La partecipazione italiana ai primi bandi NMBP in H2020 e le opportunità future

Transcription

1 La partecipazione italiana ai primi bandi NMBP in H2020 e le opportunità future Donata Medaglini Università degli Studi di Siena Rappresentante Italiano nel Comitato di Programma H2020 Nanotechnologies and Advanced Materials, Biotechnology and Advanced Manufacturing and Processing Giornata Nazionale di Lancio dei Bandi NMBP in Horizon 2020 Roma, 30 Settembre 2015

2 RISULTATI NMBP CALLS 2014 Calls H2020-SPIRE-2014 H2020-FoF-2014 H2020-EeB-2014 H2020-NMP-2014-two-stage H2020-NMP-PILOTS-2014 H2020-NMP-CSA-2014 H2020-NMP-GV-2014 H2020-LEIT-BIO H2020-SILC-II calls, 40 topics Budget M 96 projects retained for funding 1122 participants 2

3 Risultati 2014 NMBP No. proposte presentate No. Proposte finanziate Tasso medio di successo Partecipazione % (tasso medio di successo del programma NMBP: 8%) No. Partecipanti italiani in proposte presentate No. Partecipanti italiani finanziati Tasso di successo partecipanti Italiani Contributo finanziario per l Italia % M (~10% del budget totale ) Coordinamento No. Proposte presentate a coordinamento italiano No. Coordinamenti italiani finanziati Tasso di successo coordinatori Italiani ,5% ~ 13% Progetti finanziati sono a Coordinamento Italiano

4 4 21,45 17,03 97,08 4,36 10,99 64,18 11,26 49,42 9,87 48,03 1,46 39,55 5,47 16,38 49,28 1,23 0,70 2,05 0,22 0,54 1,15 0,08 0,84 0,00 5,91 0,48 7,96 0,01 0,00 4,60 3,41 1,73 0,00 6,78 1,40 0,61 Calls 2014 NMBP EC Funding (M ) AT BE DE DK EL ES FI FR IE IT LU NL PT SE UK BG CY CZ EE HR HU LT LV MT PL RO SI SK BR CH IL IS MXNO TR US EU15 EU13 OTH

5 Budget Calls NMBP Budget/ Calls Total Budget : 992,2 million Budget 2014: 485,52 million Budget 2015: 504 million Sustainable Process Industries 13,5% Energy Efficient Buildings 11,5% Contributions to other programme (ICT/WASTE) NMP 1,8% 49,2% NMP 49,2% Factories of the Future 16% BIOTECH 7,9% 41% of the NMBP Budget for PPP

6 FoF PPPs in NMBP EeB SPIRE Total contribution ( ) Funding for Italy ( ) Calls 2014 % of EU funding to IT IT Success Rate FoF % 15.6 % (42 out of 269) SPIRE % 8.7% (6 out of 69) EeB ,0% 12.1% (16 out 132)

7 cppps calls 2014 (FoF, EeB and SPIRE) Participants/Coordinators in selected projects 7 7

8 cppps calls 2014 (FoF, EeB and SPIRE) EC contribution by countries 8 8

9 FoF-Results 2014 Calls Participants/Coordinators in selected projects IT Participants Success Rate: ~ 15.6% (selezionate/presentate) IT Participants: ~ 17,6% IT Coordinators Success Rate: ~15.3 % (selezionate/presentate) IT Coordinators: ~ 19% EC contribution by countries Funding to Italy: ~ 19% of EU funding 9 9

10 EeB-Results 2014 Calls Participants/Coordinators in selected projects IT Participants Success Rate: ~ 12% (selezionate/presentate) IT Coordinators Success Rate: ~ 6.7 % (selezionate/presentate) Funding to Italy: 10% of EU funding EC contribution by countries 10% 10 10

11 SPIRE-Results 2014 Calls Participants/Coordinators in selected projects Participants/Coordinators in selected projects IT Participants: ~ 8.7% (partecipazioni/totale) IT Coordinators Success Rate: 0 % (retained/totale) EU Funding to Italy: ~ 3% of EU funding EC contribution by countries

12 NMP- two stage -Results 2014 Calls IT Participants Success Rate: ~ 29 % (selezionate/presentate) IT Coordinators Success Rate: ~57 % (selezionate/presentate) Funding to Italy: ~ 14.3% of EU funding EC funding by country ATBGCHCZDK EL FI HR IE IT LU MTNL PL RO 12 SI TR US

13 , , , , , , ,00 Eligible Proposals 10 proposals Requested funding 70.2 M H2020-SILC-II-2014 Sustainable Industry Low Carbon Above thresholds 2 proposals Requested funding 12.7 M Success rate 20% (100% in second stage) Main List 2 proposals Call budget 20 M Requested funding 12.7 M EC funding % AT BE BG CY CZ DE DK EE EL ES FI FR HR HU IE IT LT LU LV MTNL PL PT RO SE SI SK UK

14 14 H2020-LEIT-BIO-2014 (second stage) number of proposals and requested funding BIOTEC : Synthetic biology STAGE 1 STAGE 2 Success rate ~17% Received: 52 Eligible: 51 GO: 12 Received: 12 Eligible: 12 Funding: 85.3 M Pass: 6 Funding: 38.8 M Retained: 2 Funding: 15.1 M Reserve: 1 Funding: 6 M BIOTEC Widening industrial application of enzymatic processes BIOTEC Downstream processes unlocking biotechnological transformations STAGE 1 Received: 45 Eligible: 43 GO: 14 STAGE 2 Received: 14 Eligible: 14 Funding: M Pass: 6 Funding: 49.7 M Success rate ~21% Retained: 3 Funding: 22.5 M Reserve: 2 Funding: 17.8 M EU Funding to Italy: ~3% of EU funding

15 SME Instrument Phase 1 Results for NMP and BIOTEC topics

16 Proposals by Proposals country by country (1 st cut-off (1 st cut-off vs vs 2 nd) 2 nd cut-off) cut-off)

17 Primi Risultati Bandi 2015

18 H2020-FoF-2015 Call budget Requested EC funding 1,051,924,635 5 topics 214 eligible proposals with 2361 participations 16% EC funding 177 participations 14 retained for funding proposals 74,657,744 EC Funding Success rate: 7.1 % DE IT UK ES AT FR NL NO SE PT BE DK FI EL IE PL CZ LT CY US CH

19 19 H2020-EeB-2015 Call budget 62,480,000 Requested EC funding 616,117,721 9 % 4 topics 119 eligible proposals with 1597 participations 11 retained for funding proposals 58,772,413 EC Funding Success rate: 9.5 %

20 20 H2020-SPIRE-2015 Call budget Requested EC funding % 4 topics 82 eligible proposals with 935 participations 13 retained for funding proposals 72,627,678 EC Funding Success rate: 15.1%

21 21 H2020-NMP-2015-two-stage Call budget Eligible proposals: 467 Requested EC funding Average size 6,484, topics 90 above thresholds proposals (GO) Requesting 625,410,847 EC funding Indicative success rate for 2 nd stage: 23.7%

22 22 H2020-NMP-2015-two-stage Topics NMP NMP NMP NMP NMP NMP NMP NMP NMP NMP Nanomedicine therapy for cancer Biomaterials for treatment and prevention of Alzheimer s disease Materials innovations for the optimisation of cooling in power plants Extended in-service life of advanced functional materials in energy technologies (capture, conversion, storage and/or transmission of energy) Materials for severe operating conditions, including added-value functionalities Fibre-based materials for non-clothing applications Novel materials by design for substituting critical elements Low-energy solutions for drinking water production pilot plants Increasing the capacity to perform nano-safety assessment Next generation tools for risk governance of Nanomaterials

23 23 H2020-NMP-2015-two-stage Preliminary results TOPICS Eligible proposals nb Requested EC funding NMP ,871,420 NMP ,140,488 NMP ,814,372 NMP ,474,242 nb 12 (1 coord. IT) 7 ( 1 coord IT) 2 (1 coord ITG) 8 (1 coord IT) Go proposals Requested EC funding 97,900,000 49,371,800 16,000,000 65,350,370 NMP ,578, (3 coord IT) NMP ,099, (2 coord Iy) NMP ,957, (5 coord IT) 102,624, ,594,667 45,511,105 NMP ,102, ,403,875 NMP ,009, ,732,986 NMP ,374, ,921,068 Total 467 3,028,423, ,410,847

24 H2020-NMP-CSA-2015 Retained proposals - Country participation (requested EC funding) Call budget Requested EC funding topics Eligible proposals: % 4 retained for funding proposals 2,692, EC Funding NL SK BE PT ES FR IT EL DK UK BG

25 H2020-NMP-PILOTS-2015 Retained proposals - Country participation (requested EC funding) Call budget Requested EC funding Average size topics Eligible proposals: % 12 retained for funding proposals 58,845, EC Funding Success rate: 6.1% ES DE IT UK FR PT AT EL NO BE DK IL SE NL SI FI TR RO HU IE CY RU

26 NMBP Work Programme

27 NMBP Work Programme Draft WP to PC 1st March nd May 2015 Strategic Document Revised Draft WP PC Opinion 14 July2015 Feedback from PC Adoption WP October 2017 PC Approval WP Pre-Publication Draft WP September 2015 Calls Opening 15 October 2015 First deadline 8 December 2015

28 Pre-pubblication NMBP Work programme on Horizon 2020 website

29 Calls NMBP :Budget Budget/ Calls Total Budget : 966,9 million Budget 2016: 447,2 million Budget 2017: 519,7 million Sustainable Process Industries 13,65% Energy Efficient Buildings 10.3% NMP NMP 49,2% Factories of the Future 15% BIOTECH % of the budget for NMBP Calls 39% of the Budget for PPP

30 CALLS FOR NANOTECHNOLOGIES, ADVANCED MATERIALS, BIOTECHNOLOGY AND PRODUCTION

31 ENERGY-EFFICIENT BUILDINGS Year Topic Topic Title Instrument TRL Deadline EEB Highly efficient insulation materials with improved properties IA EEB EEB EEB Performance indicators and monitoring techniques for energy-efficiency and environmental quality at building and district level Integration of advanced technologies for heating and cooling at building and district level New technologies and strategies for the development of pre-fabricated elements through the reuse and recycling of construction materials and structures CSA IA 5-7 RIA /1/16 EEB Development of near zero energy building renovation IA EEB EEB Highly efficient hybrid storage solutions for power and heat in residential buildings and district areas, balancing the supply and demand conditions Integration of energy harvesting at building and district level RIA 4-6 IA /1/17 EEB New business models for energy-efficient buildings through adaptable refurbishment solutions CSA

32 ADVANCED MATERIALS AND NANOTECHNOLOGIES FOR HIGH ADDED VALUE PRODUCTS AND PROCESS INDUSTRIES Year Topic Topic Title Instrument TRL Deadline NMBP Novel hybrid materials for heterogeneous catalysis RIA NMBP NMBP Advanced Materials for Power Electronics based on wide bandgap semiconductor devices technology Innovative and sustainable materials solutions for the substitution of critical raw materials in the electric power system RIA 4-6 RIA st Stage: 8/12/15 2 nd Stage: 24/5/16 NMBP Architectured /Advanced material concepts for intelligent bulk material structures RIA NMBP NMBP Advanced materials and innovative design for improved functionality and aesthetics in high added value consumer goods Improved material durability in buildings and infrastructures, including offshore IA 4-6, target 7 RIA st Stage: 27/10/16 2 nd Stage: 4/5/17 NMBP Systems of materials characterisation for model, product and process optimisation RIA 4-6

33 Year Topic Topic Title Instrument TRL Deadline 2016 NMBP ADVANCED MATERIALS AND NANOTECHNOLOGIES FOR HEALTHCARE Year Topic Topic Title Instrument TRL Deadline 2016 NMBP Biomaterials for diagnosis and treatment of demyelination disorders of the Central Nervous System NMBP Nanoformulation of biologicals RIA 3/4-5/6 NMBP ERA-NET on Nanomedicine NMBP GREEN VEHICLES Affordable weight reduction of high-volume vehicles and components taking into account the entire life-cycle Development of a reliable methodology for better risk management of engineered biomaterials in Advanced Therapy Medicinal Products and/or Medical Devices RIA /1/16 RIA ERA-NET cofund RIA 3, target 5 1 st Stage: 8/12/15 2 nd Stage:24/5/16 21/1/16 4, 1 st Stage: 27/10/16 target 6 2 nd Stage: 4/5/17 NMBP Cross-cutting KETs for diagnostics at the point-of-care RIA 3/4-5/6 19/1/ NMBP NMBP Regulatory Science Framework for assessment of risk benefit ratio of Nanomedicines and Biomaterials Nanotechnologies for imaging cellular transplants and regenerative processes in vivo IA st Stage: 27/10/16 2 nd Stage: 4/5/17 RIA 3/4-5/6 1st Stage: 27/10/16 2 nd Stage: 4/5/17 NMBP Mobilising the European nano-biomedical ecosystem CSA 19/1/17

34 ADVANCED MATERIALS AND NANOTECHNOLOGIES FOR ENERGY APPLICATIONS Year Topic Topic Title Instrument TRL Deadline NMBP NMBP NMBP NMBP Advanced materials solutions and architectures for high efficiency solar energy harvesting Advanced materials enabling the integration of storage technologies in the electricity grid Cost-effective materials for power-to-chemical technologies High-performance materials for optimizing carbon dioxide capture IA IA IA IA 4, target 6 1 st Stage: 8/12/15 5, 2 nd Stage:24/5/16 target 6 3, target 5 1 st Stage: 27/10/16 5, Target 6 2 nd Stage: 4/5/17

35 BIOTECHNOLOGY Year Topic Topic Title Instrument TRL Deadline BIOTEC ERA-NET Cofund on Biotechnologies Bioconversion of non-agricultural waste into BIOTEC biomolecules for industrial applications Microbial chassis platforms with optimized metabolic BIOTEC pathways for industrial innovations through systems biology KET Biotechnology foresight identifying gaps and highvalue opportunities for the EU industry BIOTEC Microbial platforms for CO2-reuse processes in the lowcarbon economy BIOTEC Optimisation of biocatalysis and downstream processing BIOTEC for the sustainable production of high value-added platform chemicals New Plant Breeding Techniques (NPBT) in molecular BIOTEC farming: Multipurpose crops for industrial bioproducts Support for enhancing and demonstrating the impact of BIOTEC KET Biotechnology projects ERA-NET Cofund RIA 3-5 RIA /1/16 1 st Stage: 8/12/15 2 nd Stage: 24/5/16 CSA 21/1/16 RIA 3-5 IA 5-7 RIA st Stage: 27/10/16 2 nd Stage: 4/5/17 CSA 19/1/17

36 MODELLING FOR THE DEVELOPMENT OF NANOTECHNOLOGIES AND ADVANCED MATERIALS Year Topic Topic Title Instrument TRL Deadline NMBP NMBP NMBP Advancing the integration of Materials Modelling in Business Processes to enhance effective industrial decision making and increase competitiveness Network to capitalise on strong European position in materials modelling and to allow industry to reap the benefits Next generation system integrating tangible and intangible materials model components to support innovation in industry RIA 5 1 st Stage: 8/12/15 2 nd Stage:24/5/16 CSA 21/1/16 IA 6 1 st Stage: 27/10/16 2 nd Stage: 4/5/17

37 SCIENCE-BASED RISK ASSESSMENT AND MANAGEMENT OF NANOTECHNOLOGIES, ADVANCED MATERIALS AND BIOTECHNOLOGIES Year Topic Topic Title Instrument TRL Deadline NMBP NMBP NMBP NMBP Analytical techniques and tools in support of nanomaterial risk assessment Promoting safe innovation through global consolidation and networking of nanosafety centres and strengthening the European industry through cooperation in nanosafety Framework and strategies for nanomaterial characterisation, classification, grouping and readacross for risk analysis Advanced and realistic models and assays for nanomaterial hazard assessment RIA st Stage: 8/12/15 2 nd Stage:24/5/16 CSA 21/1/16 RIA 5-7 RIA st Stage: 27/10/16 2 nd Stage: 4/5/17

38 INNOVATIVE AND RESPONSIBLE GOVERNANCE OF NEW AND CONVERGING ENABLING TECHNOLOGIES Year Topic Topic Title Instrument TRL Deadline NMBP Facilitating knowledge management, networking and coordination in the field of formulated products CSA NMBP Presidency events CSA 2016 NMBP Support for National Contact Points NMBP Networking and sharing best experiences in using regional clusters strategies with a focus on supporting innovation in the NMBP thematic area CSA CSA 21/1/16 NMBP Policy support for Industry 2020 in the circular economy CSA NMBP Presidency events CSA 19/1/ NMBP Governing innovation of nanotechnology through enhanced societal engagement CSA 19/1/17 NMBP Innovative solutions for the conservation of 20th century cultural heritage RIA 4, target 6 1 st Stage: 27/10/16 2 nd Stage: 4/5/17

39 SME INSTRUMENT Year Topic Topic Title Instrument TRL SMEInst SMEInst Accelerating the uptake of nanotechnologies advanced materials or advanced manufacturing and processing technologies by SMEs Dedicated support to biotechnology SMEs closing the gap from lab to market SMEInst SMEInst

40 CALL - INDUSTRY 2020 IN THE CIRCULAR ECONOMY

41 PILOTS Year Topic Topic Title Instrument TRL Deadline 2016 Pilot lines for manufacturing of materials with PILOTS customized thermal/electrical conductivity properties Pilot Line Manufacturing of Nanostructured Antimicrobial PILOTS Surfaces using Advanced Nanosurface Functionalization Technologies IA IA 4/6, target 7 1 st Stage: 8/12/15 4/6, target 7 2 nd Stage: 24/5/16 PILOTS Pilot Lines for Manufacturing of Nanotextured surfaces with mechanically enhanced properties IA 4/6, target PILOTS Pilot Lines for 3D printed and/or injection moulded polymeric or ceramic microfluidic MEMS IA 4/6, target 7 1 st Stage: 27/10/16 2 nd Stage: 4/5/17 PILOTS Paper-based electronics RIA 3, target 5

42 FACTORIES OF THE FUTURE FOF (2016) Year Topic Topic Title Instrument TRL Deadline FOF FOF FOF FOF FOF Novel hybrid approaches for additive and subtractive manufacturing machines Machinery and robot systems in dynamic shop floor environments using novel embedded cognitive functions Zero-defect strategies at system level for multi-stage manufacturing in production lines Continuous adaptation of work environments with changing levels of automation in evolving production systems Support for the further development of Additive Manufacturing technologies in Europe RIA 4-6 IA 5-7 IA 5-7 RIA 4-6 CSA 21/1/16

43 FACTORIES OF THE FUTURE FOF (2017) Year Topic Topic Title Instrument TRL Deadline FOF New product functionalities through advanced surface manufacturing processes for mass production RIA 4-6 FOF Integration of unconventional technologies for multimaterial processing into manufacturing systems RIA FOF In-line measurement and control for micro-/nanoenabled high-volume manufacturing for enhanced reliability IA /1/17 FOF Novel design and predictive maintenance technologies for increased operating life of production systems IA 5-7 FOF New technologies and life cycle management for reconfigurable and reusable customised products IA 5-7 ICT for FACTORIES OF THE FUTURE Year Topic Topic Title Instrument TRL Deadline 2016 FOF Digital automation RIA, CSA 21/1/ FOF ICT Innovation for Manufacturing SMEs (I4MS) RIA, CSA 19/1/ FOF Photonics Laser-based production RIA, IA 21/1/16

44 SUSTAINABLE PROCESS INDUSTRIES SPIRE (2016) Year Topic Topic Title Instrument TRL Deadline 2016 SPIRE SPIRE SPIRE SPIRE SPIRE SPIRE Systematic approaches for resource-efficient water management systems in process industries Plant-wide monitoring and control of data-intensive processes Industrial technologies for the valorisation of European bio-resources into high added value process streams Industrial furnace design addressing energy efficiency in new and existing furnaces Potential use of carbon dioxide / carbon monoxide and non-conventional fossil natural resources in Europe as feedstock for the process industry Business models for flexible and delocalised approaches for intensified processing IA 5-7 RIA 4-6 IA 5-7 RIA 4-6 CSA CSA 21/1/16

45 SUSTAINABLE PROCESS INDUSTRIES SPIRE (2017) Year Topic Topic Title Instrument TRL Deadline 2017 SPIRE SPIRE SPIRE SPIRE SPIRE SPIRE Integrated approach to process optimisation for raw material resources efficiency, excluding recovery technologies of waste streams Carbon dioxide utilisation to produce added value chemicals Pilot lines based on more flexible and down-scaled high performance processing New electrochemical solutions for industrial processing, which contribute to a reduction of carbon dioxide emissions Support for the enhancement of the impact of SPIRE PPP projects Assessment of standardisation needs and ways to overcome regulatory bottlenecks in the process industry IA 5-7 RIA 4-6 IA 5-7 RIA 4-6 CSA CSA 19/1/17

46 CIRCULAR ECONOMY Year Topic Topic Title Instrument TRL Deadline CIRC CIRC CIRC CIRC Systemic, eco-innovative approaches for the circular economy: large-scale demonstration projects IA 5-7 Water in the context of the circular economy IA 5-7 Smart Specialisation for systemic eco-innovation/circular economy New models and economic incentives for circular economy business CIRC Unlocking the potential of urban organic waste RIA CSA RIA 1 st Stage: 8/3/16 2 nd Stage: 6/9/16 8/3/16

47 FACTORIES OF THE FUTURE FOF (2016) Year Topic Topic Title Instrument TRL Deadline FOF FOF FOF FOF FOF Novel hybrid approaches for additive and subtractive manufacturing machines Machinery and robot systems in dynamic shop floor environments using novel embedded cognitive functions Zero-defect strategies at system level for multi-stage manufacturing in production lines Continuous adaptation of work environments with changing levels of automation in evolving production systems Support for the further development of Additive Manufacturing technologies in Europe RIA 4-6 IA 5-7 IA 5-7 RIA 4-6 CSA 21/1/16

48 FACTORIES OF THE FUTURE FOF (2017) Year Topic Topic Title Instrument TRL Deadline FOF New product functionalities through advanced surface manufacturing processes for mass production RIA 4-6 FOF Integration of unconventional technologies for multimaterial processing into manufacturing systems RIA FOF In-line measurement and control for micro-/nanoenabled high-volume manufacturing for enhanced reliability IA /1/17 FOF Novel design and predictive maintenance technologies for increased operating life of production systems IA 5-7 FOF New technologies and life cycle management for reconfigurable and reusable customised products IA 5-7

49 NMBP : Innovative solutions for the conservation of 20th century cultural heritage Specific Challenge: 20th century cultural heritage is often confronted with different deterioration mechanisms than more ancient cultural heritage for reasons such as the use of modern materials. This requires additional research efforts regarding material composition, ageing processes, and the development of appropriate conservation technologies, modeling and simulation based approaches. Scope: develop one or more innovative solutions (functional materials or techniques) for the conservation of tangible 20th century cultural heritage. developments should be based on multi-scale modelling (in the sense of linking different types of models such as electronic, atomistic, mesoscopic and continuum etc.) Expected impact: Practical and affordable materials/technique solutions Increased efficiency of materials/technique development for cultural heritage conservation Increased use of multi-scale modelling in the development of solutions for CH conservation; Improved modelling-based decision making regarding conservation interventions; Effective market uptake of the developed solutions within five years after the end of the project; Contribution to open repository of simulation and/or experimental data; Contribution to increased citizens' awareness of 20th century tangible CH. Type of action: RIA TRL: 4-6 Budget: EUR 6-8 million/proposal Deadline: 1 st Stage: 27/10/16; 2 nd Stage: 4/5/17

50 NMBP in Horizon 2020

51 Delegazione italiana nei Comitati di Programma esprime la posizione italiana nella elaborazione dei Programmi di Lavoro (quindi dei bandi) e nei diversi stadi della loro implementazione riferimenti: gli obiettivi generali della ricerca EU d interesse per Italia i piani nazionali e regionali della ricerca le capacità di ricerca del paese obiettivi: il massimo numero di progetti italiani di successo: sostenere temi in cui la partecipazione italiana può avere successo

52 Ruolo dei rappresentanti nazionali Rappresentare gli interessi del Paese in UE Proporre alla CE modifiche ai WP Consultare gli stakeholers nazionali Creare sinergie ed alleanze con le altre delegazioni Accrescere la competitività dell Italia Partecipare alla definizione del PNR in linea con H2020 Sostenere sinergie tra UE, Regioni, MIUR, Cluster tecnologici.

53 Delegazione Italiana NMBP H2020 Donata Medaglini Rappresentante Italinana per il Comitato NMP+B in H2020 Esperti: Elisa Molinari CNR NANO, Università di Modena e Reggio Emilia Rappresentante IT nel Comitato NMP in FP7 Luisa Tondelli CNR Bologna Luisa Torsi Università di Bari Ministero dello Sviluppo Economico Confindustria

54 National contact points (NCP) per NMBP Martina De Sole Serena Borgna