Product: Model: Tool: Vendors

Transcription

1 PEAF Executive Summary Product: Model: Tool: Vendors Vendors Updated Adaptive EA Manager 01 Jul 14 Atoll SAMU 01 Jul 14 Avolution ABACUS 01 Jul 14 BizzDesign Architect 01 Jul 14 BOC Group ADOit 01 Jul 14 Casewise Corporate Modeler 01 Jul 14 Archi Archi 01 Jul 14 Dragon1 Dragon1 01 Jul 14 Essential Project Architecture Manager 01 Jul 14 Frankitecture MappIT 01 Jul 14 FutureTech ENVISION VIP 01 Jul 14 Holocentric Holocentric Modeller 01 Jul 14 IBM System Architect 01 Jul 14 igrafx Enterprise Modeller 01 Jul 14 Inartec idungu 01 Jul 14 Inspired EVA Netmodeler 01 Jul 14 Intelligile MAP Suite 01 Jul 14 iteratec iteraplan 01 Jul 14 Mega Mega Modelling Suite 01 Jul 14 MooD International MooD 01 Jul 14 Magic MagicDraw 01 Jul 14 OpenText Provision 01 Jul 14 Orbus iserver 01 Jul 14 Pragmatica DE2M 01 Jul 14 QualiWare Lifecycle Manager SAP An SAP Company SAP Sybase PowerDesigner 01 Jul 14 Softeam Modelio 01 Jul 14 Software AG Alfabet 01 Jul 14 Sparx Systems Enterprise Architect 01 Jul 14 Troux Troux Jul 14 Scoring Each vendor was asked to answer each question as follows O The requirement is met ( or Customisation required) F The requirement is met ( Required) Customisation S The requirement is met (Customisation. Required) N The requirement cannot be met Definitions Changes made using existing functionality - code changes required Customisation Changes made using new functionality - Code changes required All rights reserved. part of the material in this document may be reproduced or utilized in any form or by any means, unless a license has been obtained from a duly authorised officer of Pragmatic EA Ltd.

2 PEAF Overall Summary Product: Model: Tool: Vendors Customisation Un-answered Total Adaptive (EA Manager ) Archi (Archi) Atoll (SAMU) Avolution (ABACUS) BizzDesign (Architect) BOC Group (ADOit) Casewise (Corporate Modeler) Dragon1 (Dragon1) Essential Project (Architecture Manager) Frankitecture (MappIT) FutureTech (ENVISION VIP) Holocentric (Holocentric Modeller) IBM (System Architect) igrafx (Enterprise Modeller) Inartec (idungu) Inspired (EVA Netmodeler) Intelligile (MAP Suite) iteratec (iteraplan) Mega (Mega Modelling Suite) MooD International (MooD) Magic (MagicDraw) OpenText (Provision) Orbus (iserver) Pragmatica (DE2M) QualiWare (Lifecycle Manager) SAP (SAP Sybase PowerDesigner ) Softeam (Modelio) Software AG (Alfabet) Sparx Systems (Enterprise Architect) Troux (Troux 9.2.1) All rights reserved. part of the material in this document may be reproduced or utilized in any form or by any means, unless a license has been obtained from a duly authorised officer of Pragmatic EA Ltd.

3 Un-answered Customisation 100% 80% 60% 40% 20% Adaptive (EA Manager ) Archi (Archi) Atoll (SAMU) Avolution (ABACUS) BizzDesign (Architect) BOC Group (ADOit) Casewise (Corporate Modeler) Dragon1 (Dragon1) Essential Project (Architecture Frankitecture (MappIT) FutureTech (ENVISION VIP) Holocentric (Holocentric Modeller) IBM (System Architect) igrafx (Enterprise Modeller) Inartec (idungu) Inspired (EVA Netmodeler) Intelligile (MAP Suite) iteratec (iteraplan) Mega (Mega Modelling Suite) MooD International (MooD) Magic (MagicDraw) OpenText (Provision) Orbus (iserver) Pragmatica (DE2M) QualiWare (Lifecycle Manager) SAP (SAP Sybase PowerDesigner ) Softeam (Modelio) Software AG (Alfabet) Sparx Systems (Enterprise Architect) Troux (Troux 9.2.1) 0%

4 Yes 50 points 20 points Customisation 1 point 0 points Green >= 90% Yellow >= 70% Orange >= 50% Red < 50% Purple - Unanswered Avolution (ABACUS) IBM (System Architect) Dragon1 (Dragon1) Orbus (iserver) BizzDesign (Architect) MooD International (MooD) FutureTech (ENVISION VIP) Mega (Mega Modelling Suite) Intelligile (MAP Suite) Software AG (alfabet) OpenText (Provision) Adaptive (EA Manager ) BOC Group (ADOit) Atoll (SAMU) Troux (Troux 9.2.1) Inspired (EVA Netmodeler) SAP (SAP Sybase PowerDesigner ) Pragmatica (DE2M) Casewise (Corporate Modeler) iteratec (iteraplan) Essential Project (Architecture Magic (MagicDraw) Holocentric (Holocentric Modeller) igrafx (Enterprise Modeller) Sparx Systems (Enterprise Architect) Softeam (Modelio) Frankitecture (MappIT) Inartec (idungu) Archi (Archi) QualiWare (Lifecycle Manager)

5 PEAF Detailed Summary Product: Model: Tool: Vendors Importing Adaptive Archi Atoll Avolution BizzDesign BOC Group Casewise Dragon1 Essential Project Frankitecture FutureTech Holocentric IBM igrafx Inartec Inspired Intelligile iteratec Mega MooD International Magic OpenText Orbus Pragmatica QualiWare SAP Softeam Software AG Sparx Systems Troux A 1 Can.CSV be used as a source? O S O O O O O O O N O O O O S O O O O O O O O O O N O O F A 2 Can.XML be used as a source? O S O O O O O O F N O O O O S O O O O O O O O S O S O F F A 3 Can.XLS be used as a source? O S O O O O O O O O F O O O N O O O O O O O O O O O O S F A 4 Can.MDB be used as a source? O S N O O O O O F F F F O O N O O F O O N O F O F S O S F A 5 Can relationships be imported as a list of the form <primary key1>,<primary key 2>,<attributes>? O S O O O O O O O O O O O O N O S O O O S O O O O S O S F A 6 Can relationships be imported as a grid where <primary key1> is listed across the top, <primary key2> is listed down the side, with an X in intersecting cells indicating the O S O O O O O O O O S F O O N O S N O O S S O S O S F S F presence of a relationship? A 7 Can.VSD be used as a source? O S N O O F O O F N O F O O N O O N O O S O O O O S N F F A 8 Can the objects be mapped to entities in the Metamodel and imported as such? O S N O O F O O F N O S O O N O O N O O N O O O O S N F F A 9 Can the connectors be mapped to relationships in the Metamodel and imported as such? O S N O O F O O F N O S O N N O O N O O N O O O O S N F F A 10 Is the diagram imported the same type as a diagram created within the tool? O S N O O F O O N N O S O O N O O N O O O O O O O O N F N A 11 Can the user import the data without the display properties of the graphics? O S N O O F O O F N O S O N N O O N O O O O O O O O N F F A 12 Can the user import the data with the display properties of the graphics? O S N O O F O O S N O S O O N O O N O O O S O O O O N F F Can the diagram produced be manipulated in the same way as a diagram that was A 13 drawn natively in the tool? O S N O O O O O S N O O O O N O O N O O O O O O O O N O O A 14 Is it possible to perform round-trip engineering via Visio? S N N O O S O O F N O S O N N O O O O O N S O O O S N N S Can Hierarchical Information be imported of the form <name>,<parent name> where A 15 <parent name>'s are previously defined <names>'s? O S O O O O O O O N O O O O N O O O O O O O O O O S O O F A 16 Is this hierarchical information imported as entities linked by relationships? O S O O O O O O O N O O O S N O O O O O O O O O O S O N F A 17 Can other types of relationships supported be imported? O S O O O O O O O N O O O S N O O O O O O O O O O S O O O A 18 Can the tool handle conflicts? O S O O O O O O O O O O O F N O O O O O S O O O O O O S O Is it possible to configure rules to resolve conflicting information being imported from A 19 multiple sources F S O O O F O O S N F S O F N S O N O O S O O S O F O S O Are there any tools/functionality to enable the synchronisation of entities and/or A 20 relationships stored outside the tool (e.g. CMDB's, portfolio management tools, change management tools)? F S O O O O O O O N F S O F N F S S O O O S O S O O O S O Exporting Adaptive Archi Atoll Avolution BizzDesign BOC Group Casewise Dragon1 Essential Project Frankitecture FutureTech Holocentric IBM igrafx Inartec Inspired Intelligile iteratec Mega MooD International Magic OpenText Orbus Pragmatica QualiWare SAP Softeam Software AG Sparx Systems Troux B 1 Can.CSV be used as a target? O O O O O O O O O N O O O O S O O O O O O O O O O S O O O B 2 Can.XML be used as a target? O O O O O O O O O N O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O S O O O B 3 Can.XLS be used as a target? O S O O O O O O O O F O O O S O O O O O O O O O O O O S O B 4 Can.MDB be used as a target? O S N O O O O O O O F F O N N O O N O O N O F O F S O S O B 5 Can relationships be exported as a list of the form <primary key1>,<primary key 2>,<attributes>? O O O O O O O O O O F O O N S O O O O O S O O O O S O F F B 6 Can relationships be exported as a grid where <primary key1> is listed across the top, <primary key2> is listed down the side, with an X in intersecting cells indicating the O S O O O O O O O N F F O O S O O N O O S O O O O S O S F presence of a relationship? B 7 Can.VSD be used as a target? O S O O O F O O O O O S N N N O O O O O O S O O O S N N S B 8 Can Hierarchical Information be exported of the form <name>,<parent name> where <parent name>'s are previously defined <names>'s? O O O O O O O O O N O O O O S O O O O O S O O O O S O O F B 9 Can other types of relationships supported be exported? F S O O O O O O O N O O O O S O O O O O O O O O O S O O O Relationships Adaptive Archi Atoll Avolution BizzDesign BOC Group Casewise Dragon1 Essential Project Frankitecture FutureTech Holocentric IBM igrafx Inartec Inspired Intelligile iteratec Mega MooD International Magic OpenText Orbus Pragmatica QualiWare SAP Softeam Software AG Sparx Systems Troux C 1 Are relationships a fundamental type? O O O O O O O O O O O O O S O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O C 2 Are there fundamental types such as Hierarchy, Composition etc that a relationship can be based on O O O O O O O O O N O O O F O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O C 3 Are all relationships' stored as relationship entities linked to the related entities rather then attributes on entities O O O O O O O O O O O O O N O O O N O O O O O O O O O O O C 4 Can I view and manipulate relationships visually by creating, deleting and moving lines between entities? O O O O O O O O O N O O O F O O O N O O O O O O O O O O O C 5 Can I use a matrix to view, create, delete and modify all non hierarchical relationships? O N F O O O O O O O O F O N O O O O O O O O O S O O F O O D 1 D 2 User Interface / Ease of use Can I use a combination of the thumbwheel and the shift and ctrl keys (or equivalent) to easily pan and zoom diagrams (ala Visio)? Can I drag/create graphics (representing entities) onto the diagram and then immediately be able to move things without having to change the drawing tool into a select tool? Adaptive Archi Atoll Avolution BizzDesign BOC Group Casewise Dragon1 Essential Project Frankitecture FutureTech Holocentric IBM igrafx Inartec Inspired Intelligile iteratec Mega MooD International Magic OpenText Orbus Pragmatica QualiWare SAP Softeam Software AG Sparx Systems Troux O O O O O O O O O N O O O O O N O O O O O O O O O O O O O N O O O O O O O O N O O O O O O O S O O O O O O O O O O O D 3 Do open windows auto update when changes in other windows are made O O O O O O O O O N O O O N O O O N O O O O O N O O N O O Is there a fully featured (Diagrams, entities, properties, fully hyperlinked) "viewer" D 4 interface for consumers of the model to use to navigate the model that allows viewing but O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O not updating? All rights reserved. part of the material in this document may be reproduced or utilized in any form or by any means, unless a license has been obtained from a duly authorised officer of Pragmatic EA Ltd.

6 PEAF Product: Model: Tool: Vendors Diagrams / Views Adaptive Archi Atoll Avolution BizzDesign BOC Group Casewise Dragon1 Essential Project Frankitecture FutureTech Holocentric IBM igrafx Inartec Inspired Intelligile iteratec Mega MooD International Magic OpenText Orbus Pragmatica QualiWare SAP Softeam Software AG Sparx Systems Troux E 1 Can I define the graphic used to display entities on diagrams O N O O O S O O O N O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O F O O O E 2 Can I define the properties to be displayed on the graphic? O N O O O O O O O F O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O E 3 Can I define the appearance (font, colour, size, alignment) of the properties displayed on the graphic? O O O O O O O O F F O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O E 4 Can I fully define the location of each attribute on the graphic? O O O O O O O O F N O O O O O O O N O O O O O O O O O F O E 5 Can the displayed properties be conditionally set (e.g. make the text colour red if a property of the associated entity equals a value) O N O O O O O O F N O O O O N F O O O O S S O O O S O F O E 6 Can I define the graphic used to display relationships on diagrams O N O O O S O O F N O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O F O E 7 Can I define the properties to be displayed on the graphic? O N O O O O O O F N O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O F O E 8 Can I define the appearance (font, colour, size, alignment) of the properties displayed on the graphic? O O O O O O O O F O O O O O S F O O O O O O O O O O O F O E 9 Can I fully define the location of each attribute on the graphic? O O O O O O O O F N O O O O S O O N O O O N O O O O O F O Can the displayed properties be conditionally set (e.g. make the text colour red E 10 if a property of the associated entity equals a value) O N O O O O O O F N O O O O N F O O O O S N O O O S O F O Can I define different properties to be displayed on the beginning and ends of the E 11 graphic? O N O O O O O O F N O O O O F N O O O O O O O O O S O F O E 12 Can I define different properties to be displayed on the middle of the graphic? O N O O O O O O F N O O O F F O O O O O O O O O O S O S O E 13 Are all predefined entities provided with associated graphics? O O O O O O O O F O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O E 14 Are all predefined relationships provided with associated graphics? O O O O O O O O F O O O O F O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O E 15 Can I create fully configurable custom diagrams (e. g. Management Dashboard View)? O O O O O O O O O N O O O O S O O O O O O O O O O S O S O E 16 Can I model processes using BPMN (e.g. Activities, processes)? O N O O O O O O N N O O O O O O O N O O O O O O O O O O O E 17 Can I model Data using logical ER diagrams (e.g. to model business data models)? O N O O O O O O N N O O O S O O O N O O O O O O O O O O F Can I create a diagram, drop any number of entities of any number of types at any level E 18 of abstraction, and have the tool draw in the relationships? F O O O O O O O N N F O O O O O O O O O O S O O O O O O O E 19 Can I use that diagram to change the relationships and entities? O N O O O O O O O N O O O N O O O N O O O O O O O O O O O Can I automatically navigate the data at varying levels of detail where the E 20 relationships of those lower levels are summarised and displayed as relationships as O O O O O O N O O O O F O N N O O O O O O N O S O O O S O there are expanded or collapsed? Can I assign entities to a "group" and then have the tool draw a bounding polygon E 21 showing the entities in the group and those without? Can I do multiple groups? O O O O O O O O F N O S O N N O O O F O S S O O O S O O F Do I have access to various tools to help me layout diagrams (e.g. arrange as Hierarchy, E 22 horizontally, verticals, block, circle, star) O O O O O O N O O O O O O O S O O O O O O O O O O O O O O Do diagrams automatically update when the underlying data changes (I.e. text changes, E 23 addition or removal of entities and relationships)? O O O O O O O O O N O O O O O O O O O O O O O S O O O O O E 24 Can I use "layers" on diagrams? O N O O O O O O N N O O O O N N O F O O S O O O F N O F O Are there built views/dashboards/reports/questions available for the Business? (see E 25 Expected O N O O O O F O O O O O O F N O O O O O O O O F F O O F O Are there built views/dashboards/reports/questions available for the Finance dept (see E 26 Expected F N O O O S F O F O O F O F N O O O O O S O O F F O O F O Are there built views/dashboards/reports/questions available for the IS dept (see E 27 Expected F N O O O O F O O O O F O F N O O O O O O O O F F O O F O Are there built views/dashboards/reports/questions available for Suppliers (see Expected E 28 F N O O O S F O F O O F O F N O O O O O S F O F F O O F O Are there built views/dashboards/reports/questions available for B2B Customers (see E 29 Expected F N O O O O F O F O O F O F N O O O O O S F O F F O O F O Are there built views/dashboards/reports/questions available for Governance (e.g. E 30 Compliance to principles, polices, etc) O N O O O O O O O O O O O F N O O O O O S F O F O O O F O Impact Analysis Adaptive Archi Atoll Avolution BizzDesign BOC Group Casewise Dragon1 Essential Project Frankitecture FutureTech Holocentric IBM igrafx Inartec Inspired Intelligile iteratec Mega MooD International Magic OpenText Orbus Pragmatica QualiWare SAP Softeam Software AG Sparx Systems Troux F 1 Can I perform impact analysis by navigating a hierarchical textual representation of the model? O O O O O O O O O N O F O O O O O O O O O O O O O S O O O F 2 Can I perform impact analysis by navigating a hierarchical graphical representation of the model? O O O O O O O O O N O O O N O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O F 3 Is it possible to view the deltas between different versions of a model? O N O O O O O O O N O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O All rights reserved. part of the material in this document may be reproduced or utilized in any form or by any means, unless a license has been obtained from a duly authorised officer of Pragmatic EA Ltd.

7 PEAF Product: Model: Tool: Vendors Metamodel Adaptive Archi Atoll Avolution BizzDesign BOC Group Casewise Dragon1 Essential Project Frankitecture FutureTech Holocentric IBM igrafx Inartec Inspired Intelligile iteratec Mega MooD International Magic OpenText Orbus Pragmatica QualiWare SAP Softeam Software AG Sparx Systems Troux G 1 Does your Metamodel cover Strategy (e.g. Vision:Goals:Objectives, Mission:Strategies:Tactics, Policies:Rules, etc)? List the entities provided O O O O O O F O O O O O O O O O O F O O O O O O O O O O O G 2 Does your Metamodel cover Environmental Architecture (e.g. Trends, Influences, SWOT's, etc)? List the entities provided. O O F O O F F O O O O F O F S O O F O O S O O N F O O O O G 3 Does your Metamodel cover Business Architecture (e.g. Products, Sectors, Segments, Services, Customers, Organisation, Locations, Activities, Processes, etc)? List the O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O entities provided. G 4 Does your Metamodel cover Information/Data Architecture (e.g. Business Data Model, Logical Date Model, etc)? List the entities provided. O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O G 5 Does your Metamodel cover Technology Architecture (e.g. Services, Applications, Datastores, Databases, Technologies, Devices, etc)? List the entities provided. O O O O O O O O O O O O O F O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O G 6 Does your Metamodel cover Governance (e.g. Principles, Policies, Waivers, etc)? List the entities provided. O O O O O O F O O O O O O F S O O F O O S O O O F S O O O G 7 Do you provide an easily navigable Metamodel documentation consisting of a high level view with the ability to drill down? O O O O O O F O O O O F O F O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O G 8 Can I change the Metamodel visually? O N N O O O O O O N O O O N O O O N O O O O O O O O O O O G 9 Can I add & remove new entities? O S O O O O O O O N O O O O O O O S O O O O O O O O O O O G 10 Can I add & remove new relationships? O S O O O O O O O N O O O O O O O S O O O O O O O O O O O G 11 Can I add & remove attributes to existing and user defined entities? O S O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O F O O O G 12 Can I add & remove attributes to existing and user defined relationships? O S O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O F O O O G 13 Is the Metamodel totally flexible or are there limitations? (If so what are they?)? O S O O O O O O O O O O O S O O O F O O O O O O O O O O O G 14 Can attributes be simple (e.g. text, number, list, date, money)? O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O Can attributes have rules associated (e.g. limit number of chars, limit numbers/dates to a G 15 defined range)? O N O O O O O O O N O O O F N S O O O O O O O O O S O O O G 16 Can attributes be complex (e.g. An attribute consisting of a group of attributes)? O N O O O O N O O N O S O F O N O O O O O N O N O O O O O G 17 Can I automatically navigate the model using TOGAF as a navigation structure? O N O O O F O O F N O F O N N O O N O O O O O S O O O O O G 18 Can I automatically navigate the model using Zachman as a navigation structure? O N F O O F O O F N O F O N N O O N F O O O O S O S F O F G 19 Can I define new navigation structures? O N O O O O F O F F O O O S O O O N O O O O O S O S O O O H 1 H 2 Target and Intermediate Models Does the model fundamentally understand and support the concepts of target and intermediate models and the special relationships between them? Does the model offer specific functionality for the definition, management and analysis of target and intermediate models and the gaps between them Management Adaptive Archi Atoll Avolution BizzDesign BOC Group Casewise Dragon1 Essential Project Frankitecture FutureTech Holocentric IBM igrafx Inartec Inspired Intelligile iteratec Mega MooD International Magic OpenText Orbus Pragmatica QualiWare SAP Softeam Software AG Sparx Systems Troux O O O O O O O O O O O F O F O F O F O F O O O F O F O O O O O O O O O F O O O O F O F N F O O O F O O O F O F O O O Adaptive Archi Atoll Avolution BizzDesign BOC Group Casewise Dragon1 Essential Project Frankitecture FutureTech Holocentric IBM igrafx Inartec Inspired Intelligile iteratec Mega MooD International Magic OpenText Orbus Pragmatica QualiWare SAP Softeam Software AG Sparx Systems Troux I 1 Are all changes to the model subject to version control and management? O N N O O O O O O O O O O F O O S O O O O O O S O O O F O I 2 Is it possible to "check out" whole models? O N N O O O O O N N O O O O O O S N O O O O O O O O O O O I 3 Is it possible to "check out" partial models? O N N O O O O O N N O O O O O O S N O O O O O O O O O O O I 4 Does it allow branching and merging of entities, relationships and diagrams? O N N O O O O O O N O F O N N F O F O F O O O O O O O F F I 5 Is there any workflow built in to allow the acceptance or rejection of changes to the model O through a lifecycle (e.g. discussion, draft, authorised, published)? N F O N F O O N N O F O O N N F N O F O F O S O S O O F I 6 Can I load inconsistent and/or missing attributes into the model and then use the tool to manage the consolidation and completion of the data? O N O O O O O O O N O F O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O S F I 7 Can I generate syntax, semantic and consistency, and completeness reports? O N F O O O O O O N O F O F O S O O O O O O O O F O O F F Supplementary Questions Adaptive Archi Atoll Avolution BizzDesign BOC Group Casewise Dragon1 Essential Project Frankitecture FutureTech Holocentric IBM igrafx Inartec Inspired Intelligile iteratec Mega MooD International Magic OpenText Orbus Pragmatica QualiWare SAP Softeam Software AG Sparx Systems Troux J 1 Does the tool possess Application Portfolio Management capability or do you have another tool that does? O N O O O O O O O O O S O N O O O O O O O O O O O S O N O J 2 Do you have any out of the box integrations with 3rd part APM tools? O N O O F S F O F N F S O N N N S S F F S N O S O S O N F J 3 Does the tool possess Management Database (CMDB) capability or do you have another tool that does? F N O O O F F O F N O S O S N F O F F F S N O O O O N N N J 4 Do you have any out of the box integrations with 3rd party CMDB tools? N N O O F S F O O N F S O N N N S S O F S N O S O O O N O J 5 Does the tool possess Governance capability or do you have another tool that does? O N O O O O O O O N O F O O N O O O O O S O O S O N O N O J 6 Do you have any out of the box integrations with 3rd party Governance tools? N N O O F S F O F N O F O N N N S S F F S O O S F S O N F J 7 Does the tool possess Business Process Analysis and Simulation capability or do you have another tool that does? N N N O O O O O S N O O O O O O O S O O S O O S O S O O N J 8 Do you have any out of the box integrations with 3rd party BP Analysis and Simulation tools? N N O O F O O O F N F S O O N N S S F O S O O S O S O N F J 9 Does the tool possess Business Intelligence (BI) capability or do you have another tool that does? O N N O O O F O O O O F O O N O O O O O S N O O O S O N O J 10 Do you have any out of the box integrations with 3rd party BI tools? O O O O F O O O F O F S O F N O S N F F S O O O O S O N O J 11 List the EA Frameworks supported and describe how they are supported O O O O O O O F O O O F O F N O O O O O O O O O O O O O O Describe/Illustrate the architecture of your tool including the use of any 3rd party J 12 software. O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O List the modelling notations supported and indicate any 3rd part products used to provide J 13 the functionality O O O O O O O F O N O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O List any standard queries/reports (textual or diagrammatic - please indicate which for J 14 each) O O O O O O F O O N O F O O N O O O O O O O O O O O O O O All rights reserved. part of the material in this document may be reproduced or utilized in any form or by any means, unless a license has been obtained from a duly authorised officer of Pragmatic EA Ltd.

8 PEAF Product: Model: Tool: Vendors Expected Views Adaptive Archi Atoll Avolution BizzDesign BOC Group Casewise Dragon1 Essential Project Frankitecture FutureTech Holocentric IBM igrafx Inartec Inspired Intelligile iteratec Mega MooD International Magic OpenText Orbus Pragmatica QualiWare SAP Softeam Software AG Sparx Systems Troux K 1 What are the average costs for applications that support a particular business process O N O O O F F O F O O F O F S O O O O O S O O O O S O F O K 2 What fundamental architectures are being used and numbers of each type O N O O O O F O O O O F O F S O O O F O S O O O O O O F O K 3 What is the split between COTS and bespoke applications O N O O O F F O F O O F O F S O O O O O S O O O F S O F F K 4 How many FTE's are requirement to support an application O N F O O O F O F O O F O O S O O O F O S O O O F S O F O K 5 What applications support a business function O N O O O O F O O O O F O O S O O O O O S O O O O O O F O K 6 What applications are not covered by a DR plan O N O O O F F O F F O F O F S O O O F O S O O O O S O F O K 7 What applications or technologies are candidates for rationalisation O N O O O O F O O O O F O F S O O O O O S O O O O S O F O K 8 What applications are the most costly (value based) O N O O O O F O F O O F O F S O O O O O S O O O O S O F O K 9 What applications are the most important to the business O N O O O O F O F O O F O F S O O O O O S O O O O S O F O K 10 What are the transition plans for an application / process / etc O N O O O O F O O O O F O F S O O O O O S O O O F O O F O K 11 What are the recurring costs of an application O N O O O O F O F O O F O O S O O O O O S O O O O S O F O K 12 How critical is an application to a business process O N O O O O F O O O O F O F S O O O O O S O O O F S O F O K 13 How many users depend on an application O N F O O O F O O O O F O F S O O O O O S O O O O S O F O K 14 what is the usage profile/roadmap for an application O N O O O O F O F O O F O F S O O O F O S O O O F S O F O K 15 What skills are required to support an application O N O O O O F O F O O F O O S O O O F O S O O O O S O F O K 16 Which applications have the greatest impact on the business O N O O O O F O O O O F O O S O O O O O S O O O F S O F O K 17 Who are the business and technical owners for an application O N O O O O F O O O O F O O S O O O O O S O O O O S O F O K 18 Who are the owners of applications with no DR plans O N O O O O F O F F O F O O S O O O F O S O O O O S O F O K 19 Who is using an application O N O O O O F O O O O F O F S O O O O O S O O O O O O F O Expected Dashboards Adaptive Archi Atoll Avolution BizzDesign BOC Group Casewise Dragon1 Essential Project Frankitecture FutureTech Holocentric IBM igrafx Inartec Inspired Intelligile iteratec Mega MooD International Magic OpenText Orbus Pragmatica QualiWare SAP Softeam Software AG Sparx Systems Troux L 1 Executive Dashboard: Project Portfolio Impact Executive Summary O N O O O O F O F F O F O F N F O O F O S O O F F S O F O L 2 Executive Dashboard: Demands Executive Summary F N O O O O F O F F O F O F N F O O O O S O O F F S O F O L 3 Executive Dashboard: Portfolio Complexity Summary O N O O O S F O F F O F O F N F O O O O S O O O F S O F O L 4 Executive Dashboard: Goals and Strategy Executive Summary O N O O O O F O F F O F O F N F O O O O S O O O F O O F O L 5 Executive Dashboard: Spend Alignment Executive Summary F N F O O S F O F F O F O F N F O O F O S O O F F S O F O L 6 Executive Dashboard: Revenue Views of customers, segments, sectors, products, etc F N F O O S F O F O O F O F N F O O F O S O O F F S O F F L 7 Business And IT Executives: Business Demand F N O O O O F O F O O F O F N F O O O O O O O F F S O F O L 8 Business And IT Executives: Projects alignment to strategies O N O O O O F O O O O F O F N F O O O O O O O F F S O F O L 9 Business And IT Executives: Spend related to business need F N O O O S F O F O O F O F N F O O O O S O O F F S O F O L 10 Business And IT Executives: Programmes anad projects roadmap O N O O O O F O O O O F O F N O O O O O O O O F F S O F O L 11 Programme and Financial planners: Applications related to Business Capability O N O O O O F O O F O F O F N O O O O O O O O F F O O F O L 12 Programme and Financial planners: Enterprise Application Roadmap O N O O O O F O O F O F O F N S O O F O O O O F F O O F O L 13 Programme and Financial planners: Spend related to Business value F N O O O S F O F O O F O F N S O O O O S O O F F S O F F L 14 Enterprise architects: Analysis of interrelationships F N O O O O F O O F O F O F O O O O O O O O O O F O O F O L 15 Enterprise architects: Model enterprise O N O O O O F O O O O F O F O O O O O O O O O F F O O F O L 16 Enterprise architects: Ensure data is complete and accurate and up to date F N O O O O F O F F O F O F O O O O O O O O O O F S O F O L 17 Enterprise architects: Define Future State F N O O O O F O O F O F O F O O O O O O O O O F F O O F O L 18 Enterprise architects: Plan State transitions F N O O O O F O O F O F O F N O O O O O O O O F F O O F O L 19 Enterprise architects: Principles and policies related to goals and objectives O N O O O O F O O F O F O F S O O O O O O O O F F S O F F L 20 IT: Understand technology roadmap O N O O O O F O O F O F O F N O O O O O O O O F F O O F O L 21 IT: Analysis of interrelationships F N O O O O F O O O O F O F O O O O O O O O O F F O O F O L 22 IT: Impact Analysis O N O O O O F O O O O F O F O O O O O O O O O O F O O F O L 23 IT: Manage risks F N O O O O F O F F O F O F N O O O O O O O O F F S O F F D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z AA AB AC AD AE AF AG AH All rights reserved. part of the material in this document may be reproduced or utilized in any form or by any means, unless a license has been obtained from a duly authorised officer of Pragmatic EA Ltd.

9 PEAF Product: Model: Tool: Vendors 4 23 A. Importing 4 23 Adaptive Archi Atoll Avolution BizzDesign BOC Group Casewise Dragon1 Essential Project Frankitecture FutureTech Holocentric IBM igrafx Inartec Inspired Intelligile iteratec Mega MooD International Magic OpenText Orbus Pragmatica QualiWare SAP Softeam Software AG Sparx Systems Troux Customisation Un-answered Total B. Exporting Adaptive Archi Atoll Avolution BizzDesign BOC Group Casewise Dragon1 Essential Project Frankitecture FutureTech Holocentric IBM igrafx Inartec Inspired Intelligile iteratec Mega MooD International Magic OpenText Orbus Pragmatica QualiWare SAP Softeam Software AG Sparx Systems Troux Customisation Un-answered Total C. Relationships Adaptive Archi Atoll Avolution BizzDesign BOC Group Casewise Dragon1 Essential Project Frankitecture FutureTech Holocentric IBM igrafx Inartec Inspired Intelligile iteratec Mega MooD International Magic OpenText Orbus Pragmatica QualiWare SAP Softeam Software AG Sparx Systems Troux Customisation Un-answered Total D. User Interface / Ease of use Adaptive Archi Atoll Avolution BizzDesign BOC Group Casewise Dragon1 Essential Project Frankitecture FutureTech Holocentric IBM igrafx Inartec Inspired Intelligile iteratec Mega MooD International Magic OpenText Orbus Pragmatica QualiWare SAP Softeam Software AG Sparx Systems Troux Customisation Un-answered Total E. Diagrams / Views Adaptive Archi Atoll Avolution BizzDesign BOC Group Casewise Dragon1 Essential Project Frankitecture FutureTech Holocentric IBM igrafx Inartec Inspired Intelligile iteratec Mega MooD International Magic OpenText Orbus Pragmatica QualiWare SAP Softeam Software AG Sparx Systems Troux Customisation Un-answered Total F. Impact Analysis Adaptive Archi Atoll Avolution BizzDesign BOC Group Casewise Dragon1 Essential Project Frankitecture FutureTech Holocentric IBM igrafx Inartec Inspired Intelligile iteratec Mega MooD International Magic OpenText Orbus Pragmatica QualiWare SAP Softeam Software AG Sparx Systems Troux Customisation Un-answered Total All rights reserved. part of the material in this document may be reproduced or utilized in any form or by any means, unless a license has been obtained from a duly authorised officer of Pragmatic EA Ltd.

10 PEAF G. Metamodel Product: Model: Tool: Vendors Adaptive Archi Atoll Avolution BizzDesign BOC Group Casewise Dragon1 Essential Project Frankitecture FutureTech Holocentric IBM igrafx Inartec Inspired Intelligile iteratec Mega MooD International Magic OpenText Orbus Pragmatica QualiWare SAP Softeam Software AG Sparx Systems Troux Customisation Un-answered Total H. Target and Intermediate Models Adaptive Archi Atoll Avolution BizzDesign BOC Group Casewise Dragon1 Essential Project Frankitecture FutureTech Holocentric IBM igrafx Inartec Inspired Intelligile iteratec Mega MooD International Magic OpenText Orbus Pragmatica QualiWare SAP Softeam Software AG Sparx Systems Troux Customisation Un-answered Total I. Management Adaptive Archi Atoll Avolution BizzDesign BOC Group Casewise Dragon1 Essential Project Frankitecture FutureTech Holocentric IBM igrafx Inartec Inspired Intelligile iteratec Mega MooD International Magic OpenText Orbus Pragmatica QualiWare SAP Softeam Software AG Sparx Systems Troux Customisation Un-answered Total J. Supplementary Questions Adaptive Archi Atoll Avolution BizzDesign BOC Group Casewise Dragon1 Essential Project Frankitecture FutureTech Holocentric IBM igrafx Inartec Inspired Intelligile iteratec Mega MooD International Magic OpenText Orbus Pragmatica QualiWare SAP Softeam Software AG Sparx Systems Troux Customisation Un-answered Total K. Expected Views Adaptive Archi Atoll Avolution BizzDesign BOC Group Casewise Dragon1 Essential Project Frankitecture FutureTech Holocentric IBM igrafx Inartec Inspired Intelligile iteratec Mega MooD International Magic OpenText Orbus Pragmatica QualiWare SAP Softeam Software AG Sparx Systems Troux Customisation Un-answered Total L. Expected Dashboards Adaptive Archi Atoll Avolution BizzDesign BOC Group Casewise Dragon1 Essential Project Frankitecture FutureTech Holocentric IBM igrafx Inartec Inspired Intelligile iteratec Mega MooD International Magic OpenText Orbus Pragmatica QualiWare SAP Softeam Software AG Sparx Systems Troux Customisation Un-answered Total All rights reserved. part of the material in this document may be reproduced or utilized in any form or by any means, unless a license has been obtained from a duly authorised officer of Pragmatic EA Ltd.

11 PEAF Product: Model: Tool: Vendors 100% A. Importing 80% 60% 40% 20% Un-answered Customisation 0% Adaptive Archi Atoll Avoluti BizzDe BOC Casewi Dragon1 Essenti Frankit Future Holoce IBM igrafx Inartec Inspired Intelligi iteratec Mega MooD OpenT Orbus Pragm Quali SAP Softeam Softwa Sparx Troux 100% B. Exporting 80% 60% 40% 20% Un-answered Customisation 0% Adaptive Archi Atoll Avoluti BizzDe BOC Casewi Dragon1 Essenti Frankit Future Holoce IBM igrafx Inartec Inspired Intelligi iteratec Mega MooD OpenT Orbus Pragm Quali SAP Softeam Softwa Sparx Troux 100% C. Relationships 80% 60% 40% 20% Un-answered Customisation 0% Adaptive Archi Atoll Avoluti BizzDe BOC Casewi Dragon1 Essenti Frankit Future Holoce IBM igrafx Inartec Inspired Intelligi iteratec Mega MooD OpenT Orbus Pragm Quali SAP Softeam Softwa Sparx Troux 100% D. User Interface / Ease of use 80% 60% 40% 20% Un-answered Customisation 0% Adaptive Archi Atoll Avoluti BizzDe BOC Casewi Dragon1 Essenti Frankit Future Holoce IBM igrafx Inartec Inspired Intelligi iteratec Mega MooD OpenT Orbus Pragm Quali SAP Softeam Softwa Sparx Troux 100% E. Diagrams / Views 80% 60% 40% 20% Un-answered Customisation 0% Adaptive Archi Atoll Avoluti BizzDe BOC Casewi Dragon1 Essenti Frankit Future Holoce IBM igrafx Inartec Inspired Intelligi iteratec Mega MooD OpenT Orbus Pragm Quali SAP Softeam Softwa Sparx Troux 100% F. Impact Analysis 80% 60% 40% 20% Un-answered Customisation 0% Adaptive Archi Atoll Avoluti BizzDe BOC Casewi Dragon1 Essenti Frankit Future Holoce IBM igrafx Inartec Inspired Intelligi iteratec Mega MooD OpenT Orbus Pragm Quali SAP Softeam Softwa Sparx Troux All rights reserved. part of the material in this document may be reproduced or utilized in any form or by any means, unless a license has been obtained from a duly authorised officer of Pragmatic EA Ltd.

12 PEAF Product: Model: Tool: Vendors 100% G. Metamodel 80% 60% 40% 20% Un-answered Customisation 0% Adaptive Archi Atoll Avoluti BizzDe BOC Casewi Dragon1 Essenti Frankit Future Holoce IBM igrafx Inartec Inspired Intelligi iteratec Mega MooD OpenT Orbus Pragm Quali SAP Softeam Softwa Sparx Troux 100% H. Target and Intermediate Models 80% 60% 40% 20% Un-answered Customisation 0% Adaptive Archi Atoll Avoluti BizzDe BOC Casewi Dragon1 Essenti Frankit Future Holoce IBM igrafx Inartec Inspired Intelligi iteratec Mega MooD OpenT Orbus Pragm Quali SAP Softeam Softwa Sparx Troux 100% I. Management 80% 60% 40% 20% Un-answered Customisation 0% Adaptive Archi Atoll Avoluti BizzDe BOC Casewi Dragon1 Essenti Frankit Future Holoce IBM igrafx Inartec Inspired Intellig iteratec Mega MooD OpenT Orbus Pragm Quali SAP Softeam Softwa Sparx Troux 100% J. Supplementary Questions 80% 60% 40% 20% Un-answered Customisation 0% Adaptive Archi Atoll Avoluti BizzDe BOC Casewi Dragon1 Essenti Frankit Future Holoce IBM igrafx Inartec Inspired Intelligi iteratec Mega MooD OpenT Orbus Pragm Quali SAP Softeam Softwa Sparx Troux 100% K. Expected Views 80% 60% 40% 20% Un-answered Customisation 0% Adaptive Archi Atoll Avoluti BizzDe BOC Casewi Dragon1 Essenti Frankit Future Holoce IBM igrafx Inartec Inspired Intelligi iteratec Mega MooD OpenT Orbus Pragm Quali SAP Softeam Softwa Sparx Troux 100% L. Expected Dashboards 80% 60% 40% 20% Un-answered Customisation 0% Adaptive Archi Atoll Avoluti BizzDe BOC Casewi Dragon1 Essenti Frankit Future Holoce IBM igrafx Inartec Inspired Intelligi iteratec Mega MooD OpenT Orbus Pragm Quali SAP Softeam Softwa Sparx Troux All rights reserved. part of the material in this document may be reproduced or utilized in any form or by any means, unless a license has been obtained from a duly authorised officer of Pragmatic EA Ltd.

13 Adaptive (EA Manager ) Importing A.1 Can.CSV be used as a source? MOF repository which accepts data from numerous sources based on comprehensive underlying metamodels A.2 Can.XML be used as a source? MOF repository which accepts data from numerous sources based on comprehensive underlying metamodels A.3 Can.XLS be used as a source? MOF repository which accepts data from numerous sources based on comprehensive underlying metamodels A.4 Can.MDB be used as a source? Utility to do mapping to a metamodel A.5 Can relationships be imported as a list of the form <primary key1>,<primary key 2>,<attributes>? Supported fully. A.6 Can relationships be imported as a grid where <primary key1> is listed across the top, <primary key2> is listed down the side, with an X in intersecting cells indicating the presence of a relationship? A.7 Can.VSD be used as a source? A.8 Can the objects be mapped to entities in the Metamodel and imported as such? A.9 Can the connectors be mapped to relationships in the Metamodel and imported as such? supported fully. A.10 Is the diagram imported the same type as a diagram created within the tool? A.11 Can the user import the data without the display properties of the graphics? A.12 Can the user import the data with the display properties of the graphics? A.13 Can the diagram produced be manipulated in the same way as a diagram that was drawn natively in the tool? A.14 Is it possible to perform round-trip engineering via Visio? Customisation A.15 Can Hierarchical Information be imported of the form <name>,<parent name> where <parent name>'s are previously defined <names>'s? A.16 Is this hierarchical information imported as entities linked by relationships? Repository provides matrix function with rows anc columns where X is the intersection establishing a relationship between row object and column object Adaptive provides a utility to utilize any visio diagram as a navigation map with url hotpots to query for any object in repository, any filtered classification listn of objects, any auto rendered svg diagram, any static diagram, any object view, any query, or any workflow Extremely robust set of industry standard metamodels. Our CTO is on the Architecture Board of the Object Management Group. All standard based metamodels are out of the box and kept current with standards approval. Also, metamodels can be extended to users specific requirements if needed through drag and drop modeling capability. Repository uses the metaclass Technique. Any Diagram Type is just an instance of Technique. Repository rerenders all objects in the context of a view structure dynamically with related objects in a variety of layout strategies, so xy coordinates of objects and line segments are not needed. However, Adaptive repository utilizes the Diagram Interchange metamodel which allows for all graphical properties and xy coordinates to be rerendered in SVG if the model is exported as xml and also exports the DI metamodel semantics. Adaptive also provides an robust modeling capabilty which allows any model and associated semantics to be imported in the web based application where workflow, colloabration, access control, and advanced analytics can be leveraged. There is an option to import just semantics if warranted. Repository rerenders all objects in the context of a view structure dynamically with related objects in a variety of layout strategies, so xy coordinates of objects and line segments are not needed. However, Adaptive repository utilizes the Diagram Interchange metamodel which allows for all graphical properties and xy coordinates to be rerendered in SVG if the model is exported as xml and also exports the DI metamodel semantics. The flexibility exists to have unique diagram Types which match exactly to the source imported diagram type, or to utilize the standard diagram types yes, the modeling capability and web based repository capability uses the metaclass Technique. Any Diagram Type is just an instance of Technique. Adaptive provided a set of Visio Templates in prior releases, but has not opted for a more robust round trip solution utilizing the Adaptive Modeler which contains the underlyting metamodels and analytics needed for advanced modeling. Also, extremely powerful for protyping and building new capability in the web application. yes, Adaptive utilizes UUIDs for every object as well as name and can match either on Name of object or UUID of object in case of name changes or duplicate names being acceptable yes, Matching the metamodel in focus, thus a relationship between parent and child might be an association, or it might be instantiated as an intermediate class with associations to the parent and child objects. A.17 Can other types of relationships supported be imported? Any set of metamodel classes and associations may be imported A.18 Can the tool handle conflicts? Fully supported. A.19 A.20 Is it possible to configure rules to resolve conflicting information being imported from multiple sources Are there any tools/functionality to enable the synchronisation of entities and/or relationships stored outside the tool (e.g. CMDB's, portfolio management tools, change management tools)? Any combination of metamodel constraints, scripting constraints, XSLT transformations as well as our advanced decision rules tables can be leveraged. Adaptive has performed hundreds of these integrations and provides the training and services to leverage third party toolsets with the Adaptive offerings. see the Adaptive Integrator datasheet for details on interoperabilty with third-party tools supported out the box.