ENTERPRISE RISK MANAGEMENT IN INSURANCE GROUPS: MEASURING RISK CONCENTRATION AND DEFAULT RISK
|
|
- Sherilyn Tate
- 8 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 ETERPRISE RISK MAAGEMET I ISURACE GROUPS: MEASURIG RISK COCETRATIO AD DEFAULT RISK ADIE GATZERT HATO SCHMEISER STEFA SCHUCKMA WORKIG PAPERS O RISK MAAGEMET AD ISURACE O. 35 EDITED BY HATO SCHMEISER CHAIR FOR RISK MAAGEMET AD ISURACE FEBRUARY 2007
2 ETERPRISE RISK MAAGEMET I ISURACE GROUPS: MEASURIG RISK COCETRATIO AD DEFAULT RISK adne Gatzert Hato Schmeser Stefan Schuckmann JEL Classfcaton: G22, G28, G32 ABSTRACT In fnancal conglomerates and nsurance groups, enterprse rsk management s becomng ncreasngly mportant n controllng and managng the dfferent ndependent legal enttes n the group. The am of ths paper s to assess and relate rsk concentraton and jont default probabltes of the group s legal enttes n order to acheve a more comprehensve pcture of an nsurance group s rsk stuaton. We further examne the mpact of the type of dependence structure on results by comparng lnear and nonlnear dependences usng dfferent copula concepts under certan dstrbutonal assumptons. Our results show that even f fnancal groups wth dfferent dependence structures do have the same rsk concentraton factor, jont default probabltes of dfferent sets of subsdares can vary tremendously.. ITRODUCTIO Durng the last several years, there has been a trend toward consoldaton (M&A actvtes) n the fnancal sector of many countres (see Amel, Barnes, Panetta, and Salleo, 2004). Regulatory authortes, as well as ratng agences, are concerned wth new types of rsk and rsk concentratons arsng n fnancal conglomerates and wth how to properly assess them n group supervson (for the European Unon, see, e.g., CEIOPS, 2006). In ths context, enterprse rsk management (ERM) has become ncreasngly mportant. ERM takes a comprehensve vew of rsk and helps manage rsks n a holstc and consstent way (CAS, 2003). The am of ths paper s to provde a detaled and more comprehensve The authors are wth the Unversty of St. Gallen, Insttute of Insurance Economcs, Krchlstrasse 2, 900 St. Gallen, Swtzerland, E-Mal: nadne.gatzert@unsg.ch, hato.schmeser@unsg.ch, stefan.schuckmann@unsg.ch.
3 2 pcture of an nsurance group s rsk stuaton by assessng and relatng the rsk concentraton and jont default probabltes of ts legal enttes. We further examne the mpact of the type of dependence structure on results by comparng lnear and nonlnear dependences usng the concept of copulas. Determnaton of the rsk concentratons of an nsurance group can be based on an analyss of dversfcaton effects at a corporate level snce dversfcaton s the opposte of concentraton. In partcular, rsk concentratons, lke nterdependences or accumulaton, reduce dversfcaton effects. The dversfcaton effect s measured wth the economc captal of an aggregated rsk portfolo, whch mplctly reles on the assumpton that dfferent legal enttes are merged nto one. An essental aspect n aggregatng rsks s modelng the dependence structure usng lnear and nonlnear dependences. Copula theory can be used to model nonlnear dependences n extreme events and to test the fnancal stablty of a conglomerate structure. There has been steady growth n research on the applcaton of copula theory to rsk management. Embrechts, Mcel, and Straumann (2002) ntroduce copulas n fnance theory and analyze the effect of dependence structures on value at rsk. L (2000) apples copulas to the valuaton of credt dervatves. Frey and Mcel (200) model dependent defaults n credt portfolos, wth a specal emphass on tal dependences. An ntroducton to the use of copulas n the actuaral context can be found n Frees and Valdez (998) and Embrechts, Lndskog, and Mcel (2003). A central aspect of ERM s the aggregaton of dfferent types of rsk to calculate the economc captal necessary as a buffer aganst adverse outcomes. Wang (998, 2002) gves an overvew on the theoretcal background of economc captal modelng, rsk aggregaton, and the use of copula theory n enterprse rsk management. Kurtzkes, Schuermann, and Wener (2003) aggregate rsks at dfferent levels of a fnancal holdng company under the assumpton of jont normalty; n an emprcal study, they compute the relatve dversfcaton effect for several conglomerates. Ward and Lee (2002) use a normal copula approach to aggregate the rsks of a dversfed nsurer n a combned analytcal and smulaton model. Dmakos and Aas (2004) apply a smlar method to model total economc captal, and combne rsks by parwse aggregaton; they present a pract-
4 3 cal approach to estmate the jont loss dstrbuton of a orwegan bank and a orwegan lfe nsurance company. Favre (2003) models the overall loss dstrbuton for a four-lnes-of-busness nsurance company and examnes the nfluence of dfferent types of copulas on the value at rsk and the company s default probablty. Tang and Valdez (2006) smulate the economc captal requrements for a multlne nsurer, takng nto account dfferent types of dstrbutons and dfferent types of copulas; the resultng values for economc captal are used to compute absolute dversfcaton benefts. Rosenberg and Schuermann (2006) relax the jont normalty assumpton and use copula theory to aggregate rsks wth nonnormal margnals; they analyze the nfluence of the busness mx between credt, market, and operatonal rsk on value at rsk and calculate dversfcaton benefts by comparng the value at rsk of the dversfed conglomerate wth the stand-alone value at rsk. However, most of the lterature does not take nto account the specal rsk profle of fnancal conglomerates that arses from the group-holdng structure. Fnancal conglomerates or nsurance groups consst of several ndependent legal enttes, each wth lmted lablty. In the European Unon, for example, combnng bankng and nsurance actvtes n the same legal entty s prohbted (see Artcle 6(b) of the Lfe Insurance Drectve 2002/83/EC and Artcle 8(b) of the on- Lfe Insurance Drectve 73/239/EEC). Artcle 8() of the Lfe Insurance Drectve prohbts the combnaton of lfe and non-lfe busness n the same legal entty. Hence, where such s even lawful, a transfer of funds between dfferent legal enttes n case of an nsolvency of one entty occurs only f a transfer-of-losses contract has been sgned or f the management of the corporate group decdes n favor of cross-subsdzaton (e.g., for reputatonal reasons). Snce the contractng party s usually not the whole group, but a sngle subsdary. In prncple, the structure of an nsurance group s not mportant to those buyng nsurance from the subsdary n respect to the nsurer s default rsk. Thus, generally, for polcyholders and other debt holders, only the default rsk of ndvdual legal enttes and ther ablty to meet outstandng labltes are of relevance when there s no transfer-of-losses contract between members of the group. However, for the executve board of the nsurance group and for shareholders, nformaton on dversfcaton and thus on rsk concentraton and jont default probabltes s mportant when consderng the rsk profle of the
5 4 conglomerate for ERM. Informaton on rsk concentraton may also be helpful n obtanng a certan ratng level from a ratng agency. From the perspectve of regulatory agences, rsk concentraton nformaton can be valuable n analyzng systemc rsk of nsolvency. The default of a whole fnancal group wll, n general, have a stronger mpact on fnancal markets than the default of a sngle subsdary company. Ths paper extends prevous lterature by analyzng rsk concentratons n an nsurance group and by concurrently reportng jont default probabltes for sets of legal enttes wthn a fnancal conglomerate. otng that jont default probabltes only depend on ndvdual default probabltes and the couplng dependence structure, we further study the nfluence of dfferent dependence structures usng the concept of copulas. In partcular, we consder an nsurance group wth three legal enttes and compare results for Gauss, Gumbel, and Clayton copulas for normal and nonnormal margnal dstrbutons. Our results demonstrate that even f dfferent dependence structures mply the same rsk concentraton factor for the fnancal group, jont default probabltes of dfferent sets of subsdares can vary tremendously wth the dependence structure. The analyss shows that the smultaneous consderaton of rsk concentraton and default probabltes can provde nformaton of substantal value. The remander of the paper s organzed as follows. Secton 2 ntroduces the concept of dversfcaton on economc captal and rsk concentraton of a fnancal conglomerate. Dependence structures are presented n Secton 3, ncludng lnear and nonlnear dependences modeled wth copulas. In the numercal analyss, Secton 4, we compare results for Gauss, Gumbel, and Clayton copulas under dfferent dstrbutonal assumptons. Secton 5 summarzes the fndngs. 2. RISK COCETRATIO AD DEFAULT RISK Ths secton descrbes, frst, a framework for measurng rsk concentratons by calculatng the dversfcaton effect on the economc captal of an nsurance group, assumng that the dfferent legal enttes are merged. The economc captal s the amount necessary to buffer aganst unexpected losses from busness actvtes so as to prevent default at a specfc rsk tolerance level for a fxed tme horzon. Dversfcaton s generally ntended to reduce the overall rsk level n an n-
6 5 surance group and thus acts to allevate the dangers nherent n rsk concentraton. Calculatng rsk concentraton n an nsurance group can thus be based on an examnaton of dversfcaton effects at the group level. In a second step, the jont default probabltes of legal enttes wthn a conglomerate are ntroduced. We focus on an nsurance group wth a holdng structure and dfferent companes (legal enttes) wth lmted lablty. Generally, such a conglomerate s subject to market rsks, credt rsks, underwrtng rsks, and operatonal rsks. If each member of the group s faced wth dentcal rsks, one would expect the stochastc labltes of the dfferent enttes to be hghly correlated. Ths wll usually be the case f several frms of the same type, for example, fnancal frms, form a group. However, f the corporate group s composed of companes from wdely dfferent ndustres, the labltes between the dfferent legal enttes mght be rather uncorrelated. In what follows, we wll consder an nsurance group consstng of a bank, a lfe nsurer, and a non-lfe nsurer. In our framework, the equty value of each subsdary legal entty s modeled at two ponts n tme (t = 0, ). The value of the assets (labltes) at tme t = of company s defned as A ( L ). Debt and equty captal n t = 0 s nvested n rskless assets, leadng to a determnstc cash flow for the assets n t =, whereas labltes pad out n t = are modeled stochastcally. Stand-alone economc captal The amount of necessary economc captal depends on the specfc rsk tolerance level and on the measure chosen to evaluate corporate rsk. In the followng, we determne the necessary amount of captal usng the default probablty. The default probablty α of each legal entty can be wrtten as ( < ) =. P A L α In the next step, the nvested assets A are dvded nto two parts the expected value of the labltes E( L ) and the economc captal EC : ( ( ) ) ( ) P E L + EC < L = α ( ) α. P L E L > EC = ()
7 6 Hence, gven a probablty dstrbuton for the labltes and a certan safety level α, the economc captal EC can be derved. The necessary economc captal EC for dfferent legal enttes wthn an nsurance group can be calculated by ( ) ( ) EC = VaR α L E L =,,. (2) For consstency, all companes wthn the conglomerate should have the same safety level α. Therefore, value at rsk (VaR) s defned by { } ( ) ( ) nf ( ) VaRα L = F α = x F x α, where Aggregaton L L F L stands for the dstrbuton functon of the labltes for company. Assumng that the several companes n the nsurance group are merged nto one company (full lablty between legal enttes), the necessary economc captal for the safety level α on an aggregate level for L can be wrtten as aggr = α = = EC VaR L E L =. (3) To calculate the quantle n Equaton (3), nformaton about the cumulatve dstrbuton of the labltes s needed. Closed-form solutons for L = can be derved only for a lmted number of dstrbutons. In the case of a normal dstrbuton, only the varance of the portfolo s needed to determne the aggregate economc captal EC aggr. If no closed-form soluton can be obtaned, the quantle of the dstrbuton of the aggregate labltes L = can be estmated usng ether numercal smulaton technques or analytcal approxmatons (for an overvew, see Daykn, Pentkanen, and Pesonen, 994, pp. 9 ff.). Dversfcaton versus concentraton Gven Equatons (2) and (3), dversfcaton can be measured wth the rato of aggregated economc captal to the sum of stand-alone economc captal (see, e.g., Kurtzkes, Schuermann, and Wener, 2003),
8 7 d = EC = aggr EC. (4) In the case of lnear dependences, the factor d takes on values between zero and one and can be used to compare the level of rsk concentraton n conglomerates. A value of one corresponds to perfect correlaton, whch means that there would be no dversfcaton benefts f the dfferent legal enttes merged nto one company. When rsk factors are less than perfectly correlated, some of the rsk can be dversfed. Absolute measures for dversfcaton can be found n the lterature (see, e.g., Tang and Valdez, 2006); however, absolute measures do not allow the comparson of companes and conglomerates that are of dfferent szes. Gven a benchmark company, a hgher value of d mples possble rsk concentraton, snce lower values of d mean a hgher dversfcaton and thus a lower rsk concentraton. We henceforth refer to the coeffcent n Equaton (4) as the rsk concentraton factor. To keep the dfferent quanttes n Equaton (4) comparable, t s mportant to use the same rsk measure and the same tme horzon for all legal enttes when calculatng the economc captal. Generally, dversfcaton of the group s of no relevance to debt holders of the group s ndvdual companes (e.g., polcyholders n the case of an nsurance group) snce the whole group s not the contractng party, that s, the contract s between the polcyholder and the nsurance subsdary only (although there mght be transfer-of-loss contracts). However, for management and shareholders of the corporate group, nformaton about rsk concentraton n the dfferent sectors s of hgh mportance. Determnaton of default probabltes Even though calculaton of the dversfcaton factor may enable the detecton of rsk concentratons wthn the conglomerate, the factor s n most cases only a hypothetcal number snce ndvdual legal enttes generally do not (fully) cover the losses of the other enttes. To obtan further nsght about the conglomerate s rsk stuaton, jont default probabltes are approprate and can provde addtonal and valuable nformaton.
9 8 In contrast to the determnaton of the rsk concentraton factor, whch requres a convoluton over dfferent enttes L =, default probabltes make use of only the jont dstrbuton functon. To determne the jont default probablty of two or more legal enttes, the jont cumulatve dstrbuton functon s needed. For the case of a conglomerate comprsed of three legal enttes, the jont default probabltes of exactly one, two, and three legal enttes are gven by ( ) P = P L A, L A, L A P P, ( j j k k ) P2 = P L > A, L > A, L A, j k, (,, ) P = P L > A L > A L > A It s assumed that no transfer of losses between companes wll occur. 3. MODELIG THE DEPEDECE STRUCTURE In rsk management, approprate modelng of dependence structures s very mportant. One recommendaton n the lterature s to apply copulas n addton to lnear correlaton to ensure an adequate mappng of dependence (see Embrechts, Mcel, and Straumann, 2002). Copulas allow for the ncluson of features such as fat tals and skewness for nonellptcally dstrbuted rsks. In ths secton, frst, the concept of copulas s presented n regard to modelng nonlnear dependences. Second, lnear correlatons are dscussed as a specal case, whch further allows for a closed-form soluton for economc captal f labltes are normally dstrbuted. 3.. Copulas For contnuous multvarate dstrbuton functons, copulas serve to separate the unvarate margns and the multvarate dependence structure. The copula C represents the dependence structure and couples the margnal dstrbutons to a jont multvarate dstrbuton. Let the random varables X (wth =,..., ) have (contnuous) margnal dstrbuton functons F. From Sklar s theorem t follows that (see elsen, 999, p. 5)
10 9 ( <,..., < ) = X ( ),..., X,..., = C F ( x ) F ( x ) P X x X x F x x ( X X ),...,. For jont default probabltes, ths result mples that for fxed ndvdual default probabltes ( ) P X < 0 = α, =,...,, one can obtan for the jont default probablty of all enttes ( < 0,..., < 0) = ( 0,...,0) P X X FX,..., X = C( F ( 0 ),..., ( 0 ) X FX ) = C( α,..., α). (5) Hence, the jont default probablty depends on the dependence structure expressed by the copula C and on the margnal default probabltes α. In our case, these quanttes are gven and fxed snce the economc captal for each entty s adjusted for each entty such that the margnal default probabltes reman constant. For example, n the case of the three enttes consdered here, the probablty that legal entty and 2 default, and entty 3 survves s ( ) ( ( ) ( ) ( ) X X X X X ) ( < < > ) = ( ) ( ) = C( α α ) C( α α α ) P X 0, X 0, X 0 C F 0, F 0, C F 0, F 0, F ,,,, The probablty of default for exactly two legal enttes can thus be calculated by 2 ( 0, 0, 0, j k ) ( α α ) ( α α ) ( α α ) ( α α α ) P = P X < X < X > j k = C,, + C,, + C,, 3 C,, (6) Furthermore, the probablty that exactly one company defaults s determned by ( ) P = P X > 0 =,2,3 P P (7) 2 3 where
11 0 ( ) ( ) P = P X < 0, X < 0, X < 0 = C α, α, α. (8) In the analyss, we wll compare several copulas. To obtan boundares, we nclude the case of ndependence and perfect dependence (comonotoncty), represented by the copula (Mcel, Frey, and Embrechts, 2005, p. 89) (,..., ) mn {,..., } M u u = u u. The ndependence copula s gven by (Mcel, Frey, and Embrechts, 2005, p. 89) (,..., ) Π u u = u. = The default probablty for all three enttes s thus the product of the margnal default probabltes. From Equatons (6) (8), t follows that n the case of ndependence the default probabltes of exactly one, two, and three companes are ( α ) ( α ) ( α ) P = P P P = α α + α α + α α 3 α α α P3 = α α2 α3. The two most common Archmedan copulas, Clayton and Gumbel, are used to model the dependence structure between the enttes. These are explct copulas that have closed-form solutons and are not derved from multvarate dstrbuton functons as s the mplct Gaussan copula. In general, an -dmensonal Archmedan copula may be constructed by usng the respectve generator Φ ( t) (,..., ) ( ( )... ( )) C u u =Φ Φ u + +Φ u, whch must have certan propertes (as descrbed n Mcel, Frey, and Embrechts, 2005, p. 222). In the case of the -dmensonal Clayton copula, the generator and ts nverse are gven by (see Wu, Valdez, and Sherrs, 2006, p. 7)
12 () t ( t θ ) Φ = and () t ( t ) / θ Φ = θ +, θ whch leads to the followng representaton / θ Cl θ C, ( u,..., u ) = u θ +, = where 0 θ <. For θ, one obtans perfect dependence; θ 0 mples ndependence (Mcel, Frey, and Embrechts, 2005, p. 223). For the -dmensonal Gumbel copula, the generator and ts nverse are gven by (Wu, Valdez, and Sherrs, 2006, p. 7) ( ) θ / θ Φ () t = log() t and Φ ( t) = exp( t ), whch mples the expresson / θ Gu θ Cθ, ( u,..., u) = exp ( logu) =, where θ. For θ, one obtans perfect dependence; θ mples ndependence (Mcel, Frey, and Embrechts, 2005, p. 220). Both Clayton and Gumbel copulas exhbt asymmetres n the dependence structure. The Clayton copula s lower tal dependent; the Gumbel copula s upper tal dependent The specal case of lnear dependence Lnear dependence s a specal case of the copula concept. If X s a multvarate Gaussan random vector, then ts copula s a so-called Gauss copula (Mcel, Frey, and Embrechts, 2005, p. 9) ( ) (,..., ) ( ),..., ( ) C u u =Φ Φ u Φ u, Ga R where R s the correlaton matrx, Φ denotes the standard unvarate standard normal dstrbuton functon, and Φ denotes the jont dstrbuton functon of X. The Gauss copula measures the degree of monotonc dependence and has no
13 2 closed-form soluton, only an ntegral representaton. The copula may be constructed by the nverse method, whch maps lnear dependence n the form of the lnear correlaton of ranks, as descrbed by Iman and Conover (982) and by Embrechts, Mcel, and Straumann (2002). The use of rank correlatons ensures the exstence of a multvarate dstrbuton wth the prescrbed margnals. Gven lnear correlatons ρ ( X, X j), Spearman s rank correlaton matrx for the Gauss copula can be derved from (Mcel, Frey, and Embrechts, 2005, p. 25) ρ ( X, X ) = 2 sn (, j ρ X X S j) π 6. (9) If the jont dstrbuton s a multvarate normal wth standard normal margnals, the economc captal EC for each entty can be calculated by (see, e.g., Hull, 2003, pp. 350 ff.) ( ) EC = σ L z α, (0) where z α denotes the α-quantle of the standard normal dstrbuton and σ stands for the standard devaton. To aggregate the economc captal under the assumpton that all sectors are carred n one company, correlatons between the labltes of the dfferent enttes are needed. The symmetrc correlaton matrx R wth coeffcents ρ j between the labltes of entty and entty j s gven by ρ ρ 2 ρ ρ 2 2 R =. ρ ρ 2 The correspondng entres n the covarance matrx Σ are gven by Σ j = ρj σ ( L ) σ( Lj ) and the standard devaton of the portfolo of the labltes L = L can be calculated by = σ ( L) j. (), j= = Σ
14 3 The aggregated economc captal, assumng that all sectors n the nsurance group are merged, can be calculated from ( ) EC σ L z aggr α =. (2) Equaton (2) can be reformulated usng Equaton () to obtan the followng formula (see Kurtzkes, Schuermann, and Wener, 2003; Groupe Consultatf, 2005): ( ) α α α ( ) α ( ) EC = σ L z = Σ z = z σ L ρ z σ L aggr j j j, j=, j= = EC ρ EC, j= j j (3) T EC ρ2 ρ EC EC2 ρ2 ρ2 EC2 =. EC ρ ρ EC 2 Equaton (3) llustrates that the effect of dversfcaton on the aggregated economc captal EC aggr depends on the number of legal enttes, the relatve porton of the economc captal of the ndvdual companes EC, and the correlaton between the labltes of the dfferent companes. One way to calculate economc captal for lablty dstrbutons that are not normally dstrbuted s to use analytcal approxmaton methods such as the normalpower concept (see, e.g., Daykn, Pentkanen, and Pesonen, 994, pp. 29 ff.). 4. UMERICAL EXAMPLES In ths secton we present numercal examples n order to examne the nfluence of the dependence structure (nonlnear vs. lnear dependence) and the dstrbutonal assumptons (normal vs. non-normal) on rsk concentraton and default probabltes. Frst, the case of lnear dependence s presented for normally and non-normally dstrbuted labltes wth dfferent szes. Second, nonlnear dependences are examned for normalty and non-normalty.
15 4 Table sets out the nput parameters that are the bass for the numercal examples analyzed n ths secton. The values and dstrbutons are chosen to llustrate central effects. TABLE Economc captal for ndvdual enttes n an nsurance group for dfferent dstrbutonal assumptons gven a default probablty α = 0.50% and E( L ) = 00, =, 2, 3. Legal entty Dstrbuton type Case (A) Case (B) normal σ ( L ) EC ( ) EC σ L Bank ormal Lfe nsurer ormal on-lfe nsurer ormal Sum non-normal Bank ormal Lfe nsurer Lognormal on-lfe nsurer Gamma Sum Table contans values for two dfferent cases, (A) and (B), for normally and non-normally dstrbuted labltes. The gven default probablty of 0.50% s adapted to Solvency II regulatory requrements, whch are currently beng debated (European Commsson, 2005). For normally dstrbuted labltes, economc captal can be calculated usng Equaton (0) wth a standard normal quantle of z α = The conglomerate under consderaton conssts of a bank, a lfe nsurance company, and a non-lfe nsurer. In case (A), the labltes of all three enttes have the same standard devaton and thus requre the same economc captal. In case (B), the bank has a substantally hgher standard devaton than the nsurance enttes. Accordngly, the resultng economc captal dffers. We next change the dstrbuton assumpton to allow for non-normalty. ow, only the labltes of company (Bank) are normally dstrbuted, whereas the labltes of company 2 (Lfe Insurer) and company 3 (on-lfe Insurer) follow, respectvely, a lognormal and a gamma dstrbuton. To keep the cases compara-
16 5 ble, the expected value µ and standard devaton σ reman fxed. In the case of lognormal (a, b) dstrbuton, the parameters can be calculated by 2 a = ln ( µ ) b / 2 and b 2 = ln ( + σ 2 / µ 2 ) (Casella and Berger, 2002, p. 09). For 2 2 gamma dstrbuton (α, β), the parameters are gven by α = µ / σ and β = σ 2 / µ (Casella and Berger, 2002, pp ). The assumpton of non-normal dstrbutons leads to dfferent ndvdual economc captal values n case (A) and case (B) compared to the values under the normalty assumpton. As a result, the sum of the ndvdual economc captal (26.70 n case (A) and 7.09 n case (B)) dffers also (5.9 for both cases under the normalty assumpton). The numercal analyss proceeds as follows. Frst, we calculate the necessary aggregated economc captal based on the value at rsk at the group level for a confdence level α= 0.50% (Equaton (3)). The concentraton factor can then be derved usng the stand-alone economc captal of the legal enttes gven n Table by way of Equaton (4). Subsequently, we calculate the correspondng default probabltes P, P 2, P umercal results for lnear dependence To calculate the necessary economc captal at the group level, the correlaton matrx for the labltes s needed. Estmaton of dependences can be made on the bass of macroeconomc models. For nstance, Estrella (200) derves correlatons from stock market returns to measure possble dversfcaton effects between the bank and nsurance sectors. To obtan more comprehensve nformaton on the rsk stuaton of conglomerate under consderaton (see Table ), we compare the effect of dstrbutonal assumptons on the concentraton factor and default probabltes. Fgure shows a plot of the default probabltes for dfferent choces of the correlaton matrx wth ncreasng dependency and the correspondng concentraton factors for dfferent dstrbutonal assumptons. In partcular, we compare the cases (A) and (B) gven n Table when labltes follow a normal dstrbuton (normal) and when they are partly nonnormally dstrbuted (non-normal). For ease of exposton we use the same coeffcent of correlaton ρ between the labltes of all enttes,.e.,
17 6 ( j) ρ L, L = ρ, j. Fgure shows how the concentraton factor and nformaton on default probabltes can complement each other. Part a) llustrates that the jont default probabltes depend on the dependence structure between the legal enttes and ndvdual default probabltes. Hence, for normal and non-normal dstrbutons, the jont default probabltes reman unchanged, whereas the concentraton factor can dffer substantally. In the case of ndependence, jont default probabltes of two and three companes are (approxmately) zero n the example consdered and only ndvdual default occurs wthn the group. Wth ncreasng dependence, the probablty of a sngle default (P ) decreases, whle the probablty of combned defaults (P 2, P 3 ) ncreases. For hgher correlatons, the probablty of a combned default of two enttes (P 2 ) decreases agan. For perfectly correlated labltes, all three enttes default wth probablty 0.50%, whle P = P 2 = 0.
18 7 FIGURE Default probabltes and rsk concentraton factor for lnear dependence on the bass of Table. a) Jont default probabltes for lnear dependence.60%.40%.20%.00% 0.80% 0.60% 0.40% P P2 P3 0.20% 0.00% rho b) Rsk concentraton factor for lnear dependence 00% 90% 80% 70% normal, case (A) non-normal, case (A) normal, case (B) non-normal, case (B) 60% 50% rho otes: P = probablty that exactly one entty defaults; P 2 = probablty that exactly two enttes default; P 3 = probablty that all three enttes default. Part b) of Fgure llustrates that gven that the labltes have the same standard devatons (case (A)) the dstrbutonal assumpton has only margnal nfluence on the concentraton factor, but that dfferent correlaton factors and frm sze (case (B)) do matter. As an example, consder the case ρ = 0.3, mplyng a correlaton matrx
19 R = The correspondng concentraton factor can be derved usng Equaton (3). For normally dstrbuted labltes n case (A), the aggregated economc captal s A EC aggr = Ths s lower than the sum of stand-alone economc captal (5.9) due to dversfcaton effects. Hence, the concentraton factor s gven by d = 84.65/5.9 = 73.03%. Changng only the dstrbutonal assumpton to a non-normal dstrbuton leads to a lower value of d = 90.78/26.70 = 7.65%. Hence, the concentraton factor decreases n case of non-normal dstrbuton even though the aggregated economc captal ncreases to Ths llustrates that an absolute comparson of aggregated economc captal may be msleadng. The concentraton factor s very smlar to the results for the normal case, wth a dfference of only.38 percentage ponts, whch can be explaned by the calbraton of the dstrbutons. We calculated the parameters of the lognormal and gamma dstrbutons usng the same values for expected value and standard devaton so as to acheve better comparablty between dfferent stuatons. Hence, we can say that n the example gven the choce of a non-normal dstrbuton has very lttle mpact on concentraton factors. A much larger effect can be observed when comparng case (A) wth case (B). For normal dstrbuton, the concentraton factor for case (B) s d = 99.76/5.9 = 86.07%. Hence, ths stuaton leads to a hgher concentraton factor than case (A) (d = 73.03%). Thus, the stuaton gven n case (B) ndcates a possble exstence of rsk concentraton wthn the conglomerate, orgnatng from the bank. The bank s relatvely large rsk contrbuton to total group rsk causes a less effectve dversfcaton of rsks. Losses resultng from bankng actvtes n case (B) are less lkely to be compensated by good results from nsurance actvtes than n case (A). Thus the concentraton factor d s useful for examnng the exstence of rsk concentratons whenever a benchmark company s avalable. Overall, Fgure, part b) demonstrates that the dfference between the concentraton factors of cases (A) and (B) decreases wth ncreasng correlaton. In the
20 9 case of perfect postve correlaton, ρ =, the dfference vanshes and the concentraton factor takes on ts maxmum of 00%. Even though all four curves mply the same jont default probabltes, they have dfferent rsk concentraton factors. The dfferences n d result from changes n the amount of economc captal needed to retan a constant default probablty umercal results for nonlnear dependence In ths secton, we alter the assumpton for the dependence structure and examne the mpact of nonlnear dependences on rsk concentraton and jont default probabltes usng Clayton and Gumbel copulas as descrbed n Secton 3.. Both copulas are constructed usng Monte Carlo smulaton wth the same 200,000 paths so as to ncrease comparablty. The Clayton and Gumbel copulas are smulated usng the algorthms n Mcel, Frey, and Embrechts (2005, p. 224). The algorthm for the Gumbel copula uses postve stable varates, whch were generated wth a method proposed n olan (2005). umercal results for the Clayton and Gumbel copulas are llustrated n Fgures 2 and 3, respectvely. In both fgures, part a) dsplays default probabltes as a functon of the dependence parameter θ and part b) shows the correspondng concentraton factors. The ndependence copula marked as Π n the fgures serves as a lower boundary, whle the case of comonotoncty (M) represents perfect dependence and s thus an upper bound. At frst glance, both dependence structures n Fgures 2 and 3 appear to lead to smlar results as n the lnear case n Fgure. Overall, the probablty that any company defaults decreases wth ncreasng θ. As before, under perfect comonotoncty, all three enttes always become nsolvent at the same tme wth probablty 0.50%, whle the probablty for one or two defaulted companes s zero (P = P 2 = 0). In fact, n ths case, the concentraton factor exceeds 00% snce the value at rsk s not a subaddtve rsk measure (for a dscusson, see Embrechts, Mcel, and Straumann, 2002, p. 22).
21 20 FIGURE 2 Default probabltes and rsk concentraton factor for Clayton copula on the bass of Table. a) Jont default probabltes for Clayton copula.60%.40%.20%.00% 0.80% 0.60% 0.40% 0.20% 0.00% Π M theta P P2 P3 b) Rsk concentraton factor for Clayton copula 00% 90% 80% 70% normal, case (A) non-normal, case (A) normal, case (B) non-normal, case (B) 60% 50% Π M theta otes: P = probablty that exactly one entty defaults; P 2 = probablty that exactly two enttes default; P 3 = probablty that all three enttes default. A comparson of Fgures 2 and 3 reveals that the type of tal dependence (upper vs. lower) has a sgnfcant mpact on the partcular characterstcs of the jont default probabltes curves. In case of the upper tal dependent Gumbel copula, companes become nsolvent far more often, and hence the jont default probablty of all three enttes quckly approaches 0.50% n the lmt M. In contrast, the default probabltes of the lower tal dependent Clayton copula converge to 0.50% much more slowly. In fact, even for θ close to 20, the generaton of random numbers from the Clayton copula becomes ncreasngly dffcult, despte the fact that the jont default probablty of all three enttes s only 0.3%.
22 2 FIGURE 3 Default probabltes and rsk concentraton factor for Gumbel copula on the bass of Table. a) Jont default probabltes for Gumbel copula.60%.40%.20%.00% 0.80% 0.60% 0.40% P P2 P3 0.20% 0.00% Π M theta b) Rsk concentraton factor for Gumbel copula 00% 90% 80% 70% normal, case (A) non-normal, case (A) normal, case (B) non-normal, case (B) 60% 50% Π M theta otes: P = probablty that exactly one entty defaults; P 2 = probablty that exactly two enttes default; P 3 = probablty that all three enttes default. Even though results for default probabltes and concentraton factors under the Gauss, Gumbel, and Clayton copulas look very smlar at frst glance, they can dffer tremendously, whch wll be demonstrated n the next subsecton Comparng the mpact of nonlnear and lnear dependences To compare and dentfy the consderable effects of the underlyng dependence structures on default probabltes, we take examples from the Fgures, 2, and 3 that have the same concentraton factor, usng case (A) wth normally dstrbuted margnals so as to make the results comparable.
23 22 Two examples are presented n Fgure 4 for fxed concentraton factors of 90% n part a) and 99.40% n part b) from the Clayton, Gauss, and Gumbel copulas. The examples n each part of the fgure have the same concentraton factor and thus exhbt the same value at rsk. Although the compared companes have the same rsk, default probabltes dffer substantally wth the dependence structure. FIGURE 4 Comparson of jont default probabltes for one (P ), two (P 2 ), and three (P 3 ) companes for dfferent dependence structures; case (A), normal dstrbutons. a) Rsk concentraton factor d = 90%. Clayton (theta = 20) Gauss (rho = 0.7) P3 P2 P Gumbel (theta =.3) b) Rsk concentraton factor d = 99.40%. 0.00% 0.30% 0.60% 0.90%.20%.50% Clayton (theta = 20) Gauss (rho = 0.95) P3 P2 P Gumbel (theta = 3) 0.00% 0.30% 0.60% 0.90%.20%.50% otes: P = probablty that exactly one entty defaults; P 2 = probablty that exactly two enttes default; P 3 = probablty that all three enttes default. A comparson of parts a) and b) of Fgure 4 shows that the sum of default probabltes (= P + P 2 + P 3 ).e., the probablty that one, two, or three companes default s hgher for the lower concentraton factor d = 90%. Furthermore, for d = 99.40%, the parttonng between the three jont default probabltes (P, P 2, P 3 ) s shfted toward P 3, whle P decreases. Hence, a hgher concentraton factor
24 23 s accompaned by a lower sum of default probabltes, but nduces a sgnfcantly hgher jont default probablty of all three enttes. Fgure 4 demonstrates the consderable nfluence that the choce between Clayton, Gauss, and Gumbel copulas has on jont default probabltes. The Clayton copula leads to the hghest sum of default probabltes, but has the lowest probablty of default for all three companes (P 3 ). The other extreme occurs under the Gumbel copula, where P 3 s hghest and P takes the lowest value, whle the Gauss copula nduces values between those of the Clayton and Gumbel copulas. Our results show that even f dfferent dependence structures mply the same value at rsk and thus the same rsk concentraton factor, jont default probabltes can dffer tremendously. Furthermore, our analyss demonstrates that the smultaneous reportng of rsk concentraton factors and default probabltes can be of substantal value, especally for the management of the corporate group. By comparng lnear and nonlnear dependences, we found that the effect of msmodelng dependences may not only lead to sgnfcant dfferences n assessng rsk concentraton, but can also lead to msestmatng jont default probabltes. Hence, there s a substantal model rsk nvolved wth respect to dependence structures. 5. SUMMARY Ths paper assessed and related rsk concentratons and jont default probabltes of legal enttes n a conglomerate composed of three enttes, a bank, a lfe nsurance company, and a non-lfe nsurance company. Our procedure provded valuable nsght regardng the group s rsk stuaton, whch s hghly relevant for enterprse rsk management purposes. An nsurance group (a conglomerate) typcally conssts of several legally ndependent enttes, each wth lmted lablty. However, dversfcaton concepts assume that these enttes are fully lable and all together meet all outstandng labltes of each. Even f dversfcaton s of no mportance from a polcyholder perspectve, t s useful n determnng rsk concentraton n an nsurance group because greater dversfcaton generally mples less rsk. To determne default probabltes, we focused on the case of lmted lablty wthout transfer of losses between the dfferent legal enttes wthn the group.
25 24 Jont default probabltes only depend on ndvdual default probabltes and the couplng dependence structure. Hence, we studed the effect of dfferent dependence structures usng the concept of copulas. In the numercal analyss, we consdered an nsurance group comprsed of three legal enttes and compared results from the Gauss, Gumbel, and Clayton copulas for normal and non-normal margnal dstrbutons. Economc captal was adjusted for each stuaton to satsfy a fxed ndvdual default probablty. In contrast to the rsk concentraton factor, jont default probabltes only depend on ndvdual default probabltes and on the dependence structure, not on dstrbutonal assumptons. For all models, we found that the rsk concentraton factor and the jont default probablty of all three enttes ncrease wth ncreasng dependence between the enttes, whle the probablty of a sngle default decreases. Overall, the sum of default probabltes of one, two, or three enttes decreases wth ncreasng dependence. Furthermore, one entty s large rsk contrbuton, n terms of volatlty, led to a much hgher rsk concentraton factor for the group as a whole. Our fndngs further demonstrated that even f dfferent dependence structures mply the same rsk concentraton factor for the group, jont default probabltes for dfferent sets of subsdares can vary tremendously. In partcular, the lower tal dependent Clayton copula led to the lowest probablty of default for all three enttes, whle the upper tal dependent Gumbel copula exhbted the hghest default probablty. The analyss showed that a smultaneous consderaton of rsk concentraton factor and default probabltes can be of substantal value, especally for the management of the corporate group wth respect to enterprse rsk management.
26 25 REFERECES Amel, D., Barnes C., Panetta, F., and Salleo, C. (2004): Consoldaton and Effcency n the Fnancal Sector: A Revew of the Internatonal Evdence. Journal of Bankng & Fnance 28(0), CAS (2003): Overvew of Enterprse Rsk Management. Avalable at Casella, G., and Berger, R. L. (2002): Statstcal Inference. Duxbury Press, Pacfc Grove. CEIOPS (2006): Advce to the European Commsson n the Framework of the Solvency II Project on Sub-Group Supervson, Dversfcaton Effects, Cooperaton wth Thrd Countres and Issues Related to the MCR and SCR n a Group Context (CEIOPS-CP-05/06). Avalable at Daykn, C. D., Pentkanen, T., and Pesonen, M. (994): Practcal Rsk Theory for Actuares. Chapman & Hall, London. Dmakos, X. K., and Aas, K. (2004): Integrated Rsk Modellng. Statstcal Modellng 4(4), Embrechts, P., Lndskog, F., and Mcel, A. J. (2003): Modellng Dependence wth Copulas and Applcatons to Rsk Management. In Rachev, S. (ed.): Handbook of Heavy Taled Fnance, pp Elsever. Embrechts, P., Mcel, A., and Straumann, D. (2002): Correlaton and Dependence n Rsk Management: Propertes and Ptfalls. In Dempster M. A. H. (ed.): Rsk Management: Value at Rsk and Beyond, pp Cambrdge Unversty Press, Cambrdge. Estrella, A. (200): Mxng and Matchng: Prospectve Fnancal Sector Mergers and Market Caluaton. Journal of Bankng and Fnance 25(2), European Commsson (2005): Polcy Issues for Solvency II Possble Amendments to the Framework for Consultaton (Markt/2505/0). Brussels. Favre, F. (2003): Copula: A ew Vson for Economc Captal and Applcaton to a Four Lne of Busness Company. Paper presented at ASTI Colloquum, Berln.
27 26 Frees, E. W., and Valdez, E. V. (998): Understandng Relatonshps Usng Copulas. orth Amercan Actuaral Journal 2(), 25. Frey, R., and Mcel, A. J. (200): Modellng Dependent Defaults. ETH E-Collecton, Zürch. Avalable at Groupe Consultatf (2005): Dversfcaton Techncal Paper. Workng Group Group and Cross-Sectoral Consstency. Avalable at Hull, J. C. (2003): Optons, Futures and Other Dervatves. Pearson Educaton, Upper Saddle Rver, J. Iman, R. L., and Conover, W. (982): A Dstrbuton Free Approach to Inducng Rank Correlaton Among Input Varables. Communcatons n Statstcs Smulaton and Computaton, (3), Kurtzkes, A., Schuermann, T., and Wener, S. M. (2003): Rsk Measurement, Rsk Management and Captal Adequacy n Fnancal Conglomerates. In Brookngs-Wharton Papers on Fnancal Servces, pp L, D. X. (2000): On Default Correlaton: A Copula Functon Approach. Journal of Fxed Income 9(4), Mcel, A. J., Frey, R., and Embrechts, P. (2005): Quanttatve Rsk Management. Concepts, Technques, Tools. Prnceton Unversty Press, Prnceton, J. elsen, R. B. (999): An Introducton to Copulas. Sprnger, ew York. olan, J. P. (2005): Stable Dstrbutons: Models for Heavy Taled Data, forthcomng. Rosenberg, J., and Schuermann, T. (2006): A General Approach to Integrated Rsk Management wth Skewed, Fat-taled Rsks. Journal of Fnancal Economcs 79(3), Tang, A., and Valdez, E. A. (2006): Economc Captal and the Aggregaton of Rsks Usng Copula. Paper presented at the 28 th Internatonal Congress of Actuares, Pars. Avalable at Wang, S. (998): Aggregaton of Correlated Rsk Portfolos: Models and Algorthms. Proceedngs of the Casualty Actuaral Socety 85,
28 27 Wang, S. (2002): A Set of ew Methods and Tools for Enterprse Rsk Captal Management and Portfolo Optmzaton. In The Casualty Actuaral Socety Forum, Summer 2002, Dynamc Fnancal Analyss Dscusson Papers, pp Ward, L. S., and Lee, D. H. (2002): Practcal Applcaton of the Rsk Adjusted Return on Captal Framework. In The Casualty Actuaral Socety Forum, Summer 2002, Dynamc Fnancal Analyss Dscusson Papers, pp Wu, F., Valdez, E. A., and Sherrs, M. (2006): Smulatng Exchangeable Multvarate Archmedean Copulas and ts Applcatons. Workng Paper, Unversty of ew South Wales, Sydney.
THE DISTRIBUTION OF LOAN PORTFOLIO VALUE * Oldrich Alfons Vasicek
HE DISRIBUION OF LOAN PORFOLIO VALUE * Oldrch Alfons Vascek he amount of captal necessary to support a portfolo of debt securtes depends on the probablty dstrbuton of the portfolo loss. Consder a portfolo
More informationAnalysis of Premium Liabilities for Australian Lines of Business
Summary of Analyss of Premum Labltes for Australan Lnes of Busness Emly Tao Honours Research Paper, The Unversty of Melbourne Emly Tao Acknowledgements I am grateful to the Australan Prudental Regulaton
More informationbenefit is 2, paid if the policyholder dies within the year, and probability of death within the year is ).
REVIEW OF RISK MANAGEMENT CONCEPTS LOSS DISTRIBUTIONS AND INSURANCE Loss and nsurance: When someone s subject to the rsk of ncurrng a fnancal loss, the loss s generally modeled usng a random varable or
More informationCan Auto Liability Insurance Purchases Signal Risk Attitude?
Internatonal Journal of Busness and Economcs, 2011, Vol. 10, No. 2, 159-164 Can Auto Lablty Insurance Purchases Sgnal Rsk Atttude? Chu-Shu L Department of Internatonal Busness, Asa Unversty, Tawan Sheng-Chang
More informationVasicek s Model of Distribution of Losses in a Large, Homogeneous Portfolio
Vascek s Model of Dstrbuton of Losses n a Large, Homogeneous Portfolo Stephen M Schaefer London Busness School Credt Rsk Electve Summer 2012 Vascek s Model Important method for calculatng dstrbuton of
More informationAn Alternative Way to Measure Private Equity Performance
An Alternatve Way to Measure Prvate Equty Performance Peter Todd Parlux Investment Technology LLC Summary Internal Rate of Return (IRR) s probably the most common way to measure the performance of prvate
More informationTraffic-light a stress test for life insurance provisions
MEMORANDUM Date 006-09-7 Authors Bengt von Bahr, Göran Ronge Traffc-lght a stress test for lfe nsurance provsons Fnansnspetonen P.O. Box 6750 SE-113 85 Stocholm [Sveavägen 167] Tel +46 8 787 80 00 Fax
More informationPortfolio Loss Distribution
Portfolo Loss Dstrbuton Rsky assets n loan ortfolo hghly llqud assets hold-to-maturty n the bank s balance sheet Outstandngs The orton of the bank asset that has already been extended to borrowers. Commtment
More informationCourse outline. Financial Time Series Analysis. Overview. Data analysis. Predictive signal. Trading strategy
Fnancal Tme Seres Analyss Patrck McSharry patrck@mcsharry.net www.mcsharry.net Trnty Term 2014 Mathematcal Insttute Unversty of Oxford Course outlne 1. Data analyss, probablty, correlatons, vsualsaton
More informationCopulas. Modeling dependencies in Financial Risk Management. BMI Master Thesis
Copulas Modelng dependences n Fnancal Rsk Management BMI Master Thess Modelng dependences n fnancal rsk management Modelng dependences n fnancal rsk management 3 Preface Ths paper has been wrtten as part
More informationRisk Measurement and Management of Operational Risk in Insurance Companies from an Enterprise Perspective
FRIEDRICH-ALEXANDER UNIVERSITÄT ERLANGEN-NÜRNBERG RECHTS- UND WIRTSCHAFTS- WISSENSCHAFTLICHE FAKULTÄT Rsk Measurement and Management of Operatonal Rsk n Insurance Companes from an Enterprse Perspectve
More informationThe Development of Web Log Mining Based on Improve-K-Means Clustering Analysis
The Development of Web Log Mnng Based on Improve-K-Means Clusterng Analyss TngZhong Wang * College of Informaton Technology, Luoyang Normal Unversty, Luoyang, 471022, Chna wangtngzhong2@sna.cn Abstract.
More informationHow To Calculate The Accountng Perod Of Nequalty
Inequalty and The Accountng Perod Quentn Wodon and Shlomo Ytzha World Ban and Hebrew Unversty September Abstract Income nequalty typcally declnes wth the length of tme taen nto account for measurement.
More informationUnderwriting Risk. Glenn Meyers. Insurance Services Office, Inc.
Underwrtng Rsk By Glenn Meyers Insurance Servces Offce, Inc. Abstract In a compettve nsurance market, nsurers have lmted nfluence on the premum charged for an nsurance contract. hey must decde whether
More informationWhat is Candidate Sampling
What s Canddate Samplng Say we have a multclass or mult label problem where each tranng example ( x, T ) conssts of a context x a small (mult)set of target classes T out of a large unverse L of possble
More informationEfficient Project Portfolio as a tool for Enterprise Risk Management
Effcent Proect Portfolo as a tool for Enterprse Rsk Management Valentn O. Nkonov Ural State Techncal Unversty Growth Traectory Consultng Company January 5, 27 Effcent Proect Portfolo as a tool for Enterprse
More informationA Model of Private Equity Fund Compensation
A Model of Prvate Equty Fund Compensaton Wonho Wlson Cho Andrew Metrck Ayako Yasuda KAIST Yale School of Management Unversty of Calforna at Davs June 26, 2011 Abstract: Ths paper analyzes the economcs
More informationStatistical Methods to Develop Rating Models
Statstcal Methods to Develop Ratng Models [Evelyn Hayden and Danel Porath, Österrechsche Natonalbank and Unversty of Appled Scences at Manz] Source: The Basel II Rsk Parameters Estmaton, Valdaton, and
More informationStress test for measuring insurance risks in non-life insurance
PROMEMORIA Datum June 01 Fnansnspektonen Författare Bengt von Bahr, Younes Elonq and Erk Elvers Stress test for measurng nsurance rsks n non-lfe nsurance Summary Ths memo descrbes stress testng of nsurance
More informationTraffic-light extended with stress test for insurance and expense risks in life insurance
PROMEMORIA Datum 0 July 007 FI Dnr 07-1171-30 Fnansnspetonen Författare Bengt von Bahr, Göran Ronge Traffc-lght extended wth stress test for nsurance and expense rss n lfe nsurance Summary Ths memorandum
More informationModule 2 LOSSLESS IMAGE COMPRESSION SYSTEMS. Version 2 ECE IIT, Kharagpur
Module LOSSLESS IMAGE COMPRESSION SYSTEMS Lesson 3 Lossless Compresson: Huffman Codng Instructonal Objectves At the end of ths lesson, the students should be able to:. Defne and measure source entropy..
More informationCHOLESTEROL REFERENCE METHOD LABORATORY NETWORK. Sample Stability Protocol
CHOLESTEROL REFERENCE METHOD LABORATORY NETWORK Sample Stablty Protocol Background The Cholesterol Reference Method Laboratory Network (CRMLN) developed certfcaton protocols for total cholesterol, HDL
More informationOn the Optimal Control of a Cascade of Hydro-Electric Power Stations
On the Optmal Control of a Cascade of Hydro-Electrc Power Statons M.C.M. Guedes a, A.F. Rbero a, G.V. Smrnov b and S. Vlela c a Department of Mathematcs, School of Scences, Unversty of Porto, Portugal;
More informationANALYZING THE RELATIONSHIPS BETWEEN QUALITY, TIME, AND COST IN PROJECT MANAGEMENT DECISION MAKING
ANALYZING THE RELATIONSHIPS BETWEEN QUALITY, TIME, AND COST IN PROJECT MANAGEMENT DECISION MAKING Matthew J. Lberatore, Department of Management and Operatons, Vllanova Unversty, Vllanova, PA 19085, 610-519-4390,
More informationDEFINING %COMPLETE IN MICROSOFT PROJECT
CelersSystems DEFINING %COMPLETE IN MICROSOFT PROJECT PREPARED BY James E Aksel, PMP, PMI-SP, MVP For Addtonal Informaton about Earned Value Management Systems and reportng, please contact: CelersSystems,
More informationThe Application of Fractional Brownian Motion in Option Pricing
Vol. 0, No. (05), pp. 73-8 http://dx.do.org/0.457/jmue.05.0..6 The Applcaton of Fractonal Brownan Moton n Opton Prcng Qng-xn Zhou School of Basc Scence,arbn Unversty of Commerce,arbn zhouqngxn98@6.com
More informationHow To Evaluate A Dia Fund Suffcency
DI Fund Suffcency Evaluaton Methodologcal Recommendatons and DIA Russa Practce Andre G. Melnkov Deputy General Drector DIA Russa THE DEPOSIT INSURANCE CONFERENCE IN THE MENA REGION AMMAN-JORDAN, 18 20
More informationAnswer: A). There is a flatter IS curve in the high MPC economy. Original LM LM after increase in M. IS curve for low MPC economy
4.02 Quz Solutons Fall 2004 Multple-Choce Questons (30/00 ponts) Please, crcle the correct answer for each of the followng 0 multple-choce questons. For each queston, only one of the answers s correct.
More informationMeasuring portfolio loss using approximation methods
Scence Journal of Appled Mathematcs and Statstcs 014; (): 4-5 Publshed onlne Aprl 0, 014 (http://www.scencepublshnggroup.com/j/sjams) do: 10.11648/j.sjams.01400.11 Measurng portfolo loss usng approxmaton
More informationRisk-based Fatigue Estimate of Deep Water Risers -- Course Project for EM388F: Fracture Mechanics, Spring 2008
Rsk-based Fatgue Estmate of Deep Water Rsers -- Course Project for EM388F: Fracture Mechancs, Sprng 2008 Chen Sh Department of Cvl, Archtectural, and Envronmental Engneerng The Unversty of Texas at Austn
More information1. Fundamentals of probability theory 2. Emergence of communication traffic 3. Stochastic & Markovian Processes (SP & MP)
6.3 / -- Communcaton Networks II (Görg) SS20 -- www.comnets.un-bremen.de Communcaton Networks II Contents. Fundamentals of probablty theory 2. Emergence of communcaton traffc 3. Stochastc & Markovan Processes
More informationHOUSEHOLDS DEBT BURDEN: AN ANALYSIS BASED ON MICROECONOMIC DATA*
HOUSEHOLDS DEBT BURDEN: AN ANALYSIS BASED ON MICROECONOMIC DATA* Luísa Farnha** 1. INTRODUCTION The rapd growth n Portuguese households ndebtedness n the past few years ncreased the concerns that debt
More informationAn Interest-Oriented Network Evolution Mechanism for Online Communities
An Interest-Orented Network Evoluton Mechansm for Onlne Communtes Cahong Sun and Xaopng Yang School of Informaton, Renmn Unversty of Chna, Bejng 100872, P.R. Chna {chsun,yang}@ruc.edu.cn Abstract. Onlne
More informationTesting Adverse Selection Using Frank Copula Approach in Iran Insurance Markets
Journal of mathematcs and computer Scence 5 (05) 54-58 Testng Adverse Selecton Usng Frank Copula Approach n Iran Insurance Markets Had Safar Katesar,, Behrouz Fath Vajargah Departmet of Statstcs, Shahd
More informationThe OC Curve of Attribute Acceptance Plans
The OC Curve of Attrbute Acceptance Plans The Operatng Characterstc (OC) curve descrbes the probablty of acceptng a lot as a functon of the lot s qualty. Fgure 1 shows a typcal OC Curve. 10 8 6 4 1 3 4
More informationA Novel Methodology of Working Capital Management for Large. Public Constructions by Using Fuzzy S-curve Regression
Novel Methodology of Workng Captal Management for Large Publc Constructons by Usng Fuzzy S-curve Regresson Cheng-Wu Chen, Morrs H. L. Wang and Tng-Ya Hseh Department of Cvl Engneerng, Natonal Central Unversty,
More informationECONOMICS OF PLANT ENERGY SAVINGS PROJECTS IN A CHANGING MARKET Douglas C White Emerson Process Management
ECONOMICS OF PLANT ENERGY SAVINGS PROJECTS IN A CHANGING MARKET Douglas C Whte Emerson Process Management Abstract Energy prces have exhbted sgnfcant volatlty n recent years. For example, natural gas prces
More informationRisk Model of Long-Term Production Scheduling in Open Pit Gold Mining
Rsk Model of Long-Term Producton Schedulng n Open Pt Gold Mnng R Halatchev 1 and P Lever 2 ABSTRACT Open pt gold mnng s an mportant sector of the Australan mnng ndustry. It uses large amounts of nvestments,
More informationInstitute of Informatics, Faculty of Business and Management, Brno University of Technology,Czech Republic
Lagrange Multplers as Quanttatve Indcators n Economcs Ivan Mezník Insttute of Informatcs, Faculty of Busness and Management, Brno Unversty of TechnologCzech Republc Abstract The quanttatve role of Lagrange
More informationAnalysis of the provisions for claims outstanding for non-life insurance based on the run-off triangles
OFFE OF THE NSURANE AND PENSON FUNDS SUPERVSORY OMMSSON Analyss of the provsons for clams outstandng for non-lfe nsurance based on the run-off trangles Ths Report has been prepared n the nformaton Systems
More informationHow To Understand The Results Of The German Meris Cloud And Water Vapour Product
Ttel: Project: Doc. No.: MERIS level 3 cloud and water vapour products MAPP MAPP-ATBD-ClWVL3 Issue: 1 Revson: 0 Date: 9.12.1998 Functon Name Organsaton Sgnature Date Author: Bennartz FUB Preusker FUB Schüller
More informationCausal, Explanatory Forecasting. Analysis. Regression Analysis. Simple Linear Regression. Which is Independent? Forecasting
Causal, Explanatory Forecastng Assumes cause-and-effect relatonshp between system nputs and ts output Forecastng wth Regresson Analyss Rchard S. Barr Inputs System Cause + Effect Relatonshp The job of
More informationIstituto Italiano degli Attuari Riunione di Seminario Attuariale. A Collective Risk Model for Claims Reserve Distribution
Isttuto Italano degl Attuar Runone d Semnaro Attuarale Unverstà Cattolca del Sacro Cuore Mlano, 12 Maggo 2011 A Collectve Rsk Model for Clams Reserve Dstrbuton no Savell Full Professor of Rsk Theory Catholc
More informationStaff Paper. Farm Savings Accounts: Examining Income Variability, Eligibility, and Benefits. Brent Gloy, Eddy LaDue, and Charles Cuykendall
SP 2005-02 August 2005 Staff Paper Department of Appled Economcs and Management Cornell Unversty, Ithaca, New York 14853-7801 USA Farm Savngs Accounts: Examnng Income Varablty, Elgblty, and Benefts Brent
More informationIntra-year Cash Flow Patterns: A Simple Solution for an Unnecessary Appraisal Error
Intra-year Cash Flow Patterns: A Smple Soluton for an Unnecessary Apprasal Error By C. Donald Wggns (Professor of Accountng and Fnance, the Unversty of North Florda), B. Perry Woodsde (Assocate Professor
More informationTo manage leave, meeting institutional requirements and treating individual staff members fairly and consistently.
Corporate Polces & Procedures Human Resources - Document CPP216 Leave Management Frst Produced: Current Verson: Past Revsons: Revew Cycle: Apples From: 09/09/09 26/10/12 09/09/09 3 years Immedately Authorsaton:
More informationNumber of Levels Cumulative Annual operating Income per year construction costs costs ($) ($) ($) 1 600,000 35,000 100,000 2 2,200,000 60,000 350,000
Problem Set 5 Solutons 1 MIT s consderng buldng a new car park near Kendall Square. o unversty funds are avalable (overhead rates are under pressure and the new faclty would have to pay for tself from
More informationGender differences in revealed risk taking: evidence from mutual fund investors
Economcs Letters 76 (2002) 151 158 www.elsever.com/ locate/ econbase Gender dfferences n revealed rsk takng: evdence from mutual fund nvestors a b c, * Peggy D. Dwyer, James H. Glkeson, John A. Lst a Unversty
More informationPRIVATE SCHOOL CHOICE: THE EFFECTS OF RELIGIOUS AFFILIATION AND PARTICIPATION
PRIVATE SCHOOL CHOICE: THE EFFECTS OF RELIIOUS AFFILIATION AND PARTICIPATION Danny Cohen-Zada Department of Economcs, Ben-uron Unversty, Beer-Sheva 84105, Israel Wllam Sander Department of Economcs, DePaul
More informationGroup Solvency Optimization Model for Insurance Companies Using Copula Functions
Internatonal Conference on Econocs, Busness and Marketng Manageent IPEDR vol.9 () () IACSIT Press, Sngapore Group Solvency Optzaton Model for Insurance Copanes Usng Copula Functons Masayasu Kanno + Faculty
More informationThe impact of hard discount control mechanism on the discount volatility of UK closed-end funds
Investment Management and Fnancal Innovatons, Volume 10, Issue 3, 2013 Ahmed F. Salhn (Egypt) The mpact of hard dscount control mechansm on the dscount volatlty of UK closed-end funds Abstract The mpact
More informationAn Empirical Study of Search Engine Advertising Effectiveness
An Emprcal Study of Search Engne Advertsng Effectveness Sanjog Msra, Smon School of Busness Unversty of Rochester Edeal Pnker, Smon School of Busness Unversty of Rochester Alan Rmm-Kaufman, Rmm-Kaufman
More informationCalculation of Sampling Weights
Perre Foy Statstcs Canada 4 Calculaton of Samplng Weghts 4.1 OVERVIEW The basc sample desgn used n TIMSS Populatons 1 and 2 was a two-stage stratfed cluster desgn. 1 The frst stage conssted of a sample
More informationFixed income risk attribution
5 Fxed ncome rsk attrbuton Chthra Krshnamurth RskMetrcs Group chthra.krshnamurth@rskmetrcs.com We compare the rsk of the actve portfolo wth that of the benchmark and segment the dfference between the two
More informationA DYNAMIC CRASHING METHOD FOR PROJECT MANAGEMENT USING SIMULATION-BASED OPTIMIZATION. Michael E. Kuhl Radhamés A. Tolentino-Peña
Proceedngs of the 2008 Wnter Smulaton Conference S. J. Mason, R. R. Hll, L. Mönch, O. Rose, T. Jefferson, J. W. Fowler eds. A DYNAMIC CRASHING METHOD FOR PROJECT MANAGEMENT USING SIMULATION-BASED OPTIMIZATION
More informationTransition Matrix Models of Consumer Credit Ratings
Transton Matrx Models of Consumer Credt Ratngs Abstract Although the corporate credt rsk lterature has many studes modellng the change n the credt rsk of corporate bonds over tme, there s far less analyss
More informationForecasting the Direction and Strength of Stock Market Movement
Forecastng the Drecton and Strength of Stock Market Movement Jngwe Chen Mng Chen Nan Ye cjngwe@stanford.edu mchen5@stanford.edu nanye@stanford.edu Abstract - Stock market s one of the most complcated systems
More informationIDENTIFICATION AND CORRECTION OF A COMMON ERROR IN GENERAL ANNUITY CALCULATIONS
IDENTIFICATION AND CORRECTION OF A COMMON ERROR IN GENERAL ANNUITY CALCULATIONS Chrs Deeley* Last revsed: September 22, 200 * Chrs Deeley s a Senor Lecturer n the School of Accountng, Charles Sturt Unversty,
More information1. Measuring association using correlation and regression
How to measure assocaton I: Correlaton. 1. Measurng assocaton usng correlaton and regresson We often would lke to know how one varable, such as a mother's weght, s related to another varable, such as a
More information+ + + - - This circuit than can be reduced to a planar circuit
MeshCurrent Method The meshcurrent s analog of the nodeoltage method. We sole for a new set of arables, mesh currents, that automatcally satsfy KCLs. As such, meshcurrent method reduces crcut soluton to
More informationMultiple-Period Attribution: Residuals and Compounding
Multple-Perod Attrbuton: Resduals and Compoundng Our revewer gave these authors full marks for dealng wth an ssue that performance measurers and vendors often regard as propretary nformaton. In 1994, Dens
More informationSection 5.4 Annuities, Present Value, and Amortization
Secton 5.4 Annutes, Present Value, and Amortzaton Present Value In Secton 5.2, we saw that the present value of A dollars at nterest rate per perod for n perods s the amount that must be deposted today
More informationReporting Forms ARF 113.0A, ARF 113.0B, ARF 113.0C and ARF 113.0D FIRB Corporate (including SME Corporate), Sovereign and Bank Instruction Guide
Reportng Forms ARF 113.0A, ARF 113.0B, ARF 113.0C and ARF 113.0D FIRB Corporate (ncludng SME Corporate), Soveregn and Bank Instructon Gude Ths nstructon gude s desgned to assst n the completon of the FIRB
More informationMarginal Returns to Education For Teachers
The Onlne Journal of New Horzons n Educaton Volume 4, Issue 3 MargnalReturnstoEducatonForTeachers RamleeIsmal,MarnahAwang ABSTRACT FacultyofManagementand Economcs UnverstPenddkanSultan Idrs ramlee@fpe.ups.edu.my
More informationLIFETIME INCOME OPTIONS
LIFETIME INCOME OPTIONS May 2011 by: Marca S. Wagner, Esq. The Wagner Law Group A Professonal Corporaton 99 Summer Street, 13 th Floor Boston, MA 02110 Tel: (617) 357-5200 Fax: (617) 357-5250 www.ersa-lawyers.com
More informationRecurrence. 1 Definitions and main statements
Recurrence 1 Defntons and man statements Let X n, n = 0, 1, 2,... be a MC wth the state space S = (1, 2,...), transton probabltes p j = P {X n+1 = j X n = }, and the transton matrx P = (p j ),j S def.
More informationPrediction of Disability Frequencies in Life Insurance
Predcton of Dsablty Frequences n Lfe Insurance Bernhard Köng Fran Weber Maro V. Wüthrch October 28, 2011 Abstract For the predcton of dsablty frequences, not only the observed, but also the ncurred but
More informationA correlation sensitivity analysis of non-life underwriting risk in solvency capital requirement estimation
Insttut de Recerca en Economa Aplcada Regonal Públca Document de Treball 2011/13 pàg. 1 Research Insttute of Appled Economcs Workng Paper 2011/13 pag. 1 Insttut de Recerca en Economa Aplcada Regonal Públca
More informationKiel Institute for World Economics Duesternbrooker Weg 120 24105 Kiel (Germany) Kiel Working Paper No. 1120
Kel Insttute for World Economcs Duesternbrooker Weg 45 Kel (Germany) Kel Workng Paper No. Path Dependences n enture Captal Markets by Andrea Schertler July The responsblty for the contents of the workng
More informationWhat is Portfolio Diversification? What a CAIA Member Should Know
Research Revew CAIA What Member a CAIA Member Contrbuton Should Know What a CAIA Member Should Know What s Portfolo Dversfcaton? Apollon Fragkskos Vce Presdent, Analytcs, Head of Research, State Street
More informationForecasting the Demand of Emergency Supplies: Based on the CBR Theory and BP Neural Network
700 Proceedngs of the 8th Internatonal Conference on Innovaton & Management Forecastng the Demand of Emergency Supples: Based on the CBR Theory and BP Neural Network Fu Deqang, Lu Yun, L Changbng School
More informationCharacterization of Assembly. Variation Analysis Methods. A Thesis. Presented to the. Department of Mechanical Engineering. Brigham Young University
Characterzaton of Assembly Varaton Analyss Methods A Thess Presented to the Department of Mechancal Engneerng Brgham Young Unversty In Partal Fulfllment of the Requrements for the Degree Master of Scence
More informationHow To Find The Dsablty Frequency Of A Clam
1 Predcton of Dsablty Frequences n Lfe Insurance Bernhard Köng 1, Fran Weber 1, Maro V. Wüthrch 2 Abstract: For the predcton of dsablty frequences, not only the observed, but also the ncurred but not yet
More informationCriminal Justice System on Crime *
On the Impact of the NSW Crmnal Justce System on Crme * Dr Vasls Sarafds, Dscplne of Operatons Management and Econometrcs Unversty of Sydney * Ths presentaton s based on jont work wth Rchard Kelaher 1
More informationRate-Based Daily Arrival Process Models with Application to Call Centers
Submtted to Operatons Research manuscrpt (Please, provde the manuscrpt number!) Authors are encouraged to submt new papers to INFORMS journals by means of a style fle template, whch ncludes the journal
More informationA Structure for General and Specc Market Rsk Eckhard Platen 1 and Gerhard Stahl Summary. The paper presents a consstent approach to the modelng of general and specc market rsk as dened n regulatory documents.
More information"Research Note" APPLICATION OF CHARGE SIMULATION METHOD TO ELECTRIC FIELD CALCULATION IN THE POWER CABLES *
Iranan Journal of Scence & Technology, Transacton B, Engneerng, ol. 30, No. B6, 789-794 rnted n The Islamc Republc of Iran, 006 Shraz Unversty "Research Note" ALICATION OF CHARGE SIMULATION METHOD TO ELECTRIC
More informationManagement Quality and Equity Issue Characteristics: A Comparison of SEOs and IPOs
Management Qualty and Equty Issue Characterstcs: A Comparson of SEOs and IPOs Thomas J. Chemmanur * Imants Paegls ** and Karen Smonyan *** Current verson: November 2009 (Accepted, Fnancal Management, February
More informationReturn decomposing of absolute-performance multi-asset class portfolios. Working Paper - Nummer: 16
Return decomposng of absolute-performance mult-asset class portfolos Workng Paper - Nummer: 16 2007 by Dr. Stefan J. Illmer und Wolfgang Marty; n: Fnancal Markets and Portfolo Management; March 2007; Volume
More informationCHAPTER 14 MORE ABOUT REGRESSION
CHAPTER 14 MORE ABOUT REGRESSION We learned n Chapter 5 that often a straght lne descrbes the pattern of a relatonshp between two quanttatve varables. For nstance, n Example 5.1 we explored the relatonshp
More informationCalculating the high frequency transmission line parameters of power cables
< ' Calculatng the hgh frequency transmsson lne parameters of power cables Authors: Dr. John Dcknson, Laboratory Servces Manager, N 0 RW E B Communcatons Mr. Peter J. Ncholson, Project Assgnment Manager,
More informationManagement Quality, Financial and Investment Policies, and. Asymmetric Information
Management Qualty, Fnancal and Investment Polces, and Asymmetrc Informaton Thomas J. Chemmanur * Imants Paegls ** and Karen Smonyan *** Current verson: December 2007 * Professor of Fnance, Carroll School
More informationMethods for Calculating Life Insurance Rates
World Appled Scences Journal 5 (4): 653-663, 03 ISSN 88-495 IDOSI Pulcatons, 03 DOI: 0.589/dos.wasj.03.5.04.338 Methods for Calculatng Lfe Insurance Rates Madna Movsarovna Magomadova Chechen State Unversty,
More informationFinancial Mathemetics
Fnancal Mathemetcs 15 Mathematcs Grade 12 Teacher Gude Fnancal Maths Seres Overvew In ths seres we am to show how Mathematcs can be used to support personal fnancal decsons. In ths seres we jon Tebogo,
More informationCyber-Insurance: Copula Pricing Framework and Implications for Risk Management
Cyber-Insurance: Copula Prcng Framework and Implcatons for Rsk Management Hemantha S. B. Herath Assocate Professor, Department of Accountng, Faculty of Busness, 40 Taro Hall, 500 Glenrdge Avenue, St. Catharnes,
More informationEvaluating credit risk models: A critique and a new proposal
Evaluatng credt rsk models: A crtque and a new proposal Hergen Frerchs* Gunter Löffler Unversty of Frankfurt (Man) February 14, 2001 Abstract Evaluatng the qualty of credt portfolo rsk models s an mportant
More informationEstimating Total Claim Size in the Auto Insurance Industry: a Comparison between Tweedie and Zero-Adjusted Inverse Gaussian Distribution
Estmatng otal Clam Sze n the Auto Insurance Industry: a Comparson between weede and Zero-Adjusted Inverse Gaussan Dstrbuton Autora: Adrana Bruscato Bortoluzzo, Italo De Paula Franca, Marco Antono Leonel
More informationAn Evaluation of the Extended Logistic, Simple Logistic, and Gompertz Models for Forecasting Short Lifecycle Products and Services
An Evaluaton of the Extended Logstc, Smple Logstc, and Gompertz Models for Forecastng Short Lfecycle Products and Servces Charles V. Trappey a,1, Hsn-yng Wu b a Professor (Management Scence), Natonal Chao
More informationCHAPTER 5 RELATIONSHIPS BETWEEN QUANTITATIVE VARIABLES
CHAPTER 5 RELATIONSHIPS BETWEEN QUANTITATIVE VARIABLES In ths chapter, we wll learn how to descrbe the relatonshp between two quanttatve varables. Remember (from Chapter 2) that the terms quanttatve varable
More informationEstimation of Dispersion Parameters in GLMs with and without Random Effects
Mathematcal Statstcs Stockholm Unversty Estmaton of Dsperson Parameters n GLMs wth and wthout Random Effects Meng Ruoyan Examensarbete 2004:5 Postal address: Mathematcal Statstcs Dept. of Mathematcs Stockholm
More informationPricing Multi-Asset Cross Currency Options
CIRJE-F-844 Prcng Mult-Asset Cross Currency Optons Kenchro Shraya Graduate School of Economcs, Unversty of Tokyo Akhko Takahash Unversty of Tokyo March 212; Revsed n September, October and November 212
More informationL10: Linear discriminants analysis
L0: Lnear dscrmnants analyss Lnear dscrmnant analyss, two classes Lnear dscrmnant analyss, C classes LDA vs. PCA Lmtatons of LDA Varants of LDA Other dmensonalty reducton methods CSCE 666 Pattern Analyss
More informationEstimating Total Claim Size in the Auto Insurance Industry: a Comparison between Tweedie and Zero-Adjusted Inverse Gaussian Distribution
Avalable onlne at http:// BAR, Curtba, v. 8, n. 1, art. 3, pp. 37-47, Jan./Mar. 2011 Estmatng Total Clam Sze n the Auto Insurance Industry: a Comparson between Tweede and Zero-Adjusted Inverse Gaussan
More informationTraffic State Estimation in the Traffic Management Center of Berlin
Traffc State Estmaton n the Traffc Management Center of Berln Authors: Peter Vortsch, PTV AG, Stumpfstrasse, D-763 Karlsruhe, Germany phone ++49/72/965/35, emal peter.vortsch@ptv.de Peter Möhl, PTV AG,
More informationHow To Calculate The Prce Of An Ndex Opton
Prcng ndex optons n a multvarate Black & Scholes model Danël Lnders AFI_1383 Prcng ndex optons n a multvarate Black & Scholes model Danël Lnders Verson: October 2, 2013 1 Introducton In ths paper, we consder
More informationBERNSTEIN POLYNOMIALS
On-Lne Geometrc Modelng Notes BERNSTEIN POLYNOMIALS Kenneth I. Joy Vsualzaton and Graphcs Research Group Department of Computer Scence Unversty of Calforna, Davs Overvew Polynomals are ncredbly useful
More information8.5 UNITARY AND HERMITIAN MATRICES. The conjugate transpose of a complex matrix A, denoted by A*, is given by
6 CHAPTER 8 COMPLEX VECTOR SPACES 5. Fnd the kernel of the lnear transformaton gven n Exercse 5. In Exercses 55 and 56, fnd the mage of v, for the ndcated composton, where and are gven by the followng
More informationActivity Scheduling for Cost-Time Investment Optimization in Project Management
PROJECT MANAGEMENT 4 th Internatonal Conference on Industral Engneerng and Industral Management XIV Congreso de Ingenería de Organzacón Donosta- San Sebastán, September 8 th -10 th 010 Actvty Schedulng
More informationThe Current Employment Statistics (CES) survey,
Busness Brths and Deaths Impact of busness brths and deaths n the payroll survey The CES probablty-based sample redesgn accounts for most busness brth employment through the mputaton of busness deaths,
More informationBrigid Mullany, Ph.D University of North Carolina, Charlotte
Evaluaton And Comparson Of The Dfferent Standards Used To Defne The Postonal Accuracy And Repeatablty Of Numercally Controlled Machnng Center Axes Brgd Mullany, Ph.D Unversty of North Carolna, Charlotte
More information