1 Why are Word Problems so Darned Hard? Alan H. Schoenfeld University of California Berkeley, CA, USA
2 Preface: Why middle school math is important My friend complains to a hospital doctor that his pain medicine isn t adequate. What s your dose? Two pills every two hours. OK, we ll double it to four pills every four hours.
3 A simple model of solving word problems Read problem Make a model or diagram Write equation(s) Solve equations Check.
4 It s not that simple. I m going to unpack each of the steps in the previous slide, and add a few hidden steps, to suggest why things are as hard as they are.
5 Reading & Language Comprehension Issues, 1. A five-pound box of sugar costs $1.80 and contains 12 cups of sugar. Marella and Mark are making a batch of cookies. The recipe calls for 2 cups of sugar. Determine how much the sugar for the cookies costs. Note: batch = recipe!
6 Reading & Comprehension, 2 The upper Angel Falls, the highest waterfall on Earth, are 750 m higher than Niagara Falls. If each of the falls were 7 m lower, the upper Angel Falls would be 16 times as high as Niagara Falls. How high is each waterfall? Hmmm Upper falls, lower falls, Niagara falls, Waterfalls
7 R&C, 3 (From a mainstream text) The Java Joint wishes to mix organic Kenyan coffee beans that sell for $7.25 per pound with organic Venezuelan beans that sell for $8.50 per pound in order to form a 50 pound batch of Morning Blend that sells for $8.00 per pound. How many pounds of each type of bean should be used to make the blend? Also: savings bonds, fungicide, red pigment, processing a 24-exposure roll of film,
8 Mathematical Disposition (predilection to think mathematically) A fairly typical student reads this task: A dragonfly, the fastest insect, can fly a distance of 50 feet in about 2 seconds. How long will it take for the dragonfly to fly 375 feet? What will the student do/say?
9 Here s what happened Less than 1/5 second pause after reading problem S: So, first I ll divide 375 with 50, and then wait. Or, I will multiply 50, no wait, now what? This is dividing 5 times what can get 8? T: So you re thinking divide S: I m not understanding. Do you look at 5 times the number first or is it the big number this is 50 into it first? T: Well let s see, what are the quantities we re looking at here? And what are you trying to find out? S: (Couldn t say what the goal was:) Trying to find out how many seconds the dragonfly can fly in 375 feet wait How many seconds will it take it to fly 375 feet? T: OK, why don t you draw a picture of what you think is going on, it might be helpful
10 S: (Draws a picture of a road, a town, a little dragonfly.) T: (Focuses on quantities and where they are in the picture ) T: Refocuses S on what they want to find out, how long to get to 375 feet) and what they know (50 feet in 2 seconds). T: So that looks great. So what do you think you should do next? S: I have an idea, maybe 50 times 375 divided by 2? That won t work. (Does computation and sees it goes nowhere.) T: What are we trying to find out?
11 S: How many seconds will it take the dragonfly to fly 375 feet? T: And we know what? S: It can fly 50 feet in 2 seconds. T: All right, what do you think, well, if it could go fly 50 feet / S: /in 4 seconds it would be 100 feet, in 6 it would be 200, 8 would be 300, so 9 would be 350, there s 25 missing, so 1/2 of it to get 375 so 9 1/2 seconds to get 375. T: That sounds pretty good [And further exchange, where the teacher works to get the student, who now gets the problem, to see that rate, or proportional reasoning, can be useful.]
12 For many kids, math is not about sense-making. John wants to make wooden bookcases that are two feet wide. He has two five-foot long boards. How many two-foot long boards can he cut from them? 70% of the kids say five.
13 Make a model or diagram What s relevant? How do you picture it?
14 The Dragonfly Problem
15 The local cab company charges $1.25 for the first mile traveled and then $0.35 for each additional mile. Natalie spent $7.20 on a ride in a cab. How many miles did Natalie travel?
16 The waterfalls problem
17 Situation Models of the problem contexts The Taxicab problem: The local cab company charges $1.25 for the first mile traveled and then $0.35 for each additional mile. Natalie spent $7.20 on a ride in a cab. How many miles did Natalie travel? The State Fair problem: Jamal went to the State Fair. It cost $5 to get into the fair. Each ride cost $2. If Jamal spent a total of $21, how many rides did he go on?
18 Reading the math from the problem statement. The upper Angel Falls, the highest waterfall on Earth, are 750 m higher than Niagara Falls. If each of the falls were 7 m lower, the upper Angel Falls would be 16 times as high as Niagara Falls. How high is each waterfall? What are your first thoughts?
19 Mine were: It s two simultaneous equations in 2 variables. I ll use convenient letters: A for Angel, N for Niagara, and derive the equations from statements.
20 A river steamer After hearing the three words a river steamer from a river current problem, one subject said, It's going to be one of those river things with upstream, downstream, and still water. You are going to compare times upstream and downstream or if the time is constant, it will be distance.... After hearing five words of a triangle problem, one subject said, this may be something about how far is he from his goal using the Pythagorean theorem. (Hinsley, Hayes, & Simon, 1977, p. 97).
21 Think about how that helps you with: The upper Angel Falls, the highest waterfall on Earth, are 750 m higher than Niagara Falls. If each of the falls were 7 m lower, the upper Angel Falls would be 16 times as high as Niagara Falls. How high is each waterfall? Use A for the height of Angel Falls Use N for the height of Niagara Falls A = N A -7 = 16 (N -7) Then solve. Knowing where I m going cuts through tons of stuff!
22 People s Conceptual Models of the situations to be analyzed T: What are we trying to find out? S: How many seconds will it take the dragonfly to fly 375 feet? T: And we know what? S: It can fly 50 feet in 2 seconds. T: All right, what do you think, well, if it could go fly 50 feet / S: /in 4 seconds it would be 100 feet, in 6 it would be 200, 8 would be 300, so 9 would be 350, there s 25 missing, so 1/2 of it to get 375 so 9 1/2 seconds to get 375. T: That sounds pretty good [And further exchange, where the teacher works to get the student, who now gets the problem, to see that rate, or proportional reasoning, can be useful.]
23 A clash in perspectives We see this as a multiplicative/proportional situation, in which distance per second is a convenient and powerful unit. Many students see this as an additive situation, with a non-standard yardstick: every 2 seconds the dragonfly advances 50 feet. The students perspective makes sense! But how do you lead them to the more powerful mathematical perspective?
24 And there s meta-level knowledge: Consider this problem: Alan can mow the lawn in 40 minutes. David can move the lawn in 50 minutes. How long does it take both of them to mow the lawn together (assuming two mowers, no crashes, etc.) How do you approach this? You have to know that the only things you can combine are rates (how much of the lawn each gets mowed per unit time.)
25 Deriving The Right Equation(s) There s an art to picking the right variable, and it s not easy to pick up. Consider: The length of a rectangle is five inches longer than twice the width of the rectangle. The perimeter of the rectangle is 112 inches. What are the dimensions (the length and the width) of the rectangle? What s your choice of independent variable? How did you know to pick that one?
26 Solving the Equation(s) Whew! We finally get something straightforward and procedural! (Well, almost. Strategy choice is actually non-trivial. When to substitute, when to eliminate? )
27 Checking the answers and the context. Can there really be 31 remainder 12 buses? 1-foot-long shelves in a 2-foot bookcase? Finishing up properly is every bit as much about sense-making as getting started.
28 In conclusion: What may have seemed straightforward: Read problem Make a model or diagram Write equation(s) Solve Check, Actually turns out to be pretty complex:
30 And, every one of the boxes in that diagram requires complex pedagogical strategies and interventions, if you want there to be a good chance that students will get it!
31 And that s why it s hard. But, knowing that also gives us an agenda to work on. So
32 Let s keep our sleeves rolled up and continue working
Math 40 9.7 & 9.8: The Big Four Square, Rectangle, Triangle, Circle Pre Algebra We will be focusing our attention on the formulas for the area and perimeter of a square, rectangle, triangle, and a circle.
LESSON 10 GEOMETRY I: PERIMETER & AREA INTRODUCTION Geometry is the study of shapes and space. In this lesson, we will focus on shapes and measures of one-dimension and two-dimensions. In the next lesson,
Math Smart 643 The GED Math Formulas The GED math test gives you a page of math formulas that you can use on the test, but just seeing the formulas doesn t do you any good. The important thing is understanding
Free Pre-Algebra Lesson 55! page 1 Lesson 55 Perimeter Problems with Related Variables Take your skill at word problems to a new level in this section. All the problems are the same type, so that you can
APPLICATIONS AND MODELING WITH QUADRATIC EQUATIONS Now that we are starting to feel comfortable with the factoring process, the question becomes what do we use factoring to do? There are a variety of classic
MATH Student Book th Grade Unit Unit FRACTION OPERATIONS MATH 0 FRACTION OPERATIONS Introduction. Like Denominators... Adding and Subtracting Fractions Adding and Subtracting Mixed Numbers 0 Estimating
5.5.1 Name Grade 5: Fractions 1. Write the fraction for the shaded part. 2. Write the equivalent fraction. 3. Circle the number equal to 1. A) 9 B) 7 C) 4 D) 7 8 7 0 1 4. Write a mixed number and an improper
Review Eercise Set 3 Eercise 1: The larger of two positive numbers is greater than the smaller. Find the two numbers if their product is 63. Eercise : The length of a rectangle is 4 inches less than twice
58 Equations and Inequalities Supply the reasons in the proofs for the theorems stated in Problems 65 and 66. 65. Theorem: The complex numbers are commutative under addition. Proof: Let a bi and c di be
Acute An angle less than 90 degrees An acute angle is between 1 and 89 degrees Analog Clock Clock with a face and hands This clock shows ten after ten Angle A figure formed by two line segments that end
Name Period_ 7 th Accelerated Chapter 1 Review Part I-Multiple Choice 1. What is the unknown quantity? a. 432 inches b. 180 inches c. 7.2 inches d. 108 inches 2. It takes 3 eggs to bake 36 cupcakes. How
Student Outcomes Students give an informal derivation of the relationship between the circumference and area of a circle. Students know the formula for the area of a circle and use it to solve problems.
MATH 21 College Algebra 1 Lecture Notes MATH 21 3.6 Factoring Review College Algebra 1 Factoring and Foiling 1. (a + b) 2 = a 2 + 2ab + b 2. 2. (a b) 2 = a 2 2ab + b 2. 3. (a + b)(a b) = a 2 b 2. 4. (a
.6 Perimeters and Areas of Similar Figures How do changes in dimensions of similar geometric figures affect the perimeters and the areas of the figures? ACTIVITY: Creating Similar Figures Work with a partner.
NS6-0 Dividing Whole Numbers by Unit Fractions Pages 6 STANDARDS 6.NS.A. Goals Students will divide whole numbers by unit fractions. Vocabulary division fraction unit fraction whole number PRIOR KNOWLEDGE
New York State Testing Program Mathematics Common Core Sample Questions Grade6 The materials contained herein are intended for use by New York State teachers. Permission is hereby granted to teachers and
FRACTIONS: A CONCEPTUAL APPROACH A Singapore Math Topical Presentation Grades -6 Dr. Suchint Sarangarm Three distinct meanings of fractions Part of a Whole: the fraction indicates that a whole has been
The verbal answers to all of the following questions should be memorized before completion of pre-algebra. Answers that are not memorized will hinder your ability to succeed in algebra 1. Number Basics
2-1 Position, Displacement, and Distance In describing an object s motion, we should first talk about position where is the object? A position is a vector because it has both a magnitude and a direction:
NAME DATE PERIOD Precision and Measurement The precision or exactness of a measurement depends on the unit of measure. The precision unit is the smallest unit on a measuring tool. Significant digits include
7 (9-0) Chapter 9 Quadratic Equations and Quadratic Functions where x is the number of years since 1980 and y is the amount of emission in thousands of metric tons (Energy Information Administration, www.eia.doe.gov).
Teacher Page Geometr / Da # 10 oordinate Geometr (5 min.) 9-.G.3.1 9-.G.3.2 9-.G.3.3 9-.G.3. Use rigid motions (compositions of reflections, translations and rotations) to determine whether two geometric
5.1 Introduction to Rational Expressions The Technique: 1. Reduce: 2. Simplify: When simplifying rational expressions, you are actually dividing both the numerator and the denominaror by common factors.
Perimeter is a measurement of length. It is the distance around something. We use perimeter when building a fence around a yard or any place that needs to be enclosed. In that case, we would measure the
Revision Notes Adult Numeracy Level 2 Place Value The use of place value from earlier levels applies but is extended to all sizes of numbers. The values of columns are: Millions Hundred thousands Ten thousands
Grade FCAT. Mathematics Sample Questions The intent of these sample test materials is to orient teachers and students to the types of questions on FCAT. tests. By using these materials, students will become
FCAT FLORIDA COMPREHENSIVE ASSESSMENT TEST Mathematics Reference Sheets Copyright Statement for this Assessment and Evaluation Services Publication Authorization for reproduction of this document is hereby
Calculating Area, Perimeter and Volume You will be given a formula table to complete your math assessment; however, we strongly recommend that you memorize the following formulae which will be used regularly
C H A P T E R 11 Nonlinear Systems and the Conic Sections x y 0 40 Width of boom carpet Most intense sonic boom is between these lines t a cruising speed of 1,40 miles per hour, the Concorde can fly from
Grade 4 FSA Mathematics Practice Test Answer Key The purpose of these practice test materials is to orient teachers and students to the types of questions on paper-based FSA tests. By using these materials,
7 th Grade Math TAKS-STAAR-STAAR-M Comparison Spacing has been deleted and graphics minimized to fit table. (1) Number, operation, and quantitative reasoning. The student represents and uses numbers in
BIRKBECK MATHS SUPPORT www.mathsupport.wordpress.com Measurements 1 In this section we will look at - Examples of everyday measurement - Some units we use to take measurements - Symbols for units and converting
The student will be able to: Geometry and Measurement 1. Demonstrate an understanding of the principles of geometry and measurement and operations using measurements Use the US system of measurement for
Question 1 Test 1, Second QR Section (version 2) Two triangles QA: x QB: y Geometry: Triangles Answer: Quantity A is greater 1. The astute student might recognize the 0:60:90 and 45:45:90 triangle right
Final Word Problem Practice #1 Beginning Algebra / Math 100 Fall 2013 506 (Prof. Miller) Student Name/ID: Instructor Note: Assignment: Set up a tutoring appointment with one of the campus tutors or with
Veterans Upward Bound Algebra I Concepts - Honors Brenda Meery Kaitlyn Spong Say Thanks to the Authors Click http://www.ck12.org/saythanks (No sign in required) www.ck12.org Chapter 6. Factoring CHAPTER
Baking Math Learning Centre Finding Areas of Shapes Bakers often need to know the area of a shape in order to plan their work. A few formulas are required to find area. First, some vocabulary: Diameter
Bake Cookies Day (Dec. 18) Meeting (Multiple Topics) Topic This meeting s problems cover a variety of topics. However, there is a heavy emphasis on proportional reasoning. Materials Needed Copies of the
8 th Grade Task 2 Rugs Student Task Core Idea 4 Geometry and Measurement Find perimeters of shapes. Use Pythagorean theorem to find side lengths. Apply appropriate techniques, tools and formulas to determine
Pre-lgebra Lesson 6-1 to 6-3 Quiz Multiple hoice Identify the choice that best completes the statement or answers the question. 1. Find the area of the triangle. 17 ft 74 ft Not drawn to scale a. 629 ft
Basic Lesson: Pythagorean Theorem Basic skill One leg of a triangle is 10 cm and other leg is of 24 cm. Find out the hypotenuse? Here we have AB = 10 and BC = 24 Using the Pythagorean Theorem AC 2 = AB
Sect 9.5 - Perimeters and Areas of Polygons Ojective a: Understanding Perimeters of Polygons. The Perimeter is the length around the outside of a closed two - dimensional figure. For a polygon, the perimeter
Mathematics Before reading this section, make sure you have read the appropriate description of the mathematics section test (computerized or paper) to understand what is expected of you in the mathematics
INTEGRATED ALGEBRA The University of the State of New York REGENTS HIGH SCHOOL EXAMINATION INTEGRATED ALGEBRA Tuesday, January 27, 2015 1:15 to 4:15 p.m., only Student Name: School Name: The possession
Virginia Mathematics Checkpoint Assessment MATHEMATICS 5.8 Strand: Measurement Standards of Learning Blueprint Summary Reporting Category Grade 5 SOL Number of Items Number & Number Sense 5.1, 5.2(a-b),
BASIC MATHEMATICS COMPETENCY TEST SAMPLE TEST 2004 A scientific, non-graphing calculator is required for this test. The following formulas may be used on this test: Circumference of a circle: C = pd or
When you are stumped on an SAT or ACT math question, there are two very useful strategies that may help you to get the correct answer: 1) work with the answers; and 2) plug in real numbers. This review
Summer Math Eercises For students who are entering Pre-Calculus It has been discovered that idle students lose learning over the summer months. To help you succeed net fall and perhaps to help you learn
Exercises 7.3.1 Five chickens eat 10 bags of scratch in 20 days. How long does it take 18 chickens to eat 100 bags of scratch? 7.3.2 Suppose a is jointly proportional to b and c. If a = 4 when b = 8 and
Unit Number and Operations Fractions: Multiplying and Dividing Fractions Introduction In this unit, students will divide whole numbers and interpret the answer as a fraction instead of with a remainder.
Mental Questions 1. What number is five cubed? KS3 MATHEMATICS 10 4 10 Level 8 Questions Day 1 2. A circle has radius r. What is the formula for the area of the circle? 3. Jenny and Mark share some money
Lecture Notes Quadratic Word Problems page 1 Sample Problems 1. The sum of two numbers is 31, their di erence is 41. Find these numbers.. The product of two numbers is 640. Their di erence is 1. Find these
The Effect of Taxes on Equilibrium Example 1: Suppose the demand function is p = 50 2q, and the supply function is p = 10 + 3q. a) Find the equilibrium point b) Sketch a graph Solution to part a: Set the
Areas of Rectangles Objective To reinforce students understanding of area concepts and units of area. www.everydaymathonline.com epresentations etoolkit Algorithms Practice EM Facts Workshop Game Family
WHAT IS AREA? CFE 3319V OPEN CAPTIONED ALLIED VIDEO CORPORATION 1992 Grade Levels: 5-9 17 minutes DESCRIPTION What is area? Lesson One defines and clarifies what area means and also teaches the concept
Right Triangles If I looked at enough right triangles and experimented a little, I might eventually begin to notice a relationship developing if I were to construct squares formed by the legs of a right
Key Terms in This Session Session 6 Area Previously Introduced scale factor New in This Session area midline similar figures Introduction Area is a measure of how much surface is covered by a particular
Geometry Unit Seven: Surface Area & Volume, Practice In Problems #1 - #4, find the surface area and volume of each prism. 1. CUBE. RECTANGULAR PRISM 9 cm 5 mm 11 mm mm 9 cm 9 cm. TRIANGULAR PRISM 4. TRIANGULAR
.8 Related Rates Section.8 Notes Page This section involves word problems dealing with how something is changing with respect to time. We will first find a formula that is used for the problem and then
Chapter The Derivative Applied Calculus 148 Section 9: Applied Optimization We have used derivatives to help find the maximums and minimums of some functions given by equations, but it is very unlikely
Class: Date: Math 10 - Unit Final Review - Numbers Multiple Choice Identify the choice that best answers the question. 1. Write the prime factorization of 60. a. 2 7 9 b. 2 6 c. 2 2 7 d. 2 7 2. Write the
Lesson Number 3 Multiplication of Whole Numbers & Factors Professor Weissman s Algebra Classroom Martin Weissman, Jonathan S. Weissman. & Tamara Farber What Are The Different Ways To Show Multiplication?
Student Name: Date: Contact Person Name: Phone Number: Teas Assessment of Knowledge and Skills Eit Level Math Review Lesson 18 Pythagorean Triples & Special Right Triangles TAKS Objective 6 Demonstrate
What five coins add up to a nickel? five pennies (1 + 1 + 1 + 1 + 1 = 5) Which is longest: a foot, a yard or an inch? a yard (3 feet = 1 yard; 12 inches = 1 foot) What do you call the answer to a multiplication
Ma KEY STAGE 3 Year 9 mathematics test Tier 6 8 Paper 2 Calculator allowed First name Last name Class Date Please read this page, but do not open your booklet until your teacher tells you to start. Write
Page 1 1. Tommy has jars of marbles. Each jar is _ filled with marbles. How many full jars of marbles does Tommy have? Shade the model and complete the calculations below to show how you found your answer.
Ma KEY STAGE 3 Mathematics test TIER 6 8 Paper 1 Calculator not allowed First name Last name School 2009 Remember The test is 1 hour long. You must not use a calculator for any question in this test. You
Probability and Expected Value This handout provides an introduction to probability and expected value. Some of you may already be familiar with some of these topics. Probability and expected value are
New York State Testing Program Mathematics Common Core Sample Questions Grade7 The materials contained herein are intended for use by New York State teachers. Permission is hereby granted to teachers and
Grade 2 Math Expressions Vocabulary Words Unit 1, Book 1 Understanding Addition and Subtraction OSPI word: number pattern, place value, value, whole number Link to Math Expression Online Glossary for some
Question Test, First QR Section O is the center of the circle... QA: The circumference QB: Geometry: Circles Answer: Quantity A is greater. In order to find the circumference of the circle, we need the
The Theory and Practice of Using a Sine Bar, version 2 By R. G. Sparber Copyleft protects this document. 1 The Quick Answer If you just want to set an angle with a sine bar and stack of blocks, then take
476 CHAPTER 7 Graphs, Equations, and Inequalities 7. Quadratic Equations Now Work the Are You Prepared? problems on page 48. OBJECTIVES 1 Solve Quadratic Equations by Factoring (p. 476) Solve Quadratic
8th Grade Texas Mathematics: Unpacked Content What is the purpose of this document? To increase student achievement by ensuring educators understand specifically what the new standards mean a student must
mathematics College Algebra Geometry Trigonometry Sample Test Questions A Guide for Students and Parents act.org/compass Note to Students Welcome to the ACT Compass Sample Mathematics Test! You are about
New York State Testing Program Mathematics Common Core Sample Questions Grade The materials contained herein are intended for use by New York State teachers. Permission is hereby granted to teachers and
ALGEBRA I (COMMON CORE) The University of the State of New York REGENTS HIGH SCHOOL EXAMINATION ALGEBRA I (Common Core) Thursday, January 28, 2016 1:15 to 4:15 p.m., only Student Name: School Name: The
1 P a g e Grade 9 Mathematics Unit 3: Shape and Space Sub Unit #1: Surface Area Lesson Topic I Can 1 Area, Perimeter, and Determine the area of various shapes Circumference Determine the perimeter of various