Emerging Opportunities in the Indian Consumer Finance Market: Market Size, Strategies, Products and Competitive Landscape

Similar documents
Emerging Opportunities and Growth Prospects in the Indonesian Travel Intermediaries Industry, Analyses and Forecasts to 2016

Emerging Opportunities in Indian Wealth Management Industry: Market Size, Strategies, Products, and Competitive Landscape

The Insurance Industry in Antigua and Barbuda, Key Trends and Opportunities to 2017

The Insurance Industry in British Virgin Islands, Key Trends and Opportunities to 2017

Personal Accident and Health Insurance in Malaysia, Key Trends and Opportunities to 2016

Online Strategies of Banking and Insurance Companies in the BRIC Countries

Timetric. Publisher Sample

The Insurance Industry in Palau, Key Trends and Opportunities to 2017

The Insurance Industry in Comoros, Key Trends and Opportunities to 2017

Landlord Insurance in the UK Key Trends and Opportunities to 2017

Social Media Marketing Strategies Adopted by Financial Services Industry in Emerging Economies

Timetric. Publisher Sample

Online Strategies of Banking and Insurance Companies in India: Market Profile

Term Life Assurance in the UK, Key Trends and Opportunities to 2017

This is a licensed product of Ken Research and should not be copied

Timetric. Publisher Sample

Electronic Warfare - Emerging Trends, Approaches, Key issues and Investment Outlook. Reference code: DF4420PR Published: March 2015

2020 Foresight: Best Practices in Implementing Mobile Payments

World City Millionaire Rankings. May 2013

6wresearch

Beer in the Czech Republic

Mutual Fund Category Analysis Banking Sector Funds

This is a licensed product of Ken Research and should not be copied

The Indian Car Rental Market to Market Profile

Mobile Advertising Market - India

Telecommunications Industry Forecasts 2015

STATS WINDOW. Retail industry

India Healthcare IT Market Prospects to Increasing Focus of Vendors in Tier 2 and 3 Cities

2020 Foresight: Best Practices in Implementing Mobile Payments

Industry Dynamics and Competitive Landscape in the Chilean Non-Life Insurance Industry to 2016: Market Profile

2020 Foresight: Retail Bank Loyalty Programs

This is a licensed product of AM Mindpower Solutions and should not be copied

The UAE Cement Industry Outlook: Business Opportunities and Future Growth Potential to 2016

Cloud Computing Market India

Hotel Industry in India ( )

ICT services for SMEs in Western Europe: forecasts and analysis

Australia Insurance Market Outlook to Rising Importance of Household Insurance

Reliance Commercial Finance. Loan Against Property. September 2015

Finance Ministers Speech NDTV Profit Business Leadership awards 2011

Middle Eastern Managed Services Market Emerging Opportunities in the Managed Services Market

Industry Dynamics and Competitive Landscape in the Chilean Life Insurance Industry to 2016: Market Profile

Index. Copyright material from - licensed to npg - PalgraveConnect

Queries concerning subscriptions to this publication should be directed to Earl Bederman at the above contact numbers.

Software Testing Market India

This is a licensed product of Ken Research and should not be copied

Games Consoles: Global Industry Guide

SREI Infrastructure Ltd.

The Rise of Luxury Goods in Emerging Cities

Evolvement of Financial Brokerage Market with the Inception of Discount Brokers to Raise Concerns for the Sustaina

Canadian Consumer Credit Trends. Q Prepared by: Equifax Analytical Services

Development of consumer credit in China

PEER GROUPS CMP MARKET CAP EPS P/E (X) P/BV(X) DIVIDEND Company Name (Rs.) Rs. in mn. (Rs.) Ratio Ratio (%)

Life Insurance in Pakistan, Key Trends and Opportunities to 2016

Life Insurance Market Report - India

Sample-Global Big Data Market in the Healthcare Sector. technavio insights

How To Understand The Online Advertising Market In Quatar

Netscribes (India) Pvt. Ltd.

Rating Criteria for Finance Companies

HEALTHCARE BUSINESS INTELLIGENCE (BI) MARKET

Luxury Car Market India

SWOT Assessment: FireMon Security Manager Suite v7.0

Secunia Corporate Software Inspector (Secunia CSI) ver.5.0

MBA Forecast Commentary Joel Kan,

This is a licensed product of Ken Research and should not be copied

NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF AUTOMOBILE MANUFACTURERS OF SOUTH AFRICA

Service provider strategies for mobile advertising: case studies

Linarch. April Sample Report - Global Ethernet Exchange Services Market

Higher FDI in Indian Insurance sector a buzz for the industry

Verdict Financial: Wealth Management. Data Collection and Forecasting Methodologies

Muthoot finance ltd. (mfl) IPO note

TechNavio Infiniti Research

Online Life Insurance Market in India

Sample-Global Telepresence Equipment

Strategic Focus Report Enterprise Mobility

Egypt Wind Energy Outlook. Reference Code: GDAE0215VPT Publication Date: May 2015 SAMPLE. Egypt Wind Energy Outlook

VoIP Market India July 2014

CRISIL Research Impact note

Global Lending & Leasing Survey. Back to a new normal? A survey carried out by Linedata Edition

Retail. White Paper. Driving Strategic Sourcing Effectively with Supply Market Intelligence

2. China Life and Non-Life Insurance Market Size by Value,

Industry Dynamics and Competitive Landscape in the Vietnamese Non-Life Insurance Industry to 2016: Market Profile

Public and Product Liability Insurance in the UK, Key Trends and Opportunities to 2017

US Hospital Information Systems Overview and Outlook, Managing Information in an Era of Reform

How To Understand The Turkish Economy

State Farm Bank, F.S.B.

2013 ICT Enterprise Insights in the Life Sciences Industry

SWOT Assessment: dotcms dotcms v2.5

Motor Insurance in Europe

SAMPLE PAGES Data Center and Managed Security Services in Latin America: Leveraging Telcos Services Portfolio

2 nd Quarter, 2012 Results ANALYST MEETING, 27 JULY, 2012

Luxury Car Market In India ( )

Singapore: Automotive Industry Guide

INDIAN LUBRICANT INDUSTRY - SHRINKING MARGINS

2015 Pyramid Research Latin America Telecom Insider

Mortgage and Loan BPO

Global IT Spending By SMBS Market to Grow at CAGR of 6% according to forecast from 2016 to 2020

Separately managed accounts

UAE Banking sector overview June 2015

Transparency Market Research

CHAPS Market Report 2015

Transcription:

Emerging Opportunities in the Indian Consumer Finance Market: Market Size, Strategies, Products and Competitive Landscape Industry Forecast Report BRICdata John Carpenter House 7 Carmelite Street London EC4Y 0BS United Kingdom Tel: +44 (0)20 7936 6400 Fax: +44 (0)20 7336 6813 Reference code: IS2013MR Published: May 2012 www.bricdata.com www.bricdata.com

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 1 Executive Summary Market size The Indian consumer finance market valued INRX.XX trillion in 2011, after growing at a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of XX.XX% during the review period (2007 2011). It is projected to retain a high CAGR of XX.XX% over the forecast period (2012 2016), to reach a value of INRXX.XX trillion in 2016. The strong growth will be driven by the country s improving macro- and micro-economic fundamentals, and by the increasing domestic demand for consumer finance services. The personal loans category valued INRXXX.X billion in 2011, after recording an annual growth rate of XX.X% during the year. India s credit card loans category is in an early stage of development, and recorded a poor CAGR of -X.XX% during the review period due to its high defaults rate. However, the category is expected to achieve positive CAGR of X.XX% over the forecast period, to reach a value of INRXXX.X billion in 2016. The auto loans category increased in value at an impressive CAGR of XX.XX% during the review period. The fastest-growing category was gold loans, which achieved a CAGR of XX.XX% during the review period. As a result, the gold loans category reached a value of INRXXX.X billion in 2011. The housing loans category valued INRX.X trillion in 2011, after registering an annual growth rate of XX.X%. The category is expected to grow at a CAGR of XX.XX% over the forecast period. The educational loan category recorded a robust CAGR of XX.XX% during the review period, to reach a value of INRXXX.X billion in 2011. Trends and drivers Challenges Regulations India s rising employment levels are expected to generate more demand for consumer finance in the country. The unemployment rate in India is projected to decrease from X.X% in 2011 to X.X% in 2016. The improving employment conditions in the country will encourage Indians to increase their personal consumption expenditure, which will create a higher demand for consumer finance products, such as personal loans, education loans, auto loans and mortgage loans. The changing lifestyles and increasing spending on the consumer durables in India is providing lucrative investment opportunities in the consumer finance market. The changing of consumption pattern from basic commodities to discretionary products, such as branded products, has encouraged Indians to take out more personal loans during the review period. The increasing number of automobile sales in India has increased the demand for auto loans. The Indian economic growth led the disposable income levels in the country to rise, which encouraged more of the population to purchase automobiles. Approximately 75% of Indian cars are bought through loans and around 90% of commercial vehicles are purchased using auto loans. The country s sustained economic growth, rising disposable income levels, affordable interest rates and tax incentives are the main macroeconomic growth drivers that are encouraging the housing loan category s development in India. Although the Indian consumer finance market registered significant growth during the review period, the market s growth decelerated towards the end of the review period as a result of the country s microfinance crisis caused by India s strict regulatory environment. The Indian consumer finance market has a reputation of having a high defaults rate in the personal loan category. The defaults rate in the personal loan category rose sharply during the review period, which led Indian consumer finance providers to face liquidity pressures and low assets. The Indian banking industry is well developed, and highly regulated by the Reserve Bank of India (RBI). There are numerous laws in the country that regulate various types of retail lending transactions and control the lending activities of banks, non-banking financial companies (NBFCs) and microfinance institutions at both the central and state levels. In addition, the Banking Regulation Act manages several activities of the Reserve Bank of India. Page 2

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Competitive landscape The Indian banking industry is well regulated, and contains 167 commercial banks. The banks operating in India include a mixture of both domestic and foreign businesses. Despite the fragmented nature of the Indian banking industry, the competitive landscape for the Indian consumer finance market varies significantly depending on each product category. The auto loan category is dominated by privately owned enterprises, especially three private-sector banks: HDFC Bank, ICICI Bank and Kotak. The credit card loan category is in an initial stage of development. The category is consolidated among four leading banks: the State Bank of India, HDFC Bank, ICICI Bank and Citibank. These four banks together generated over XX% of the total category value in 2011. Meanwhile, the education loans in the country are mainly provided by public-sector banks. Page 3

TABLE OF CONTENTS TABLE OF CONTENTS 1 Executive Summary... 2 2 Future Outlook of Consumer Finance in India... 8 3 Indian Consumer Finance Market Dynamics... 10 3.1 Macroeconomic fundamentals... 11 3.1.1 GDP... 11 3.1.2 Annual disposable income... 12 3.1.3 Inflation rate... 13 3.1.4 FDI inflows... 14 3.2 Consumer attitudes towards credit... 15 3.3 Key performance indicators... 16 3.4 Regulatory framework... 18 4 Indian Consumer Finance Market Opportunity and Growth Potential... 20 4.1 Overview... 20 4.2 Personal Loans... 22 4.3 Credit Card Loans... 23 4.4 Auto Loans... 24 4.5 Gold Loans... 25 4.6 Housing Loans... 26 4.7 Education Loans... 27 5 Key Trends and Growth Drivers for the Indian Consumer Finance Market... 28 5.1 Personal Loans... 28 5.2 Credit Card Loans... 29 5.3 Auto Loans... 30 5.4 Gold Loans... 31 5.5 Housing Loans... 32 5.6 Education Loans... 34 6 Industry Structure and... 35 6.1 Indian Banking Industry Market Share... 36 6.2 Housing Loan... 37 6.3 Auto Loan... 38 6.4 Credit Card Loan... 39 6.5 Education Loan... 40 6.6 Gold Loan... 41 7 Strategies... 42 7.1 Marketing and Product Strategies... 42 7.2 Market Entry Strategies... 44 7.3 Growth Strategies... 46 8 Challenges... 47 9 Company Profiles... 48 9.1 State Bank of India (SBI)... 48 9.2 Housing Development Finance Corp. Ltd (HDFC)... 49 Page 4

TABLE OF CONTENTS 9.3 ICICI Bank Ltd... 51 9.4 Kotak Mahindra Bank... 53 9.5 AXIS Bank Limited... 54 9.6 Other private banks... 55 10 Appendix... 56 10.1 About BRICdata... 56 10.1.1 Areas of expertise... 56 10.2 Methodology... 57 10.3 Disclaimer... 58 Page 5

TABLE OF CONTENTS LIST OF FIGURES Figure 1: Indian Future Outlook of Consumer Finance (INR Billion)... 8 Figure 2: Indian GDP at Constant Prices (US$ Billion), 2007 2016 (Base Year 1999 2000)... 11 Figure 3: Indian Annual Disposable Income (US$ Billion), 2007 2016... 12 Figure 4: Indian Inflation Rate (%), 2007 2016... 13 Figure 5: Indian FDI Inflows (US$ Billion), 2007 2010... 14 Figure 6: Indian Banking Industry Value by Loans and Deposits (US$ Billion), 2007 2016... 16 Figure 7: Indian Banking Industry Growth by Performance Indictor (%), 2007 2016... 17 Figure 8: Indian Consumer Finance Market Size (INR Trillion), 2007 2016... 20 Figure 9: Indian Consumer Finance Market Size by Category (INR Billion), 2007 2016... 21 Figure 10: Indian Personal Loans Market Size (INR Billion), 2007 2016... 22 Figure 11: Indian Credit Card Loans Market Size (INR Billion), 2007 2016... 23 Figure 12: Indian Auto Loans Market Size (INR Trillion), 2007 2016... 24 Figure 13: Indian Gold Loans Market Size (INR Billion), 2007 2016... 25 Figure 14: Indian Housing Loans Market Size (INR Trillion), 2007 2016... 26 Figure 15: Indian Education Loans Market Size (INR Billion), 2007 2016... 27 Figure 16: Indian Unemployment Rate (%), 2007 2016... 28 Figure 17: Indian Urban and Rural Population (%), 2007 2016... 32 Figure 18: Indian Number of Households (Million), 2007 2016... 33 Figure 19: Indian Leading Banks by Assets (% Share), March 2011... 36 Figure 20: Indian 10 Leading Banks by Assets (INR Billion), March 2011... 36 Figure 21: Indian Housing Loans Market Share (%), 2011... 37 Figure 22: Indian Auto Loans Market Share (%), 2011... 38 Figure 23: Indian Credit Card Loans Market Share (%), 2011... 39 Figure 24: Indian Gold Loans Market Share (%), 2011... 41 Page 6

TABLE OF CONTENTS LIST OF TABLES Table 1: Indian GDP at Constant Prices (US$ Billion), 2007 2016 (Base Year 1999 2000)... 11 Table 2: Indian Annual Disposable Income (US$ Billion), 2007 2016... 12 Table 3: Indian Inflation Rate (%), 2007 2016... 13 Table 4: Indian Banking Industry Value by Loans and Deposits (US$ Billion), 2007 2016... 16 Table 5: Indian Banking Industry Growth by Performance Indictor (%), 2007 2016... 17 Table 6: Indian Consumer Finance Market Size (INR Trillion), 2007 2011... 20 Table 7: Indian Consumer Finance Market Size by Category (INR Billion), 2007 2016... 21 Table 8: Indian Personal Loans Market Size (INR Billion), 2007 2016... 22 Table 9: Indian Credit Card Loans Market Size (US$ Million), 2007 2016... 23 Table 10: Indian Auto Loans Market Size (INR Trillion), 2007 2016... 24 Table 11: Indian Gold Loans Market Size (INR Billion), 2007 2016... 25 Table 12: Indian Housing Loans Market Size (INR Trillion), 2007 2016... 26 Table 13: Indian Education Loans Market Size (INR Billion), 2007 2011... 27 Table 14: Indian Credit Card Transactions Volume and Value, FY2009 FY2011... 29 Table 15: Market Entry Strategy of Foreign Banks in India... 44 Table 16: Foreign Banks in India... 44 Page 7

FUTURE OUTLOOK OF CONSUMER FINANCE IN INDIA 2 Future Outlook of Consumer Finance in India Personal loans The personal loans category increased in value at a CAGR of X.XX% during the review period, and is projected to register a CAGR of X.XX% over the forecast period, to reach INRX.X trillion in 2016. Credit card loans India s credit card loans category recorded high defaults rates during the review period, which led the category to record a negative CAGR of -X.XX% during the review period. Auto loans Figure 1: Indian Future Outlook of Consumer Finance Housing loans Auto loans Personal loans Gold loans Education loans Credit card loans CAGR 2011-2016 XXX% XXX% XXX% XXX% XXX% XXX% 2011 2016 Source: BRICdata analysis BRICdata Page 8

INDIAN CONSUMER FINANCE MARKET DYNAMICS 3 Indian Consumer Finance Market Dynamics This chapter covers four topics: the country s macroeconomic environment, consumer attitudes towards credit, key performance indicators and the consumer finance regulatory framework. The first section details the macroeconomic factors that affect the Indian consumer finance market. The second section analyses consumer attitude towards credit, the third section analyses the key performance indicators of Indian banking industry and the final section analyses the market s prevailing regulatory environment. Indian consumer finance market can be segmented into the following categories: Personal loans Credit card loans Auto loans Gold loans Housing loans Educations loans 3.1 Macroeconomic fundamentals 3.1.1 GDP India s gross domestic product (GDP) at constant prices valued US$X.X trillion in 2011, after increasing at a CAGR of X.XX% during the review period. The country s GDP is projected to record a stronger CAGR of X.XX% over the forecast period, to reach a value of US$X.X trillion in 2016. Since the Indian economy is expected to grow strongly over the forecast period, the demand for financial services and the Indian consumer finance market should also rise. Table 1: Indian GDP at Constant Prices (US$ Billion), 2007 2016 (Base Year 1999 2000) 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 GDP XXX.X XXX.X XXX.X XXX.X X,XXX.X 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 GDP X,XXX.X X,XXX.X X,XXX.X X,XXX.X X,XXX.X Source: BRICdata analysis BRICdata Figure 2: Indian GDP at Constant Prices (US$ Billion), 2007 2016 (Base Year 1999 2000) Source: BRICdata analysis BRICdata Page 9

INDIAN CONSUMER FINANCE MARKET OPPORTUNITY 4 Indian Consumer Finance Market Opportunity and Growth Potential 4.1 Overview India s consumer finance market recorded strong growth during the review period. This was mainly due to the banking industry s robust development, and the country s increasing disposable income and rising property prices in tier I and tier II cities. The consumer finance market valued INRX.X trillion in 2011, after increasing at a CAGR of XX.XX% during the review period. It is projected to register a CAGR of XX.XX% over the forecast period, to reach a value of INRXX.X trillion in 2016. The strong growth will be driven by the country s improving macroeconomic conditions and rising domestic demand for consumer finance products. Table 6: Indian Consumer Finance Market Size (INR Trillion), 2007 2011 Year Market Size (INR Trillion) 2007 X.XX 2008 X.XX 2009 X.XX 2010 X.XX 2011 X.XX 2012 XX.XX 2013 XX.XX 2014 XX.XX 2015 XX.XX 2016 XX.XX Source: BRICdata analysis BRICdata Figure 8: Indian Consumer Finance Market Size (INR Trillion), 2007 2016 Source: BRICdata analysis BRICdata Page 10

KEY TRENDS AND GROWTH DRIVERS 5 Key Trends and Growth Drivers for the Indian Consumer Finance Market 5.1 Personal Loans Improving employment situation India s rising employment levels are expected to generate more demand for consumer finance in the country. The unemployment rate in India is projected to decrease from X.X% in 2011 to X.X% in 2016. The improving employment conditions in the country will encourage Indians to increase their personal consumption expenditure, which will create a higher demand for consumer finance products such as personal loans. Figure 16: Indian Unemployment Rate (%), 2007 2016 Source: BRICdata analysis BRICdata Page 11

COMPANY PROFILES 6 Industry Structure and 6.1 Indian Banking Industry Market Share The State Bank of India was India s leading bank in terms of assets, as it accounted for XX.X% of the total assets in the banking industry in March 2011. Meanwhile, the private ICICI Bank was the second-largest bank in the country, with X.X% of the total banking industry assets in 2011. Figure 19: Indian Leading Banks by Assets (% Share), March 2011 Source: BRICdata analysis BRICdata Page 12

APPENDIX 7 Appendix 7.1 About BRICdata BRICdata publishes in-depth strategic intelligence reports that help its customers better understand opportunities in emerging markets and industry sectors. Its reports provide an independent, expert view supported by primary research and access to leading data and intelligence sources. BRICdata is a comprehensive source of insights and analysis, and publishes a broad range of reports across a number of different industry sectors, including consumer, retail, financial services, technology, telecoms and construction. BRICdata is headquartered in London with research, analysis and account management teams based across Europe, the US and Asia-Pacific. Its global research footprint is supported by a network of external associates, data partners and industry experts to give the clearest possible perspective on emerging markets. 7.1.1 Areas of expertise BRICdata operates a dedicated, multilingual team of in-house industry analysts with significant experience of global and country-level research. BRICdata also maintains data and research partnerships with other research companies, industry experts and trade associations, along with a network of independent industry consultants and former industry participants contributing research and reports to bring additional insight and expertise in more specialist areas. BRICdata s research offering spans the following industry areas: Construction BRICdata publishes reports covering the entire construction value chain: construction materials, equipment, construction services, architectural services and interior design. It also covers the main value sectors of construction activity: commercial, infrastructure, industrial, institutional and residential. This comprehensive view of the market enables BRICdata to detail key growth sectors and countries and identify the most attractive industry opportunities. Consumer goods Covering a broad range of areas across the consumer goods market, from interior products to fast-moving consumer goods (FMCG), ingredients, and packaging, BRICdata offers a comprehensive insight into key consumer sectors across fast-growing markets, identifying key trends, future innovations and growth opportunities. Comprehensive data sets including unique primary survey-driven research creates accurate market forecasts and understanding of the factors driving consumption behavior. Financial services Providing detailed insights into insurance and banking markets, BRICdata s financial services reports identify key market opportunities, emerging technologies and channel strategies. The reports provide unique data combined with local examples of best practice and expert insights into the market. Retail BRICdata maintains a comprehensive database of forecasts of retail spending, along with a series of unique indicators enabling a forward view of retailers prospects in emerging markets. The reports identify emerging concepts in retail, including the nascent online and mobile retail sectors in the BRIC countries and other emerging markets. Technology BRICdata tracks key trends and innovations, emerging technologies and markets, and the key operators in both emerging markets and technologies. Covering a range of emerging and disruptive technologies including telecoms, social media, online and mobile retailing, and telemedicine, BRICdata examines strategies for success, the state of the competitive landscape and the inherent threats and opportunities in the emerging technological economy. Page 13

APPENDIX 7.2 Methodology All BRICdata reports are rigorously sourced and created according to a comprehensive, two-stage methodology. This includes internal audit and primary research. A) Internal audit Review of in-house databases to gather existing data: o Historic market databases and reports o Company database o projects database B) Primary research Review of the latest company strategy and asset management trends 1) Research A. Sources Collection of the latest market-specific data from a wide variety of industry sources: o Government statistics o Industry associations o Company filings o Broker reports o International organizations B. Expert opinion Collation of opinion taken from leading industry experts Analysis of third-party opinion and forecasts: o Broker reports o Industry associations o Official government sources C. Data consolidation and verification Consolidation of data and opinion to create historical datasets Creation of models to benchmark data across sectors and geographies 2) Research Analysis Market forecasts Feed of forecast data into market models: o Macroeconomic indicators o Industry-specific drivers Analysis of Market Databases to identify trends by sector: o Latest trends o Key drivers of the market 3) Report Writing Analysis of market data Discussion of company and industry trends and issues Integration of survey results Annual review of trends Standardization of market definitions using recognized industry classifications 4) Quality Control A. Templates Detailed process manuals Standardized report templates and accompanying style guides Complex forecasting tool used to ensure forecast methodologies are consistently applied QC checklists B. QC process Peer review Senior-level QC Random spot checks on data integrity Page 14

APPENDIX 7.3 Disclaimer All rights reserved. Benchmark checks across databases Market data cross-checked for consistency with accumulated data from company filings No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior permission of the publisher, BRICdata. The facts of this report are believed to be correct at the time of publication but cannot be guaranteed. Please note that the findings, conclusions and recommendations that BRICdata delivers will be based on information gathered in good faith from both primary and secondary sources, whose accuracy we are not always in a position to guarantee. BRICdata can, therefore, accept no liability whatsoever for actions taken based on any information that may subsequently prove to be incorrect. Page 15