Kan de holde til det? risikovurdering ved flytning af Bygdøys vikingeskibe

Transcription

1 Kan de holde til det? risikovurdering ved flytning af Bygdøys vikingeskibe Jesper Stub Johnsen Vicedirektør, Nationalmuseet Bevaring og Naturvidenskab 1 Kulturrådet og Norsk hermetikkmuseum, Stavanger, 4. februar 2015

2 Kan de holde til det? risikovurdering ved flytning af Bygdøys vikingeskibe Ekspertkomiteen bestod af: May Cassar, University College of London Ronald Brockius, Museum für Antike Schiffart, Mainz David Saunders, The British Museum Jesper Stub Johnsen, Nationalmuseet (chair) 2

3 Historisk Museum 3 05/02/2015 Risk assessment of four future scenarios for the Viking Ships and Assemblage, JSJ

4 Vikingskipshuset på Bygdøy 4 05/02/2015 Risk assessment of four future scenarios for the Viking Ships and Assemblage, JSJ

5 Vikingskipshuset på Bygdøy Oseberg, Gokstad, Tune Dyrehoveder Slæder 5 05/02/2015 Risk assessment of four future scenarios for the Viking Ships and Assemblage, JSJ

6 Alum-treated object from storage, showing the inner core that is now highly fragmented (darker brown). Outer surface is impregnated with alum (lighter brown). ph wood ca 1-2

7 Bygdøy vs Bjørvika Historisk Museum Vikingskipshuset på Bygdøy Forslag om nyt museum på Bjørvika 7 05/02/2015 Risk assessment of four future scenarios for the Viking Ships and Assemblage, JSJ

8 8 05/02/2015 Risk assessment of four future scenarios for the Viking Ships and Assemblage, JSJ

9 9 05/02/2015 Risk assessment of four future scenarios for the Viking Ships and Assemblage, JSJ

10 10 05/02/2015 Risk assessment of four future scenarios for the Viking Ships and Assemblage, JSJ

11 11 05/02/2015 Risk assessment of four future scenarios for the Viking Ships and Assemblage, JSJ

12 MANDATE Examine, in an international context, what can be accepted as reversible and irreversible damage to the Ships and Objects. Carry out a comprehensive assessment of the risks related to a possible relocation of the Viking Ships and Fragile Objects. If relocation is acceptable, assess and recommend practical implementation of a possible relocation and visualize all the aspects of a removal process. Calculate costs related to moving Ships and Objects, including the repair of damage to the Ships and Objects.

13 Vikingskipshuset på Bygdøy Oseberg, Gokstad, Tune Dyrehoveder Slæder 13 05/02/2015 Risk assessment of four future scenarios for the Viking Ships and Assemblage, JSJ

14 Samlingens værdi og skrøbelighed 14 05/02/2015 Risk assessment of four future scenarios for the Viking Ships and Assemblage, JSJ

15 15 05/02/2015 Risk assessment of four future scenarios for the Viking Ships and Assemblage, JSJ

16 Scenarier 1. Forblive på Bygdøy status quo 2. Nyt museumskompleks på Bygdøy efterfulgt af istandsættelse af eksisterende bygning 3. Istandsættelse af eksisterende bygning på Bygdøy 4. Nyt museum på Bjørvika 16 05/02/2015 Risk assessment of four future scenarios for the Viking Ships and Assemblage, JSJ

17 METODE 17 05/02/2015 Risk assessment of four future scenarios for the Viking Ships and Assemblage, JSJ

18 CCI Framework for Preservation of Museum Collections Risk Assessment 18 05/02/2015 Risk assessment of four future scenarios for the Viking Ships and Assemblage, JSJ

19 19 05/02/2015 Risk assessment of four future scenarios for the Viking Ships and Assemblage, JSJ

20 20 05/02/2015 Risk assessment of four future scenarios for the Viking Ships and Assemblage, JSJ

21 21 05/02/2015 Risk assessment of four future scenarios for the Viking Ships and Assemblage, JSJ

22 Selected issues from risk list Short term risks towards alum preserved objects R0087 R0090 R0096 R0088 Det Norske Veritas AS. All rights reserved.

23 23 05/02/2015 Risk assessment of four future scenarios for the Viking Ships and Assemblage, JSJ

24 Risici fordelt på type Short term Long term 24 05/02/2015 Risk assessment of four future scenarios for the Viking Ships and Assemblage, JSJ

25 25 05/02/2015 Risk assessment of four future scenarios for the Viking Ships and Assemblage, JSJ

26 Resultat af risikovurdering 26 05/02/2015 Risk assessment of four future scenarios for the Viking Ships and Assemblage, JSJ

27 Resultat af risikovurdering 27 05/02/2015 Risk assessment of four future scenarios for the Viking Ships and Assemblage, JSJ

28 Resultat af risikovurdering 28 05/02/2015 Risk assessment of four future scenarios for the Viking Ships and Assemblage, JSJ

29 Resultat af risikovurdering 29 05/02/2015 Risk assessment of four future scenarios for the Viking Ships and Assemblage, JSJ

30 Resultat af risikovurdering Every Scenario has risks that are considered to be critical. None of the Scenarios that are proposed for the improvement of the conditions can be completed without what the Expert Committee considrs to be critical short or long term risks 30 05/02/2015 Risk assessment of four future scenarios for the Viking Ships and Assemblage, JSJ

31 31 05/02/2015 Risk assessment of four future scenarios for the Viking Ships and Assemblage, JSJ

32 32 Hvorfor ikke Bjørvika?

33 33 05/02/2015 Risk assessment of four future scenarios for the Viking Ships and Assemblage, JSJ

34 34 05/02/2015 Risk assessment of four future scenarios for the Viking Ships and Assemblage, JSJ

35 35 jects/saving-oseberg/

36 Nytt Vikingetidsmuseum på Bygdøy 36

37 Den arkæologiske udgravning af Roskilde skibene Museumsøen i Roskilde under udgravningerne 1997 Werner Karrasch Vikingeskibsmuseet, Roskilde 37

38

39 39

40 København London Berlin 40

41 TAK FOR OPMÆRKSOMHEDEN 41