Latvia during the global economic and financial crisis Second Japan Baltic Seminar 1 December 2009, Tokyo 1
Different experience behind, challenges ahead 15 10 5 Transition -56% in 1991-1993 GDP 1991-2012 (% yoy) 0 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012-5 -10-15 -20 Banking crisis Russian crisis EU accession +33% in 2004-2007 -25 Global/local crisis -30-35 -25% 2008-2010 Source: statistics, SEB bank a 2
Development trends of economy 2004-20072007 Growth stimulus domestic demand Substantial inflow of capital Increasing domestic demand Rapid growth Emerging risks: Internal imbalance External imbalance 2008-20102010 Influence of the global financial crisis Decrease of the inflow of foreign capital in Latvia Improvement of CAB Domestic demand declines External demand shrinks GDP decreases 2011- Growth stimulus external demand Global financial system recovery External demand increases Latvian exports grow Domestic demand increases GDP increases 3
Main reasons behind the severe crisis in Latvia Expansionary fiscal policy in the booming times - no reserves for tougher times The real estate bubble: real estate prices increased 6.5 times the increase in wages only 2.5 times (June 2001- December 2006 ) partially financed by credit (50% per year growth in 2003-2007); Inflation without corresponding productivity growth eroded Latvia s competitiveness (in 2008 inflation was 15.4%) Large current account deficit (>25% of GDP in 2006) Global financial crisis at the end of 2008 hit also Latvia s banking system (bail-out of the largest domestically-owned commercial bankworth 1.9% of GDP directly and 5% indirectly ) 4
Macroeconomic indicators of Latvia in 2009 The economy of Latvia is still in the correction phase from the huge imbalances accumulated during the years of overheating, but stabilisation signs start to appear: In Q3 2009 GDP dropped by 18.4% (seasonally non-adjusted, year-on-year), while on quarter-to-quarter basis there was an increase by 3.9% (positive already for 2 periods); The overall industrial production output has slightly increased (in Q3 2009 increased by 0.5% compared to Q2 2009); Several industries display growth on a yearly basis (wood and chemical up by 17% and 8% respectively); The enormous contraction of the economy induces changes in the labour market and the job market is returning under the control of the employers: Registered unemployment level has grown to 14.1% in October 2009; In Q2 2009 the average real wage compared to the previous year s value was lower by 3%, while in the state budget sector the nominal wage cut was approximately 22%; There are clear signs for increased Latvia s competitiveness: Year-on-year inflation in October 2009 was negative with deflation of 0.9%, while on a monthly basis prices have been decreasing already for 7 months, averaging to 0.5% per month; Current account deficit has turned into a surplus (from -13% in 2008 to +1.3% in Q1 2009, and approximately +14.2% of GDP in Q2 2009. 5 Source: CSB, State Employment Agency, Bank of Latvia
Foreign trade is renewing Exports and imports of goods by quarters (LVL mln) 2500 2000 Exports Imports 1500 1000 500 0 2005 I II III IV 2006 I III IV 2007 I III IV 2008 I III IV 2009 I III 6 II II II II Source: CSB
700 600 500 400 300 200 100 0-100 -200-300 -400-500 -600-700 -800-900 -1000-1100 Astonishing surplus in current account Current account (LVL m) 07 I II III IV 08 I II III IV 09 I II GOODS SERVICES INCOME CURRENT TRANSFERS Soure: Bank of Latvia 7
Million LVL 3500 Safe currency 3000 2500 2000 1500 1000 500 0 I 2008 II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII I 2009 Net foreign assets II III IV V VI VII VIII Monetary base Source: Bank of Latvia 8
International Financial support EUR 7.5 billion available 40% of GDP 2009 40% taken by now The financial support has allowed Latvia to, i.a.: Cover budget deficits Refinance the government liabilities Support the banking system Nordic Countries (not taken); 1900 International support, EUR mln Other (not taken); 400 EC (taken); 2200 NB - close to 50% of the received funds were held in the Treasury to ensure the stability of financial sector IMF (not taken); 900 IMF(taken); 800 EC (not taken); 900 World Bank (not taken); 400 Source: Ministry of Finance 9
Program for stabilization and growth revival of the national economy (I) Goals: to stabilise the economy; to evade possible liquidity problems; to renew long-term stability by strengthening the banking sector, preventing fiscal imbalances, and preserving stable monetary policy; to improve the competitiveness of the national economy to reach sustainable GDP growth and balanced state budget as soon as possible. 10
Program for stabilization and growth revival of the national economy (II) Strict and stable monetary policy, which is based in fixed exchange rate of the national currency to the euro. The do all the necessary steps to fulfill the Maastricht criteria that would ensure introduction of the euro as soon as possible by 2014; Strict fiscal policy. Consolidation measures to decrease the budget deficit in 2012 by up to 3% of GDP; Decreasing of remuneration. Reductions of wages and the employed in the public sector and to encourage understanding and agreement with the private sector to promote the moderation of wages in all sectors; 11
Program for stabilization and growth revival of the national economy (III) Continuation of making state administration more effective and efficient, carrying out of education, health, and other public services reforms by decreasing and restructuring of human resources in these sectors and optimise ministries and their subordinate agencies in terms of activity and number of institutions; Increasing the flexibility of labour market by fostering requalification and returning to work of the unemployed; Stabilisation of financial sector. Provision of state aid for strengthening of credibility and work ability of credit institutions hand in hand with intensified supervision of credit institutions; 12
Program for stabilization and growth revival of the national economy (IV) Maintaining of social protection activities to lower social tension; Decreasing the administrative burden: simplifying the processes of tax administration, real estate registration, receiving construction permits, as well as by promoting a wider usage of the state integrated information systems among institutions and enterprises; The state and the municipal governments implement the measures to foster the development of entrepreneurship and to facilitate business registration and licensing procedures; In order to improve the processes of business insolvency and liquidation, the government has drafted amendments to the Insolvency Law; Legal framework for PPP projects is improved; 13
Program for stabilization and growth revival of the national economy (V) Improving economic competitiveness by concentrating the financing of the EU structural funds. EUR 4.53 billion (20% of GDP 2009) available by year 2013. Almost 20% of the funds or close to EUR 1 billion for stimulating entrepreneurship; Loan instruments, guarantees by the Latvian Guarantee agency and the State Treasury, risk capital instruments, advance payments for projects financed from the EU funds to be implemented; Several programmes have been launched aimed at promotion of knowledge-based economy; The export credit guarantee system that has been introduced as of 1 June 2009; The programme on the improvement of energy efficiency of apartment buildings has been launched. 14
Budget 2010 Screening of the state budget expenditures according to functions; Domestic and external experts, social partners involved; Takes into account the agreements reached with international donors; Budget deficit of 6.5% of GDP 2010: Consolidation by 4.2% of GDP 2010; Well below the 8.5% agreed with the IMF and the EC; Budget 2010 to be passed in Parliament today (1 December 2009). 15 Source: Ministry of Finance
Fiscal consolidation will continue Central government budget deficit (mln. lats) 5500 5000 * amendments in January ** amendments in April *** amendments in June 4500 4000 3500 3000 2500 2000 1500 1000 2006 2007 2008 2009* 2009** 2009*** 2010* 16 EXPENDITURE REVENUES Source: CSB, MoF Source: PM advisors
Consolidation measures/ structural reforms (I) Structural reforms/ optimizations: # of employees in ministries (-30%) # of state agencies (76 25) Nominal wages in public sector (-22%) (Q2 2009 (y-o-y)) Unified salary system in public sector # of hospitals (59 24) # of schools (# closed ~100) Administrative burden (e.g. easing the VAT related procedures) 17
Consolidation measures/ structural reforms (II) Revenues: Excise tax Real estate tax base Capital gains tax for deposits, dividends introduced Gambling tax VAT (18 21%) Non-taxable minimum Dividends from state owned companies No changes planned in Corporate Income tax State guarantees for loans: To improve competitiveness For exports to risky destinations For self-employed and micro companies 18
Outlook for 2010 The GDP decline has bottomed out in 2009. In 2010 the GDP contraction is expected to be around 4% with positive GDP growth in the second half of 2010. At the end of 2010 the registered unemployment level is expected to be close to the value today. The internal devaluation process will keep its momentum the wages are expected to further adjust so to reach the real level of Latvia s productivity. The negative wage growth will also be reflected in the inflation the overall yearly average inflation will be negative in 2010. The latter two factors will have a positive impact on Latvia s competitiveness, notably it will be displayed in Latvia s export dynamics. In 2010 Latvia s exports are expected to resume growth on a yearly basis. In 2010 the internal market is still expected to shrink, therefore we expect also continuation of the decrease in imports. 19