism? Can the landscape and airport infrastructure be integrated following ecological criteria? How can an airport be integrated into the local context? What design devices can be used? How can we combine today s technological requirements with the need for unforeseen new functions in the future? In the future, how might disused airport infrastructure possibly be recycled? This study aims to make an initial contribution to research on the airport system in North East Italy in relation to current landscape transformation dynamics. The first part provides a theoretical background to the theme of airports, cities and the landscape. The intention is to provide an over view of contemporar y scientific literature in order to open a dialogue on the hitherto little explored theme of airports in relation to the landscape. The second part examines the particular characteristics of Italy s national airport system, then goes on to consider airports in North East Italy through original data and documents. Particular attention is given to the study of Venice airport, identifying the environmental risks and scenarios deriving from the urgent effects of climate change. Historical documents and accurate themed maps highlight the conflicts emerging around the airport and the possible short, medium and long term 14 INTRODUCTION
scenarios for the future. The study aims to develop a method to orient planning and design of an ecological airport system, identifying possible alternative development scenarios on multiple scales. The final section of the study therefore presents a series of designed projects proposing targeted design devices able to guide definition of the strategies and decisions to be taken today for the future. In an era dominated by uncertainty about tomorrow and by a race towards real or presumed sustainability, infrastructure must be re-planned, not just to accommodate today s technological functions or contingent needs, but also with a view to possible future re-cycle, generating a method for re-inventing the landscape and thus becoming fertile ground for the unexpected. ECOLOGICAL AIRPORT URBANISM 15