Ocean Observatories Initiative Schedule of Construction Project Management and Control Anthony Ferlaino OOI Project Manager Science Community Workshop I Baltimore, Nov 11-12, 2009
Process Controls of a Large Facilities Project Scope Work Breakdown Structure Resources and Materials Time Phasing Integrated Schedule Funding Budget Program Policies and Procedures Change Control Construction Science Community Workshop 1 2
OOI Scope Science Community Workshop 1 3
Science Community Workshop 1 4
Summary WBS Level 3 OOI Master Program Schedule WBS: 1 System Integration Cyberinfrastructure Coastal / Global Observatory OOI_RSN Education And Public Engagement WBS: 1.1 WBS: 1.2 WBS: 1.3 WBS: 1.4 WBS: 1.7 Project Management Project Management Project Management Project Management Project Management WBS: 1.1.1 WBS: 1.2.1 WBS: 1.3.1 WBS: 1.4.1 WBS: 1.7.1 Systems Engineering WBS: 1.1.2 Systems Engineering WBS: 1.2.2 Systems Engineering WBS: 1.3.2 Systems Engineering WBS: 1.4.2 Education System Engineering WBS: 1.7.2 Operations Planning WBS: 1.1.3 System Development WBS: 1.2.3 Subsystem Development WBS: 1.3.3 Subsystem Development WBS: 1.4.3 Education Tools Development WBS: 1.7.3 Education And Public Engagement WBS: 1.1.4 Implementation WBS: 1.2.5 Implementation Site Implementation Implementation WBS: 1.3.4 WBS: 1.4.4 WBS: 1.7.4 Environmental Management WBS: 1.1.5 Science Community Workshop 1 5
WBS as an Integrator Science Community Workshop 1 6
Policies, Process, Plans and Tools Systems Engineering Management Plan Configuration Management Plan Risk Management Plan Earned Value Management Plan Schedule Management Plan Cost Book Database, Cost Estimating Plan Property Management Plan Collaborative Tools Confluence, WebEx Alfresco JIRA Subversion DOORS Science Community Workshop 1 7
Program Controlled Documents 1000 00000_CMP_OOI 1000 00001_B2_Table 1001 00000_PEP_OOI 1001 00100_Annual_Work_Plan 1002 00000_CEP_OOI 1003 00000_QA_QC_Plan_OOI 1004 00000_Commissioning_Plan_OOI 1005 00000_EVM_Plan_OOI 1006 00000_EHSP_OOI 1007 00000_Risk_Management_Plan_OOI 1008 00000_Acquisition_Plan_OOI 1010 00000_OM_Plan_OOI.doc 1011 00000_Property_Management_Plan_OOI 1012 00000_Security_Management_Plan_OOI 1020 00000_Schedule_Management_Plan_OOI Integrated Risk Register_(all1022 xxxxx) IMS (all IOs OOI, CI, RSN, CGSN) WBS_Dictionary_(all1041 xxxxx) Cost_Book_(all1050 xxxxx) L4 RSN Primary Infrastructure L4 RSN Profilers L4 RSN Shore Station 1100 00000_SEMP_OOI 1101 00000_FND_OOI 1120 00000_Requirements_Module_Hierarchy 1199 00000_Document_Tree_OOI L1 Programmatic Requirements L1 Science Themes L2 Common Requirements L2 Cyber User Requirements L2 Educational Requirements L2 Operational Requirements L2 Reference Module L2 Science Questions L2 Science Requirements L3 CG System Requirements L3 CI System Requirements L3 RSN System Requirements L4 RSN LV Node L4 RSN Observatory Mgmt System L4 RSN Vertical Mooring L4 CG Autonomous Underwater Vehicle L4 CG Data Concentrator L4 CG Glider L4 CG Instrument Package L4 CG Moorings L4 CG Multi Function Nodes L4 CG Operations and Management Center L4 CG Platform Control L4 CG Power Systems L4 CG Profiler L4 CG Surface Buoys L4 CG Telemetry Systems L4 CI Analysis and Synthesis L4 CI Common Execution Infrastructure L4 CI Common Operating Infrastructure L4 CI Data Management L4 CI Implementation L4 CI Planning and Prosecution L4 CI Sensing and Acquisition L4 RSN Backhaul L4 RSN Extension Cable L4 RSN Instrument Package L4 RSN Jbox Science Community Workshop 1 8
Construction Build Something Already! Science Community Workshop 1 9
Systems Engineering V Model Iteration N Iteration 2 Iteration 1 Acquirer Needs & Expectations Iteration N Iteration 2 Iteration 1 OOI Commissioning Acquirer Requirements Validation End Product Formal Acceptance Testing (Requirements Validation Processes) Other Stakeholder Requirements System Technical Requirements Verification System-of-Systems Integration & Test System Integration & Test OL IOs Decomposition &Definition Logical Solution Representations Physical Solution Representations Specified Requirements Verification Software & Hardware Implementation Subsystem Integration & Test Element Integration & Testing Integration & Verification Acquisition & Supply / Technical Management / Technical Evaluation Science Community Workshop 1 10
Progressive Test and Acceptance Component Level Testing Connectors, LVNs, MVNs, AUVs, Gliders, Sensors, FATs, etc. Subsystem / System Integration Tests (Hardware/Software) Software functionality Control and Data integration, Data throughput, Data quality FATs Sub-System / System Readiness Testing Primary and Secondary Infrastructure inspections and tests Software release testing AUVs, Gliders etc. FATs System Acceptance Tests (Transfer of Ownership) Primary/secondary Infrastructure with nodes, software and communications Buoys, moorings, sensors, equipment and software and telecommunication Pioneer and Endurance buoys, moorings, sensors equipment, software and communications Shore stations Culminate in Commissioning at Array Level Acceptance transfers property ownership to OL Begin Operations domain control of systems Starts insurance Science Community Workshop 1 11
Progressive Test and Acceptance System Acceptance Tests (Transfer of Ownership) Primary/secondary Infrastructure with nodes, software and communications Buoys, moorings, sensors, equipment and software and telecommunication Pioneer and Endurance buoys, moorings, sensors equipment, software and communications Shore stations Providing Data As Available Subject to Testing Needs Demonstration of Integrated Steady-State Capabilities Culminate in Commissioning at Array Level Acceptance transfers property ownership to OL Full Support and Logistics Systems Available and Operating Begin Operations Domain control of systems Starts insurance Available for Science Community Workshop 1 12
Configuration Management Standards and Conventions Naming, Numbering, Drawing Responsibilities and Authority Controlled vs Non-controlled Details on Technical Documents Document Management, Types, Stages Collaboration Applications Configuration Control Structure and Process. Change Control Boards (CCB) IO Change Control Board System Level Change Control Board OOI Change Control Board Science Community Workshop 1 13
CCB Benefits Use change control process to manage to project baselines, requirements, guiding principles (hierarchical decision tree) The CCB process is required to ensure product quality, schedule, budget and business commitments Controlled process to estimate Impact of changes Communication that authorizes changes to a baseline release Science Community Workshop 1 14
Classes of Changes Class I Changes: Change to a controlled design document, controlled policy/plan document, statement of work or contract and one or more of the following statements apply: Affects any physical or functional requirement in approved configuration Affects any approved functional, allocated or product configuration documentation, cost, warranties, or contract milestones, Affects approved product configuration documentation and one or more of the following: safety, correction of a hazard or conformance to applicable design standards, compatibility, interoperability, interfaces, or logistic support, retrofit of tested or delivered units, interchangeability, substitutability, or replace ability of any item down to non-repairable subassemblies, sources on a source control drawing Affects system configuration to the extent that retrofit (replacement of components) action would be taken on a formally tested or commissioned component. Science Community Workshop 1 15
Classes of Changes Class II Changes: Change to a controlled item and not categorized as class 1, such as: Cost of change is below specified threshold EVM items, Task level or lower, under the management of a CAM Correction of typographical errors Science Community Workshop 1 16
Board Levels IO Level System Level Interfaces with other subsystems/systems or IOs OOI Level Science Scope, Baseline Budget / Schedule NSF Program Manager Review CA and CSA Thresholds Each with specified core membership, authority and reporting structure Science Community Workshop 1 17
Construction Build Something Already! Really! Science Community Workshop 1 18
Schedule Graphic Science Community Workshop 1 19
Schedule Graphic Science Community Workshop 1 20
Schedule Graphic Science Community Workshop 1 21
Schedule Graphic Science Community Workshop 1 22
Construction The Beginning. Science Community Workshop 1 23