Renewable Energy Technology Diffusion to Mitigate Climate Change Impact



Similar documents
Grid Connected Solar Power in India. Tarun Kapoor Joint Secretary Ministry of New and Renewable Energy Government of India

Analysis of state-wise RPO Regulation across India

Renewable Energy Certificate Mechanism

Renewable Energy. and Renewal Energy Certificates in Indian Context

Renewable Energy Certificate Mechanism for India. ABPS Infrastructure Advisory. Background

Renewable Energy Certificate Mechanism in India

Web Edition: PROVISIONAL POPULATION TOTALS. Chapter 5. Census of India 2001 Series 1, India, Paper 1 of Chapter 5

Renewable Purchase Obligation (RPO) / Renewable Energy Certificates (REC) Advisory and Trading

Women s Energy Justice Network: CDM Financing and Microlending for Appropriate Technology REEEP Output # N3123

STATE WISE DATA As on

Press Note on Poverty Estimates,

Report On Development of Conceptual Framework For Renewable Energy Certificate Mechanism for India

GOVERNMENT OF INDIA PRESS INFORMATION BUREAU *****

WORKING PAPER. India: Implementing incentives focused on energy. Anuradha R.V., Sumiti Yadava (Clarus Law Associates)

DENSITY OF POPULATION. Figures Map Table/Statements Notes

In Focus. India s Renewable Energy Certificate Market

DRAFT National Mission on Small Hydro

TWO NEW MUST-HAVE RESEARCH REPORTS ON THE RENEWABLE ENERGY SECTOR

Hum a n Re s o u r c e s in He a lt h Se c t o r

THE INDIAN MARKET FOR RENEWABLE ENERGY THE 100 GW SOLAR INITIATIVE

Renewable Energy Certificate (REC) - A Key Step for the Growth of Renewable Energy in India

Government of India Ministry of New and Renewable Energy MNRE

State Data Centre. Round Table Conference 30 th July 2009

Press Note on Poverty Estimates,

INDIA RENEWABLE ENERGY STATUS REPORT May 14. NOVONOUS

Chapter 3 LITERACY AND EDUCATION

Solar City Master Plan - Executive Summary

DELHI ELECTRICITY REGULATORY COMMISSION

BASEL DISCLOSURES DOCUMENT AS ON 31 st December 2014 TABLE DF-3 CAPITAL ADEQUACY

PRICE DISSEMINATION PROJECT

Strategy for Providing 24x7 Power Supply. Forum of Regulators

ALL INDIA WEATHER SUMMARY AND FORECAST BULLETIN

KERALA STATE ELECTRICITY REGULATORY COMMISSION THIRUVANANTHAPURAM IN THE MATTER OF

Wind Power Programme in India

qualifications a second discipline or for ex-servicemen upper age succeeding pages. CODE Age

National Iodine Deficiency Disorders Control Programme

Tamil Nadu WiNd ENErgy ProfilE

ESTIMATION OF LIFE EXPECTANCY AT BIRTH

34-1/2013/DAF Dr. Ambedkar Foundation Ministry of Social Justice & Empowerment

Energy Efficiency, Clean Power as Engine for Sustainable Growth

Tamil Nadu Electricity Regulatory Commission

IDENTIFICATION OF DEALERS

PUNJAB STATE ELECTRICITY REGULATORY COMMISSION SCO , SECTOR 34-A, CHANDIGARH. Petition No.26 of 2010 (Suo Motu) Date of Order: 7.7.

Business Models for Off grid solar for Electricity Access in Rural/Urban India

Uttar Pradesh Rooftop Solar Photovoltaic Power Plant Policy, 2014

I M P L E M E N TAT I O N O F T H E R E N E WA B L E E N E R GY C E R T I F I CAT E ( R EC) F RA M E WO R K I N I N D I A

Enhancing the corporate energy performance

INDONESIA S COUNTRY REPORT ENCOURAGING CLEAN ENERGY INITIATIVE

Overview of Infrastructure and Construction Machinery Industry in India Opportunities and Challenges Rajesh Nath Managing Director VDMA India

DRAFT KERALA STATE ELECTRICITY REGULATORY COMMISSION, NOTICE. No. 442/CT/2014/KSERC Dated, Thiruvananthapuram 31 st March, 2015

Green Power Accounting Workshop: Concept Note For discussion during Green Power Accounting Workshop in Mexico City, May 13th 2011

At a Glance. Constructed Over 3.0 million sq. ft. in Retail, Entertainment, Commercial, Parking & Residential Assets. Planned (next 3 years)

Resolution: Energy and climate. Year and Congress: November 2009, Barcelona. Category: Environment and Energy. Page: 1. Energy and climate change

Technology Fact Sheet for Mitigation

Loan Details. Document on Educational Loans

All India Companies, Industries, Business houses, Corporates directory,database

Initiatives by TEDA and

S. No. Year Obligation expressed as percentage of energy consumption (%)

International Solar Energy Arena January 23rd, 2009, Istanbul STEAM (Strategic Technical Economic Research Center)

RAJASTHAN ELECTRICITY REGULATORY COMMISSION JAIPUR

Analysis of Solar Energy Industry in India & Its Future Prospects

Energy Productivity & Pricing

Presentation Title ( Arial, Font size 28 )

Financial Results Q3 & 9M FY February 11, 2016

Sub: States Fiscal Consolidation ( )

Residential Solar Service Agreement (RSSA) Customer Sited Solar Photovoltaic Systems

NeGP Infrastructure Components (State Data Centre, SWAN, SSDG)

ESBI Carbon Solutions. Partnering with Countries to Achieve their Full Carbon Credit Potential

Existing Wind Power Policies and Incentives

REPORT ON THE WORKING OF THE WORKMEN S COMPENSATION ACT, 1923 FOR THE YEAR 2009

REPORT ON DEVELOPMENT OF REC FRAMEWORK IN INDIA PRICING OF RENEWABLE ENERGY AND RENEWABLE ENERGY CERTIFICATES

Renewable Energy LORD Green Real Estate Strategies, Inc.

FULL SOLAR SUPPLY OF INDUSTRIALIZED COUNTRIES - THE EXAMPLE JAPAN

Portfolio Manager and Green Power Tracking

DRAFT OF THE GOA STATE GOVERNMENT POLICY TOWARDS RENEWABLE, SOLAR ENERGY AND ENERGY CONSERVATION- GOA 2014

Trends in Private and Public Investments in Agricultural Marketing Infrastructure in India

Comparison of Recent Trends in Sustainable Energy Development in Japan, U.K., Germany and France

PROCEDURE FOR ISSUANCE OF RENEWABLE ENERGY CERTIFICATE TO THE ELIGIBLE ENTITY BY CENTRAL AGENCY

Pragati Maidan, New Delhi May, Smarter Solutions for a Better Tomorrow. Organiser. Exhibitions India Group

How to Earn the LEED Green Power Credit

Government of India Earth System Science Organization Ministry of Earth Sciences India Meteorological Department

Solar Panels and the Smart Grid

CLIMATE CHANGE & FORESTS; STATUS OF SCIENCE, POLICY & RESEARCH. Prof. Ravindranath Indian Institute of Science Bangalore

How are energy companies adapting to the changing rules in the energy sector? Jaroslav Zlabek Country President Schneider Electric Polska

Emerging market for Green Certificates

a) Whether there is a need to revisit the existing approach for debt: equity ratio or to continue with the existing composition?

Status of Renewable Energy in Liberia

Innovation For Cool Earth Forum (ICEF) 2 nd Annual Meeting

Success in Scaling-up Solar Energy in Rajasthan, India

ESTIMATES OF MORTALITY INDICATORS

Clean State Energy Actions 2011 Update. connecticut

We endorse a comprehensive approach to address all greenhouse gas emissions. We recognise the importance of increasing energy efficiency

Ministry of Power & Energy

Preparatory Paper on Focal Areas to Support a Sustainable Energy System in the Electricity Sector

Solar Power Policy Uttar Pradesh 2012 Suggestions to be sent to : dirupneda@rediffmail.com ho_nmk@rediffmail.com

Summary of the Impact assessment for a 2030 climate and energy policy framework

Clean State Energy Actions 2011 Update. colorado

GOVERNMENT OF INDIA UNSTARRED QUESTION NO 822 ANSWERED ON NORMS FOR BPL

Transcription:

Renewable Energy Technology Diffusion to Mitigate Climate Change Impact *Rajesh Kumar **Arun Agarwala, * Kumar Rajesh, IDDC, IIT Delhi, New Delhi- 110016 **Agarwala A.K. IDDC, IIT Delhi- 110016 Abstract Diffusion of Renewable Energy Technologies (RETs) is governed by the status of the technology in terms of efficiency and techno-economical feasibility. The states plans for the deployment of resources for development, with special reference to sustainable environment and the demand and supply energy model help to provide more focus on the long term goals. The theory of diffusion modeling allows analysis of diffusion processes and the study of growth rates of different technologies, particularly for India with the eight National Missions under the National Action Plan for Climate Change (NAPCC). The paper presents energy computing models for optimally allocating different types of renewables in the distribution system so as to minimize energy loss. The proposed energy computing model optimises the integration of renewable energy resources with technical and financial feasibility. An econometric model identifies the potential of renewable energy sources, mapping them for computational analysis, which enables the study to forecast the demand and supply scenario. The enriched database on renewable sources and Government policies customise the delivery model for potential to transcend the costs vs. benefits barrier. The simulation and modeling techniques have overtaken the drawbacks of traditional information and communication technology (ICT) in tackling the new challenges in maximizing the benefits with smart hybrid grid. Data management has to start at the initial reception of the energy source data, reviewing it for events that should trigger alarms into outage management systems and other real-time systems such as portfolio management of a virtual hybrid power plant operator. The paper highlights two renewable source, solar and wind, for study, which can be extended to other renewable sources. Key words: Techno-Economical feasibility, RET diffusion model, Energy Efficiency, PAT, Renewable Energy Certificates Introduction Recognizing that climate change is a global challenge, India will engage actively in multilateral negotiations in the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change, in a positive, constructive and forward-looking manner. Our objective will be to establish an effective, cooperative and equitable global approach based on the principle of common but differentiated responsibilities and respective capabilities, enshrined in the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC). we must not only promote sustainable production processes, but equally, sustainable lifestyles across the globe There are Eight National Missions which form the core of the National Action Plan, representing multi-pronged, long-term and integrated strategies for achieving key goals in the context of climate change. While several of these programmes are already part of our current actions, they may need a change in direction, enhancement of scope and effectiveness and accelerated implementation of time-bound plans. In this paper some of initiatives taken are focus of discussion which are primarily necessary for RET diffusion. Modern electrical power systems (the grid) have been developing since the late 19th century and take different forms around the world. Some systems are very advanced and highly reliable but are at different scales, for example the Eastern Interconnection in the USA that serves 228 million consumers across 8.85 million square kilometers contrasts with smaller, more isolated systems such as Ireland serving a population of 6.2 million across 81,638 km2 (NISRA, 2009). Other systems are not as well developed but are rapidly evolving. This growth of electricity demand coupled with the geographically dispersed nature of many renewable sources makes electricity an attractive energy vector to harness RE where adequate network infrastructure is available. Additionally, with the development of inexpensive and effective communications systems and technologies as well as smart meters, the electrical power system is experiencing dramatic change. All these potential developments RE, demand side participation, electric vehicles and any new thermal generation (i.e., fossil fuel or nuclear) need to be integrated into electrical power systems. They collectively and individually pose common and unique challenges. The promotion of renewable energy to mitigate the impact of climate change is described in section 2 and additional Carbon saving by energy efficiency in section 3. The section 4 describe a complete model for RE technology diffusion which ended with section 5 on conclusion. 52

2 Renewable Energy Certification in India 2.1 Renewable Energy Potential The REC mechanism has the prime objectives of RPO regulation, increased flexibility for participants to carry out RE transactions, overcoming geographical constraints, reduce transaction costs, development of all encompassing incentive mechanism and reduce risks for local distribution licensee. India has been bestowed with huge RE potential on sources including solar, wind, biomass and small hydro. Central Electricity Authority conducted a survey on energy potential and highlighted India s potential of solar energy approximately at 5000 trillion kwh/year equivalent. The combined potential of various RE sources excluding solar energy, in some major states in India, is shown in figure 1 below [Goyal Mohit, Jha Rakesh, (2009); Strategic Plan (2011]. The states, after considerations on the potential of REC as highlighted in fig.1, have announced promotional benefits for renewable energy. These benefits are in the form of accelerated depreciation benefits, tax benefits, generation based incentives and capital subsidy. Further, CDM benefit is also available to renewable energy projects [Kumar R, Agarwala A.K., (2013-1)]. 14000 12000 RE Potential in States 10000 RE Potential in MW 8000 6000 4000 2000 0 Gujrat Karnataka Kerala M.P Maharstra Odisha Rajasthan Tamilnadu AP States in India Fig. 1: State-wise Gross RE Potential Capacity( Excluding Solar) The Solar Mission has set a target of 20,000 MW and stipulates implementation and achievement of the target in 3 phases, with first phase 2012-13, second phase 2013-2017 and the third phase 2017-2022, for various components, including grid connected solar power. Grid connected Solar Thermal power projects of an aggregate capacity of 500 MW have been selected in FY 2010-11. Solar PV power projects of about 200 MW capacity have been selected in FY 2010-11. Grid Connected Solar PV power projects of up to 350 MW capacity are selected in FY 2011-12. 2.2 Renewable Energy Certification Mechanism In this mechanism, one REC is issued to the RE generator for one MWh electrical energy fed into the grid. The REC issued by SERC has a Unique Certificate Number with information on name of the issuing body, generator identity, type of generation technology, installed capacity of the generator, location of the generator and signature of the authorized person. The REC generator must apply within a period three months of the generation for issuance of RE certificate on grid connected RE projects of 250 kw and above [Kumar R, Agarwala A.K., (2013-1]. The REC is available for trade up to 365 days after the date of issuance. The RE generator identifies the RE potential and coordinates with state Government for the power sale agreement. The approved RE generator installs the RE plant and contacts state load distribution centre (SLDC) for the supply 53

of energy to the grid and energy metering. SLDC monitors the energy distribution and certifies the energy fed to the distributor for the issuance of REC by CERC. The REC issued by registry are tradable at two power exchanges within 365 days. 2.3 Renewable Energy Purchase Obligation The Electricity Act 2003 (EA 2003) sets Renewable Purchase Obligation (RPO) targets for distribution companies to purchase a certain percentage of their total power requirement from renewable energy sources [Kumar R, Agarwala A.K., (2013)]. The RE generator may sell electricity to the distribution company and the associated RECs to the distribution company or any other obligated entity. The RE generator may sell RECs to the entities with RPO target in the State or outside the State [RE-2013]. The methodology to identify RPO obligation as given in table 1 depends on the following factors: Projections of total quantum of energy required for sale in the State and Central Govt. policies. Potential for different types of renewable energy in the State and quantum of energy currently being generated by renewable sources within the State. Technical & Commercial impact of renewable power on the retail tariff. S.N State/UT In India RPO (%) 2013-14 S.N. State/UT in India RPO (%) 2013-14 1 Andhra Pradesh 5.00 15 Maharashtra 8.00 2 Assam 5.60 16 Meghalaya 1.00 3 Arunachal Pradesh 5.60 17 Odisha 6.00 4 Bihar 4.50 18 Punjab 3.50 5 Chattisgarh 6.25 19 Rajasthan 8.20 6 Delhi 4.80 20 Tamil Nadu 9.00 7 Gujrat 7.00 21 Tripura 1.00 8 Haryana 3.00 22 Uttrakhand 5.05 9 Himachal Pradesh 10.25 23 Uttar Pradesh 6.00 10 Jammu & Kashmir 5.00 24 West Bangal 4.00 11 Jharkhand 4.00 25 Goa & UTs 3.00 12 Karnataka BESCOM,MESCOM, CHESCOM* For other supplier 10.25 (for >5MW CPP ) 7.25 26 Manipur 5.00 13 Kerala 3.90 27 Mizoram 7.00 14 Madhya Pradesh 5.50 28 Nagaland 8.00 Renewable Purchase Obligation on Captive Power Plant and Open Access * BESCOM,MESCOM, CHESCOM are the Electricity supply Company in Karnataka Table 1 Indian States with RPO obligation for the FY 2013-14 2.1 Renewable Energy Certificate Trading The trading of REC is on two exchanges with centralised information and control mechanism at Central Electricity Regulatory Commission (CERC). The REC Trading started in April, 2011 with a slow response but has gained momentum within a few months operated through two exchanges PXIL and IEX. These exchanges offer easy access, transparent and fully electronic market place, and a robust and user friendly platform to trade on RECs. The trading from DEcember, 2011 to June, 2013 is shown in fig 2, reflects that REC certificate issuance growth rate is sharp rise after September, 2012, due to marketing constraint and its streamline around 3,00,000 every month. The REC issued are rising continuously, while the REC redeemed are stagnated below three lakhs, which create large closing balance. The rise in closing balance indicates the low demand for REC and the cost is likely to fall in future. The REC closing balance on 31 st December, 2012 is 14,86,111 and floor trade price for non- solar REC is INR 1500 ($28) and for solar REC is INR 12620 ($ 230). 54

70 60 50 x 10000 REC Issued REC Redeemed 40 30 20 10 0 Sep-11 Dec-11 Apr-12 Jul-12 Oct-12 Jan-13 May-13 Aug-13 Fig 2; REC status from December, 2011 to June, 2013 3 Perform, Achieve and Trade( PAT) 3.1 Mechanism To enhance energy efficiency in industries, a new mechanism Perform, Achieve and Trade (PAT) is designed with the basic green energy concept to comply with international policy similar to the Energy Efficiency Portfolio Standard (EEPS) mechanisms in US, Tradable Green certificates (TGC) in Europe and similar programmes in other countries [33]. The PAT mechanism designed to promote enhanced energy efficient technology to be adopted by industry to improve target on specified specific energy consumption (SEC) in a cost-effective manner. Perform Achieve and Trade (PAT) needs improvement to give its operational mechanism scale, complexities, timelines for successful delivery. Bureau of Energy efficiency (BEE) is the centralised agency for the implementation of PAT programme and will start trade on certificates by 2014. The PAT mechanism targets energy incentive sector, and identified 8 sectors for the first phase 2012-15, namely Thermal Power Plants, Fertilizer, Cement, Pulp and Paper, Textiles, Chlor-Alkali, Iron & Steel and Aluminum. The PAT framework has a methodology for identification of designated consumer (DC) and currently 478 DCs are working with BEE in 8 sectors. The design phase includes calculations for setting up SEC for each DC and reduction target [Kumar R, Agarwala A.K., (2013)]. 3.2 ESCerts Trading BEE in coordination with Ministry of Power, Ministry of Finance, Ministry of new & Renewable energy and Ministry of Science & Technology prepared a draft design of PAT assessment document (PAD), which contains the information on process and technology upgraded which reflected in the form of enhanced energy saving. This paper proposes ESCerts trading mechanism and methodology that needs extensive information exchange between Designated Consumers (DCs), State Designated Agencies (SDAs), Designated Energy Auditors (DENAs), Power Exchanges, Bureau of Energy Efficiency (BEE) and Central Registry on a regular basis. The central registry office is assigned responsibility for creation of the information network and share timely and accurate information while maintaining confidentiality, transparency and security. This could be achieved through adopting dedicated software programme PAT-Net, an online integrated information system for the operation and data management for creation, transfer, trading and cancellation of ESCert. The PAT-Net is an information consortium and provides connection to all the BEE, DCs, SDAs, DENAs, Trading exchanges, Central Registry, trader and banks. Each one of them will be provided with a unique access depending on their category, with user rights assigned accordingly. In the proposed model, PAT-Net, overall administrative control, rights and responsibility entrusted on BEE. 4 Renewable Energy Technology Diffusion Model In order to achieve the most accurate predictive analysis, influential factors in energy application have been taken into full consideration during design of energy model in this article. Taking the collected abundant data and related economic indicator models through further strict calculation can be used to predict relative economic indicators. Three typical renewable energy sources, namely solar, wind and geothermal energy have been taken in the thesis to explore the design thinking of the energy models. 4.1 Solar Energy Photovoltaic : 55

The solar energy photovoltaic power model with economic indicators is E SPV { I R, P V, L, T PV,S PV } --- (1) The global solar radiation I R obtained from the surface of the solar cell array The energy in the form electrical voltage and current produced by solar cell array is P V The inverter loss during conversion to usable energy L Substituted quantity T PV of PAT for conventional energy power conversion and smart grid technology REC Certificate for the generation S pv 4.2 SolarThermal Power : The Solar Thermal heating Energy is obtained as; E ewh {, η 1, η 2, Q uf, T ewh,s ewh } --- (2) Solar energy assurance factor Solar energy heat collecting system efficiency η 1 Solar water heating system efficiency η 2 Useful heat quantity of solar heat collecting system Q uf Substituted quantity T ewh of PAT for conventional energy power conversion and smart grid technology REC Certificate for the generation S pv 4.3 Energy Model for REC, PAT and Fossil fuel Power Plant The renewable energy Model is considered for the factor from equation 1, 2, 4 and 6 for the availability of resources in consideration of fossil fuel energy ( E fs ) E T { E re E fs } where E re ={E spv,e ewh E w E gshp E other re } (3) The Bass diffusion model [Rao K. Usha, Kishore V.V.N., (2010)], as considered by K Usha Rao et al. [37] is a mixed influence model with three parameters i.e. coefficient of technology, policy and business innovation, coefficient of imitation and total potential. = [ p+ r + Ecert + {N (t)}] [m N(t) ] (4) where p is the coefficient of technology and business innovation, r is RE certification and ECert carbon mitigation policy, q is the coefficient of imitation and m is the total potential. The Control Design and Simulation Module provides a numerical simulation environment that enables users to test the model, and the Module can be used to analyse the interactions between hybrid mechanical-electrical systems [Krishnan S S (2010); Rao K. Usha, Kishore V.V.N., (2010)]. Furthermore, the quality of existing models can be improved and other control strategies can be investigated by simulating deep-bar induction generators and more complex models of drive trains. 5 Conclusion It is possible to mitigate the climate change and GHG emissions to a certain level, though not completely, by human beings. The Climate Change, Mitigation and Adaptation have been reviewed in view of IPCC and clean development mechanism (CDM), one of the most recommended and promising technology for mitigation, introduced under the Kyoto Protocol is reviewed vis-à-vis PAT and REC Mechanism. Cost-effective and immediate to implement Energy Efficiency and energy saving certification is the need of the hour. Funding for GHG mitigation projects in developing countries is crucial for addressing the global climate change problem. The existing policies and the amendments needed in the framing of new policies have been reviewed. The portfolios of policy instruments used by the industrialized countries in their evolving climate change strategies should be widened, increasing the coverage of those policy instruments to all sectors. In scaling the policy responses to climate change, local thinking must be coupled with global and national scales of action in order to achieve the levels of CO 2 reductions needed to avoid dangerous climate impacts. Reference Goyal Mohit, Jha Rakesh, (2009)Introduction of Renewable Energy Certificate in the Indian scenario, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 2009;13: 1395 1405 Krishnan S S, Narang Niket, Dolly Smita Kumari, King Robin and Subrahmanian Eswaran (2010) Global Mechanisms to Create Energy Efficient and Low-Carbon Infrastructures : An Indian Perspective, 978-1-4244-8479-9/10/ c 2010 IEEE Kumar Rajesh (2010), Scientific Infrastructure for Inclusive Growth, SKOCH Thinkers & Writers Forum / Compendium of Papers 2009-10 Kumar Rajesh (2010-1), SOLAR Quarterly, January 2010, Soleckshaw Status and Vision, TERI Publication 56

Kumar Rajesh, Agarwala A.K, (2012) RET Diffusion Model for Techno-Economics feasibility, International Conference on SOLARIS -2012 - Energy security Global Warming and Sustainable Climate organized by IIT Delhi and BERS on 7-9 th February, 2012 Kumar R, Agarwala A.K., (2013). Renewable Energy Certificate and Perform, Achieve, Trade mechanisms to enhance the energy security for India, Energy Policy 55 (2013) 669 676 Kumar R, Agarwala A.K., (2013-1) Energy Certificates REC and PAT Sustenance to Energy Model for India" Renewable & Sustainable Energy Reviews published by Elsevier, 21 (2013) 315 323 NISRA 2009 http://www.dfpni.gov.uk/publication-scheme-what-our-are-priorities-service-standards-dfp_customer_survey_2007-2 RE-2013 REConnect Energy Volume 32, June, 2013 Rao K. Usha, Kishore V.V.N., (2010) A review of technology diffusion models with special reference to renewable energy technologies, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 2010;14: 1070 10 Schmid Gisele (2012), The development of renewable energy power in India: which policies have been effective? Energy Policy 45(2012)317-326 Strategic Plan (2011)for New and Renewable Energy Sector for the period 2011-17, Ministry Of New And Renewable Energy (MNRE), Government Of India, February 2011 57