Kim Erickson November 20, 2014 Phoenix, AZ New Emerging Technologies
CEE member program administrators impact markets in the US and Canada Residential Commercial Industrial Whole House HVAC Gas Space Heating Appliances Gas Water Heating Lighting Consumer Electronics Swimming Pools Building Performance Unitary Airconditioning and Heat Pumps Gas Boiler Systems Clothes Washers Kitchens Gas Water Heating Lighting Systems Data Centers and Servers Strategic Energy Management Premium Efficiency Motors Motor Systems Distribution Transformers Municipal Water and Wastewater 2
CEE supports cross cutting functions EM&V Behavior change Connectivity Emerging Technology 2014 Emerging Technologies Collaborative Sponsors BC Hydro Bonneville Power Administration ComEd DTE Energy Northwest Energy Efficiency Alliance NYSERDA Sacramento Municipal Utility District Sempra Southern California Edison Xcel Energy 3
Adoption Emerging Technologies 101 Does it work? Does it save energy? Can the market deliver it? Do people like it? How do we identify the highest performers? How do we leverage existing trade networks? Time Energy efficiency programs work to shorten the adoption time 4
Strategic Energy Management 5% average annual energy intensity reduction More savings over time 5
SEM Minimum Elements Customer commitment Policy, goals, resources Planning and implementation Assessment, map, metrics and goals, project register, employee engagement, implementation, reassessment, System for measuring and reporting energy performance Measurement, data collection and availability, analysis, reporting 6
Strategic Energy Management Programs 2014 Industrial SEM Programs & Pilots (21) AEP Ohio Ameren IL BC Hydro BPA Commonwealth Edison-Nicor Gas Consumers Energy Efficiency New Brunswick Efficiency Nova Scotia Efficiency Vermont Energy Trust of Oregon Focus on Energy WI Hydro Quebec Idaho Power National Grid OPA PPL Electric Utilities Puget Sound Energy Pacificorp Snohomish PUD So Cal Edison-So Cal Gas Co. Tacoma Power Bold indicates programs that use the CEE SEM Minimum Elements in program design or delivery Data collected by CEE in the 2011-2014 CEE SEM Program Case Studies surveys 7
Strategic Energy Management CONSIDERATIONS Multi-year engagements Ability to claim savings from O&M, behavior Goals related to customer satisfaction, economic development RESOURCES CEE Initiative, common definition Case studies National and international platforms DOE Superior Energy Performance ENERGY STAR for Industry ISO 50001 8
Health Care Opportunity: Interested industry Challenges Limited data, particularly on plug loads Competing customer priorities Resources ENERGY STAR, CEE Health Care Exploration Work together, bigger impact Define targeted objective Support interested industry meet targeted objective 9
Demand Control Kitchen Ventilation (DCKV) 30-70% Range of fan energy savings + 11% HVAC savings in mild climate 10
DCKV Programs 2014 >1,000,000 Kitchen Ventilation Systems in the US Market penetration around 5% Based on the 2014 CEE Commercial Kitchens Program Summary. DCKV Programs (31) AEP Ohio, Ameren IL, Austin Energy BC Hydro, BPA, City of Palo Alto Commonwealth Edison, Consumers Energy DTE Energy, Efficiency Nova Scotia Energy Trust of Oregon, Fortis BC Gaz Metro, Georgia Power Hawaii Energy Efficiency Program Northern California Power Agency NV Energy, NYSERDA PG&E, Pacificorp, PECO Platte River Power Authority Sacramento Municipal Utility District San Diego Gas and Electric Snohomish PUD, So Cal Edison Southern Minnesota Municipal Power Agency Union Gas. Vermont Gas WI Focus on Energy, Xcel Energy 11
Demand Control Kitchen Ventilation (DCKV) CONSIDERATIONS Savings vary by application, climate, system configuration Quality installation, commissioning, and training are key Ongoing monitoring and commissioning helps persistence RESOURCES CEE Program Design Guide ENERGY STAR Emerging Tech Award DOE Better Buildings Alliance Guide and member interest Field test protocol and case study collection 12
Commercial Advanced Lighting and Controls 0% Worst case scenario, controls only Savings from controls alone 70% 93% Savings from controls + lighting upgrade Source: Cree Market penetration of LED linear replacement lamps <0.1% 70% % of lighting not automatically controlled Source: Lighting Controls Association 13
Commercial Advanced Lighting Controls CONSIDERATIONS Savings vary by application, product and existing conditions Technology evolves very rapidly Program claimable savings vary based on building codes RESOURCES CEE Assessment Procedure for Commercial Lighting Controls Compilation of CEE members assessments In process/under consideration by CEE Lighting Committee 14
Heat Pump Water Heaters 2,684 kwh* Annual energy savings for an average family with a 50 gallon HPWH with an EF of 2.35, when compared to an electric resistance water heater. *Based on the US Government Energy Guide Label. Source: US DOE, Measure Guideline: Heat Pump Water Heaters in New and Existing Homes, February 2012. 15
Heat Pump Water Heaters Assessments (18) Bonneville Power Administration, Duke Energy, Northwest Energy Efficiency Alliance, Pacific Gas and Electric, Sacramento Municipal Utility District, San Diego Gas and Electric, Tennessee Valley Authority 2014 Programs (27)* Baltimore Gas and Electric, Black Hills Energy, Cape Light Compact, City of Palo Alto Utilities, Con Ed, CT Light and Power, Efficiency ME, Efficiency VT, Fortis BC, Liberty Utilities, National Grid, NH Electric Coop, NJ Clean Energy Program, NIPSCO, NSTAR, NYSERDA, PG&E, Public Service of NH, Puget Sound Energy, Sacramento Municipal Utility District, SoCal Edison, Tennessee Valley Authority, United Illuminating, Unitil, Western MA Electric *Based on the 2014 CEE Residential Appliances Program Summary. 16
Heat Pump Water Heaters CONSIDERATIONS Market readiness: installer capabilities Customer readiness: Noise Complexity Site requirements Adequate airflow Condensate drain Ambient temps RESOURCES Compilation of CEE member assessments (in process) ENERGY STAR specification Online reviews 17
Clothes Dryers, Heat Pump Clothes Dryers Savings Potential: 20%* Resource: ENERGY STAR ET Award and 2015 Spec Concern: Understanding actual energy performance of baseline and EE models Multiple test procedures Do test procedures reflect real world conditions? Concern: Customer preferences and drying time *Based on ENERGY STAR website 18
Televisions and Set Top Boxes Savings Potential: 25%* Resource: ENERGY STAR, CEE Consumer Electronics Program Center What s new: Ultra HD TVs *Based on ENERGY STAR website Savings Potential: 45%* Resource: ENERGY STAR, CEE working group Challenges: non-traditional partners, lack of data on energy consumption and use 19
Wrap Up Televisions Set Top Boxes Demand Control Kitchen Ventilation Strategic Energy Management Advanced Lighting and Lighting Controls Clothes Dryers Heat Pump Water Heaters 20
Contact Kim Erickson Senior Program Manager Emerging Technologies 617-532-0026 kerickson@cee1.org 21