Fault Characteristics in Electrical Equipment
|
|
- Erica Simon
- 8 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 1. Introduction Proper design and installation of electrical equipment minimizes the chance of electrical faults. Faults occur when the insulation system is compromised and current is allowed to flow through an unintentional path. IEEE Std 493 Recommended Practice for the Design of Reliable Industrial and Commercial Power Systems 1 publishes data that reports that the vast majority of faults are classified as line-toground, or more simply ground faults. Industry data collected from published reports indicates that many faults are low level [1][2][3][4] [5][6][7][8][9]. Those reports describe equipment meltdown when the faults were not cleared by the overcurrent device in a timely manner. The reason that a low level ground fault can burn down a power distribution board while typically a phase-to-phase fault does not is that, counterintuitively, a low-current fault can release far more energy than can a high current fault. The reason is that for most overcurrent protective devices, lower level faults require more time to clear. As will be shown later, this slower clearing time causes much more energy to be released. This situation is particularly dangerous for ground faults as a ground fault has the potential to be a low-current fault. While ungrounded distribution systems would reduce the likelihood of a ground fault, ungrounded systems are almost never recommended due to the potential for damaging high line-to-ground voltages that can occur during intermittent ground faults [10]. 2. Published IEEE Ground Fault Failure Data Electrical equipment is very reliable. Even when looking at the systems that are not maintained or installed properly, failure rates for devices are typically fractions of 1% 2. However, should a work tool be dropped or an accidental short circuit occur, a fault may result. Faults that involve a ground path back to the source are called ground faults. IEEE Std 493 examined the total number of faults that occurred over a sample of equipment, and compared the quantity of those involving ground with those that didn t and calculated a percentage of each type of fault relative to the total. Table 1. Data Extracted from IEEE Std Table a b c Table 1 is a subset of Table from IEEE Std It shows those types of circuit elements that involve cable conductors. Focusing on the bottom section of this table (labeled Failure Type) for a moment, and using the Cable column as an example, note that 73% (marked with a a in Table 1) of all cable failures involve arcing faults to ground, 1% (marked b) involve arcing faults that don t involve ground, and the remaining 26% (marked c) don t involve an arcing fault 3. Focusing only on the arcing failures that involve a fault, we see that out of the 74% percent (73+1 out of 100) of failures that involve a fault, 99% (73 divided by 74 rounded up) involved ground. The remaining 1% (1 divided by 73%) did not. 1 Also known as the Gold Book. See reference [6] at end of paper. 2 IEEE Std Table 10-2 describes the expected failure rate of all electrical devices surveyed. 3 An example of a failure that does not involve a arcing fault would be a cable break (e.g. continuity failure) where neither of the two ends of the break touched an energized or, in the case of a loose energized conductor, grounded conductor. If no current flows after the failure, it is not considered a fault. Another type of fault would be a wiring error where conductors are accidentally wired as a short circuit. Such a fault does not involve arcing.
2 This IEEE 493 standard is stating that for a cable, it is nearly 100 times more likely (99% divided by 1%) for a cable fault to be a ground fault versus a fault not involving ground. From an analysis of the physical properties of how a cable fails this would seem to make sense. After all, a ground fault only requires one conductor s insulation to fail, while a phase-to-phase fault would require insulation to fail on two separate conductors at the same time. 3. Published Equipment Meltdown Reports Many authors [1][2][3][4][5] have reported electrical equipment being destroyed by persistent arcing faults. In each case, the reason for the extended clearing time was that the amount of current flowing was substantially less than bolted fault levels. Overcurrent protective devices like fuses and circuit breakers are designed to operate quickly at 3-phase bolted fault levels. Due to the inverse time current characteristics of these devices, they do not respond as quickly at reduced current levels. In the case of the melt-down, the fuse or circuit breaker did not malfunction. Rather the fault current was too low to clear the fuses or operate the breaker quickly enough to reduce the I2t energy to a sufficiently low level. It is a common misperception that low current faults release less energy than high current faults. In particular with fuses and to a lesser extent with circuit breakers, the exact opposite is true. So how much current flows during a ground fault? In section of IEEE Std 1584 [12], the authors explain that arcing currents, in general, are very difficult to predict. In lab testing the authors stated that for one test point the calculated current was between 45% and 50% higher than the measured arc current (emphasis added). In other words, the actual current was only ½ what was expected. This was for phase-to-phase fault with known circuit path impedance under controlled laboratory conditions! While not tested by the 1584 team, single-phase ground faults compound the uncertainty since with a ground fault, the current flows through other than phase conductors with known impedance. Ground impedance may include enclosure metal, ground bar 1, conduit or other material, much having a higher impedance than the phase conductors. The problem is that since current limiting fuses have a very steep time current curve, any reduction in the magnitude of current results in an increased clearing time 2, with typically the time increasing proportional to the reduction of current raised to the fourth power (I 4 ). In the example shown in Figure 1, reducing the current by one-half from 9000A, (i.e. 15x rating) to 4500A (7.5x rating) flowing through a 600A RK-1 fuse increases the clearing time by 25 times (0.5 s from 0.02 s). Figure 1 current = 2x decrease causes a time = 25x increase If we change the current by a factor of two, to what exponent must you raise that value to obtain a change of 25? Mathematically: 2 x = 25? To solve this equation for the unknown x, we take the logarithm base 2 of each side of the equation. Since most scientific calculators only include log base 10 and base e (ln), we must convert a logarithm from one base to another: log b (x)= (x) Eq. (1) (b) So starting with 2 x = 25 and taking the log base 2 of each side we have: log 2 (2 x )= log 2 (25), simplifies to x = (25) = = 4.64 (2) In other words, = 25, or the increase in clearing time is inversely proportional to the change in current raised to the 4.64 power. As can be seen, clearing time for a fuse increases rapidly as fault current drops. 1 The National Electrical Code (NEC) does not require that ground conductors be sized as large as phase conductors. 2 For circuit breakers, the current reduction would need to drop below the instantaneous pick up before the clearing time increases. 2
3 White Paper TP E How does this affect energy flowing through the fuse; the i 2 t? Since incident energy is proportional ( ) to current squared times time (i.e. I 2 t), a reduction in current reduces the energy by the square, but increases the time by the 4.64 power. Energy 9000A I 2 t = K (0.02) = 1.62x10 6. K amp 2 -seconds Energy 4500A I 2 t = K (0.5) = 1.01x10 7. K amp 2 -seconds 1.62x10 7. K = x10 6. K The result is that the energy increases by a factor of 6.25 times as the fault current magnitude is halved. What exponent describes this equation? 2 x = 6.25, x =? log 2 (2 x ) = log 2 (6.25) x = (6.25) = = 2.64 (2) Therefore, = 6.25 Eq. (2) Notice that the exponent for the change in energy (2.64) is exactly 2 less than the exponent for the magnitude of the current change (4.64). Why? From the equation E i 2 t it is clear that if the current is reduced, the energy contributed by the current is reduced by the square (i2). Likewise, as we ve just calculated, if decreasing the current increases the clearing time proportional to the 4.64 power, then the net result is the energy decreases by the square while simultaneously increasing by the 4.64 power or ( ) = Current Limiting versus Non-Current Limiting Does this increase only occur with current limiting fuses, and more specifically, only when the current-limiting fuse is operating in the current limiting region of the time overcurrent curve? No. Consider the non-current limiting region in Figure 2 bounded by the two current values of 4500A (7.5 times 600A) and 1000A (1.67 times 600A). For a current ratio change of 4.5 (4500A/1000A), the time changes by 1000x (500s/0.5s). As before, we solve the exponential equation as: 4.5 x = 1000 with x =? Transforming the logarithm base using Eq. (1): log 4.5 (x) = Solve for x: (x) (4.5) log 4.5 (4.5 x ) = log 4.5 (1000) or x = log (1000) 3 10 = (4.5) = 4.59 Calculating the change in energy at the two clearing times: Energy 4500A I 2 t = K (0.5) = 1.01x10 7. K amp 2 -seconds Energy 1000A I 2 t = K (500) = 5x10 8. K amp 2 -seconds When taking the ratio of the two energy values at the two current levels, the energy released at the 1000A current level versus the 4500A level was: 5x10 8. K 1.01x10 7. K = 49.5 times higher incident energy! 4.5 x = 49.5, x =? log 4.5 (2 x ) = log 4.5 (6.25) x = log (49.4) = (4.5) = 2.59 Eq. (3) Therefore, = 49.5 In other words, incident energy increased by a value proportional to the ratio of the current change raised to the 2.59 power even when not in the current limiting region of the fuse! Clearly it doesn t matter whether fuses are operating in the current limiting or non-current limiting region. In both cases reducing current flowing through the fuse increases energy released through the fuse 3. Figure 2 3 As mentioned earlier, this does not occur in circuit breakers until the fault current drops below the instantaneous pickup of the circuit breaker. Therefore, in non-current-limiting breakers, the incident energy reduces as the fault current reduces. In current-limiting circuit breakers, the incident energy remains constant as the fault current reduces. 3
4 4. Supplemental Ground Fault Protection Since these lower current faults take so long to clear, thus releasing increased incident energy, adding ground fault protection might seem to be an appropriate method to help reduce clearing time and therefore lower incident energy. One issue to remember is that ground fault provisions added to a fuse protected system require that the ground fault open a device in series with the fuse. This is usually the disconnect switch immediately upstream from the fuse and packaged as a complete switch and fuse combination. The problem is that the interrupting rating of the switch in series is almost always lower than the interrupting rating of the fuse. This isn t a problem since normally the switch relies on the fuse to clear any fault that exceeds the interrupting rating of the switch. A particular problem occurs if a ground fault relay attempts to open a switch while the current flowing through the switch is above the interrupting rating of the switch and simultaneously the fuse is sized such that it s clearing time is slower than the switch s opening time. Attempting to clear such a fault would likely result in the destruction of the switch, likely with significant collateral damage. Typical solutions to this problem have been either to include a highcurrent inhibit (also called Class II ground fault protection) or to add a time delay to the GF tripping. We examine each of these methods and the problems with both. If the ground fault exceeded 1413 amperes, the GF relay would be inhibited from sending a trip signal and the fuse would have to clear the fault. Referring to Figure 3, a current of 1413 amperes flowing through this 600A RK-1 fuse would result in a clearing time somewhere between 19 and 50 seconds. As shown in Eq. (2) and Eq. (3), incident energy increases by the ratio of current raised to the 2.5 power GF High Current Inhibit Be careful when selecting a Class II ground fault relay, since many are designed to be applied with motor contactors. Motor contactors have very low interrupting ratings, so many Class II relays have very low inhibit levels. As an example Table 2, shows available models from a particular vendor s Class II ground fault relay family. Choosing a GF relay for a Size 5 starter, for example operating at 208V, we see that this relay would not send a ground fault signal for any current that exceeded 1413A. Table 2. Typical Class II GF Relay Family Figure 3 So, if arc flash incident energy calculations are evaluated using higher current values (assume 20,000 amps will flow in a phase fault), then if only 1413 amperes were to flow during a ground fault, then these equations imply that you might well see incident energy values of: ( ) = = 753 times higher! 1413 If we applied a 125 HP, 208V, 3-phase motor to a fused switch protected by this GF relay combination, the motor would consume 342 amperes full load. Using Table from the National Electrical code, this motor could not use a time-delay fuse larger than 175% of this value, or 600A. If the ground fault current did not exceed 1413 amperes, the GF relay would trip the stored energy switch or motor starter instantaneously, clearing the fault quickly and reducing incident energy GF Time Delay To get around the problem of the switch opening before the fuse has enough time to clear a fault, some engineers have added time delay to the ground fault relay. If the delay is enough to allow the fuse to operate faster than the relay for any current value above the switch interrupting rating, the fuse will always operate first. A typical delay is 0.1 seconds (6-cycles). The problem identified was that prior to the end of this 6-cycle delay, an arc may have propagated from a ground fault into a phase fault. At this point, the currents are again balanced and the ground fault relay would believe that the ground fault has disappeared even though an arc flash event continues. In the Malmedal [1] example, the phase-to-phase arcing current was calculated to equal only 29% of available fault current and the installed fuse needed over 2 minutes to clear the fault. 4
5 White Paper TP E Unfortunately, today, the IEEE-1584 equations do not calculate the additional energy released from the single-phase, lower-current fault, prior to the escalation into a 3-phase fault. As pointed out in [8], this can result in a substantial underestimation in incident energy. As a result, Malmedal [1] recommends against adding time delay to ground fault relays protecting fuses. Note that this problem of slow clearing time is not a problem with circuit breakers, since unlike a switch and fuse, the contacts of a breaker are rated for the full interruption rating of the breaker. As a result, these contacts do not require any intentional delay when clearing a ground fault. Consequently, a circuit breaker can be programmed to clear a ground fault faster than a fused switch equipped with ground fault protection. This faster clearing time by the circuit breaker for these lower current faults results in lower incident energy released. Another feature of many ground fault equipped circuit breakers is the inclusion of zone selective interlocking (ZSI). Circuit breakers can be provided with zone selective interlocking (ZSI) to remove the intentionally delay normally added to the upstream clearing time. As shown in Figure 4, when a fault is detected downstream of two selectively coordinated breakers, the breaker closest to the fault should clear the fault first. That means the upstream breaker should delay just enough time to maintain selective coordination with the downstream breaker. What is different in a ZSI scheme is that the downstream breaker sends an inhibit signal to the upstream breaker, confirming to the upstream breaker that the downstream breaker does indeed see the fault and will clear the fault. Figure 4 However, if as shown in Figure 5, the fault occurs between the two breakers, the upstream does not receive a ZSI inhibit signal from the downstream breaker because the downstream breaker does not have fault current flowing through it. Without the ZSI inhibit signal, the upstream breaker reprograms itself to remove all intentional delays, thus clearing the fault faster. ZSI has been shown to be so effective that a new Section has been added to the 2011 version of the National Electrical Code [13] that now requires ZSI or equivalent protection for any circuit breaker that includes intentional tripping delay [14][15]. 5. Statistical Evidence of Low Level Ground Faults Eaton molded case circuit breakers include a built-in method of detecting if a single phase fault exceeds 10 ka. Evidence that a single phase fault exceeded 10 ka is evident should that circuit breaker ever be returned to the factory for testing. Over the 30 plus years this method has been included, next to none of the breakers returned for analysis show this evidence. This would imply that nearly all single phase (i.e. ground) faults are faults of less than 10 ka. Therefore, to better understand the risk your personnel face, it is suggested that a minimum arcing fault current be calculated. Measure resistance between a point on enclosure sheet steel to ground bond. Since bonding impedances may be in the 0.1 ohm range, a line to ground fault on a 277 or 347 line-to-neutral may only result in 2770 or 3470 amperes of fault currents. These low levels of fault current may result in extended clearing times and high levels of arc flash incident energy. 6. Summary Based on data from IEEE Std as well as common sense, ground faults are substantially more common than phase-to-phase faults. Since ground current flows, by definition, through conductors other than expected current carrying conductors, the impedance of those conductors is unknown. Eaton s own statistical evidence from warranty and repair records lends evidence to this conclusion. The problem is that many authors report that low-level ground faults failed to be cleared by conventional overcurrent protection quickly enough to save the equipment from substantial damage. While ground fault protection can be added to some fused switches, problems have been reported due to the required intentional delay that must be added and/or with coordinating Class II ground fault relay to insure that the switch opens only during times when low (or no) current is flowing. Circuit breakers do not require this intentional ground fault delay and therefore can clear a fault more quickly reducing incident energy below the incident energy released when the same circuit is protected by a fuse, whether current limiting or not. Remember, fuses work better at higher current levels. Low level faults cause problems for fuses. As this paper and IEEE [16] has shown, most low voltage fault magnitudes are below the current limiting range of a fuse. Depending on the range of your selected overcurrent device, this may result in extended clearing time and excessive arc flash incident energy. Ground fault sensing with instantaneous clearing and ZSI is recommended to mitigate these high incident energy levels. Figure 5 Since time delay is always required on an upstream breaker, any system with two or more levels of ground fault protection will have mandatory time delay on the upstream breaker. Because of this requirement, it is very important to insure that any ZSI system selected reduces the clearing time of the upstream breaker to sufficient fast clearing times (<80 ms). 5
6 7. References [1] K. Malmedal, P.K. Sen, Arcing fault currents and the criteria for setting ground fault relays in solidly-grounded low voltage systems, Industrial and Commercial Power Systems Technical Conference, 2000, Conference Record, Annual Meeting, Issue 2000, pp [2] H. Bruce Land III, The Behavior of Arcing Faults in Low- Voltage Switchboards, IEEE Transactions on Industry Applications, Vol. 44, No. 2, March-April 2008, pp [3] R. Doughty, T. Neal, T. Macalady, V. Saporita, K. Borgwald, The use of low-voltage current-limiting fuses to reduce arcflash energy, IEEE Transactions on Industry Applications, Vol. 36, Issue 6, Nov-Dec 2000, pp [4] H. Bruce Land III, Determination of the Cause of Arcing Faults in Low-Voltage Switchboards, IEEE Transactions on Industry Applications, Vol. 44, No. 2, March-April 2008, pp [5] J.G.J. Sloot, R.J. Ritsma, Protection against fault arcs in low voltage distribution boards, Eindhoven University of Technology, Netherlands, Protection-against-fault-arcs.pdf. [6] IEEE Recommended Practice for Electric Power Distribution for Industrial Plants, IEEE Std , Approved December 2, [7] H. Stanback, Predicting Damage from 277-V Single Phase to Ground Arcing Faults, IEEE Transactions on Industry Applications, Vol. IA-13, Issue 4, Jul 1977, pp [8] D. G. Loucks, Calculating Incident Energy Released With Varying Ground Fault Magnitudes on Solidly Grounded Systems, IEEE Transactions on Industry Applications, Vol. 46, Issue 2, 14 Jan 2010, pp [9] G. Parise, et. al., Arcing Fault in Sub-Distribution Branch- Circuits, IEEE Transactions on Power Delivery, Vol. 8, No. 2, April 1993, pp [10] D.G. Loucks, Transient Overvoltages on Ungrounded Systems from Intermittent Ground Faults, Eaton Application Note, download from: [11] Design of Reliable Industrial and Commercial Power Systems, IEEE Standard 493, Approved 7 February [12] IEEE , IEEE Guide for Performing Arc-Flash Hazard Calculations [13] NPFA 70, National Electrical Code, 2011, National Fire Protection Association. [14] Eaton Code Breaker 2011, NEC Arc Flash Reduction Requirement, pub/@electrical/documents/content/pa e.pdf [15] Eaton, Arc Flash Energy Reduction Techniques Energy- Reducing Maintenance Switching, ecm/groups/public/@pub/@electrical/documents/content/ tp e.pdf [16] T. Papallo, M. Valdes, G. Roscoe, Predicting Let-Through Arc-Flash Energy for Current Limiting Circuit Breakers, IEEE Transactions on Industry Applications, Vol. 46, Issue 5, 16 September 2010, pp Eaton Corporation Electrical Sector 1000 Cherrington Parkway Moon Township, PA United States 877-ETN-CARE ( ) Eaton.com 2011 Eaton Corporation All Rights Reserved Printed in USA TP E / TN September 2011 Eaton is a registered trademark of Eaton Corporation. All other trademarks are property of their respective owners.
PRESENTED AT THE 2011 IEEE IAS PULP & PAPER INDUSTRY TECHNICAL CONFERENCE, NASHVILLE, TN: IEEE 2011 - PERSONAL USE OF THIS MATERIAL IS PERMITTED.
Arc Flash Energy Reduction Techniques Zone Selective Interlocking & Energy-Reducing Maintenance Switching Christopher G. Walker Senior Member, IEEE Eaton Corporation Moon Township, PA 15108 chrisgwalker@eaton.com
More informationSafety By Design. Strategies for Electrical Contractors
Safety By Design Strategies for Electrical Contractors Introduction Engineering and system design significantly impact worker safety System design provides opportunity to eliminate/minimize workers exposure
More informationChoosing the Best Solution for Reducing Arc Energy
CONVENTION SESSION HANDOUT Choosing the Best Solution for Reducing Arc Energy Terry L. Schiazza, Business Development Manager Square D / Schneider Electric SESSION #11 Independent Electrical Contractors
More informationArc Flash Safety in 400V Data Centers
Arc Flash Safety in 400V Data Centers Strategies for protecting employees from underappreciated yet potentially deadly hazards By Dave G. Loucks PCM Solution Manager Eaton Corporation Executive summary
More informationHAZARDS, INCLUDING SHOCK, ARC FLASH AND FIRE
Appendix B-2 - Electrical Safety In Design Final Report TECHNOLOGIES THAT REDUCE LIKELIHOOD OF INJURY FROM ELECTRICAL HAZARDS, INCLUDING SHOCK, ARC FLASH AND FIRE The following are technologies that reduce
More informationEngineering Series Ratings: Is It Practical?
Engineering Series Ratings: Is It Practical? By the National Electrical Manufacturers Association The 2005 National Electrical Code (NEC) introduces a change regarding series ratings for circuit breakers
More informationShort Circuit Current Calculations
Introduction Several sections of the National Electrical Code relate to proper overcurrent protection. Safe and reliable application of overcurrent protective devices based on these sections mandate that
More informationHow to reduce exposure to arc flash hazards
GE Energy Industrial Solutions How to reduce exposure to arc flash hazards Multiple solutions for new and existing facilities imagination at work Multiple Issues Today s power system engineer must not
More informationMitigation of Arc-Flash Hazards and Reduction of Costs by Selective Arc-Flash Protection
Mitigation of Arc-Flash Hazards and Reduction of Costs by Selective Arc-Flash Protection L. Kumpulainen, S. Dahl J. Ma Vamp Ltd, Finland Vamp Ltd, China 1 ABSTRACT This paper describes causes and characteristics
More informationCONDUCTOR SHORT-CIRCUIT PROTECTION
CONDUCTOR SHORT-CIRCUIT PROTECTION Introduction: This paper analyzes the protection of wire from fault currents. It gives the specifier the necessary information regarding the short-circuit current rating
More informationArc Flash Hazards. Electrical Hazards. Dan Neeser Field Application Engineer DanRNeeser@Eaton.com. Electrical Hazards 2/18/2015. Shock.
Arc Flash Hazards Dan Neeser Field Application Engineer DanRNeeser@Eaton.com Electrical Hazards Electrical Hazards Shock Arc Flash Arc Blast 2 1 Arcing Fault Basics 35,000 F Radiant Heat & UV Speed of
More informationmisconceptions about arc-flash hazard assessments
misconceptions about arc-flash hazard assessments There are some common misconceptions about Arc-Flash Hazard Assessments which reduce the effectiveness of the Assessments and can increase electrical hazards.
More informationGuidelines on the Short Circuit Current Rating for Industrial Control Panels
usa.siemens.com/sccr Guidelines on the Short Circuit Current Rating for Industrial Control Panels Technical Paper for Practical Applications White Paper I October 2014 As per NEC Edition 2014, and UL508A
More informationArc Flash Mitigation & Selective Co-ordination
Arc Flash Mitigation & Selective Co-ordination Michael Hodder March 2015 Overview This seminar will provide information on: Mitigating arc flash hazards Selective Coordination What can we do to make these
More informationNew standardized approach to arc flash protection
New standardized approach to arc flash protection Samuel Dahl Juha Arvola Tero Virtala Arcteq Relays Ltd Arcteq Relays Ltd Arcteq Relays Ltd Wolffintie 36 F 11 Wolffintie 36 F 11 Wolffintie 36 F11 65200
More informationAlternate Methods to Short Circuit Breaker Coordination
Alternate Methods to Short Circuit Breaker Coordination Nguyen Perez, PE Senior Electrical Engineer 2600 Douglas Road, Suite 301 Coral Gables, Florida 305.529.1515 (p) www.brplusa.com Importance in Healthcare
More informationCIRCUIT BREAKER INTERRUPTING CAPACITY AND SHORT-TIME CURRENT RATINGS
CIRCUIT BREAKER INTERRUPTING CAPACITY AND SHORT-TIME CURRENT RATINGS David D. Roybal, P.E. Senior Member, IEEE Eaton Electrical 3697 Mount Diablo Boulevard Lafayette, CA 94549 Abstract Low-voltage circuit
More informationElectrical Grounding. Appendix C
Appendix C Electrical Grounding Low-Voltage Equipment Grounding The most frequently cited Office of Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) electrical violation is improper occupational grounding of equipment
More informationElectronic Trip Circuit Breaker Basics Circuit Breaker Application Guide Class 0600
Electronic Trip Circuit Breaker Basics Circuit Breaker Application Guide Class 0600 Data Bulletin 0600DB1104 03/2012 Retain for future use. Electronic Trip Circuit Breaker Basics 0600DB1104 Table of Contents
More informationApplication of Four-Pole Circuit Breakers within Data Centers
Application of Four-Pole Circuit Breakers within Data Centers December 2013/AT324 by Frank Waterer, Fellow Engineer, Schneider Electric Engineering Services Make the most of your energy SM Revision #1
More informationFortune Oregon Data Center Increases Reliability with a High Resistance Grounding System
Fortune Oregon Data Center Increases Reliability with a High Resistance Grounding System Cory David Smith, Project Manager, ECOM Engineering Inc., and David Lawrence Smith, Principal, ECOM Engineering
More informationArc Flash Energy Mitigation Techniques
Arc Flash Energy Mitigation Techniques When short circuits occur on an electrical distribution system, an arc flash event usually forms. These arc flash events can cause dangerous and potentially fatal
More informationReverse-feed applications for circuit breakers
Technical Publication PU01200001E Contents Description Page Intoduction.......................................................................... 2 breaker classifications..........................................................
More informationCorner-Grounded Delta (Grounded B Phase) Systems
Data Bulletin 2700DB0202R03/12 09/2012 Replaces 2700DB0202R2/09 dated 02/2009 Corner-Grounded Delta (Grounded B Phase) Systems Class 2700 Retain for future use. Introduction Corner-grounded delta systems
More informationIntegrating SPDs in Switchgear & Switchboards Causes More Problems than it Solves
Integrating SPDs in Switchgear & Switchboards Causes More Problems than it Solves White Paper July 2010 Integrating surge protective devices (SPD) into distribution equipment (i.e. switchgear, switchboards,
More informationSelecting Current Transformers Part 1 By Darrell G. Broussard, P.E.
By Darrell G. Broussard, P.E. Introduction: As engineers, we are aware that electrical power systems have grown. How much have they grown? When was the last time you specified a 2400-volt system, a 4160-volt
More informationSPECIAL TOPICS ON GROUND FAULT PROTECTION AND PROTECTION COORDINATION IN INDUSTRIAL AND COMMERCIAL POWER SYSTEMS
SPECIAL TOPICS ON GROUND FAULT PROTECTION AND PROTECTION COORDINATION IN INDUSTRIAL AND COMMERCIAL POWER SYSTEMS Claudio S. Mardegan claudio.mardegan@engepower.com www.engepower.com Phone: 55 3579-8777
More informationA Guide to Performing An Arc Flash Hazard Assessment Using Power Analysis Software
A Guide to Performing An Arc Flash Hazard Assessment Using Power Analysis Software Abstract: The nature of explosive equipment failures, and the rate of serious burn injuries in the electrical industry
More informationEngineering innovation
Eaton's Electrical Engineering Services & Systems Solutions Focus Seamless Solutions for Reliable, Efficient and Safe Power Systems Engineering innovation Progressive solutions for today s power systems
More informationARC FLASH CALCULATIONS & LABELING REQUIREMENTS
ARC FLASH CALCULATIONS & LABELING REQUIREMENTS Presented by: Edmund Elizalde EYP Mission Critical Facilities, Inc. Slides by: Lonnie Lindell SKM Systems Analysis, Inc. 1 Agenda NEC 110.16 NFPA 70E IEEE
More informationHow Much Voltage Drop Is Acceptable?
How Much Voltage Drop Is Acceptable? Article supplied by Ideal The National Electrical Code (NEC) recommends that the combined voltage drop of the electrical system (branch circuit and feeders) not exceed
More informationPREFACE. Your comments or suggestions are welcome and appreciated. They should be sent to:
PREFACE UL developed the Dead-Front Switchboard Marking Guide for code authorities, electric utilities, contractors, installers, users, designers, and other interested parties to aid in understanding deadfront
More informationSimplified Guide To Understanding Short-Circuit Current Rating FIND IT, FIX IT, FORGET IT
Simplified Guide To Understanding Short-Circuit Current Rating FIND IT, FIX IT, FORGET IT Are You Ready For The New SCCR Marking Requirements? What Is A Short-Circuit Current Rating (SCCR)? SCCRs on components
More informationUnderstanding Arc Flash
Understanding Arc Flash Presented by Eddie F. Jones, PE 1 2 3 4 5 Five to 10 arc flash explosions occur in electric equipment every day in the United States. This number does not include cases in which
More informationELECTRICAL CIRCUITS. Electrical Circuits
Electrical Circuits A complete path, or circuit, is needed before voltage can cause a current flow through resistances to perform work. There are several types of circuits, but all require the same basic
More informationPart 1 System Modeling & Studies for Existing Systems
Part 1 System Modeling & Studies for Existing Systems Operation Technology, Inc. Copyright 2009 Result of rapid release of energy due to an arcing fault between two conductors. Bus voltages > 208V Temperatures
More informationMission Critical Data Center Systems
Mission Critical Systems Mission Critical/ Electrical Distribution Systems Data center electrical distribution designs are rapidly evolving, driven by needs such as increasing power densities, energy efficiency,
More informationElectrical Resistance Resistance (R)
Electrical Resistance Resistance (R) Any device in a circuit which converts electrical energy into some other form impedes the current. The device which converts electrical energy to heat energy is termed
More informationASK THE EXPERTS. Resistance Grounding Q&A. with industry experts
ASK THE EXPERTS Resistance Grounding Q&A with industry experts system grounding system grounding system grounding system grounding system grounding System Grounding Definition and Different Types What
More informationAtlanta Chapter IEEE Industry Applications Society
Atlanta Chapter IEEE Industry Applications Society Electrical Equipment Room Design Considerations presented at the Sheraton Buckhead Hotel Atlanta, Georgia November 20, 2006 Outline 1. Definitions 2.
More informationArc Flash Mitigation. Executive summary. by Antony Parsons, Ph.D., P.E.
by Antony Parsons, Ph.D., P.E. Executive summary Arc flash events can result in significant injury to workers, including severe burn injuries. The most effective arc flash safety programs are not those
More informationUL 508A Industrial Control Panels Power Distribution and Control. Lunch & Learn Training. 2002 Eaton Corporation. All rights reserved.
UL 508A Industrial Control Panels Power Distribution and Control Lunch & Learn Training 2002 Eaton Corporation. All rights reserved. Agenda Who is UL and what role do they play? What is the UL 508A Standard?
More informationTechnical Guide. SKM Arc Flash Line Side vs. Load Side
SKM Arc Flash Line vs. Load The option of choosing the line-side or the load-side arc flash incident energy for arc flash labels is an important decision when performing an arc flash hazard analysis. When
More informationARC FLASH HAZARD MITIGATION. Industrial Tests, Inc. [indtests.com]
ARC FLASH HAZARD MITIGATION ARC FLASH HAZARD MITIGATION NWHA TECHNICAL SEMINAR May 17, 2012 Richard D Reese Power Systems Manager Industrial Tests, Inc. Rocklin, California [Dick@indtests.com; 916-660-2837]
More informationLow Voltage Switchgear
Arc Resistant Switchgear n Insulated and isolated bus n Separation barriers and top venting n Breaker shutters 12 SWITCHGEAR Arc resistant metal-enclosed low voltage switchgear is an optional product offering
More informationSwitchgear and Metal-Enclosed Bus
Section 18 Switchgear and Metal-Enclosed Bus 180. SWITCHGEAR ASSEMBLIES 180A. General Requirements for All Switchgear. This rule covers general requirements for all switchgear. Examples of switchgear found
More informationBypass transfer switch mechanisms
Power topic #6013 Technical information from Cummins Power Generation transfer switch mechanisms > White paper By Gary Olson, Director, Power Systems Development This paper describes the configuration
More informationA Survey of Arc Flash Computation Methods and Mitigation Strategies By Dr. Carl J. Spezia
Volume 26, Number 2 - April 20 through June 20 A Survey of Arc Flash Computation Methods and Mitigation Strategies By Dr. Carl J. Spezia Peer-Refereed Perspective Papers Keyword Search Electricity Energy
More informationGround Fault Protection on Ungrounded and High Resistance Grounded Systems
> the power to protect Ground Fault Protection on Ungrounded and High Resistance Grounded Systems Application Guide www.i-gard.com table of contents SUBJECT PAGE 1. Introduction...1 2. Ungrounded Systems...1
More informationWhat Are the Qualifications to Conduct Arc Flash Studies? Where Do You Begin?
What Are the Qualifications to Conduct Arc Flash Studies? Where Do You Begin? Comparing apples-to-apples bids Plant Services Special Report A shock hazard analysis should be included as part of an arc
More informationA USERS GUIDE TO ARC RESISTANT LOW VOLTAGE SWITCHGEAR & MOTOR CONTROL ANALYTICAL COMPARISON VS ARC FLASH TEST RESULTS
A USERS GUIDE TO ARC RESISTANT LOW VOLTAGE SWITCHGEAR & MOTOR CONTROL ANALYTICAL COMPARISON VS ARC FLASH TEST RESULTS By: Gabriel Arce, ABB, San Luis Potosi, Mexico Casey McCollum, ABB, Houston, TX John
More informationFusible Disconnect Switch
Circuit Breakers Circuit breakers are used in panelboards and switchboards to provide circuit protection and provide a means of energizing and de-energizing a circuit. Siemens Sentron molded case circuit
More informationArc Flash Mitigation. Remote Racking and Switching for Arc Flash danger mitigation in distribution class switchgear.
Arc Flash Mitigation Remote Racking and Switching for Arc Flash danger mitigation in distribution class switchgear. Distance is Safety We will discuss through examples of actual occurrences and possible
More informationIRRIGATION PUMPING Table of Contents - Section 900
IRRIGATION PUMPING Table of Contents - Section 900 PARAGRAPH 900.1 GENERAL 1 900.2 METERING REQUIREMENTS 1 900.3 CUSTOMER S CONTROL EQUIPMENT 2 900.4 SERVICE CONDUCTOR REQUIREMENTS 2 900.5 RECOMMENDATIONS
More informationMotor Protection Voltage Unbalance and Single-Phasing
Motor Protection Voltage Unbalance and Single-Phasing Cooper Bussmann contributes the following information, which is an excerpt from their 190-page handbook SPD Selecting Protective Devices Based on the
More informationModern Power Distribution Systems
Modern Power Distribution Systems geindustrial.com Modern Business Runs on 24/7 Power Distribution Historically, engineers and architects have had to approach building design with the assumption that they
More informationGrounding of AC generators and switching the neutral in emergency and standby power systems
Power topic #6006 Part 2 of 2 Technical information from Cummins Power eneration rounding of AC generators and switching the neutral in emergency and standby power systems > White paper By Lawrence A.
More informationProper Application of 415V Systems in North American Data Centers. A White Paper from the Experts in Business-Critical Continuity
Proper Application of 415V Systems in North American Data Centers A White Paper from the Experts in Business-Critical Continuity Introduction Increasing pressure to reduce operating expenses and be more
More informationOPTIMIZING POWER SYSTEM PROTECTION FOR MODERN DATA CENTERS
OPTIMIZING POWER SYSTEM PROTECTION FOR MODERN DATA CENTERS Data center power systems are constructed with a premium on reliability at a significant cost. The return on this investment is realized if it
More informationIMPROVING SELECTIVITY & ARC-FLASH PROTECTION THROUGH OPTIMIZED INSTANTANEOUS PROTECTION SETTINGS Copyright Material IEEE Paper No.
MPROVNG SELECTVTY & ARC-FLASH PROTECTON THROUGH OPTMZED NSTANTANEOUS PROTECTON SETTNGS Copyright Material EEE Paper No. ESW 2012 EEE. Reprinted, with permission, from authors, Marcelo E. Valdes, Steve
More informationPrimary and Secondary Electrical Distribution Systems
Primary and Secondary Electrical Distribution Systems Critical Facilities Round Table 12th Quarterly Membership Meeting June 2, 2006 David D. Roybal. P.E. Eaton Electrical Cutler-Hammer Products Utility
More information101 BASICS SERIES LEARNING MODULE 3: FUNDAMENTALS OF ELECTRICAL DISTRIBUTION. Cutler-Hammer
101 BASICS SERIES LEARNING MODULE 3: FUNDAMENTALS OF ELECTRICAL DISTRIBUTION Cutler-Hammer WELCOME Welcome to Module 3, Fundamentals of Electrical Distribution. If you have successfully completed Module
More informationManagement Systems 10 Electrical Safety Audit 14 PPE 20 Arc Mitigation 22 Hazard Assessment 26
Management Systems 10 Electrical Safety Audit 14 PPE 20 Arc Mitigation 22 Hazard Assessment 26 Assessing The Hazards Of High and Low Voltage Single-Phase Arc-Flash By Albert Marroquin One common question
More informationCircuit Breakers and Switchgear. Thomas Greer Director of Engineering TLG Services
Circuit Breakers and Switchgear Thomas Greer Director of Engineering TLG Services Presentation Outline Switchgear Definition Overcurrent Protection Devices Circuit Breaker Trip Curves and Coordination
More informationObjectives. Electric Current
Objectives Define electrical current as a rate. Describe what is measured by ammeters and voltmeters. Explain how to connect an ammeter and a voltmeter in an electrical circuit. Explain why electrons travel
More informationUnified requirements for systems with voltages above 1 kv up to 15 kv
(1991) (Rev.1 May 2001) (Rev.2 July 2003) (Rev.3 Feb 2015) Unified requirements for systems with voltages above 1 kv up to 15 kv 1. General 1.1 Field of application The following requirements apply to
More informationOvercurrent Protection
Overcurrent Protection Data Bulletin 0600DB0301 R03/12, 03/2012 0600DB0301 R03/12, 03/2012 Overcurrent Protection Table of Contents Table of Contents Section 1: Overcurrent Protection Fundamentals and
More informationSentron Series Circuit Breakers
Sentron Series Circuit Breakers Siemens Sentron Series circuit breakers are available in nine frame sizes: ED, FD, JD, LD, LMD, MD, ND, PD, and RD. Sentron Series circuit breakers have a wide range of
More informationBRANDON AND CLARK INC. // SCOTT W. CLARK, P.E. ELECTRICAL CONTINUING EDUCATION ARC FLASH - NFPA 70E
BRANDON AND CLARK INC. // SCOTT W. CLARK, P.E. ELECTRICAL CONTINUING EDUCATION ARC FLASH - NFPA 70E Training is not a substitute for following corporate safety guidelines. Always refer to the latest safety
More informationData Bulletin. Circuit Breaker Characteristic Trip Curves and Coordination Class 0600 TRIP CURVES AND COORDINATION CIRCUIT BREAKER TRIP CURVES
Data Bulletin Bulletin No. 000DB0 August 0 Cedar Rapids, IA, USA Class 000 TRIP CURVES AND COORDINATION CIRCUIT BREAKER TRIP CURVES Thermal Tripping Characteristics agnetic Tripping Characteristics A coordination
More informationEvaluating Water-Damaged Electrical Equipment
Evaluating Water-Damaged Electrical www.nema.org Evaluating Water-Damaged Electrical 1 USE OF THIS PUBLICATION This publication provides information on how to evaluate electrical equipment that has been
More informationArc Fault Circuit Interrupters Frequently Asked Questions
Contents My AFCI is tripping! What do I do? What is the difference between branch feeder and combination type Arc Fault Circuit Interrupters? What is new with the 2008 NEC versus the 2005 NEC with respect
More information2004 TRANSMISSION SYSTEMS SEMINAR MEDIUM VOLTAGE, METAL-CLAD ARC RESISTANT SWITCHGEAR: ENHANCING WORKPLACE SAFETY
2004 TRANSMISSION SYSTEMS SEMINAR MEDIUM VOLTAGE, METAL-CLAD ARC RESISTANT SWITCHGEAR: ENHANCING WORKPLACE SAFETY Thomas P. McNamara, P.E. Manager, Development Engineering ABB Inc. Power Technologies Medium
More informationPROTECTION AGAINST ELECTRIC SHOCK by John Ware
16 become live under fault conditions. The potential of the metal enclosure is higher than that of the main earthing terminal of the installation (and that of Earth) because of a potential difference created
More information90.2(A) Covered & 90.2(B) Not Covered 6/23/2015. Learning Objectives. 90.2(A) Covered & 90.2(B) Not Covered. Change Summary
Learning Objectives After reviewing this material, the student will be able to: 1. Identify the installations that fall under the scope of the 2015 edition of NFPA 70E. 2. Identify the assessments required
More informationWhat are the basic electrical safety issues and remedies in solar photovoltaic installations?
What are the basic electrical safety issues and remedies in solar photovoltaic installations? Presented by: Behzad Eghtesady City of Los Angeles Department of Building and Safety Topics Covered Photovoltaic
More informationSTANDARDS AND RATINGS FOR THE APPLICATION OF MOLDED CASE, INSULATED CASE, AND POWER CIRCUIT BREAKERS
STANDARDS AND RATINGS FOR THE APPLICATION OF MOLDED CASE, INSULATED CASE, AND POWER CIRCUIT BREAKERS David D. Roybal, P.E. Senior Member, IEEE Cutler-Hammer, Inc. 3697 Mount Diablo Boulevard Lafayette,
More informationArc Terminator Active Arc-Resistant Switchgear
Arc Terminator Active Arc-Resistant Switchgear Increasing safety and productivity by extinguishing internal arcing faults within the switchgear. The Square D Arc Terminator from Schneider Electric offers
More informationEvaluating Water-Damaged Electrical Equipment
Evaluating Water-Damaged Electrical Equipment 1 USE OF THIS PUBLICATION This publication provides information on how to evaluate electrical equipment that has been exposed to water through flooding, fire
More informationEvaluating Water-Damaged Electrical Equipment
Evaluating Water-Damaged Electrical Equipment 1 USE OF THIS PUBLICATION This publication provides information on how to evaluate electrical equipment that has been exposed to water through flooding, fire
More informationLow Voltage Fuses For Motor Protection
Code Requirements The NEC or CEC requires that motor branch circuits be protected against overloads and short circuits. Overload protection may be provided by fuses, overload relays or motor thermal protectors.
More informationELECTRICAL SAFETY RISK ASSESSMENT
ELECTRICAL SAFETY RISK ASSESSMENT The intent of this procedure is to perform a risk assessment, which includes a review of the electrical hazards, the associated foreseeable tasks, and the protective measures
More informationDC disconnects for solar photovoltaic installations. Connecting the. power of the sun
DC disconnects for solar photovoltaic installations Connecting the power of the sun Solar energy is heating up Interest in renewable energy sources has never been greater, and the fastest growing of these
More informationShort-circuit, Protective Device Coordination & Arc Flash Analysis. By Albert Marroquin Operation Technology, Inc.
Short-circuit, Protective Device Coordination & Arc Flash Analysis By Albert Marroquin Operation Technology, Inc. Agenda Short-circuit Calculations for Arc Flash Analysis Protection and Coordination Principles
More information21 st Century Facilities
Electrical Testing 21 st Century Facilities Facility Owners face tough challenges 24 X 7 reliability needed Non linear loads cause harmonics VFD Computers Switching transients disrupt operations Less customer
More informationNFPA 70E 2012 Rolls Out New Electrical Safety Requirements Affecting Data Centers
NFPA 70E 2012 Rolls Out New Electrical Safety Requirements Affecting Data Centers A market position paper from the experts in Business-Critical Continuity TM Executive Summary Electrocutions are the fourth
More informationIntroduction to Arc Flash
Introduction to Arc Flash Worker Training of Electrical Hazards Including Arc Flash SH-16614-7 This material was produced under grant number SH-16614-7 from the Occupational Safety and Health Administration,
More informationThe Importance of the X/R Ratio in Low-Voltage Short Circuit Studies
The Importance of the X/R Ratio in Low-Voltage Short Circuit Studies DATE: November 17, 1999 REVISION: AUTHOR: John Merrell Introduction In some short circuit studies, the X/R ratio is ignored when comparing
More informationProduct Description Full Voltage Starting Electric Fire Pump Controllers FTA1000
Product Description Full Voltage Starting Electric Fire Pump Controllers FTA1000 Description Firetrol FTA1000 Full Voltage Fire Pump Controllers are intended for use with electric motor driven fi re pumps
More informationAnalyzing Electrical Hazards in the Workplace
Analyzing Electrical Hazards in the Workplace By Dennis K. Neitzel, CPE AVO Training Institute, Inc. The need for analyzing electrical hazards in the workplace has been recognized by a small segment of
More informationProtect your home and family with Advanced Technology from Cutler-Hammer
Protect your home and family with Advanced Technology from Cutler-Hammer Residential Home Fire Statistics Annually - over 415,000 Residential Fires Annually - over 40,000 electrical fires over 350 deaths
More informationEffective July 2015 Supersedes April 2015. Reliability... 4. Selective coordination... 4. Inherent fuse reliability... 4
Application note 10079 Supersedes April 2015 BUSSMANN SERIES Contents Description Page Description Page Background................................ 2 Data center products........................ 6 Energy
More informationECE 586b Course Project Report. Auto-Reclosing
ECE 586b Course Project Report Auto-Reclosing Srichand Injeti May 5, 2008 Department Of Electrical and computer Engineering University Of Western Ontario, London Ontario Table of contents 1. Introduction...1
More informationGrounding and Electrical Safety of Shore Power Supply and DC Stinger System Design
Grounding and Electrical Safety of Shore Power Supply and DC Stinger System Design Dev Paul AECOM 2101 Webster Street, Suite 1900, Oakland, Ca 94612 dev.paul@aecom.com; (510) 419 6448 Abstract: To enhance
More informationExtend the Life of Existing Switchgear
Extend the Life of Existing Switchgear January 2011/1910DB1002 by Hal Theobald, Product Manager Schneider Electric USA, Inc. Make the most of your energy SM Summary Introduction... p 3 Maintenance Requirements...
More information..OR How To Protect your 3-Phase Equipment Investment with 3-Phase Monitors from Time Mark...
..OR How To Protect your 3-Phase Equipment Investment with 3-Phase Monitors from Time Mark... TIME MARK CORPORATION 11440 EAST PINE STREET TULSA, OK 74116 USA tel 918 438-1220 fax 918 437-7584 www.time-mark.com
More informationCommon Electrical Hazards in the Workplace Including Arc Flash. Presented by Ken Cohen, PhD, PE & CIH (Ret.)
Common Electrical Hazards in the Workplace Including Arc Flash Presented by Ken Cohen, PhD, PE & CIH (Ret.) 1 What s New In February 1972, OSHA incorporated the 1971 edition of the National Fire Protection
More informationZONE SELECTIVE INTERLOCKING (ZSI) APPLICATION AND TESTING GUIDE SIEMENS WL UL489 AND UL1066 AIR CIRCUIT BREAKERS
Definition: Zone Selective Interlocking (ZSI) - A method which allows two or more ground fault breakers to communicate with each other so that a short circuit or ground fault will be cleared by the breaker
More informationRISK MITIGATION for ELECTRICAL WORK. Feb 2013 San Diego CA
RISK MITIGATION for ELECTRICAL WORK Feb 2013 San Diego CA Agenda I. RISK Define the Risks Arc Flash Review II. MITIGATION 3 Easy Steps New Designs Vs. Existing Systems III. DUKE UNIVERSITY EXAMPLE I. Risk
More informationThe Application of Circuit Breakers to Reduce Downtime in Datacentres
The Application of Circuit Breakers to Reduce Downtime in Datacentres Tim Campbell BEng MIET. Marketing Manager, Terasaki Electric (Europe) Ltd. Abstract Circuit breakers fulfil several functions in the
More information