Fist-Ode Special Relativistic Coections to Keple s Obits Tyle J. Lemmon and Antonio R. Mondagon Physics Depatment, Coloado College, Coloado Spings, Coloado 80903 (Dated: Decembe 30, 00) Abstact axiv:0.5438v [asto-ph.ep] 4 Dec 00 Beginning with a Lagangian that is consistent with both Newtonian gavity and the momentum-velocity elation of special elativity, an appoximate elativistic obit equation is deived that descibes elativistic coections to Kepleian obits. Specifically, coections to a Kepleian obit due to special elativity include: pecession of peihelion, educed adius of cicula obit, and inceased eccenticity. The pediction fo the ate of pecession of peihelion of Mecuy is in ageement with existing calculations using only special elativity, and is one sixth that deived fom geneal elativity. All thee of these coections ae qualitatively coect, though suppessed when compaed to the moe accuate geneal-elativistic coections in this limit. The esulting obit equation has the same fom as that deived fom geneal elativity and is easily compaed to that descibing Keple s obits. This teatment of the elativistic cental-mass poblem is complementay to othe solutions to the elativistic Keple poblem, and is appoachable by undegaduate physics majos whom have not had a couse dedicated to elativity. PACS numbes: 04.5.Nx, 95.30.Sf, 03.30.+p, 95.0.Ce
I. INTRODUCTION The elativistic contibution to the ate of pecession of peihelion of Mecuy is calculated accuately using geneal elativity [ 6]. Howeve, the poblem is commonly discussed in undegaduate and gaduate classical mechanics textbooks, without intoduction of an entiely new, metic theoy of gavity. One appoach [7 ] is to define a Lagangian that is consistent with both Newtonian gavity and the momentum-velocity elation of special elativity. The esulting equation of motion is solved petubatively, and an appoximate ate of pecession of peihelion of Mecuy is extacted. This appoach is satisfying in that all steps ae poved, and a bief intoduction to special elativity is included. On the othe hand, one must be content with an appoximate ate of pecession that is about one-sixth the coect value. Anothe appoach [ 6] is that of a mathematical execise and histoy lesson. A modification to Newtonian gavity is given, without poof, esulting in an equation of motion that is the same as that deived fom geneal elativity. The equation of motion is then solved using appopiate appoximations, and the coect ate of pecession of peihelion of Mecuy is extacted. Both appoaches povide an oppotunity fo students of classical mechanics to undestand that elativity is esponsible fo a small contibution to peihelic pecession and to calculate that contibution. We pesent a eview of the appoach using only special elativity, followed by an altenative solution of the equation of motion deived fom Lagange s equations. An appoximate ate of peihelic pecession is deived that agees with established calculations. This effect aises as one of seveal small coections to Keple s obits, including educed adius of cicula obit and inceased eccenticity. The method of solution makes use of coodinate tansfomations and the coespondence pinciple, athe than the standad petubative techniques, and is appoachable by undegaduate physics majos. A elativistic paticle of mass m obiting a cental mass M is commonly descibed by the Lagangian [7, 7 ] L = mc γ U(), () whee: γ v /c ; v = ṙ + θ ; and U() = GMm/. (G is Newton s univesal gavitational constant, and c is the speed of light in vacuum.) The equations of motion follow fom Lagange s equations, d L L = 0, () dt q i q i
fo each of {q i } = {θ, }, whee q i dq i /dt. The esults ae: which implies that l γ θ = constant; and d dt [γ θ] = 0, (3) γ + γṙ + GM γ θ = 0. (4) The fist of these [Eq. (3)] is the elativistic analogue to the Newtonian equation fo the consevation of angula momentum pe unit mass, and is used to eliminate θ in Eq. (4), γ θ = l γ 3. (5) Time is eliminated by successive applications of the chain ule, togethe with the conseved angula momentum [3 7]: and, theefoe, ṙ = l γ d dθ ; (6) γ = γṙ l γ d dθ. (7) Substituting Eqs. (5) and (7) into the equation of motion Eq. (4) esults in l d l GMγ + dθ = 0. (8) We anticipate a solution of Eq. (8) that is nea Kepleian and intoduce the adius of a cicula obit fo a nonelativistic paticle with the same angula momentum, c l /GM. The esult is d c dθ + c = + λ, (9) whee λ γ is a velocity-dependent coection to Newtonian obits due to special elativity. The conic-sections of Newtonian mechanics [8 33] ae ecoveed by setting λ = 0 (c ): d c dθ + c =, (0) which implies that whee e is the eccenticity. c = + e cos θ, () 3
II. KEPLERIAN LIMIT AND ORBIT EQUATION The planets of ou sola system ae descibed by nea-cicula obits (e ) and equie only small elativistic coections (v/c ). Mecuy has the lagest eccenticity (e 0.), and the next lagest is that of Mas (e 0.09). Theefoe, λ [defined afte Eq. (9)] is taken to be a small elativistic coection to nea-cicula obits of Newtonian mechanics (Kepleian obits). Neglecting the adial component of the velocity, which is small compaed to the tangential component, and expanding γ to fist ode in v /c esults in λ ( θ/c). () (See Sec. IV and App. A fo a thoough discussion of this appoximation.) Once again using the angula momentum to eliminate θ, this may be expessed as λ (l/c) γ (l/c) ( λ), o The equation of motion Eq. (9) is now expessed appoximately as λ (l/c). (3) d c dθ + c + ( ɛ c ). (4) whee ɛ (GM/lc). The conic-sections of Newtonian mechanics, Eq. (0) and Eq. (), ae now ecoveed by setting ɛ = 0 (c ). The solution of Eq. (4) fo ɛ 0 appoximately descibes Kepleian obits with small coections due to special elativity. If ɛ is taken to be a small elativistic coection to Kepleian obits, it is convenient to make the change of vaiable /s c /. The last tem on the ight-hand-side of Eq. (4) is then appoximated as ( c /) + /s, esulting in a linea diffeential equation fo /s(θ): ɛ d dθ s ( ɛ) + ɛ s The additional change of vaiable α θ ɛ esults in the familia fom: d s c dα s + s c s whee s c ( ɛ)/ɛ. The solution is simila to that of Eq. (0):. (5), (6) s c s + A cos α, (7) 4
whee A is an abitay constant of integation. In tems of the oiginal coodinates, Eq. (7) becomes whee c + ẽ cos κθ, (8) ɛ c c ɛ, (9) ẽ ɛ, (0) κ ( ɛ). () Accoding to the coespondence pinciple, Keple s obits, Eq. (), must be ecoveed in the limit ɛ 0 (c ), so that ɛa e is the eccenticity of Newtonian mechanics. To fist ode in ɛ, Eqs. (9) () become so that elativistic obits in this limit ae descibed concisely by c c ( ɛ), () ẽ e( + ɛ), (3) κ ɛ, (4) c ( ɛ) + e( + ɛ) cos ( ɛ)θ. (5) This appoximate obit equation has the same fom as that deived fom geneal elativity [34], c ( 3ɛ) + e( + 3ɛ) cos ( 3ɛ)θ, (6) and clealy displays thee chaacteistics: pecession of peihelion; educed adius of cicula obit; and inceased eccenticity. III. CHARACTERISTICS OF NEAR-KEPLERIAN ORBITS The appoximate obit equation Eq. (5) pedicts a shift in the peihelion though an angle θ π( κ ) πɛ (7) pe evolution. This pediction is identical to that deived using the standad appoach [7, 35] to incopoating special elativity into the Keple poblem, and is compaed to obsevations assuming 5
that the elativistic and Kepleian angula momenta ae appoximately equal. Fo a Kepleian obit [8 33] l = GMa( e ), whee G = 6.670 0 m 3 kg s, M =.989 0 30 kg is the mass of the Sun, and a and e ae the semi-majo axis and eccenticity of the obit, espectively. Theefoe, the elativistic coection defined afte Eq. (4), ɛ GM c a( e ), (8) is lagest fo planets closest to the Sun and fo planets with vey eccentic obits. Fo Mecuy [36, 37] a = 5.79 0 0 m and e = 0.056, so that ɛ.66 0 8. (The speed of light is taken to be c = 8.987554 0 6 m /s.) Accoding to Eq. (7), Mecuy pecesses though an angle θ πgm c a( e ) = 8.36 0 8 ad (9) pe evolution. This angle is vey small and is usually expessed cumulatively in ac seconds pe centuy. The obital peiod of Mecuy is 0.4085 teestial yeas, so that Θ 00 y 360 60 60 θ (30a) 0.4085 y π 7.6 acsec/centuy. (30b) The geneal elativistic (GR) teatment esults in a pediction of 43.0 acsec/centuy [34 55], and agees with the obseved pecession of peihelia of the inne planets [37 46, 56 59]. Histoically, this contibution to the pecession of peihelion of Mecuy s obit pecisely accounted fo the obseved discepancy, seving as the fist tiumph of the geneal theoy of elativity [ 4]. The pesent appoach, using only special elativity, accounts fo about one-sixth of the obseved discepancy, Eq. (30b). Pecession due to special elativity is illustated in Fig.. The appoximate elativistic obit equation Eq. (5) [o Eq. (8) togethe with Eqs. () (4)] pedicts that a elativistic obit in this limit has a educed adius of cicula obit (e = 0). This chaacteistic is not discussed in the standad appoach to incopoating special elativity into the Keple poblem, but is consistent with the GR desciption. An effective potential natually aises in the GR teatment of the cental-mass poblem [34, 36, 40, 4, 43, 46, 53, 54, 60, 6], V eff GM + l GMl c 3, (3) that educes to the Newtonian effective potential in the limit c. In the Kepleian limit, the GR angula momentum pe unit mass l is also taken to be appoximately equal to that fo a 6
Kepleian obit [34, 36 43, 46, 54, 6, 6]. Minimizing V eff with espect to esults in the adius of a stable cicula obit, R c = c + c ɛ c ( 3ɛ), (3) so that the adius of cicula obit is pedicted to be educed: R c c 3ɛ c. (Thee is also an unstable cicula obit. See Fig..) This eduction in adius of cicula obit is six times that pedicted by the pesent teatment using only special elativity, fo which c c ɛ c. [See Eq. ().] Most discussions of the GR effective potential Eq. (3) emphasize elativistic captue, athe than educed adius of cicula obit. The / 3 tem in Eq. (3) contibutes negatively to the effective potential, esulting in a finite centifugal baie and affecting obits vey nea the cental mass (lage-velocity obits). (See Fig..) This puely GR effect is not expected to be descibed by the appoximate obit equation Eq. (5), which is deived using only special elativity and assumes obits vey fa fom the cental mass (small-velocity obits). An additional chaacteistic of elativistic obits is that of inceased eccenticity. Equation (5) pedicts that a elativistic obit will have inceased eccenticity, when compaed to a Kepleian obit with the same angula momentum: ẽ e ɛe. [See Eq. 3.] This chaacteistic of elativistic obits also is not discussed in the standad appoach to incopoating special elativity into the Keple poblem, but is consistent with the GR desciption. The GR obit equation in this Kepleian limit Eq. (6) pedicts an incease in eccenticity ẽ e 3ɛe, which is six times that pedicted by the pesent teatment using only special elativity. IV. DISCUSSION The appoximate obit equation in Eq. (5) povides small coections to Keple s obits due to special elativity. [Compae Eqs. (5) and ().] A systematic veification may be caied out by substituting Eq. (5) into Eq. (4), keeping tems of odes e, ɛ, and eɛ only. The domain of validity is expessed by subjecting the solution Eq. (5) to the condition c (33) fo the smallest value of. Evaluating the obit equation Eq. (5) at the peihelion ( p ) esults in c = + e( + ɛ) p ɛ. (34) 7
The substitution of this esult into Eq. (33) esults in the domain of validity: e( + ɛ) + ɛ. (35) Theefoe, the elativistic eccenticity ẽ = e( + ɛ), and Eq. (5) is limited to descibing elativistic coections to nea-cicula (Kepleian) obits. Also, the elativistic coection ɛ, and thus the obit equation Eq. (5) is valid only fo small elativistic coections. In Sec. II the elativistic coection to Kepleian obits λ [defined afte Eq. (9)] is appoximated by: neglecting the adial component of the velocity, v = ṙ + ( θ) ( θ) ; and keeping tems only up to fist ode in the expansion γ + (v/c). Neglecting the adial component of the velocity in the elativistic coection λ is consistent with the assumption of nea-cicula, appoximately Kepleian obits, and is complementay to the assumption c / peceding Eq. (5). It is emphasized that the adial component of the velocity is neglected only in the elativistic coection λ; it is not neglected in the deivation of the elativistic equation of motion Eq. (9). That thee is no explicit appeaance of ṙ in the elativistic equation of motion Eq. (9), othe than in the definition of γ, is due to a fotunate cancellation afte Eq. (7). Futhemoe, the appoximate obit equation Eq. (5) has the same fom as that [Eq. (6)] aising fom the GR desciption, in which the adial component of the velocity is not explicitly neglected. A fist-ode seies appoximation fo γ is consistent with the Kepleian limit. Inteestingly, howeve, the poblem is soluble without tuncating the seies. (See Appendix A.) This moe elaboate deivation yields diminishing etuns due to the complementay assumption c /, which implicitly constains the velocity to be much smalle than the speed of light. The esulting appoximate obit equation [Eq. (A3)], c ( ɛ) + e( + 5ɛ) cos ( ɛ)θ, (36) 4 is almost identical to that deived using a much simple appoach in Sec. II [Eq. (5)]. Although this altenative obit equation pedicts a elativistic coection to eccenticity that is nealy onehalf that of the GR esult, it lacks the symmety of the GR obit equation Eq. (6), and it does not povide significant futhe qualitative undestanding of elativistic coections to Kepleian obits. V. CONCLUSION The pesent appoach to incopoating special elativity into the Keple poblem esults in an appoximate obit equation [Eq. (5)] that has the same fom as that deived fom geneal ela- 8
tivity in this limit [Eq. (6)] and is easily compaed to that descibing Keple s obits [Eq. (0)]. This obit equation clealy descibes thee coections to a Kepleian obit due to special elativity: pecession of peihelion; educed adius of cicula obit; and inceased eccenticity. The pedicted ate of pecession of peihelion of Mecuy is identical to established calculations using only special elativity. Each of these coections is exactly one-sixth of the coesponding coection descibed by geneal elativity in the Kepleian limit. This deivation of an appoximate obit equation is complementay to existing calculations of the ate of pecession of peihelion of Mecuy using only special elativity. The cental-mass poblem is descibed by a Lagangian that is consistent with both Newtonian gavity and the momentum-velocity elation of special elativity. Howeve, coodinate tansfomations and the coespondence pinciple ae used to solve the equations of motion esulting fom Lagange s equations, athe than the standad petubative methods. The esulting closed-fom, appoximate obit equation exhibits seveal chaacteistics of elativistic obits at once, but is limited to descibing small elativistic coections to appoximately Newtonian, nea-cicula obits. This obit equation, deived using only special elativity, povides a qualitative desciption of coections to Kepleian obits due to geneal elativity. Exact solutions to the special elativistic Keple poblem equie a thoough undestanding of special elativistic mechanics [63, 64] and ae, theefoe, inaccessible to most undegaduate physics majos. The pesent appoach and method of solution is undestandable to nonspecialists, including undegaduate physics majos whom have not had a couse dedicated to elativity. Appendix A Fo nea-cicula obits the adial component of the velocity is small compaed to the tangential component and is neglected in the elativistic coection λ = γ. [See Eq. (9).] An exact infinite-seies epesentation, γ n=0 ( (n)! θ ) n, (A) n (n!) c is used, athe than the appoximate fist-ode tuncated seies used in Sec. II. (The emainde of this deivation paallels that of Sec. II.) Consevation of angula momentum is used to eliminate θ, esulting in λ [ ( ) ] (n)! l n( c ) n, n (n!) c c n=0 9 (A)
in tems of which the equation of motion Eq. (9) is now expessed appoximately as d dθ c + c + λ. (A3) The conic-sections of Newtonian mechanics, Eqs. (0) and (), ae ecoveed by setting c. Fo nea-cicula, appoximately Kepleian obits it is convenient to make the change of vaiable /s c /, so that ( c /) n + n/s. In tems of this new vaiable, the elativistic coection Eq. (A) is λ (γ ɛ ) + ɛγ 3 ɛ s, (A4) whee γ ɛ / ɛ, and the following seies is identified: n=0 ( ) n n(n)! l = ɛγ n (n!) ɛ 3. c c (A5) Thus, the equation of motion Eq. (A3) is lineaized: d γ ɛ dθ s + ɛγ3 ɛ γ ɛ s. (A6) The additional change of vaiable α θ ɛγ 3 ɛ esults in the familia fom: d dα s c s + s c s, (A7) whee s c ( ɛγ 3 ɛ )/(γ ɛ ). The solution is simila to that of Eq. (0): s c s + A cos α, (A8) whee A is an abitay constant of integation. In tems of the oiginal coodinates, Eq. (A8) becomes whee (including fist-ode appoximations) c + ẽ cos κθ, (A9) γɛ ( ɛ) ɛ c c c ( ɛ ɛ), ( γ ɛ )( ɛ) ẽ A ɛ ɛa( + 5ɛ), 4 (A0) (A) κ ( ɛγɛ 3 ) ɛ. (A) 0
Accoding to the coespondence pinciple, Keple s obits [Eq. () with e < ] must be ecoveed in the limit ɛ 0 (c ), so that ɛa e is the eccenticity of Newtonian mechanics. Theefoe, elativistic obits in this limit ae descibed concisely by c ( ɛ) + e( + 5 4 ɛ) cos ( ɛ)θ. (A3) This altenative obit equation diffes fom that [Eq. (5)] deived using the much simple appoach in Sec. II only in the elativistic coection to eccenticity. See the discussion at the end of Sec. IV. [] A. Einstein, Ekläung de Peihelbewegung des Meku aus de allgemeinen Relativitätstheoie, Sitzungsbe. Peuss. Akad. Wiss. Belin (Math. Phys.) 95, 83 839 (95). [] A. Einstein, Explanation of the peihelion motion of mecuy fom the geneal theoy of elativity, in The Collected Papes of Albet Einstein, tanslated by A. Engel (Pinceton Univesity Pess, Pinceton, 997), Vol. 6, pp. 6. This aticle is the English tanslation of Ref.. [3] A. Einstein, Die Gundlage de allgemeinen Relativitätstheoie; von A. Einstein, Ann. d. Phys. 354 (7), 769 8 (96). [4] Refeence, pp. 46 00. This aticle is the English tanslation of Ref. 3. [5] K. Schwazschild, Übe das Gavitationsfeld eines Massenpunktes nach de Einsteinschen Theoie, Sitzungsbe. Peuss. Akad. Wiss., Phys.-Math. Kl. 96, 89 96 (96). Repinted in tanslation as On the gavitational field of a mass point accoding to Einstein s theoy, axiv: physics/9905030v [physics.hist-ph]. [6] J. Doste, Het veld van een enkel centum in Einstein s theoie de zwaatekacht, en de beweging van een stoffelijk punt in dat veld, Vesl. Akad. Amst. 5, 63 80 (96-97). Repinted in tanslation as The field of a single cente in Einstein s theoy of gavitation, and the motion of a paticle in that field, Poc. K. Ned. Akad. Wetensch. 9 (), 97 5 (97), <adsabs.havad.edu/abs/ 97KNAB...9..97D>. [7] H. Goldstein, C. Poole, and J. Safko, Classical Mechanics (Addison Wesley, San Fancisco, 00), 3d ed., pp. 3 34 and p. 33 (Execise 6). [8] J. V. José and E. J. Saletan, Classical Dynamics: A Contempoay Appoach (Cambidge Univesity Pess, Cambidge, 998), pp. 09 and 76 77 (Poblem ).
[9] P. C. Petes, Comment on Mecuy s pecession accoding to special elativity [Am. J. Phys. 54, 45 (986)], Am. J. Phys. 55 (8), 757 (987). [0] T. Phipps, J., Response to Comment on Mecuy s pecession accoding to special elativity, [Am. J. Phys. 55, 757 (987)], Am. J. Phys. 55 (8), 758 (987). [] T. Phipps, J., Mecuy s pecession accoding to special elativity, Am. J. Phys. 54 (3), 45 (986). [] Refeence 7, pp. 536 539. [3] S. T. Thonton and J. B. Maion, Classical Dynamics of Paticles and Systems (Thomson Books/Cole, Belmont, CA, 004), pp. 9 93 and 3 36. [4] V. D. Bage and M. G. Olsson, Classical Mechanics: A Moden Pespective (McGaw-Hill, Inc., New Yok, 995), pp. 306 309. [5] G. R. Fowles, Analytical Mechanics (Holt, Rinehat and Winston, New Yok, 977), pp. 6 64. [6] L. N. Hand and J. D. Finch, Analytical Mechanics (Cambidge Univesity Pess, Cambidge, 998), pp. 40 4 (Poblems 8 and 9). [7] Refeence 3, pp. 578 579. [8] Refeence 4, p. 366 (Poblem 0-). [9] J. M. Potgiete, Deivation of the equations of Lagange fo a elativistic paticle, Am. J. Phys. 5 (), 77 (983). [0] E. A. Desloge and E. Eiksen, Lagange s equations of motion fo a elativistic paticle, Am. J. Phys. 53 (), 83 84 (985). [] Y.-S. Huang and C.-L. Lin, A systematic method to detemine the Lagangian diectly fom the equations of motion, Am. J. Phys. 70 (7), 74 743 (00). [] S. Sonego and M. Pin, Deiving elativistic momentum and enegy, Eu. J. Phys. 6, 33 45 (005). [3] Refeence 7, p. 87. [4] Refeence 8, p. 84. [5] Refeence 3, p. 9. [6] Refeence 5, p. 48. [7] P. Hamill, Intemediate Dynamics (Jones and Batlett Publishes, LLC, Sudbuy, MA, 00), p. 330. [8] Refeence 7, pp. 9 96. [9] Refeence 8, pp. 84 86. [30] Refeence 3, pp. 300 304. [3] Refeence 5, pp. 37 57.
[3] P. Smith and R. C. Smith, Mechanics (John Wiley & Sons, Chicheste, 990), pp. 95 0. [33] Refeence 7, pp. 307 343. [34] T. J. Lemmon and A. R. Mondagon, Altenative deivation of the elativistic contibution to peihelic pecession, Am. J. Phys. 77 (0), 890 893 (009); axiv:0906.v [asto-ph.ep]. [35] D. H. Fisch, Simple aspects of post-newtonian gavitation, Am. J. Phys. 58 (4), 33 337 (990). [36] S. M. Caoll, An Intoduction to Geneal Relativity: Spacetime and Geomety (Addison-Wesley, San Fancisco, 004), pp. 05 6. [37] J. Plebański and A. Kasiński, An Intoduction to Geneal Relativity and Cosmology (Cambidge Univesity Pess, Cambidge, 006), pp. 76 8. [38] C. W. Misne, K. S. Thone, and J. A. Wheele, Gavitation (Feeman, San Fancisco, 973), pp. 0 5. [39] S. Weinbeg, Gavitation and Cosmology (John Wiley & Sons, New Yok, 97), pp. 94 0. [40] W. Rindle, Relativity: Special, Geneal, and Cosmological (Oxfod Univesity Pess, New Yok, 00), pp. 38 45. [4] H. Ohanian and R. Ruffini, Gavitation and Spacetime (W. W. Noton & Company, New Yok, 994), pp. 40 408. [4] R. D Inveno, Intoducing Einstein s Relativity (Oxfod Univesity Pess, New Yok, 995), pp. 95 98. [43] M. P. Hobson, G. P. Efstathiou, and A. N. Lasenby, Geneal Relativity: An Intoduction fo Physicists (Cambidge Univesity Pess, Cambidge, 006), pp. 05 6, 30 33. [44] K. Doggett, Comment on Pecession of the peihelion of Mecuy, by Daniel R. Stump [Am. J. Phys. 56, 097 098 (988)], Am. J. Phys. 59 (9), 85 85 (99). [45] D. R. Stump, Pecession of the peihelion of Mecuy, Am. J. Phys. 56 (), 097 098 (988). [46] G. Ovanesyan, Deivation of elativistic coections to bounded and unbounded motion in a weak gavitational field by integating the equations of motion, Am. J. Phys. 7 (9), 9 96 (003). [47] A. M. Nobili and I. W. Roxbugh, Simulation of geneal elativistic coections in long tem numeical integations of planetay obits, in Relativity in Celestial Mechanics and Astomety: High Pecision Dynamical Thoeies and Obsevational Veifications, edited by J. Kovalevsky and V. A. Bumbeg (IAU, Dodecht, 986), pp. 05 0, <adsabs.havad.edu/abs/986iaus..4..05n>. [48] C. Magnan, Complete calculations of the peihelion pecession of Mecuy and the deflection of light 3
by the Sun in geneal elativity, unpublished, axiv:07.3709v. [49] M. M. D Eliseo, The fist-ode obital equation, Am. J. Phys. 75 (4), 35 355 (007). [50] D. R. Bill and D. Goel, Light bending and peihelion pecession: A unified appoach, Am. J. Phys. 67 (4), 36 39 (999). [5] B. Dean, Phase-plane analysis of peihelion pecession and Schwazschild obital dynamics, Am. J. Phys. 67 (), 78 86 (999). [5] N. Ashby, Planetay petubation equations based on elativistic Kepleian motion, in Relativity in Celestial Mechanics and Astomety: High Pecision Dynamical Thoeies and Obsevational Veifications, edited by J. Kovalevsky and V. A. Bumbeg (IAU, Dodecht, 986), pp. 4 5, <adsabs.havad.edu/abs/986iaus..4...4a>. [53] R. M. Wald, Geneal Relativity (Univesity of Chicago Pess, Chicago, 984), pp. 36 43. [54] J. B. Hatle, Gavity: An Intoduction to Einstein s Geneal Relativity (Addison-Wesley, San Fancisco, 003), pp. 9 04. [55] A. Schild, Equivalence pinciple and ed-shift measuements, Am. J. Phys. 8 (9), 778 780 (960). [56] Refeence 54, pp. 30 3. [57] M. G. Stewat, Pecession of the peihelion of Mecuy s obit, Am. J. Phys. 73 (8), 730 734 (005). [58] D. Bouwe and G. M. Clemence, Obits and masses of planets and satellites, in The Sola System: Planets and Satellites, edited by G. P. Kuipe and B. M. Middlehust (Univesity of Chicago Pess, Chicago, 96), Vol. III, pp. 3 94. [59] C. Sigismondi, Astomety and elativity, Nuovo Cim. B 0, 69 80 (005). [60] Refeence 38, pp. 660 66, Box 5.6. [6] F. Y.-H. Wang, Relativistic obits with compute algeba, Am. J. Phys. 7 (8), 040 044 (004). [6] A. Havey, Newtonian limit fo a geodesic in a Schwazschild field, Am. J. Phys. 46 (9), 98 99 (978). [63] W. Rindle, Special Relativity (Olive and Boyd, London, 960), pp. 79 03. [64] J. L. Synge, Relativity: The Special Theoy (Noth-Holland Publishing Company, Amstedam, 958), pp. 394 399. 4
.5 Einstein 0.5 sin θ /c 0 0.5.5.5 Keple 0.5 0 0.5.5 cos θ / c FIG. : Relativistic obit in a Kepleian limit (solid line), as descibed by Eq. (5), compaed to a coesponding Kepleian obit (dashed line) [Eq. ()]. The pecession of peihelion is one obital chaacteistic due to special elativity and is illustated hee fo 0 θ 0π. This chaacteistic is exaggeated by both the choice of eccenticity (e = 0.3) and elativistic coection paamete (ɛ = 0.) fo puposes of illustation. Pecession is pesent fo smalle (non-zeo) easonably chosen values of e and ɛ as well. (The same value of e is chosen fo both cuves.) 5
0.5 0 Newtonian Mechanics Geneal Relativity c l Veff -0.5-0.5 R c c -0.75 0 0.5.5.5 3 / c FIG. : Effective potential commonly defined in the Newtonian limit to Geneal Relativity (solid line) [Eq. (3)], compaed to that deived fom Newtonian mechanics (dashed line). The vetical dotted lines identify the adii of cicula obits, R c and c, as calculated using geneal elativity and Newtonian mechanics, espectively. Geneal elativity pedicts [Eq. (3)] a smalle adius of the cicula obit than that pedicted by Newtonian mechanics. The value ɛ = 0.06 is chosen fo puposes of illustation. 6