Protein Purification Workflow Development Using Bio-Rad s NGC Chromatography System and Stain-Free Gel Technology

Similar documents
Transforming a ChromLab Software 2-D Purification Template into an Automated Multidimensional (Multi-D) Purification Workflow An Instructional Guide

Image Lab Software for the GS-900 Densitometer

Image Lab Software How to Obtain Stain-Free Gel and Blot Images. Instructions

ProteinChip Energy Absorbing Molecules (EAM)

Accelerated Electrophoresis with Faster Run Times and Increased Sample Throughput

ENrich SEC 70 ENrich SEC 650 High-Resolution Size Exclusion Columns Instruction Manual

Application Note. USD 2995 (a) High Throughput Regeneration Study on MEP HyperCel Mixed-Mode Sorbent on ScreenExpert RoboColumns u

TECHNICAL BULLETIN. HIS-Select Nickel Affinity Gel. Catalog Number P6611 Storage Temperature 2 8 C

POROS CaptureSelect affinity columns for highspeed quantification of IgG Fc fusion proteins

Choose your optimal tools for protein studies

Aurum Ion Exchange Mini Kits and Columns. Instruction Manual

Efficient Multi-Well Protein Purification Strategies

Computer Specifications

Cell Sorting. S3e Cell Sorter Quick Guide

Automated Method Development Utilizing Software-Based Optimization and Direct Instrument Control

amplification tech Optical Design of CFX96 Real-Time PCR Detection System Eliminates the Requirement of a Passive Reference Dye

HiPer Ion Exchange Chromatography Teaching Kit

How To Install A Gel Doc Xr+ Camera On A Computer Or Mouse Or Tv (For A Powerbook) With A Zoom Lens (For An Ipa) With An Iphone Or Ipa (For Mac) With The Zoom Lens

Expression Proteomics // Tools for Protein Separation and Analysis. 2-D Electrophoresis. Tools for Rapid, High-Resolution Protein Separations

Foreign Taxes Paid and Foreign Source Income INTECH Global Income Managed Volatility Fund

Installation Qualification/Operational Qualification Protocols and Instructions. Experion Automated Electrophoresis Station and Software

50 g 650 L. *Average yields will vary depending upon a number of factors including type of phage, growth conditions used and developmental stage.

Affi-Prep Protein A Matrix Instruction Manual

The Theory of HPLC. Gradient HPLC

A Complete Solution for Method Linearity in HPLC and UHPLC

EZ-Run Protein Gel Solution. EZ-Run Protein Standards. EZ-Run Gel Staining Solution. Traditional SDS-Page Reagents. Protein Electrophoresis

Recent advances in the purification of IgM monoclonal antibodies

Configuring DHCP for ShoreTel IP Phones

Lab 10: Bacterial Transformation, part 2, DNA plasmid preps, Determining DNA Concentration and Purity

Determination of Pesticide Residues in Drinking Water Using Automated Solid-Phase Extraction and Gas Chromatography with Nitrogen Phosphorus Detection

Gel Filtration Standard

What is Eluent Generation?

Bio-Rad Laboratories. QC data management solutions. Introduce Your Laboratory to a Whole New World of Unity Data Management Solutions

INSTRUCTIONS Edition AC

QIAGEN Supplementary Protocol

His GraviTrap. GE Healthcare. Operation

Method Development for Size-Exclusion Chromatography of Monoclonal Antibodies and Higher Order Aggregates

POROS CaptureSelect affinity columns for rapid, small-scale purification and sample preparation of recombinant proteins

Process-scale purification of monoclonal antibodies polishing using Capto Q

relating to household s disposable income. A Gini Coefficient of zero indicates

Application Note. Separation of three monoclonal antibody variants using MCSGP. Summary

Diafiltration: A Fast, Efficient Method for Desalting, or Buffer Exchange of Biological Samples

Application Note. Purifying common light-chain bispecific antibodies using MCSGP. Summary

THE WORLD S LEADING CAR DESIGN MAGAZINE

IOOF QuantPlus. International Equities Portfolio NZD. Quarterly update

Thermo Scientific Dionex Chromeleon 7 Chromatography Data System Software

What Is the Total Public Spending on Education?

MLX BCG Buccal Cell Genomic DNA Extraction Kit. Performance Characteristics

[NUGENESIS SAMPLE MANAGEMENT ] AMPLE IMPROVING LAB EFFICIENCY, ANAGEMENT ACCELERATING BUSINESS DECISIONS. bigstock.com $69

GRS Plasmid Purification Kit Transfection Grade GK (2 MaxiPreps)

World Consumer Income and Expenditure Patterns

Guide to Reverse Phase SpinColumns Chromatography for Sample Prep

QIAsymphony RGQ Protocol Sheet

Purification of GST-tagged Proteins

AT-S39 Version 1.3 Management Software for the AT-8024 and AT-8024GB Fast Ethernet Switches. Software Release Notes

Supported Payment Methods

[ Care and Use Manual ]

Integrating CaliberRM with Software Configuration Management Tools

Updating the QIAcube operating software

High-Throughput 3-D Chromatography Through Ion Exchange SPE

EZ Load Molecular Rulers. Catalog Numbers bp bp bp PCR bp kb Precision Mass

OCTOBER Russell-Parametric Cross-Sectional Volatility (CrossVol ) Indexes Construction and Methodology

The fastest spin-column based procedure for purifying up to 10 mg of ultra-pure endotoxin-free transfection-grade plasmid DNA.

41 T Korea, Rep T Netherlands T Japan E Bulgaria T Argentina T Czech Republic T Greece 50.

Thermo Scientific Prelude SPLC System FPO. Making LC/MS accessible. to clinical research and toxicology labs

Reporting practices for domestic and total debt securities

Chem 405 Biochemistry Lab I Experiment 2 Quantitation of an unknown protein solution.

Report on Government Information Requests

einvoice A fully automated digital solution for companies of all sizes

Supported Payment Methods

Appendix 1: Full Country Rankings

Protein extraction from Tissues and Cultured Cells using Bioruptor Standard & Plus

Rapid GST Inclusion Body Solubilization and Renaturation Kit

ProteoMiner Protein Enrichment Kits

Single Step Clarification & Capture of a Recombinant Protein from E. coli Osmotic Shock by Crossflow Chromatography

What Proportion of National Wealth Is Spent on Education?

Selective Testosterone Analysis in Human Serum by LC-FAIMS-MS/MS

UltraClean Soil DNA Isolation Kit

Quantum View Manage Administration Guide

Chromatin Immunoprecipitation

Report on Government Information Requests

BT Premium Event Call and Web Rate Card

HighPure Maxi Plasmid Kit

Thermo Scientific icap 7000 Series ICP-OES. Low cost ICP-OES analysis high quality data

Thermo Scientific SOLAµ SPE Plates Technical Guide. Consistent excellence. for bioanalysis

IMD World Talent Report. By the IMD World Competitiveness Center

LC-MS/MS Method for the Determination of Docetaxel in Human Serum for Clinical Research

Pall in the Brewery (more value per hectolitre) DE Free Clarification FB1795

UltraClean PCR Clean-Up Kit

The Role of Banks in Global Mergers and Acquisitions by James R. Barth, Triphon Phumiwasana, and Keven Yost *

Glutathione Resin. User Manual. User Manual. Cat. Nos , , PT (071414)

How To Get A New Phone System For Your Business

How To Use An Enzymatics Spark Dna Sample Prep Kit For Ion Torrent

1.5 GHz Active Probe TAP1500 Datasheet

NimbleGen DNA Methylation Microarrays and Services

Bio-Plex Analysis Software

Access the world. with Schwab Global Investing Services

E-Seminar. Financial Management Internet Business Solution Seminar

Classic Immunoprecipitation

Application Guide... 2

Transcription:

Protein Purification Workflow Development Using Bio-Rad s NGC Chromatography System and Stain-Free Gel Technology Paul Ng, Kiran Kaur, Jonathan Kohn, Anna Quinlan, and Jeff Habel Bio-Rad Laboratories, Inc., 00 Alfred Nobel Drive, Hercules, CA, USA Tech Note Protein Purification Bulletin 630 Abstract High purity protein is a common requirement for biochemical and structural studies. A common approach is to recombinantly express an affinity-tagged version of the protein of interest. This is, however, not always a viable option. Here we discuss protein purification workflow development for untagged proteins using Bio-Rad s NGC Chromatography System and stain-free gel technology and introduce a new indicator of method performance, the purity quotient difference (PQD). Introduction High purity protein samples are essential for applications from protein structure determination and biochemical characterization to antibody production. A standard purification approach is the use of affinity tags such as hexahistidine (6x histidine) or glutathione-s-transferase (GST) tags. These tags increase the throughput and efficiency of the protein purification workflow, as protocols are often readily available or supplied by the manufacturer. ph, and buffer scouting when developing purification workflows and illustrate how the Bio-Rad NGC Chromatography System and ChromLab Software facilitate this process and make untagged proteins of high purity attainable for every researcher. Additionally, we illustrate the value of stain-free SDS-PAGE during workflow development for visual confirmation of each step with respect to purity, molecular weight, and impurities. Finally, we introduce the PQD calculation as a way to monitor method performance for purification of fluorescent proteins. Affinity tagging is not always a viable option. Some proteins are unstable or inactive once tagged or require posttranslational modifications that do not permit recombinant expression. In these cases, researchers often settle for lower purity protein rather than exhaustively explore purification options, since the purification optimization process can be time and labor intensive when no particular column resins or buffer conditions are dictated by an affinity tag. Sample Column Scouting ph %B Whether purifying tagged or untagged proteins, an optimal purification workflow includes column, ph, and elution buffer gradient (%B) optimization for each purification step followed by visual confirmation of the chromatographic results using SDS-PAGE (Figure 1). Here we show that the medium-pressure Bio-Rad NGC Chromatography System, equipped with column switching valve, sample pump, buffer blending valve, and the ChromLab Software scouting feature, allows us to automate the process of column, ph, and %B optimization. Using the untagged, chromogenic protein, prancer purple, we illustrate that small changes in column chemistry or ph have drastic effects on protein binding and changes in the elution buffer ph or gradient can greatly impact purity of the eluted protein. Our findings cement the importance of column, Visual confirmation via stain-free SDS-PAGE ~30 min Separate and visualize Fig. 1. Protein purification workflow scouting. %B Separate and visualize Volume ~30 min ~30 min Separate and visualize

Materials and Methods Protein Expression The kanamycin-resistant prancer purple expression vector (DNA 2.0) was transformed into HB1 E. coli using the standard heat shock method. A single colony was picked into ml LB supplemented with kanamycin (LB/kan) and grown overnight at C. Cells were then pelleted using an Eppendorf 804 Centrifuge (rotor A-4-44) at 4,000 rpm (2,880 RCF) for min, resuspended in ml of fresh LB/kan, and inoculated into 1 L of LB/kan. Cultures were grown at C on a shaker set to 0 rpm. Prancer purple expression was induced when cultures reached an OD 600 of 0.4, by adding IPTG to a final concentration of 0.1 mm. After overnight induction, cells were harvested by centrifugation with a Sorvall SA-600 Rotor at,000 rpm (14,00 RCF) for min. Kanamycin was used at a concentration of 0 μg/ml for liquid and solid phase growth. Cell Lysis Cell pellets were resuspended in ml B-PER Lysis Buffer (Pierce cat. #78243) supplemented with μl of 1 mg/ml DNase I and 0 μl of 1 M MgCl 2. Lysates were clarified by centrifugation at,000 rpm (14,00 RCF) for min. Column Scouting Bio-Rad s NGC Discover System was used for all chromatography. Three 1 ml anion exchange chromatography columns, Foresight Nuvia Q, Bio-Scale Mini UNOsphere Q, and Bio-Scale Mini Macro-Prep High Q, and a ml Bio-Scale Mini CHT Type II Chromatography Column were attached to different positions on the NGC Column Switching Valve. The ion exchange scouting method was generated in ChromLab Software. Using the buffer blending valve, stock solutions Q1 (0.2 M HCl), Q2 (0.2 M Tris), Q3 (water), and Q4 (4 M NaCl) were mixed to generate buffer A (0 mm Tris ph 7.) and buffer B (0 mm Tris ph 7. and 1 M NaCl). The scout feature was used to scout four columns attached to different positions of the column switching valve. Clarified lysate was diluted threefold with water and 1 ml of diluted lysate was directly injected onto the columns using the sample pump. Columns were equilibrated for column volumes (CV) with buffer A. Approximately 1 ml of sample was applied to the columns. The columns were then washed with ml of buffer A and protein was eluted with a CV linear gradient from 0 0% B followed by a CV 0% B wash. After the linear gradient, the columns were stripped and re-equilibrated with a CV 0% B wash, followed by a CV buffer A wash. All purification steps were carried out at a 1 ml/min flow rate. Fractions from each run were analyzed by SDS-PAGE. ph Scouting Once the Foresight Nuvia Q Column was selected as the first column, the ChromLab Software scout feature was set to the ph scouting option. Binding was assessed at ph 7.0, 7., 8.0, and 8.. 1 ml of diluted lysate was directly injected onto the Foresight Nuvia Q Column at each ph during the method using the sample pump. Approximately 0.2 ml fractions were collected from each run and analyzed by SDS-PAGE. %B Scouting After ph 7. was selected, the scout feature was used to optimize %B. The CV linear gradient portion of the elution phase was selected for the %B scouting (, 30, 40, and 0 final %B). 1 ml of diluted lysate was directly injected onto the Foresight Nuvia Q Column at each ph using the sample pump. 0.2 ml fractions were collected from each run and analyzed by SDS-PAGE. CHT Ceramic Hydroxyapatite Chromatography The pooled Foresight Nuvia Q fractions were diluted twofold with water. The buffer system on the Bio-Rad NGC Discover System was changed to phosphate (Q1 = 0.2 M sodium phosphate monobasic and Q2 = 0.2 M sodium phosphate dibasic) and ml of sample were loaded onto a ml Bio-Scale Mini CHT Type II Column pre-equilibrated with 0 mm sodium phosphate ph 7. Protein was eluted with a CV linear gradient from 0 0% B and 1 ml fractions were collected. ENrich SEC 70 Chromatography The pooled CHT fractions were concentrated to 0 µl (~-fold) using a Millipore K Concentrator. The sample was then injected via static loop onto an ENrich SEC 70 Size Exclusion Column pre-equilibrated with 0 mm sodium phosphate and 0 mm NaCl (% B). Protein was eluted using isocratic flow for 1.2 CV. 1 ml fractions were collected and analyzed by SDS-PAGE. Stain-Free SDS-PAGE Analysis For all chromatography scouting, samples were analyzed by SDS-PAGE on Any kd Criterion TGX Stain-Free Gels. Gels were run for 30 min at 300 ma/gel and then immediately imaged using the ChemiDoc Imaging System. Purity Quotient Calculations Data for individual scouting runs were opened in the evaluation tab of the ChromLab Software (Figure 2C). Peak integration was performed on the 280 and 2 nm traces. The table in the fractions tab containing peak area and peak relative area was imported into Microsoft Excel. The purity quotient (PQ) for each wavelength was calculated by dividing the relative area (%) by the collected volume (ml). The purity quotient difference for prancer purple (PQD PP ) was calculated for each fraction as PQ 2 PQ 280 and graphed as a histogram. Histograms of the runs for each scouting type (column, ph, and %B) were graphed together for analysis. PQD equations: PQ = Relative Area (%)/Collected Volume (ml) PQ POI PQ contaminant = PQD PQD > 0: more of the protein of interest (POI) than contaminants PQD < 0: more contaminants than POI PQD = 0: POI is present in equal amount as contaminants 14 Bio-Rad Laboratories, Inc. Bulletin 630

A l 3 (280 nm), mau 2,000 1,000 0 1,000 Overlay Trace Comparison 1 0 4 8 12 16 24 28 32 36 40 44 48 2 Volume, ml n l 3 (280 nm) Macro-Prep n l 3 (280 nm) Nuvia Q n l 3 (280 nm) UNOsphere n l 4 (2 nm) Macro-Prep n l 4 (2 nm) Nuvia Q n l 4 (2 nm) UNOsphere n Conductivity UNOsphere D PQD value 0 Ft 1 Column wash 0 0% B gradient 0% B 0% 0% B B 9 13 17 21 2 29 33 41 4 49 3 7 61 6 69 73 77 81 8 89 93 97 1 9 113 117 121 12 129 133 1 141 14 149 3 7 161 B MW, kd S L 6 Nuvia Q UNOsphere Q Macro-Prep High Q 84 86 88 133 134 14 146 6 84 86 88 136 1 144 14 91 93 9 140 144 6 Fraction number 20 0 0 7 0 2 Fig. 2. Column scouting. A, offset chromatogram overlays of prancer purple column scouting runs. Total protein, 280 nm traces of Macro-Prep Q (n), Nuvia Q (n), and UNOsphere Q (n) runs are overlaid with the prancer purple absorbance trace at 2 nm (n). B, Stain-free SDS-PAGE analysis of column scouting. µl of each fraction was loaded on a 26-well Any kd Criterion TGX Stain-Free Gel. The prancer purple E. coli lysate (L) was diluted 1: before loading µl. Prancer purple molecular weight: 26.4 kd. S, Precision Plus Protein Unstained Standard. C, ChromLab Software evaluation of the Nuvia Q Column scouting run. The fractions tab in the peak integration menu shows the 2 nm fraction heat map and data table. The table contains the calculated relative area and collected volume for each fraction, which is used to calculate the purity quotient. D, histogram of the prancer purple purity quotient difference (PQ2 PQ280) per fraction from each column scouting run. UNOsphere Q (n); Nuvia Q (n); Macro-Prep Q (n). C Prancer Purple Binding % Calculations Individual column scouting runs were opened in the evaluation tab of the ChromLab Software. Peak integration with using default settings was performed on the 2 nm trace. Switching to the manual integration tab, the peak list for each run was reduced to three peaks (flowthrough, elution, and 0% B) with the following start and end volumes: flowthrough 0.98 7.39 ml, elution 22.17 31.82 ml, and strip 4.49 2.41 ml. Results Column Scouting Identifies Optimal Resin for Protein Binding Untagged prancer purple was expressed recombinantly in E. coli. Prancer purple has a predicted isoelectric point (pi) of 6.6 and the chosen lysis buffer a ph of 7., making anion exchange an excellent first step in our purification workflow. Bio-Rad has a number of different anion exchange resins of various bead sizes and chemistries. We chose a larger bead size that could accommodate faster flow rates with our highly viscous crude lysate sample. 14 Bio-Rad Laboratories, Inc. Bulletin 630

Three 1 ml anion exchange chromatography columns, Foresight Nuvia Q, Bio-Scale Mini UNOsphere Q, and Bio-Scale Mini Macro-Prep High Q, were attached to different ports of the NGC Column Switching Valve. A single method was generated in ChromLab Software specifying identical buffer conditions and flow rate for all three columns. Selecting the column variable in the ChromLab Software scout feature allowed us to assess protein binding under identical sample and chromatography conditions. An automated queue of the three runs was made possible by using the NGC Sample Pump to directly inject the sample onto the column during the sample application phase and by automatically assigning collected fractions during elution to the appropriate column scouting run. Even though all three resins are anion exchange resins, marked differences in their ability to bind prancer purple were observed, most likely due to differences in bead chemistries. Looking at the relative area percentages (Table 1), prancer purple bound most efficiently to Foresight Nuvia Q Resin, less efficiently to Bio-Scale Mini UNOsphere Q Resin, and did not bind to Bio-Scale Mini Macro-Prep High Q Resin (Figure 2). The calculated purity quotient difference for prancer purple (PQD PP ) and SDS-PAGE data supported the conclusion that Foresight Nuvia Q was the best resin choice for the first step of the prancer purple purification workflow. Table 1. Prancer purple relative area percentages. Start, ml End, ml Relative Area, % Run: Macro-Prep Flowthrough 0.98 7.39.44 Elution (0 0% B) 22.17 31.82 36.2 0% B 4.49 2.41 8.36 Run: Nuvia Q Flowthrough 0.98 7.39 2.63 Elution (0 0% B) 22.17 31.82 67.67 0% B 4.49 2.41 6.7 Run: UNOsphere Flowthrough 0.98 7.39 33.68 Elution (0 0% B) 22.17 31.82 61.04 0% B 4.49 2.41.28 ph Scouting Identifies Optimal Binding ph With the best column resin chosen, we next optimized the method s buffer ph. Since ph affects the ionization status of proteins, it is a particularly crucial factor in ion exchange chromatography. Utilizing the buffer blending valve and the ph scouting option in the ChromLab Software scout feature, we tested binding of prancer purple to Foresight Nuvia Q Resin over a ph range from 7.0 8. in an automated queue of four runs. Although prancer purple bound to the Foresight Nuvia Q Resin at every tested ph, at higher ph more impurities bound to the columns (Figure 3). To minimize impurities, a buffer ph of 7. was chosen. A 1,302. Overlay Trace Comparison 1 C Ft Column wash 0 0% B gradient 0% B wash l 3 (280 nm), mau 902. 02. 2. 297. 0 4 8 12 16 24 28 32 36 40 44 48 2 6 Volume, ml PQD value n l 3 (280 nm) ph 7.0 n l 3 (280 nm) ph 7. n l 3 (280 nm) ph 8.0 n l 3 (280 nm) ph 8. n l 4 (2 nm) ph 7.0 n l 4 (2 nm) ph 7. n l 4 (2 nm) ph 8.0 n l 4 (2 nm) ph 8. 0 1 3 7 9 11 13 17 19 21 23 2 27 29 31 33 3 39 41 43 4 47 49 1 3 7 9 61 63 6 67 69 71 73 7 77 79 81 B ph 7.0 ph 7. ph 8.0 ph 8. L 39 41 43 3 39 41 38 40 42 44 40 42 44 46 S MW, kd 20 0 0 7 0 2 Fraction number Fig. 3. ph scouting. A, offset chromatogram overlays of prancer purple ph scouting runs. Total protein, 280 nm traces of ph 7.0 (n), 7. (n), 8.0 (n), and 8. (n) are overlaid with the prancer purple absorbance trace at 2 nm (n). B, Stain-free SDS-PAGE analysis of ph scouting. µl of each fraction was loaded on an 18-well Any kd Criterion TGX Stain-Free Gel. The prancer purple E. coli lysate (L) was diluted 1: before loading µl. Prancer purple molecular weight: 26.4 kd. S, Precision Plus Protein Unstained Standard. C, histogram of the prancer purple purity quotient difference (PQ2 PQ280) per fraction from each ph scouting run. ph 7.0 (n), 7. (n), 8.0 (n), and 8. (n). 14 Bio-Rad Laboratories, Inc. Bulletin 630

%B Scouting Identifies Optimal Elution Buffer Concentration and Gradient Once an optimal ph was established for prancer purple binding, we optimized the elution step to separate prancer purple from remaining contaminants. Using the %B scouting option of ChromLab Software, we assayed a CV elution gradient from 0% final %B in four separate runs. The shallowest buffer gradient, 0 % B, resulted in optimal enrichment of prancer purple (Figure 4A, B). Some high and low molecular weight contaminants were still present, leading us to add additional purification steps to our workflow (Figure 4B). C PQD value 0 1 3 7 9 11 13 17 19 21 23 2 27 29 31 33 3 39 41 43 4 47 49 1 3 7 9 61 63 6 67 69 71 73 7 77 79 81 A Overlay Trace Comparison 1 Fraction number l 3 (280 nm), mau 969 69 169 Fig. 4. %B scouting. A, offset chromatogram overlays of prancer purple %B scouting runs. Total protein, 280 nm traces of the CV gradient elution to a final %B of % (n), 30% (n), 40% (n), and 0% (n) are overlaid with the prancer purple absorbance trace at 2 nm (n). B, Stain-free SDS- PAGE analysis of %B scouting. µl of each fraction was loaded on an 18-well Any kd Criterion TGX Stain-Free Gel. The prancer purple E. coli lysate (L) was diluted 1: before loading µl. Prancer purple molecular weight: 26.4 kd. S, Precision Plus Protein Unstained Standard. C, histogram of the prancer purple purity quotient difference (PQ2 PQ280) per fraction from each %B scouting run. % B (n), 30% B (n), 40% B (n), and 0% B (n). B 231 24 28 32 36 40 44 48 2 6 n l 3 (280 nm) final %B n l 3 (280 nm) final %B 30 n l 3 (280 nm) final %B 40 n l 3 (280 nm) final %B 0 Volume, ml n l 4 (2 nm) final %B n l 4 (2 nm) final %B 30 n l 4 (2 nm) final %B 40 n l 4 (2 nm) final %B 0 0 % B 0 30% B 0 40% B 0 0% B L 14 16 18 14 16 18 14 16 18 14 16 18 S MW, kd 20 0 0 7 0 2 Elimination of Remaining Contaminants Using Bio-Scale Mini CHT Type II Ceramic Hydroxyapatite Resin During our initial column scouting phase, we also assessed prancer purple binding to the mixed-mode ion exchange resin Bio-Scale Mini CHT Type II Ceramic Hydroxyapatite. Prancer purple showed high affinity for this resin and markedly, the contaminants in the elution profile were distinct from those found in our Foresight Nuvia Q elution. We therefore chose Bio-Scale Mini CHT Type II Resin for our second purification step, to remove remaining contaminants from the Foresight Nuvia Q elution. The optimized Foresight Nuvia Q Bio-Scale Mini CHT Type II Column combination yielded highly pure prancer purple as illustrated by the absence of contaminating bands in Any kd Criterion TGX Stain-Free Gels (Figure ). Buffer Exchange and Sample Polishing Using Size Exclusion Chromatography For some applications, such as crystallography, final elution buffer composition is crucial. Similarly, many applications require the final sample buffer composition to be identical from batch to batch. When using gradient elution, however, the exact buffer composition of the pooled elution fractions is frequently unknown. Size exclusion chromatography (SEC) is an excellent method to ensure consistent buffer composition from prep to prep, since fractionation is not dependent on buffer gradients. SEC also eliminates low abundance contaminant, proteolyzed fragments, and aggregate species, ensuring high purity and uniformity of final protein. We therefore incorporated a final size exclusion step in our purification protocol using the ENrich SEC 70 Column, which has a high pressure limit that allowed higher flow rates and reduced the time needed for this step compared to carbohydrate based beads (Figure ). 14 Bio-Rad Laboratories, Inc. Bulletin 630

MW, kd 20 0 0 7 0 Nuvia Q CHT ENrich 70 S L FT 0% B E E E Our data show that column scouting is essential, even when a specific resin type, such as anion exchange resin, has already been chosen. As we show here, resins designed for similar use (in this case anion exchange) can show drastically different binding efficiencies for a given protein. Even though Foresight Nuvia Q and Bio-Scale Mini UNOsphere Q Resins are both strong anion exchange resins with trimethylamine functional groups, prancer purple bound only to Foresight Nuvia Q Resin. This is most likely due to differences in bead chemistries and size. 2 Fig.. Visual confirmation of the final purification workflow for untagged prancer purple. µl of sample was loaded on an Any kd Criterion TGX Stain-Free Gel. Lysate (L) and Nuvia Q flowthrough were diluted 1:. Elutions (E) are shown for Nuvia Q, CHT Type II Ceramic Hydroxyapatite, and ENrich 70 Columns. Prancer purple molecular weight: 26.4 kd. Discussion This study illustrates that untagged protein can be purified to high homogeneity when purification options are sufficiently explored. Exhaustive exploration is often impractical, because identifying an ideal purification workflow requires optimization of multiple variables, such as column resin, ph, and %B, at each step. This means that a multitude of runs is required at each purification step to identify the purification workflow that yields protein of the desired purity. Traditionally, this process requires individually setup and programmed runs for each tested column, ph, and %B condition. ChromLab Software, however, allowed us to automate and accelerate this tedious process. ChromLab Software can be programmed to execute several runs sequentially. It controls different components of the NGC System, such as the NGC Sample Pump that directly injects sample onto the column, the Buffer Blending Valve that allows scouting of ph and %B, and the Column Switching Valve that can automatically switch between up to five different columns. This permitted us to scout four ion exchange columns without user intervention in the same setup and instrument programming time as that required for one traditional run. In a similar fashion, we were able to explore multiple ph conditions without the need to make and titrate individual buffers for each tested ph. Finally, automated %B scouting allowed us to improve the final purity of protein. A second challenge of purification workflow development is evaluating which of the scouted methods yields the best results. Traditionally, based on the A 280 trace of the chromatogram, which tracks the presence of protein eluting from the column throughout the chromatography run, fractions are chosen for analysis by SDS-PAGE. A method is then chosen that (1) yields high amounts of the protein of interest, (2) yields few contaminating proteins, and (3) elutes the protein of interest over a small volume. Here we introduced a third factor, the purity quotient difference (PQD), that can inform method development when the protein of interest and contaminants absorb light at different wavelengths. Most proteins contain tryptophans and thus absorb light at a wavelength of 280 nm. Chromogenic proteins, fluorescently tagged proteins, or metal-bound proteins such as hemoproteins, as well as contaminants such as DNA, absorb light at other wavelengths. Using the NGC Discover Multi- Wavelength Detection System, we could distinguish the elution profile of prancer purple (2 nm) from the elution profile of contaminating proteins (280 nm). Because the area under the absorbance peaks in a chromatogram is proportional to the amount of protein eluted in that peak, we were able to calculate the purity quotient difference for prancer purple. The peak integration feature of ChromLab Software calculates the area under elution peaks, as well as the relative peak area, which is a measure of what percentage of total protein of interest loaded elutes in a particular peak (Figure 2C). Since we wanted to determine which method yielded the highest concentration of prancer purple, we normalized the relative peak area by dividing it by the volume collected. We call this value the purity quotient and it was calculated for prancer purple (PQ 2 ) and total protein (PQ 280 ). The goal of preparative chromatography, however, is not simply to obtain a high yield of protein; the goal is to obtain a high yield of pure protein. Purity is traditionally assessed qualitatively by SDS-PAGE. By subtracting the purity quotient of the contaminant (PQ 280 ) from the purity quotient of the protein of interest (PQ 2 ), we calculated the purity quotient difference for prancer purple (PQD PP ). 14 Bio-Rad Laboratories, Inc. Bulletin 630

Using these calculations, a PQD of zero indicates that contaminants and the protein of interest are present at equal amounts. A PQD >0 indicates that the protein of interest is enriched, and a PQD <0 indicates that contaminants are enriched. PQDs can be plotted across fractions to generate PQD histograms. PQD histograms for different scouting conditions can then be overlaid to identify the method with the highest PQD over the smallest number of fractions (Figure 2D, 3C, 4C). B-PER and Sorvall are trademarks of Thermo Fisher Scientific. Microsoft and Excel are trademarks of Microsoft Corporation. Precision Plus Protein Standards are sold under license from Life Technologies Corporation, Carlsbad, CA, for use only by the buyer of the product. The buyer is not authorized to sell or resell this product or its components. PQD analysis, however, is intended to complement, not replace, SDS-PAGE. Although a high PQD indicates enrichment of the protein of interest, it does not preclude the presence of contaminating proteins. The PQD histograms for ph scouting would suggest that there is no improvement in purification when the ph is raised to 8.0 from 7. (Figure 3C). SDS-PAGE analysis, however, clearly shows that more impurities co-elute with prancer purple at ph 8.0 (Figure 3B). PQD histograms also do not address the nature of impurities. Our initial round of column scouting included the mixed-mode Bio-Scale Mini CHT Type II Ceramic Hydroxyapatite Resin. We found that prancer purple was purified to a similar extent using the Foresight Nuvia Q and Bio-Scale Mini CHT Type II Resins but different contaminating proteins were found in the elutions. We were thus able to identify an optimal second column for prancer purple purification in our initial column scouting runs. This emphasizes the need to analyze not only the final purity of the protein of interest but also the impurities present in each column scouting run, as this information can inform the choice of resin for subsequent purification steps. Using Bio-Rad s precast Any kd Criterion TGX Stain-Free Gels we were able to resolve and analyze protein samples in less than 30 minutes, which permitted us to characterize elution patterns from a large number of fractions in a very short time. The combination of stain-free SDS-PAGE and PQD analysis described here can be applied to column, ph, and %B scouting, as well as additional scouting steps, such as optimization of organic phase for reverse-phase chromatography or ammonium sulfate concentration for hydrophobic interaction chromatography. As this prancer purple case study illustrates, NGC system-mediated automation of these scouting processes allowed exhaustive exploration of purification options. Combined with ChromLab Software s intuitive programming features and preloaded purification templates, the NGC System allowed us to purify an untagged protein without compromising purity. Additionally, the molecular weight and associated impurities were assessed after each optimization step using TGX Stain-Free SDS-PAGE for visual confirmation of purity. Unlike conventional SDS-PAGE, the TGX gel chemistry enables gels to be run in 30 minutes or less and the stain-free chemistry eliminates the need for staining and destaining. Together, this greatly decreased the overall time to result for SDS-PAGE and enabled near-parallel analysis of chromatographic optimization and visual confirmation by SDS-PAGE. 14 Bio-Rad Laboratories, Inc. Bulletin 630

Bio-Rad Laboratories, Inc. Life Science Group Web site www.bio-rad.com USA 800 424 6723 Australia 61 2 9914 2800 Austria 43 1 877 89 01 Belgium 03 7 3 00 Brazil 11 306 70 Canada 90 364 343 China 86 21 6169 800 Czech Republic 4 241 430 32 Denmark 44 2 00 Finland 09 804 22 00 France 01 47 9 69 6 Germany 49 89 31 884 0 Greece 30 2 932 2 Hong Kong 82 2789 3300 Hungary 36 1 49 60 India 91 124 4029300 Israel 03 963 600 Italy 39 02 216091 Japan 81 3 6361 7000 Korea 82 2 3473 4460 Mexico 2 488 7670 The Netherlands 0318 40666 New Zealand 64 9 4 2280 Norway 23 38 41 30 Poland 48 22 331 99 99 Portugal 31 21 472 7700 Russia 7 49 721 14 04 Singapore 6 64 3188 South Africa 27 (0) 861 246 723 Spain 34 91 90 0 Sweden 08 12700 Switzerland 026 674 0 Taiwan 886 2 278 7189 Thailand 1800 88 22 88 United Kingdom 0 8328 00 Bulletin 630 Rev D US/EG 14-2340 1214 Sig 1214