Direct to Home Television: A Review



Similar documents
1. INTRODUCTION. 1.1 Background and Motivation. 1.2 The Digital Television Era

Chapter 1 - Introduction

DIRECT TO HOME TELEVISION SCOPE IN PAKISTAN

A Study on HITS Technologies the Latest Trends in Cable TV Communication

IndusInd Media & Communications

Smart LNB. White Paper. May 2014

Small Networks - Go Digital with TRANSMODULATORS

9 The continuing evolution of television

Case study Sky The Best in Entertainment Across All Channels

How To Make Money From A Triple Play Service

Traffic load and cost analysis for different IPTV architectures

Global Direct-to-Home (DTH) Markets, 5 th Edition

DIRECT TO HOME TELEVISION (DTH)

6. COMPETITION BETWEEN TV DISTRIBUTION PLATFORMS

Demonstration of Internet Protocol Television(IPTV) Khai T. Vuong, Dept. of Engineering, Oslo University College.

OECD EXPERT MEETING. Presentation by Supran Sen Secretary General Film Federation of India

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) on Digital Addressable Cable TV Systems

MEASAT Satellite Systems Sdn. Bhd.

Cable and Satellite Digital Entertainment Networks. Moving toward an Integrated Digital Media Experience

Study Of Recent Developments In DTH (Direct-To-Home) Technology

Hybrid system and new business model

CATV s Answer to Satellite Competition

Emerging Markets for H.264 Video Encoding

Video Compression Trends & OUTLOOK. Andreas Pentrelli Solution Consultant

ELEMENTS OF CABLE TELEVISION

Digital Cable TV. User Guide

Pakistan Electronic Media Regulatory Authority Consultation paper

Highlight. 21 October OTT Services A Digital Turning Point of the TV Industry

ACCESS CHARGE A fee charged subscribers or other telephone companies by a local exchange carrier for the use of its local exchange networks.

Ministry of Information and Broadcasting Services

Trends of Interactive TV & Triple Play

Subscription Television in Australia. Kim Williams, CEO FOXTEL July 2002

IPTV Primer. August Media Content Team IRT Workgroup

Applications that Benefit from IPv6

SERIES H: AUDIOVISUAL AND MULTIMEDIA SYSTEMS Infrastructure of audiovisual services Communication procedures

PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF VIDEO FORMATS ENCODING IN CLOUD ENVIRONMENT

Internet Protocol Television (IPTV)

RSPG public consultation related to the draft opinion on EU spectrum policy implications of the digital dividend.

INTERNET PROTOCOL TELEVISION (IPTV) SERVICES

Establishing the Next Generation of Video. Ferdinand Kayser, Chief Commercial Officer

Hybrid TV. Taking Advantage of the Best of IPTV and SatTV August 08 TIME INSIGHT. 2. DTH as a first step. 1. How it all began

Digital TV business models

IPTV the future of television?

New TV Technologies for Science Education. A.K. Bhatnagar Chief Engineer Doordarshan

Images move the world We move images

FiOS. An All- Fiber Network. Neil Tomasetti Alaa Shaheen Sankarbrathy Ponnusamy Mohammed Babatin Varshal Patel. Introduction:

Setting up Digital Cable on an S1Digital Media Center

Netflix. Daniel Watrous. Marketing. Northwest Nazarene University

A New Business Model of DBS Services in China

TAM Annual Universe Update 2015

The Opportunity for White-labeled IPTV & OTT TV for MNOs, MSOs and ISPs. Date: 19 January 2014

SHEET 5 CABLE TELEVISION SYSTEM

Solon Survey of European Cable Communication 2014

The Business of Bundled Services: Consumers, Models, and Uptake

The Next Growth Era for Japan s Pay-TV Business. Toru Kato Director, General Manager, Media Business Unit Jupiter Telecommunica:ons Co., Ltd.

Fujitsu Gigabit Ethernet VOD Solutions

Strategic Review of Satellite and Space Science use of Spectrum. Satellite workshop 3 July 2015

Top Homebuyer Trends. The Internet Home computers Functional home office Access to entertainment services Assurance of resale value

BROADCASTING ACT (CHAPTER 28) Code of Practice for Television Broadcast Standards

INDUSIND MEDIA & COMMUNICATIONS LTD. (Hinduja Group)

Study structure and methodology

television audience measurement - a guide

WKDS: FM Radio Station

! Giving the subscribers a choice of watching streaming content or receiving quickly delivered DVDs by mail.

A STUDY ON DIGITAL VIDEO BROADCASTING TO A HANDHELD DEVICE (DVB-H), OPERATING IN UHF BAND

LINE IN, LINE OUT AUDIO IN, AUDIO OUT FIXED, VARIABLE TO TV, VIDEO IN, VIDEO OUT Sony Electronics Inc. All rights reserved.

VAST TV. Enjoy watching the channels you love.

White Paper Content Delivery Networks (CDN) for Live TV Streaming

E1-E2 (EB) Chapter 8A. Broadband Services

growth in digital segments while traditional media remain resilient

HOW TO GET A GREAT TV DEAL 6 WAYS TO EXTEND YOUR WIFI

Cyfrowy Polsat IR Newsletter. 5 11March 2012

(Refer Slide Time: 4:45)

VoIP Market India July 2014

LGI. casestudy. overview

COMMUNICATIONS OUTLOOK 1999

New markets HEVC DVB T2 Germany. Herbert Tillmann

VisionFibreMedia. 1 Gb to your business

wireless triple play network -

Solutions Overview. IPTV on your Network.

From IPTV to mobiletv and OTTV *TV. From IPTV to mobile TV and over-the-top TV. Alessandro Bogliolo

Over the Top and Pay TV Opportunities: How are operators and content providers working together to create innovative platforms?

Harnessing The Internet s Multimedia Potential

Transition from Analog to High Definition Television in Hospitals

JACKSON COUNTY SCHOOL BOARD Marianna, Florida. Down and Dirty IPTV

Market & Business Development in in Television HbbTV and IPTV in Australia

Connections and Setup

Maheshwari, Manasvi (2014). Digitisation of Cable Television in India. International Journal of Research (IJR). Vol-1, Issue-2.

FTTn/VDSL2 Broadband Networks

Verizon Communications. FiOS Technology

ASIAN JOURNAL OF MANAGEMENT RESEARCH Online Open Access publishing platform for Management Research

Transcription:

Direct to Home Television: A Review 1 Karanpreet Kaur, 2 Amit Kumar 1 Dept. of ECE, DWIET, Mohali, Punjab, India 2 College of Information Science and Technology, Nanjing Forestry University, Nanjing, China Abstract DTH is a new technology and it has matured to its full potential in other parts of the world. There are many application has been found every day for exploitation of benefits of DTH.The word DTH is synonymous with transmission of digital video channel to home subscribers using a small dish antenna. The DTH utilizes a technology which enables a home to receive high speed internet broadband access data communication, voice over internet protocol (IP) telephony and much more using an open standard Digital Video Broadcasting (DVB) technology. In this paper we discuss that how DTH is related with the cable and also about the role of DTH in rural and urban areas. DTH platforms worldwide are focusing on increasing ARPU ( Average Revenue Per User) by pushing premium services, the NSR report predicts that global DTH industry revenues will grow from $70 billion in July 2010 just $100 billion in 10 years, i.e., by 2018. II. How Does DTH Work? DTH network consists of a broadcasting center, satellites, encoders, multiplexers, modulators and DTH receivers. A DTH service provider has to lease Ku-band transponders from the satellite. The encoder converts the audio, video and data signals into the digital format and the multiplexer mixes these signals. At the user end, there will be a small dish antenna and set-top boxes to decode and view numerous channels. On the user s end, receiving dishes can be as small as 45 cm in diameter [9]. Keywords DTH Industry in India, Relationship Between DTH and Cable, DTH Future I. Introduction DTH is defined as the reception of satellite programs with a personal dish in an individual home. And an individual Set Top Box (STB) empowering you to pick & choose you bundles of choice and pay for what you watch. Direct to home connects urban, rural and remote areas of the country and provides desire information communication, education and entertainment at the click of a button. There are five major components involved in a Direct To Home (DTH) satellite system: the programming source, the broadcast center, the satellite, the satellite dish and the receiver. This technology is originally referred to as Direct Broadcast Satellite (DBS) technology and India is one of the biggest DTH service providers in the world. Though DBS and DTH present the same services to the consumers, there are some differences in the technical specifications. While DBS is used for transmitting signals from satellites at a particular frequency band [the band differs in each country, DTH is used for transmitting signals over a wide range of frequencies [normal frequencies including the KU and KA band. The satellites used for the transmission of the DTH signals are not part of any international planned frequency band. DBS has changed its plans over the past few years so as to include new countries and also modify their mode of transmission from analog to digital. But DTH is more famous for its services in both the analog and digital services which includes both audio and video signals. The dishes used for this service is also very small in size. When it comes to commercial use, DBS is known for its service providing a group of free channels that are allowed for its targeted country. The low cost of DTH when compared to other local cable providers is also one main reason for this substantial growth. The idea of DTH was first provided to India in 1996, but the laws were changed by the year 2000 and thus DTH was allowed [1-2]. Fig. 1: Main Parameter of DTH III. DTH Features and Technology A. MPEG-2 v/s MPEG-4 Old players use MPEG-2 technology while new players are using MPEG-4 technology which enables players to broadcast high quality video content along with more channels in the same bandwidth. MPEG4 offers a better compression/quality ratio for transmitted videos than MPEG2. B. DVB-S v/s DVB-S2 DVB-S is the original Digital Video broadcasting forward error coding and modulation standard for satellite television. Digital Video Broadcasting - Satellite - Second Generation (DVB- S2) is an enhanced specification to replace the DVB-S standard; this development of DVB-S2 coincided with the introduction of HDTV and H.264 (MPEG-4 AVC) video codecs. The DVD-S2 system allows transmission of one or more MPEG-2 or MPEG-4 audio and video streams whereas DVD-S was designed for MPEG-2. Airtel Digital, Tata Sky D2H and Videocon D2H support DVB-S2 technology. Channel publish content in High Definition (HD) or Standard Definition - HD content might not be captured by DTH if they do not support DVB-S2. C. IPTV and Recording IPTV (Internet Protocol Television) is TV service which is delivered using IP (Internet Protocol) technology, which is the same technology used in Internet Services. In this service the TV channels are encoded in IP format and delivered to TV using a Set Top Box. The IP TV Service also includes Video on Demand www.ijear.org International Journal of Education and Applied Research 57

ISSN: 2348-0033 (Online) Services which is is similar to watching Video CD s / DVD s using a VCD / DVD player. Movies, Instructional Videos and other content shall be available to customers in the IP TV Services. If you are unable to watch a daily soap for a week because you are busy, you see all five episodes back-to-back on the weekend with the recordings available. All this requires enormous amounts of bandwidth. IPTV is currently available in India mainly through BSNL and MTNL. These companies are providing is a cross between cable and DTH. D. Pause and Record Tata Sky Plus gives facility of pausing, rewinding and recording features in their service. This costs more than their regular DTH service for setup box and installation. iphone and ipad into a universal remote for television to help the subscriber network and watch TV at the same time, Airtel Digital has made the offering to farmers in rural areas. Most of these services are free of cost -- for now. The industry analysts feel that designing a new VAS-based innovation model is the need of the hour for the service providers, to stay a step ahead of their competitors. The DTH subscriber base in India increased by 134.44% in a period of two years. As on March, 35.56 million DTH subscribers are registered with private service providers. December 2010 encountered a 21.21% increase in terms of subscriber base which is the maximum for the given time period. The average growth rate has been 12.99%. Major DTH service providers include Dish TV, Airtel, Reliance, Tata Sky, Videocon and Sun Direct TV. E. Movies on Demand Movies are available on what is called Video-On-Demand (VOD), some new movie releases can be bought and watched at the comfort of your home. F. Interactive TV Interactive TV provides additional features and services like Tuitions, Shopping, and Stories for your child, cooking shows, astrology, news and more. You should check these out for anything that might be useful. G. Multilingual User Interface Most DTH offer user interfaces in multiple languages which enable anyone non-conversant in English also to easily browse and use the services. DTH services provide multiple users to select and store channels of their interest for ease in viewing and shuffling channels. H. Channel Lock, Parental Lock, Channel Hide There are features by which you can lock or hide the channels that you do not want. You can also use parental locks to prevent children from viewing unwanted channels. I. Services Centre s This is a very important factor especially if you do not want to go through any pain during the installation or any issue process. The service should be reasonable and you should check with neighbors or acquaintances for a feedback of the service provider [11]. IV. DTH industry in India India is very popular emerging market for DTH services with a large television viewing population. Specially, the number of DTH subscribers in India is forecasted to grow at a compound annual growth rate of 38.9 percent from 2007 to 2012. Today, DTH services are getting popularity in India because of direct to home technology, which is emerging as the leading digital TV transmission platform in India. DTH services in India are very flexible and on time. DTH providers here are listed here:-airtel, Videocon, Tata sky, Sun direct, Dish TV. These are few service providers in India [1]. A. DTH Scenario in India Direct-to-Home (DTH) companies are busy seeking for innovative VAS (value-added services)-based model to fetch the demands of the new target audience consisting of social networking freaks, housewives, students, farmers, kids and businessmen. So, while Tata Sky has introduced a device to turn the 58 In t e r n a t io n a l Jo u r n a l o f Ed u c a t io n a n d Ap p l i e d Re s e a rc h Fig. 2: Market Share of DTH [14] B. Recent Developments 1. Dish TV added 725,000 new subscribers in the quarter ended June 30, 2011, taking the total number of gross subscribers to 11.2 million and net subscribers to 8.9 million. 2. At the end of Q1FY12, Reliance Digital TV has 3.7 million subscribers, with an 11% market share in the Indian DTH market. 3. Videocon d2h claims to have reached a subscriber base of 4 million. 4. Tata Sky claims a subscriber base of over 75 lakh or 7.5 million users (as of August). 5. Airtel Digital TV reported a subscriber base of 6.26 million, at the end of Q1FY12 [3-4]. Fig. 3: Growth of DTH Subscribers Base Per Annum V. Relationship Between DTH and Cable DTH, TV channels will be transmitted from the satellite to a small dish antenna mounted on the window or rooftop of the subscriber s home. So the broadcaster directly connects to the user DTH can also reach the remotest of areas since it does away with the intermediate step of cable and wires (cables) that come to your home. DTH offer digital superior quality picture against cable TV www.ijear.org

today which is most analog. DTH is an encrypted transmission that travels to the consumer directly through a satellite. DTH transmission is received directly by the consumer at his end through a small dish antenna. The encrypted transmission is decoded by an individual STB at your home. The other advantage of DTH is the availability of satellite broadcast in rural and semi-urban areas lying of cable is difficult. Due to digital compression techniques, many more niche channels are available than cannot be provided by cable operators. DTH also offers digital quality signals which do not degrade the picture or sound quality. It also offers interactive channels and program guides with customers having the choice to block out programming which they consider undesirable [5]. Fig. 4: Cable V/s DTH Trends A. DTH Doing Well, but 80% Households Still on Cable TV Even as the DTH players are gradually ramping up their market share, the Cable connections still form the preferred choice for a large majority of the subscribers even today. While DTH subscribers summed-up to paltry 22 million by 2010, the overall Cable subscriber base in the country stood at 83 million during 2008. With the entry of corporate giants such as Dish TV, Tata Sky, Airtel Digital TV and Big TV among other players, the market for DTH services is more organized than the Cable industry and has been able to sneak into the market for digital T V, effectively competing wide-spread cable operators. five households avails of digital connection. Most of the cable connections come with fixed charges and cost, mostly cheaper than DTH services, with out any add-on packages and free access to most of the channels on air including latest yet pirated movies on local connections. However, the pay-dth is gradually gaining ground in rural India where the subscriber base has almost doubled since past couple of years. Many analysts are of the view that both cable and DTH services can grow simultaneously in the Indian market. In fact, DTH players target 33% of cable market in the next couple of years. It certainly seems that after mobile revolution, it could well be turn of the DTH market to explode into a mass product. And most probably the competition and involvement of the big corporate world in this business space would ultimately benefit none other than the final consumer of the premium directto-home services [6]. VI. DTH in Rural and Urban Area Direct-to-Home (DTH) is penetrating rural India in greater measure as the share of pay-dth has almost doubled in rural India, as compared to 2008. As per a study known as. Digital connection involves reception of TV signals through a set-top-box, (STB), either through DTH or through cable. The DTH service is growing fastest and has been higher across platforms, whether it is metros or even smaller towns. Both urban and rural digital growth is mainly coming from pay-dth; the growth rate of the same is specifically higher in rural areas. The share of pay-dth among all DTH households has been 86% for urban compared to 64% for rural areas. But if we compare the statistics in 2008, the growth in the digital segment in the rural sector was 34%, in 2009 it was 49% and in 2010 it was 64%. What prevails over everything else is that DTH has been observed as the growth provider for digital TV in both strata, whereas cable STB. The rural market has been responding fantastically compared to the urban one, said the TAM spokesperson. According to the statistics provided by the report, Maharashtra, Gujarat, Uttar Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh, and Delhi have performed better with a higher growth rate than the all-india figures for TV and C&S (cable and satellite). According to the demographic composition studied by TAM on the digital platform, non-metros have seen a significant digital growth, considering that all-india digital growth has been around 11%. TV, C&S and digital segments grew by 9%, 11% and 54% respectively per year, as per the TAM report, where growth has been primarily driven by non-metro markets. TAM s spokesperson added, What the Indian landscape is seeing is the co-existence of C&S and digital on the same platform, which is marvelous. According to industry sources, the DTH story has been fairly optimistic, as the industry added about 12 million customers in the first five years but in the last one year the industry has added 10 million more customers. Therefore, today the total DTH market is around 22 million. Airtel, which has around 2.5 million customers for its DTH service, said that rural India is an important market, It (the rural market) has played a substantial role in our growth in DTH services in the last one year or so. Increasingly, we find that over 60% of our customers come from outside the top 300 towns in India [7]. Fig. 5: DTH & Cable TV Household as a Percentage of Totals According to the TAM Annual Universe Update 2010 study, out of the estimated 135 million total number of TV households in India, 80% of the them are subscribed to cable and satellite connection. From this cable subscriber base, only one in every www.ijear.org International Journal of Education and Applied Research 59

ISSN: 2348-0033 (Online) its subscriber base explode from 6 million to 75 million over the same period [13]. B. Challenges Faced by the Industry Policy and Regulation Lack of Exclusive Content Cap on Foreign Investment Cap on Cable Company/ Broadcaster Investment The Rule of Must Carry Interoperability issues. Non-availability of Transponders Fig. 6: Rural Vs Urban Scenario VII. DTH Future The most significant and disturbing prediction is financial. Even though DTH platforms worldwide are focusing on increasing ARPU ( Average Revenue Per User) by pushing premium services, the NSR report predicts that global DTH industry revenues will grow from $70 billion in July 2010 just $100 billion in 10 years, i.e., by 2018. The reports points towards market fragmentation, and increased competition, from other sectors such a not Cable TV, but also IPTV, and the internet particularly in advanced markets such as the USA and France. However, while, 99 DTH operators were beaming over 13,800 channels at the July of 2010, it is predicted that more than 21,000 channels will be beamed from DTH platforms, by end 2018. Fig. 7: DTH Subscribers Awareness A. Sunny Side up for DTH Firms 1. DTH Subscriptions Grow by Million, Every Month Government policy is also expected to favor further DTH growth. Digitization will lead to hefty rise in revenues for broadcasters as it will eliminate carriage fees they pay to cable TV operators, substantially cutting cost of operations of running channels. At present, carriage and placement fees corner nearly 20% of the total cost of running a channel. The government is also pushing for a hike in FDI limit in DTH from 49% to 74%. For DTH, the growth was even faster between July and September 2010 with 5.6 million additions in three months [12]. 2. DTH and Digital Cable Will Co-Exist Most viewers seem to prefer Direct-To-Home (DTH) to view television. However, cable (digital) will still be an important broadcast mode. This observation has been made by a FICCI- KPMG report on media and entertainment. The number of DTH households in the country is set to go up from 37 million in 2011 to 86 million by 2016.Digital cable, on the other hand, would see 60 In t e r n a t io n a l Jo u r n a l o f Ed u c a t io n a n d Ap p l i e d Re s e a rc h C. Environment Analysis- Porter s Model Let us apply the porter s five forces model in the context of DTH industry. Out observations are categorized in to the five forces as below: Threat of Substitutes Terrestrial Television Cable TV Internet Protocol Television (IPTV) Bargaining Power of Suppliers [8, 10] VIII. Conclusion With the existing regulatory restrictions, increasing content cost and lack of transponders, DTH terrain appears too steep to climb. With content differentiations not happenings in the near future, companies have to differentiate only at the services and cost levels. The increasing consumer awareness and expectations also make it is difficult to satisfy the consumer. India being the home of entertainment hungry populace, volumes play the role of a growth driver. Attractively priced and feature rich package targeted at the critical mass is the mantra for sustaining the growth. Today s customer is sensitive to price as well as to quality. A prudent DTH operator should also take a serious look at the substitutes and complements. There should diversity and creates his presence in the entire spectrum of broadcasting and telecommunication services. The final winner cannot be a pure DTH player but a convergent player who offers all in one to the value-conscious, price sensitive Indian consumer. The DTH industry is very bright in the future years. References [1] Chaman Goyal (2010), DTH HOME: DTH services on Modern Technology, [Online] Available: http://www. sooperarticles.com/communications-articles/dth-home-dthservices-modern-technology-36909.html [2] DTH Technology working electronic circuit diagram electronics, [Online] Available: http://www.circuitstoday. com/direct-to-home-dth-technology-%e2%80%93- working [3] Magazine for Satellite Broadcasting & Broadband Industries- News Update, [Online] Available: http://news_view.asp. htm [4] Saptarishi Dutta (2011), MEDIANAMA News & Analysis of digital media in India, [Online] Availabe: http://www. medianama.com/2011/09/223-chart-of-the-day-dthsubscribers-in-india/ [5] Tech In, [Online] Available: http://teck.in/news/what-is-dthwhy-is-dth-different-from-cable-tv-t107.html [6] Digital TV: IP TV vs. DTH v/s. Cable TV Monday, (2009), [Online] Available: http://amitslab.com/blog/2009/06/22/ digital-tv-ip-tv-vs-dth-vs-cable-tv/ www.ijear.org

[7] Sathish (2010), Digital TV growth in India driven by rural market, [Online] Available: http://www.moneylife.in/ article/8/5287.html [8] R. Srinivasan,"DTH Industry in India Future Prospectus", Economic Affairs, Vol. 56, No. 2, June 2011, pp. 185-188. [Online] Available: www.ndpublisher.in/last_issue/ea/12_ Economics.pdf [9] Priya Ganapati (2004), WHAT IS DTH, [Online] Available: http://www.rediff.com/money/2004/mar/23spec.htm [10] [Online] Available: http://www.authorstream.com/ Presentation/aSGuest20765-203837-dth-technology-globusengineering-education-ppt-powerpoint/ [11] DTH (Direct to Home) Television Guide, [Online] Available: http://indiahometips.com/dth-plan-guide.html [12] Sanjib Kr Baruah, Hindustan Times, New Delhi, October 30, 2011, [Online] Available: http://www.hindustantimes.com/ India-news/NewDelhi/DTH-subscriptions-grow-by-millionevery-month/Article1-762974.aspx [13] K.VENKATASUBRAMANIAN, DTH and digital cable will co-exist, [Online] Available: http://www. thehindubusinessline.com/features/investment-world/ macro-view/article3314911.ece [14] "Dth Service Providers: New Horizions, Sunny Side up for DTH Firms (2011), [Online] Available: http:// www.businessandeconomy.org/31032011/storyd. asp?sid=6035&pageno=1 Karanpreet Kaur is pursuing her bachelor s degree in Electronics and Communication from Doaba Group of Colleges, Mohali (Punjab Technical University), Punjab, INDIA. She has published a paper in International Journal. Her field of research is Wireless Communication Networks. Amit Kumar received his bachelor s degree in Mathematics from the Himachal Pradesh University, Shimla, India, in 2002 and Masters degree in Computer Application from Kurukshetra University, Kurukshetra, India, in 2006. He completed his M.Phil. in Computer Science from Annamalai University, Annamalai nagar, Tamilnadu, India, in 2010. He is currently pursuing his Ph.D. in Computer Science. He is working as a Lecturer in the Department of Computer Science, College of Information Science and Technology, Nanjing Forestry University, Nanjing, China. He has many publications in National/ International Conference proceedings and International Journals. He is a reviewer for many international Journals. His current interest includes Techno-Economic Analysis of Broadband Wireless Networks viz. WiMAX-m, HSPA+ and LTE-Advanced. His future focus is to explore the Green Wireless Technologies and their Sustainable development. www.ijear.org International Journal of Education and Applied Research 61