GT Data Centre & Durabilité Gestion énergétique des Data Centres Jean-Marc Alberola, Airbus Industry Dominique Roche, ORANGE (copilote GT) The ICT Users Green Way S
Gestion energétique & Green ICT CTO Alliance gathers European ICT Users, major European Companies and European Governments. This User actor issues white papers and general rules for sustainable ICT, and implements a global process which supports Green development of ICT areas in European region: data centres, transmission nodes, fixe and mobile networks, customer networks CTO Alliance supports quick implementation of the Green process by high level commitment in order to ensure Green Way development of European countries European Green Users committee ETSI / ISG OEU (Industry Specification Group - Operational energy Efficiency for Users) declines CTO Alliance White Papers in official documents : Position Papers and Referential Specifications ISG OEU Position Papers defines ICT Users position on improvement and monitoring of Green ICT in order to propose these ones to European & International Standardisation Organizations and ITU CTO Alliance Gov European Standardisation Organizations CENELEC and ETSI as International Joint Committee ISO/IEC JTC1 develops Standards and ITU issues Recommendations supporting the Green process OEU Gov
Ecosystème européen pour Green ICT Deliverables EUROPEAN USERS FORUM CTO Alliance / CRIP WG Energy Efficiency & Carbon Footprint - White papers on sustainable ICT elements (e.g. ICT sites, equipment) EUROPEAN COMMISSION DG Connect & DG Enterprise INDUSTRY SPECIFICATION GROUP OPERATIONAL ENERGY EFFICIENCY FOR USERS ISG OEU ETSI & CTO Alliance/CRIP members Deliverables further to CTO Alliance proposal a) Guidance for implementation of efficient networks efficiency quality levels included (e.g. on Data centres) b) Position papers Technical Committee CENELEC/TC 215 ICT equipment & network installation Deliverables - EN 50 600 Series Design of Data centres - EN 50 174 Series Design & installation of & broadband networks Technical Committee ETSI ATTM Access Terminals Transmission & Multiplexing Transmission systems & Network Engineering Deliverables - ES 205 200 Series Definitions of KPIs to monitor energy efficiency improvement - TS 105 174 Series Broadband network general engineering Technical Committee ETSI EE Environmental Engineering Deliverables - ES 202 336-12 ICT equipment power monitoring - ES 202 706 Measurement methods of Energy Efficiency for radio access - ES 203 215 Measurement methods of Energy Efficiency for fixed broadband access Technical Committee ISO/IEC JTC1/SC39 ICT Sustainability Deliverables - Future standards on Design of Data Centres & Broadband network Technical Sub-Group ITU-T SG5 Energy & Environment Deliverables - R.1410 Methodology for assessment of ICT environmental impact for goods, networks & services - R.1420 Methodology for energy consumption and ICT greenhouse gas emissions impact assessment in organizations
Planification de la normalisation Green ICT (1) Field Domain INDUSTRY OPERATORS INCLUDED RESIDENTIAL HOME & SMALL / MEDIUM ENTERPRISES ICT USERS STRATEGY BY 12 /24 MONTHS [Target date for deliverable achievement # H2 2015] 100 90 80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 Works Topic User Ref Achieved On going First version Next one Gov Leader Data Centre General Engineering Build TS 105 174-2-2 2009 H2 2014 DC&S G. Gérard Objective & Global KPI s for Data Centre energy management monitoring Run ES 205 200-1 & -2-1 2013 H2 2014 DC&S G. Gérard Guidance defining Data Centre Global KPI DCEM and implementation Run GS OEU 001 2013 DC&S G. Gérard Sustainable ICT Data Centres installation / Facilities & infrastructures Build EN 50 600-1 & -2-1/-2-2 2013 DC&S G. Gérard Reduction of energy consumption in telecommunications equipment and related infrastructure Build TR 102 530 2011 DC&S tbd Better determination of equipment energy consumption for improved sizing of power plant Build TR 102 531 2007 DC&S tbd Use of alternative energy solutions in telecommunication installations Build TR 102 532 2012 DC&S tbd Guidance on Thermal Management of racks, cabinets and locations Build TR 102 489 2013 DC&S tbd Monitoring and Control Interface for Infrastructure Equipment series RFP ES 202 336-1 to -12 2011 2015 DC&S tbd Data Centre Referential Specification Build + RFP GS OEU 006 H2 2014 DC&S G. Gérard Sustainable ICT Nodes installation / Facilities & infrastructures Build EN 50 600-2-3/-2-4/ -2-5/-2-6 2015 DC&S G. Gérard Consumption measurement of servers Run GS OEU 003 H2 2014 H2 2015 DC&S G. Gérard Consumption measurement of storage Run GS OEU 0XX H2 2014 H2 2015 DC&S G. Gérard Gov for governance, that means one steering committee per quarter (DC&S=CTO Alliance/CRIP GT DC&D) Leader is the entity in charge to promote and publish relevant documents. Current status of work development & finalized Former status of work development & finalized 2010
Planification de la normalisation Green ICT (2) Field Domain ALL DOMAINS ICT USERS STRATEGY BY 12/24 MONTHS [Target date for deliverable achievement # H2 2015] 100 90 80 70 60 Works Topic Used by Ref First version Achieved Life Cycle Assessment of equipment, network and services RFP+Run TS 103 199 2011 2015 DC&S tbd To be fully implemented on the field in order to be efficient and avoid duplication of CTO Alliance On going Run H2 2015 DC&S tbd standards by internal specification development presentation Next one Gov Leader 50 40 30 20 10 Gov for governance, that means one steering committee per quarter (DC&S=CTO Alliance/CRIP GT DC&D) Leader is the entity in charge to promote and publish relevant documents. Current status of work development & finalized Former status of work development & finalized 2010
Protocoles de transmission données techniques (1) Etat des lieux des protocoles utilisés Besoins des utilisateurs Minimum de protocoles Interopérabilité totale de ceux opérationnels Proposition des utilisateurs et action
Protocoles de transmission données techniques (2) Questionnaire sur les protocoles de transmission des informations techniques Survey to support position paper about "Transmission protocol to transmit technical information for ICT site" ref. ETSI : TGS OEU-004_Survey version : V1.0 objective : to collect information from users about pratices to collect and monitor technical and energy data from IT equipments and facilities equipments used in Data Centres Demande faite aux membres CRIP de répondre à ce questionnaire Pour émettre un Position Paper poussant à minimiser le nombre de protocoles pouvant dialoguer entre eux réduire les coûts d exploitation
Reconnaissance du data centre "Green Label" (1) Dossier technique DCEM et son Référentiel annoncé Le Position Paper Européen sur le KPI Global GS OEU 001 soutenu par la Commission Européenne: Spécification des ICT User émise par le Comité ETSI ICT User OEU dont le Board est composé de membres CRIP et de représentants de la CE, définissant jauge et échelle de niveaux Green (voir transparent suivant) Sera disponible en français incluant un guide simple d application La Referential Specification définissant les règles et documents normatifs incontournables pour réaliser un Green DC (Durable)
Reconnaissance du data centre "Green Label" (2) Jauge & Echelle des Green DC Gauge DC G S M L XL KPI EC range KPI EC 1 GWh 1 GWh KPI EC 4 GWh 4 GWh KPI EC 20 GWh KPI EC 20 GWh Performance > < > < A 0,00 0,70 1,00 B 0,70 1,00 1,00 1,40 C 1,00 1,30 1,40 1,70 D 1,30 1,50 1,70 1,90 E 1,50 1,70 1,90 2,10 F 1,70 1,90 2,10 2,30 G 1,90 2,10 2,30 2,50 H 2,10 2,40 2,50 2,70 NOTE: Built after 2005 DCp Range I 2,40 2,70 Built before 2005 DCp Range Year 2005 is the year of Kyoto Protocol entering into force
Outil «Green Label» DC Name : Data Center Name 2 ENERGIES CONSUMPTIONS gauge Company : Company Name 2 KPI EC 61 KPI EC1 : 24 520 XL Zip Code : Zip Code 2 Country : Country 2 Class Built age : 1989 DC Area : 2462 m² Perf DCG : 2,08 E Tier Class : Tier III CR S : 404 m² TASK EFFICIENCY Assessment : mixed Ref. Year : 2012 date : 28/02/2013 KPI TE 2,08 Site Boundaries ENERGY REUSE W CRS : 1 KPI REUSE - W REUSE : 0,5 RENEWABLE ENERGY W REN : 0,5 KPI REN - The ICT Users Green Way S Grid Electricity EC DC : 24 520 MWh data Centre EC SP : 24 445 MWhe Annexes Local Non Renewable source EC FEN : 75 MWh Local Renewable source EC REN : MWh Data room EC HE : 11 810 MWhe Energy reuse EC RE : MWhth EC AUX : 12 635 MWh IT room floor space Density : 16 District or central cooling EC TH : MWhth X Kth : 0,37 = - MWhe EER 2,5 Losses 8 1
GT Data Centre & Durabilité Merci pour votre écoute et votre prochain soutien aux travaux du GT Data Centre & Durabilité où vous serez les bienvenus
Data Centre & Sustainability Annexes
Benchmarking of Green Users of ICT World Areas of the ICT world to be processed with - Sites including data centres & transmission nodes (e.g. fixed & mobile access, core) - Fixed & mobile networks Acknowledgement of quality level of ICT elements - Green quality level of networks (fixe, mobile) - Self-assessment SDML (Sustainable Digital Multi-service Label) - Green Label (Global KPIs & Carbon Ratio) - Green quality level of nodes ( data centres, transmission) - Self-assessment SDML (Sustainable Digital Multi-service Label) - Green Label (Global KPIs & Carbon Ratio) Global KPI for benchmarking of data centres & ICT sites Defined in ETSI GS OEU 001 & GS OEU 008 Taken into account standards ETSI ES 205 200-1 & ETSI ES 205 200-2-1
Global KPI of ICT sites Global KPI KPI DCEM = [ DC G ; DC P ] DC G defines the energy consumption gauge of the data centre or ICT site DC P defines the performance of the data centre or ICT site for the relevant gauge Gauge DC G With KPI EC Objective KPI for yearly "Energy Consumption" Gauge DC G KPI EC range S M L XL KPI EC 1 GWh 1 GWh KPI EC 4 GWh 4 GWh KPI EC 20 GWh KPI EC 20 GWh
Green Performance of ICT Sites Performance DC (1) P KPITE = new PUE DC KPI 1 W KPI 1 W P TE KPI REUSE REUSE REN With KPITE Objective KPI for "Task Efficiency" (1) (ratio of electricity consumption of all components) REN WREUSE KPIREUSE WREN KPIREN Mitigation factor for KPIREUSE Objective KPI for "Energy Reuse" Mitigation factor for KPIREN Objective KPI for "Renewable Energy" Built after 2005 DCp Range Performance > < > < A 0,00 0,70 1,00 B 0,70 1,00 1,00 1,40 C 1,00 1,30 1,40 1,70 D 1,30 1,50 1,70 1,90 E 1,50 1,70 1,90 2,10 F 1,70 1,90 2,10 2,30 G 1,90 2,10 2,30 2,50 H 2,10 2,40 2,50 2,70 NOTE: I 2,40 2,70 Built before 2005 DCp Range Year 2005 is the year of Kyoto Protocol entering into force
Operational Goals of ICT World Carbon Emissions & Total Energy Consumption Ratios for carbon emissions and best practices to use it In order to monitor carbon emissions Global key performance indicators (KPIs) Global Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) on Energy Management monitoring and best practices to use it In order to be able to monitor energy management Operational architecture of deployed networks Description of efficient General Engineering of operating sites and networks In order to optimize their "green" performance and technology improvement for "sustainable" services, "Green" Labels included Definition of general rules for implementation of sites and networks In order to support operational deployment of sustainable sites & networks Energy consumption measurement Definition of field methods of energy consumption measurement In order to support operational monitoring of energy consumption Energy Efficient Equipment Energy efficient equipment to reduce energy consumption In order to improve efficiency of equipment by mean of Guidance and recommendations
Data Centre & Sustainability Merci