Information, The invisible Hand and Google. Michael Rothschild Princeton University

Size: px
Start display at page:

Download "Information, The invisible Hand and Google. Michael Rothschild Princeton University"

Transcription

1 Information, The invisible Hand and Google Michael Rothschild Princeton University In 1900 (David Hilbert, 1902) addressed the International Congress of Mathematicians on Mathematical Problems. He discussed the importance of problems for the development of mathematics and described 23 unsolved problems from all branches of mathematics. The search for solutions of these problems inspired much of 20 th century mathematics. In summer 2003 the 24 panelists for this conference received an asking them to describe problems whose solution would motivate the economists of the 21 st century. I suspect few mathematicians will subscribe to the equation (1) 24 economists = 1 Hilbert or even (2) Joe Stiglitz + 24 other economists = 1 Hilbert -- but it is a nice thought. Before getting down to the serious work of setting problems Hilbert observed: In dealing with mathematical problems, specialization plays, as I believe, a still more important part than generalization. Perhaps in most cases where we seek in vain the answer to a question, the cause of the failure lies in the fact that problems simpler and easier than the one in hand have been either not at all or incompletely solved. All depends, then, on finding out these easier problems, and on solving them by means of devices as perfect as possible and of concepts capable of generalization. This rule is one of the most important levers for overcoming mathematical difficulties and it seems to me that it is used almost always, though perhaps unconsciously This is an excellent statement of the MIT approach to economic theory which runs through Joe s best work. 1 12/09/03

2 Since Hilbert set forth 23 problems, the implication of equations (1) or (2) is that my brief is to set at most one problem. Does the decline in costs of finding and processing information lead to the occasional reappearance of the invisible hand? I searched Google for Stiglitz on Sept 3rd and found roughly 211,000 references. The first is appropriately to Joe s home page. Curious about the last, I began scrolling through the references. Mindful of (Robert M. Solow, 1970) s advice about difficult and unglamorous work 1, I considered getting a research assistant. However, Google soon informed me that: In order to show you the most relevant results, we have omitted some entries very similar to the 828 already displayed. Most of the references were to Joe s work but the 828th reference was to CNdb: Hugo Stiglitz... Nude Male Celebs. When I googled economics imperfect information I found about 206,000 references, (817 without duplicates). While not a perfect guide, (Stiglitz is not explicitly mentioned until page 2) it is pretty good; most references are to an excellent book, The Economics Of Imperfect Information (Louis Phlips, 1988); references abound to key papers, including several by Joe, that show that markets in which information is not freely available to all do not work very well. One could consider this a paradox. Google is a very efficient way for the uninformed to find out about how the world doesn t work very well for the uninformed. The paradox is overstated although it does remind me that when we worked together Joe or I would often proclaim that an example we had just worked out was a stake 1 But it may be what God made graduate students for. Presumably he had something in mind. 2 12/09/03

3 through the heart of capitalism, a demonstration that socialism cannot work or, very rarely, an illustration of the beauty of the market 2. The paradox is overstated because Google is far from perfect for the unsophisticated. A search for economics information produces a grab bag of results, the most prominent of which are about data or the new information economy. Google requires a fast internet connection not available to all in a world where close to a quarter of all people live on less than $1 a day.. Google is still a wonder. Google and the internet are prime examples of decreasing costs (close to zero marginal cost) and network externalities that are textbook causes of market failure and the need for centralization. In this environment Google does what economists have claimed prices do; it aggregates information in a decentralized manner; grist for its (cheap) mill is the data provided by people going about their business with no interest in producing the information that Google spits out. Let s consider first what Google does and how it works and then ask what the implications are for the economics of imperfect information. The Google algorithm (Sergey Brin and Lawrence Page, 1999, Lawrence Page and Sergey Brin, 1998) will be familiar to all economists. Suppose we have a set of web pages. Let (3) W ij=the number of times page i links to (cites) page j and let (4) w ij W ij = W j ij Then w= w is a Markov matrix which for simplicity we assume is irreducible (every ij page eventually cites every other page.) w has a unique positive eigen vector p. When 2 Sometime recalculation changed a sign and the nature of the universe. 3 12/09/03

4 normalized so that p i = 1, then p i is just the ergodic probability that page i will be linked or cited. When you search Google for Stiglitz you get the web pages that contain the text Stiglitz ordered by the size of their p i coefficient. The first is, appropriately, Joe s home page. (Ignacio Palacios-Huertay and Oscar Volijz, 2003) have observed that the Google algorithm is, the unique index of intellectual influence satisfying a set of apparently reasonable axioms. Google is much more than the ergodic theorem (M. Golubitsky et al., 1975) 3. Since the number of web pages is large (the source of Google s name), storing the text of all web pages is not trivial; nor is constantly calculating the appropriate eigen value of w. The most important problem is defeating those who wish to cheat Google by artificially inflating their probability of being linked. (Some years ago five graduates students in economics sent out an to five other graduate student; the consisted of their own names and a request that that recipients cite the papers of these students in their next paper, remove the name at the top of the list, append their own name to the list of names and forward the changed to four other graduate students.) Colleagues in computer science tell me that a secret and escalating war continues in which web pages try to inflate their Google ranking and Google tries to prevent them from doing so. The invisible hand argument is that it may be in people s self interest to create web pages whose links are informative; this makes the web page more useful and more likely to be read and cited/linked. Google performs the aggregation. It is of course true that Google has competitors and that Google must make money. Still decreases in costs of acquiring and processing information make Google cheap to operate and Google 3 A tribute to Joe would be incomplete with out a citation to one of the authors (unjustly) obscure papers. 4 12/09/03

5 does for Web pages what (Friedrich A. von Hayek, 1932) rather vaguely claimed markets and prices did for commodities 4. A question for economic theory is whether or not this is rare and anomalous or whether changes in information technology can lead to a new economic paradigm of the economics of information. Much of the argument to date has centered on two questions: 1. The viability of open software. Economists, in particular, (J. Lerner and J. Tirole, 2002) argue that standard economic arguments about incentives and rewards can explain phenomena like Linux. Others (see in particular(y. Benkler, 2002)) argue that open software is akin to the scientific enterprise in which many scientists continually add to our understanding of the way in which the world works. In physics, say, knowledge advances at an uneven pace. Some people make large contributions, some small. Science advances without, or despite, a formal hierarchy. Those who contribute to science are human beings with interests and motives but they are more complex than, at least the caricature of, homo economicus. 2. What resources are or should be free? In the debate about Napster this takes the form of arguing about whether anyone should pay fixed costs for a good whose marginal cost is zero. This is an old argument to economists. In this sense one way of framing this question may be in part whether or not changes in information technology makes more of commerce like physics or more like the bourse. 4 An apocryphal story is that one of the motivations for developing Google was to help computer scientists convince academic administrators that those who had not published in journals or books had had an extraordinary impact on the profession. The first description of the Google algorithm that I could find was a submission to a 1998 conference Page and Brin (1998) 5 12/09/03

6 3. My fellow panelist and colleague, Avinash Dixit, pointed out to me that decreasing the cost of information processing will not eliminate the information asymmetries that Joe has studied with such skill and originality. Those concerned with privacy rights note with some foreboding that decreases in costs of finding information may drastically change who is likely to know more about whom. References Benkler, Y. "Coase's Penguin, or, Linux and the Nature of the Firm." Yale Law Journal, 2002, 112(3), pp Brin, Sergey and Page, Lawrence. "The Anatomy of a Large-Scale Hypertextual Web Search Engine," Golubitsky, M.; Keeler, E. B. and Rothschild, M. "Convergence of Age Structure - Applications of Projective Metric." Theoretical Population Biology, 1975, 7(1), pp Hayek, Friedrich A. von. Prices and Production. New York,: Macmillan, Hilbert, David. "Mathematical Problems Lecture Delivered before the International Congress of Mathematicians at Paris in 1900." Bulletin of the American Mathematical Society, 1902, 8, pp Lerner, J. and Tirole, J. "Some Simple Economics of Open Source." Journal of Industrial Economics, 2002, 50(2), pp Page, Lawrence and Brin, Sergey. "Pagerank, an Eigenvector Based Ranking Approach for Hypertext.," 21st Annual ACM/SIGIR International Conference on Research and Development in Information Retrieval. Melbourne, Palacios-Huertay, Ignacio and Volijz, Oscar. "The Measurement of Intellectual Influence," Phlips, Louis. The Economics of Imperfect Information. Cambridge Cambridgeshire ; New York: Cambridge University Press, Solow, Robert M. Growth Theory: An Exposition. Oxford,: Clarendon, /09/03

An Innocent Investigation

An Innocent Investigation An Innocent Investigation D. Joyce, Clark University January 2006 The beginning. Have you ever wondered why every number is either even or odd? I don t mean to ask if you ever wondered whether every number

More information

WHAT ARE MATHEMATICAL PROOFS AND WHY THEY ARE IMPORTANT?

WHAT ARE MATHEMATICAL PROOFS AND WHY THEY ARE IMPORTANT? WHAT ARE MATHEMATICAL PROOFS AND WHY THEY ARE IMPORTANT? introduction Many students seem to have trouble with the notion of a mathematical proof. People that come to a course like Math 216, who certainly

More information

Semantic Search in Portals using Ontologies

Semantic Search in Portals using Ontologies Semantic Search in Portals using Ontologies Wallace Anacleto Pinheiro Ana Maria de C. Moura Military Institute of Engineering - IME/RJ Department of Computer Engineering - Rio de Janeiro - Brazil [awallace,anamoura]@de9.ime.eb.br

More information

Rafal Borkowski, Hipoteczna 18/22 m. 8, 91-337 Lodz, POLAND, E-mail: r-borkowski@go2.pl

Rafal Borkowski, Hipoteczna 18/22 m. 8, 91-337 Lodz, POLAND, E-mail: r-borkowski@go2.pl Rafal Borkowski, Hipoteczna 18/22 m. 8, 91-337 Lodz, POLAND, E-mail: r-borkowski@go2.pl Krzysztof M. Ostaszewski, Actuarial Program Director, Illinois State University, Normal, IL 61790-4520, U.S.A., e-mail:

More information

The science of encryption: prime numbers and mod n arithmetic

The science of encryption: prime numbers and mod n arithmetic The science of encryption: prime numbers and mod n arithmetic Go check your e-mail. You ll notice that the webpage address starts with https://. The s at the end stands for secure meaning that a process

More information

Similar matrices and Jordan form

Similar matrices and Jordan form Similar matrices and Jordan form We ve nearly covered the entire heart of linear algebra once we ve finished singular value decompositions we ll have seen all the most central topics. A T A is positive

More information

Million Dollar Mathematics!

Million Dollar Mathematics! Million Dollar Mathematics! Alissa S. Crans Loyola Marymount University Southern California Undergraduate Math Day University of California, San Diego April 30, 2011 This image is from the Wikipedia article

More information

Doug Ravenel. October 15, 2008

Doug Ravenel. October 15, 2008 Doug Ravenel University of Rochester October 15, 2008 s about Euclid s Some s about primes that every mathematician should know (Euclid, 300 BC) There are infinitely numbers. is very elementary, and we

More information

Commentary on The Status and Quality of Teaching and Learning of Science in Australian Schools 1

Commentary on The Status and Quality of Teaching and Learning of Science in Australian Schools 1 Commentary on The Status and Quality of Teaching and Learning of Science in Australian Schools 1 Jan Thomas Executive Officer Australian Mathematical Society This is a very thorough report and, in the

More information

Application of Game Theory in Inventory Management

Application of Game Theory in Inventory Management Application of Game Theory in Inventory Management Rodrigo Tranamil-Vidal Universidad de Chile, Santiago de Chile, Chile Rodrigo.tranamil@ug.udechile.cl Abstract. Game theory has been successfully applied

More information

3. INNER PRODUCT SPACES

3. INNER PRODUCT SPACES . INNER PRODUCT SPACES.. Definition So far we have studied abstract vector spaces. These are a generalisation of the geometric spaces R and R. But these have more structure than just that of a vector space.

More information

7 QUESTIONS TO ASK YOUR PPC AGENCY. We Turn Browsers Into Buyers

7 QUESTIONS TO ASK YOUR PPC AGENCY. We Turn Browsers Into Buyers 7 QUESTIONS TO ASK YOUR PPC AGENCY We Turn Browsers Into Buyers 7 Questions to Ask Your PPC Agency Choosing a PPC agency is similar to purchasing a home. It s an important choice, one which will affect

More information

What Can Aid Do? David B. Skarbek and Peter T. Leeson

What Can Aid Do? David B. Skarbek and Peter T. Leeson David B. Skarbek and Peter T. Leeson Under normal conditions, devoting more resources to X s production produces more X. This follows from the nature of the physical world, which positively relates quantities

More information

CORSO DI POLITICA ECONOMICA PER L INNOVAZIONE FACOLTÀ DI ECONOMIA R.GOODWIN UNIVERSITÀ DI SIENA

CORSO DI POLITICA ECONOMICA PER L INNOVAZIONE FACOLTÀ DI ECONOMIA R.GOODWIN UNIVERSITÀ DI SIENA FACOLTÀ DI ECONOMIA R.GOODWIN UNIVERSITÀ DI SIENA PROF.SSA MARIA ALESSANDRA ROSSI ALESSANDRA.ROSSI@UNISI.IT Open innovation and user innovation AGENDA Demand is key to innovation not only because it drives

More information

Statement of Dr. Stephen Wolfram Founder & CEO, Wolfram Research, Inc. and author of A New Kind of Science

Statement of Dr. Stephen Wolfram Founder & CEO, Wolfram Research, Inc. and author of A New Kind of Science Statement of Dr. Stephen Wolfram Founder & CEO, Wolfram Research, Inc.... 1 Statement of Dr. Stephen Wolfram Founder & CEO, Wolfram Research, Inc. and author of A New Kind of Science before the Subcommittee

More information

P vs NP problem in the field anthropology

P vs NP problem in the field anthropology Research Article P vs NP problem in the field anthropology Michael.A. Popov, Oxford, UK Email Michael282.eps@gmail.com Keywords P =?NP - complexity anthropology - M -decision - quantum -like game - game-theoretical

More information

Revised Version of Chapter 23. We learned long ago how to solve linear congruences. ax c (mod m)

Revised Version of Chapter 23. We learned long ago how to solve linear congruences. ax c (mod m) Chapter 23 Squares Modulo p Revised Version of Chapter 23 We learned long ago how to solve linear congruences ax c (mod m) (see Chapter 8). It s now time to take the plunge and move on to quadratic equations.

More information

Panel on Emerging Cyber Security Technologies. Robert F. Brammer, Ph.D., VP and CTO. Northrop Grumman Information Systems.

Panel on Emerging Cyber Security Technologies. Robert F. Brammer, Ph.D., VP and CTO. Northrop Grumman Information Systems. Panel on Emerging Cyber Security Technologies Robert F. Brammer, Ph.D., VP and CTO Northrop Grumman Information Systems Panel Moderator 27 May 2010 Panel on Emerging Cyber Security Technologies Robert

More information

Tetris is Hard: An Introduction to P vs NP

Tetris is Hard: An Introduction to P vs NP Tetris is Hard: An Introduction to P vs NP Based on Tetris is Hard, Even to Approximate in COCOON 2003 by Erik D. Demaine (MIT) Susan Hohenberger (JHU) David Liben-Nowell (Carleton) What s Your Problem?

More information

Ranking on Data Manifolds

Ranking on Data Manifolds Ranking on Data Manifolds Dengyong Zhou, Jason Weston, Arthur Gretton, Olivier Bousquet, and Bernhard Schölkopf Max Planck Institute for Biological Cybernetics, 72076 Tuebingen, Germany {firstname.secondname

More information

Critical Study David Benatar. Better Never To Have Been: The Harm of Coming into Existence (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2006)

Critical Study David Benatar. Better Never To Have Been: The Harm of Coming into Existence (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2006) NOÛS 43:4 (2009) 776 785 Critical Study David Benatar. Better Never To Have Been: The Harm of Coming into Existence (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2006) ELIZABETH HARMAN Princeton University In this

More information

EDUCATION AND EXAMINATION COMMITTEE SOCIETY OF ACTUARIES RISK AND INSURANCE. Copyright 2005 by the Society of Actuaries

EDUCATION AND EXAMINATION COMMITTEE SOCIETY OF ACTUARIES RISK AND INSURANCE. Copyright 2005 by the Society of Actuaries EDUCATION AND EXAMINATION COMMITTEE OF THE SOCIET OF ACTUARIES RISK AND INSURANCE by Judy Feldman Anderson, FSA and Robert L. Brown, FSA Copyright 25 by the Society of Actuaries The Education and Examination

More information

How to start research and how to present it?

How to start research and how to present it? How to start research and how to present it? Peter Kondor Budapest, CEU, 2010 Introduction What is research? How to start? How to present it? How to make it a paper? The main purpose of workshop to provide

More information

Notes V General Equilibrium: Positive Theory. 1 Walrasian Equilibrium and Excess Demand

Notes V General Equilibrium: Positive Theory. 1 Walrasian Equilibrium and Excess Demand Notes V General Equilibrium: Positive Theory In this lecture we go on considering a general equilibrium model of a private ownership economy. In contrast to the Notes IV, we focus on positive issues such

More information

ERC Synergy Grant White Paper. impact Privacy, Accountability, Compliance, and Trust in Tomorrow s Internet

ERC Synergy Grant White Paper. impact Privacy, Accountability, Compliance, and Trust in Tomorrow s Internet ERC Synergy Grant White Paper impact Privacy, Accountability, Compliance, and Trust in Tomorrow s Internet Principal Investigators (PIs) : Michael Backes, Saarland University : Peter Druschel, Max Planck

More information

Pretty Good Privacy (PGP)

Pretty Good Privacy (PGP) Pretty Good Privacy (PGP) Contents...1 Abstract...2 Introduction...3 The importance of the cryptography...4 The idea about how (PGP) works...5 Legal issues surrounding (PGP)...6 The implementation and

More information

David G. Tucek Value Economics, LLC 13024 Vinson Court St. Louis, MO 63043 Tel: 314/434 8633 Cell: 314/440 4925 David.Tucek@valueeconomics.

David G. Tucek Value Economics, LLC 13024 Vinson Court St. Louis, MO 63043 Tel: 314/434 8633 Cell: 314/440 4925 David.Tucek@valueeconomics. 1 Economic Controversy in Personal Injury Cases An Example of a Bad Example Submitted for Publication in the Journal of the Missouri Bar, (Draft 2/14/2012) David G. Tucek Value Economics, LLC 13024 Vinson

More information

The Union-Find Problem Kruskal s algorithm for finding an MST presented us with a problem in data-structure design. As we looked at each edge,

The Union-Find Problem Kruskal s algorithm for finding an MST presented us with a problem in data-structure design. As we looked at each edge, The Union-Find Problem Kruskal s algorithm for finding an MST presented us with a problem in data-structure design. As we looked at each edge, cheapest first, we had to determine whether its two endpoints

More information

I m Graydon Trusler and I ve been doing all the Marketing for my wife s divorce law firm in Austin for 8 years or so.

I m Graydon Trusler and I ve been doing all the Marketing for my wife s divorce law firm in Austin for 8 years or so. I m Graydon Trusler and I ve been doing all the Marketing for my wife s divorce law firm in Austin for 8 years or so. I m going to take the same approach with you that I have with our marketing aimed at

More information

Ph.D. Thesis Research: Where do I Start?

Ph.D. Thesis Research: Where do I Start? Ph.D. Thesis Research: Where do I Start? Notes by Don Davis Columbia University If you are the next Paul Samuelson and will wholly transform the field of economics, pay no heed. If you are the next Ken

More information

ESMT BUSINESS BRIEF. Exploitative Abuses. Lars-Hendrik Röller, ESMT. ESMT No. BB-107-002 ISSN 1866 4024

ESMT BUSINESS BRIEF. Exploitative Abuses. Lars-Hendrik Röller, ESMT. ESMT No. BB-107-002 ISSN 1866 4024 Business Brief Consolidation Index: Critical Success Factors for Industry Consolidation 1 ESMT No. BB-107-002 ESMT BUSINESS BRIEF Lars-Hendrik Röller, ESMT ISSN 1866 4024 2 Business Brief Consolidation

More information

Overview. Bigness, in more formal terms. Big Data? ITNPBD4: Lecture 2. d i =, j =1:M. d i

Overview. Bigness, in more formal terms. Big Data? ITNPBD4: Lecture 2. d i =<d i,j >, j =1:M. d i ITNPBD4: Lecture 2 Leslie Smith Overview What makes big data big and why isn t this simply pure Mathematics? Cleanness and completeness of data Why all the fuss now? What s new technologically What do

More information

1 Sets and Set Notation.

1 Sets and Set Notation. LINEAR ALGEBRA MATH 27.6 SPRING 23 (COHEN) LECTURE NOTES Sets and Set Notation. Definition (Naive Definition of a Set). A set is any collection of objects, called the elements of that set. We will most

More information

Monday and Wednesday 5:30 to 7:30 and by Appointment

Monday and Wednesday 5:30 to 7:30 and by Appointment American University Master Of Science in Personnel and Human Resource Management Strategic Human Resource Management Course Number MGMT 671 Summer 1999 Professor Robert C. Hoell Office: Office Hours: Office

More information

Critical analysis. Be more critical! More analysis needed! That s what my tutors say about my essays. I m not really sure what they mean.

Critical analysis. Be more critical! More analysis needed! That s what my tutors say about my essays. I m not really sure what they mean. Critical analysis Be more critical! More analysis needed! That s what my tutors say about my essays. I m not really sure what they mean. I thought I had written a really good assignment this time. I did

More information

Published in Journal of Legal Economics, Volume 5, Number 2, Fall 1995 pp.57-65.

Published in Journal of Legal Economics, Volume 5, Number 2, Fall 1995 pp.57-65. Published in Journal of Legal Economics, Volume 5, Number 2, Fall 1995 pp.57-65. The Defense Economist s Role in Litigation Settlement Negotiations Lawrence M. Spizman Professor of Economics State University

More information

A Guide to the Pension Options

A Guide to the Pension Options A Guide to the Pension Options James A. Chalfant and Helen L. Henry 1 Explanatory note: the purpose of this document is to go beyond the requests for tables showing simple, hypothetical results for new

More information

Nancy Cartwright, Hunting Causes and Using Them: Approaches in Philosophy and Economics

Nancy Cartwright, Hunting Causes and Using Them: Approaches in Philosophy and Economics Review of Nancy Cartwright, Hunting Causes and Using Them: Approaches in Philosophy and Economics Kevin D. Hoover Departments of Economics and Philosophy Duke University Box 90097 Durham, North Carolina

More information

FAIR TRADE IN INSURANCE INDUSTRY: PREMIUM DETERMINATION OF TAIWAN AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE. Emilio Venezian Venezian Associate, Taiwan

FAIR TRADE IN INSURANCE INDUSTRY: PREMIUM DETERMINATION OF TAIWAN AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE. Emilio Venezian Venezian Associate, Taiwan FAIR TRADE IN INSURANCE INDUSTRY: PREMIUM DETERMINATION OF TAIWAN AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE Emilio Venezian Venezian Associate, Taiwan Chu-Shiu Li Department of Economics, Feng Chia University, Taiwan 100 Wen

More information

You Could Have Invented Spectral Sequences

You Could Have Invented Spectral Sequences You Could Have Invented Spectral Sequences Timothy Y Chow Introduction The subject of spectral sequences has a reputation for being difficult for the beginner Even G W Whitehead (quoted in John McCleary

More information

MA150/WR150 Investigations in Geometry Spring 2014 Lectures: Tuesday, Thursday 2-3:30 in COM 213 Discussion section: Tuesday 3:30-4:30 in PSY B36

MA150/WR150 Investigations in Geometry Spring 2014 Lectures: Tuesday, Thursday 2-3:30 in COM 213 Discussion section: Tuesday 3:30-4:30 in PSY B36 MA150/WR150 Investigations in Geometry Spring 2014 Lectures: Tuesday, Thursday 2-3:30 in COM 213 Discussion section: Tuesday 3:30-4:30 in PSY B36 Professor: Steve Rosenberg Office: MCS 248 Contact: sr@math.bu.edu;

More information

Why Nuix doesn t believe in Magic

Why Nuix doesn t believe in Magic Why Nuix doesn t believe in Magic Nuix has participated in the Gartner Magic Quadrant for ediscovery Software for the past four years. Over that time, the ediscovery market has changed considerably. Unfortunately,

More information

Position Statement on Electronic Voting

Position Statement on Electronic Voting Position Statement on Electronic Voting Jeffrey S. Chase Department of Computer Science Duke University December 2004 (modified 11/2006) This statement is a response to several requests for my position

More information

The search for the perfect pension system, like. An Integrated Approach to Pension Benefits. Conflicting Objectives. William J.

The search for the perfect pension system, like. An Integrated Approach to Pension Benefits. Conflicting Objectives. William J. An Integrated Approach to Pension Benefits by William J. Ruschau The search for the perfect pension system, like the search for the Holy Grail, continues to prove elusive. The economic collapse of 2008

More information

Some Polynomial Theorems. John Kennedy Mathematics Department Santa Monica College 1900 Pico Blvd. Santa Monica, CA 90405 rkennedy@ix.netcom.

Some Polynomial Theorems. John Kennedy Mathematics Department Santa Monica College 1900 Pico Blvd. Santa Monica, CA 90405 rkennedy@ix.netcom. Some Polynomial Theorems by John Kennedy Mathematics Department Santa Monica College 1900 Pico Blvd. Santa Monica, CA 90405 rkennedy@ix.netcom.com This paper contains a collection of 31 theorems, lemmas,

More information

But For Causation in Defective Drug and Toxic Exposure Cases: California s Form Jury Instruction CACI 430

But For Causation in Defective Drug and Toxic Exposure Cases: California s Form Jury Instruction CACI 430 But For Causation in Defective Drug and Toxic Exposure Cases: California s Form Jury Instruction CACI 430 By Matt Powers and Charles Lifland Since the California Supreme Court s 1991 decision in Mitchell

More information

Tissue Economies: Blood, Organs, and Cell Lines in Late Capitalism

Tissue Economies: Blood, Organs, and Cell Lines in Late Capitalism Tissue Economies: Blood, Organs, and Cell Lines in Late Capitalism By Catherine Waldby and Robert Mitchell Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 2006, ISBN 0-8223-3770-3 Price $21.95, pp. 231 Reviewed by

More information

Retail Banking: Innovation distinguishes between the leaders and the followers GRANT THORNTON FINANCIAL SERVICES GROUP SEPTEMBER 2013

Retail Banking: Innovation distinguishes between the leaders and the followers GRANT THORNTON FINANCIAL SERVICES GROUP SEPTEMBER 2013 Retail Banking: Innovation distinguishes between the leaders and the followers GRANT THORNTON FINANCIAL SERVICES GROUP SEPTEMBER 2013 10-30% of customers make up 90% of profits 1 New entrants Customers

More information

Composition as Explanation Gertrude Stein

Composition as Explanation Gertrude Stein Composition as Explanation Gertrude Stein First delivered by the author as a lecture at Cambridge and Oxford, this essay was first published by the Hogarth Press in London in 1926 and revived in the volume

More information

MASTER S PROGRAM IN INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY

MASTER S PROGRAM IN INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY MASTER S PROGRAM IN INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY Computing Electronics and Communication Systems Mathematics Program description This program covers many fields in the broad area of information technology, including

More information

On the Paradox of the Question

On the Paradox of the Question On the Paradox of the Question Theodore Sider Analysis 57 (1997): 97 101 Ned Markosian (1997) tells a story in which philosophers have an opportunity to ask an angel a single question. In order to circumvent

More information

Controlling Cheating in Online Courses: A Primer. How can you help your students decide not to cheat?

Controlling Cheating in Online Courses: A Primer. How can you help your students decide not to cheat? Controlling Cheating in Online Courses: A Primer 2013 Pearson This material was developed by Sarah Smith with help from the MyLabs and Mastering Group and with material from

More information

The Set of Candidate Models

The Set of Candidate Models 1 The Set of Candidate Models Formulation of critical hypotheses and models to adequately reflect these hypotheses is conceptually more difficult than estimating the model parameters and their precision.

More information

PROMOTING PRIVATELY FUNDED SETTLEMENT OF MARS

PROMOTING PRIVATELY FUNDED SETTLEMENT OF MARS MAR 98-036 PROMOTING PRIVATELY FUNDED SETTLEMENT OF MARS Alan B. Wasser Why is there no really significant effort being made to develop affordable human transport to Mars? Everyone knows the answer to

More information

Data Science Center Eindhoven. Big Data: Challenges and Opportunities for Mathematicians. Alessandro Di Bucchianico

Data Science Center Eindhoven. Big Data: Challenges and Opportunities for Mathematicians. Alessandro Di Bucchianico Data Science Center Eindhoven Big Data: Challenges and Opportunities for Mathematicians Alessandro Di Bucchianico Dutch Mathematical Congress April 15, 2015 Contents 1. Big Data terminology 2. Various

More information

Inventions, Innovations, and Intellectual Property

Inventions, Innovations, and Intellectual Property Inventions, Innovations, and Intellectual Property September 16, 2013 Introduction Voip-Pal s intellectual property value is derived from 4 recently-issued (or announced) USPTO patents; including one foundational

More information

Code of Practice. Preamble 1. Procedures 5

Code of Practice. Preamble 1. Procedures 5 Code of Practice Contents Preamble 1 Code of Practice 2 Procedures 5 Preamble The European Mathematical Society Ethics Committee was created by the Executive Committee of the European Mathematical Society

More information

Spectrum Policy and the Evolution of the Wireless Internet: Some Thoughts on Where Economists Agree and Disagree Smith School Working Paper Series

Spectrum Policy and the Evolution of the Wireless Internet: Some Thoughts on Where Economists Agree and Disagree Smith School Working Paper Series Spectrum Policy and the Evolution of the Wireless Internet: Some Thoughts on Where Economists Agree and Disagree Smith School Working Paper Series November 2013 25 March 2013 Working Paper 13-03 Robert

More information

Should New Merger Guidelines Give UPP Market Definition?

Should New Merger Guidelines Give UPP Market Definition? December 2009 (Release 1) Should New Merger Guidelines Give UPP Market Definition? Richard Schmalensee Massachusetts Institute of Technology & LECG www.competitionpolicyinternational.com Competition Policy

More information

Why Computer Science? Robert H. Sloan University of Illinois at Chicago

Why Computer Science? Robert H. Sloan University of Illinois at Chicago Why Computer Science? Robert H. Sloan University of Illinois at Chicago I have two teenage daughters. The older one is in college, and is studying computer science (CS). The younger one is in high school,

More information

7. Normal Distributions

7. Normal Distributions 7. Normal Distributions A. Introduction B. History C. Areas of Normal Distributions D. Standard Normal E. Exercises Most of the statistical analyses presented in this book are based on the bell-shaped

More information

EDUCATING SCHOOL LEADERS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

EDUCATING SCHOOL LEADERS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY EDUCATING SCHOOL LEADERS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY EXECUTIVE SUMMARY EDUCATING SCHOOL LEADERS At a time when America s schools face a critical demand for effective principals and superintendents, the majority

More information

Innovation Roles The People You Need for Successful Innovation. A White Paper. Dean Hering Jeffrey Phillips. NetCentrics Corporation

Innovation Roles The People You Need for Successful Innovation. A White Paper. Dean Hering Jeffrey Phillips. NetCentrics Corporation Innovation Roles The People You Need for Successful Innovation A White Paper By Dean Hering Jeffrey Phillips NetCentrics Corporation November 1, 2005 NetCentrics 2005. All rights reserved. 1 Table of Contents

More information

TEACHERS USING COMPUTERS IN MATHEMATICS: A LONGITUDINAL STUDY

TEACHERS USING COMPUTERS IN MATHEMATICS: A LONGITUDINAL STUDY TEACHERS USING COMPUTERS IN MATHEMATICS: A LONGITUDINAL STUDY Michael O. J. Thomas The University of Auckland The computer has been in mathematics classrooms for over 20 years now, but with widely varying

More information

15.401 Finance Theory

15.401 Finance Theory Finance Theory MIT Sloan MBA Program Andrew W. Lo Harris & Harris Group Professor, MIT Sloan School Lectures 10 11 11: : Options Critical Concepts Motivation Payoff Diagrams Payoff Tables Option Strategies

More information

The chance of a lifetime Study social work at Stockholm University in Sweden At a turning point in your life? This could be the chance of a lifetime!

The chance of a lifetime Study social work at Stockholm University in Sweden At a turning point in your life? This could be the chance of a lifetime! The chance of a lifetime Study social work at Stockholm University in Sweden At a turning point in your life? This could be the chance of a lifetime! 2 The chance of a lifetime The chance of a lifetime

More information

Graph Processing and Social Networks

Graph Processing and Social Networks Graph Processing and Social Networks Presented by Shu Jiayu, Yang Ji Department of Computer Science and Engineering The Hong Kong University of Science and Technology 2015/4/20 1 Outline Background Graph

More information

Is Japan's Saving Rate High? (p. 3)

Is Japan's Saving Rate High? (p. 3) Is Japan's Saving Rate High? (p. 3) Fumio Hayashi Understanding Japan's Saving Rate: The Reconstruction Hypothesis (p. 10) Lawrence J. Christiano Are Economic Forecasts Rational? (p. 26) Michael P. Keane

More information

It has been contended that it would be possible for a socialist economy to solve

It has been contended that it would be possible for a socialist economy to solve THE EQUATIONS OF MATHEMATICAL ECONOMICS AND THE PROBLEM OF ECONOMIC CALCULATION IN A SOCIALIST STATE LUDWIG VON MISES I It has been contended that it would be possible for a socialist economy to solve

More information

Income Replacement Versus Expense Approach to Insurance Needs Analysis. Shawn Brayman, BSc, MES Chief Executive Officer PlanPlus Inc.

Income Replacement Versus Expense Approach to Insurance Needs Analysis. Shawn Brayman, BSc, MES Chief Executive Officer PlanPlus Inc. !! Income Replacement Versus Expense Approach to Insurance Needs Analysis Shawn Brayman, BSc, MES Chief Executive Officer PlanPlus Inc. 2008 Financial Frontier Awards Submission 2008 Income Replacement

More information

What Is Pay Per Click Advertising?

What Is Pay Per Click Advertising? PPC Management can be very confusing and daunting for newcomers to the field. Money is on the line and it s a very competitive arena where lots of people are trying to capitalize on the same keywords for

More information

THESIS: THE US SHOULD NOT ALLOW MORE LENIENT WORKPLACE- POLLUTION (THAN PUBLIC) STANDARDS, WORKERS (1) ARE NOT FULLY INFORMED ABOUT HIGHER RISKS; (2)

THESIS: THE US SHOULD NOT ALLOW MORE LENIENT WORKPLACE- POLLUTION (THAN PUBLIC) STANDARDS, WORKERS (1) ARE NOT FULLY INFORMED ABOUT HIGHER RISKS; (2) SAMPLE PAPER FROM DR. SHRADER-FRECHETTE (BIOSCIENCE CITATION FORMAT) THESIS: THE US SHOULD NOT ALLOW MORE LENIENT WORKPLACE- POLLUTION (THAN PUBLIC) STANDARDS, BECAUSE OFTEN WORKERS (1) ARE NOT FULLY INFORMED

More information

AN INTRODUCTION TO PREMIUM TREND

AN INTRODUCTION TO PREMIUM TREND AN INTRODUCTION TO PREMIUM TREND Burt D. Jones * February, 2002 Acknowledgement I would like to acknowledge the valuable assistance of Catherine Taylor, who was instrumental in the development of this

More information

One Cloud doesn t fit all:

One Cloud doesn t fit all: One Cloud doesn t fit all: The emerging trends in multi-vendor cloud platforms To cloud or not to cloud is no longer the question. Organisations have moved beyond the deliberation stage, and with many

More information

BENEFIT-COST ANALYSIS OF A KENTUCKY DUI ACCIDENT COUNTERMEASURE PROGRAM

BENEFIT-COST ANALYSIS OF A KENTUCKY DUI ACCIDENT COUNTERMEASURE PROGRAM BENEFIT-COST ANALYSIS OF A KENTUCKY DUI ACCIDENT COUNTERMEASURE PROGRAM Glenn C. Blomquist University of Kentucky, Lexington, Kentucky, U.S.A. Summary. The purpose of this paper is to apply a general model

More information

Further Steps: Geometry Beyond High School. Catherine A. Gorini Maharishi University of Management Fairfield, IA cgorini@mum.edu

Further Steps: Geometry Beyond High School. Catherine A. Gorini Maharishi University of Management Fairfield, IA cgorini@mum.edu Further Steps: Geometry Beyond High School Catherine A. Gorini Maharishi University of Management Fairfield, IA cgorini@mum.edu Geometry the study of shapes, their properties, and the spaces containing

More information

COLLECTIVE INTELLIGENCE: A NEW APPROACH TO STOCK PRICE FORECASTING

COLLECTIVE INTELLIGENCE: A NEW APPROACH TO STOCK PRICE FORECASTING COLLECTIVE INTELLIGENCE: A NEW APPROACH TO STOCK PRICE FORECASTING CRAIG A. KAPLAN* iq Company (www.iqco.com) Abstract A group that makes better decisions than its individual members is considered to exhibit

More information

The 1st European Conference on Teaching and Learning Politics, International Relations and European Studies Maastricht, 26-27 June 2014

The 1st European Conference on Teaching and Learning Politics, International Relations and European Studies Maastricht, 26-27 June 2014 The 1st European Conference on Teaching and Learning Politics, International Relations and European Studies Maastricht, 26-27 June 2014 Conference papers and presentations are works-in-progress - they

More information

GUIDE TO WRITING YOUR RESEARCH PAPER Ashley Leeds Rice University

GUIDE TO WRITING YOUR RESEARCH PAPER Ashley Leeds Rice University GUIDE TO WRITING YOUR RESEARCH PAPER Ashley Leeds Rice University Here are some basic tips to help you in writing your research paper. The guide is divided into six sections covering distinct aspects of

More information

The following is a reprint of an interview with

The following is a reprint of an interview with An Interview with Sun-Yung Alice Chang Y K Leong Asia Pacific Mathematics Newsletter Sun-Yung Alice Chang The following is a reprint of an interview with Professor Sun-Yung Alice Chang of Princeton University

More information

Rory Vaden. Take the Stairs 7 Steps to Achieving True Success

Rory Vaden. Take the Stairs 7 Steps to Achieving True Success RoryVaden TaketheStairs 7StepstoAchievingTrueSuccess Take the Stairs Rory Vaden Success is a choice that is as simple as deciding to Take the Stairs Self Discipline Strategist and author Rory Vaden shares

More information

White paper The future of Service Desks - vision

White paper The future of Service Desks - vision White paper The future of Service Desks - vision Service Desks require strategic consideration and innovation to raise user productivity and to support business goals. Fujitsu has the experience and feedback

More information

Metrics Report: MATHEMATICS & COMPUTER SCIENCE (rev. 3/29/05)

Metrics Report: MATHEMATICS & COMPUTER SCIENCE (rev. 3/29/05) Metrics Report: MATHEMATICS & COMPUTER SCIENCE (rev. 3/29/05) I. Program Overview A. Department Profile (faculty, students, curriculum) The Department of Mathematics & Computer Science is an established

More information

Knowledge Asset Management

Knowledge Asset Management SMR International Putting KM to Work Knowledge Asset Management In the Current Economic Crisis, Taking Care of What Your People Know Keeps Survival and Growth on Track Your Company s Knowledge Assets:

More information

Beattie v Secretary of State for Social Security,

Beattie v Secretary of State for Social Security, CASE ANALYSIS Income Support Capital to be treated as income - Structured settlement of damages for personal injury - Whether periodical payments that arise from the annuity are to be treated as income

More information

Human Resource Management and Development

Human Resource Management and Development Human Resource Management and Development product: 4388 course code: c302 Human Resource Management and Development Centre for Financial and Management Studies, SOAS University of London First Edition

More information

GRADUATE PROGRAMME BARCELONA 2015/2016. MSc & PhD in Economics

GRADUATE PROGRAMME BARCELONA 2015/2016. MSc & PhD in Economics GRADUATE PROGRAMME BARCELONA 2015/ MSc & PhD in Economics GRADUATE PROGRAMME Barcelona 2015 / The University of Barcelona s Graduate Programme in Economics has been developed for students who intend to

More information

Top Top 10 Algorithms in Data Mining

Top Top 10 Algorithms in Data Mining ICDM 06 Panel on Top Top 10 Algorithms in Data Mining 1. The 3-step identification process 2. The 18 identified candidates 3. Algorithm presentations 4. Top 10 algorithms: summary 5. Open discussions ICDM

More information

A STUDY OF OPEN INNOVATION IN CLOUD COMPUTING

A STUDY OF OPEN INNOVATION IN CLOUD COMPUTING A STUDY OF OPEN INNOVATION IN CLOUD COMPUTING Grozdalina Grozeva 1, Yordan Dimitrov 2 1 Department of Management, Technical University, Bulgaria, E-mail: grozeva77@abv.bg 2 Department of Management, Technical

More information

Psychology has been considered to have an autonomy from the other sciences (especially

Psychology has been considered to have an autonomy from the other sciences (especially THE AUTONOMY OF PSYCHOLOGY Tim Crane, University College London Psychology has been considered to have an autonomy from the other sciences (especially physical science) in at least two ways: in its subject-matter

More information

Why is Internal Audit so Hard?

Why is Internal Audit so Hard? Why is Internal Audit so Hard? 2 2014 Why is Internal Audit so Hard? 3 2014 Why is Internal Audit so Hard? Waste Abuse Fraud 4 2014 Waves of Change 1 st Wave Personal Computers Electronic Spreadsheets

More information

We invite submissions, which may react to, and expand on to the following questions of Digital Material/ism :

We invite submissions, which may react to, and expand on to the following questions of Digital Material/ism : Call for Papers Digital Material/ism: How Materiality shapes Digital Culture and Social Interaction First Issue of Digital Culture & Society Abstract deadline: February 1, 2015 The idea of a society, in

More information

Providence College Local Faculty Survey: Analytical Memo of Findings

Providence College Local Faculty Survey: Analytical Memo of Findings Providence College Local Faculty Survey: Analytical Memo of Findings October 1, 2013 Overview The following memorandum provides an analytical narrative of the results of the 2013 Ithaka S+R Local Faculty

More information

How Good Are The Best Papers of JASIS? Terrence A. Brooks. School of Library and Information Science. University of Washington

How Good Are The Best Papers of JASIS? Terrence A. Brooks. School of Library and Information Science. University of Washington How Good Are The Best Papers of JASIS? Terrence A. Brooks School of Library and Information Science University of Washington tabrooks@u.washington.edu 1 Abstract A citation analysis examined the twenty

More information

A MECHANICS FOR ASSURING DATA STORAGE SECURITY IN CLOUD COMPUTING

A MECHANICS FOR ASSURING DATA STORAGE SECURITY IN CLOUD COMPUTING A MECHANICS FOR ASSURING DATA STORAGE SECURITY IN CLOUD COMPUTING 1, 2 Pratibha Gangwar, 3 Mamta Gadoria 1 M. Tech. Scholar, Jayoti Vidyapeeth Women s University, Jaipur, priya25mehta@gmail.com 2 M. Tech.

More information

On the Interaction and Competition among Internet Service Providers

On the Interaction and Competition among Internet Service Providers On the Interaction and Competition among Internet Service Providers Sam C.M. Lee John C.S. Lui + Abstract The current Internet architecture comprises of different privately owned Internet service providers

More information

COM 332 Interpersonal Communication Course Credit: 3 Hours

COM 332 Interpersonal Communication Course Credit: 3 Hours COM 332 Interpersonal Communication Course Credit: 3 Hours I. TC/TGS Catalog Course Description An examination of interpersonal communication theories and the application of those theories to specific

More information