From Skategate to Biathlon: Defining Corruption in Sport Samantha Gorse Centre for the International Business of Sport Coventry University
Agenda The aims of this presentation are to: Highlight the differences between management and competition corruption in sport, providing examples of each from Winter Sports Discuss the dilemma in defining corruption in sport Provide a definition of corruption in sport
Corruption in Sport Doping Vote Rigging Gambling Match Fixing Undue Influence Points Shaving Bribery Embezzlement Over 2,000 cases of corruption collected SO FAR
Management Corruption Maennig (2005) Involves non-competition decisions made by sporting officials and governing bodies For example: Awarding of host city status for major sporting events Negotiation and allocation of rights (e.g. broadcasting, merchandising) Awarding of contracts for construction of sporting venues and the governance of sport
IOC Hosting Rights Scandal 2002 Winter Olympics in Salt Lake City Lost rights to hold the 1998 Winter Games Paid more than $1million to 24 member of the IOC panel that chooses the venue for the Games Two executives on the organising committee forced to resign and leader of the bidding committee dropped from a lucrative consulting role IOC forced resignation of 4 IOC members and expelled another 6
Skategate 2002 Winter Olympics in Salt Lake City, USA Close contest between Canadian pair, Jamie Sale & David Pelletier, and the Russian skaters Yelena Berezhnaya and Anton Sikharulidze Gold medal initially awarded to the Russian pair Canadians awarded a gold medal after French judge, Marie-Reine Le Gougne, was forced to vote for the Russian pair in exchange for a French ice dance victory
Competition Corruption Maennig (2005) Involves activities by athletes and/or those officials who have a direct responsibility for the outcome of a sporting contest (i.e. a referee or umpire) For example: Doping Match Fixing Points Shaving
Doping in Biathlon Olga Medvedtseva (Pyleva) Stripped of her silver medal from the 15km race and kicked out of the Olympics for a positive drugs test for carphedon Stated that she had been given drugs by a trusted personal doctor for an ankle injury that hadn t included carphedon on its ingredients list Banned for two years
Tocchetgate Investigated as part of Operation Slapshot, an illegal nationwide gambling ring, led by New Jersey State Police Tocchet, a 22-year NHL veteran, pleaded guilty to conspiracy to promote gambling and promoting gambling Defence lawyer, Kevin Marino, said that Tocchet was not involved in fixing hockey games Given two years probation NJ State trooper, James Harney, sentenced to six years in prison for his part
Defining the Problem Sport Sociology Hughes & Coakley (1991) Positive Deviance and Overconforming to the Sport Ethic Love the thrill of competing and want to continue to participate for as long as possible Athletes don t see their overconformity to the sport ethic as deviant Through positive deviance people do harmful things to themselves and perhaps others while motivated by a sense of duty and honour (311)
Defining the Problem Sports Economics In sport, corruption may take the form of behaviour by athletes who refrain from achieving the levels of performance normally required in the sport in question to win the competition and instead intentionally permit others to win, or behaviour by sporting officials who consciously perform their allocated tasks in a manner at variance with the objectives and moral values of the relevant club, association, competitive sports, in general and/or society at large Maennig (2005:189)
Defining the Problem Clear that these two definitions of corruption are at odds How can an athlete be doing everything to overconform to the sport ethic, to be seen as an athlete, and allow an opponent to win? Lack of standardisation in a definition of corruption and in dealing with the behaviour Lyudmila Blonska or Dwain Chambers Major League Baseball or National Football League
Defining the Problem today Corruption in sport is: Any illegal, immoral or unethical activity that attempts to deliberately distort the result of a sporting contest for the material gain of one or more parties involved in that activity Gorse & Chadwick (2009)
Where now? Construction of database detailing cases of corruption in international sport Further development of typology of corruption Analysis of how corruption impacts on sport marketing strategy
Thank you for your attention For more information about this research project, please visit the CIBS website http://www.coventry.ac.uk/researchnet/d/755 and look at the Working Paper Series