Conference Program Programma del Convegno SIXTH INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM ON CATHOLIC SOCIAL THOUGHT AND MANAGEMENT EDUCATION SESTO CONVEGNO INTERNAZIONALE SU PENSIERO SOCIALE CRISTIANO E FORMAZIONE MANAGERIALE The Good Company Dialogo tra Pensiero Sociale Cristiano e responsabilità sociale d impresa Pontificia Università San Tommaso (Angelicum) Roma, Italia October 5-7, 2006 5-7 Ottobre, 2006 www.stthomas.edu/thegoodcompany/ 1
Thursday, October 5 Giovedì 5 Ottobre Registration Angelicum Entrance Opening Mass Church of Sts. Dominic and Sixtus WELCOME 8:00 10:00 11:00 Aula Minor Registrazione dei partecipanti Entrata dell Angelicum Messa d apertura Chiesa di San Domenico e Sisto MESSAGIO DI BENVENUTO Helen Alford, O.P., Conference Co-Chair, Dean of the Faculty of Social Sciences, Pontifical University of St. Thomas (Angelicum) Italy Renato Cardinal Martino, President of the Pontifical Council of Jusice and Peace and of the Pontifical Council for the Pastoral Care of Migrants and Itinerant People, Vatican City OPENING PLENARY (with translation) Setting Up the Dialogue Between CST and CSR Stefano Zamagni, Professor of Economics, University of Bologna, Italy Bruno S. Frey, Professor of Economics, University of Zurich, Switzerland Chair: Francesco Merloni, former President of UCID (Italian section of UNIAPAC) Helen Alford, O.P., Co-reponsabile della conferenza, Preside della Facoltà di Scienze Sociali della Pontificia Università San Tommaso, Italia Cardinale Renato Martino, Presidente del Pontificio Consiglio di Pace e Giustizia e del Pontificio Consiglio della Pastorale per i Migranti e Itineranti, Città del Vaicano PLENARIA D APERTURA (con traduzione) Impostare il Dialogo Tra PSC e RSI Stefano Zamagni, Professore di Economia, Università di Bologna, Italia Bruno S. Frey, Professore di Economia, Università di Zurigo, Svizzera Coordina: Francesco Merloni, ex presidente dell UCID Lunch 13:00 Sala delle Colonne Pranzo 2
Concurrent Sessions I 14:30 Sessioni simultanee I AULA MINOR Small Business and CST-CSR / Piccole imprese e PSC E CSR (with translation / con traduzione) Leonardo Becchetti, Contagious Small Good Firms: The Case of Fair Trade Peter Heslam and Ben Andradi, Catholic Social Teaching and the Role of Business in the Eradication of Poverty Jean-Luc Castro, An Exploration of the Influence of Catholic Values on Management Practices of Heads of SMCs: The Social Doctrine of the Catholic Church Put to the Test Within Firms RESPONDENT: Laura Michelini COMMUNICATIONS: Laura Michelini, NGO-Business Partnerships in Italy: An Exploratory Study CHAIR: P.M. Mathew AULA 9 Comparing/Contrasting CST & CSR Antonio Argandoña, From Ethical Responsibility to Corporate Social Responsibility Rev. Domènec Melé, Mainstream Theories on Normative Corporate Social Responsibility: Analysis from Catholic Social Thought RESPONDENTS: Albert Erisman and Barbara Wall COMMUNICATIONS: Albert Erisman, Building the Case for Corporate Social Responsibility; Robert DeFina and Barbara Wall, Speaking in Tongues: CSR, CST and the Legitimation of Free Market Economics CHAIR: Gregorio Guitián AULA 10 Law, Governance and the Purpose of the Firm Robert Miller, Maximizing Shareholder Value in the Good Company Robert Vischer, Moral Identity, Subsidiarity and the Good Company RESPONDENTS: Robert Keen and Ernest Pierucci COMMUNICATIONS: Robert Keen, An Aquinas in the Boardroom; Ernest Pierucci, Is There Room in the Rule? Does the Business Judgment Rule Allow Space for the Principles of Catholic Social Teaching to Guide the Operation of a Corporation? CHAIR: Mutholil George, S.J. AULA 8 Justice, Wages and Outsourcing Albino Barrera O.P., Outsourcing: The Case for Residual Obligations Shirley Roels, Global Compensation Justice for Educated Young Adults 3
RESPONDENTS: Pablo Paras and Jude Njoku COMMUNICATIONS: Pablo Paras, A Cry for Help: Wealth Distribution in Mexico; Jude Njoku, Justice and Corporate Responsibility: Catholic Thought Versus Liberal Economic Ethics CHAIR: Marcelo Paladino AULA 1 Theological Perspectives Gil Bailie, Keeping Good Company: The Leavening Influence of Morally Ordered Lives Reyes Calderon Cuadrado and Jose Luis Alvarez Arce, The Roots of the Corporate Corruption: Deceit, Religion, and the Good Company RESPONDENTS: Danila Raskov and Sergei Lukin COMMUNICATIONS: Danila Raskov, Homo Oeconomicus and its Alternatives: Economic and Theological Approaches, and Sergei Lukin, Corporate Social Responsibility and Business Objectives CHAIR: Judith Merkle, SNDdeN 16:30 Break Concurrent Sessions II 17:00 Sessioni simultanee II AULA MINOR Pluralism, Natural Law and Convergence of CST and CSR / Pluralismo, Diritto Naturale e Convergenza tra PSC e RSI (with translation / con traduzione): Geert Demuijnck, Convergence in Divergence of CST and CSR in a Retailer Ethics Committee: A Case Study Christine Fletcher, CST, CSR and the Purpose Driven Company RESPONDENTS: Michael Nader; D. Kirk Davidson and John Larrivee COMMUNICATION: Michael Nader, Personnel Policies of the Good Company According to Catholic Social Teaching; D. Kirk Davidson and John Larrivee, How Can the Company Be Good If Its Products are Bad? CHAIR: Francesco Compagnoni, O.P. AULA 9 CST, CSR and Poverty John Bunch, (Bottom of the Pyramid) Economic Development Strategies and Catholic Social Teaching Gene Laczniak and Nicholas Santos, S.J., Catholic Social Teaching and the Construction of Just Markets 4
RESPONDENT: Muweme Muweme COMMUNICATIONS: Muweme Muweme, The Good Company in the Context of Zambia CHAIR: Collin Timms AULA 1 Economic Democracy Peter Davis, The Co-operative, Catholic Social Thought and the Good Company: The Importance of Pluralism in the Market Enzo Pezzini, Cooperatives: Good Companies by Definition? RESPONDENTS: Aitziber Mugarra Elorriaga and Angel Rodriguez, Jorge Turmo, and Oscar Vara COMMUNICATIONS: Aitziber Mugarra Elorriaga, How to Become a Good Company in Practice? Some Experiences in Social Economy in the Basque Country; Angel Rodriguez, Jorge Turmo, and Oscar Vara, Forms of Property and the Doctrine of the Church CHAIR: David Herrera AULA 10 Ethical Leadership Andre Delbecq, Questions Organizational Leaders Pose to Theologians William Byron S.J., The Making of an Ethical Executive RESPONDENT: Mario Molteni COMMUNICATIONS: Mario Molteni, The Common Good and Socio-Competitive Creativity CHAIR: Juliet Bucoy AULA 8 Panel: Catholic Institutions: Healthcare and Universities Sister Melanie DiPietro and Alison Sulentic, SSM Health Care: The Integration of Catholic Social Thought Values in a Modern Health Care System Adelaide Madera, The Good Company in the Healthcare Field Cindy Heine, Fostering Middle-Level Thinking in Catholic Healthcare: An Evaluation of One Health System s Leadership Development and Formation Efforts Clemente Ivo Juliatto, Can a University be a Good Company? Cristian L. Adaui, Jhony Velásquez D., and Alonso Quintanilla Perez-Wicht, Mainstreaming Catholic Social Thought in a Business School: A Case Study CHAIR: David Durenberger Reception at the Angelicum 19:00 Rinfresco all Angelicum 5
Friday, October 6 Venerdì 6 Ottobre PLENARY (with translation) The Common Good 9:00 AULA MINOR PLENARIA (con traduzione) Il Bene Comune Robert Sugden, Professor of Economics, University of East Anglia, United Kingdom Respondents: Lee Tavis, Professor of Finance, University of Notre Dame, USA and Stefano Zamagni, Professor of Economics, University of Bologna, Italy Chair: Charles Clark, Professor of Economics, St. John s University, USA Robert Sugden, Professore di Economia, Università di East Anglia, Gran Bretagna Controrelatori: Lee Tavis, Professore di Finanza, Università di Notre Dame, USA e Stefano Zamagni, Professore di Economia, Università di Bologna, Italia Coordina: Charles Clark, Professore di Economia, Università di St. John s, USA Concurrent Sessions III 10:30 Break 11:00 Sessioni simultanee III AULA MINOR The Common Good in Society as a Whole / Il bene comune nella società in generale (with translation / con traduzione) Sean Healy, s.m.a. and Brigid Reynolds, s.m., Practices and Policies of Companies Negotiating National Agreements An Irish Case Study Barbara Sena, How Can We Measure the Contribution of the Business to the Common Good? Operationalising the Theoretical Concept of the Common Good André Habisch, The Principle of Subsidiarity as a Normative Rationale for Corporate Community Involvement and Business Investment in Social Capital RESPONDENT: Tony McNamara COMMUNICATIONS: Tony McNamara, Consumer, Client, Customer or Citizen: Can the State be a Good Company? CHAIR: Maria Gabriella Baldarelli AULA 1 The Common Good in CST and CSR Joseph DesJardins, Sustainability as the Common Good: Distinguishing the Right From the Good in Theories of Corporate Social Responsibility 6
Leo Clarke and Edward Lyons, Germain Grisez and the Corporate Common Good RESPONDENTS: Michael J. Miller; Donatella Chiodo and Caterina Ferrone COMMUNICATIONS: Michael J. Miller, Vocation and the Common Good: A Second Look at the CSR Movement; Donatella Chiodo and Caterina Ferrone, The Model of a Catholic CSR in Comparison with the Model of a Secular CSR CHAIR: Robert Kennedy AULA 10 Asia PRESENTER: Thomas Hong-Soon Han, Catholicism and Confucianism in Dialogue for Corporate Social Responsibility Stephan Rothlin S.J., Developing Catholic Social Teaching and Corporate Social Responsibility in the Chinese Context RESPONDENT: Dennis McCann COMMUNICATIONS: Dennis McCann, Corporate Social Responsibility and Catholic Social Teaching in Hong Kong: A Case Study CHAIR: Pablo Tiong, O.P. AULA 8 Panel: CST/CSR Pedagogy Athar Murtuza, Assessing the Goodness of Islamic Banks From the Perspective of CSR and CST Jeanette Loanzon, From Manhattan to Dapitan: Human Dignity and Structural Realities in a Filipino Business School Louis Xavier Hrudayaraj S.J., Forming Managers in a Business School for The Good Company Steven Papamarcos, Unifying a Divided Life: Enhancing the Social Justice Learning in Service-Learning by Building Critical Thinking Skills John Médaille, Teaching Business as a Vocation: Orthodoxy and Orthopraxis CHAIR: Bruce Anderson Lunch 13:00 Sala delle Colonne Pranzo At 14:00, in aula 10, there will be an informal presentation of Sneep Roma, a local group of the international Student Network for Ethics in Economic Practice (SNEEP). Alle 14, in aula 10 ci sarà una presentazione informale di Sneep Roma, gruppo locale della rete internazionale Student Network for Ethics in Economic Practice (SNEEP). 7
PLENARY SESSION (with translation) Practical Implications of Catholic Social Thought 14:30 Aula Minor PLENARIA (con traduzione) Implicazioni pratiche del pensiero sociale cristiano José Ignacio Mariscal, CEO Grupo Marnhos (Mexico-DF), President Elect of UNIAPAC Respondents: Lorna Gold, Policy Analyst, Trocaire; Economy of Communion Franco Gesualdi, Centre for a New Model of Development Chair: Giuseppe Mastromatteo, Professor of Economics, Catholic University of Milan, Italy José Ignacio Mariscal, Amministratore delegato Grupo Marnhos (Mexico-DF), Presidente di UNIAPAC Controrelatori: Lorna Gold, Policy Analyst (Trocaire); Economy of Communion Franco Gesualdi, Centro Nuovo Modello di Sviluppo Coordina: Giuseppe Mastromatteo, Professore di Economia, Università Cattolica di Milano Concurrent Sessions IV 16:00 Break 16:30 Sessioni simultanee IV AULA MINOR Panel: Cases of Good and Not So Good Companies / Casi di aziende buone e non (with translation/ con traduzione) Thomas Bausch and Robert Ouimet, Tomasso Corporation A Sustainable 35 Year Experimentation of Christian Anthropology and the Common Good in a Competitive Industry Patricia Debeljuh, The Company as a Community of People: The Bimbo Case Marco Foschini, Agriculture and Corporate Social Responsibility: The Experience of Coldiretti Vicente T. Villegas, The Cultural Basis of the Good Company: Social Responsibility from a Filipino Christian Perspective Al Gini and Alexei Marcoux, Malden Mills: When Being a Good Company Isn t Good Enough CHAIR: Luigi Dieli AULA 10 Environment, CST and CSR Laura Baritz, O.P., Does Common Good Involve Environment? Surveying Different Common Good Models with Regard to Environment Francis Kadaplackal, P. Hefner s Concept Created Co-creator as a Source of Inspiration for a Sustainable Corporate Environmental Responsibility RESPONDENTS: Arpad Baranyi; Osvaldo Ferreiro and Beatriz Calderón 8
COMMUNICATIONS: Árpád Baranyi, Environmental Economics and Business Ethics: Ends by Themselves or Instruments of Profit?; Osvaldo Ferreiro and Beatriz Calderón, A Company Based on Values, With Corporate Social Responsibility, is a Good Company: CST + CSR = GC CHAIR: Adelaide Madera AULA 1 Finance, Ethics and Investing GianDemetrio Marangoni and Stefano Solari, The Good Company Facing Financialisation: The Relationship Between Corporate Choices and the Institutional Environment in Light of Catholic Social Thought Rev. Francis McHugh, Your City is Our City: Ethical Responsibility in the Financial Sector RESPONDENTS: Bridget Lyons and Lucjan Orlowski; Seamus Finn OMI COMMUNICATIONS: Bridget Lyons and Lucjan Orlowski, Transparency in Financial Markets and Institutions: A Catholic Social Thought Perspective; Seamus P. Finn OMI, The Difference that Catholic Institutional Investors Make CHAIR: Leonardo Becchetti AULA 9 Big Business, Human Dignity and Social Capital Lee Tavis, Determining Standards for the Implementation of CSR/CST Paul Dembinski and Patrick de Varax, The Good Company: Does Size Matter? RESPONDENTS: Maarten Biermans and Yuliya Shcherbinina COMMUNICATIONS: Maarten Biermans, The Dignity of the Good Company: A Comparison of the Usages of the Concept of Human Dignity ; Yuliya Shcherbinina, Social Capital: Good Company s Perspective CHAIR: Father Johney Xavier Puthukkattu AULA 8 Panel: Cases Daniel Steininger, Leadership How Catholics Can Be Successful Leaders in Business and Tax-Exempt Organizations Vincent Maher, Joseph Ford and John DeBiase, Small and Mid-Sized Businesses: As Local as CST and CSR Get Gina Vega and Patrick Primeaux, S.M., Moral Intuition and Transformative Organizations Ken Hackett and Dave Piraino, Catholic Relief Services: One Organization s Journey with Catholic Social Thought and Corporate Social Responsibility Lura Mack and Margaret Weber, The Premise of Community Investment Essential for the Good Company CHAIR: John Fontana End of Sessions 18:30 Termine delle sessioni 9
Saturday, October 7 Sabato 7 Ottobre PLENARY (with translation) Stakeholder Theory 9:00 Aula Minor PLENARIA (con traduzione) La teoria degli stakeholder Helen Alford, O.P. Dean of the Faculty of Social Sciences, Pontifical University of St. Thomas (Angelicum), Italy Respondents: Lorenzo Sacconi, Professor of Economics, University of Trent, Italy and Ken Goodpaster, Professor of Business Ethics, University of St. Thomas, U.S.A. Chair: Mark Sargent, Dean of the Villanova University School of Law, U.S.A. Helen Alford, O.P. Preside della Facoltà di Scienze Sociali, Pontificia Università San Tommaso (Angelicum), Italia Controrelatori: Lorenzo Sacconi, Professore di Economia, Università di Trento, Italia e Ken Goodpaster, Professore dell Etica degli Affari, Università di St Thomas, USA Coordina: Mark Sargent, Preside della Facoltà di Giurisprudenza, Università Villanova, USA Concurrent Sessions V 10:30 Break 11:00 Sessioni simultanee V AULA MINOR Work in CST and CSR / Il lavoro tra Psc e RSI (with translation / con traduzione) Daniel Brennan, Howard Behar and Heribert Schmitz, If Employees Were Really to Enjoy Their Work, What Would Happen to Capitalism? Hendrik Opdebeeck, The Dialogue of CST and CSR in E.F. Schumacher s Last Publication Good Work : Participation as a Linkage Between Principle and Practice. RESPONDENTS: Jean-Bernard Bruneteaux; Vincenzo Putrignano and Daniela Verducci COMMUNICATIONS: Jean-Bernard Bruneteaux, The Company: Between Shareholder and Customer; Vincenzo Putrignano and Daniela Verducci, In the Good Company One Works Better: Positive Interactions between CST and CSR CHAIR: Michal Michalski AULA 9 Personalism and Stakeholder Theory Ken Goodpaster, Stakeholders and the Common Good: A Polarity at the Core of Corporate Conscience 10
Lorna Gold and Rev. John McNerney, A Personalistic Perspective on Corporate Social Responsibility: An Application in the Economy of Communion Paradigm RESPONDENTS: Gianfransco Rusconi and Tibor Hejj COMMUNICATIONS: Gianfranco Rusconi, Stakeholder Theory and Business Economics; Tibor Hejj, What is the Holistic Stakeholder Value Matrix Derived From? CHAIR: Jeanne Buckeye AULA 1 Philosophical Perspectives on CST and CSR Kenneth Melchin and Darlene O Leary, Profit and the Good Company: Lonergan s Ethical Foundations and Economic Analysis in Dialogue with Catholic Social Thought and Corporate Social Responsibility Jim Wishloff, The Land of Realism and the Shipwreck of Idea-ism: Thomas Aquinas and Milton Friedman on the Good Company and the Social Responsibilities of Business RESPONDENTS: David W. Lutz and Mi-Yong Lee-Peuker COMMUNICATIONS: David W. Lutz, Rival Philosophical Foundations of the Good Company; Mi-Yong Lee-Peuker, Multi-Dimensional Rationality and Action Theory CHAIR: Cecilia Borgna AULA 10 Relationality in the Economy Luigino Bruni and Alessandra Smerilli, The Price of Socrates: CSR, Group Identification and Common Good in Organisations Vittorio Pelligra, Can You Buy Trustworthiness? An Experimental Study RESPONDENT: Giuseppe Argiolas COMMUNICATIONS: Giuseppe Argiolas, The Good Management: Drivers of Corporate Social Orientation Towards a Multidimensional Success CHAIR: Domenico Santangelo AULA 8 Panel: Assessing and Measuring the Good Company Elisa Golin and Giampietro Parolin, with Francesca Grandi and Chiara Rubinelli, Good Company: From Strategy to Sharing through Accountability Sonja Gallhofer and Jim Haslam, Catholic Social Thought, Corporate Social Responsibility and Accounting Timothy Mahoney, Accounting for Just Wages: A Reporting Standards Proposal Robert Shoemake and Douglas Jondle, Assessing the Good Company Dan Hess, A Framework for CSR Assessment, Measurement and Reporting CHAIR: Dean Maines 11
Lunch CLOSING PLENARY (with translation) 13:00 Sala delle Colonne 14:30 Aula Minor Pranzo PLENARIA DI CHIUSURA (con traduzione) What Have We Learned and Where Do We Go From Here? Panelists: Ben Andradi, Yuliya Shcherbinina, Charles Clark, Jeanette Loanzon, Luigino Bruni Chair: Michael Naughton, Director of the John A. Ryan Institute fo Catholic Social Thought, U.S.A. Cosa abbiamo imparato e dove andiamo a questo punto? Panel: Ben Andradi, Yuliya Shcherbinina, Charles Clark, Jeanette Loanzon, Luigino Bruni Coordina: Michael Naughton, Direttore dell Istituto John Ryan per lo studio del pensiero sociale cristiano, USA Mass Choir of the Church of Sts. Dominic and Sixtus Visit to the Gallery and Closing Dinner 16:00 18:00 Palazzo Doria Pamphilj Messa Coro della Chiesa di Ss. Domenico e Sisto Visita alla Galleria con Cena di chiusura The Advisory Committee Il comitato scientifico Helen Alford, Leo Andringa, Thomas Bausch, Leonardo Becchetti, Simona Beretta, Benoit Bonamy, Luigino Bruni, Francesco Cesareo, Francesco Compagnoni, Charles Clark, Peter Davis, Edwin M. Epstein, Jeanette Loanzon, Dennis McCann, Michael Naughton, Mary Kay O Rourke, Giampietro Parolin, Ernest Pierucci, Mark Sargent, Mark Sorokin, Don Paolo Tarchi, Lee Tavis, Pablo Tiong, Stefano Zamagni. Angelicum Organizing Committee Il gruppo organizzativo dell Angelicum Daniele Carelli, Beata Sidor, Yuliya Shcherbinina, Ivan Attard, Kestutis Liobikas 12