High-strength steels for chassis and exhaust components Application related developments and materials at Benteler Automotive J. Lackmann, H-G. Lambers, A. Frehn Benteler Automobiltechnik GmbH, Paderborn Dr. Lackmann, 09.04.2013 1
Outline Benteler Group Materials at Benteler Automotive Application related materials and developments - Chassis Application related materials and developments - Structure Application related materials and developments - Exhaust Summary Dr. Lackmann, 09.04.2013 2
Under the strategic management holding, Benteler International AG, the operative business is organized into the three legally independent business divisions within Benteler Deutschland GmbH. Benteler International AG Benteler Deutschland GmbH Benteler Automotive Benteler Stahl/Rohr Benteler Distribution Dr. Lackmann, 09.04.2013 3
Worldwide activity Benteler Automotive 2012 Sales: 5,530 million euros 22,400 employees 74 plants, 20 engineering and sales offices in 29 countries (Status 12/2011) Status October 2012 Dr. Lackmann, 09.04.2013 4
Dr. Lackmann, 09.04.2013 5
Materials overview 2500 Material-Strength : Rm / UTS [MPa] 2000 1500 1000 500 250 Application in series production Armoring Steel BSEC610 Armoring Steel BSEC510 Boron Steels / Surface finished Multi Phase Steels Micro Alloyed Steels Stainless Steels DDQ Steels Aluminium Sheet / Forged Carbon Fibre Al-Profile 6000-7000- Alloys Application approval in PPR Armoring Steels Ultra High Strength Alloys Boron steels High manganese steel MG-Forged MG-Sheet Plastic-Steel-Hybrid Plastic Foams Carbon Fibre Glass Fibre Dr. Lackmann, 09.04.2013 6
Overall application related material requirements Mechanical technological properties - Strenght - Hardening behavior - Formability - Modulus - Ductility - Thermo-mechanical properties - Quench propertries Machinability - Die-cutting - Laser-cutting - Drilling High strain rate behavior - Dynamic strength - Remaining strain - Ballistic resistance Fatique behavior - Fatique strength - Wöhler diagramms - Crack initiation and - growth Surface properties - Surface defects - Roughness Material price - Basic price - Alloying costs Logistic propterties - Available dimensions - Tolerances - Available semi-finished parts - Worldwide availability and quality Corrosion resistance / Coatability - Zinc-coating - Cataphoretic painting - Plasma nitriding - Hot- / wet corrosion properties Dr. Lackmann, 09.04.2013 7 Joining properties - Weldability - Brazeability - Other joining technologies
Requirement Formability of high strenght steels - Formability (including thinning) is a key parameter regarding the produceability of Benteler Automotive products - Consistently determined characteristic values are needed for for forming simulations - Influence of material characteristics along die- or laser-cutted holes and edges has to be considered for lifetime prediction - Increasing the formability of high strength steels desired - Reduction of the variance of mechanical properties (heat dependend) Dr. Lackmann, 09.04.2013 8
Requirement Dimenional tolerances of high strenght steels Example: Roll-rate of compound crank rear axles Influencing factors: Axle kinematics Shear center of the torsion profile Effective torsion lenght Thickness of the torsion element Influence of thickness torenances Basis for analytical estimation: B-segment vehicle (VW) (closed profile, D=115mm, t=2,4mm) t [mm] 2,40-2,45 4,04% 2,50 8,19% 2,55 12,43% 2,60 16,77% 2,65 21,21% Increasing the sheet thickness of the torsion element results in highly variing roll-rates and therefore considerable effects on the vehicle dynamics (over-/ under steering) Dr. Lackmann, 09.04.2013 9
Requirement Weldability of high strength steels 500 S420MC-S420MC BAS100(+A)-BAS100 (+A) BAS100 (+QT)-BAS100 (+QT) TRIP800 Grundmaterial WEZ Schweißgut WEZ Grundmaterial 450 400 Härte nach Vickers, HV0,5 350 300 250 200 150 100 50 MAG-weldseam Consumables: G4Si1 (S420MC/TRIP800) ESAB13.31 (BAS100) 0 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 Messpunkt Nr. Maximum allowable hardness within weldseam and heat affected zone is limited by OEMs Reduction of hardness steps by changing chemical compositions or annealing parameters Further examination of hydrogen embrittlement required Dr. Lackmann, 09.04.2013 10
Requirement Corrosion resistance of high strength steels Increasing requirements regarding corrosion resistance and weight reduction Standard cataphoretic painting not allways sufficitent Possible alternatives Zinc coating (strip) Weldseams highly affected Zinc coating (part) Reduction of fatique strength Weight increase Hydrogen embrittlement? LME-risk? 3 years / ca. 95.000 km Dr. Lackmann, 09.04.2013 11
Requirement mechanical properties of high strength steels Austenitic stainless steel Steel grades used for chassis components Elongation at strain A, % IF Alum. Magn. DDQ Isotrope Stähle IF-HS HSLA BH und P BAS100 +A BTR165 HR 11 1 9 TRIP DP BAS100 +QT 3 HSLA/Baustähle CP % 76 MS Austenitische nichtrostende Stähle Mehrphasenstähle Benteler-Stahlsorten (BTR165, BAS100) Andere Stahlsorten 22MnB5 TWIP BTR165 +QT Tensile strenght R m, MPa Dr. Lackmann, 09.04.2013 12
Steel grades used for chassis components HSLA / mild steels Grades: Micro-alloyed and mild steels (R e : 315 650 MPa) Products: Cross member, suspension arms, compound crank rear axles, tube components Advantages / Disadvantages: + Low carbon content (weldability hardness steps) + Strength / formability ratio + Minimal variation of mechanical properties within rolled strip + Different strength levels available + Worldwide available (Hot- and cold rolled strip) - Reduced formability and springback for high-strentgh grades Development trends: - Further reduction of grain- and precipitation size (Nano-Hiten) - Perlite-free variants showing increased formability(hsm650hd) Dr. Lackmann, 09.04.2013 13
Steel grades used for chassis components multiphase steels Grades: F/B540, F/B590, F/B780, SZBS800, CP-W800, DP450 Products: Suspension arms, reinforcements Vorteile/Nachteile: Similar to HSLA / mild steel + Improved formability and hardening potential + Significant bake-hardening effect + Improved hole expensionalbility (FB) - Wordwide availability(different concepts DP/TRIP) - Springback for HSS-grades - Weldeability for TRIP-steel - Hot rolled strip availability for DP/TRIP Development trends: - Further optimization of F/B-grades - Reduction of C-content of TRIP-steels Dr. Lackmann, 09.04.2013 14
Steel grades used for chassis components air hardening steels Grades: BAS100, BNX120 (R e : 700 Mpa 850 MPa) Komponenten: Front subframe Vorteile/Nachteile: + High formability in the not hardenend condition combined with high strength of hardened parts + No significant hardness steps within the heat affected zone - Alloying costs (Mo und V) - Wordwide availability Development trends at Benteler: - Optimization of mechanical properties and availability Dr. Lackmann, 09.04.2013 15
Competitor to steel - Aluminium grades used for chassis components Component Alloys Condition Strenght Elongation at break Extruded profiles EN AW-6060 EN AW-6005A EN AW-6063 T6 bzw. T5 R e > 225 MPa R m > 270 MPa A 5 > 8% HF welded tubes EN AW-5454 EN AW-5457 H111 R e > 100 MPa R m > 230 MPa A 5 > 20% Casted parts EN AC-42100 T6 R e > 190 MPa R m > 230 MPa A 5 > 2% Sheets for pressed parts EN AW-5454 EN AW-5457 H111, H22 and higher R e > 200 MPa R m > 270 MPa A 5 > 11% Forged parts EN AW-6062 EN AW-6110 (Cu limited) T6 R e > 370 MPa R m > 400 MPa A 5 > 9% High strength: 300-400 MPa (R m ) Ultra high strenght: > 400 MPa (R m ) Dr. Lackmann, 09.04.2013 16
Potential future steel grades for chassis components NANO-HITEN, TWIP - steels Steels showing increased elastic modulus Reference: JFE, Japan Reference: ArcelorMittal Low cost - air hardening steel, Bainite??? Reference: Microstructure of the BSR05-10 (air hardened) Dr. Lackmann, 09.04.2013 17
High strength steels for hot formed structural components and ballistic protection systems Tesile Zugfestigkeit stress [MPa] [Mpa] 2400 2200 2000 1800 1600 1400 1200 1000 800 600 400 200 0 HSS UHSS PHS PM BSEC610 hot formed BSEC510 hot formed BTR165 hot formed FB CP DP BTR165 hot rolled HSLA TRIP P, BH, IFHS 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 Bruchdehnung [%] Strain [%] Temperature (0-1000 C) Ac3 Ms TTT-Diagramm Cooling Transformation Mf Ferrite Bainite Perlite Martensite Martensite Time (0-1000 s, log) DDQ, UDDQ Dr. Lackmann, 09.04.2013 18
Partial hardening of high strength steels for structural components high strength T1 transition T2 ductile T3 Temp 3 distance 0 HV0,5 500 Vickers hardness Martensite Martensite + Bainite Ferrite + Perlite advantage: strength optimized design properties: quenched sec.: soft sec.: R m: 1450 MPa 550 MPa R e : 1100 MPa 400 MPa ε (A5): > 6 % > 20% good crash performance weight reduction Part integration T2 Temp 1 Temp 2 Direction of material flow T3 Dr. Lackmann, 09.04.2013 19
Hot formable ultra high strength steels for ballistic protection components Benteler Security Steel (BSEC) // C Cr Ni Mn based BSEC-grades available Hardness [HB] Impact work [J] Application BSEC450 410-480 40-60 Floor parts BSEC510 480-550 25-40 Vehicle protection up to STANAG I BSEC610 570-640 10-15 Vehicle protection up to STANAG III Benteler steel plant Lingen BSEC+ Surface hardened BSEC-grades for additional ballistic resistance Dr. Lackmann, 09.04.2013 20
Hot formable ultra high strength steels for ballistic protection components Ballistic protection up to t = 20 mm by fully martensitic microstructure Parts integration / avoidance of constructional vulnerabilities Development trends at Benteler: - Reduction of alloying costs - Reduction of CEV Dr. Lackmann, 09.04.2013 21
High Temperature Resistant Ferritic Steel for Exhaust Application BMBF-Project RUB Reference: ThyssenKrupp Nirosta Objective: Development of high temperature resistant (quasistatic and thermo mechanical fatique) ferritic stainless steel for exhaust applications, based on Laves phase precipitation Close the gap regarding high temperature mechanical properties between austenitic and ferritic stainless steel at cost of ferritc steels Idea: Manipulation of laves phase and carbonitride precipitation behavior and solvus temperatures by molybdenum-, tungsten-, silicon- and niobium content Reliable grain stabilization up to application temperatures of 950 C Dr. Lackmann, 09.04.2013 22
High Temperature Resistant Ferritic Steel for Exhaust Application Ferrite950 C Si Mn Cr Mo W V Nb Ti N ma-% < 0,02 0,6 0,4 18 0,5 1,5 0,1 0,8 < 0,1 < 0,05 548 Ferrite 950 Laves-phase - (Fe, Cr, Si) 2 (Nb, W, Mo) 415 488 1.4509 1.4521 0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 Zyklen Nf Ferrite 950 grade: Laves phase and carbonitrides precipitates stabilize grains up to 1000 C Thermo-mechanical properties significantly improved Excellent wet- and hot corrosion resistance Potential material for components exposed to high exhaust temperatures (downsized engines) Development activities at Benteler: - Further validation tests on prototypes (manifolds, pipes, converter) Dr. Lackmann, 09.04.2013 23
Summary Chassis components Steel grades with different mechanical strenght will be the first choice for many chassis components HSLA and mulitphase steel are predominantly used For components, where rigidity is most important, an increase of the elastic modulus is desired Hot formed structural components and ballistic protection systems Partial hardening of MnB steel grades allows for tailoring mechanical propteries within a wide range Hot formable ultra high strength steels are used for ballistic protection systems The reduction of alloying costs while maintaining strenght-ductility characteristics is attempted Exhaust components Chromium oxide based austenitic and ferritic stainless steel grades are predominantly used for exhaust components Ferritic stainless steel Ferrite 950 is a potential material for closing the gap between austenitic and ferritic stainless steels FVK / Aluminium FVK (glass / carbon) are getting more and more important for chassis (e.g. leave-spring) as well as structural components (e.g. reinforcements) Joint venture Benteler SGL Aluminium (5xxx / 6xxx ) is increasingly used for chassis and strucutral components Benteler Aluminium Systems Dr. Lackmann, 09.04.2013 24