REDEVELOPMENT PLAN CITY OF LAWRENCEVILLE TAX ALLOCATION DISTRICT #2 COLLEGE CORRIDOR DRAFT DECEMBER, October 19, 2011

Transcription

1 CITY OF LAWRENCEVILLE TAX ALLOCATION DISTRICT #2 COLLEGE CORRIDOR DRAFT REDEVELOPMENT PLAN DECEMBER, 2010 October 19, 2011 Prepared for: City of Lawrenceville Prepared by:

2 TABLE OF CONTENTS Table of Contents... i Executive Summary... 2 Overview... 2 The Opportunity... 2 City of Lawrenceville TAD #2 College Corridor Qualifies as a TAD... 3 The College Corridor TAD... 3 The Plan... 4 Proposed Public Investments... 7 College Corridor TAD Benefits... 7 Introduction... 8 The Vision... 8 The Plan... 9 Geographic Boundaries (A)...10 How Residents in Lawrenceville and Gwinnett County Benefit...12 Overview of Tax Allocation Districts...12 Proposal Grounds for Exercise of Redevelopment Powers (B)...13 Why the College Corridor Area Qualifies as a Redevelopment Area...14 Summary of Project Conditions...15 Plan Vision and Goal Proposed Land Uses after Redevelopment (C)...16 Proposed Redevelopment Projects (D) Contractual Relationships (E) Relocation Plans (F) Zoning & Land Use Compatibility (G) Method of Financing / Proposed Public Investments (H) TAD Potential of City of Lawrenceville TAD #2 College Corridor...24 Proposed Public Investments...24 The Benefits of the College Corridor TAD to the City...25 Assessed Valuation for TAD (I) Historic Property within Boundaries of TAD (J) Creation & Termination Dates for TAD (K) Tax Allocation Increment Base (M) Property Taxes for Computing Tax Allocation Increments (N) Tax Allocation Bond Issues (O, P, Q) Amount of Bond Issue...28 Term of the Bond Issue or Issues...28 Rate of Bond Issue...28 Positive Tax Allocation Increments...28 Property to be Pledged for Payment of the Bonds...28 School System Impact Analysis (R) The Current Value of the College Corridor TAD Verses the Gwinnett Schools Tax Digest...29 Proposed Redevelopment in the College Corridor TAD...29 Estimated Number of Public School Students from the College Corridor TAD...30 The Location of School Facilities within the Redevelopment Area...30 An Estimate of Educational Special Purpose Local Option (ESPLOST) Sales Taxes Projected from TAD Development...30 Conclusion Regarding School Impacts...31 Summary of College Corridor TAD Benefits Appendices Appendix A. Maps & Drawings...33 Appendix B. Figures & Descriptions...40 List of Tax Parcel ID Numbers (Properties within the TAD)...41 Development Plan and TAD Potential...49 Cost Schedule...51 Appendix C. Lawrenceville City Council...52 Appendix D. Gwinnett County Board of Commissioners...53 Appendix E. Gwinnett County Board of Education...54 * Headings followed by a letter in parenthesis [e.g. (A)] denote information required per Georgia Code Chapter 36, Title 44. Redevelopment Plan i

3 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY This plan presents the rationale, boundaries, fiscal data and proposed projects which could result from the formation of City of Lawrenceville Tax Allocation District #2 College Corridor. This redevelopment plan was prepared in conformance with the provisions of Georgia Redevelopment Powers Law (O.C.G.A. Title 36 Chapter 44) which governs the creation of the Tax Allocation Districts (TADs) in the state. Leadership in the preparation of this plan was provided by the City of Lawrenceville. OVERVIEW The College Corridor TAD area consists of 293 parcels on 497 acres. It stretches along Collins Hill Road (also called Northdale Road) from the Lawrenceville city border to North Clayton Street and into the heart of downtown, terminating at East Oak Street. The proposed TAD area begins at the new Georgia Gwinnett College (GGC) and travels through commercial development attracted to the location s proximity to Hwy 316, through older residential neighborhoods with a mix of single family and multifamily housing. It includes the historic Lawrenceville train depot and crosses the rail lines which form the northern border of downtown Lawrenceville. City of Lawrenceville TAD #2 - College Corridor Proposed TAD Summary Parcels 293 Acreage* Appraised Value $103,177, Assessed Value $41,505, Taxable Value $32,324, City of Lawrenceville Taxable Value $901,286,990 % of Lawrenceville Taxable Value 3.59% * Approximate Source: BAG, Gwinnett County Tax Commissioner, Georgia Department of Revenue THE OPPORTUNITY The opportunity for the City of Lawrenceville is to leverage private reinvestment through targeted public improvements that will facilitate and encourage the transformation of the College Corridor. The College Corridor is particularly important to the City of Lawrenceville because its revitalization will be mutually beneficial to its oldest asset, the historic downtown and its newest asset, Georgia Gwinnett College. The corridor is anchored by the historic downtown which has benefited from the City s investments in improving and supporting revitalization. At the northern end of the corridor is Georgia Gwinnett College (GGC). Founded in 2006, Georgia Gwinnett College has already grown from 118 students during its first semester to over 5,000 students by the fall of The school is rapidly increasing its capacity. The Georgia University System estimates that there will be additional demand from 70,000 additional students by GGC will be poised to compete for many of these students. The City believes that the revitalization of the Corridor will link the college, the downtown, as well as the City of Lawrenceville and Gwinnett County as a whole. Redevelopment Plan 2

4 CITY OF LAWRENCEVILLE TAD #2 COLLEGE CORRIDOR QUALIFIES AS A TAD The City of Lawrenceville has the authority to exercise all redevelopment and other powers authorized or granted municipalities pursuant to the Redevelopment Powers Law (Chapter 44 of Title 36 of the O.C.G.A), as granted by 2008 House Bill 1007 (2008 Ga. L. p. 4024, et seq.), as approved by Lawrenceville voters by referendum on November 4, Specifically, the College Corridor TAD meets the state requirements for determining a redevelopment area as evidenced by the following: Buildings in the TAD area are significantly older than in the surrounding areas The average age of retail space in the TAD is 50 years old and the average age of office properties in the TAD is 54 years old. The TAD area significantly has significantly lower values than either the City or County properties in the area have an assessed value of $83,591 per acre compared to $203,018 in the City and $143,084 in the County. The current intensity and quality of development in the TAD area do not support the City s vision for the area. The current infrastructure in the TAD area will be insufficient and needs to be upgraded to support redevelopment. THE COLLEGE CORRIDOR TAD This plan calls for the creation of the College Corridor Tax Allocation District, whose redevelopment area includes the property within the boundaries shown on the map below. (For a larger copy of the map, please see the Appendix.) This potential TAD includes 293 parcels on approximately 497 acres. In 2011, the appraised value of these parcels was $103.2 million and the taxable value was $32.3 million. These parcels represent approximately 3.6% of the City of Lawrenceville s taxable value of $901.3 million. City of Lawrenceville TAD #2 - College Corridor Proposed TAD Summary Parcels 293 Acreage* Appraised Value $103,177, Assessed Value $41,505, Taxable Value $32,324, City of Lawrenceville Taxable Value $901,286,990 % of Lawrenceville Taxable Value 3.59% * Approximate Source: BAG, Gwinnett County Tax Commissioner, Georgia Department of Revenue Redevelopment Plan 3

5 City of Lawrenceville TAD #2 College Corridor TAD Boundary Map THE PLAN The vision for the College Corridor TAD is to replace outmoded and economically underutilized properties with a mix of uses that will serve several purposes. First, the City aims to increase housing opportunities for the students, faculty and staff of Georgia Gwinnett College. In addition, the City is encouraging a better mix of commercial properties, particularly retail and entertainment uses that will appeal to this new population. Finally, the City would like to improve the infrastructure which supports the corridor, increasing its capacity for automobiles while encouraging a walkable environment with sidewalks, greenspace and other amenities supportive of pedestrians, cyclists and transit traveling between the college and downtown. Redevelopment Plan 4

6 For the purposes of this TAD plan, five hypothetical projects were created to illustrate the impact of potential redevelopment in the TAD area. They are focused on creating a mix of uses throughout the corridor to help achieve the broader goals of the City s Comprehensive Plan, particularly the vision for a revitalized College Corridor. City of Lawrenceville TAD #2 College Corridor Boundary Map with Potential Redevelopment Projects A B C D E Redevelopment Plan 5

7 These five potential projects could include: A total of 713 new residential units: 102 townhomes, 50 condominiums 561 student apartments 336,790 s.f. of retail space 378,234 s.f of office space and 232 hotel rooms 92,760 s.f. of civic/institutional space. Based upon the proposed development plan, it is estimated that there will be $210.2 million of new market value created in the College Corridor TAD at build-out, which will result in an increase of $83.2 million in taxable value. This increase could result in an estimated $2.8 million in new property taxes annually or $2.1 million in bondable property taxes per year. This could support total potential TAD bond proceeds of up to $18.4 million. City of Lawrenceville TAD #2 - College Corridor Potential TAD Estimate 2011 Market Value of Redevelopment Projects $28,346, Taxable Value of Redevelopment Projects $9,152,280 Potential Taxable Value of Projects at Build Out $92,377,840 Net New Taxable Value Increment at Build Out $83,225, Millage Rates for TAD Purposes City of Lawrenceville Gwinnett County Incorporated M&O Gwinnett Schools M&O Total Millage Rate New Property Taxes* $2,762,256 Bondable Value (95%) $2,624,144 Debt Coverage Ratio 125% Bondable Property Tax $2,099,315 TAD Bond Amount Interest Rate 7.0% Bond Term (years) 25 Estimated Bond Amount* $24,620,365 Issuance Costs (3%) $738,611 Capitalized Interest (24 months) $3,200,647 Debt Reserve (10%) $2,309,246 Net Bond Proceeds $18,371,860 Redevelopment Plan 6

8 PROPOSED PUBLIC INVESTMENTS As noted in this plan, the College Corridor s existing infrastructure is inadequate to support the community s full vision of redevelopment for the area. Once development is underway, having a TAD in place will help fund the infrastructure improvements necessary to create a pedestrian-friendly, more-accessible corridor consistent with the City s vision. City of Lawrenceville TAD #2 College Corridor Potential Allocation of TAD Funds Infrastructure Item Estimated Cost 1 Infrastructure Improvements $5,520,000 2 Curb and Sidewalk Improvements/Traffic Control $3,680,000 3 Structured Parking $3,680,000 4 Site Preparation Demolition and Clearance, Remediation $1,840,000 4 Parks and Greenspace $2,760,000 5 Other Redevelopment Initiatives $920,000 Total Initial TAD Funding Request $18,400,000 Categories and cost allocations are estimates for potential projects as of October, 2011 and are subject to revision as the Redevelopment Plan is implemented. This will change over time as priorities are identified or addressed. Specific project amounts, allocations and priorities are subject to change. COLLEGE CORRIDOR TAD BENEFITS As shown in the following table, the creation of the College Corridor TAD could generate $210.2 million in new development which would increase the current $32.3 million taxable value of the TAD by an additional $83.2 million, a 257% increase. This would result in approximately $2.8 million in new annual property tax receipts and support TAD funding for up to $18.4 million in needed infrastructure. The proposed commercial development could generate $1.6 million in local sales tax each year and support the creation of approximately 2,400 permanent jobs. City of Lawrenceville TAD #2 - College Corridor Summary of Potential Benefits Market Value of TAD at Build Out Market Value of new private capital investment Cost of public infrastructure to be financed by the TAD Estimated annual ad valorem tax increment at full build out Estimated Potential New Sales Tax* $313.4 million $210.2 million $18.4 million $2.8 million $1.5 million Estimated New Jobs Created ** 2,400 * Includes SPLOST and ESPLOST ** Consultant prepared estimate Redevelopment Plan 7

9 INTRODUCTION In October of 2008, the City of Lawrenceville adopted their Comprehensive Plan Update This plan sets for the long-range vision for the future of Lawrenceville, focusing on land uses and redevelopment opportunities which encourage economic growth while protecting the City s historic character and its natural resources. In addition, the plan focuses on ways to differentiate Lawrenceville from the surrounding areas, to capitalize on its strengths and to foster a greater sense of identity throughout the City. In order to achieve this vision, the City has adopted several strategies with the aim of: improving transportation connectivity; improving pedestrian amenities and promoting alternative forms of transit; encouraging a variety of housing types; promoting existing economic strengths and foster their expansion; encouraging revitalization of aging properties and infill development; and expanding the tax base of the City. The College Corridor, stretching from the new Georgia Gwinnett College into the heart of downtown represents a significant opportunity for the City of Lawrenceville to enact these strategies. This plan calls for the formation of the College Corridor TAD, which will be a critical tool to aid in the implementation of this vision. Through targeted public investments, the City will encourage private redevelopment, providing a greater range of employment opportunities, housing options and services to the residents, students and visitors of Lawrenceville and Gwinnett County. Vision Statement Lawrenceville will be the center of the northeast region of Atlanta, as it becomes home to leading education, healthcare, commerce, industry, and government, while protecting its history and neighborhoods. Lawrenceville shall enact standards of high quality for planned growth and redevelopment, while protecting its natural resources and strengthening its neighborhoods. Lawrenceville shall call upon its rich heritage to provide a community that is a destination for the rest of the region. -Comprehensive Plan 2030 THE VISION Lawrenceville defines itself as the historic governmental, healthcare, educational and economic hub of Gwinnett County, with a long tradition of close-knit neighborhoods, civic pride and a strong, vibrant central business district. With the explosive growth of Gwinnett County over the last forty years, Lawrenceville has evolved from the local market town for the neighboring countryside to a small urban center amidst the ever-spreading neighborhoods and strip commercial centers. Lawrenceville desires to mature into an urban focal point within the County, with a number of cultural, recreational, educational, lifestyle and employment opportunities. -Comprehensive Plan 2030 The City of Lawrenceville s vision for the College Corridor is a revitalized corridor with a broad range of housing options and commercial development supported by new investment in infrastructure, including transportation improvements, new greenspace and amenities which encourage pedestrians and cyclists throughout the corridor. This combination of public and private investment will provide a broader range of housing options, create employment and business opportunities, improve transportation flow through the area, promote walkability and transit, ensure that the corridor reflects the character of the city and increase the city s tax digest. Redevelopment Plan 8

10 THE PLAN The purpose of the College Corridor TAD is to implement the strategies and recommendations found in the Lawrenceville Comprehensive Plan Update These strategies include: 1) Provide quality alternative housing choices for a full life-cycle community. Encourage a variety of home styles, densities and price ranges in locations that are accessible to jobs and services to ensure housing for individuals and families of all incomes and age groups. Establish a balance of housing types, costs and densities that result in a positive fiscal impact for the City. Encourage a wide variety of mixed-use developments with multi-story residential components within the High Rise Corridor. Encourage and promote academic-friendly housing alternatives in the College corridor area. Encourage traditional neighborhoods and mixed-use developments. Encourage a variety of types of new multi-family housing, such as town homes and stacked-flats. 2) Expand business and employment opportunities within Lawrenceville. Promote reinvestment in commercial areas outside of the downtown commercial district. Support strategic public investments to attract more private business. 3) Promote and maintain an efficient transportation network to support regional circulation and encouraging alterative transportation options for the City s residents and businesses. Encourage increased interconnectivity of non-residential uses to reduce traffic congestion. Encourage more mixed use projects to help reduce vehicle trips. Research funding mechanisms to improve local street connectivity, widening and additional sidewalk connections where possible. Continue to support the development of the Brain Train commuter rail effort between Atlanta and Athens. Integrate the possibility of a multi-modal station into future transportation and land use plans for the College Corridor LCI study. 4) Establish appropriate planning procedures and innovate planning tools to guide growth and development. Encourage development within principal transportation corridors. Foster public/private partnerships that will improve planning procedures and tools. Maximize the use of existing and programmed public facilities. Minimize the public service costs and reduce environmental impacts of development. Ensure that work and service areas are convenient to living areas to promote energy conservation. Ensure that higher density housing is located in close proximity to major thoroughfares, employment centers, shopping facilities and other activity centers. Encourage reuse and revitalization of obsolete commercial facilities. Redevelopment Plan 9

11 Promote walkable (pedestrian-oriented and nicely-landscaped) and planned (rather than strip) commercial development. Within existing strip commercial areas, allow for the in-fill of compatible mixed uses. Encourage retail and office uses to locate in designated areas that are well served by public infrastructure. Locate office development near commercial activities and higher density residential areas. 5) Maximize the attractive character of Lawrenceville by establishing aesthetically pleasing gateways and corridors into the City. 6) Promote land redevelopment and infill development. Promote the redevelopment of under-utilized or vacated land or structures Promote the redevelopment of land whose land use function is outdated or obsolete. Indentify and investigate the large scale (multi-parcel) redevelopment potential of areas in need of redevelopment or revitalization. Provide economic incentives to identify and redevelop multi-parcel areas with underutilized, vacated or outdated land uses. The College Corridor TAD is a vital tool for the City of Lawrenceville that will enable to City to achieve these goals by leveraging public investment to encourage private redevelopment in the City. GEOGRAPHIC BOUNDARIES (A) This plan calls for the creation of the City of Lawrenceville TAD #2 - College Corridor, whose redevelopment area includes the parcels shaded in green in the boundary shown on the map below. The TAD focuses on properties which lie along Collins Hill Road (also called Northdale Road) from Georgia Gwinnett College in the north until it merges with North Clayton Street and then extends into downtown, terminating at East Oak Street. The TAD extends along Hurricane Shoals Road from Philip Boulevard in the west to Buford Drive in the east, including properties extending north to GA 316, the site of the interchange improvements currently underway by the Georgia Department of Transportation. Redevelopment Plan 10

12 City of Lawrenceville TAD #2 College Corridor TAD Boundary Map (L) 1 1 For a larger view of the map, see Appendix A. Tax Parcel Identification numbers for properties included within the TAD are listed in Appendix B. Redevelopment Plan 11

13 HOW RESIDENTS IN LAWRENCEVILLE AND GWINNETT COUNTY BENEFIT The benefits to the City and Gwinnett County from the completed projects include the following: Traffic improvements to facilitate traffic flow within the area as well as beautification of the streetscapes; A revitalized mixed-use gateway linking the Georgia Gwinnett College to the heart of downtown Lawrenceville; Increased amenities supporting Georgia Gwinnett College, making the school more competitive and successful; An expanded job base in office related uses, professional, retail and service industries; New living, working, shopping, dining and entertainment opportunities that will serve residents, students and faculty, and attract visitors from outside the county; Increased personal incomes and new local businesses; Potential private investment of $210.2 million creating a new housing options and revitalized commercial uses; and Substantial new annual tax revenues from property taxes, sales taxes and business licenses. OVERVIEW OF TAX ALLOCATION DISTRICTS Tax allocation districts are Georgia s version of tax increment financing. Tax increment financing is a redevelopment funding mechanism that reinvests the future taxes from real estate development back into a project as an incentive to attract new private investment into an area. As described by the Council of Development Finance Agencies. ( TIF was created and first used in California in Hundreds of TIF districts have helped spur urban redevelopment in cities across the country. Today, all 50 states and the District of Columbia use tax increment financing. In 1985, the Georgia General Assembly authorized formation of Georgia s form of tax increment financing called Tax Allocation Districts (TADs). The purpose of a Georgia tax allocation district is similar to tax increment financing in any other state. It uses the increased property taxes generated by new development in a designated redevelopment area to finance costs related to the development such as public infrastructure, land acquisition, relocation, demolition, utilities, debt service and planning costs. Other costs it might cover include: Sewer expansion and repair Storm drainage Street construction & expansion Water supply Park improvements Bridge construction and repair Curb and sidewalk work Grading and earthwork Traffic control Cities and counties throughout Georgia have created TADs to stimulate major new construction and renovation or rehabilitation in underdeveloped or blighted areas. For example, ten TADs have been created in Atlanta, and additional TADs have been created in Marietta, Smyrna, Acworth, Woodstock, Holly Springs, East Point, Clayton County and DeKalb County. In 2009, Gwinnett County created five TADS in CIDs in the County. Over 50 Georgia cities and counties either have or are considering creating TADs in their communities. A TAD offers local governments the opportunity to promote redevelopment projects in areas that would otherwise not receive investment. Redevelopment Plan 12

14 The creation of the College Corridor TAD will enhance the private development community s interest in investing in major redevelopment projects in the City of Lawrenceville. A TAD will bring the City of Lawrenceville and Gwinnett County additional economic advantages as well. Other Georgia tax allocation districts, redevelopment areas like Atlantic Station (Midtown Atlanta) and Camp Creek Marketplace (East Point), have demonstrated the benefits of TAD, including: A stronger economic base Private development that would not have occurred without the TAD designation is attracted by this incentive. The halo effect Several Georgia TADs have generated significant new investment in areas surrounding the TAD as well as within the tax allocation districts, further expanding the positive economic impact. No impact on current tax revenues Redevelopment is effectively promoted without tapping into existing general governmental revenues or levying special assessments on property owners. Expanded local tax base By stimulating economic activity TAD s expand the local tax digest, additional retail sales, and as a result, SPLOST revenues. It is self-financing TADs are self-financing, since they are funded by the increased tax revenues from new development within the district. High leverage Typically TAD funds represent between 5-15% of project costs, leveraging 7-20 times their value in private investment. In summary, a tax allocation district supports the infrastructure necessary to make an underutilized area attractive to private development, at no additional cost to the taxpayer. It does not create a tax increase for the community, nor does it reduce current tax revenues the community currently receives. The creation of the College Corridor Tax Allocation District is designed to provide the financial incentive to support the creation of the vision set forth in the Comprehensive Plan Update by helping to fund the substantial improvements to public infrastructure needed to support the new, more intensive mixed-use development called for in the vision for the area. As such, it is a highly appropriate and consistent use of this financing technique as defined in Georgia s Redevelopment Powers Law. PROPOSAL Through the creation of the College Corridor TAD, the City of Lawrenceville is positioning the area for new opportunities for reinvestment and revitalization through the implementation of the vision for the community seen in the Comprehensive Plan Update GROUNDS FOR EXERCISE OF REDEVELOPMENT POWERS (B) Tax Allocation Districts (TAD)s are authorized in Georgia under the Redevelopment Powers Law, O.C.G.A. Title 36, Chapter 44. In 2009, the Redevelopment Powers Law was re-enacted again, with the following definition of a redevelopment area. Redevelopment area means an urbanized area as determined by current data from the US Bureau of the Census or an area presently served by sewer that qualifies as a blighted or distressed area, a deteriorating area, or an area with inadequate infrastructure as follows: Redevelopment Plan 13

15 (A) A blighted or distressed area is an area that is experiencing one of more conditions of blight as evidenced by: (i) The presence of structures, buildings, or improvements that by reason of dilapidation; deterioration; age; obsolescence; inadequate provision for ventilation, light, air, sanitation, or open space; overcrowding; conditions which endanger life or property by fire or other causes; or any combination of such factors, are conducive to ill health, transmission of disease, infant mortality, high unemployment, juvenile delinquency, or crime and are detrimental to the public health, safety, morals, or welfare; (ii) The presence of a predominant number of substandard, vacant, deteriorated, or deteriorating structures, the predominance of a defective or inadequate street layout, or transportation facilities; or faulty lot layout in relation to size, accessibility, or usefulness; (iii) Evidence of pervasive poverty, defined as being greater than 10 percent of the population in the area as determined by current data from the U.S. Bureau of the Census, and an unemployment rate that is 10 percent higher than the state average; (iv) Adverse effects of airport or transportation related noise or environmental contamination or degradation or other adverse environmental factors that the political subdivision has determined to be impairing the redevelopment of the area; or (v) The existence of conditions through any combination of the foregoing that substantially impair the sound growth of the community and retard the provision of housing accommodations or employment opportunities; (B) A deteriorating area is an area that is experiencing physical or economic decline or stagnation as evidenced by two or more of the following: (i) The presence of a substantial number of structures or buildings that are 40 years old or older and have no historic significance; (ii) High commercial or residential vacancies compared to the political subdivision as a whole; (iii) The predominance of structures or buildings of relatively low value compared to the value of structures or buildings in the surrounding vicinity or significantly slower growth in the property tax digest than is occurring in the political subdivision as a whole; (iv) Declining or stagnant rents or sales prices compared to the political subdivision as a whole; (v) In areas where housing exists at present or is determined by the political subdivision to be appropriate after redevelopment, there exists a shortage of safe, decent housing that is not substandard and that is affordable for persons of low and moderate income; (vi) Deteriorating or inadequate utility, transportation, or transit infrastructure; and (C) An area with inadequate infrastructure means an area characterized by: (i) Deteriorating or inadequate parking, roadways, bridges, pedestrian access, or public transportation or transit facilities incapable of handling the volume of traffic into or through the area, either at present or following redevelopment; or (ii) Deteriorating or inadequate utility infrastructure either at present or following redevelopment. WHY THE COLLEGE CORRIDOR AREA QUALIFIES AS A REDEVELOPMENT AREA The City of Lawrenceville has the authority to exercise all redevelopment and other powers authorized or granted municipalities pursuant to the Redevelopment Powers Law (Chapter 44 of Title 36 of the O.C.G.A), as granted by 2008 House Bill 1007 (2008 Ga. L. p. 4024, et seq.), as approved by Lawrenceville voters by referendum on November 4, Specifically, the College Corridor TAD meets the state requirements for determining a redevelopment area noted above as evidenced by the following: B (i) Properties in the corridor are significantly older than in the surrounding areas. While some of these properties are historic in nature and are an asset to Lawrenceville, many of them were built in the late 1960s and early 1970s and lack architectural character and are suffering from disinvestment. Redevelopment Plan 14

16 According to CoStar, Inc., retail properties in the College Corridor have an average age of 50 years, compared to 28 years old in Lawrenceville and 22 years old in Gwinnett County. Office properties in the College Corridor have an average age of 54 years old, compared to 34 years old in Lawrenceville and 25 years old in Gwinnett County. (CoStar) Industrial properties in the College Corridor have an average age of 36 years old, compared to 23 years old in Lawrenceville and 22 years old in Gwinnett County. (CoStar) According to Claritas, the average age of housing in the College Corridor is 26 years old. Almost 40% of housing units in the area were built before B (iii) The significant age of the corridor properties and a lack of investment are shown through the diminished value of the properties. In the College Corridor, 497 acres of development have an assessed value of $41.5 million, or $83,591 per acre. This is approximately 41% of the per acre value of property in the City of Lawrenceville as a whole ($203,018 per acre) and 58% of the per acre value of property in the County as a whole ($143,084 per acre). City of Lawrenceville TAD #2 College Corridor Assessed Value per Acre College Corridor TAD City of Lawrenceville Gwinnett County Assessed Value $41,505,600 $1,197,402,780 $31,615,022,318 Acres 497 5, ,955 Assessed Value/Acre $83,591 $203,018 $143,084 Source: Georgia Department of Revenue, Gwinnett County Tax Assessor C (iii) The City of Lawrenceville is embarking on an ambitious plan to redevelop the corridor into a more intensive mix of uses and with expanded housing options for Georgia Gwinnett College students. At buildout, there will be significant numbers of new residents in the area. Current transportation infrastructure will not be sufficient after redevelopment. In addition, there is almost no pedestrian access or access to transit facilities in the TAD area currently. SUMMARY OF PROJECT CONDITIONS Buildings in the TAD area are significantly older than in the surrounding areas The average of retail space in the TAD is 50 years old and the average age of office properties in the TAD is 54 years old. The TAD area significantly has significantly lower values than either the City or County properties in the area have an assessed value of $83,591 per acre compared to $203,018 in the City and $143,084 in the County. The current intensity and quality of development in the TAD area do not support the City s vision for the area. The current infrastructure in the TAD area will be insufficient following redevelopment. Redevelopment Plan 15

17 PLAN VISION AND GOAL The goal of the College Corridor TAD is to encourage the private infill development as well as the redevelopment of outmoded commercial and residential properties into pedestrian friendly, mixed-use centers to achieve the vision set forth in the City of Lawrenceville s Comprehensive Plan Update By fulfilling this vision, the City hopes to: Encourage the success and vitality of both the new Georgia Gwinnett College and its historic downtown by promoting supportive land uses and connectivity between the two City assets. Increase economic activity in the corridor by supporting current businesses and expanding the employment base in the area. Grow the tax base of the City of Lawrenceville. Improve interparcel connectivity, create mixed-use environments and improve infrastructure to ease traffic in the area. Create a more pedestrian-friendly environment which supports alternative forms of transportation. Expand the housing options in the City of Lawrenceville, including a diversity of housing types and price points. Create a sense of place and improve the aesthetic conditions of the corridor. PROPOSED LAND USES AFTER REDEVELOPMENT (C) The TAD Redevelopment Plan proposes that the TAD area will be redeveloped into a mix of uses, including residential, focusing on academic-friendly and student housing, as well as supportive retail and office uses. The vision for this area is founded in the Lawrenceville Comprehensive Plan Update , which defines several character areas for the corridor. College Corridor The majority of the corridor is designated as part of the College Corridor Character Area. According to the Plan, the city s desired development pattern for the area includes: City of Lawrenceville Character Areas Development projects that compliment college life. Create a strong physical connect between downtown and the college campus. Redevelopment of existing single-family and multifamily neighborhoods into high-quality off-campus housing for college students, faculty and staff. Expansion of college campus on the south side of SR316 for future athletic events. Encourage a variety of transit and transportation modes from campus to downtown and surrounding commercial districts. Provide entertainment areas along the Depot that will encourage interaction between the college and downtown. Redevelopment Plan 16

18 Commercial A small portion of the TAD area, north of Hurricane Shoals Road at Buford Drive, is designated as a Commercial Character Area. According to the plan, regional commercial areas should include mix of retail, office, services, and employment to serve a regional market area, furthermore, this character area should consider the following: Big box retail should be limited to these areas. Infill development/redevelopment of vacant commercial structures is desirable. Commercial developments should be master planned to ensure that infrastructure will meet the needs of all commercial businesses at build-out. New developments should incorporate architectural guidelines compatible with regional commercial styles or common themes that reflect adjacent developments. Landscaping and buffer/screenings should be encouraged against non-commercial uses and along adjacent roadways. Adjacent commercial uses should be compatible with one another. Downtown Character Area After crossing the rail lines, the TAD terminates at East Oak Street. This four block area is included in the Downtown Character Area. According to the Comprehensive Plan, The downtown Lawrenceville area should develop with a combination of greenspace, office, governmental, commercial, residential, residential-commercial uses. High Rise Corridor - In addition, the northern portion of the TAD is included in the High Rise Corridor, a district stretching along Hwy 316 that the City of Lawrenceville has designated as the location for its future high-density development. According to the plan, the high rise corridor is to promote the development of properties in a manner that integrates commercial uses with office and residential uses and promote pedestrian accessibility among these uses, specifically: Residential development and commercial / office uses should be designed to complement each other and create a complementary live / work environment within each master planned project. Commercial uses should include a mix of retail, services, and offices to serve adjacent residents day-to-day needs, and should match the character of the high rise-use. High rise project design should be very pedestrian-oriented, with easy connections between different uses within the project, as well as with adjacent uses. Recreational, cultural, plazas, and greenspace uses should be integrated into the project design. Provide connectivity to neighboring communities and major destinations, such as libraries, neighborhood centers, health facilities, commercial clusters, parks, schools, etc. Parking structures such as multi-level decks should be included in each high rise development. PROPOSED REDEVELOPMENT PROJECTS (D) For the purposes of this TAD plan, five hypothetical projects were created to illustrate the impact and potential redevelopment in the TAD area. They are based on the character areas described above, to help achieve the broader goals of the City s Comprehensive Plan. A map of the potential projects, as well as a brief description and a summary of the redevelopment value is presented below. Redevelopment Plan 17

19 City of Lawrenceville TAD #2 College Corridor Boundary Map with Potential Redevelopment Projects A B C D E Catalyst Project A Student Village and Conference Center This redevelopment site is located in the southeast quadrant of the intersection of Highway 316 and Collins Hill Road, terminating on the south at Hurricane Shoals Road. It contains 39 Redevelopment Plan 18

20 acres on 21 parcels, with a current market value of $10.4 million and a taxable value of $4.1 million. The site could be redeveloped into a student village, focusing on student apartments and supportive retail as well as a hotel and convention center associated with Georgia Gwinnett College. Potential redevelopment could include 371 apartments to provide expanded housing options college students in the area, retail space (154,600 s.f.) and a hotel with 232 rooms and conference space. The project would potentially have a market value of $106.3 million and a taxable value of $42.5 million, an increase in taxable value of $38.4 million. Catalyst Project B Mixed Use Office and Housing Node This redevelopment site contains 16 acres on 19 parcels. The current market value for the parcels is $7.5 million, with a taxable value of $3.0 million. Potential redevelopment would be anchored by 85,050 s.f. of office space and 66 townhome units. The project would potentially have a market value of $24.3 million and a taxable value of $8.4 million, an increase in taxable value of $5.4 million. Catalyst Project C Commercial Node This redevelopment site contains 16 acres on 9 parcels, with a current market value of $5.2 million and a taxable value of $1.2 million. The site could be redeveloped with a mix of commercial space to leverage off of the adjacent retail properties. The redevelopment of the site could include 168,048 square feet of office space and 93,360 s.f. of retail space. This potential project would have a market value of $36.9 million and a taxable value of $14.8 million, an increase in taxable value of $13.6 million. Catalyst Project D Depot Mixed Use This redevelopment site contains 20 acres on 22 parcels and includes the historic depot of Lawrenceville. Currently, the site has a market value of $2.3 million and a taxable value of $863,320. The site could potentially be redeveloped to include 88,830 s.f. of additional adaptive-use and new retail as well as new housing, including 36 townhomes and 190 student apartments. The estimated market value of this redevelopment project would be $41.0 million and it could have a taxable value of $15.7 million, an increase in taxable value of $14.8 million. Catalyst Project E Adaptive Reuse Condominiums This redevelopment site contains nine acres on three parcels and is the site of a 1940s school which is no longer in use. Currently, the site has a market value of $2.9 million and a taxable value of zero, due to public ownership. The site could be redeveloped using a combination of adaptive reuse and new construction to create a combination of live-work space which could include 50 residential units and 125,136 square feet of office space. The estimated market value of this redevelopment project would be $30.0 million and it could have a taxable value of $11.0 million, an increase in taxable value of $11.0 million. Summary of Potential Redevelopment Projects These five potential projects could include 713 new residential units, including 102 townhomes, 50 condominiums and 561 student apartments. They could include 336,790 s.f. of new retail space, 378,234 s.f. of office space, and a 232-room hotel with meeting and Redevelopment Plan 19

21 convention space. The total market value of these projects could be $238.5 million with a taxable value of $95.4 million, an increase in taxable value of $83.2 million. City of Lawrenceville TAD #2 College Corridor Potential TAD Projects Project A B C D E Total Parcels Acreage Appraised Value $10,429,600 $7,513,400 $5,186,400 $2,331,400 $2,885,600 $28,346, Assessed Value $4,171,840 $3,005,360 $2,074,560 $932,560 $1,154,240 $11,338, Taxable Value $4,131,840 $3,005,360 $1,151,760 $863,320 $0 $9,152,280 Potential Redevelopment Projects Developable Acreage (%) 80% 60% 60% 60% 80% Developable Acreage (%) Residential Townhomes Units (10 /acre) Value per Unit $175,000 $175,000 $175,000 $175,000 $175,000 $175,000 Condos Units (35/acre) Value per Unit $150,000 $150,000 $150,000 $150,000 $225,000 $225,000 Student Apartments Units (40/acre) Value per Unit $125,000 $125,000 $125,000 $125,000 $125,000 $125,000 Total Residential Value $46,380,000 $11,576,250 $0 $29,906,100 $11,250,000 $99,112,350 Commercial Retail S.F. (25,000/acre) 154,600-93,360 88, ,790 Value per S.F. $125 $125 $125 $125 $125 $125 Office S.F. (30,000/acre) - 85, , , ,234 Value per S.F. $150 $150 $150 $150 $150 $150 Hotel (25/acre) Rooms Value per Room $175,000 $175,000 $175,000 $175,000 $175,000 $175,000 Total Commercial Value $59,907,500 $12,757,500 $36,877,200 $11,103,750 $18,770,400 $139,416,350 Civic S.F. (15,000/acre) 92, ,760 Value per S.F. $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 Total Appraised Value of Redevelopment $106,287,500 $24,333,750 $36,877,200 $41,009,850 $30,020,400 $238,528,700 Total Assessed Value of Redevelopment $42,515,000 $9,733,500 $14,750,880 $16,403,940 $12,008,160 $95,411,480 Total Taxable Value of Redevelopment * $42,515,000 $8,410,500 $14,750,880 $15,693,300 $11,008,160 $92,377,840 Redevelopment Plan 20

22 CONTRACTUAL RELATIONSHIPS (E) Pursuant to O.C.G.A (a), the Lawrenceville City Council will act as the redevelopment agent and will exercise redevelopment powers as needed to implement this plan. In doing so, the Council, either directly or through its designee, may conduct the following activities and enter into the following contracts: 1. Coordinate implementation activities with other major participants in the redevelopment plan and their respective development and planning entities involved in implementing this redevelopment plan. 2. Enter into development agreements with private developers to construct infrastructure and vertical developments to implement the redevelopment plan. 3. Negotiate and enter into commercial financing agreements and intergovernmental agreements as needed. 4. Coordinate public improvement planning, design and construction among City, County and State agencies and departments. 5. Prepare (either directly or through subcontract to other appropriate entities) economic and financial analyses, project-specific feasibility studies and assessments of tax base increments in support of the issuance of tax allocation bonds or other forms of financing by the City. 6. The City will enter into contractual relationships with qualified vendors for the provision of professional and other services required in qualifying and issuing the bonds or other forms of financing, including, but not limited to, legal, underwriting, financial analysis and other related services. 7. The City will perform other duties as necessary to implement the redevelopment plan. RELOCATION PLANS (F) Should the relocation of existing homes or businesses be required for the implementation of the College Corridor TAD Plan, such relocation expenses may be provided for under all applicable federal, state and local guidelines if public funds are used for property acquisition. If such funding sources require relocation, benefits would be offered to tenants and users for relocation. ZONING & LAND USE COMPATIBILITY (G) The variety of the corridor s land uses are reflected in the fact that there are eleven different zoning categories used in the corridor. Most of the corridor is designated for general commercial and residential uses, but it also includes both light and heavy industrial and institutional designations. In addition, the TAD area includes portions of two of the City s overlay districts: the High Rise Overlay District, which affects the northern portion of the corridor as it intersects with Hwy 316 and the Downtown Overlay District, which affects the southern portion of the corridor as it enters into historic downtown Lawrenceville. Redevelopment Plan 21

23 An overview of the zoning categories represented in the TAD is below. These descriptions are taken from the City s Zoning Ordinance. For a larger view of the Zoning Map, see the Appendix. City of Lawrenceville Zoning Map (TAD Area Detail) Single Family Residence 18,000 Square Foot Lot District (RS-180) This district is designed to stabilize and protect the residential characteristics of the district and to encourage a suitable family life on large size lots. Single Family Residence 15,000 Square Foot Lot District (RS-150) This district is designed to stabilize and protect the residential characteristics of the district and to encourage a suitable family life on large size lots. Modified General Residence (RM12) This district is designed to provide for low rise, medium density apartment developments that will be compatible when located near and among lower and moderate density type of developments. The purpose of this Ordinance is not to allow any construction of new apartments. The purpose of this Ordinance is to allow existing RM-12 zoned property to be converted to RM-12 modified so that property owners may purchase buildings within an apartment complex that already exist, and to hold ownership in separate entities. General Business District (BG) To provide for a wide range of retail and service establishments. Highway Service Business District (HSB) This district is designed to provide for the effective use of land situated in relationship to major highways and highway interchanges so efficient grouping of activities can develop to serve the public. Front yard requirements are designed to provide for the safety of the traveling public by provisions for adequate off-highway maneuvering and parking space. Light Manufacturing District (LM) This district provides for a wide range of heavy commercial and light industrial uses, all of which shall be able to meet comparatively rigid specifications as to nuisance free performance. This district specifically excludes residences on the theory that the mixture of residential use, and public services and facilities for residences with those of industry is contrary to the purpose of these regulations irrespective of whether the industry is encroaching on a residential area or a residential area is encroaching on an industrial area. Heavy Manufacturing District (HM) This district provides for the widest range of industrial operations permitted in the City. It is the district for location of those industries which have not reached a technical state in processing which renders them completely free of nuisance factors or where economics precludes construction and operation in a nuisance free manner. Industries permitted in this district must, however, meet all Federal and State pollution control regulations and Ordinances from time to time enacted by the City of Lawrenceville. Redevelopment Plan 22

24 Central General Business District (BGC) This district is designed to provide a general business district which will take into account the special characteristics of the Central Business District of the City. Office Institutional District To provide for a wide range of office and institutional establishments, not involving the sale, storage or processing of merchandise. Downtown Overlay District This district is designed to: (1) Preserve, protect and enhance Downtown s historic and future role as the civic and economic center of Lawrenceville and symbol of Gwinnett County. (2) Create an environment where people can live, work, meet and play. (3) Encourage a balanced mix of retail, professional, residential, civic, entertainment, and cultural uses. (4) Enhance the efficient utilization of parking facilities by encouraging shared parking and alternative modes of transportation. (5) Provide safe and accessible parks and plazas. High Rise Overlay District The purpose of the High Rise Overlay District is to promote the development of properties in a manner that integrates commercial and/or office with residential land uses, promotes pedestrian accessibility among uses, reduces automobile trips, provides a livable environment for project residents, and enhances the value and aesthetics of the surrounding community. This Special Use district utilizes connective streetscapes to promote an environment conducive to human activity through the provision of landscaping, street/shade trees, street furniture and sidewalks to unify and interconnect varying uses. City of Lawrenceville High Rise Overlay District Map Redevelopment Plan 23

25 METHOD OF FINANCING / PROPOSED PUBLIC INVESTMENTS (H) TAD POTENTIAL OF CITY OF LAWRENCEVILLE TAD #2 COLLEGE CORRIDOR The following estimates the potential bond revenues from the redevelopment projects in the College Corridor TAD, assuming that both Gwinnett County and the Gwinnett School Board pledge their M&O millage to the TAD redevelopment effort. Based upon the proposed development plan, it is estimated that there will be $210.2 million of new market value created in the College Corridor TAD at build-out, which will result in an increase of $83.2 million in taxable value. This increase could result in an estimated $2.8 million in new property taxes annually or $2.6 million in bondable property taxes per year. This could support total potential net TAD bond proceeds of up to $18.4 million. City of Lawrenceville TAD #2 - College Corridor Potential TAD Estimate 2011 Market Value of Redevelopment Projects $28,346, Taxable Value of Redevelopment Projects $9,152,280 Potential Taxable Value of Projects at Build Out $92,377,840 Net New Taxable Value Increment at Build Out $83,225, Millage Rates for TAD Purposes City of Lawrenceville Gwinnett County Incorporated M&O Gwinnett Schools M&O Total Millage Rate New Property Taxes* $2,762,256 Bondable Value (95%) $2,624,144 Debt Coverage Ratio 125% Bondable Property Tax $2,099,315 TAD Bond Amount Interest Rate 7.0% Bond Term (years) 25 Estimated Bond Amount* $24,620,365 Issuance Costs (3%) $738,611 Capitalized Interest (24 months) $3,200,647 Debt Reserve (10%) $2,309,246 Net Bond Proceeds $18,371,860 PROPOSED PUBLIC INVESTMENTS As noted earlier, the College Corridor s existing transportation infrastructure is inadequate to support the community s full vision of redevelopment for the area and to support the more intensive mixed-use development called for in the Comprehensive Plan. Once development is Redevelopment Plan 24

26 underway, having a TAD in place will help fund the infrastructure improvements necessary to create pedestrian-friendly, mixed-use developments consistent with this shared vision. The total public cost for implementing the public improvements needed to fulfill the City s vision, including construction and improvement of the necessary public infrastructure, is currently estimated at $18.4 million, which the City intends to fund through the tax allocation district. The purpose of the proposed infrastructure improvements funded by the TAD would be five-fold: To make needed improvements to transportation infrastructure required to support new development and increase traffic flow from Gwinnett Georgia College and Downtown Lawrenceville. To make enhancements such as streetscapes, curb and sidewalk improvements and public spaces to improve the experience of students, residents and visitors in the Corridor. To provide funding for the development of structured parking, if needed. To provide funds to support site-specific development activities, including site preparation, demolition and clearance, utility improvements and environmental remediation to support redevelopment. To support other redevelopment initiatives as identified through the course of redevelopment. City of Lawrenceville TAD #2 College Corridor Potential Allocation of TAD Funds Infrastructure Item Estimated Cost 1 Infrastructure Improvements $5,520,000 2 Curb and Sidewalk Improvements/Traffic Control $3,680,000 3 Structured Parking $3,680,000 4 Site Preparation Demolition and Clearance, Remediation $1,840,000 4 Parks and Greenspace $2,760,000 5 Other Redevelopment Initiatives $920,000 Total Initial TAD Funding Request $18,400,000 Categories and cost allocations are estimates for potential projects as of October, 2011 and are subject to revision as the Redevelopment Plan is implemented. This will change over time as priorities are identified or addressed. Specific project amounts, allocations and priorities are subject to change. As shown in detail in this redevelopment plan, the potential value of new private investment could be $238.5 million at the time of completion, which, when combined with TAD infrastructure costs, will result in nearly $256.9 million in new investment in the City of Lawrenceville s College Corridor TAD. The private redevelopment costs will be funded from a variety of public and private sources including developer and investor equity, construction and permanent loans from financial institutions. THE BENEFITS OF THE COLLEGE CORRIDOR TAD TO THE CITY The benefits to the City will include: A substantial increase in the tax digest which would not have occurred without the TAD. The potential taxable value of the TAD at build out is estimated to be $115.6 million, an Redevelopment Plan 25

27 increase of $83.2 million, or a 257% increase over the base taxable value of $32.3 million. A greater intensity of high-value residential and commercial development which will minimize service demands while increasing the City s tax digest. A location in a newly revitalized, traditional neighborhood center will bring higher value than the aging, outmoded, strip highway development currently seen in the corridor. The TAD will create new development which is supports the success and growth of Georgia Gwinnett College, creating a revitalized corridor that will have a variety of housing options for students, faculty and staff as well as supportive land uses like office, retail and a hotel/conference center. Additional commercial development will further diversify the tax base. Aging properties will be replaced with new, vibrant mixed use projects that will have wide market appeal. The TAD will leverage substantial private investment. Using TAD financing to fund construction of infrastructure will enable the City to leverage approximately $18.4 million in TAD funding to attract $239.5 million in private investment, a leverage ratio of $13.02 in private dollars invested for every $1.00 of TAD investment. The TAD will support the creation of jobs. The TAD will stimulate construction employment and an estimated 2,400 permanent jobs, which are will result in new payroll, increased incomes for City residents, and increased revenues for area businesses. Development will create substantial growth in property and sales tax revenues. Once all TAD obligations of the district are retired, the City will receive the full property tax increment from the new development created and throughout the period the proposed redevelopment will generate additional retail sales with the result of increasing SPLOST revenues. Market Value of TAD at Build Out City of Lawrenceville TAD #2 - College Corridor Summary of Potential Benefits Market Value of new private capital investment Cost of public infrastructure to be financed by the TAD Estimated annual ad valorem tax increment after full build out Estimated Potential New Sales Tax* $313.4 million $210.2 million $18.4 million $2.8 million $1.5 million Estimated New Jobs Created ** 2,400 * Includes SPLOST and ESPLOST ** Consultant prepared estimate ASSESSED VALUATION FOR TAD (I) The redevelopment area for City of Lawrenceville Tax Allocation District #2 College Corridor as defined in this Redevelopment Plan has a 2011 fair market value of $103,177,280 an assessed value of $41,505,600 and a taxable value of $32,324,720 according to the tax records of Gwinnett County. Pursuant to the Redevelopment Powers Law, upon adoption of the Redevelopment Plan and the creation of the tax allocation district, the City will request that the Commissioner of Revenue of the State of Georgia certify the tax base for 2011, the base year for the proposed tax allocation district. Redevelopment Plan 26

28 The tax base will increase in the future through the private investment stimulated by the implementation of the redevelopment plan and the issuance of tax allocation bonds. In addition, this redevelopment is intended to stimulate other development in the district and lead to a substantial increase in property values as the Redevelopment Plan is implemented. Upon completion of the redevelopment of the College Corridor area as presented in this plan, this tax allocation district is projected to have a market value of $313.4 million and a taxable value of $115.6 million. HISTORIC PROPERTY WITHIN BOUNDARIES OF TAD (J) The redevelopment area does not have any properties listed on the National Register of Historic Places. In the event that any historic properties are subsequently identified within the TAD, they will not be substantially altered in any way inconsistent with technical standards for rehabilitation; or demolished unless feasibility for reuse has been evaluated based on technical standards for the review of historic preservation projects, which technical standards for rehabilitation and review shall be those used by the state historic preservation officer. CREATION & TERMINATION DATES FOR TAD (K) The College Corridor Tax Allocation District will be created effective December 31, The Redevelopment Powers Law provides that the district will be in existence until all redevelopment costs, including debt service, are paid in full. This repayment is projected to take 25 to 30 years. TAX ALLOCATION INCREMENT BASE (M) On or before December 30, 2011, the City of Lawrenceville, acting as the redevelopment agent, will apply to the State Revenue Commissioner for a certification of the tax allocation increment base of the proposed tax allocation district. City of Lawrenceville TAD #2 - College Corridor Proposed TAD Summary Parcels 293 Acreage* Appraised Value $103,177, Assessed Value $41,505, Taxable Value $32,324, City of Lawrenceville Taxable Value $901,286,990 % of Lawrenceville Taxable Value 3.59% * Approximate Source: BAG, Gwinnett County Tax Commissioner, Georgia Department of Revenue Property Taxes Collected Within Tax District to Serve as Base Total Taxable ($32,324,720) x Useable Millage ( ) = $1,072,857 Redevelopment Plan 27

29 PROPERTY TAXES FOR COMPUTING TAX ALLOCATION INCREMENTS (N) As provided in the Redevelopment Powers Law, the taxes that will be included in the tax increment base for the tax allocation district are based on the following authorized millage rates: Creation of the tax allocation district will not affect any existing or planned business improvement districts created within the boundaries of the redevelopment area. TAX ALLOCATION BOND ISSUES (O, P, Q) AMOUNT OF BOND ISSUE Upon adoption of this Redevelopment Plan, the City proposes to issue tax allocation bonds or other financing approaches in one or more bond issues in amounts to range from $15 to $25 million. TERM OF THE BOND ISSUE OR ISSUES The City proposes to issue tax allocation bonds for a term no longer than 25 years. RATE OF BOND ISSUE City of Lawrenceville TAD #2 - College Corridor 2011 M&O Millage Rates City of Lawrenceville M&O Gwinnett County Incorporated M&O Gwinnett Schools M&O Total Millage Rate *Levies for bonded indebtedness are not included in the calculation of the millage rates for TAD purposes. Source: Gwinnett County/Georgia Department of Revenue The City intends to issue fixed-rate tax exempt bonds if possible. The actual rate, however, will be determined at the time of issuance based upon general market conditions, anticipated development within the redevelopment area, assessed taxable property values, and federal tax law considerations. The City reserves the option to either operate the district on a pay-asyou-go basis or consider other potential financing options including other commercial financing to support future projects, as appropriate. POSITIVE TAX ALLOCATION INCREMENTS The positive tax allocation increment for the period covered by the term of the bonds is estimated to range from $2.5 million to $3.0 million annually after the build out is complete. The actual amount will depend upon the pace at which the Redevelopment Plan is implemented and the impact of the redevelopment activities and other economic factors on the tax base in the district as a whole. PROPERTY TO BE PLEDGED FOR PAYMENT OF THE BONDS The bonds will be secured by the positive tax allocation increment from eligible ad valorem taxes levied by the City on real property for these purposes. Redevelopment Plan 28

30 SCHOOL SYSTEM IMPACT ANALYSIS (R) Georgia s Redevelopment Powers Law, governs the operation of tax allocation districts (TAD s) in the State. The Law was amended during the 2009 legislative session to include a new provision under section (9)(R)for preparation of a School System Impact Analysis. This section presents the school impacts of City of Lawrenceville Tax Allocation District #2 College Corridor in order to address the requirements of this new portion of the Redevelopment Powers Law. THE CURRENT VALUE OF THE COLLEGE CORRIDOR TAD VERSES THE GWINNETT SCHOOLS TAX DIGEST The current taxable value for the College Corridor TAD is $33,659,600. (Taxable value differs slightly from remainder of the TAD plan due to difference in homestead exemptions for City and School taxes.) According to the Georgia Department of Revenue, the 2010 taxable value of the Gwinnett County Public School s digest is $27.7 million. Thus, the College Corridor TAD represents approximately 0.01% of the School s total tax digest. The amount of ad valorem school taxes collected from the properties in the designated College Corridor TAD, as determined by the tax assessor on December 31, 2011, will continue to flow to the Gwinnett County School Board thorough out the operation of the TAD. The College Corridor TAD will receive any additional property taxes collected above the 2011 base amount for use to attract redevelopment to this portion of the County. City of Lawrenceville TAD #2 - College Corridor Portion of Gwinnett Schools Tax Digest Net M&O Digest College Corridor TAD $33,659,600 Gwinnett County Public Schools $27,715,379,831 % of GCPS Tax Digest 0.01% Source: Georgia Department of Revenue Note: Taxable value differs slightly from remainder of the TAD plan due to difference in homestead exemptions for City and School taxes. PROPOSED REDEVELOPMENT IN THE COLLEGE CORRIDOR TAD As detailed earlier in this plan, there are five potential redevelopment projects located on 98 acres of the 497--acre College Corridor TAD. The redevelopment plan calls for a higher-density mix of uses and a focus on land uses which will support and capitalize on the new Georgia Gwinnett College to create a revitalized Corridor extending from the city limits into Downtown Lawrenceville, creating new activity nodes which will be attractive for living, working, shopping and entertaining. Based on the proposed development plan, the new development could be worth $238.5 million, increasing the value of the TAD by $210.2 million from the current market value of the tax parcels included in the TAD. The projects could include: 713 new residential units including 102 townhome units and 50 condominium units and 561 student apartments; 378,234 of general office space; 336,790 square feet of retail space, including new restaurants and shopping destinations, and 232 new hotel rooms Redevelopment Plan 29

31 ESTIMATED NUMBER OF PUBLIC SCHOOL STUDENTS FROM THE COLLEGE CORRIDOR TAD Based on the proposed projects the following table presents an estimate of the number of new residents and school children that could be anticipated to live in the College Corridor TAD over the next twenty years as a result of the proposed development. There are not established multipliers which differentiate between student apartments and general apartments. Therefore, we have calculated the estimated number of residents and pupils for general apartments, though it is assumed that the number of school children will be significantly less in apartments catering to full time college students. Units For Sale Housing Townhomes 102 City of Lawrenceville TAD #2 - College Corridor Estimated Residents and School Aged Children Resident Multiplier Estimated Residents School Aged Children Multiplier* Estimated School Aged Children 2-bedroom (60%) bedroom (40%) MF Condos 50 1-bedroom (70%) bedroom (30%) Apartments bedroom (50%) bedroom (50%) Total Units 713 Total Residents/Total Pupils 1, TotalResidents/Pupils/unit Source: Rutgers University/Center for Urban Policy Research, 2006/BAG As shown on the table, there will be an estimated 1,262 new residents and 124 school aged children from the combined potential development of 713 residential units over the next twenty years. This would represent an average of 63 new residents and six school aged children per year over the next 20 year development period. Gwinnett County Schools estimates their enrollments at 161,000 students. Therefore, the potential development projects in the College Corridor TAD would increase total enrollment by 0.08% over 20 years. THE LOCATION OF SCHOOL FACILITIES WITHIN THE REDEVELOPMENT AREA There are no Gwinnett County Schools facilities in the TAD Redevelopment Area: AN ESTIMATE OF EDUCATIONAL SPECIAL PURPOSE LOCAL OPTION (ESPLOST) SALES TAXES PROJECTED FROM TAD DEVELOPMENT The table below estimates the amount of ESPLOST sales tax would be generated by the potential redevelopment of the College Corridor TAD. The 152 new general households in the corridor would generate retail purchases of $1.9 million annually, with an estimated $1.4 Redevelopment Plan 30

32 million occurring locally. This would generate $6,820 ESPLOST revenues for Gwinnett County Schools annually. The proposed student apartments could house 1,010 residents. It is estimated that these students would spend $8,500 on discretionary purchases. (O Donnell & Associates, LLC) If 80% of these purchases were spent on local retail, it would total $4.8 million in local retail purchases, generating $24,033 in annual ESPLOST revenues. In addition, the 336,790 square feet of retail development would generate $74.1 million in sales annually, generating $740,938 in ESPLOST. Together, new spending by residents and students and spending in revitalized retail space could generate $771,791 annually in ESPLOST revenues for Gwinnett County Schools. City of Lawrenceville TAD #2 - College Corridor Estimated ESPLOST Revenues to Gwinnett County Schools General Housing Households Household Income (2010) Retail Purchases* Local Retail Purchases ** ESPLOST*** 152 $51,280 $1,948,640 $1,364,048 $6,820 Student Housing Residents Discretionary Spending Retail Purchases* Local Retail Purchases ** ESPLOST*** 1,010 $8,500 $6,866,640 $4,806,648 $24,033 Retail Space SF Sales/SF Total Sales ESPLOST 336,790 $220 $74,093,800 $740,938 Total Annual ESPLOST Revenues** $771,791 *25% of income for general housing and 80% of student discretionary spending. **70% ***Adjusted residential retail purchases by 50% to avoid double counting retail purchases Source: American Community Survey, College Student Spending Behavior by O Donnell & Associates, LLC ULI, BAG CONCLUSION REGARDING SCHOOL IMPACTS As demonstrated in the preceding analysis, the economic impacts to Gwinnett County Schools from participating in the Lawrenceville TAD #2 - College Corridor are: 1. The College Corridor TAD redevelopment area will affect the future appreciation on 0.01% (one-tenth of one percent) of the School s tax digest. The current amount of property taxes from the district will continue to go to the school system only increases above the current amount are pledged to the TAD. 2. The redevelopment area will potentially attract as many as 1,282 new residents and 124 school children over the next twenty years. This represents a growth of approximately six students per year and a total addition of 0.08% over 20 years to the enrollment of Gwinnett County Schools. Because the majority of these units will be marketed to college students, it is anticipated that the actual number of school children in these projects will be even less than this estimate. 3. There are no Gwinnett County School facilities in the TAD area. Redevelopment Plan 31

33 4. The proposed redevelopment will generate an additional $771,791 in ESPLOST funds each year. Thus we conclude that the potential gains to the Gwinnett County Schools from participating in College Corridor TAD will be substantial due to the future growth in its tax digest and ESPLOST revenues, with minimal impact on the demand for school services. SUMMARY OF COLLEGE CORRIDOR TAD BENEFITS As shown in the following table, the creation of the College Corridor TAD would generate $210.2 million of new market value in the TAD which would increase the current $32.3 million taxable value of the TAD by an additional $83.2 million, a 257% increase. This would result in approximately $2.8 million in new annual property tax receipts and support TAD funding for up to $18.4 million in needed infrastructure. The proposed commercial development could generate $1.6 million in local sales tax each year and support the creation of approximately 2,400 permanent jobs. City of Lawrenceville TAD #2 - College Corridor Summary of Potential Benefits Market Value of TAD at Build Out Market Value of new private capital investment Cost of public infrastructure to be financed by the TAD Estimated annual ad valorem tax increment after full build out Estimated Potential New Sales Tax* $3787 million $210.9 million $18.4 million $2.8 million $1.6 million Estimated New Jobs Created ** 2,400 * Includes SPLOST and ESPLOST ** Consultant prepared estimate Redevelopment Plan 32

34 APPENDICES APPENDIX A. MAPS & DRAWINGS Appendix A: Maps and Drawings 33

35 City of Lawrenceville TAD #2 - College Corridor TAD Boundary Map (L) Appendix A: Maps and Drawings 34

36 City of Lawrenceville TAD #2 College Corridor Boundary Map with Potential Redevelopment Projects A B C D E Appendix A: Maps and Drawings 35

37 City of Lawrenceville Zoning Map Appendix A: Maps and Drawings 36

38 City of Lawrenceville Zoning Map (TAD Area Detail) Appendix A: Maps and Drawings 37

39 City of Lawrenceville Future Development Map Appendix A: Maps and Drawings 38

40 City of Lawrenceville Future Development Map (TAD Area Detail) Appendix A: Maps and Drawings 39

41 APPENDIX B. FIGURES & DESCRIPTIONS Appendix B: Figures and Descriptions 40

42 LIST OF TAX PARCEL ID NUMBERS (PROPERTIES WITHIN THE TAD) City of Lawrenceville TAD #2 - College Corridor TAD Parcels PIN Owner Address Acres 2011 Appraised Value 2011 Assessed Value 2011 Taxable Value CHILDRESS A B & BRANDON C 111 TANNER ST 2.0 $583,400 $233,360 $233, FORESTER JAMES E 107 TANNER ST 0.2 $7,800 $3,120 $3, HUTCHINS FRANCES CATHERINE 120 TANNER ST 0.1 $73,400 $29,360 $9, CHEEK W DERRICK 102 NORTHDALE RD 0.2 $94,400 $37,760 $37, LANCE KENNETH 131 NORTHDALE RD 3.3 $152,600 $61,040 $61, A LANCE KENNETH REAR TANNER ST 1.5 $17,600 $7,040 $7, B CHEEK DERRICK 123 NORTHDALE RD 0.3 $59,900 $23,960 $23, PAPPY SAMUEL 155 NORTHDALE RD 0.3 $95,000 $38,000 $38, REDEEMING LOVE INTERNATIONAL FELLOWS 115 NORTHDALE RD 0.3 $87,800 $35,120 $ PAPPY SAMUEL NORTHDALE RD 0.6 $3,900 $1,560 $1, STEPHENS GREGORY H 140 HURRICANE SHOALS RD 1.3 $800,000 $320,000 $320, C004 LANCE KENNETH RAILROAD ST 0.2 $1,700 $680 $ A DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION HURRICANE SHOALS RD 7.0 $2,257,000 $902,800 $ EVERGREEN WORLDWIDE INC 200 HURRICANE SHOALS RD 1.0 $670,200 $268,080 $268, A WILLIAMS FRANKLIN M 438 HURRICANE SHOALS RD 0.7 $79,600 $31,840 $31, PRIME ENTERPRISES INC 386 HURRICANE SHOALS RD 2.7 $288,800 $115,520 $115, MURDOCK PATRICIA &DONNA G 79 HURRICANE SHOALS RD 1.3 $66,900 $26,760 $26, A MURDOCK PATRICIA R 69 HURRICANE SHOALS RD 0.5 $70,800 $28,320 $8, NORTHDALE BUSINESS PARK LLC 478 NORTHDALE RD 5.2 $1,500,000 $600,000 $600, WELLS FARGO BANK NA 506 NORTHDALE RD 0.6 $203,700 $81,480 $81, MRE-CH1 LLC 49 HURRICANE SHOALS RD 0.9 $895,000 $358,000 $358, COLLINS HILL GROUP LLC 615 COLLINS HILL RD 0.8 $81,200 $32,480 $32, HURRICANE SHOALS MEDICAL BUILDING LL 550 NORTHDALE RD 1.3 $108,400 $43,360 $43, A HURRICANE SHOALS MEDICAL BUILDING LL 15 HURRICANE SHOALS RD 0.4 $77,800 $31,120 $31, GUNTER MARY SUE HUSCUSSON 549 NORTHDALE RD 0.6 $81,100 $32,440 $12, A GUNTER MARY SUE HUSCUSSON 549 NORTHDALE RD 1.4 $42,300 $16,920 $16, SHAKOUR JEAN 535 NORTHDALE RD 1.0 $275,100 $110,040 $110, THREAT JEFFERY C & REBECCA S NORTHDALE RD 6.1 $637,600 $255,040 $255, THREAT JEFFERY C & REBECCA S 479 NORTHDALE RD 0.9 $255,400 $102,160 $102, HUONG NGUYEN THUY 467 NORTHDALE RD 0.5 $87,800 $35,120 $35, KRDZALIC REFIKA 457 NORTHDALE RD 0.5 $25,000 $10,000 $10, TURNER HAROLD M & ELIZABETH L 447 NORTHDALE RD 0.5 $101,800 $40,720 $40, IWANOWSKI ANNE M 439 NORTHDALE RD 0.4 $87,100 $34,840 $34, NICHOLS CLINE W ETAL 431 NORTHDALE RD 0.4 $74,200 $29,680 $9, GUNTER JEWELL LEE 409 NORTHDALE RD 1.5 $190,200 $76,080 $76, DURHAM CHARLES D 371 NORTHDALE RD 0.9 $94,500 $37,800 $37, DURHAM DEBRA J 160 NORTHDALE RD 0.9 $64,900 $25,960 $25, RUSSELL CARROLL ANN 134 NORTHDALE RD 0.4 $65,200 $26,080 $6, PRICE MARIE GRAVITT 120 NORTHDALE RD 0.6 $101,700 $40,680 $20, MALCOLM MARY M 805 NORTH CLAYTON ST 0.3 $110,900 $44,360 $44,360 Source: Gwinnett County Tax Assessor Appendix B: Figures and Descriptions 41

43 City of Lawrenceville TAD #2 - College Corridor TAD Parcels PIN Owner Address Acres 2011 Appraised Value 2011 Assessed Value 2011 Taxable Value BOHON C RAY & DOLORES ANNE C 815 NORTH CLAYTON ST 0.4 $382,200 $152,880 $152, LAWRENCEVILLE TRADE PLAZA LLC 823 NORTH CLAYTON ST 1.0 $742,300 $296,920 $296, HILL CYNTHIA A 835 NORTH CLAYTON ST 0.4 $110,000 $44,000 $44, KELLEY CAROL H 630 NORTH CLAYTON ST 0.5 $76,700 $30,680 $30, LAWRENCEVILLE BRETHREN ASSEMBLY INC NORTH CLAYTON ST 0.3 $11,900 $4,760 $ HARMONY WOODS LLLP 385 NORTHDALE RD 13.0 $5,130,000 $2,052,000 $2,052, BECK BUDDY D & LEAH M & KENTON 865 NORTH CLAYTON ST 0.6 $160,300 $64,120 $64, CROW G MICHAEL 862 NORTH CLAYTON ST 0.3 $150,000 $60,000 $60, BOHON CARLTON RAY & DOLORES C 854 NORTH CLAYTON ST 0.6 $178,700 $71,480 $71, PROVIDENCE LAND & DEVELOPMENT CORP 627 NORTH CLAYTON ST 0.6 $90,200 $36,080 $36, GRAVITT DANNY H 838 NORTH CLAYTON ST 0.4 $66,500 $26,600 $26, GRAVITT DANNY H 619 NORTH CLAYTON ST 0.4 $104,300 $41,720 $41, GRAVITT DANNY H 615 NORTH CLAYTON ST 0.5 $75,300 $30,120 $30, GRAVITT HARRY L & LELIA C 816 NORTH CLAYTON ST 0.0 $184,700 $73,880 $73, DAVIS DAVE H 497 NORTHDALE RD 2.5 $895,000 $358,000 $358, STEPHENS GREGORY H 150 HURRICANE SHOALS RD 0.9 $875,000 $350,000 $350, GSC PROPERTIES LP 419 HURRICANE SHOALS RD 7.3 $1,200,000 $480,000 $480, CHILDERS KENNETH G ETAL 189 HURRICANE SHOALS RD 0.9 $503,100 $201,240 $201, KQC INVESTORS LLC 208 HURRICANE SHOALS RD 1.1 $641,100 $256,440 $256, LANCE GARNETT C ETAL NORTHDALE RD 5.9 $289,300 $115,720 $115, WHITE DARIN 587 WHITEHALL LN 0.3 $80,000 $32,000 $32, PERRY DAVID E ETAL 243 HAYMARKET LN 0.3 $65,000 $26,000 $26, BRADFORD JOHN JACKIE 582 DOWNING ST 0.3 $80,000 $32,000 $32, BRADFORD JOHN JACKIE 581 DOWNING ST 0.3 $80,000 $32,000 $32, RICHIE BENNY 857 NORTH CLAYTON ST 0.3 $147,200 $58,880 $58, REGIONS BANK 250 NORTHDALE RD 2.1 $780,000 $312,000 $312, CHILDERS KENNETH G ETAL HURRICANE SHOALS RD 0.3 $9,200 $3,680 $3, PARK NAM IL ETAL 550 NORTHDALE RD 1.0 $857,600 $343,040 $343, TAU INC 5 HURRICANE SHOALS RD 0.4 $302,900 $121,160 $121, GWINNETT PROPERTIES INC 100 HURRICANE SHOALS RD 2.1 $1,950,000 $780,000 $780, VICK E O 60 HURRICANE SHOALS RD 1.5 $297,400 $118,960 $118, HURRICANE SHOALS MEDICAL BUILDING LL 15 HURRICANE SHOALS RD 0.6 $1,422,100 $568,840 $568, LANCE KENNETH NORTHDALE RD 0.4 $22,500 $9,000 $9, GWINNETT PROPERTIES INC CURTIS RD 3.4 $158,800 $63,520 $63, LOGGINS DONALD G HILLCREST GREEN DR 0.8 $139,400 $55,760 $55, LOGGINS DONALD G HILLCREST GREEN DR 0.7 $87,600 $35,040 $35, MRE-CH2 LLC 59 HURRICANE SHOALS RD 1.2 $956,200 $382,480 $382, PARK NAM IL ETAL 550 NORTHDALE RD 0.8 $635,300 $254,120 $254, A001 HAMRICK REBECCA M 51 NORTHDALE PL $50,800 $20,320 $ A002 LEON KIMBERLY MICHELL 57 NORTHDALE PL $31,000 $12,400 $0 Source: Gwinnett County Tax Assessor Appendix B: Figures and Descriptions 42

44 City of Lawrenceville TAD #2 - College Corridor TAD Parcels PIN Owner Address Acres 2011 Appraised Value 2011 Assessed Value 2011 Taxable Value 5145A003 LAMB JOHN T 61 NORTHDALE PL $49,900 $19,960 $19, A004 BURG JOHN M 67 NORTHDALE PL $50,400 $20,160 $20, A005 VARGHESE ROY 71 NORTHDALE PL $49,900 $19,960 $19, A006 PARAYIL SURESH T 77 NORTHDALE PL $51,600 $20,640 $20, A007 MARTINEZ GEORGINA 81 NORTHDALE PL $59,500 $23,800 $3, A008 WALKER SUNDOWN 87 NORTHDALE PL $57,000 $22,800 $22, A009 STILTNER PAUL A 91 NORTHDALE PL $57,500 $23,000 $23, A010 GILMER JUDY A 97 NORTHDALE PL $58,000 $23,200 $3, A011 SCHULZE RODOLF 101 NORTHDALE CT $58,000 $23,200 $23, A012 THOMAS PHILIP & TESSA 107 NORTHDALE PL $59,500 $23,800 $3, A013 EARLY GLENDA 111 NORTHDALE PL $59,500 $23,800 $3, A014 SOUTHERN VERANDA LLC 117 NORTHDALE PL $58,000 $23,200 $23, A015 COOPER RANDALL M 121 NORTHDALE PL $58,000 $23,200 $3, A016 MORA ALBERTO 127 NORTHDALE PL $57,500 $23,000 $3, A017 JEFFCOAT JUSTIN A 131 NORTHDALE PL $58,000 $23,200 $3, A018 LEVITT BETTY A 137 NORTHDALE PL $59,500 $23,800 $3, A019 LE CHRISTINE T 141 NORTHDALE PL $40,000 $16,000 $16, A020 AMERSON SARAH S 147 NORTHDALE PL $58,000 $23,200 $3, A021 SALAZAR WILMER 151 NORTHDALE PL $60,300 $24,120 $24, A022 SOUTHERN VERANDA LLC 157 NORTHDALE PL $57,500 $23,000 $23, A023 SOUTHERN VERANDA LLC 161 NORTHDALE PL $58,000 $23,200 $23, A024 CAROLYN V WEXLER 167 NORTHDALE PL $59,500 $23,800 $23, A025 JENKINS BEVERLY SMITH 171 NORTHDALE PL $59,500 $23,800 $23, A026 HOUSTON PAUL 177 NORTHDALE PL $58,000 $23,200 $23, A027 BANK OF NEW YORKS, AS TRUSTEE 181 NORTHDALE PL $58,000 $23,200 $23, A028 KERWIN JAMES B 187 NORTHDALE PL $50,000 $20,000 $0 5145A029 CULBRETH THOMAS GRAHAM 191 NORTHDALE PL $58,000 $23,200 $23, A030 MALCOM CHRISTIAN S 197 NORTHDALE PL $59,500 $23,800 $23, A031 BARBER BARBARA ANNE 201 NORTHDALE PL $59,500 $23,800 $23, A032 ECHOLS MARVIN KENNETH 207 NORTHDALE PL $57,500 $23,000 $3, A033 LE CUONG 211 NORTHDALE PL $58,000 $23,200 $3, A034 HURLEY SYLVIA J 217 NORTHDALE PL $58,000 $23,200 $3, A035 BROWN STEVEN R ETAL 221 NORTHDALE PL $57,500 $23,000 $3, A036 WAGNER SANDRA 227 NORTHDALE PL $59,500 $23,800 $3, A037 HAYS CHARLES 231 NORTHDALE PL $51,600 $20,640 $ A038 CAROLYN V WEXLER 237 NORTHDALE PL $49,900 $19,960 $19, A039 CHRISTIAN ALLEN 241 NORTHDALE PL $50,400 $20,160 $20, A040 FARTHING DAVID M & REBECCA D 247 NORTHDALE PL $50,400 $20,160 $ A041 WATSON JOHN 251 NORTHDALE PL $49,900 $19,960 $0 5145A042 BELMAR EMMANUEL 257 NORTHDALE PL $51,600 $20,640 $20,640 Source: Gwinnett County Tax Assessor Appendix B: Figures and Descriptions 43

45 City of Lawrenceville TAD #2 - College Corridor TAD Parcels PIN Owner Address Acres 2011 Appraised Value 2011 Assessed Value 2011 Taxable Value 5145A043 ROBERTS DONALD 261 NORTHDALE PL $51,600 $20,640 $ A044 ARNOLD WILLIAM E LLL 267 NORTHDALE PL $50,400 $20,160 $ A045 LARSON STEVEN G 271 NORTHDALE PL $30,000 $12,000 $12, A046 ANTHONY LINDA R 277 NORTHDALE PL $49,900 $19,960 $0 5145A047 BRIGGS SANDRA L 281 NORTHDALE PL $50,400 $20,160 $20, A048 PILET JUDY 287 NORTHDALE PL $49,900 $19,960 $19, A049 DUMONJIC JASMINKA 291 NORTHDALE PL $50,400 $20,160 $ A050 ARNOLD WILLIAM E III 297 NORTHDALE PL $51,600 $20,640 $20, A051 RUNNELS ELLEN M 436 NORTHDALE PL $51,600 $20,640 $ A052 PEREZ-GREEN JANIF 434 NORTHDALE CT $50,400 $20,160 $ A053 THRIFT NANCY J 426 NORTHDALE CT $50,400 $20,160 $ A054 HOUSE ANNE MILLER 422 NORTHDALE CT $49,900 $19,960 $19, A055 PILET JUDY N 416 NORTHDALE CT $50,400 $20,160 $20, A056 AUSTIN LISA 412 NORTHDALE CT $50,400 $20,160 $20, A057 AMERICAN LIEN FUND LP 406 NORTHDALE CT $49,900 $19,960 $19, A058 JONES TONYA CRYSTAL 402 NORTHDALE CT $50,400 $20,160 $ A059 DONEGAN MARY ANN 396 NORTHDALE CT $51,600 $20,640 $ A060 STEPHENS KAY 392 NORTHDALE CT $49,100 $19,640 $0 5145A061 WADSWORTH BOBBIE J 386 NORTHDALE CT $49,900 $19,960 $0 5145A062 LAUCK DAVID M 382 NORTHDALE CT $50,400 $20,160 $ A063 FARTHING BOBBIE S 376 NORTHDALE CT $50,400 $20,160 $ A064 JONES KYLE 372 NORTHDALE CT $51,600 $20,640 $ A065 SUMMERS CHARLIE J 383 NORTHDALE CT $50,400 $20,160 $20, A066 NASH DONNA F 387 NORTHDALE CT $50,400 $20,160 $ A067 SHAFER STEVEN D & MISTY M 393 NORTHDALE CT $49,600 $19,840 $ A068 KELSEY JACKIE S 397 NORTHDALE CT $49,900 $19,960 $0 5145A069 MURRAY NICOLE M 403 NORTHDALE CT $50,400 $20,160 $ A070 VANDORME PHILIPPE 407 NORTHDALE CT $50,400 $20,160 $20, A071 SOUTHERN VERANDA LLC 413 NORTHDALE CT $58,000 $23,200 $23, A072 HOWELL ADAM B 417 NORTHDALE CT $58,000 $23,200 $23, A073 KONDOR ILDIKO 423 NORTHDALE CT $58,000 $23,200 $3, A074 MCCLUNG LUCILLE IRENE 427 NORTHDALE CT $57,500 $23,000 $3, A075 SOUTHERN VERANDA LLC 433 NORTHDALE CT $58,000 $23,200 $23, A076 LALLATIN GLENDA 437 NORTHDALE CT $59,500 $23,800 $3, A077 PRICE ELVIN C 418 NORTHDALE CT $59,500 $23,800 $23, A078 PAPPY SAMUEL 414 NORTHDALE RD $48,500 $19,400 $19, A079 HUSSAIN DHIFAA A 408 NORTHDALE RD $20,000 $8,000 ($12,000) 5145A080 ROBINSON KARA L 404 NORTHDALE RD $58,000 $23,200 $3, A081 HEATH RUSSELL E & CHARLES L JR 398 NORTHDALE RD $58,000 $23,200 $3, A082 CLARK ROSETTA M 394 NORTHDALE RD $57,500 $23,000 $3,000 Source: Gwinnett County Tax Assessor Appendix B: Figures and Descriptions 44

46 City of Lawrenceville TAD #2 - College Corridor TAD Parcels PIN Owner Address Acres 2011 Appraised Value 2011 Assessed Value 2011 Taxable Value 5145A083 PAPPY SAMUEL 388 NORTHDALE RD $48,500 $19,400 $19, A084 CHACKO GEORGE N 382 NORTHDALE RD $46,000 $18,400 ($1,600) 5145A086 NORTHDALE CONDOMINIUMS NORTHDALE PLACE 0.0 $0 $0 $ E092 CITY OF LAWRENCEVILLE OAK ST 2.5 $330,200 $132,080 $0 5146B GROUP THE 394 NORTH CLAYTON ST 1.0 $74,200 $29,680 $29, B143 SCHURECK STEPHEN A 480 SOUTH PERRY ST 0.5 $437,400 $174,960 $174, B144 WALKER LOIS C 465 NORTH CLAYTON ST 0.5 $124,800 $49,920 $49, C001 LANCE KENNETH RAILROAD ST 0.5 $4,400 $1,760 $1, C002 LANCE KENNETH RAILROAD ST 0.2 $1,300 $520 $ C003 LANCE KENNETH RAILROAD ST 0.2 $2,000 $800 $ C005 CITY OF LAWRENCEVILLE RAILROAD ST 0.5 $35,300 $14,120 $0 5146C006 CHILDRESS A B 777 NORTH CLAYTON ST 1.4 $343,800 $137,520 $137, C007 CURCIO LOUIS A & APRIL M 625 NORTH CLAYTON ST 0.2 $114,700 $45,880 $45, C008 CLAYTON STREET COMPLEX INC 651 NORTH CLAYTON ST 0.7 $178,400 $71,360 $71, C009 MECHANICAL EQUIPMENT CO 745 NORTH CLAYTON ST 0.3 $65,500 $26,200 $26, C010 ELLIOTT TIMOTHY C 783 NORTH CLAYTON ST 0.3 $96,700 $38,680 $38, C011 WILLIAMS DONALD 806 NORTH CLAYTON ST 0.7 $76,700 $30,680 $30, C012 BACON BETTY A 750 NORTH CLAYTON ST 0.4 $79,100 $31,640 $31, C013 GANN H PARKER JR 113 MADDOX ST 0.5 $109,900 $43,960 $43, C014 BAILEY GLENN E & JACQUELINE P 127 MADDOX ST 0.3 $75,300 $30,120 $10, C015 BAILEY GLENN E ETAL MADDOX ST 0.2 $2,500 $1,000 $1, C016 HOUSING AUTHORITY MADDOX ST 5.0 $951,100 $380,440 $0 5146C018 MATHIS ALAN 155 MADDOX ST 0.5 $59,400 $23,760 $3, C020 GWINNETT METRO BAPRIST NEW CHURCH FO WEST PIKE ST 0.6 $338,700 $135,480 $0 5146C022 MUNICIPAL ELECTRIC AUTHORITY OF GEOR MADDOX ST 0.0 $0 $0 $0 5146C023 MUNICIPAL ELECTRIC AUTHORITY OF GEOR MADDOX ST 0.0 $0 $0 $0 5146C024 TOMAT REAL INC 164 MADDOX ST 1.3 $568,500 $227,400 $227, C027 HUYNH THY 122 MADDOX ST 0.3 $25,000 $10,000 $10, C028 PHILLIPS EDGAR JAMES TRUST ETA N CLAYTON ST 0.5 $25,100 $10,040 $10, C029 OSSEGE GREGORY S ETAL 634 NORTH CLAYTON ST 0.1 $43,100 $17,240 $17, C031 COOPER W O AGT ETAL WEST PIKE ST 0.3 $62,500 $25,000 $25, C032 MEA FAMILY INVESTMENTS LP 38 REID ST 0.5 $77,500 $31,000 $31, C034 CLAYTON STREET HOLDINGS LLC 550 NORTH CLAYTON ST 1.0 $510,700 $204,280 $204, C036 TWO BROTHERS TIRES INC 165 MADDOX ST 0.2 $137,000 $54,800 $54, C038 MUNICIPAL ELECTRIC AUTHORITY OF GEOR MADDOX ST 0.2 $0 $0 $0 5146E 017 BD OF COMM GWINNETT CTY OAK ST 4.7 $2,078,500 $831,400 $0 5146E 019 LAWRENCEVILLE HOUSING AUTHORITY MALTBIE ST 6.0 $999,800 $399,920 $0 5146E 023 COOPER SUZANNE M 402 SOUTH PERRY ST 0.3 $77,500 $31,000 $11, E 074 GWINNETT COUNTY BOARD OF COMMISSIONE 405 NORTH PERRY ST 1.5 $476,900 $190,760 $ JACKSON ELECTRIC MEM CORP LYLE CIR 0.0 $0 $0 $0 Source: Gwinnett County Tax Assessor Appendix B: Figures and Descriptions 45

47 City of Lawrenceville TAD #2 - College Corridor TAD Parcels PIN Owner Address Acres 2011 Appraised Value 2011 Assessed Value 2011 Taxable Value BRUNO ANTHONY J D V M 552 BUFORD DR 0.6 $400,000 $160,000 $160, MCWATERS TERRY 562 BUFORD DR 0.4 $112,900 $45,160 $45, PEEVY DONN M 572 BUFORD DR 0.4 $198,600 $79,440 $79, PASCHAL DONALD R 509 BUFORD DR 0.5 $225,900 $90,360 $90, BLACKWELL JERRY TRUMAN 131 HURRICANE SHOALS RD 0.4 $116,500 $46,600 $46, A MCCARTHY JERRY F & DONNA B 125 HURRICANE SHOALS RD 0.3 $250,000 $100,000 $100, BRAND BANKING COMPANY THE 141 HURRICANE SHOALS RD 1.6 $1,500,000 $600,000 $600, HURRICANE SHOALS ROAD PARTNERS HURRICANE SHOALS RD 0.9 $69,000 $27,600 $27, A JACKSON ELECTRIC MEM CORP HURRICANE SHOALS RD 0.0 $0 $0 $ GUNTER JEWELL LEE 579 LYLE CIR 1.1 $261,500 $104,600 $104, PASCHAL DONALD R 121 HURRICANE SHOALS RD 0.3 $120,400 $48,160 $48, HARMONY MANOR LTD 596 HURRICANE SHOALS RD 4.6 $1,216,000 $486,400 $486, BROWNLEE M D JR ETAL 597 BUFORD DR 1.37 $719,500 $287,800 $287, SEELIGER GWENDOLYN G 33 HURRICANE SHOALS RD 0.6 $180,000 $72,000 $72, HARMONY MANOR LTD 59 HURRICANE SHOALS RD 1.1 $249,400 $99,760 $99, BLACKWELL JERRY TRUMAN 133 HURRICANE SHOALS RD 0.5 $53,300 $21,320 $21, THE BRAND BANKING COMPANY 526 LYLE CIR 0.3 $178,400 $71,360 $71, GP PORTFOLIO LANDLORD #2 LLC GA HWY $1,033,900 $413,560 $413, A WHITEHEAD CHARLES E ETAL 523 HURRICANE SHOALS RD 0.7 $132,600 $53,040 $53, B HUFF DONALD R 515 HURRICANE SHOALS RD 1.2 $184,900 $73,960 $73, MCNALLY MARK T 326 HURRICANE SHOALS RD 1.5 $351,100 $140,440 $140, BENSON KENNETH C MD HURRICANE SHOALS RD 2.8 $297,100 $118,840 $118, IMPERIAL PROPERTIES LLC 301 PHILIP BLVD 2.4 $2,375,000 $950,000 $950, BENSON KENNETH C IRA HURRICANE SHOALS RD 3.1 $375,000 $150,000 $150, HOMEMART REALTY GROUP INC 284 HURRICANE SHOALS RD 0.5 $229,400 $91,760 $91, A STATON LARRY L & BOBBIE J 505 HURRICANE SHOALS RD 0.7 $184,000 $73,600 $73, ANN & RC LLC 256 HURRICANE SHOALS RD 1.0 $926,700 $370,680 $370, A SMITH C E 251 HURRICANE SHOALS RD 1.1 $800,000 $320,000 $320, BROOKS YVETTE CARLISLE 706 COLLINS HILL RD 0.5 $396,300 $158,520 $158, COLLINS HILL MEDICAL PROPERTIES INC 870 COLLINS HILL RD 0.7 $807,500 $323,000 $323, GGC REAL ESTATE PARKING I LLC 20 COLLINS HILL RD 5.0 $3,231,800 $1,292,720 $1,292, HWK INVESTMENTS INC 850 COLLINS HILL RD 5.8 $3,000,000 $1,200,000 $1,200, GKA PROPERTIES LLC 860 COLLINS HILL RD 0.7 $1,029,600 $411,840 $411, GGC REAL ESTATE PARKING I LLC 55 COLLINS INDUSTRIAL WAY 2.0 $1,963,500 $785,400 $ AAT HOLDINGS, LLC 15 COLLINS INDUSTRIAL WAY 0.3 $594,600 $237,840 $237, BINKLEY JOHN CLAYBORNE 15 COLLINS INDUSTRIAL WAY 0.2 $424,700 $169,880 $169, WALKER JAMES C 1663 COLLINS HILL RD 0.2 $3,300 $1,320 $1, BOSTOCK WILLIAM K 1663 COLLINS HILL RD 0.4 $67,400 $26,960 $26, HWK COMPANY INC COLLINS INDUSTRIAL WAY 0.6 $69,500 $27,800 $27, HURRICANE/316 LLC 732 COLLINS HILL RD 0.9 $96,200 $38,480 $38,480 Source: Gwinnett County Tax Assessor Appendix B: Figures and Descriptions 46

48 City of Lawrenceville TAD #2 - College Corridor TAD Parcels PIN Owner Address Acres 2011 Appraised Value 2011 Assessed Value 2011 Taxable Value HURRICANE/316 LLC 700 COLLINS HILL RD 0.5 $25,000 $10,000 $10, HURRICANE/316 LLC 690 COLLINS HILL RD 1.0 $800,000 $320,000 $320, HURRICANE/316 LLC 650 COLLINS HILL RD 1.4 $230,800 $92,320 $92, A001 TYFOR INVESTMENTS INC 299 HURRICANE SHOALS RD 0.4 $631,000 $252,400 $252, A002 MJET LLC 510 HURRICANE SHOALS RD 0.4 $62,800 $25,120 $25, A036 KENNEDY MILDRED BENNETT 492 HURRICANE SHOALS RD 0.8 $87,600 $35,040 $35, A038 SMITH C E HURRICANE SHOALS RD 0.4 $23,900 $9,560 $9, A039 SMITH C E HURRICANE SHOALS RD 0.4 $25,900 $10,360 $10, A040 BLACKSTOCK NORMAN 115 BELMONT DR 0.5 $138,300 $55,320 $55, A LEWIS BROTHERS LAND HOLDINGS HWY $2,128,500 $851,400 $851, LODGE DEVELOPMENT IV LLC HWY $2,375,000 $950,000 $950, MEHRE HARRY J 660 BUFORD DR 0.3 $170,000 $68,000 $68, LAWRENCEVILLE CENTER ASSO LLC 675 BUFORD DR 8.99 $313,280 $360,000 $360, COPPAGE JEAN A LYLE CIR 2.5 $275,300 $110,120 $110, A GEORGIA TRANSMISSION CORP LYLE CIR 2.7 $0 $0 $ LONG BILLY W 624 LYLE CIR 1.1 $150,600 $60,240 $60, WEBB BOBBY W 644 LYLE CIR 0.5 $115,400 $46,160 $26, ARNOLD CHARLES COLLINS HILL RD 1.7 $64,000 $25,600 $25, BROGDON SHEILA H 672 LYLE CIR 0.5 $26,700 $10,680 $10, BROGDON SHEILA H 672 LYLE CIR 0.6 $109,700 $43,880 $23, COLLINS HILLS GROUP LLC 651 COLLINS HILL RD 8.5 $297,900 $119,160 $119, A BROGDON SHEILA H 672 LYLE CIR 0.5 $26,900 $10,760 $10, RICHARDS REX G 634 LYLE CIR 0.4 $119,700 $47,880 $47, SANT NIRANKARI MISSION HWY $350,000 $140,000 $140, SEASIDE ENTERPRISES INC 635 BUFORD DR 1.86 $750,000 $300,000 $300, BROWNLEE BUDDY E NE HWY $37,800 $15,120 $15, INGLES MARKETS INCORPORATED 3675 BUFORD DR 7.87 $750,000 $300,000 $300, VON ULRIC INC 125 PARK ACCESS DR 1.4 $1,242,200 $496,880 $496, KEELAGHAN ASSOCIATES PROPERTIES LLC 751 COLLINS HILL RD 0.4 $313,000 $125,200 $125, PROPERTY GA20 LLC 655 BUFORD DR 1.28 $175,000 $70,000 $70, GA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION 875 COLLINS HILL RD 0.8 $548,400 $219,360 $219, S & K PROPERTIES INC 175 PARK ACCESS DR 0.6 $38,800 $15,520 $15, S & K PROPERTIES INC ETAL 731 COLLINS HILL RD 0.9 $646,400 $258,560 $258, MUELLER DONALD H & WENDY S 155 PARK ACCESS DR 1.0 $1,000,000 $400,000 $400, MUELLER DONALD H 175 PARK ACCESS DR 1.4 $1,100,000 $440,000 $440, HUBERT PROPERTIES LLLP HWY $143,000 $57,200 $57, MALOUF JOSEPH 104 HURRICANE SHOALS RD 0.6 $366,300 $146,520 $146, PREMIER INVESTMENT PROPERTIES 134 HURRICANE SHOALS RD 0.6 $877,200 $350,880 $350, SMITH C E HURRICANE SHOALS RD 0.6 $89,400 $35,760 $35, PREMIER INV PROPERTIES LLC 132 HURRICANE SHOALS RD 0.7 $580,000 $232,000 $232,000 Source: Gwinnett County Tax Assessor Appendix B: Figures and Descriptions 47

49 City of Lawrenceville TAD #2 - College Corridor TAD Parcels PIN Owner Address Acres 2011 Appraised Value 2011 Assessed Value 2011 Taxable Value CAREY STORAGE I (GA) STORE HOUSE LLC 98 HURRICANE SHOALS RD 7.5 $3,785,200 $1,514,080 $1,514, S & K PROPERTIES INC 175 PARK ACCESS DR 1.3 $412,900 $165,160 $165, S & K PROPERTIES INC 175 PARK ACCESS DR 1.28 $412,900 $165,160 $165, STOVALL PROPERTIES INC 695 LYLE CIR 1.4 $744,000 $297,600 $297, RANDOLPH L MEYER INC 185 PARK ACCESS DR 3.7 $554,700 $221,880 $221, LAMB HAL B III 887 BUFORD DR 0.6 $83,600 $33,440 $33, BOARD OF REGENTS OF THE UNIVERSITY S COLLINS HILL RD 17.1 $774,700 $309,880 $ GGC REAL ESTATE II LLC 940 NE COLLINS HILL RD 6.6 $3,195,200 $1,278,080 $ BOARD OF REGENTS OF THE UNIVERSITY O COLLINS HILL RD 23.3 $816,600 $326,640 $ BOARD OF REGENTS UNIVERSITY SY COLLINS HILL RD $5,579,700 $2,231,880 $ GWINNETT COUNTY GEORGIA COLLINS HILL RD 5.0 $226,500 $90,600 $0 Total $103,177,280 $41,505,600 $32,324,720 Source: Gwinnett County Tax Assessor Appendix B: Figures and Descriptions 48

50 DEVELOPMENT PLAN AND TAD POTENTIAL City of Lawrenceville TAD #2 College Corridor Potential TAD Projects Project A B C D E Total Parcels Acreage Appraised Value $10,429,600 $7,513,400 $5,186,400 $2,331,400 $2,885,600 $28,346, Assessed Value $4,171,840 $3,005,360 $2,074,560 $932,560 $1,154,240 $11,338, Taxable Value $4,131,840 $3,005,360 $1,151,760 $863,320 $0 $9,152,280 Potential Redevelopment Projects Developable Acreage (%) 80% 60% 60% 60% 80% Developable Acreage (%) Residential Townhomes Units (10 /acre) Value per Unit $175,000 $175,000 $175,000 $175,000 $175,000 $175,000 Condos Units (35/acre) Value per Unit $150,000 $150,000 $150,000 $150,000 $225,000 $225,000 Student Apartments Units (40/acre) Value per Unit $125,000 $125,000 $125,000 $125,000 $125,000 $125,000 Total Residential Value $46,380,000 $11,576,250 $0 $29,906,100 $11,250,000 $99,112,350 Commercial Retail S.F. (25,000/acre) 154,600-93,360 88, ,790 Value per S.F. $125 $125 $125 $125 $125 $125 Office S.F. (30,000/acre) - 85, , , ,234 Value per S.F. $150 $150 $150 $150 $150 $150 Hotel (25/acre) Rooms Value per Room $175,000 $175,000 $175,000 $175,000 $175,000 $175,000 Total Commercial Value $59,907,500 $12,757,500 $36,877,200 $11,103,750 $18,770,400 $139,416,350 Civic S.F. (15,000/acre) 92, ,760 Value per S.F. $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 Total Appraised Value of Redevelopment $106,287,500 $24,333,750 $36,877,200 $41,009,850 $30,020,400 $238,528,700 Total Assessed Value of Redevelopment $42,515,000 $9,733,500 $14,750,880 $16,403,940 $12,008,160 $95,411,480 Total Taxable Value of Redevelopment * $42,515,000 $8,410,500 $14,750,880 $15,693,300 $11,008,160 $92,377,840 Appendix B: Figures and Descriptions 49

51 City of Lawrenceville TAD #2 - College Corridor Potential TAD Estimate 2011 Market Value of Redevelopment Projects $28,346, Taxable Value of Redevelopment Projects $9,152,280 Potential Taxable Value of Projects at Build Out $92,377,840 Net New Taxable Value Increment at Build Out $83,225, Millage Rates for TAD Purposes City of Lawrenceville Gwinnett County Incorporated M&O Gwinnett Schools M&O Total Millage Rate New Property Taxes* $2,762,256 Bondable Value (95%) $2,624,144 Debt Coverage Ratio 125% Bondable Property Tax $2,099,315 TAD Bond Amount Interest Rate 7.0% Bond Term (years) 25 Estimated Bond Amount* $24,620,365 Issuance Costs (3%) $738,611 Capitalized Interest (24 months) $3,200,647 Debt Reserve (10%) $2,309,246 Net Bond Proceeds $18,371,860 Appendix B: Figures and Descriptions 50

52 COST SCHEDULE Infrastructure Item City of Lawrenceville TAD #2 College Corridor Potential Allocation of TAD Funds Estimated Cost 1 Infrastructure Improvements $5,520,000 2 Curb and Sidewalk Improvements/Traffic Control $3,680,000 3 Structured Parking $3,680,000 4 Site Preparation Demolition and Clearance, Remediation $1,840,000 4 Parks and Greenspace $2,760,000 5 Other Redevelopment Initiatives $920,000 Total Initial TAD Funding Request $18,400,000 Categories and cost allocations are estimates for potential projects as of October, 2011 and are subject to revision as the Redevelopment Plan is implemented. This will change over time as priorities are identified or addressed. Specific project amounts, allocations and priorities are subject to change. Appendix B: Figures and Descriptions 51

53 APPENDIX C. LAWRENCEVILLE CITY COUNCIL Judy Jordan Johnson, Mayor Marie Beiser P.K. Martin, IV Tony Powell Katie Hart Smith Appendix C: Lawrenceville City Council 52

54 APPENDIX D. GWINNETT COUNTY BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS Charlotte J. Nash, County Commissioner Shirley Lasseter, District 1 Commissioner Lynette Howard, District 2 Commissioner Mike Beaudreau, District 3 Commissioner John Heard, District 4 Commissioner Appendix D: Gwinnett County Board of Commissioners 53

55 APPENDIX E. GWINNETT COUNTY BOARD OF EDUCATION Dr. Robert McClure, District IV, 2011 Chairman Louise Radloff, District V, 2011 Vice-Chairman Carole Boyce, District I Daniel D. Seckinger, District II Dr. Mary Kay Murphy, District III Appendix E: Gwinnett County Board of Education 54