INTERNATIONALCONFERENCE ProgrammeandAbstracts GMANDNONGMSUPPLYCHAINS:THEIRCOEXISTENCEANDTRACEABILITY www.coextra.eu CoExtraConference June24,2009 AgroParisTech 16rueClaudeBernard Paris75005,France 25June2009 Paris,France StakeholderWorkshop June5,2009 PalaisduLuxembourg 15ruedeVaugirard Paris75006,France Biochip Systems
COEXTRAINTERNATIONALCONFERENCE TUESDAY,JUNE2 8:00to18:00 Settingup:ExhibitionandPosters AgroParisTech(APT) 14:00to18:00 Conferenceregistration(alsorequiredforattendingthe receptionontuesdayevening) APT mainentrance (16rueClaudeBernard, 75005Paris) 15:00to16:00 PressConference(accessreservedforpress) Chair:FrançoisHoullier(DSPPV,Scientificdirectorof Plantsandderivedproducts,France) YvesBertheau(INRA,France),FrédériqueAngevin(INRA, France),CoExtraExecutiveCommitteeMembersand BernhardKoch,Prof.ofTortLaw(InnsbruckUni.) APTsalledesconseils 19:00to20:30 Reception: Welcomecocktail&Welcomeaddress CityHallMairiedeParisVème 21PlaceduPanthéon 75005ParisV Métro:Luxembourg(15minutes walkingdistance) WEDNESDAY,JUNE3 SESSION1:ECResearch 8:0010:00 Registration APT mainentrance 9:009:10 Welcomeaddress RemiTousain(DirectorofAgroParisTech,France)and YvesBertheau(INRA,France) APTAmphiTisserand& Risler 9:109:50 Chair:YvesBertheau(INRA,France) 1.1Reportonthecoexistenceofgeneticallymodified cropswithconventionalandorganicfarming SigridWeiland(DGAgricultureandRuralDevelopment, EC),AliceStengal(DGEnvironment,EC),CiaranMangan (DGResearch,EC) 9:5010:20 1.2SIGMEAresultsoncoexistenceatthefarmlevel JeremySweet(NIAB,UK) 10:2010:50 1.3TransContainer:OverviewandProgress RuudA.deMaagdandKimBoutilier(PlantResearchIn ternationalb.v.,thenetherlands) 10:5011:30 BREAKANDVISITOFCONFERENCEEXHIBITION&POST ERS 11:3012:00 1.4CoExtraintroduction YvesBertheau(INRA,France) 12:0013:30 MIDDAYBREAK SESSION2:Parallelsessions(detailedprogrammeonpage6) 13:3015:00 ParallelsessionA.1 MethodsforManagingGene Flow Chair:JoachimSchiemann(JKI, Germany) ParallelsessionB.1 TechnologiesforManagingthe SupplyChainandDetectionof GMingredientsinfoodsand Feeds Chairs:KristinaGruden(NIB, Slovenia)&RobertaOnori(ISS, Italy) 15:00to18:00 ParallelsessionA.2 CoexistenceandTraceabilityin AgricultureandFood/Feed Production Chairs:FrédériqueAngevin (INRA,France&MortenGylling (FOI,Denmark) ParallelsessionB.2 GMOdetection Chair:ArneHolstJensen(NVI, Norway) 19:00 ConferenceDinneronRiverSeineboat SessionA:Tisserand SessionB:Risler 5
COEXTRAINTERNATIONALCONFERENCE SessionsAandBDetails WEDNESDAY,JUNE3,AgroParisTech,France,Paris SessionA1 MethodsforManagingGeneFlow Chair: JoachimSchiemann(JKI,Germany) 13:3013:50 A1.1. Biologicalmeasuresforgeneflowmitigation AlexandraHüsken(JKI,Germany) 13:5014:10 A1.2. Biocontainmentofmaizebycytoplasmicmale sterilityandxenia MariaMunsch(ETH,Switzerland) 14:1014:30 A1.3. PollencontainmentbyCleistogamyinoilseedrape XavierPinochet(Cetiom,France) 14:3014:50 14.5015.10 15:1015:40 A1.4. Chloroplasttransformationandtransgenecontain ment A1.5. Mesoscaledispersalofmaizepollenandimplica tionsforgeneflow SessionA.2. CoexistenceandTraceabilityinAgricultureandFood Production A2.1. Empiricalanalysisofcoexistenceincommodity supplychains RalfBock(MPI,Germany) S.DupontandY.Brunet(INRA,France) Chairs: FrédériqueAngevin(INRA,France)& MortenGylling(FOI,Denmark) JamesCopeland(FERA,UK)andNicolas Gryson(UniversityCollegeofGhent, Belgium) 15.4016:10 BREAK 16.1016:30 A2.2. ModellingcoexistencebetweenGMandnonGM withinsupplychains LouisGeorgesSoler(INRA,France) 16:3016:50 A2.3. Costsandbenefitsofsegregationandtraceability KlausMenrad,AndreasGabriel(WZS, betweengmandnongmsupplychainsoffinal Germany) foodproducts A2.4. ConsumersattitudestotheEUtraceabilityand JoséM.Gil&MontserratCostaFont 16.5017:10 labellingregulation (CREDAUPCIRTA,Spain) 17.1018:00 Questionsanddiscussion 13:3013:50 13:5014:10 SessionB.1. TechnologiesformanagingtheSupplyChain B1.1. GMOsamplingstrategiesinthefoodandfeed chain B1.2. RationalizationofGMOtestingbyappropriatesub samplingandcontrolplans Chairs: KristinaGruden(NIB,Slovenia)& RobertaOnori(ISS,Italy) MarinaMiraglia(ISS,Italy) YvesBertheau(INRA,France)andRoy MacArthur(FERA,UK) B1.3. Themodularapproachimplemented,pros,cons 14:1014:30 MarkvandenBulcke(IPH,Belgium) andfutureperspectives MarcoMazzara(JRCIHCP,Italy) 14:3014:50 B1.4. Validationofnovelmethodsandtechnologies B1.5. ReferencematerialsandreferencePCRassaysfor 14:5015:10 IsabelTaverniers(ILVO,Belgium) GMOquantification 15:1015:30 Questionsanddiscussion 15:3016:00 BREAK SessionB.2. Chair:ArneHolstJensen(NVI,Norway) DetectionofGMingredientsinfoods B2.1. NewrealtimePCRmethodsavailableforroutine 16:0016:20 GMOdetectionlabsapplicabilityandperform ance DoerteWulf(Genescan,Germany) 16:2016:40 B2.2. ReliabilityandcostsofGMOdetection KristinaGruden(NIB,Slovenia) 16:4017:00 B2.3. NonPCRbasedalternativeanalyticalmethods GuyKiddle(Lumora,UK) 17:0017:20 B2.4. DetectingunauthorisedandunknownGMOs ArneHolstJensen(NVI,Norway) B2.5. Newmultiplexingtoolsforreliableanalysisof 17:2017:40 MariaPla(CSIC,Spain) GMOs 17:4018:00 Questionsanddiscussion 6
COEXTRAINTERNATIONALCONFERENCE THURSDAY,JUNE4 SESSION3 9:009:20 9:20 9:40 9.4010.00 Legal,liability&redressissues Chair:BernhardKoch(ECTIL,Austria) 3.1.Legal,liability&redressissues BernhardKoch(ECTIL,Austria)andM.A.Hermitte(CNRS,France) 3.2.ScientificexpertiseandthejudgesC.Noiville(CNRS,France) 3.3.Juridicalcostbenefitanalysisofcoexistence:uneasythistask! MA.Hermitte,G.Canselier(CNRS,France)&Y.Bertheau(INRA,France) APTAmphiTisserand 10:0010:30 SESSION4 StakeholderviewsinEU: Chair:KristinaSinemus(Genius,Germany) 4.1.StakeholderopinionsandattitudesoncoexistenceofGMOswith conventionalandorganicsupplychains GeorgeSekallaris(NHRF,Greece)andRenèCusters(VIB,Belgium) 10:3011:00 BREAKANDVISITOFCONFERENCEEXHIBITION&POSTERS 11:0011:20 11:2011:40 11:4012:00 SESSION5 Dataintegration&DecisionSupportSystems Chair:NevenaAlexandrova(ABI,Bulgaria) 5.1.TheCoExtraDecisionSupportSystem:Amodelbasedintegration ofprojectresults MarkoBohanec(JSI,Slovenia) 5.2. AnalyticalDSSmodule howtosupportdecisionsinthe analyticallab KristinaGruden(NIB,Slovenia) 5.3.DSSmodulesontransportation(TMmodule)andonunapproved GMOs(UGMmodule) EstherKok(RIKILT,TheNetherlands) 12:0013:30 MIDDAYBREAK SESSION6 APTAmphiTisserand APTAmphiTisserand 13:3014:00 14:0014:30 14:3015:00 15:0015:30 Experiencesfromthirdcountries Chair:MortenGylling(FOI,Denmark) 6.1.Benefitcostanalysis,foodsafety,andtraceability JamesHammitt(HarvardUniversityCentreforRiskAnalysis,Boston,USA) 6.2.Segregationmeasuresfor(non)GMcropsandtheirimplications forsupplychainsinjapan MasashiTachikawa(IbarakiUniversity,Japan) 6.3.CoExistenceandtraceability:costsandbenefitsinfoodandfeed supplychains BillWilson(NorthDakotaUniversity,USA) 6.4.CompanyPerspective RandalGiroux(Cargill,USA) APTAmphiTisserand 15:3016:00 BREAK 16:0016:30 16:3017:00 6.5.ProtectingEuropeanqualityagriculture:nonGMfeedsupplyand production RenaudLayadi,(RegionBretagne,France) 7.IntegrationofCoExtraresultsinEUtoolsforcoexistence& traceability GuyvandenEede&EmilioRodriguezCerezo(EuropeanCommission/JRC) 8.SummaryofmainCoExtradeliverables&results,perspectives APTAmphiTisserand 17:0017:30 Informationdissemination&application YvesBertheau(INRA,France) 9.ConcludingComments 17.3018:00 fromcoextra,inra,ecrepresentatives 19:00 Freeevening 7
COEXTRAINTERNATIONALCONFERENCE Stakeholderworkshop PalaisduLuxembourg,Paris Friday,June5 8:008:30 Registration Entrance Chair(wholeday):YvesBertheau(INRA,France) Stakeholderpanel:GarlichvonEssen(EuropeanSeedAssociation,ESA),Arnaud Petit(CommitteeofProfessionalAgriculturalOrganisations,GeneralCommit teeforagriculturalcooperationintheeuropeanunion,copacogeca),agnès Davi(ConfederationofFoodandDrinkIndustriesoftheEU,CIAA),OlivierAn drault(ufcquechoisir,federalunionofconsumers),mireilleferri(vice présidenterégioniledefrance),maaikeraaijmakers( PlatformBiologica ) Moderator:OlivierdeLagarde(journalist) SalleMédicis 8:309:00 Introductorytalk MarionGuillou(CEOINRA,France) IntroductiontoCoExtra YvesBertheau(INRA,France) 9:009.20 Fromseedstosilo:agriculturalcoexistenceandtraceabilityissues FrédériqueAngevin(INRA,France) 9:2010:30 Roundtable Panelquestions,thenaudiencequestions 10.3010:50 Legalissues BernhardKoch(ECTIL,Austria) 10:5012:00 Roundtable Panelquestions,thenaudiencequestions 12:0014:00 LUNCHBREAK SalleRenéCoty 14:0014:30 Supplychainmanagementandeconomicissues MortenGylling(FOI,Denmark) SalleMédicis 14:3015:30 Roundtable Panelquestions,thenaudiencequestions 15:3016.10 Stakeholderopinionsandattitudes Somelessonsfromstakeholderinteractionsforthefutureofcoexistence RenèCusters(VIB,Belgium) Statement PascaleHebel(CREDOC,France) 16.1017:10 Roundtable Panelquestions,thenaudiencequestions 17:1017:40 Finalcomments 17:5518.10 ConclusionsbyJeanLouisBorloo(FrenchMinisterofEnvironment) 17.4017.55 CoExistenceofGMandnonGMsupplychains:thepointofviewoftheCom missionerinchargeofagriculture. JulienMousnier(MemberofthecabinetofMsFischerBoel,EC,Brussels) 8