UDI and Interoperability



Similar documents
Improving Patient Safety and Supply Chain Efficiency with GS1 Standards in HEALTHCARE

2012 GTIN Sunrise Explained IMPLEMENTATION ROADMAP FOR U.S. HEALTHCARE SUPPLY CHAIN MEMBERS

Implementation of the GS1 Standards in Healthcare

GS1 STANDARDS & UDI UPDATE SIOBHAN O BARA GS1US

The Values & Benefits of Using a GDSNData Pool. Prepared by: Anthony Hayes Greg Patterson

White Paper Healthcare Supply Chain Traceability

Efficient Data Sharing in Healthcare

Solution Provider. Engagement with GS1 Standards

A GLOBAL CURE FOR HEALTHCARE

UDI as the Cornerstone to Medical Device Data Capture. Presentation to: 27th Global GS1 Healthcare Conference

GS1 Global Update. MIGUEL A. LOPERA, President & CEO, GS1. March 2015

Healthcare Provider Tool Kit United Nations Standard Products and Services Code (UNSPSC ) Improving Patient Safety and Supply Chain Efficiency

143: Standards in your Healthcare ERP System

GS1 Healthcare US HEALTHCARE SUPPLIER TOOL KIT. Global Trade Item Number (GTIN )

AN INTRODUCTION TO THE GLOBAL TRADE ITEM NUMBER (GTIN) TABLE OF CONTENTS

Adoption of GS1 and PEPPOL Standards:

By Natalia Wilson, MD, MPH

Business Process Map of GDSN Healthcare Attributes to Hospital Processes

The Australian Supply Chain Reform Past, Present and Future

11 billion. reasons to say thank you to barcodes

How To Help The Global Healthcare User Group (Hug)

Global Data Synchronisation Network User Group Charter

WHITE PAPER. GS1 DataBar in the Retail World

Unique Device Identification Update FDA and GHTF

Supply Chains. Making Your Supply Chain Run Better Gain Efficiency and Transparency with SAP Solutions That Support GS1 Standards

Unique Device. Adoption and Use Trends for Medical Devices. Authors: Anya Kroupnik and Susan Moretti

AN INTRODUCTION TO THE GLOBAL INDIVIDUAL ASSET IDENTIFIER (GIAI) TABLE OF CONTENTS

Mass Serialization and Traceability Implementation in the Pharma Industry. Mathieu Aman, Global Program Lead F. Hoffmann-La Roche Ltd, Switzerland

Position Paper (II) Healthcare Provider Advisory Council Implementation in hospitals hindered by bar code symbol issues

Develop Project Charter. Develop Project Management Plan

EHIMA Guidance Document Revision: V05 Issue date:

Major Release 3.1. Global Webinar. 1 October 2015

Project Management Plan Outline ITSC

SOURCE ID RFID Technologies and Data Capture Solutions

GS1 Standards Implementation have a logical order of chronology and complexity GDSN GLN GTIN

How EDI accommodates GS1 GLN & GTIN

Kroger Program Mercury Supplier Frequently Asked Questions May, 2013

GS1 Healthcare Provider Advisory Council (HPAC) Feargal McGroarty St James Hospital, Dublin, Ireland HPAC Tri-Chair

IMPLEMENTATION GUIDELINE

RFID Survives Sterilization to Deliver Medical Device Tracking Solution

IBM RFID for Supply Chain and Logistics: Reusable Asset Tracking solution

IMPLEMENTATION GUIDELINE

Chipotle Mexican Grill

isurf -An Interoperability Service Utility for Collaborative Supply Chain Planning across Multiple Domains: Textile Supply Chain Pilot 1

IBM Solution for Pharmaceutical Track & Trace

DoD/VA Data Synchronization Program

How To Serialize

How To Do Business With Target

U.S. FDA Unique Device Identification (UDI) Rule Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) R M A R

FAQ: Unique Device Identification Final Rule

In a Global Economy: Staying Competitive in the Multi-Channel Distribution Industry Through Effective Use of Best Practices

Terrace Consulting Services

Four distribution strategies for extending ERP to boost business performance

Increasing Efficiency in the Healthcare Supply Chain through NEHTA Maria Palazzolo CEO

Getting Started with the Warehouse Management System Training Course -V 0.3

Solving Pricing Alignment in Healthcare

Some of the possible ways that Aurora can provide value and assist in solving your current business problems include:

The Plan s Journey From Scope to WBS to Schedule

GDSN (Release 2.X) Trade Item Implementation Guide

Reducing healthcare costs with supply chain best practices. How standardized

PROJECT MANAGEMENT PLAN TEMPLATE < PROJECT NAME >

The Project Planning Process Group

Enterprise Visibility Solutions

The Impact of Auto ID DC Technologies on Inventory Management

California Department of Mental Health Information Technology Attention: MHSA-IT th Street, Room 141 Sacramento, CA 95814

CONTRACT MANUFACTURING FOR LIFE SCIENCES

DRIVE VALUE ACROSS YOUR SUPPLY CHAIN WITH CHIP-BASED RFID SERIALIZATION A simpler, more cost effective solution for deploying item-level tagging

Pharmaceutical Distribution Security Alliance (PDSA)

Payment on Time Case Study

IBM Solution for Pharmaceutical Track & Trace: Supply chain visibility drives overall performance

A SUGGESTED HARMONIZATION OF DMAIC WITH PMBOK PROJECT LIFE CYCLES FOR PHARMACEUTICAL LEAN SIX SIGMA PROJECTS

Unique Device Identification Challenges for Manufacturers Focus UDID

When Assessing CANTIER Manufacturing ERP Software, BENEFIT comes 1 st while COST should only be Secondary

Three Critical Components of the Specialty 3PL Experience. What should you expect from your supply chain partner?

The ITS Project Management Framework

The Kroger Company: Transforming the Product Data Management Landscape

Project Management Guidebook

Description of Program Management Processes (Initiating, Planning) 2011 PROGstudy.com. All rights reserved

Table of Contents. ecommerce...1 SmartSync...9 Electronic Data Interchange (EDI)...11 ebusiness Partnerships...13 ebusiness Integrated Solutions...

GS1 Healthcare US Global Data Synchronization Network (GDSN ) Data Integration Readiness Scorecard

Effective Data Inc. White Paper: UCCnet White Paper

How To Use The Gs1 Databar Expanded

Identitovigilance technologies

Prepared for: Item Centre & GS1 Canada Overview

Minnesota Health Insurance Exchange (MNHIX)

Microsoft Dynamics AX 2012 R3, clear cut benefits for your Organisation

2012 CASE STUDY ON QR CODE (2D) BASED ASSET INFORMATION MANAGEMENT SOLUTION (R- AIMS)

Transcription:

UDI and Interoperability June 25, 2015 James Phillips Franciscan Missionaries of Our Lady Health System Slide 1

James Phillips Office of Data Standards and Interoperability Unique Device Identifiers, Franciscan Missionaries of Our Lady Health System James Phillips is leading the UDI project for The Office of Data Standards & Interoperability team with Franciscan Missionaries of Our Lady Health System (FMOLHS). As a member of the MMIS team James managed data files that included contracts and pricing for the Health System. He joined FMOLHS last year after a progression of positions involving supply chain services, logistics, inventory management, purchasing, project management and Material Manager for a DOD contractor. James is a Louisiana native and earned his Bachelor of Science in Business Management and Entrepreneurship from Louisiana Tech University in Ruston, LA. He has completed an Intermediate Project Management course through LANtec of Louisiana and holds a Certification in GS1 Standards. He also supports projects such as: implementing GS1 U.S. data standards and interoperability, integrating Global Location Numbers (GLN) and Global Trade Identification Numbers (GTIN), touchless order with seven pilot manufacturers, implementing Unique Device Identifier (UDI) capture, track and trace, and Global Data Synchronization Network (GDSN) implementation. Currently James is supporting a GE Lean Six Sigma Black Belt Project for the Operating Room Supply Chain Redesign across the FMOL Health System. Slide 2

Franciscan Missionaries of Our Lady Health System Slide 3

The Franciscan Missionaries of Our Lady Health System s service area is diverse and encompasses over 2.4 million people, over 50% of the State s population. As a nonprofit, mission-focused Catholic healthcare ministry, we give special attention to our citizens who are most in need. During the most recent fiscal year, we provided more than $39 million in unreimbursed care and community support to the underprivileged. Slide 4

Franciscan Missionaries of Our Lady Health System Slide 5

FMOLHS - Our Story Where do we begin it was easy Having the right tools in place GS1 Toolbox Master Project Plan Master Network Diagram Master Process Document Aligning our GLNs with our manufacturers Getting the GTINs into our ERP now & later Parallel Projects, CDC, Charge-Master, ERP, etc. Trading information with our GPO Slide 6

Our Story Where we started Who we partnered with What did we do first What was the initial output graphic courtesy of FMOLHS How the structure designed When did we know we were ready How did we build our GLN Hierarchy What did we do to begin loading our manufacturing partners GTINS and GLNs into our ERP Slide 7

Our Story What departments were involved How did we get buy in What automation was used How did we adjust to the technology constraints Where are we now OR Supply Chain Project What will we do next graphic courtesy of FMOLHS Slide 8

Our Partners Our 7 Pilots Manufacturers Slide 9

Our Partners Our Technology Partners Infor Lawson Slide 10

Our Partners US Healthcare Systems Slide 11

Our Partners Advisory Groups Slide 12

GS1 US Data Standards Slide 13

Documentation to Share The Master Project Plan that can be used as a foundation easily adaptable to insert any unique areas you have within your Health System. We built it based on PMI methodologies and Lean Six Sigma methodologies specific to implementing GS1 US Standards in the Health System. An updated version of the Master Project Plan that includes the additional work elements discovered while the pilots were active, will be completed before the end of June 2015. This is the final version of the Master Network Diagram for direct and distributed items. The Master Process Document was finished in February 2015 and is ready for distribution. As new documents are completed, I will share those with you as well. Slide 14

The Charter Project Charter Project Name: GS1 Data Standards- Cook Medical Short Name: GS1 Data Standards Project Number: GS12014 Location: All Facilities Business Case: We do not have GS1 Data Standards implemented at FMOLHS Start Date: 6/26/2013 Project Manager: Sandi Michel Executive Sponsor: Bill Mosser Core Process: Transacting using GLN and GTIN to support the Touchless Ord Sub-Process: Capture GLNs and GTINs for Cook Medical in Lawson Problem Statement: GLN, GTIN and UDI are not currently captured in Lawson for items purchased by FMOLHS.FMOL will align with all aspects of the GS1 data standards. Currently, most of the ship-to facilities have a GLN number, GTINs are captured in IC11 and UDIs are mandated at the manufacturer level to provide to businesses. Project Y: Target of what you want to change Standardize the Health System to GS1 global data standards by populating the Lawson System with GLN, GTIN, and UDI; transitioning to use GTIN or UDI for purchasing and Logistics. Phase 1: All supplies that flow through Lawson with GTIN are in scope Phase 1: All implantables with UDI Phase 1: Implantables without UDI Goal Identify and capture GLN and GTIN for Cook Medical throughout Supply Chain Process Scope FMOLHS TEAM MEMBERS/Resources IN OUT Black Belt/Instructor Stephen Griffin Phase 1: All supplies that do not flow Blue Belt Name: Sandi Michel through Lawson without GTIN are not in scope Name Sandi Michel Carol Kitts Angela Gautreau Jessica Sharp Lynette Thibeau Jennifer Aldridge Michelle Boatner Patrice Cahn Rebecca Williams Angela Barker Melissa Brouillette Subject Matter Expertise Project Management EDI EDI AP NuVia, Lawson Lawson Application Admin Purchasing Logistics Process Engineer - Green Belt Resource Utilization GHX SME %Time Req. Slide 15

Master Project Plan Task Name Duration Start Finish Predecessors Resource Names Initiation 94 days Tue 10/8/13 Fri 2/14/14 Project Sponsor Create Charter 1 day Tue 10/8/13 Tue 10/8/13 Project Sponsor Develop the Charter 1 day Tue 10/8/13 Tue 10/8/13 Project Sponsor Charter Completed 0 days Tue 10/8/13 Tue 10/8/13 3 Project Sponsor OUTPUT: Charter 0 days Tue 10/8/13 Tue 10/8/13 Project Sponsor Create the Project Initiation Documentation (Optional) 85 days Mon 10/21/13 Fri 2/14/14 Project Sponsor Develop the Project Initiation Documents 3 days Mon 10/21/13 Wed 10/23/13 Project Sponsor Complete the Project Initiation Documents 0 days Fri 2/14/14 Fri 2/14/14 25 Project Sponsor Planning 125 days Tue 10/8/13 Mon 3/31/14 GS1 Assessment of Current State 56 days Mon 11/11/13 Tue 1/28/14 Project Manager Contact GS1 to arrange for assessments 2 days Mon 11/11/13 Tue 11/12/13 Project Manager 3 days Wed 11/13/13 Fri 11/15/13 11 Project Manager Tour each facility 5 days Mon 11/18/13 Fri 11/22/13 12 Project Manager 3 days Mon 11/25/13 Wed 11/27/13 13 Project Manager Large Team Kickoff Meeting to communicate expectations 0.5 days Mon 11/11/13 Mon 11/11/13 14 Project Manager Assessment begins first facility 3 days Tue 11/12/13 Thu 11/14/13 15 Project Manager,GS1 Prepare Readout 5 days Fri 11/15/13 Thu 11/21/13 16 GS1 Complete Assessment & Readout 0 days Tue 1/28/14 Tue 1/28/14 GS1 Develop Project Management Plan 125 days Tue 10/8/13 Mon 3/31/14 Project Manager Scope Planning 96 days Tue 10/8/13 Tue 2/18/14 Project Manager Develop Preliminary Project Scope Statement 1 day Mon 10/21/13 Wed 10/23/13 Project Manager Scope Definition 1 day Tue 10/8/13 Thu 10/24/13 21 Project Manager Complete Preliminary Project Scope Statement 1 day Fri 10/25/13 Fri 10/25/13 22 Project Manager Create the WBS 1 day Thu 1/30/14 Fri 1/31/14 Project Manager Create Definition of Terms or Glossary 10 days Mon 2/3/14 Fri 2/14/14 24 Project Manager Finalize Preliminary Project Scope Documents 2 days Mon 2/17/14 Tue 2/18/14 25 Project Manager Complete Project Scope Management Plan 0 days Tue 2/18/14 Tue 2/18/14 26 Project Manager OUTPUT: Scope Management Plan 0 days Tue 2/18/14 Tue 2/18/14 27 Project Manager Schedule Development 12 days Fri 2/28/14 Mon 3/17/14 Project Manager Activity Resource Estimating 3 days Fri 2/28/14 Tue 3/4/14 Project Manager Activity Duration Estimating 3 days Fri 2/28/14 Tue 3/4/14 Project Manager Activity Definition 3 days Fri 2/28/14 Tue 3/4/14 Project Manager Activity Sequencing 3 days Fri 2/28/14 Tue 3/4/14 Project Manager Activity Sequencing Process Flow Map 3 days Wed 3/5/14 Fri 3/7/14 33 Project Manager Slide 16

Network Diagram Slide 17

Master Implementation Process Franciscan Missionaries of Our Lady Health System FMOLHS-GS1 US DATA STANDARDS MASTER PROCESS IMPLEMENTATION PLAN A global plan for the implementation of the GS1 Standards for Health Systems around the United States. First Edition- Supply Chain Sandi Michel James Phillips Matthew Kurtz Slide 18

TABLE OF CONTENTS PROCESS IMPLEMENTATION TEAM CONTROL TABLES... 2 Document Revision Control... 2 Circulation List... 2 Change Control Log... 3 Document Approval... 3 1. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY... 7 2. PROCESS IMPLEMENTATION... 8 2.1. Objective... 8 2.2. FDA Unique Device Identification (UDI) Regulation... 8 2.4. GS1... 10 2.5. Master Project Plan and Subprojects... 11 2.6. Process Management Plan... 11 3. HOW TO INITIATE THE PROJECT... 14 3.1. Develop Charter... 14 3.2. Identify Stakeholders... 14 3.3. Implementation Plan... 14 4. HOW TO PLAN THE PROJECT... 16 4.1. Acceptance Requirements... 16 4.2. Project Timelines... 17 4.2. Financial Resources... 19 4.3. Expected Project Deliverables:... 19 4.4. Project Implementation Roles... 20 4.5. Process Flow Development... 22 4.6. Communication Plan... 25 5. HOW TO EXECUTE THE PROJECT PLAN... 26 5.1 Process Implementation Structure... 26 5.2. Picking Organizations to Pilot... 27 5.3. Implementing GLNs... 27 5.4. Implementing GTINs... 28 Slide 19

The UDI allows you to more efficiently and effectively manage your supply chain in a number of ways including: Better cash flow: Using UDI simplifies your chargeback and rebate processing, thereby decreasing the amount of money your organization has in unresolved sales accounts. Reduced labor costs: Adoption of UDI reduces the amount of time staff spend building and maintaining tables in different systems to track all your proprietary account numbers. Simplified supply chain management: Using a common number (UDI) facilitates information exchange between various supply chain partners. Efficient payment and reporting processes: Using UDIs allows sales to be automatically reported to providers with fewer errors, thereby improving electronic data interchange (EDI) and ebusiness dealings. Enhanced inventory management: UDIs provide a consistent way of identifying items. This means that receivers are in a position to correctly identify the items for distribution and use by reducing the number of items sent in error, thereby supporting efficient replacement of these items throughout the organization. Premier Research Institute The Pew Charitable Trusts Slide 20

Including the UDI in your clinical suite software and EHRs can provide a number of possible benefits for your organization, including: Facilitating easier recalls when devices malfunction. Enabling clinicians and researchers particularly at large health systems to conduct analyses on device performance. Allowing more accurate reporting, reviewing and analyzing of adverse event reports so that problem devices can be identified and corrected more quickly. Preventing medical errors by enabling health care professionals and others to more rapidly and precisely identify a device and obtain important information concerning the characteristics of the device. Reduce manual and unstandardized methods of data entry to record device use with an electronic system. Slide 21

Continued Fully implementing UDIs will take time and require addressing a number of challenges. A key challenge is that UDIs may initially be captured in any of a variety of clinical, inventory, registry, or other IT systems. Robust adoption and use of UDIs will require bridging these different components and changing IT and administrative processes to, among other things, ensure that UDIs are properly captured and associated with patients electronic health records. In December 2014, the Brookings Institution with collaboration from FDA published a detailed roadmap for effective UDI implementation. Significantly, the roadmap s recommendations stated that while the path to full implementation is complex, there are relatively straightforward steps that can be done now to begin realizing the benefits of UDI implementation across the health care system. The roadmap s recommendations specifically urged ONC to support the incorporation of UDIs into certification criteria for health IT. Slide 22

Automatic identification and data capture Automatic identification and data capture (AIDC) refers to the methods of automatically identifying objects, collecting data about them, and entering that data directly into computer systems (i.e. without human involvement). Technologies typically considered as part of AIDC include bar codes, Radio Frequency Identification (RFID), biometrics, magnetic stripes, Optical Character Recognition (OCR), smart cards, and voice recognition. AIDC is also commonly referred to as Automatic Identification, Auto-ID, and "Automatic Data Capture." Slide 23

Interoperability Incorporate UDI into various electronic databases, including supply chain, electronic health records, claims, and billing systems; the benefits greatly exceed the costs. Two key trusted data sources are: GDSN GUDID Slide 24

Global Data Synchronization Network The Global Data Synchronizations Network (GDSN) enables trading partners to globally share trusted product data. You can exchange product information with business partners in an automatic and efficient way that ensures brand integrity. To be able to exchange product data on GDSN, you must join a data pool that s been tested and certified to meet GS1 global standards. It s important to remember this is a business project, not just an IT project, so you ll need to engage stakeholders at all levels within your company to get it off the ground. Slide 25

Tips from GS1 US Step 1 Getting buy-in Set up a core business team with subject matter experts and technical experts. Sell your strategy you will need to get commitment from senior management within the business. It s a good idea to make sure your partners get this too, so each business is working towards the same goal. Step 2 Building your strategy Build a business case for your company make sure you link it to key performance indicators so you can track the progress of your strategy. Start by looking at how your business currently operates and work from there to identify how GDSN will benefit your business. You ll also need to look at your IT resources and identify costs so you can spread the investments you ll need to make. Choose an implementation team at this stage you ll need to choose the GDSN Data Pool. Step 3 Setting the standard for your data Check the quality of your data make sure you re not synchronizing incorrect or wrongly classified data. Step 4 Getting started Begin with small steps before rolling it out to the whole business or all of your suppliers, start working with a few key items and just a few trading partners to test the water. Test it out try to set up pilot tests with some of your partners. This will help you monitor the results and make any necessary changes before you go ahead with full production. Slide 26

Device Identification Prior to UDI Non standard device identification systems; standards used in different ways Not necessary unique or unambiguous Does not include all necessary levels of uniqueness Manufacturers own number/catalogue number Distributors apply different, proprietary number; lot or serial number not captured Hospital yet different identification number/code Information on use not usually captured Control numbers rarely captured Slide 27

Unique Device Identifiers GUDID Integration support and mapping Drive GS1 standards / scanning in the ERP Drive GS1 standards / scanning in the EHR Vendor Relationship Adverse Event Reporting Meaningful Use Reporting Value Analysis CDM Team Registries Recalls Real-time locating systems (RTLS) / Asset Tracking Slide 28

Public Health Benefits The UDI system provides global visibility and supports: Medical device recalls Adverse event reporting Tracking and tracing Supply chain security Anti counterfeiting/diversion Disaster/terror preparation Shortages/substitutions Reduction of medical errors (e.g., bedside scanning) Easily accessible source of device information for patients and clinicians Slide 29

Implementation Steps Facilitate incorporation of UDI into EHRs as part of EHR certification Complete pilot demonstrating ability to incorporate UDI into hospital information systems Complete collaboration as basis for initial UDI roadmap for incorporating UDI into EHRs and ensuring real time access to device information across data sources Slide 30

MASTER DATA MANAGEMENT GS1 Standards Adoption Roadmap Identified process impacts/opportunities in a Process Flow with Product ID (SNI/UDI) capture from Procurement through Reporting Included maintaining traceability of SNI and UDI in lower units of measure -barcoding, kitting, prepackaging in-house System Integration Impacts Overall systems context drawing with transition states completed Re-visit when GDSN data pool solution in-place for mapping FDA Global Unique Device Identification Database (GUDID) data to internal systems and GS1 GDSN Product Traceability Solutions/Services for Interoperable Systems High level design to align for MDM and technical environment to define robust solution designs by system and integration points (ERP, WMS, GDSN, EHR and related clinical, financial & reporting systems) and process (supply chain, pharmacy, central distribution center); engage applications and implementation partners. Slide 31

Next Steps Implementing access to the GDSN to provide attributes from the manufacturers with real-time updates. Integration of GS1 barcode labels/ scanning with IT systems and internal process changes to achieve true interoperability Develop Requirement Specifications for ERP, WMS, GDSN, and EHR systems, enhancements and interfaces. Define system implementation, training and system release project plans and organization impact. Lead or execute system implementations, enhancements and integration with selected partners External Integration EDI, SPL Publish documentation to other Healthcare Companies across the US Slide 32

How to Establish an Office of Data Standards & Interoperability in Your Health System Slide 33

Overview The Office of Data Standards & Interoperability was established to design, develop, establish, and implement standards and interoperability across FMOLHS, meet regulatory requirements and to share the documentation of processes, network designs, master project plans with other health systems across the United States. The foundation for GS1 US Standards is standardization and interoperability. FMOLHS has implemented GLNs and GTINs for seven pilot manufacturers and is now implementing data synchronization with access to the GDSN. Slide 34

Initiation Defining the project Identifying and engaging a Sponsor Creating the Mission and Vision Statements Creating the Charter Identifying the Stakeholders Defining Roles & Responsibilities Writing the job descriptions Creating a functional organization chart Slide 35

Planning Staffing Leadership Positions Constructing the Master Project Plan Producing the Master Process Documents Developing a Proposed Network Diagram Designing a SharePoint Site Establishing the SharePoint Site Slide 36

Execution Assigning subprojects to each Manager of DS&I Creating materials list for initial tools and supplies Ordering materials Receiving and assigning "Assets" to Managers of DS&I" Communicating Roles and Responsibilities Establishing Contact List Slide 37

Monitoring & Controlling Scheduling Weekly Status Meetings Addressing Risks and Document Outcomes Capturing Issues and Document Solutions Communicating with Stakeholders Communicating with Sponsor Adjusting processes as needed Evaluating progress Finalizing documentation Transitioning to Normal Operations Begins Slide 38

Closing Reviewing Lessons Learned Discovering Opportunities for Improvement Making improvements Setting up Operational Control Plan Setting Goals for 1 year, 3 years, 5 years Transitioning to Operations Completed Slide 39

Slide 40