European Resilient Floorcovering : an industry s approach to LCA and EPD ERFMI Study 1
LCA and EPD for RESILIENT FLOORCOVERING AGENDA WHO IS ERFMI? AIMS OF THE STUDY METHODOLOGY, STEPS, CHOICES RESULTS FOR ERFMI MEMBERS FOR BUILDING DESIGNERS Web site 2
WHO IS ERFMI? European Resilient flooring Manufacturer s industry European trade association for smooth flexible floorings The floorings are from vinyl, linoleum, rubber > 90% of West European resilient contract building flooring > 75% of West European domestic resilient flooring 3
WHO IS ERFMI? ERFMI members: ALTRO Group (UK) AMTICO Company Ltd (UK) ARMSTRONG DLW AG (D) BONAR FLOORS Ltd (UK) FATRA as. (CZ) FORBO International SA (CH) NORA (D) GERFLOR SA (F) LENTEX SA (PL) MONDO Spa (I) POLYFLOR Ltd (UK) UPOFLOOR Oy (FIN) TARKETT AG (F) / TARKETT-MARLEY Ltd 4
ERFMI STATEMENT ERFMI believes that Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) is important : To establish all environmental impacts To identify any areas where improvements need to be made In 1994-1996, ERFMI asked Fraunhofer Institute (D) to carry out a first study on environmental impact of their products based on life cycle analysis. In 2005 a Updated study was decided. 5
AIMS OF THE STUDY? FOR BUILDING DESIGNER Provide averaged environmental information on typical products Provide EPDs in accordance with ISO 14000 series and European EPD draft (see CEN TC350) FOR FLOORING MANUFACTURERS Provide eco-design tool for internal, individual improvement Know personal status in comparison to others (benchmarking) 6
KEY CONDITIONS TO SUCCEED (1/2) UNANIMOUS WILLING OF EACH ERFMI MEMBERS STEERING COMMITTEE PVC, linoleum, rubber manufacturer representative To define planning, functional unit, system boundaries, weighted data, etc. To settle the common rules : cleaning procedure, life time, etc. LCA AND ECO-DESIGN SOFTWARE AND DATABASE EXPERT (PE International) 7
KEY CONDITIONS TO SUCCEED (2/2) INDEPENDANT WORKING GROUP LEADER To gather the needed data through the ERFMI members, To guaranty the confidential data between each participant, To aggregate these data To be an interface between ERFMI members and PE International Time and budget resources 2 years Initial external budget: >150K 8
SIZE OF THE PROJECT 10 product families 7 PVC 1 Rubber 1 linoleum 1 synthetic thermoplastic Individual recipes with 10 to 30 components 64 Participant data sets to be collected Data set could be an average from various plants 9
TYPICAL PRODUCT FAMILY Homogeneous PVC floor coverings (EN 649 Heterogeneous PVC floor coverings (EN 649) Semi flexible PVC tiles (EN 654) PVC floor coverings with foam layer (EN 651) Cushioned PVC floor coverings (EN 653) Printed Laminate PVC floor coverings (EN 649) PVC safety floor (EN 13845) Smooth rubber floor coverings (EN 1817) Plain and decorative linoleum (EN 548) 10
TYPICAL PRODUCT FAMILY PER MANUFACTURER ARMSTRONG AMTICO ALTRO BONARFLOR FATRA FORBO GERFLOR LENTEX POLYFLOOR SATHIS TARKETT UPOFLOOR FREUDENBERG MONDO TOTAL EN 649 HOMOGENEOUS PVC 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 7 EN 649 HETEROGENEOUS PVC 1 1 1 1 1 1 6 EN 13845 SAFETY PVC 1 1 1 1 1 1 6 EN 654 SEMI FLEXIBLE PVC 1 1 1 1 4 EN 649 PRINTED LAMINATED PVC 1 1 1 2 5 EN 653 CUSHIONED PVC 1 1 1 1 1 5 EN 651 PVC WITH FOAM BACKING 1 1 1 1 1 1 6 EN 14565 SYNTH. THERMOPLASTIC 1 1 2 EN 548 LINOLEUM 1 1 1 3 EN 1817 RUBBER SMOOTH 1 1 2 11
PROJECT OVERVIEW A B C D E Manufacturer generate datasets Data acquisition Plausibility check, Neutralisation, calculating average data, weighting by market average Independent consultant Model with individual data LCA for flooring products Generation of a Model in GaBi 4 Software Export via gbm-file GaBi Software Model with average data of product group PE International carries out the LCA study, model design, generates EPD report Eco design tool internal use EPD report external use 12
METHODOLOGY: data collection Manufacture Use EoL Recipe with ingredients Substrates/ other layers Transport Transport Coating, calendering, pressing Transport Installation loss + adhesive at laying Transport Transport Mechanical recycling Incineration Auxiliaries Energies with regional reference Cleaning regime Transport Landfill 13
METHODOLOGY: Key points (1/2) Functional Unit: 1 sqm installed Manufacturer data sheet collection must cover more than 70% of the production for each typical family Emission in water, ground or air Confidential formulation or process trick Transport Option road, rail or sea Transport of raw materials to production site: for the 10 more used per each typical family Transport to laying site: average distance for each ERFMI member typical product, weighted with the market share 14
METHODOLOGY: Key points (2/2) Common installation laying condition for each PVC, linoleum and rubber floor covering Common cleaning procedure for the 3 type of products (PVC, lino and rubber) 15
16
METHODOLOGY: Key points (2/2) End of life scenarios: 20% landfill, 80% incineration Declaration of all dangerous substances as per European EPD draft 17
METHODOLOGY: MAIN DIFFICULTIES Industry data collection : unit use: kwh / Kcal, % / pcr, etc Data sheet collection with 2 steps for missing data Steering comity : Pre set recipe and process data collection sheets Cleaning procedure PE International End of life scenarios Environmental data for agricultural components or chemical additives 18
METHODOLOGY: IMPACT CATEGORIES Abbreviations AP = Acidification potential (kg SO2 equiv) EP = Eutrophication Potential (kg PO4 equiv) GWP = Global Warming Potential (kg CO2 equiv) ODP = Ozone Depletion Potential (kg R11 equiv) POCP = Photochemical Ozone Creation Potential (kg C2H4 equiv) 19
RESULTS INFORMATIONS AND BENEFITS FOR INTERNAL ERFMI MEMBERS USE Eco-design tool 20
21
22
23
24
RESULTS INFORMATIONS AND BENEFITS FOR BUILDING DESIGNERS, ARCHITECTS The flooring replacement interval is dependent on many variables which are outside the resilient flooring manufacturer influence. It is therefore not possible to provide a single representative figure for an individual flooring type EPD: (Environmental Information Sheet) On line Eco design tool demo 25
30
Thanks to ERFMI LCA Steering Committee 31