Wisconsin Thought Leadership Roundtable. May 3 rd 2010 Madison Wisconsin

Transcription

1 Wisconsin Thought Leadership Roundtable May 3 rd 2010 Madison Wisconsin

2 Welcome and Introductions Agenda The growth of EE in the Midwest over the last 10 years Wendy Jaehn, MEEA Wisconsin accomplishments in EE Jolene Sheil, WI PSC Impact of ARRA funding for EE programs Brian Driscoll, WI Office of Energy Independence PSC study on Clean Energy Jobs bill John Shenot, WI PSC Analysis of Wisconsin EE programs Dan York, ACEEE Opportunities for EE in the future Susan Stratton, ECW Q&A and Discussion Reception Grand Terrace West

3 Welcome & Introductions Introductions Purpose of Thought Leadership Roundtables

4 MEEA s Mission MEEA is a nonprofit organization bridging the gaps between energy efficiency policy development and program implementation.

5 Our Members Are Diverse stakeholders in energy efficiency Academic/Research Organizations Manufacturers/Retailers State and Local Governments Utilities (IOUs/Munis/Coops) Energy Service Firms/Consultants Leading Nonprofits General Interest/Professionals MEEA has over 115 members

6 The growth of EE in the Midwest in the last 10 years - impact of mature policies and new programs Wendy Jaehn, MEEA

7 MEEA s Policy Role Provide regional perspective Prepare legislative and regulatory analysis Provide testimony, when asked Build coalitions among diverse stakeholders Promote best practices Hold education and advocacy events Energy Expos Annual Conference, Midwest Energy Solutions Activate the grassroots

8 Millions $1,000 $900 $800 $700 $600 $500 $400 $300 Energy Efficiency Investment by Midwest Electric and Natural Gas Utilities WI Public Benefit Fund Adopted (precedes graph) EERS Adopted IL Electric MN Electric, Natural Gas EERS Adopted MI Electric, Natural Gas OH Electric EERS Adopted IN Electric IL Natural Gas $912 $200 $100 $178 $0

9 Energy Efficiency Investment Rising Regional Totals Increases predicted, value currently unknown for Electric & Natural Gas Efficiency 2004: $178 M 2006: $318 M 2007: $335 M 2008*: $443 M 2009*: $546 M 2010*: $714 M 2011*: $859 M 2012*: $912 M *Estimated Nov 2009

10 Illinois Indiana Iowa Kansas Kentucky Michigan Minnesota Missouri Nebraska North Dakota Ohio South Dakota Wisconsin 2.00% by % 1.50% by % 1.50% 1.00% 0.50% Midwest Energy Efficiency 2.00% by % current Standard Levels 1.00% current 1.00% by % by % current 1.50% current 2.00% by % current 0.40% current 0.00%

11 Midwest Efficiency Funding from the American Reinvestment and Recovery Act *Values in $1 million $25.3 $12.8 $24.6 $24.5 $13.2 $23.7 $30.9 $18.8 $30.9 $56.4 $23.6 $38.3 $131.9 $37.4 $54.2 $80.8 $21.1 $40.5 $128.1 $43.8 $57.4 $141.5 $37.2 $55.5 $242.5 $112.2 $101.3 $131.8 $42.4 $68.6 $243.4 $76.6 $82.0 $266.8 $84.2 $96.1 $70.9 $25.4 $52.5 Weatherization Assistance Programs: $1.586 billion Energy Efficiency and Conservation Block Grants: $ million State Energy Programs: $ million Midwest Total: $2.86 billion

12 Building Energy Codes Adoption of most efficient residential and commercial building energy codes IECC 2009 (Residential) ASHRAE (Commercial) Training for building inspectors and contractors Code compliance requires building inspectors ARRA requires 90% compliance within 8 years

13 Building Energy Codes Latest Residential Energy Code, IECC 2009, is required by ARRA IECC 2009 homes use 15-17% less energy than IECC 2006 homes The US DOE has determined that the International Residential Code (IRC) is not a equivalent to the IECC and so does not comply with ARRA requirements

14 Residential Energy Code Adoption in the Midwest Code level adopted as of January IECC or Equiv IECC or Equiv IECC or Equiv. Precedes 1998 IECC No Statewide Code Voluntary Statewide Code Code Upgrade to 2009 IECC in Process

15 Commercial Energy Code Adoption in the Midwest Code level adopted as of January 2010 ASHRAE or Equiv. ASHRAE or Equiv. ASHRAE /2001 or Equiv. Precedes ASHRAE No Statewide Code Voluntary Statewide Code Code Upgrade to 2009 IECC in Process Note: IECC references ASHRAE

16 Appliance Standards Many U.S. standards are obsolete Current administration wants to catch up States can go above federal standards No significant appliance standards in Midwest CA s recent television standard estimated to save customers $1 billion / year by 2013 Over 1000 models meet first tier requirements CA Energy Commission, Docket 09-AAER-1C

17 Appliance Standards

18 Current and Planned Decoupling Decoupling Authorized Pilot Projects gas electric

19 Contact Info Wendy Jaehn Executive Director Midwest Energy Efficiency Alliance

20 Wisconsin accomplishments in EE impact of state s historical leadership and Focus on Energy Jolene Sheil, Public Service Commission of WI

21 Impact of ARRA funding for EE programs what is expected impact in 2010 and 2011 Brian Driscoll, WI Office of Energy Independence

22 PSC study on Clean Energy Jobs bill and recommendations for EE and review of renewable standard Overview of history of DSM investment in Wisconsin John Shenot, Public Service Commission of WI

23 Analysis of Wisconsin EE programs review of EE throughout the country Dan York, ACEEE

24 Opportunities for EE in the future what is the true potential Recommendations on strategies to better value EE in research and planning Susan Stratton, Energy Center of Wisconsin

25 Q&A and Discussion

26 Reception Grand Terrace West