Exclusive Seattle s Sound Transit comes in at No. 3., with $9 billion in total project costs. 2014 Top Rail Projects Survey With a reported $16.5 billion in projects, New York City Transit again tops the list, with the amount of streetcar projects in North America continuing to grow. Total project purse grows nearly 50% over 10 years. By Alex Roman, Managing Editor With a reported $16.5 billion in projects, the Metropolitan s (MTA) New York City Transit sits at the top spot in METRO s Top Rail Projects survey, which has a $99 billion total project purse for 2014. When including MTA s Long Island Rail Road (No. 25) and the Metro-North Railroad (No. 26), the overall total for projects taking place in the state of New York total more than $18.6 billion. Canadian projects continue to make a splash with a total of $21 billion appearing in this year s list, while five streetcar systems appearing at the bottom of the list come in at $674 million. Rounding out METRO s top five are the Toronto Transit Commission with $13.2 billion; Seattle s Sound Transit with $9 billion; Boston s Massachusetts Bay with $6.2 billion; and the City & County of Honolulu DOT Services Rapid Transit Division with $5.1 billion. Streetcars Streetcars are becoming a greater presence, with $674 million in projects appearing in this year s Top Rail Projects list. In Tucson, Ariz., Sun Link s $196 mil- Continues on page 18 14 < metro magazine JUNE 2014 metro-magazine.com
TOP RAIL Projects 2014 Sponsored by Total Railcars (Current) Cost of Projects in Millions State Rail Riders Now (in millions) Commuter Railcars Light Railcars Heavy Railcars Other Railcars Locomotives Rank 2013 Agency Rank City 1 MTA New York City Transit New York NY $16,550 6,745 6,292 0 0 72 453 1,700 1 2 Toronto Transit Commission Toronto ON $13,200 954 676 28 0 65 250 278 2 3 Sound Transit Seattle WA $9,000 120 0 62 58 11 0 10 3 4 Massachusetts Bay Boston MA $6,200 1068 432 205 421 82 10 274 4 5 City & County of Honolulu DOT Honolulu HI $5,100 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 5 Services Rapid Transit Division 6 San Diego Metropolitan San Diego CA $3,500 169 0 140 28 7 1 40.6 7 Transit System 7 Los Angeles County Metropolitan Los Angeles CA $3,366 280 104 176 0 0 0 96 12 8 Regional Transportation District Denver CO $3,300 172 0 172 0 0 0 24.8 6 9 Washington Metropolitan Area Washington DC $3,100 1,128 1,128 0 0 0 0 215 8 Transit Authority 10 Connecticut Department Newington CT $3,000 323 0 0 323 24 0 38 9 of Transportation 11 New Jersey Transit Newark NJ $2,700 1,231 0 93 1138 207 0 102.2 10 12 Metropolitan Transit Authority Houston TX $2,686 18 0 18 0 0 0 10.6 11 13 Edmonton Transit Edmonton AB $2,500 94 0 94 0 0 0 29.1 13 13 Utah Transit Authority Salt Lake City UT $2,500 170 0 117 53 18 0 18.7 14 15 Capital Railway Ottawa ON $2,100 3 0 0 0 0 3 2 17 16 Metro Transit Minneapolis/St.Paul MN $1,600 104 0 86 18 6 0 11.2 15 17 San Francisco Municipal Railway San Francisco CA $1,560 240 0 151 0 0 89 200 16 18 Calgary Transit Calgary AB $1,548 192 0 192 0 0 0 62.9 18 19 TriMet Portland OR $1,490 133 0 127 6 0 0 39.8 20 20 Santa Clara Valley San Jose CA $1,425 100 0 100 0 0 0 10.3 19 21 The Greater Vancouver Vancouver BC $1,400 342 298 0 44 5 0 123 20 -TransLink >> JUNE 2014 metro magazine > 15
TOP RAIL Projects 2014 Sponsored by Total Railcars (Current) Cost of Projects in Millions State Rail Riders Now (in millions) Commuter Railcars Light Railcars Heavy Railcars Other Railcars Locomotives Rank 2013 Agency Rank City 22 Charlotte Area Transit System Charlotte NC $1,345 23 0 20 0 0 3 4.9 23 23 Dallas Area Rapid Transit Dallas TX $1,320 163 0 163 0 0 0 29.5 22 24 Chicago Transit Authority Chicago IL $1,265 1,190 1,190 0 0 0 0 211 N/A 25 MTA Long Island Rail Road Jamaica NY $1,240 1,100 0 0 1,100 45 0 81 25 26 MTA Metro-North Railroad New York NY $816 1,150 867 0 283 75 0 81.1 26 27 Valley Metro Rail Phoenix AZ $670 50 0 50 0 0 0 14.2 24 28 Florida Department of Transportation Orlando FL $615 20 0 0 20 0 0 0 27 29 Southern California Regional Los Angeles CA $571 158 0 0 158 52 0 10.7 28 Rail Authority 30 Caltrain San Carlos CA $426 90 0 0 90 29 0 4 30 31 Amtrak Washington DC $389 1,553 1,553 0 0 396 0 31.2 31 32 Port Authority Trans-Hudson Corp. Jersey City NJ $351 438 0 0 350 0 88 72.8 32 33 Societe de Transport de Montreal Montreal QC $350 756 0 756 0 0 0 250 33 34 Southeastern Pennsylvania Philadelphia PA $278 926 371 159 396 8 0 339.3 35 35 Sacramento Regional Transit District Sacramento CA $270 76 0 76 0 0 0 27.2 36 36 Miami-Dade Transit Miami FL $250 176 136 0 0 0 40 30 29 37 Metra Chicago IL $207 1018 0 0 837 146 181 81.1 38 38 City of Tucson Department Tucson AZ $196 0 0 0 0 0 7 0 37 of Transportation 39 City of Cincinnati Cincinnati OH $147 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 N/A 40 M-1 Rail Detroit MI $137 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 40 41 Metropolitan Atlanta Rapid Atlanta GA $142 318 318 0 0 0 0 77.7 39 Transit Authority 42 City of Kansas City Kansas City MO $102 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 N/A 43 Atlanta Streetcar Atlanta GA $92 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 N/A 16 < metro magazine JUNE 2014 metro-magazine.com
2014 Top Rail Projects survey Continues from page 14 lion streetcar project (No. 38) is part of the $2.1 billion Regional Transportation Plan, approved by Pima County voters in May 2006. The project, which is funded by the Regional, is scheduled to open July 25. With an aggressive build schedule, the project added seven streetcars as of press time and moved from the construction and production phase to testing and training over the course of the past year. The City of Cincinnati is in the first phase of its 3.6-mile streetcar system (No. 39), with project costs coming in at a reported $147 million. In May, the Southwest Ohio Regional Transit Authority s Metro, which the City requested assume responsibility for streetcar marketing and community education, issued a Request for Proposals (RFP) for the creation of a brand identity and branding system of the Cincinnati Streetcar. The RFP includes a logo and guidelines related to its use that will be needed for everything related to streetcar operations, including vehicles, signs, operators uniforms, website and printed materials. Detroit s 3.3-mile M-1 Rail streetcar project (No. 40), which is set to open by late 2016, was approved in March for a $10 million loan from the state. The vision for a rail line along the Woodward Corridor has been in existence since 2007, and it has gone through a number of iterations in technology and actual cars and total distance. The project is set to officially break ground later this summer. Meanwhile, the two additional projects in this year s survey include Kansas City s Downtown KC Streetcar (No. 42) and the Atlanta Streetcar (See METRO April 2014) at No. 43. In May, the City of Atlanta and the Metropolitan Atlanta Rapid Transit Authority announced they will jointly manage the 2.7-mile line that will run along an east-west route with 12 stops/ stations using streetcars powered by overhead wire technology. In Kansas City, the two-mile Downtown streetcar starter line was set to break ground in May. The system will in- Minneapolis Metro Transit was set to open its $957 million Green Line in June. Top 10 Largest Rail Fleets 1 MTA New York City Transit...6,745 2 Amtrak...1,553 3 New Jersey Transit... 1,231 4 Chicago Transit Authority... 1,190 5 MTA Metro-North Railroad... 1,150 6 Washington Metropolitan Area Transit Authority... 1,128 7 MTA Long Island Rail Road...1,100 8 Massachusetts Bay Area...1,068 9 Metra... 1,018 10 Toronto Transit Commission... 954 The top 10 largest rail fleets comprise approximately 76% of the total with 17,137 vehicles. MTA s New York City Transit continues to top the list. Railcar Fleet Mix 8% 23% 10% 2004 59% Heavy...59%...13,128 Commuter..23%...5,256 Light...8%...1,856 Other...10%...2,173 13% 23% 59% Heavy...59%..13,365 Commuter..23%... 5,323 Light... 13%...2,985 Other...5%...1,125 Compared with 10 years ago, heavy railcars still make up the largest fraction of the sum with 13,365 vehicles, which is slightly higher than 2004 s 13,128 vehicles. Commuter and light railcars remain second and third, with light rail vehicles climbing in the last 10 years by 60%. Respondents said they have approximately 3,372 new railcars on order. 5% 2014 18 < metro magazine JUNE 2014 metro-magazine.com
2014 Top Rail Projects survey clude 16 stops spaced approximately every two blocks and serve the city s Central Business District; the Crossroads Art District; the Power and Light District; and numerous other businesses, restaurants, art galleries, educational facilities and residential neighborhoods. The completion of the Downtown KC Streetcar starter line project is anticipated in summer of 2015 followed by a period of testing. It is expected that by the end of 2015 the first streetcar rides will occur through Downtown Kansas City in over a half a century. Ready for launch As of press time, Minneapolis/St. Paul-based Metro Transit (No. 16) was in final testing of its $957 million MET- RO Green Line and set to begin revenue service on June 14. Total Project Costs (2010-2014 in billions) $100 $95 $90 $85 $80 $75 87 83 83 Streetcar projects listed in the survey, including Kansas City s, (rendering shown) totaled a reported $674 million. The Green Line is an 11-mile lightrail line connecting downtown Minneapolis, the University of Minnesota and downtown St. Paul. The METRO Green Line includes 18 new light rail stations. The Green Line will also serve five downtown Minneapolis stations that are shared with the METRO Blue Line, which travels south from Minneapolis to the Minneapolis-St. Paul International Airport and the Mall of America in Bloomington. Metro Transit is also in preliminary engineering on its Green Line Extension, which includes an additional 16 miles of double track as well as 16 new stations. It will be part of an integrated system of transitways, including connections to the Blue Line, the Northstar Commuter Rail line and Metro Transit bus routes. 99 99 $70 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 This year s $99 billion in total projects is $12 billion higher than reported in 2010 and about $32.5 billion more than was reported in 2004. Top 5 in 2004 1 MTA New York City Transit........................ $12,399 2 Metropolitan Transit Authority of Harris County...$7,500 3 Santa Clara Valley..$5,500 4 Port Authority of New York/ New Jersey...$4,000 5 Sound Transit...$3,180 In August, No. 23, the Dallas Area Rapid Transit (DART) will begin service on its 4.7-mile Orange Line extension from Belt Line Station to the newly rebuilt Dallas/Fort Worth International Airport station. The extension is part of DART s 14- mile Orange Line and brings the nation s longest light rail system to 90 miles. When the station opens, riders will only need to walk approximately 300 feet from the station to the terminal. At a Glance Further analysis of this year s numbers show that respondents have approximately 3,300 new railcars on order, with a majority of those vehicles expected to be heavy railcars. In METRO s list 10 years ago, NYC Transit topped the list with $12 billion in projects and a total of 6,589 vehicles. In fact, when comparing the numbers from 2004 and 2014, not a whole lot has changed, except for the total project purse, which hit $66.3 billion in 2004, has grown by 49%. If you know an agency with plans for the future, but were omitted from this year s survey, please let us know so that we can include it next year. METRO would also like to send a special thanks to all the agencies for taking the time to fill out our surveys and continuing to participate in this annual feature. 20 < metro magazine JUNE 2014 metro-magazine.com