losure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized The World Bank Implementation Status & Results Brazil Second Bolsa Família (P101504) Operation Name: Second Bolsa Família (P101504) Project Stage: Implementation Seq.No: 7 Status: ARCHIVED Archive : 27-May-2014 Country: Brazil Approval FY: 2011 Product Line: IBRD/IDA Region: LATIN AMERICA AND CARIBBEAN Lending Instrument: Adaptable Program Loan Implementing Agency(ies): Key s Board Approval 16-Sep-2010 Original Closing 30-Dec-2015 Planned Mid Term Review 20-Jan-2014 Last Archived ISR 21-Oct-2013 Effectiveness 24-Nov-2011 Revised Closing 30-Dec-2015 Actual Mid Term Review 24-Mar-2014 Project Development Objectives Project Development Objective (from Project Appraisal Document) The objective of the Project is to strengthen the BF Program's ability to achieve its objective of reducing poverty and inequality and promoting human capital development by improving schooling and health status of children and reducing incidence of malnutrition among the poor population. The proposed operation would achieve this objective by supporting: (a) the strengthening of the program's overall governance through enhanced basic program management functions and accountability, oversight and control functions, in three axes: the registry of beneficiaries (Cadastro Unico), management of benefits, and monitoring of conditionalities; (b) the consolidation of the program?s monitoring and evaluation system; and (c) the strengthening of linkages between Bolsa Familia beneficiaries with complementary actions beyond the program to promote graduation from poverty; these activities would be carried out through the National Commitment for Social Development strategy in the MDS. Has the Project Development Objective been changed since Board Approval of the Project? Yes Component(s) No Component Name Component Cost Conditional Cash Transfers (Grants) 185.00 Strengthening Cadastro Unico as the Main Targeting Instrument for Social Programs 2.80 Institutional Strengthening for the Consolidation of the Bolsa Familia Program 4.60 Consolidation of the Monitoring and Evaluation System in the Ministry of Social Development 4.50 Supporting the National Commitment for Social Development (CNDS) 1.30 Operational Support to the Project Implementation Unit at the Ministry of Social Development 1.20 Overall Ratings Previous Rating Current Rating Progress towards achievement of PDO Satisfactory Satisfactory Overall Implementation Progress (IP) Satisfactory Satisfactory Page 1 of 7
Overall Risk Rating Previous Rating Current Rating Low Implementation Status Overview This is a Mid Term Review ISR, based on an implementation support mission that took place from March 24 28, 2014. To date, about US$189.5 million has been disbursed, corresponding to 94.5% of the total Project envelope. The Bolsa Familia program (PBF) has been consolidated as a fundamental pillar of the Brasil Sem Miseria Plan (BSM), the Brazilian government s national strategy for eradicating extreme poverty. The coverage of PBF increased from to 13.4 (Dic 2011) to 14.1 million families (Dec 2013) and the total budget for 2014 is R$ 24.7 billion. The average benefit per month per family increased from R$145 in 2012 to R$213 in 2013. The innovations implemented in PBF within the BSM context have had improved results. For example: (i) As a result of the active-search strategy (busca ativa) and other specific registration actions, a total of 1,046,279 families were added to the registry of beneficiaries (Cadastro Unico) by December 2013. Of this total, 129,550 were indigenous families, and 107,065 were Quilombola. (ii) The Ministry of Social Development (MDS), responsible for Project implementation, built a robust monitoring system based on the revised version of the Cadastro Unico. In order to strengthen the system for monitoring conditionalities and following up with families who have not complied, MDS also invested in improving the technical capacity of staff and the expansion of the social assistance network. Specifically, 1,191 mobile teams and 121 boats for these teams were made available and more schools that serve PBF beneficiaries joined complementary programs such as Mais Educação and Saúde na Escola. (iii) Resources to municipalities and states on the basis of the Decentralized Management Index (IGD) increased by 82%, with a total amount of R$560 million allocated by the MDS every year in support of decentralized management. (iv) Another innovation was the effort, under the BSM plan, to boost families income so that they could overcome the extreme poverty income threshold (set at R$70 per person per month). Accordingly, several measures were adopted: the BSM Plan adjusted the PBF benefit amounts; it increased the cap on the number of children and adolescents that could receive the variable benefit in each family; it began paying benefits to pregnant and lactating women; and, most importantly, it created a new benefit that closed the extreme poverty gap for all extremely poor families in the program. Through these measures, approximately 22 million people have overcome extreme poverty since the launch of the BSM Plan, from an income perspective. In addition, the BSM Plan continued to consolidate activities to promote the productive inclusion of the poor and vulnerable in the economic arena, in both urban and rural areas. As of March 2014, more than one million people had enrolled in the vocational training program PRONATEC-BSM; 364.2 thousand PBF beneficiaries participated in Programa de Microempreendedor Individual (MEI), a program for individual micro-entrepreneurs. Regarding productive inclusion in rural areas, 286.3 thousand PBF beneficiary households received technical assistance and resources for promoting rural production. In addition, 501.1 thousand water reservoirs were built in the semi-arid Northeast region of the country with the support of the Agua Para Todos Program (Water for All). The Project supports the objectives of the BSM and is on track to meet its development objectives and indicator targets. Locations No Location data has been entered Results Project Development Objective Indicators Page 2 of 7
Indicator Name Core Unit of Measure Baseline Current End Target Percentage of 16-17 year old youth in Percentage Value 75.00 83.50 85.00 beneficiary families attending school 31-Dec-2009 Information only available on 75% of beneficiaries. This is the best result we have since the start of monitoring this indicator. The improvement is due to the merge between MoE's Educational Census and BF's "Sistema Presença" administrative dataset. Data on 100% of beneficiaries. Primary school attendance of children of Percentage Value 85.00 94.00 90.00 extremely poor beneficiary families 30-Jun-2009 Percentage of children aged 0-6 and pregnant women in beneficiary families complying with heath conditionalities First semester information on 85% of beneficiaries shows compliance of 97% equivalent to 84% overall. This indicator covers children 6-15 years old (primary school age) who are eligible for the program. There was a 5 percentage points increase when compared to the same period in 2012. This is the best result we have since the start of monitoring this indicator. This improvement is due to the merge between MoE's Educational Census and BF's "Sistema Presença" administrative dataset. Percentage Value 63.00 73.44 75.00 30-Jun-2009 Information on 63% of beneficiaries shows 99% compliance giving overall 63%. At the end of the year 2013, based on the calculation of the 2nd semester of the health monitoring system of compliance were followed 73.44% of beneficiary households of BSF. The percentage obtained was higher than same period 2012, 0.31 percentage points. Page 3 of 7
Use of Cadastro Unico for targeting state level social programs Number Value 9.00 9.00 21.00 10-Jan-2011 This is the number of state governments using Cadastro Unico for targeting other programs than BF. In December 2013, there were 9 state governments using the Single Registry to target state level social programs. States and programs are: 1. Distrito Federal - DF Sem Miséria 2. Espírito Santo - Bolsa Capixaba 3. Mato Grosso - Panela Cheia. 4. Rio de Janeiro -Renda Melhor 5. Rio Grande do Sul - RS Mais Igual 6. Santa Catarina - Santa Renda 7. Paraná - Família Paranaense 8. Minas Gerais-Nova Lima - Vida Nova 9. Amazonas - Manaus - Bolsa Municipal There was a drop in this indicator because some state level cash transfer programs that used the Single Registry were incorporated into the BSM federal program, namely: Adjunto da Solidadariedade, Acre; Renda Cidadã, Goiás; Bolsa Futuro, Rondônia; and Renda Cidadã, São Paulo. The drop in the indicator was a result of the integration effort under the BSM plan. Transfer coverage in first quintile Percentage Value 50.00 81.56 75.00 31-Dec-2009 Pesquisa Nacional por Amostragem de Domicílios 81.56% of individuals among the 20% poorest of Brazil are Page 4 of 7
Intermediate Results Indicators (PNAD- the national household survey) PNAD 2006 in families receiving BF transfers. This indicator is calculated annuallybased on PNAD. The fall from 82.42% in 2011 to 81.56% in 2012 is a result of random statistical fluctuations. Indicator Name Core Unit of Measure Baseline Current End Target New IGD established and scores average Number Value 0.80 0.84 0.85 above 0.85 by the end of the program 31-Dec-2009 New Decentralized Management Index (IGD) has been implemented and scores are improving steadily. Number of beneficiary families Amount(USD) Value 12000000.00 13763134.00 12900000.00 30-Jun-2009 The unit of measure is number of families not amount (usd) Cadastro Único strengthened as the main Percentage Value 0.00 75.00 83.00 targeting instrument for social programs 31-Dec-2009 The indicator tracks the % of beneficiaries registered in Version 7 of Cadeunico The percentage of beneficiaries recorded above corresponds to those under the updated version of Cadastro Unico. As of Dec 2013, there were 27,200,920 households registered under Cadastro Unico, of which 18,694,662 were in version 7. Monitoring and Evaluation System of MDS Text Value System not consolidated Being consolidated Consolidated M&E System consolidated 23-Nov-2011 National Commitment for Social Development launched Text Value National Commitment for Social Development launched 20-Jan-2012 In the context of the new BSM A new indicator was agreed with MDS: number of effective Page 5 of 7
In-house DPI procurement and FM capacity strengthened (staff hired and trained) strategy the government wants to review this indicator. enrollments in PRONATEC/ BSM-FIC among the poor. The initial target was 267thousand enrollments by December 2013, which has been largely surpassed since the number of enrollments in Dec. 2013 was 900.8 thousand. The proposed changes in this indicator will be evaluated in the Project restructuring procedures. Text Value 0 0 5 31-Dec-2011 Number of training in procurement and FM The management team has not yet been hired. To date, the financial and contract management activities have been carried out by MDS s Directoriat for International Projects team; however, this has taken an extraordinary effort on the DIP team's part and for sustainability reasons, hiring of a fiduciary team is considered a priority. Data on Financial Performance (as of 17-Apr-2014) Financial Agreement(s) Key s Project Ln/Cr/Tf Status Approval Signing Effectiveness Original Closing Revised Closing P101504 IBRD-78410 Effective 16-Sep-2010 21-Sep-2011 24-Nov-2011 30-Dec-2015 30-Dec-2015 Disbursements (in Millions) Project Ln/Cr/Tf Status Currency Original Revised Cancelled Disbursed Undisbursed % Disbursed P101504 IBRD-78410 Effective USD 200.00 200.00 0.00 189.50 10.50 95.00 Disbursement Graph Page 6 of 7
Key Decisions Regarding Implementation No key decisions for disclosure beyond those mentioned above. Restructuring History There has been no restructuring to date. Related Projects There are no related projects. Page 7 of 7