Digital Signatures for SharePoint Rodd Schlerf ARx - FDA Markets Manager fda@arx.com Jonathan Schreiber ARx - SE Manager ARX 855 The Folsom most St. widely Suite 939 deployed San Francisco, signature CA engine (415) in 839 the 8161 FDA regulated www.arx.com industries sales@arx.com
About the Speaker I work for a digital signature vendor I will not be speaking about my company s product, instead I will be referencing best practices and strategies being used in the industry as a whole Rodd Schlerf Life Science Practice Manager ARx, Inc. FDA@arx.com
ARx Company Overview ARx: the world s largest supplier of standard digital signatures. CoSign: used by more organizations than all alternatives combined. ARx has domain expertise and CoSign has a dominant market share in highly regulated and security minded industries, and government. Life Sciences Architectural, Engineering & Construction US Federal, State and & Local Gov t Finance, Legal & Insurance Healthcare Payers & Providers Labs, Research & Education EU & Other Global Gov t Energy & Petrochem
ARx CoSign in Life Sciences 9 of the top 10 BioPharmas >50% of the top 25 And hundreds altogether 10 of the top 20 Medical Device Companies 7 of the top 10 Clinical Research Organizations > 40 CROs all together + the in-house clinical operations of many sponsors And many of the leading Academic Research Organizations US Department of Health & Human Services And many other US, EU and ROW government agencies and departments 20,000+ Investigators Sites, IRBs, Labs & Clinical Research Associates And the world s largest Leading Clinical Technology Vendors EDC, IVRS, epro, CDMS, AERS, CTMS, etmf, ELN, LIMS, SDMS Retail Pharmacy Chain Food Manufacturer Beverage Manufacturer Cosmetics Company
Agenda Why use Digital Signatures? Where are they being used? How are they being used? Q&A
esignature Vendors
Why Digital Signatures? Digital Signatures are standard electronic signatures. In the US these standards are known as FIPS PUB 186-3, FIPS PUB 180-3, and ITU-T X.509v3. These same standards are recognized, endorsed and adopted by governments, industries, and software vendors globally under NIST, ETSI, ISO, OASIS, IETF, and W3C.
Signer / ID Verification Digital Signature(s) embedded in Electronic Record = Digitally Signed Electronic Records that can be fully trusted independent of the vendor, the vendor s technology, the signer(s) and the signer s organization. Self-contained, Portable and Sustainable signature record that is verifiable across Geographies, Organizations, Technologies and Time.
Verification the 3 I s Visible Signature: Embedded Metadata: Identity Intent Integrity Digital Signatures are NOT just an electronic replacement for Pen & Paper!
Digital Signatures in Life Sciences
Where are digital signatures relevant? in any business application in the enterprise or in the cloud Enterprises and Government Software ISVs and VARs SaaS Services And Clouds An ever-present, secure, and consistent signature service for employees to sign anytime / anywhere Add value to your technology investments and seamlessly complete your business process automation A robust, scalable, and easy-to-integrate signature engine for signing from any mobile computing device
Relevance for Enterprises & Government An ever-present, secure, and consistent signature service for employees to sign anytime / anywhere Digital signatures are being used throughout enterprises in both FDA GxP regulated and non-regulated operations. Work Instructions Test Plans GCP GxP Site Visit Reports HR Validation Documents CTMS EMR / EHR i9 QMS EDM Many organizations use digital signatures extensively in integrated with SharePoint for highly regulated applications including their core Quality Management Systems. C o m m o n E n t e r p r i s e A p p l i c a t i o n s Legal Informed Consents Training Records SOPs Regulatory Packets IP CLM ELN Patent Documents cgmp Electronic Batch Records MES R&D Chain of Custody Recipes Lab Reports LIMS GLP 1572 etmf ERP Certificates of Analysis AP/AR Contracts & Agreements Purchasing Service Reports Orders Drawings ECOs Invoices CAD Product Samples NDA / CDA Approvals Sales & Marketing Quotes & Proposals CRM
Relevance for SaaS Services & Clouds A robust, scalable, and easy-to-integrate signature engine for signing from any mobile computing device. Many large (private) cloud applications and (public) SaaS services in the life sciences market use digital signatures as required by the FDA for open systems. Many of these clouds use SharePoint as the collaborative web application and signing interface. C o m m o n C l o u d A p p l i c a t i o n s SharePoint QMS CTMS CLM EMR / EHR Drug Samples Contracts & Agreements Capital Purchase Requests etmf HR i9 eclinical Shared Services Patient Assistance & Reimbursements Investigator Portals Virtual Pharma Collaboration Site Visit Reports M&A Secure Workspace
Relevance for Software ISVs & VARs Add value to your technology investments and seamlessly complete your business process automation Many leading SaaS and independent software vendors (ISV) already support digital signatures, and more and more are layering their applications on top of SharePoint. Most any eform, workflow, EDM/ECM or other business application can be integrated with digital signatures. e F o r m s E D M / E C M & W o r k f l o w C u s t o m W e b A p s SCORE
Components of a Proper Digital Signature The (3) C s of a Proper Digital Signature 1. Compliance 2. Choice 3. Control
1. Compliance Compliance with Digital Signature Standards CoSign is standard digital signature implementation. These standards include ITU-T X.509v3, and the US designation published by NIST - FIPS PUB 186-3, FIPS PUB 180-3. Compliance with FDA Requirements 11.30 Controls for Open Systems: Persons who use open systems to create, modify, maintain, or transmit electronic records shall employ procedures and controls designed to ensure the authenticity, integrity, and, as appropriate, the confidentiality of electronic records from the point of their creation to the point of their receipt. Such procedures and controls shall include those identified in 11.10, as appropriate, and additional measures such as document encryption and use of appropriate digital signature standards to ensure, as necessary under the circumstances, record authenticity, integrity, and confidentiality. http://www.arx.com/industries/digital-signature-for-life-sciences-legal-compliance Compliance with EU Directive Compliance with other Global Standards These same digital signature standards are recognized, endorsed and adopted by other governments and industries, as well independent standards bodies and software vendors under ISO, ETSI, OASIS, IETF, and W3C.
1. Compliance Digital Signatures are the 3 rd wave of 21 CFR Part 11 electronic signature/record compliance strategies
2. Choice A proper Digital Signature system should not be: An eforms solution A Workflow solution A Document Management solution Instead, the Digital Signature system should be a signature engine that easily integrates with an organization s preferred technologies Sign directly within common document authoring tools Sign directly within enterprise business systems Sign within a web application with a browser from any mobile computing device
3. Control It is ourphilosophy that our clients and partners should (must) have the freedom to choose and control the methods, policies, procedures and technologies that best fit their organizational governance and SOPs. You should not be required to re-engineer your business because of the narrow specifications and requirements of some outside party or vendor You already have ID proofing procedures and strategies your HR and IT including ARx. CoSign adapts to your polices, procedures and Security Policies, your Customer & Supplier Screening Policies, and other complementary technologies - not the other way around. supporting technologies and services You already have user-provisioning and user-management systems You already have authentication methods
Total Cost of Ownership The price of digital signature solutions has come down dramatically in the past decade as technology advances and more vendors compete. However the total cost of ownership (TCO) still varies significantly from one approach to another. June, 1 2007 Issue: The State of eclinical Technology The Value of Digital Signatures in eclinical Applications www.actmagazine.com/appliedclinicaltrials/article/articledetail.jsp?id=431927
Total Cost of Ownership 1,000 User Analysis
Total Cost of Ownership It is not just the price of the software licenses and digital certificates that make up the total cost of ownership 10 other things to consider: 1. What is the cost to validate and qualify the system? How does vendor support? 2. How does the system support 21CFR part 11 for MS Office signing? 3. Are licenses from Adobe required to sign PDFs? What PDF viewers are supported? 4. What is the cost/effort to integrate with various business aps? How about validation? 5. Can signing be performed from any PC, MAC or any mobile computing device? 6. Are licenses transferrable? Is there any restriction on # signatures? Any applications? 7. How are digital certificates/keys generated, renewed, refreshed and revoked? 8. How are users managed, and what is the associated system administration cost? 9. How long does the system take to deploy and be operational? Is the system a shared service or a dedicated product? 10. What experience and support can the vendor provide in terms of HIPPA and FDA compliance, or compliance with specific country requirements?
Summary Digital Signatures are not just a replacement for paper. Each digitally signed electronic records contains the (3) I s. Signer Identity/Intent, Document Integrity Trust can be established simply by accepting one-time trust in the public root certificate (public ID) of the signing organization. Digital Signatures are being used extensively throughout life science enterprise and public / private clouds. The (3) C s of a Proper Digital Signature system include: 1. Compliance: with digital signature standards, FDA and other regulatory requirements, US, EU and other country specific requirements. 2. Choice: choose the best digital signature engine. Choose your preferred eform(s), workflow automation system(s), EDM/ECM(s) and other complimentary technologies. 3. Control: govern your business according to your own policy, procedure and enforcement systems. The vendor / system should adopt to you, not vice versa. And the 4 th C - Cost-Effective. Consider the total cost of ownership (TCO) including 3 rd party products and services.
Thank You! Rodd Schlerf Life Science Practice Manager ARx, Inc. FDA@arx.com