CITY OF SANDUSKY LOCAL LANDMARK APPLICATION THE KINGSBURY BUILDING COLUMBUS AVENUE, SANDUSKY, OH

Transcription

1 CITY OF SANDUSKY LOCAL LANDMARK APPLICATION THE KINGSBURY BUILDING COLUMBUS AVENUE, SANDUSKY, OH

2 1702 JOSEPH LLOYD PARKWAY W I LLOUGHBY, OH MAROUSBROTHERS. COM May 26, 2016 City of Sandusky Landmark Commission 222 Meigs Street, Sandusky, OH RE: Kingsbury Building - Local Landmark Consideration Dear Members of the Commission: First, I would like to start off by congratulating and thanking you for serving the City of Sandusky in this most important, and newly formed, role. Your community has so many worthwhile assets in need of protection and recognition. It is my sincere hope that, in the years to come, dozens of applications follow this one; each with as good a story of historical significance for the Sandusky community as the one prior! Second, I would just like to add a few personal remarks regarding the Kingsbury Building application that we have prepared for your review and consideration. To look at the building as it stands today, particularly if you've already seen photos of what it originally looked like, you may question why we would seek to locally landmark the building. But, that is precisely why. Yes, the building is a little less whole; however, the Kingsbury building has served its community and, to this day, sits waiting for an opportunity to become relevant and a9tive again - if just given the chance. This has been a dark shuttered corner of the central downtown commercial district for over a decade. The building has seen better days and is currently vacant. People passing by may never understand, have compassion for or gain an appreciation for its past unless it is documented and celebrated. Only then, can a building like this one be embraced by the community. I think the current generation has an obligation to the next generation to help them understand what roles a building played in the community. I know it's "just bricks and mortar" but this particular building made quite a "real estate sacrifice" in 1923 when it lost one,

3 third of its footprint... forever altering the Kingsbury Block. That should not be the deciding factor in its evaluation and fate. In my opinion, the purpose of local landmark designation is threefold; first, to recognize a building for its historic or architectural significance, second, to help preserve its character or character defining features and, third, to have oversight over decisions that could adversely affect the building itself or the surrounding architecture - particularly in the case of demolition. It is easy to see that the building does not look like it did when it was originally constructed and hasn't for over nine decades but, alteration aside, the Kingsbury Building has been a consistent part of the community landscape on Columbus Avenue since Consider how very different the block would look had it been removed completely when the Commercial Banking & Trust Co. building was constructed. Every building in Sandusky has the potential to tell a story we choose to tell the Kingsbury's today. We hope you like it as much as we do. Enjoy and thank you again for your thoughtful review. Sincerely, Marous Brothers Construction, Inc. Sharon Trsek, LEEP AP Architectural Historian

4 Preparing Your Application: CITY OF SANDUSKY LANDMARK COMMISSION 222 Meigs Street Sandusky, Ohio Phone (419) LANDMARK DESIGNATION APPLICATION Please type or use black ink and use paper no larger than 11 x 17 for the required supporting i n f o r m a t i o n. City s t a f f is a v a i l a b l e to a d v i s e in t h e preparation of applications. Filing Your Application: When completed, the attached application will initiate consideration of a property for designation as a local historic landmark. The application will enable the Sandusky Landmark Commission to determine whether the property qualifies for designation. *The guidelines developed for this application are based on the evaluation process set forth in Chapter 1161 of the City of Sandusky s Code of Ordinances. 1. Name of Property Historic Name: Current Name: 2. Location Please include the full street address of the property, including its local jurisdiction. Parcel Identification Numbers (PIN) can be found by contacting the Erie County Auditor s office or website. Street Address: City/Town/Jurisdiction: PIN Number: 3. Owner Information (If more than one, list primary contact) Name: Address: Phone:

5 4. Applicant/Contact Person (If other than owner) Name: Address: Phone: 5. General Data/Site Information A. Date of construction and major additions/alterations: B. Number, type and date of construction of outbuildings: C. Approximate lot size or acreage: D. Architect, builder, carpenter, and/or mason: E. Original use: F. Present use: 6. Classification A. Category (building(s), structure or site): Building A building, is created principally to shelter any form of human activity. (i.e.: house, barn, hotel, church, school, theater, stable) Structure - The term "structure" is used to distinguish from buildings constructions made usually for purposes other than creating human shelter (i.e.: tunnel, bridge, highway, silo) Site - A site is the location of a significant event, a prehistoric or historic occupation or activity, or a building or structure, whether standing, ruined, or vanished, where the location itself possesses historic, cultural, or archeological value regardless of the value of any existing structure. (i.e.: battlefield, cemeteries, designed landscape) B. Ownership (check one): Private Public

6 C. Number of Contributing and non-contributing resources on the property: A contributing building, site, structure, or object adds to the historic associations, historic architectural qualities, or archeological values for which a property is significant because it was present during the period of significance, relates to the documented significance of the property, and possesses historic integrity or is capable of yielding important information about the period. Contributing Non-Contributing Buildings Structures Objects Sites D. Previous field documentation (when and by whom): E. National Register status and date (listed, eligible, study list): Please contact the National Register Coordinator at the State Historic Preservation Office to determine National Register status. 7. Supporting Documentation (attach to application on separate sheets) A. Required Documents Eleven (11) copies of the application shall be submitted as well as one (1) digital application B. Required Photographs Digital photographs shall be submitted. Please include a printout of the images. To save paper and ink, as many as nine images may be placed on a single 8 X 10 sheet of paper, though images should be a least 3 ¼ X 2 ½. Proofs may be in black and white on regular paper. For buildings and structures, include all facades and at least one (1) photo of all other contributing and non-contributing resources. Also include at least one (1) photo that shows the main building or structure within its setting. For sites, include overall views and any significant details. Photos must be identified with the name of the property, its address or location, and the date.

7 C. Maps Include two (2) maps; one (1) clearly indicating the location of the property in relation to the local community, and one (1) showing the boundaries of the property. Tax maps with the boundaries of the property are preferred, but survey or sketch maps are acceptable. Sketch maps should reflect, describe and l a b e l a l l b u i l d i n g s, structures, objects or s i t e s, w i t h i n t h e p r o p e r t y boundary. Please show street names and numbers and all structures on the property. Mapping information may be obtained from the Erie County Auditor s website: D. Historical significance (Applies to all classifications) Note a n y s i g n i f i c a n t e v e n t s, p e o p l e, a n d /or f a m i l i e s a s s o c i a t e d w i t h t h e property. Please clearly define the significance of the property in the history. (For example, the property may have been the birthplace of an influential citizen, represent historical patterns of commercial or agricultural development, or served as an important center of community activity). Include all major owners. Please include a bibliography of sources consulted. E. Architectural description, significance and integrity (Applies to buildings, structures and objects) For buildings and structures, describe, including exterior architectural features, additions, remodeling, and alterations. Also describe significant outbuildings. Context of the history (For example, the building or structure might be one of a town s only surviving examples of a Greek Revival building, or it may be a unique local interpretation of the Arts and Crafts movement. An object might be a statue designed by a notable sculptor.) Include a statement describing how the building or structure currently conveys its historic integrity. For example, does it retain elements of its original design, m a t e ri a l s, l o c a t i o n, w o r k m a n s h i p, s e t t i n g, h i s t o ri c a s s o c i a t i o n s, or f e e l i n g, o r a n y c o m b i n a t i o n t h e r e o f? Please include a bibliography of sources consulted. F. Property boundary, significance and integrity (Applies to all classifications) Describe the land area to be designated, address any prominent landscape features. Clearly explain the significance of the land area proposed for designation and its historical relationship to the building(s) or structure(s) located within the property boundary or, in the case of sites, the historical event or events that make the land area significant. For buildings and structures, the designated land area may represent part of or the entire original parcel boundaries, or may encompass vegetative buffers or important outbuildings. For sites, the designated area may encompass a landscape that retains its historic integrity (i.e. a battlefield encompassing undisturbed historic view sheds).

8 8. Signatures Applicant: Date: I have read the general information on landmark designation provided by the City of Sandusky Landmark Commission and affirm that I support landmark designation of the property defined herein. Owner: Date:

9 Kingsbury Building Local Landmark Application Supporting Documentation Appendices Section B Required Photos Section C Maps Section D Historical Significance Section E Architectural Significance Section F Property Boundary

10 Section B: Required Photographs All photographs were taken by Marous Brothers Construction Photo Descriptions and Camera Direction Image 0001 Front Façade, camera facing east. Image 0002 Front Façade in perspective, camera facing north / slightly northeast. Image 0003 Detail of oriole window projection and masonry detailing to accentuate window openings on front elevation (cornice also in view), camera facing upward / east. Image 0004 Detail of Kingsbury abutment to Commercial Banking & Trust Co. building at their front (Columbus Avenue) elevations, camera facing east. Image 0005 Front Façade in perspective, camera facing east/slightly southeast. Image 0006 Full Block view of Columbus Avenue frontage from East Washington Row (far right) to East Market Street (far left), camera facing north / slightly northeast. Image 0007 Front Façade of Commercial Savings & Trust Bank part of original Kingsbury Block parcel, facing east. Image 0008 Rear elevation taken from shared alley located in the center of the block midway between E. Washington Row to the south and E. Market Street to the north, camera facing west. Image 0009 Rear elevation taken from rear corner of alley behind Commercial Banking & Trust looking up toward Kingsbury Building, camera facing upward / west. Image 0010 Rear elevation taken from front corner of rear alley directly behind Kingsbury Building looking up toward Kingsbury Building & Commercial Savings & Trust Co. building, camera facing upward / southwest. Image 0011 Rear elevation of Kingsbury Building and side elevation of Commercial Savings & Trust Co. building where they meet / terminate, camera facing west. Image 0012 Rear elevation of Kingsbury upper floors and elevator penthouse, camera facing upward / northwest. Image 0013 Rear elevation taken from 3 rd floor window looking onto single story rooftop, camera facing downward / east. Image 0014 First floor interior taken from rear corner looking toward far North corner at Columbus Avenue, camera facing northwest. Image 0015 Detail interior column capitol and stamped tin ceiling panels, camera facing upward.

11 Image 0016 Detail decorative plasterwork along stairwell wall at first floor, camera facing upward / northwest. Image 0017 Detail at 2 nd floor banister, baluster and newel post at top of straight run stairwell, camera facing northwest. Image nd floor double loaded corridor (typical for 3 rd floor as well) and millwork in original finish, camera facing south. Image 0019 Detail of office fronting Columbus Avenue with plaster wall and ceiling finish and millwork in original finish (typical), camera facing northwest. Image 0020 Detail monumental staircase with open string and original millwork finish, camera facing east.

12 Image 0001 Image 0002 Image 0003 Image 0004

13 Image 0005 Image 0006 Image 0007 Image 0008

14 Image 0009 Image 0010 Image 0012 Image 0011

15 Image 0013 Image 0014 Image 0015 Image 0016 Image 0017

16 Image 0019 Image 0018 Image 0020

17 Section C: Maps USGS Topographic Map Source citation: A USGS Topographic Map (7.5 Minute Series) established by the U.S. Department of the Interior has been provided of the Sandusky Quadrangle in Sandusky, Ohio. A small red circle on the map identifies the location of the subject property. Tax Sketch Map / Property Card / Pictometry Aerial Source citation: The Property Record Card is a dynamically generated PDF available for viewing and download by the Erie County Auditor s Office. The Property Record Card summarizes the property's data and the pictometry page provides an aerial image of the building within the context of its neighborhood. GIS parcel file last updated 5/24/2016. Sanborn Fire Insurance Map Source citation: Sandusky Library Historical Collections, Archive Room (microfiche format and hardbound book). Fair Use copyright. Dating from 1913, the Sanborn map collection within the archive room at the Sandusky Library consists of a uniform series of large scale maps and microfiche depicting the commercial, industrial, and residential sections of Sandusky. Dating as far back as 1867 in some US communities, the maps were designed to assist fire insurance agents in determining the degree of hazard associated with a particular property and therefore show the size, shape, and construction of dwellings, commercial buildings, and factories as well as fire walls, locations of windows and doors, sprinkler systems, and types of roofs. The maps also indicate widths and names of streets, property boundaries, building use, and house and block numbers.

18 U.S. DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR 82 45' 55000mE D S W OO mN 3 40' ' 30" FEET 41 30' Bay Point ER ATE 57 5 OHIO 7.5-MINUTE SERIES CO N F ED 600 Johnson Island 42' 30" 3 56! " # DR 41 30' 575 Confederate Stockade Cem SANDUSKY QUADRANGLE Bay Point Shoal U. S. GEOLOGICAL SURVEY 45 Moseley Channel 575 Cedar Point DR 575 C L IF F E IS LAN D Lake Erie SAN DUS KY - PEL E Y - KEL LEY ISL A ND SANDU SK SAN DUS KY - 94 PUT IN B AY CO A W A T CO OT RIE E Cedar Point Cedar Point Marina FEET Sandusky Bay W 57 5 IL LO W DR Battery Park Marina PER DR T W AY DR W AY RE O S O PETER SON LN W AY 57 5 AN Br LF Grid Zone Designation 17T RD OR O W CRE EK RD LL h tc Di Bo h it c h D AHARI D KA L tc 625 au D TA YL Taylor Ditch RD OR SCALE 1: RD TA YL 0.5 RANSO M RD 1 3 KILOMETERS 1 METERS MILES FEET 5000 OOK STA 650 FOX 6000 S RT HO CU T CUT 3 RD ' CONTOUR INTERVAL 5 FEET NORTH AMERICAN VERTICAL DATUM OF 1988 This map was produced to conform with the National Geospatial Program US Topo Product Standard, A metadata file associated with this product is draft version mN 250 Schle ssma n Dit ch Local Connector Local Road Secondary Hwy 4WD X W Interstate Route QUADRANGLE LOCATION Gypsum Kelleys Island Castalia Sandusky Huron Bellevue Kimball Milan ADJOINING 7.5' QUADRANGLES 82 37' 30" ROAD CLASSIFICATION Ramp mE Expressway OHIO 41 22' 30" RD RD. US Route / SANDUSKY, OH 2013 H State Route NSN. NGA REF NO. U S G S X 2 4 K ,000-m Square ID Lin dsl ey Dit ch RANSOM RD M AIN TEN ANC E S R MB h Mulberry Creek Herb Farm * * U.S. National Grid ne os SCHE NK RD S TA CA MP BE LL ST UTM GRID AND 2013 MAGNETIC NORTH DECLINATION AT CENTER OF SHEET di GALLOWAY RD Pl um 625 D a h s D it c h HAY ES A VE 650 NA LU AP D a u t ch D i t c R 3 1 N RD GN R MILA RD 57 42' 30" Ø S RD E AV MILS MILS MN 85 US BO O MB PENTOLITE RD Boo s Di tch Keys Golf Course Perkins Cem Bogart o RD ok I «2 «2 E BOGART RD LAKE CT IN D DR! " # HULL RD LAKE F ORE ST DR E WATE RBERRY DR ON l W DR GE RD 25' ST HULL RD W WATERBE RRY D BI R Columbus Park u GALLO WAY RD D 600 W E ST W Ditch EX i ng D itch Jewish Cem! " # ATH D RP Di 0 60 mm S IA Pl RD EE 600 BRANDON HUL L 600 LU HAY ES A VE ED R He P N EN N VA YL 87 Osborn State Farm CO Imagery...NAIP, August 2011 Roads TomTom Names...GNIS, 2013 Hydrography...National Hydrography Dataset, 2011 Contours...National Elevation Dataset, 2010 Boundaries...Census, IBWC, IBC, USGS, Public Land Survey System...BLM, 2013 UG H C AV E GT ON IN M RE 250 Taylor D it ch AV E E C HWOOD DR ND 45 RD Brook LI 600 AN D CEDA R POINT RD DA CE 575 ST E RD WOO D DR 625 D Y WA N AVE IG A CH I M CL EV EL R ES A V F n EN DR IAS W O ODR ID HAY n 625 This map is not a legal document. Boundaries may be generalized for this map scale. Private lands within government reservations may not be shown. Obtain permission before entering private lands. A 57 5 VD BL LL RD 625 US M Fairview Lanes LN Ohio Business Coll Produced by the United States Geological Survey North American Datum of 1983 (NAD83) World Geodetic System of 1984 (WGS84). Projection and meter grid: Universal Transverse Mercator, Zone 17T foot ticks: Ohio Coordinate System of 1983 (north zone) SE AL e Cr 650 P EA N LA Li l e s Di t ch ND KY O RT SH 55 ERS 575 DR 650 FOX RD 57 5 BA YV NS I EW ET L LN N I OH MATTH ES AVE RD D OA ILR RA RD BO NASA PLUM BR O O K 3 U NT SU 88 m D UB N AVE Sandusky South DR OW NA AD O E M LD GI Galloway Airport FEET NS RD SA Wilmer P ip 82 45' ERK I Griffing Sandusky Airport JEANE T T OL O E R ST UB 57 5 F O X B OR Ranch Wood Ohio Soldiers and Sailors Home Cem CA MP BE LL ST 41 22' 30" ST MI BLVD H E RA TE VE NS PAT RO L PATROL «4 E OLD GAT E TR ES 89 O! " # D SH W 625 RD PIP 575 M E RR IW DEWITT AVE LN o 625 N FEET MILL ER RD DR n E HOM 600 T ONEWAY D R STO NEW OO D DR RODS DR CAMPB ELL ST O E AV Southgate Acres R W BOGA RT RD 625 K E AV D Lincolnshire Wilmer Cem « W OD W LA E S 85 W BOGART RD ND R D EP ST T a yl or Di tch N LA 600 K OA DR STONYRIDG E k! " # EE! " # ro Sulp hur B W STRUB LL ST ST EA Erie County Fairgrounds n 57 5 H Sandusky Cem Erie County Farm Cr pe W STRUB RD 45 VE LA CR FA LLEN TIM B ER DR EATHE R RD DR Pi E FARWE L EY ST T HS 48 T T HS T 50 E AV n 2 45 ON 6 N TONE WAY W S SS RE T BU DR PROS PECT ST ES A VE 600 ST C CAM P ST n F «4 Mills Cr CL E 250 T DS MARSHAL L AVE «ER LA MI B L EL RD 575 HAY MILLS ST M C K IN CAMP ST PEAR L ST AV E IN HARR ISON ST TI FF LASALLE ST BROAD WAY ST 575 OLDS ST HURO N ST WIL SON ST E AV N O O J R SH GT M A RI LE I N WA PA N T E HU ST ^ Sandusky Speedway T R GEOR GE ST RO E PERKINS AVE Pip e Cr IN 575 H 46 T PO LN ST Holiday Estates 25' 625 F EE TR ISH Holiday Marina R AV E RIV E H PA R 600 W PERKINS AVE PO C RD 600 Hermes Dairy Farm 45 R 5 57 N n n W 42 N 90 R LA Strobel Field LV D MI H n B ST IE 45 DA ER 5TH ST 575 IN ROCKWE LL ST 600 «1 ST S T n VE SA TAYLOR ST Venetian Marina CE 6 ST CH Oando Marina 3 R D ST BU ST W OSBORN E ST 1ST ST T NS T IL S L UM AV E ST CO FI N SE T ES TI F T RRE WA YN WA NE FIN H B UCHANAN ST 600 ST ES REE U n MacArthur Park 60 0 R SE AV E R S WAY FILMORE ST PIER CE ST n C AT 88 Saint Josephs Cem Mills Creek Golf Course Mi l ls Cr 101 «Calvary Cem DE SAN FOR D ST W PER KI N S AVE 45 N DEPO T E N RO MO n C E NT R A L AVE! " # ST 89 ST CE 45 POLK ST! " # SUP ERI OR ST Baywater Estates D S n n n T TYLER ST SENE CA ST VENICE RD n S H EL BY ST F BARKER ST Saint SANDU SKY ST Marys Cem! " # N IS O ' 30" 575 HU RO NA VE n PO SANDUSKY CA RR ST VENICE RD r sc Lions Park Mill 6 R EN 575 W MONROE ST W MA «4 ST N LTO 90 L AW Cholera! Cem # " TON Z ST ING ASH WW F T SS OGONT ST AM D EA E R IE S T KE T DR SYCAMORE LINE R MA T W NE FU W RS EL I SYCA MOR E LINE W TE WA R SH O SHERM AN ST IR Deepwater Marina Cedar Point Causeway ^ ST RY 27' 30"

19 Erie County, Ohio - Property Record Card Parcel: Card: 1 GENERAL PARCEL INFORMATION Owner MAROUS DEVELOPMENT LLC Property Address COLUMBUS SANDUSKY OH Mailing Address SECOND ST 102 Land Use Legal Description Neighborhood School District OFFICES (3 STORIES OR MORE WITH ELEVATOR 6 WASHINGTON ROW CEN80' & 5 W17 1/4 OF SANDUSKY SD MAP NUMBER: 6 VALUATION Appraised Assessed Land Value $17, $6, Improvements Value $194, $68, CAUV Value $0.00 $0.00 Total Value $212, $74, LAND Land Type Acreage Depth Frontage Depth Value P1 - PRIMARY $17, AGRICULTURAL Land Type Land Usage Soil Type Acres Value SALES Date Buyer Seller Price 11/6/1998 MAROUS DEVELOPMENT DEGIDIO ANTHONY J $125,000 COMMERCIAL Property Record Card generated 5/24/2016 4:20:03 PM for Erie County, Ohio

20 File Edit Vif!Vll Favorites Tools Help Safety ~ Tools ~ ~ ~ ~ QuickSearch " Base Land Valuation Sales Sketch Tax Improvements Additions Residential Agricultural Commerrial/Industrial Comments Pictometry Levies Base Data Parcel: Owner. MAROUS DEVELOPMENT UC Back to Search Results Ltll Get help viewing property data. Address: COLUMBUS SANOUSKY OH - Save Property Report Discrepancy Copynght 2007 D1g1tal Data Tedmologles, Inc. GJS parcel shapefi/e last updated S/23/201610:JJ:02 PM. Admmistrators javascript:_dopostback('ctloosc ontentplaceholderlsmnudata','12') 8\100% ~

21 Sanborn Fire Insurance Map Sandusky, Ohio 1913 (rev. 1953)

22 Sanborn Fire Insurance Map Sandusky, Ohio 1913 (rev. 1953) Enlargement

23 Section D: Historical Significance The Parcel The Northeast corner of Columbus Avenue and Washington Row in Sandusky was owned very early on by David Campbell, publisher in 1822 of the first newspaper in the Firelands called the Clarion (the predecessor of the Sandusky Register). Campbell s home was located on this corner until he died in 1861, after which stores occupied the site. In the 1880 s, the Arnold & Henkelman Drug Store was located here. The Henkelman Drug Store later moved to the opposite side of Columbus Avenue within a storefront location at the Sloane House during Mr. Henkelman s partnership with Mr. Bechberger. 1 In 1882 William T. West bought the Campbell corner and, by 1894, the heirs of Abel Kingsbury West built the Kingsbury Block upon it. The West Brothers The West family made significant contributions to Sandusky in its early days. On June 15, 1815 William T. West was born on the home farm at Washington Mountain near Pittsfield, Massachusetts. His brother Abel Kingsbury West was born two years later on October 22, Their father was a man of prominence and decided character and their mother a woman of intelligence and energy. Passing his boyhood days upon his father s farm, Abel laid the foundation for that upright, honorable integrity that characterized his life. A limited common school education was all he ever enjoyed, but of this he made the most, and had the practical ability to use what he knew. Although of a delicate and nervous temperament, he always showed, as a boy, the same perseverance and constancy of application that marked his career as a man. 2 In his youth, William T. West also earned a common school education but sought out additional knowledge in the trades first in brick making and later, at age sixteen, he began an apprenticeship in cabinet making. The latter was his stand by for many years. 3 In 1835, William decided to go west. Reaching Albany, he secured his first contract which was for the making of thirty tables for the State Legislative hall. During the panic of 1837, he thought he would try his luck in Cincinnati or Columbus. He arrived from the east in Buffalo where, by mistake, his baggage was put on board a boat bound for Sandusky. West swam after the boat and was picked up but the captain would not turn back and instead brought him to Sandusky. Thus, force of circumstances made Mr. West a resident of the Sandusky community. Though he may have been a reluctant citizen, his influence was important to the growth of the city. One of the happiest and most hard working men of the 1840 s was our fellow townsman, William T. West that was what the Sandusky Register printed in For over fifty years, the name William T. West was associated with the building of Sandusky. He could be called a self made man and liked to boast that his country school education had cost him only fifty cents. Soon after his arrival in Sandusky, William opened a cabinet shop on Water Street; two 1 Walter s Peptonized Port Sold in Sandusky web blog post. Sandusky History. Sandusky Library Historical Collections, September 15, Web. May 20, The Firelands Pioneer Volume XIII. Firelands Historical Society, Norwalk, OH, 1878, pg Upton, Harriet Taylor. History of the Western Reserve Volume 2. New York: The Lewis Publishing Company, 1910., pg 1243.

24 years later he sold his business to begin a new endeavor with his younger brother, Abel, in the business of selling general merchandise. A.K. traveled from New York, where he had been working as a manager of a retail department at Quackenbosh & Lee (a large dry goods house) in Troy New York, and entered into a partnership with William T. to commence a dry goods business. 4 For 45 years, the store was known as W.T. & A.K. West, and, for about ten years, their store was in a frame building on Water Street. They remained associated not only in that enterprise but in various other large and successful ventures. The brothers were a combination considered ideal, William T. being aggressive and resourceful, and A.K., economical, cool and conservative. Eventually, they moved their store to one of their own buildings erected on Columbus Avenue, which later became the south part of their hotel, the West House. This was a great venture for them at the time and taxed the skill and energy of them both to their utmost. 5 Although the West House was begun in 1848 initially for business purposes, the entire building was not completed and opened as a hotel until just before Sandusky hosted the Ohio State Fair in the Fall of Located on the Southwest corner of Columbus Avenue and Water Street, the West House was one of the largest hotels in the western states and long considered the finest hotel in northern Ohio. The West brothers bought fine furniture and other equipment in New York, and during the fair season, it was widely recorded that the hotel accommodated more than 2,000 guests. In later years, William T. West spent large sums of money in altering and re furnishing the West House. The hotel was popular among travelers, who could travel to Sandusky via steamers on Lake Erie. The West House was generally thought to be much larger than required for Sandusky; however, after the Civil War had been in progress a short time, the hotel was filled to capacity until the close of the war putting it on its financial feet. This was due in large part to the location of a Confederate officers prison on Johnson s Island. William T. West with a partner, Philander Gregg, traveled to Washington early on during the Civil War and were awarded a government contract to construct all of the necessary prison buildings and officers quarters on Johnson s Island where, later, thousands of Confederate prisoners were confined. 6 William T. West was also president of the first steamboat company organized in Sandusky. One of the most remarkable features of Mr. West s building achievements was that he never employed an architect, but, although not technically educated, designed his own buildings with the skill of a veteran. 7 In 1868, well after the Civil War had ended, William T. & A.K. West, constructed a 2 story limestone building at 149 East Water Street. The next year they sold the property to William Robertson who added another story to the building (today, the building is referred to as The Granary Building at 149 East Water Street). 8 Abel Kingsbury West as a business man was clear in his perceptions, cautious and experienced, and when his judgement was settled as to any course of action, he pursued it boldly and liberally. He was a model merchant, intense in his nature, strict and exacting of those in his employ, showing small 4 The Firelands Pioneer Volume XIII. Firelands Historical Society, Norwalk, OH, 1878, pg 94 5 Ibid. 6 Hansen, Helen M. At Home In Early Sandusky: Foundations For The Future. N.P., pg Upton, Harriet Taylor & Harry Gardner Cuttler. History of the Western Reserve Volume 2. New York: The Lewis Publishing Company, pg Hansen, Helen M. & Virginia Steinemann. From the Widow s Walk: A View of Sandusky Volume II. Follett House Museum: Sandusky, OH, pg. 35.

25 sympathy to the indolent and shiftless, but to those who were faithful in their duties he was a firm friend and judicious counselor. He was a regular attendant of the Presbyterian church, manifested a deep interest in its welfare and was one of its most generous supporters. He was married in 1860 to Caroline E. Wood. He was kind and sympathetic in all the relations of life and a true and faithful friend. On April 16, 1880, Abel Kingsbury West died of inflammatory rheumatism and was buried in Oakland Cemetery. His brother, William, managed A.K. s estate. In 1882 William bought the Campbell corner. The heirs of Abel, his widow and two daughters, Harriet and Mary West Anderson, became concerned when William began to acquire property in only his name on Washington Row to build what eventually was the Mahala Block. The heirs thought Columbus Avenue frontage was being deprived of depth so they went to court and in 1891 were awarded the corner lot with the addition of part of the adjoining lot on East Washington Row. In 1884, William T. West acquired the building at 201 West Water Street and made alterations to its façade. Aside from its address, that building is commonly referred to as the Cassedy West Building. 9 In 1892, West demolished several houses existing along East Washington Row and built on the portion of the parcel he owned naming the Mahala Block after his wife Lydia Mahala Todd West. Due to a depression this building spelled his financial doom. As a side note, William T. West was very optimistic that he could recover financially from his Mahala Block real estate endeavor but he died of pneumonia in 1899 at the age of The Kingsbury Block Three years after winning their court case against their Brother In Law/Uncle, William T. West, in 1894, the heirs of Abel Kingsbury West razed the existing buildings on Columbus Avenue and the adjoining East Washing Row parcels and erected the handsome Kingsbury Block, naming it after their family patriarch. The Kingsbury Block was home to dentists, physicians, attorneys, insurance companies, jewelers, and many other businesses. There was even a photography studio (proprietor C. J. Pascoe) in the Kingsbury Building for many years. As noted within the publication, From the Widows Walk, Dentists, doctors, lawyers, insurance companies, etc. leased the many offices on the second and third floors of the Kingsbury Block, where the terror children felt going to the dentist was tempered by the thrill of riding the elevator. In 1907, when the Ohio State Medical Association met in Sandusky for their annual meeting, Dr. William Graefe and Dr. H. C. Schoepfle, as well as dentists Dr. William S. Deeley, Dr. D. D. Smith, and Dr. J. K. Douglas all had their offices in the Kingsbury Block. From 1913 to 1916, the City Hall was on the third floor occupying five rooms after a fire gutted the market house were they had resided for 25 years. Most of the records were saved, and once moved in 9 Damm, Ellie. Treasure by the Bay: The Historic Architecture of Sandusky, Ohio. Cranbury, NJ: Associated University Presses, Inc., pg Upton, Harriet Taylor & Harry Gardner Cuttler. History of the Western Reserve Volume 2. New York: The Lewis Publishing Company, pg 1243.

26 to the Kingsbury building the city government was back in business. In 1915, City Hall was moved from the Kingsbury building into the former police and fire station on West Market Street. The Kingsbury building also played a role in the history of telephone service in Sandusky. The Sandusky Telephone Company, the "Home system," was founded in 1895 and had their exchange located within the Kingsbury Block. In 1922, the Sandusky Telephone Company merged with The Ohio Bell Telephone Company into one system with their combined headquarters in Cleveland. 11 They vacated the Kingsbury Block following the merger. In January of 1920, Mary West Anderson (Daughter of Abel Kingsbury) & George F. Anderson (Husband) released the dower to The Commercial National Bank of Sandusky. This bank was formed through the merger in 1903 of the Moss National Bank and the Second National Bank. In 1922, the American Banking & Trust Company also became a part of what was then the Commercial Banking & Trust Company, with capital of $200,000 and in the same year, the warranty deed was transferred from The Commercial National Bank of Sandusky to The Commercial Banking and Trust Company of Sandusky. In January 1923, The Commercial Banking and Trust Company of Sandusky began demolishing approximately 38 feet of the south end of the Kingsbury Block. They hired the local firms of Millott & Parker as Architect and Boldt Construction as Contractor to build a bank building in the Beaux Arts tradition influenced by the Neo Classical Revival. The bank opened in June 1924, while Tenants Realty acquired the remainder of the Kingsbury Block. The S.S. Kresge Company bought the building in 1929 and opened its second Sandusky location. The H. & S. Bakery leased a portion of space in 1932 and operated a retail bakery there until Kresge expanded and continued operations until about There have been many subsequent owners and tenants including retail establishments such as the Manhattan Clothing, The House of Fabrics and National Micro Computer s Inc. until November of 1998 when Marous Development purchased the property from Anthony DeGidio. The building has been fully vacant for nearly 20 years. What Remains? The Cassedy West Building (listed on the National Register of Historic Places) still stands and, though relevant to the history of West brothers, was not a structure designed or built through the W.T. & A.K West partnership. The Granary Building, later modified and expanded, (listed on the National Register of Historic Places) still stands and was designed by W.T. West. The Mahala Block, designed by W.T. West, burned to the ground in 1909, the West House hotel designed by W.T. and developed by W.T. & A.K. West, was razed in 1919, and, while the site of the Johnson s Island Civil War Prison was designated a National Historic Landmark in 1990, all of the Civil War related structures (except for the cemetery) on Johnson s Island have been destroyed. Lastly, one third of the Kingsbury Block, constructed in the memory of A.K. West, was demolished in 1922 to make way for the Commercial Banking & Trust Company. With this understood, although it s original building footprint has changed (which causes pause for consideration to the National Register of Historic Places), the remaining two thirds of the 11 Hansen, Helen. At Home In Early Sandusky: Foundations For The Future. N.P., page 24

27 former Kingsbury Block is no less historic and has presided over the gateway into the downtown commercial district for over a century. Its architecture is striking and compatible with surrounding historic structures of the same time period. The preservation of what remains of the former Kingsbury Block (now Kingsbury building) has become increasingly important as other structures built through the W.T. & A.K West partnership or, in later years, as separate West brother ventures have been lost. Works Cited Historic Narrative Sources Damm, Ellie. Treasure by the Bay: The Historic Architecture of Sandusky, Ohio. Cranbury, NJ: Associated University Presses, Frohman, Charles E. Sandusky s Yesterdays. Columbus, Ohio: The Ohio Historical Society, Hansen, Helen. At Home In Early Sandusky: Foundations For The Future. N.P., o Walter s Peptonized Port Sold in Sandusky web blog post. Sandusky History. Sandusky Library Historical Collections, September 15, Web. May 20, o A Child s Clothing in the 1850s web blog post. Sandusky History. Sandusky Library Historical Collections, April 3, Web. May 21, The Firelands Pioneer Volume XIII. Firelands Historical Society, Norwalk, OH, 1878, pg 93. Upton, Harriet Taylor. History of the Western Reserve Volume 2. New York: The Lewis Publishing Company, 1910, pg Historic Figure Sources Sandusky Library Historical Collections (website) Follett House Museum (archives) Old House Guild (archives) Cleveland Memory Collection (website)

28 Figure 1 Columbus Avenue north of Washington Row (Eleutheros Cooke residence at corner of West Washington Row & Columbus Ave. and the Arnold & Henkelman Drug Store is at the corner of East Washington Row & Columbus Ave.) Date circa 1870 s

29 Figure 2 Kingsbury Block Photograph Date 1894 (year built)

30 Figure 3 Panoramic View North from Court House of Columbus Ave. Date Unknown

31 Figure 4 Postcard View of Columbus Avenue looking South Date Circa latter half 1890 s

32 Figure 5 View of east side of Columbus Ave. to Lake. Date circa early 1900 s

33 Figure 6 Portrait Photographs of brothers William T. West (left) and Abel Kingsbury West (right) Date circa 1870 s

34 Figure 7 Postcard View of West House Corner of Columbus Ave & W. Water St. Date early 1900s At Right - Contemporary view of this location (2016)

35 Figure 8 Photographs of (top right) the officers quarters at Johnson s Island prison, (bottom right) Hoffman s battalion at Johnson s Island with prison barracks in distance, (bottom center) Yankee Guards standing post and (below left) a Johnson s Island prison lithograph of war time sketches drawn by Edward Goald. Date circa

36 Figure 9 Photograph of the Mahala Block East Washington Row Date 1892 At Right - Contemporary view of this location (2016)

37 Figure 10 Postcard View of Columbus Avenue looking South Date Unknown

38 Figure 11 Postcard View of Columbus Avenue looking South Date circa early 1900 s

39 Figure 12 View of Mahala Block fire - Photo taken from West Washington Row looking East Date November 18, 1909

40 Figure 13 View of Mahala Block fire Photo taken from East Washington Park where a crowd had gathered to watch the blaze Date November 18, 1909

41 Figure 14 View of the remains after the fire only the Louis Adolph house (right) and Kingsbury (left) remained on East Washington Row. Date November 1909

42 Figure 15 Knights of St. John parade on Columbus Avenue Date 1910

43 Figure 16 Photo postcard - east side of Columbus Avenue Date circa

44 Figure 17 Postcard View of Columbus Avenue from Interurban Station. Date circa

45 Figure 18 Postcard - Birdseye view of Columbus Avenue and Washington Park in distance Date circa.1910

46 Figure 19 Postcard view of Columbus Avenue looking North Date 1913

47 Figure 20 Postcard view of Columbus Avenue Date circa. 1922

48 Figure 21 (Left) Advertisement for Dental Office within Kingsbury Block, (Right) Photograph of tenant directory of the Kingsbury Block Date circa.1920

49 Figure 22 Kingsbury Block, Columbus Avenue & East Washington Row, as it appeared just prior to partial demolition. Date December 30, 1922

50 Figure 23 Columbus Avenue & East Washington Row, as it appeared during the construction of Commercial Banking & Trust Co. Date January November 1923

51 Figure 24 Columbus Avenue & East Washington Row, as it appeared during the construction of Commercial Banking & Trust Co. Date January November 1923

52 Figure 25 Photograph of corner at Columbus Avenue & East Washington Row. Date circa. 1924

53 Figure 26 Postcard view of Columbus Avenue looking North Date circa. late 1920 s early 1930 s

54 Figure 27 Postcard view of Columbus Avenue looking North Date circa s

55 Figure 28 Postcard view of Columbus Avenue looking North Date circa s

56 Figure 29 Photograph of the corner at Columbus Avenue & East Washington Row. Date circa s

57 Figure 30 Photograph of storefront signage at Kingsbury Building Date circa s

58 Figure 31 Contemporary photograph of the corner at Columbus Avenue & East Washington Row. Date 2016

59 Section E: Architectural Description, Significance, Integrity Like many buildings in cities and towns across the country, the Kingsbury Block does not belong to any one specific architectural style; instead, the building s commercial design borrows elements from several styles or fuses stylistic elements resulting in a hybrid composition. This was a fairly common practice for buildings designed and constructed in the late 19 th or early 20 th century. There are Romanesque revival elements such as the masonry construction, square tower, and rounded arch windows. There are Victorian elements such as the bay and oriel windows, narrow mortar joints, and dark interior millwork. There are Renaissance revival elements such as the projected centralized entrance at Columbus Avenue, the tall rectangular double hung windows, bracketed cornice and lowpitched roof. Some of fused stylistic elements, historically, included classical features such as the balustrade at the roofline on the East Washington Row elevation and decorative plasterwork on the interior, as well as Romanesque influences such as the short, robust columns within the tower and polychromatic wall treatment of contrasting light and dark masonry brick adding visual interest to the facade. A strong division exists between the upper and lower zones of the façade. The treatment can be considered a three part vertical block with clear distinction between upper and lower stories. Additionally, a pronounced difference exists between the architectural treatment of the 2 nd & 3 rd stories to that of the uppermost 4 th story which, aesthetically, is almost treated as an attic story placed atop a masonry belt course. The façade is comprised of a buff (roman) brick veneer with a very narrow joint profile laid in an elongated one third running bond pattern. The mortar joints have a high sand ratio with local aggregates. The sides of the building are masonry but are hidden from view since neighboring structures abut both elevations. The rear elevation of the building, which faces a shared alley, is generally speaking inaccessible to the public but features a red brick in a common bond pattern every seventh course. The Kingsbury Block is a four story building with full basement on a stone foundation which was, historically, (along Columbus Avenue) composed of four vertical bays defined slight setback of masonry on the 1 st and 3 rd asymmetrical bays flanking the large central portion of the façade with a tower (additional 5 th story) at the 4 th bay where Columbus Avenue and East Washington Row meet and three asymmetrical vertical bays along East Washington Row. Windows at the 2 nd and 3 rd floors are simple one over one double hung wood sash whereas, at the 4 th floor, the top sash of the double hungs are rounded. The primary elevation (facing Columbus Ave.) was, at one time, dominated at floors 2 4 by grouped wood 1/1 double hung windows. Each bay contains three windows with the center fixed window being slightly wider than the two flanking double hung windows. The only exception to this statement is evident at the fourth bay, where there exists only an angled two window configuration (both double hung), it should be noted that prior to demolition of the substantial turreted portion of the building s footprint fronting Washington Row, this two window configuration celebrated the center of the Kingsbury Block over the building s main entrance which also featured a portico. Referring to historic photographs and postcards as well as contemporary photographs, Chicago style oriel windows existed on floors 2 3 in bay configurations with continuous dentil molding occurring at the cornice, a continuous sill course, tin aprons with Doric triglyph and wreath ornament also exist. On the 4th floor, beginning at the north end of the façade, there exists; a bay window (a fixed sash flanked by two double hung sashes) topping off the oriel window configuration, then a set of three round arched

60 windows, another set of three round arched windows, then a set of two round arched windows (refer to the previous paragraph, as the windows in this location helped to set off the entrance to the Kingsbury Block), followed by a final set of three round arched windows. A continuous brick stilted arch occurs above each arched window grouping to accentuate their location on the façade. Metal elements on this structure include the oriel window panels and the decorative bracketed cornice. The Kingsbury s basement is utilitarian in design. Its first floor is a large open space which retains its original floor to ceiling heights, decorative stamped tin ceiling, plaster finished perimeter walls with some detailing, tongue & groove hardwood flooring. On the second, third and fourth floors, the remaining half of the historically u shaped circulation plan is intact with a double loaded corridor servicing small rooms on either side. Historic wood sash and millwork all remain as does the primary staircase. The elevator rails and rooftop penthouse still exist but the cab and its enclosure no longer service. By 1924, U shaped floor plan had its southern most portion of the building (including its distinctly pronounced tower) demolished to make way for the Beaux Arts style Commercial Banking & Trust Company s new building. What remains at Columbus Avenue are two thirds of what used tobe a magnificent building, now in an L shaped plan on the upper floors with the ground floor and basement rectangular in shape. While some of its architectural integrity has certainly been lost, the remaining portion is a fine example of its historic craftsmanship and architectural design. Works Cited Damm, Ellie. Treasure by the Bay: The Historic Architecture of Sandusky, Ohio. Cranbury, NJ: Associated University Presses, Hansen, Helen. From the Widow s Walk: A View of Sandusky. Sandusky, Ohio: Follett House Museum, Branch of Sandusky Library, Old House Guild Ohio Historic Inventory Form(s)

61 Section F: Property Boundary, Significance and Integrity The historic property boundary for the Kingsbury Block includes both the Kingsbury building and the Commercial Savings & Trust Co. building (now on two separate parcels) as they exist today from the northernmost wall of Kingsbury along Columbus Avenue and extending up to the sidewalk of East Washington Road and returning North to the easternmost rear wall of the Commercial Savings & Trust Co. For the purpose of local landmark designation, ideally both buildings could be linked through reference of the historic parcel; however, if only designating the Kingsbury building as a local landmark as it exists today, referring to the tax map, the parcel would begin at the northernmost wall of Kingsbury and end at the southernmost wall of Kingsbury where it meets the Commercial Banking & Trust Co. building fronting Columbus Avenue. The first block on the west side of Columbus Avenue has been built over twice, which, during the Kingsbury building s period of historic significance, was the site of the Sloane House Hotel from 1881 to the early 1950s and U.S. Post Office from 1857 to Its first transformation came with LaSalle s Department Store replacing the Sloane House and a pair of 3 story buildings replacing the Post Office. Later, the contemporary design and construction of the County building and parking garage consumed the entire block fronting Columbus Avenue as it exists today. Therefore, the historic integrity of the west side of Columbus Avenue within this first block is lost. Alternately, the first block on the east side of Columbus Avenue has experienced some alteration over the past century but retains its historic setback and composition as well as its architectural integrity, particularly at each end fronting Columbus Avenue with the Commercial Banking & Trust Co. building and Kingsbury anchoring the East Washington end and the Stone s Block anchoring the East Market Street end. Columbus Avenue serves as the main artery into the downtown Commercial District and Washington Park providing a green wall up to Washington Row where the setting changes from landscaping to architecture, the property s significance is center stage. Many Sanduskians are likely unaware of the history associated with the Kingsbury building or the impact that the West brothers efforts had on this great city. While some of its architecture has been lost, the story of the Kingsbury is worth preserving to tell for generations to come.

62 1. No. 4. Present Namt1(s)? <3 MANHAT'rAl'i CLO'l'HING CO. Erie 5. Other Name{s) -3-.-l-o-ca_t_io_n_o_f_N_e_g_a_tl_v_es H & S nrikcry Stor~, rextoe Jewelry Store Old Hnu~rn Gu'i1n K,wel D1!p:1rt.,11,.,nt St1H 1~ Ii. Specific location Columbun Ave. 7. City or Town If Rural, Township &. Vicini Ly ~~nnd11!ij~, 8. Sile Plan ')'Ith North Arrow 0 V ') t',wo.1\,,.,~to~ fl.~ 16. Thematic ategory r~-n 17. Dale(s) or Period c Style or Design 19. Architect or Engineer 20. Contractor or Builder 28. No. ol Stories 29. Basement? 30. Foundation Material ntone 31. Wall Construction h Roof Type & Material No. ol Bays 21. Original Use, If apparent Fron( Side.--...c.f''- 1'-<;..;.)..;..r...:1-'-~!:..:. ; J134. Wall Treatment 22. Present Use rnen' fl cl o l:h in. store 35. Pian Shape L _ U.T.M. Reference R o"er '\,,, t& R e t t y. S 1rnp~;on e t.a. l Interior!!QOd 1-.>---- J~ Yes Kl No 0 Addition 0 Altered ~ Moved 0 / I '71 I 3 ls I? lo l t IO I I ii \.sl'i lo I s:i~ Id l-;;?-;::;-::-:-:-;-: :-:---=--1--e-xt_erl_;or=l ~O::::O::::c'l===l 23. Ownership Public O 36. Changes -!J-. _C_o_o_rd_1_n_a_te_s...,... Private~x (Explain 24. Owner's Name & Address, in #42) Lat. L_o_ng= if known 37. Condition /one Eas11nr1 Northing 25. Open to Yes:Jlc 38. Preservation Yes~ -,o =-S-it_e_1""' -,------S,-t-ru_c_tur_e_O:,:-.. Public? l im.i tecl No_ O_ Underway? No.O Buildino 1(J Object D 26. Local Contact Person or Organization 39. Endangered? , nNa11onal Yesll 12. lslt YesO Olrl Hou~;e Guild ByWhat? R_e_g_is_L_er_? N_o_r.a_-+- E_l_ig_i_b_le_? N_o_cr_.lt-::2::-7.=::- 0:...th:..:.e_r..,!S.!.u:::.rv.:::..::e..:.ys::::,_ in_:::..w::::...:h'--ic::..h::.:.l_n_c_lu_d_e_d. 13. Part o f Eslab. Yes LJ 14. District Yes l31_ V-is-ib_l_e_f_ro_m Y_es_ri!J_ Hist. Dist.? No ~I Potent'!? No O Public Road? No o 15. Name of Established District Yes 0 No ID 41. Distance from and l 2 1 Frontage on Road BO 1 I: I i; I, l I 42. Further Oescrip11on o l Important Features P.rick p;:i.int.p.<i facac'le. Oriel winnow!; on 2nd and Jrd storier;. One ori.p.l winnow at north Ernd of 4th floor, other /.i.th floor wi.ndowr. Rre ningle n:::irrow roundec1 arr.h. Pail,t C!r'l metrl. f::inci.worl< bf~twt~en ntorien hetween wi.ndown. Woocten hr::icl<:etf, on overha nr:,, 1~. imitation mnrble tile on lnt floor fron!. 43. His tory and Significance Or1v.inRll.v nart of the Kinp;nb11ry building, tht~ r;out h nicle of which h;:in th-' (!n torn d 0wn. 44. Description ol Environment and Outbuildings 45. Sources o f Information 46. Prepared by OHG 47. Organization Olct Hou f;e Gui..1d : '18. Date. 49. Rcv!!iion Dc.>.'o{:,). (..

63 (JHIO HIST' 'RIC INVENTORY Ohio Historical Center Columbus, Ohio /3 6. Specific Location \ J...3~- '~ o GA,,,.-w.. n.j/ C\.l'(. 16. Thematic.Category 28. No. of Stories ~_ - _ : _1 ~29. Basement? ;;.. 4 Yes Er"' No D...! <::::.'" t, l 31. Wall Construction...)v-,\,l,'\..1-W.,ft,.,_ -8.-S~lt~e~P~la~n.;...;;w~lt~h~ IJJ '-o:-rt:-h-a:-r-ro_w N--~~1~9~_-A~r-c~h~ ite- c'"'.'t_o_r-:e~n-g:-in_e_e_r -tt ~'( l lni..~~ ~ a il 32. Roof Type_ & ~aterial S r,,r-~~s.-- ~.. '= 20. Contractor or Builder, -.. -l133. No. ol Bays 1 -Z 1 ~ Original Use, If apparent Front Side ~ 11---'-,o,_:i\"-'cu'-=- -(;.)' , 'J34. Wall Treatment 22. Present Use - co'-'-*h A~ ~'-, ~ :';,-, \.(?_. iylc:'ttl'l ~uk_ ~U, 35. Plan Shape L.,a.h<1-,..:., &...,t--) ~o,.,) 1)1-lCA1'.,i,, J ot/11..,11.1 ~. ~"\' 23. Ownership U Public D 36. Changes Addition D :.:.: ~ Private GI--" (Explain Altered G" 9. Coordinates In #42) Moved O 24. Owner's Name & Address, 17. Date(s) or Period t '.,,}. '//J 30. Foundation Material C-lt_y_o_r_T_o_w_n lf_r_u_r_al-,-t-o_w_n_s-hi_p_&~v-:i-ci:-n-:it-y~'"1-:8:-.-:s::"'.t-y:-le_o_r-=-d...;.es-:i-gn.d_it1t1 _U.....,a Lat. L_o_n~g_. ii knoi n,. "',.Q.,\, ~ 37. Condition U.T.M. Reference t,~h<u.} ~ l"::('.\t,.,\... w, r,.:ily1, lnterior q.._lj~ - l.,.-'... - _IQ_v~ i~_:l>'t.._ 11 I I II I i I I I I I I I I I I I '~-=------'----,- -n---=-ex..:..:..ter...:,_i or= 9,);::; o, :;:::: J: =-:. = =.. =Jlf zone Easting Northing 25. Open to Yes Preservation Yes [!f" ;;;;.;~---~;.,_.::.-..;;._-=--i'l Public? No Q Und rway? N o 10. Site~/ Structure D L, '"' - ;.. 1 : e o Building L=r Ob1 ect D 26. Local Contact Person or Organization 39. Endangered? Yes D 1-1-._0_n_N_a_tio_n_a..,..I -Y..,.e_s_D_-,----:-1".:"2.-:l-s-:-:lt-----:-Y:-e-s-:O=-:li,,-. 1 ; /,.. By What? No 13' A_e_g_is_te_r? -,-,N_o..;.)<"...,...-+ E_l_lg_i_bl_e_?----:-":""N_o-:::(}l.=-fl 27. Other Surveys i n Which Included 13. Part of Estab. Yes D 14. District Yes~ Hist. Dist.? No~ Potent'I? No D 40. Visible from Public Road? 15. Name of Established District 41. Distance lrom and / J- Frontage on Road go' kirnt~'-- Yes EJ No D History and Significance 44. Description of Environment and Outbuildings 45. Sources of Information 46. Prepared by,, 1 ~ 1, r.,!/ :' l, 1,t & (:8,J I\ C.. \.(( I t!(.\. \J '

64 LJi ~ OD.. ~~.. ~~.. ~~.. ~.~. ~.~. ~.. ~~.. ~~.. ~~.. ~~.. ~.~. ~.~.~.. ~~.. ~~.. ~~.. ~.~. ~.~..~.~.~ ~.~.. ~~.. ~~.. ~~.. ~~.. ~~.. ~~.. ~~.. ~ V... = =-- ODD D D D D D D D D D D D IU U U IIII - I!!- CJ CJ CJCJCJ CJ CJ lol(qj CJ CJ CJ CJ CJ CJ CJ DOD D -- = ---= ---= = = DOD DD -=- -.. Cl Cl Cl Cl Cl Cl Cl (Q)lol(Q) Cl Cl Cl Cl Cl Cl Cl DOD la ~loi Cl Cl aaa Cl Cl DOD CICI aaa CICI 'liq] (QI CICI aaa CICI DOD aa aa!qi!qi aa aa DD CICI aaa CICI (QI [Q] (QI CICI aaa CICI DOD - ~ - ~ ~ \, ~ \, M \,..,...- GRANITE ASCIA I I II I I I.Ll~.iltl ~~llll~i.i I I I I I I I II I Ir- II nrn r mti I. 11 =-. D = I I I I " I ~ASONRY STOREFRONT Will-I AUJMIN~ STOREFRONT WINDOWS AND DOORS EXISTING FRONT (COLUMBUS A VENUE) ELEVATION SCALE 118" = 1'-0" V_ I_N T_ A G_ E 2_38_-_2_4_0_C_O_L_U_M_B_U_S_A_V_E_NU_E_ B_U_IL_D_IN_G_E_L_E_V_A_T_IO_N_S ~ Marous Brothers o E v E L o P M E N T a R o u P May 26, 2016 ~ c o N s T R u c T I o N