Overview How BC teacher salaries rank among the provinces and territories in 2011



Similar documents
4.0 Health Expenditure in the Provinces and Territories

Instructions NDEB Equivalency Process

House for sale (Dept. of Finance) Real Estate

Open Government and Information Management. Roy Wiseman Executive Director, MISA/ASIM Canada CIO (Retired), Region of Peel

Attachment A. Electricity Rate Comparison Annual Report. May 1, 2011 Rates

Police-reported crime statistics, 2013 Released at 8:30 a.m. Eastern time in The Daily, Wednesday, July 23, 2014

Nursing Education in Canada, Consolidated Statistics for Entry-to-Practice Certificate, Diploma and Baccalaureate Programs:

Canadian Provincial and Territorial Early Hearing Detection and Intervention. (EHDI) Programs: PROGRESS REPORT

Resolving Customer Complaints

Competitive Alternatives 2014: Special Report - Focus on Tax

Application deadline: march 31 Apply for a $2,000 bursary!

Section V. Jurisdictional Requirements (Section V) General Instructions

Police-reported crime statistics, 2014 Released at 8:30 a.m. Eastern time in The Daily, Wednesday, July 22, 2015

Complaints or concerns about health care services or business services can be directed to a number of sources.

Engineers Canada 2012 Membership Survey

DOMINION LAND SURVEY. COMPOSED AND PRODUCED BY : Chris Rule. Permission is granted for use by acknowledging the author s name.

Valerie Tarasuk Andy Mitchell Naomi Dachner. PROOF Research to identify policy options to reduce food insecurity

Canadian Geography for ESL/ESOL Classrooms

National Retail Report Canada FALL 2015 EDITION. Accelerating success.

Juristat Bulletin Article. Criminal harassment in Canada, By Shelly Milligan

Saskatchewan Small Business Profile 2012

Workers Compensation How to Make a Claim

BRAIN INJURY NATIONAL PROVINCIAL ALBERTA. A.N.D Canada

The Regulation and Supply of Nurse Practitioners in Canada: Health Expenditure Estimates

TAXES AND SURCHARGES ON AIRLINE TICKETS

DIGITAL ECONOMY ANNUAL REVIEW

THE CANADIAN ISP COUNT, 2003: How many, where they are and what they do

AGREEMENT IN PRINCIPLE Labour Mobility Chapter of the Agreement on Internal Trade/Teaching Profession

Income tax rates for Canadian-controlled private corporations (CCPCs)

The Dietitian Workforce in Canada

REGISTERED NURSING ASSOCATIONS CONTACT INFO

Internet Connectivity Among Aboriginal Communities in Canada

2010 National Physician Survey :

POSTAL OUTLET FILE TECHNICAL SPECIFICATIONS

Municipal Revenue Sources Review Inter jurisdictional Comparison of Revenue Tools

Minimum Wage Rates in Canada:

SUMMARY OF SERVICES

2016 CARE. Chartered Accountancy Reciprocity Examination

Where to Study Criminology/Criminal Justice and related fields of study/work in Canada

A Snapshot State of the Nation: K- 12 Online Learning in Canada

Make a FIRST Impression... Not a LAST!

Pay Statement Guidelines

Sprott Flow-Through Limited Partnerships. Sprott Tax-Assisted Investments

The state of early childhood education and care in Canada 2012

Pharmacist Workforce, 2012 Provincial/Territorial Highlights

Ressources humaines et Développement des compétences Canada

SECTION V. Each jurisdiction s requirements can now be found in this section, including filing requirements/dates and mailing addresses.

taxation Current to June 20, 2013 What s Inside

PERMANENT RESIDENTS 2014

Re-Settlers: The Secondary Migration of Immigrants Between Canada s Cities Jack Jedwab Executive Director Association for Canadian Studies

How to File the T5 Return of Investment Income

ICE CONSULTING INTERNATIONAL HANS R. WUTHRICH Box 1609 Gimli Manitoba Canada R0C 1B0 Fax Cell

Registered Nurses Education in Canada Statistics

Careers in wildlife conservation

R esearch report LEVIES, FEES, CHARGES AND TAXES ON NEW HOUSING: 2002 HOUSING AFFORDABILITY AND FINANCE SERIES

CANADA S INTERNET PERFORMANCE: NATIONAL, PROVINCIAL AND MUNICIPAL ANALYSIS APRIL 2016

4,500 INTERIOR DESIGN PROFESSIONALS, INCLUDING STUDENTS. At IDC, we know the value that building relationships,

Aboriginal People in Canada s Labour Market: Work and Unemployment, Today and Tomorrow

Co-Op Development Fundamentals in Canada

Employment termination and group insurance coverage

Transferring Pension Credit into the PSPP

PEI Population Demographics and Labour Force Statistics

Salary Scale Analysis. For Medical Imaging and Radiation Technologists and Therapists

Fisheries and Marine Institute - Certificates

Statistical Portrait of the Frenchspeaking Immigrant Population Outside Quebec ( )

Atlantic Provinces 71 COMMUNITIES

Salary Scale Analysis. For Medical Imaging and Radiation Technologists and Therapists

COMPARISON OF ELECTRICITY PRICES IN MAJOR NORTH AMERICAN CITIES. Rates in effect April 1, ,0272

Consistent Results Across Most of The Board

RECOGNIZED HEALTH CARE AIDE PROGRAMS

Spending on Postsecondary. of Education, Fact Sheet. Education Indicators in Canada. June 2011

DISABILITY PENSION (PLUS-related services and benefits)

COMPARISON OF ELECTRICITY PRICES IN MAJOR NORTH AMERICAN CITIES. Rates in effect April 1, 2011

WEST NILE VIRUS AND OTHER MOSQUITO-BORNE DISEASE NATIONAL SURVEILLANCE REPORT

The Number of Businesses in Alberta is Gaining Momentum

January Facts on Alberta Living and Doing Business in Alberta

Dear Reader: Presented herewith is the Annual Gaming Report pursuant to Section 56 of the Gaming Control Act for the year ending March 31, 2013.

Article. Work absences in by Maria Dabboussy and Sharanjit Uppal

加 拿 大 留 學 中 心 (Foreign Student Services)

Control and sale of alcoholic beverages, for the year ending March 31, 2013 Released at 8:30 a.m. Eastern time in The Daily, Thursday, April 10, 2014

Access to Basic Banking Services

Financial Recruitment Incentive Programs for Nursing Personnel in Canada

NEW CARRIER SIGN UP REQUEST FORM

Living in Alberta. Child Care Cost of Living Education Entertainment Food Items Gasoline Health Care

West Nile virus National Surveillance Report English Edition September 8 to September 14, 2013 (Report Week 37)

Appendix. Value for Money? Teacher Compensation and Student Outcomes in Canada s Six Largest Provinces

March 2014 Second survey report: skills shortages in Canada

A Demographic and Socio-Economic Portrait of. AboriginAl PoPulAtions in CAnAdA

Occupational Therapists in Canada, 2010 National and Jurisdictional Highlights and Profiles

Catalogue no X. Police Resources in Canada

Control and sale of alcoholic beverages, for the year ending March 31, 2012 Released at 8:30 a.m. Eastern time in The Daily, Thursday, April 11, 2013

Investment Dealers Association of Canada

COMPARISON OF ELECTRICITY PRICES IN MAJOR NORTH AMERICAN CITIES. Rates in effect April 1, ,0272

Notices / News Releases

Application Timeframes: January and April, 2013

If you have an accident

Ms. Cecilie Lord (Chair) Assistant Deputy Minister Health Strategies Division Alberta Health Jasper Avenue, 24th Floor Edmonton, AB T5J 2N3

J.D. Power Reports: Canadian Wireless Network Performance: No Service, No Satisfaction

Transcription:

13 BARGAINING PROPOSAL BRITISH COLUMBIA TEACHERS FEDERATION Document Number: U102 Date: Time: Overview How BC teacher salaries rank among the provinces and territories in 2011 Minimum The minimum salary for a BC teacher with qualifications ranks 11th in Canada, including the provinces and territories. Based on provinces only, the rank shifts to 8th among the ten provinces. Maximum The maximum salary for a BC teacher with qualifications ranks 9th in Canada, including the provinces and territories. Based on provinces only, the rank shifts to 6th among the ten provinces. Category 6 Minimum The minimum salary for a BC teacher with Category 6 qualifications ranks 12th in Canada, including the provinces and territories. Based on provinces only, the rank shifts to 9th among the ten provinces. Maximum The maximum salary for a BC teacher with Category 6 qualifications ranks 11th in Canada, including the provinces and territories. Based on provinces only, the rank shifts to 8th among the ten provinces. Summary table: Ranking of BC teacher salaries The following table shows how BC teacher salaries rank compared to the other provinces and territories, and also the ranking on provinces only. The rankings are based on the average salary for the representative school districts listed in the salary comparison tables (pages 2 and 3). For the detailed tables on which these rankings are based, see pages 4 and 5. Provinces and territories (out of 13) Provinces only (out of 10) Cat 5 minimum 11th 8th Cat 5 maximum 9th 6th Cat 6 minimum 12th 9th Cat 6 maximum 11th 8th U102 1

2011* Canadian teacher salary rankings: Provinces and territories Equivalents to BC s minimum Equivalents to BC s maximum Prov. City/Province/Territory 2011* Cat 5 Min Prov. City/Province/Territory 2011* Cat 5 Max NT NWTTA $ 76,079 NT NWTTA $111,929 NU Nunavut $ 70,460 NT Yellowknife Catholic $106,800 NT Yellowknife Catholic $ 68,817 NT Yellowknife School District #1 $103,365 NT Yellowknife School District #1 $ 67,626 NU Nunavut $101,334 YT Yukon $ 65,869 AB Edmonton SD 7 $ 95,354 AB Edmonton SD 7 $ 61,489 AB Lethbridge SD 51 $ 95,161 AB Lethbridge SD 51 $ 61,472 YT Yukon $ 95,153 AB Calgary SD 19 $ 61,038 AB Calgary SD 19 $ 95,073 ON Ottawa Carleton Secondary $ 53,551 ON Toronto Secondary $ 89,614 SK Saskatchewan $ 53,327 ON Eastern OECTA $ 88,933 MB Winnipeg $ 52,814 ON Ottawa Carleton Secondary $ 88,816 MB Brandon $ 52,678 ON Elementary Teachers of Toronto (ETFO) $ 87,882 ON Ottawa Carleton Elementary (ETFO) $ 52,432 ON Near North Elementary (ETFO) $ 87,589 ON Near North Elementary (ETFO) $ 52,050 ON Ottawa Carleton Elementary (ETFO) $ 86,717 ON Toronto Secondary $ 51,738 SK Saskatchewan $ 81,945 ON Eastern OECTA $ 51,338 MB Brandon $ 80,709 NL Newfoundland and Labrador $ 51,166 MB Winnipeg $ 80,309 ON Elementary Teachers of Toronto (ETFO) $ 50,739 NB New Brunswick $ 75,241 NB New Brunswick $ 48,793 BC Prince George (July 1, 2010 June 30, 2011) $ 74,353 BC Victoria (July 1, 2010 June 30, 2011) $ 48,626 BC Vancouver (July 1, 2010 June 30, 2011) $ 74,353 BC Vancouver (July 1, 2010 June 30, 2011) $ 48,083 BC Victoria (July 1, 2010 June 30, 2011) $ 74,353 NS Nova Scotia $ 48,020 QC Quebec $ 71,946 PEI PEI $ 47,135 NS Nova Scotia $ 68,536 BC Prince George (July 1, 2010 June 30, 2011) $ 45,909 PEI PEI $ 68,117 QC Quebec $ 40,067 NL Newfoundland and Labrador $ 67,001 * Unless otherwise specified. This table was prepared by BCTF Research. Selection of equivalent categories for BC s and Category 6 was done by comparing definitions and requirements for each category, by province, or territory. 2 U102

2011* Canadian teacher salary rankings: Provinces and territories Equivalents to BC s Category 6 minimum Equivalents to BC s Category 6 maximum Prov. City/Province/Territory 2011* Cat 6 Min Prov. City/Province/Territory 2011* Cat 6 Max NT NWTTA $ 79,307 NT NWTTA $ 116,678 NU Nunavut $ 73,451 NT Yellowknife Catholic $ 114,705 NT Yellowknife Catholic $ 72,863 NT Yellowknife School District #1 $ 111,642 NT Yellowknife School District #1 $ 72,016 NU Nunavut $ 104,952 YT Yukon $ 68,112 AB Edmonton SD 7 $ 99,119 NL Newfoundland and Labrador $ 65,996 AB Lethbridge SD 51 $ 98,955 AB Lethbridge SD 51 $ 65,270 AB Calgary SD 19 $ 98,938 AB Edmonton SD 7 $ 65,256 YT Yukon $ 97,845 AB Calgary SD 19 $ 64,905 ON Toronto Secondary $ 94,707 NS Nova Scotia $ 62,946 ON Ottawa Carleton Secondary $ 94,649 MB Winnipeg $ 59,191 ON Eastern OECTA $ 94,614 MB Brandon $ 59,086 ON Elementary Teachers of Toronto (ETFO) $ 92,878 SK Saskatchewan $ 56,815 ON Ottawa Carleton Elementary (ETFO) $ 92,821 ON Toronto Secondary $ 55,404 ON Near North Elementary (ETFO) $ 92,811 ON Ottawa Carleton Secondary $ 55,377 MB Winnipeg $ 89,675 ON Near North Elementary (ETFO) $ 54,428 MB Brandon $ 89,083 ON Elementary Teachers of Toronto (ETFO) $ 54,333 NL Newfoundland and Labrador $ 87,792 ON Eastern OECTA $ 54,309 SK Saskatchewan $ 86,614 ON Ottawa Carleton Elementary (ETFO) $ 54,217 NS Nova Scotia $ 85,699 BC Victoria (July 1, 2010 June 30, 2011) $ 53,676 NB New Brunswick $ 81,851 NB New Brunswick $ 53,195 BC Victoria (July 1, 2010 June 30, 2011) $ 81,707 BC Vancouver (July 1, 2010 June 30, 2011)) $ 52,823 BC Prince George (July 1, 2010 June 30, 2011) $ 81,488 PEI PEI $ 52,793 BC Vancouver (July 1, 2010 June 30, 2011) $ 81,488 BC Prince George (July 1, 2010 June 30, 2011) $ 50,588 PEI PEI $ 76,289 QC Quebec $ 43,463 QC Quebec $ 71,946 * Unless otherwise specified. This table was prepared by BCTF Research. Selection of equivalent categories for BC s and Category 6 was done by comparing definitions and requirements for each category, by province, or territory. U102 3

How BC teacher salaries rank among the provinces and territories The following tables show how BC salaries rank compared to the other provinces and territories, and also the ranking on provinces only; an average is used here for those provinces/territories with more than one collective agreement (based on the examples in earlier tables in this report). The minimum salary for a BC teacher with qualifications ranks 11th in Canada, including the provinces and territories. Based on provinces only, the rank shifts to 8th among the ten provinces. The maximum salary for a BC teacher with qualifications ranks 9th in Canada, including the provinces and territories. Based on provinces only, the rank shifts to 6th among the ten provinces. BC s ranking, based on 2011 minimum salary Prov. Province/Territory 2011 Cat 5 Min Ranking Ranking, provinces only NT* Northwest Territory $ 70,841 1 NU Nunavut $ 70,460 2 YT Yukon $ 65,869 3 AB* Alberta $ 61,333 4 1 SK Saskatchewan $ 53,327 5 2 MB* Manitoba $ 52,746 6 3 ON* Ontario $ 51,975 7 4 NL Newfoundland and Labrador $ 51,166 8 5 NB New Brunswick $ 48,793 9 6 NS Nova Scotia $ 48,020 10 7 BC* British Columbia (July 1, 2010 June 30, 2011) $ 47,539 11 8 PEI PEI $ 47,135 12 9 QC Quebec $ 40,067 13 10 This table was prepared by BCTF Research. BC s ranking, based on 2011 maximum salary Prov. Province/Territory 2011 Cat 5 Max Ranking Ranking, provinces only NT* Northwest Territory $107,365 1 NU Nunavut $101,334 2 AB* Alberta $ 95,258 3 1 YT Yukon $ 95,153 4 ON* Ontario $ 88,259 5 2 SK Saskatchewan $ 81,945 6 3 MB* Manitoba $ 80,509 7 4 NB New Brunswick $ 75,241 8 5 BC* British Columbia (July 1, 2010 June 30, 2011) $ 74,353 9 6 QC Quebec $ 71,946 10 7 NS Nova Scotia $ 68,536 11 8 PEI PEI $ 68,117 12 9 NL Newfoundland and Labrador $ 67,001 13 10 This table was prepared by BCTF Research. * Average salary based on the sample of districts included in the salary comparison tables in the earlier section of this report. 4 U102

Category 6 The minimum salary for a BC teacher with Category 6 qualifications ranks 12th in Canada, including the provinces and territories. Based on provinces only, the rank shifts to 9th among the ten provinces. The maximum salary for a BC teacher with Category 6 qualifications ranks 11th in Canada, including the provinces and territories. Based on provinces only, the rank shifts to 8th among the ten provinces BC s ranking, based on 2011 Category 6 minimum salary Prov. Province/Territory 2011 Cat 6 Min Ranking Ranking, provinces only NT* Northwest Territory $ 74,729 1 NU Nunavut $ 73,451 2 YT Yukon $ 68,112 3 NL Newfoundland and Labrador $ 65,996 4 1 AB* Alberta $ 65,263 5 2 NS Nova Scotia $ 62,946 6 3 MB* Manitoba $ 59,139 7 4 SK Saskatchewan $ 56,815 8 5 ON* Ontario $ 54,678 9 6 NB New Brunswick $ 53,195 10 7 PEI PEI $ 52,793 11 8 BC* British Columbia (July 1, 2010 June 30, 2011) $ 52,362 12 9 QC Quebec $ 43,463 13 10 This table was prepared by BCTF Research. BC s ranking, based on 2011 Category 6 maximum salary Prov. Province/Territory 2011 Cat 6 Max Ranking Ranking, provinces only NT* Northwest Territory $114,342 1 NU Nunavut $104,952 2 AB* Alberta $ 99,004 3 1 YT Yukon $ 97,845 4 ON* Ontario $ 93,747 5 2 MB* Manitoba $ 89,379 6 3 NL Newfoundland and Labrador $ 87,792 7 4 SK Saskatchewan $ 86,614 8 5 NS Nova Scotia $ 85,699 9 6 NB New Brunswick $ 81,851 10 7 BC* British Columbia (July 1, 2010 June 30, 2011) $ 81,561 11 8 PEI PEI $ 76,289 12 9 QC Quebec $ 71,946 13 10 This table was prepared by BCTF Research. * Average salary based on the sample of districts included in the salary comparison tables in the earlier section of this report. U102 5

Overview of teacher salary differences Teacher salary differences as of September 2010 In 2010 11, a Vancouver teacher at maximum salary (Cat. 5) earns: o $10,969 less than an elementary teacher in Toronto, o $11,876 less than a secondary teacher in Ottawa, and o $16,860 less than a teacher in Edmonton. In 2010 11, a Prince George teacher at maximum salary (Cat. 5) earns: o $10,685 less than an elementary teacher in Near North, o $1,325 more than a teacher in New Brunswick, and o $16, 675 less than a teacher in Lethbridge. Teacher salary differences as of September 2011 If BC teachers do not receive a salary increase for 2011 12, a Vancouver teacher at maximum salary (Cat. 5) will earn: o $13,529 less than an elementary teacher in Toronto, o $14,463 less than a secondary teacher in Ottawa, and o $21,001 less than a teacher in Edmonton. If BC teachers do not receive a salary increase for 2011 12, a Prince George teacher at maximum salary (Cat. 5) will earn: o $13,236 less than an elementary teacher in Near North, o $ 888 less than a teacher in New Brunswick, and o $20, 808 less than a teacher in Lethbridge. What if BC teachers receive no salary increase for 2011 12? By September 2011, the earnings gap between an Edmonton teacher and a Vancouver teacher with 10 years teaching experience at will widen from $16,860 to $21,001. By September 2011, the earnings gap between a Lethbridge teacher and a Prince George teacher with 10 years teaching experience at will widen from $16,675 to $20,808. Teacher salary comparison tables Urban: Vancouver, Ottawa, Toronto, and Edmonton (see pp. 7 8) September 2010 September 2011 Non-Urban: Prince George, Near North, New Brunswick, and Lethbridge (see pp. 9 10) September 2010 September 2011 6 U102

Urban teacher salary comparisons September 2010 This comparison shows the salary difference between Vancouver (BC) and Toronto (ON), Ottawa (ON), and Edmonton (AB), for current salary levels in 2010 11. Category A3 Category A3 Step Vancouver (Sept 2010: 2%) Toronto* (Sept 2010: 3%) Vancouver compared to Toronto Ottawa* (Sept 2010: 3%) Vancouver compared to Ottawa Edmonton** (Sept 2010: 2.92%) Vancouver compared to Edmonton 0 $48,083 $49,261 -$1,178 $51,991 -$3,908 $58,819 -$10,736 1 $50,494 $52,569 -$2,075 $55,413 -$4,919 $61,991 -$11,497 2 $52,904 $56,066 -$3,162 $58,839 -$5,935 $65,165 -$12,261 3 $55,315 $59,559 -$4,244 $62,262 -$6,947 $68,337 -$13,022 4 $57,725 $63,243 -$5,518 $65,684 -$7,959 $71,510 -$13,785 5 $60,135 $66,919 -$6,784 $69,107 -$8,972 $74,682 -$14,547 6 $62,546 $70,599 -$8,053 $72,532 -$9,986 $77,854 -$15,308 7 $64,956 $74,279 -$9,323 $75,954 -$10,998 $81,026 -$16,070 8 $67,367 $77,957 -$10,590 $79,377 -$12,010 $84,198 -$16,831 9 $69,777 $81,640 -$11,863 $82,800 -$13,023 $87,371 -$17,594 10 $74,353 $85,322 -$10,969 $86,229 -$11,876 $91,213 -$16,860 Difference between step 0 and step 10 $26,270 $36,061 $34,238 $32,394 Notes: Selection of equivalent categories for BC s and 6 was done by comparing definitions and requirements for each category, by province or territory. The categories chosen as the most suitable matches are based on information on teacher certification qualifications available online for each province or territory. For further information, contact mwhite@bctf.ca in BCTF Research. increase percentages calculated by BCTF Research comparing figures in salary grids for each collective agreement. * Toronto and Ottawa: 2010 salary figures from relevant collective agreements for Toronto Elementary and Ottawa- Carleton Secondary. ** Edmonton: 2010 salary figures from collective agreement. Sources: Collective Agreement between Toronto District School Board and ETFO (2008 12): http://www.ett.ca/sites/default/files/2008-2012-elementary%20ca%20-%20sept2-09%20-%20cs_0.pdf Collective Agreement between Ottawa-Carleton School Board and OSSTF (2008 12): http://www.osstf25.on.ca/tbu.ca.pdf Collective Agreement between Board of Trustees of Edmonton School District No 7 and the ATA (2007 12): http://www.teachers.ab.ca/for%20members/%20benefits%20and%20pension/collectiveagreements/pages/e dmonton%20school%20district%20no%207%20(2007%20-%202012).aspx U102 7

Step Urban teacher salary comparisons September 2011 This comparison shows the salary difference between Vancouver (BC) and Toronto (ON), Ottawa (ON), and Edmonton (AB) if salary levels for BC public school teachers remain unchanged in 2011 12. Vancouver (Sept 2011: Category A3 Toronto* (Sept 2011: Vancouver compared to Toronto Category A3 Ottawa* (Sept 2011: Vancouver compared to Ottawa Edmonton** (Sept 2011: Vancouver compared to Edmonton 0%) 3%) 3%) 4.54%) 0 $48,083 $50,739 -$2,656 $53,551 -$5,468 $61,489 -$13,406 1 $50,494 $54,146 -$3,652 $57,075 -$6,581 $64,805 -$14,311 2 $52,904 $57,748 -$4,844 $60,604 -$7,700 $68,123 -$15,219 3 $55,315 $61,346 -$6,031 $64,130 -$8,815 $71,439 -$16,124 4 $57,725 $65,140 -$7,415 $67,655 -$9,930 $74,757 -$17,032 5 $60,135 $68,927 -$8,792 $71,180 -$11,045 $78,073 -$17,938 6 $62,546 $72,717 -$10,171 $74,708 -$12,162 $81,389 -$18,843 7 $64,956 $76,507 -$11,551 $78,233 -$13,277 $84,705 -$19,749 8 $67,367 $80,296 -$12,929 $81,758 -$14,391 $88,021 -$20,654 9 $69,777 $84,089 -$14,312 $85,284 -$15,507 $91,338 -$21,561 10 $74,353 $87,882 -$13,529 $88,816 -$14,463 $95,354 -$21,001 Difference between step 0 and step 10 $26,270 $37,143 $35,265 $33,865 Notes: Selection of equivalent categories for BC s and 6 was done by comparing definitions and requirements for each category, by province or territory. The categories chosen as the most suitable matches are based on information on teacher certification qualifications available online for each province or territory. For further information, contact mwhite@bctf.ca in BCTF Research. increase percentages calculated by BCTF Research comparing figures in salary grids for each collective agreement. * Toronto and Ottawa: 2011 salary figures from relevant collective agreements for Toronto Elementary and Ottawa- Carleton Secondary. **Edmonton: 2011 salary figures for Edmonton from collective agreement. Sources: Collective Agreement between Toronto District School Board and ETFO (2008 12): http://www.ett.ca/sites/default/files/2008-2012-elementary%20ca%20-%20sept2-09%20-%20cs_0.pdf Collective Agreement between Ottawa-Carleton School Board and OSSTF (2008 12): http://www.osstf25.on.ca/tbu.ca.pdf Collective Agreement between Board of Trustees of Edmonton School District No 7 and the ATA (2007 12): http://www.teachers.ab.ca/for%20members/%20benefits%20and%20pension/collectiveagreements/pages/e dmonton%20school%20district%20no%207%20(2007%20-%202012).aspx 8 U102

Non-urban teacher salary comparisons September 2010 This comparison shows the salary differences between Prince George (BC) and Near North (ON), New Brunswick, and Lethbridge (AB) at current salary levels for 2010 11. Category A3 Category CV Step New Prince Prince Near Prince Lethbridge Prince Brunswick George George North** George **** George *** compared (Sept (Sept 2010: compared to (Sept 2010: compared to (Sept 2010: to New 2010: 2%) 3%) Near North 2.92%) Lethbridge 4%) Brunswick 0 $45,909 $50,534 -$4,625 $47,358 -$1,449 $58,802 -$12,893 1 $48,543 $53,384 -$4,841 $49,922 -$1,379 $62,025 -$13,482 2 $51,176 $56,234 -$5,058 $52,490 -$1,314 $65,249 -$14,073 3 $53,809 $59,084 -$5,275 $55,055 -$1,246 $68,470 -$14,661 4 $56,443 $61,936 -$5,493 $57,627 -$1,184 $71,693 -$15,250 5 $59,076 $64,786 -$5,710 $60,196 -$1,120 $74,915 -$15,839 6 $61,709 $67,637 -$5,928 $62,760 -$1,051 $78,139 -$16,430 7 $64,343 $70,488 -$6,145 $65,329 -$986 $81,359 -$17,016 8 $66,976 $73,339 -$6,363 $67,899 -$923 $84,583 -$17,607 9 $69,609 $76,189 -$6,580 $70,459 -$850 $87,804 -$18,195 10* $74,353 $79,039 -$4,686 $73,028 $1,325 $91,028 -$16,675 11 $85,038 -$10,685 Difference between step 0 and step 10 $28,444 $28,505 $25,670 $32,226 Notes: Selection of equivalent categories for BC s and 6 was done by comparing definitions and requirements for each category, by province or territory. The categories chosen as the most suitable matches are based on information on teacher certification qualifications available online for each province or territory. For further information, contact mwhite@bctf.ca in BCTF Research. increase percentages calculated by BCTF Research based on figures in each collective agreement. * Prince George: Some schools in Prince George receive $57 more at step 10 due to the grid lift for schools eligible for the Recruitment & Retention allowance. ** Near North salary grid taken from collective agreement for Elementary teachers (ETFO). *** New Brunswick: NB has a provincial salary grid. The 4% salary increase for NB is based on a 2% increase as of March 1, 2010 and a 2% increase as of September 1, 2010. **** Lethbridge: 2010 salary figures from collective agreement. Sources: ETFO Near North Collective Agreement (Sept 1, 2008 Aug 31, 2012): http://nntl.ca/wpcontent/uploads/collective_agreement-_08-12_final.pdf New Brunswick Teachers' Federation Collective Agreement (Mar 1, 2008 Feb 29, 2012): http://www.district2.nbed.nb.ca/documents/hr_payroll/agreement-nbtf.pdf Lethbridge School District 51 Collective Agreement (2007 2012): http://www.teachers.ab.ca/for%20members/%20benefits%20and%20pension/collectiveagreements/pages/l ethbridge%20school%20district%20no%2051%20(2007%20-%202012).aspx U102 9

Non-urban teacher salary comparisons September 2011 This comparison shows the salary difference between Prince George (BC) and Near North (ON), New Brunswick, and Lethbridge (AB) if salary levels for BC public school teachers remain unchanged in 2011 12. Category A3 Teacher s Certificate V Prince Near Prince New Prince George Lethbridge Prince Step George North** George Brunswick*** compared to **** George (Sept 2011: (Sept 2011: compared to (Sept 2011: New (Sept 2011: compared to 0%) 3%) Near North 3%) Brunswick 4.54%) Lethbridge 0 $45,909 $52,050 -$6,141 $48,793 -$2,884 $61,472 -$15,563 1 $48,543 $54,986 -$6,443 $51,435 -$2,892 $64,841 -$16,298 2 $51,176 $57,921 -$6,745 $54,081 -$2,905 $68,211 -$17,035 3 $53,809 $60,857 -$7,048 $56,723 -$2,914 $71,579 -$17,770 4 $56,443 $63,794 -$7,351 $59,373 -$2,930 $74,948 -$18,505 5 $59,076 $66,730 -$7,654 $62,020 -$2,944 $78,316 -$19,240 6 $61,709 $69,666 -$7,957 $64,662 -$2,953 $81,687 -$19,978 7 $64,343 $72,603 -$8,260 $67,309 -$2,966 $85,053 -$20,710 8 $66,976 $75,539 -$8,563 $69,957 -$2,981 $88,423 -$21,447 9 $69,609 $78,475 -$8,866 $72,594 -$2,985 $91,790 -$22,181 10* $74,353 $81,410 -$7,057 $75,241 -$888 $95,161 -$20,808 11 $87,589 -$13,236 Difference between step 0 and step 10 $28,444 $29,360 $26,448 $33,689 Notes: Selection of equivalent categories for BC s and 6 was done by comparing definitions and requirements for each category, by province or territory. The categories chosen as the most suitable matches are based on information on teacher certification qualifications available online for each province or territory. For further information, contact mwhite@bctf.ca in BCTF Research. increase percentages calculated by BCTF Research based on figures in each collective agreement. * Prince George: Some schools in Prince George receive $57 more at step 10 due to the grid lift for schools eligible for the Recruitment & Retention allowance. ** Near North salary grid taken from collective agreement for Elementary teachers (ETFO). *** New Brunswick: NB has a provincial salary grid. The 3% salary increase for NB is based on a 2% increase as of March 1, 2011 and a 1% increase as of September 1, 2011. September 1, 2011 salary increase is effective to February 29, 2012. **** Lethbridge: 2011 salary figures from collective agreement. Sources: ETFO Near North Collective Agreement (Sept 1, 2008 Aug 31, 2012): http://nntl.ca/wpcontent/uploads/collective_agreement-_08-12_final.pdf New Brunswick Teachers' Federation Collective Agreement (Mar 1, 2008 Feb 29, 2012): http://www.district2.nbed.nb.ca/documents/hr_payroll/agreement-nbtf.pdf Lethbridge School District 51 Collective Agreement (2007 2012): http://www.teachers.ab.ca/for%20members/%20benefits%20and%20pension/collectiveagreements/pages/l ethbridge%20school%20district%20no%2051%20(2007%20-%202012).aspx 10 U102

Recent bargaining settlements in British Columbia Public sector settlements: Percentage increase in wages and salaries 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 Municipal employees Comox Valley Regional District (CUPE 556) 2% 2% 3% 2% Courtenay (CUPE Loc. 556) 2% 2% 2.75% 2.25 International Assoc. of Fire Fighters ( 953) Kelowna TBA TBA TBA International Assoc. of Fire Fighters (1271) Surrey 3.0% 2.5% Vancouver Police Union 2.95% 2.95% 1.25% 1.3% West Kelowna Association of Local Government Employees Union 1.5% 1.5% 1.5% Transportation, Communications and Other Utilities BC Rapid Transit Co (CUPE 7000) 3% TBA TBA TBA Note: TBA Increases will match those negotiated with other IAFF or TransLink workers. See BC Bargaining Database, Vol. 04, NO. 03 July 2011: Settlement Summaries at: http://www.bcbargaining.ca/reports/2011/july/sev04n03.pdf. Public sector settlements: Percentage increase in wages and salaries 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 Federal employees Canada Revenue Agency Public Service Alliance 1.50% 1.50% Municipal employees (CUPE) Kelowna 1.25% 1.25% 1.50% 1.50% North Cowichan 2.00% 2.50% 2.50% 3.00% Penticton 0% 1.00% 1.00% 1.00% Revelstoke 1.25% 1.25% 1.50% 1.50% Salmon Arm 1.25% 1.25% Transportation, Communications and Other Utilities: Percentage increase in wages and salaries 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 Canadian Freightways (Teamsters, Loc 31) 0% 1.50% 2.50% Canadian National Railway (CAW) 2.40% 2.60% 3.00% 3.00% Canadian Pacific Railway (CAW, Loc 101) 3.00% 0% 3.00% 3.00% See BC Bargaining Database, Vol. 04, NO. 02 April 2011: Settlement Summaries at: http://www.bcbargaining.ca/reports%5c2011%5capril%5csev04n02.pdf Public sector settlements: Percentage increase in wages and salaries 2010 2011 2012 2013 Federal employees Treasury Board of Canada (PSA) Education and Library Science 1.75% 1.50% 2.00% Program and Administration 1.75% 1.50% 2.00% Operational Services 1.75% 1.50% 2.00% Municipal employees (CUPE) Quesnel 0% 1.50% 2.00% Summerland 0% 1.50% 1.75% Kamloops 2.00% 2.00% 2.00% Transportation, Communications and Other Utilities CN Railway Company (Teamsters CTY) 2.40% 3.00% 3.00% See BC Bargaining database, Vol. 04, NO. 01 January 2011: Settlement Summaries at: www.bcbargaining.ca/reports%5c2011%5cjanuary%5csev04n01.pdf. U102 11

Average housing prices for major metropolitan areas A comparison of average housing prices for Census Metropolitan Areas (CMA) across Canada shows that the Vancouver CMA and the Victoria CMA had the highest average housing prices in Canada in 2009 and 2010. In 2010, the average price of a house in Vancouver (CMA) was $925,852 compared to $606,617 in Toronto (CMA), $490,128 in Edmonton (CMA), and $376,625 in Winnipeg (CMA). Average price ($) of absorbed single-detached units (ranked using 2010 prices, from highest to lowest) CMA* YTD 2010 YTD 2009 % change Vancouver CMA $925,852 $905,011 2.3% Victoria CMA $635,664 $668,875-5.0% Toronto CMA $606,617 $582,123 4.2% Greater Toronto Area (GTA) $591,551 $563,802 4.9% Abbotsford CMA $562,751 $540,985 4.0% Calgary CMA $514,466 $547,795-6.1% Edmonton CMA $490,128 $543,243-9.8% Regina CMA $438,979 $382,043 14.9% Saskatoon CMA $380,600 $383,234-0.7% Oshawa CMA $378,405 $356,513 6.1% Winnipeg CMA $376,625 $369,320 2.0% * Includes surrounding areas. BCTF Research table with data extracted from CMHC reports for a sample of Metropolitan areas. Source: CMHC. (2011). Table 4.1: Average Price ($) of Absorbed Single-detached Units. Housing Now Housing market information (by CMA). www03.cmhcschl.gc.ca/catalog/productlist.cfm?cat=70&lang=en&fr=1300138558358 12 U102

Average rents for one-, two-, and three-or-more-bedroom apartments In October 2010, Vancouver had the highest average rents for two-bedroom and three-ormore-bedroom apartments in a comparison of 18 Canadian cities. In October 2010, the average monthly rent for a two-bedroom apartment was $700 in Montreal, $881 in Regina, $1,015 in Edmonton, and $1,195 in Vancouver. Average rents in privately initiated rental apartment structures of 3 units and over (October 2010) City/town 1 Bed. 2 Bed. 3+ Bed. Abbotsford $655 $785 $875 Calgary $894 $1,069 $1,057 Edmonton $843 $1,015 $1,171 Halifax $732 $891 $1,146 Kelowna $740 $898 $1,018 Lethbridge $734 $845 $865 Montreal $627 $700 $860 Nanaimo $648 $789 $957 North Bay $662 $816 $898 Ottawa $877 $1,048 $1,312 Prince George $592 $709 $794 Regina $742 $881 $1,058 Saskatoon $765 $934 $959 St. John's $649 $725 $761 Toronto $949 $1,123 $1,322 Vancouver $940 $1,195 $1,420 Victoria $806 $1,024 $1,223 Winnipeg $649 $837 $1,056 BCTF Research table with data for a sample of cities Source: CMHC. (2010). Rental Market Statistics. www.cmhcschl.gc.ca/odpub/esub/64725/64725_2010_b02.pdf?fr=1298588171254 U102 13

14 U102

U102 15

16 U102

U102 17

:mf/tfeu 18 U102