Aalto RAE Self-Assessment Report. School of Design, University of Art and Design Helsinki. Contact: Ilpo Koskinen

Transcription

1 1(25) Aalto RAE Self-Assessment Report School of Design, University of Art and Design Helsinki Contact: Ilpo Koskinen TOC 1. SoD s Present Research Profile Scientific Quality of the Unit s Research in Scientific Impact of the Unit s Research in Societal Impact of the Unit s Research in Research Environment at the Unit of Assessment Future Potential of the Units of Assessment SWOT...10 Appendices...11 Appendix 1: 3-page Curricula Vitæ of SoD Professors (N=4) Keinonen, Turkka Korvenmaa, Pekka Koskinen, Ilpo Priha, Päikki...20 Appendix 2. Addenda to Section

2 2(25) 1. SoD s Present Research Profile School of Design defined a research strategy in early 2001; before that, research was done on individual basis. Currently, the strategy focuses on two main research areas and several auxiliary areas that change quicker. 1. Main research areas User-Centered Design. In the 1990s in industrial design, there was a group of researchers who built on ergonomics, but focused on usability. With Turkka Keinonen and Simo Säde, industrial design built a small research basis, getting intellectual and project support mostly from technical universities. Keinonen s and Säde s work proved to be useful in education, but also attracted a new intellectually curious researchers, in whose hands usability transformed first into studies of user experience, and later into what we call user-centered industrial design. Currently, there are two lines in this research. First, there are studies on methods. For example, Tuuli Mattelmäki (DA in 2006) is world expert on (cultural) probes methodology, an influential, design-based methodology that is currently spreading into many other fields of research. Second there are theoretical studies, conducted under the supervision of prof. Ilpo Koskinen, by Esko Kurvinen, who became ethnomethodologist, and Katja Battarbee, whose notion of coexperience builds on another sociological tradition, symbolic interactionism. Design Studies and Practice-Based Research. The story of more culturally oriented research goes back to the 1990s. After prof. Pekka Korvenmaa left UIAH TaiK Research institute and joined industrial design in 2000, he provided guidance and protection for many pieces of research in what has come to be known as design studies. The most notable work was Anna Valtonen s history of industrial design. However, Korvenmaa s students have recently been working on design studies rather than history. Prof. Päikki Priha has supervised most histories in textile design. When DA Maarit Mäkelä joined the School for two years after defending her doctoral thesis in 2003, she started to map possibilities and modes for doing practice-led research in the interface of art driven design and academic discourse. The most notable piece of work is a book Mäkelä edited with Sara Routarinne from a colloquium in 2005, and the second conference in 2007, organized by Nithikul Nimkulrat. 2. Auxiliary research areas Applied Materials Research. Research in ceramics and to an extent, glass design began in the 1990s, but became unsystematic in the new millennia when the physicist Markku Rajala left the department to a start-up focusing on nanocoatings. When doctoral seminars for ceramics students restarted in 2002 after a

3 3(25) pause, new momentum built up in ceramics, leading to several doctoral theses and several articles, most notably by Raija Siikamäki who defended on recycling of CRT monitor glass. In textiles, a good example of materials research is Tiina Härkäsalmi s recent DA thesis. Strategic Design. While previous stories largely tell about internal development, the final story goes external. When the government set up design policy in , lots of money was poured money into design research. Not unsurprisingly, the structure of the policy built on earlier work in industrial design. A good deal of research funding was used for user-centered design, but other research areas were built up practically from scratch. Most notably, there were a few studies on what we called strategic design, which explored the way in which design is organized in formal organizations. Research at SoD responds to Taik strategy in all details. Even though SoD research is fairly new and practically all resources are used for doctoral education, its research is well-known internationally among design schools, which often benchmark its work. The most relevant competitors and reference groups vary: - User-centered design: Technische Universiteit Eindhoven/industrial design, Carnegie Mellon University/School of Design and HCI; University of Southern Denmark; in Asia, KAIST, human-centered interaction design lab - Design Studies and Practice-Based Research: several British Universities and design schools, including Royal College of Art, London; Chelsea School of Art and Design In auxiliary areas, it is more difficult to point out benchmarks, as research mostly stems from individual efforts. The most important sources of nourishment available to SoD are user-centered research and design studies. It is not difficult to get foreign visitors and doctoral students to these areas. 2. Scientific Quality of the Unit s Research in Research at SoD has focused on research education in belief that one has to train a generation of researchers before getting into a more serious research-based training mode in design occupations that are practice-based more than traditional sciences. However, design research in Taik can already be considered relatively advanced considering the practice grounded tradition of design and design

4 4(25) education. Figure 1 has a breakdown of research by main research areas explained above (note that terminology varies slightly). Figure 1: Refereed articles at SoD by research strategy, (Source: data collected for Academy of Finland evaluation in 2008; 2008 missing from these publications, 2007 underrepresented) What comes to senior researchers, between there have been only three professors who have been nominated on scientific grounds, and the number has not increased during the period. They have been active in many other fields than research including policy-making and department administration, which explains large variations in productivity. In particular, doctoral education eats resources; today the School produces annually about 3-4 doctoral degrees which, considering the number of senior research resources, can be considered high. During the evaluation period also a more organized doctoral education arrangement, Design Connections Doctoral School, started as collaboration with University of Lapland, Faculty of Art and Design. With its 14 doctoral students, five enjoying funding from the school, DCDS is a major design research education project on international scale. In addition, several professional and textbooks edited in international, crossdisciplinary and academy-business collaboration that are based on research have been published. Also, professors at SoD have run 21 research projects during , including 8 funded by the Academy of Finland. For SoD, excellence in research is a matter of international recognition measured by publications and reputation, and the number of incoming doctoral students. Currently research strives to achieve its aims and increase quality by Establishing its position as a normal part of the School s activities Creating a separate research budget (from 2008) to support long-term research planning Building an electronics laboratory to support user-centered research Increasing the number of post-doctoral researchers. In 2009, five post-docs are working at the School. This is exceptional in the history of TaiK.

5 5(25) Establishing a wide international network with doctoral students and faculty (from 2006, it has recruited several foreign-born doctoral students; four researchers and two professors have spent significant periods of time overseas, including Art Center in Pasadena; Illinois Institute of Technology, Palo Alto Research Center, National University of Singapore) No doubt, the main achievement of the School is that design research has become a normal and integral part of academic life in design, both in terms of doctoral education and in terms of its impact on the School s strategy and education. This is an exceptional achievement among art and design schools that in general value practice at the cost of disvaluing intellectual endeavors. In fact, a good deal of education at MA level in industrial design, where this trend is at its peak, is almost wholly dependent on research. In terms of individual pieces of research, SoD research on mobile multimedia has become an international benchmark in the social sciences and software engineering. 3. Scientific Impact of the Unit s Research in Doctors in universities. In 2008, three SoD doctorates from work at the School: Tuuli Mattelmäki, Maarit Mäkelä, and Sonja Iltanen. Kärt Summatavet became professor first at Estonian Academy of Art and then Tartu University. Fang Hai works in China as researcher and professor. Antti Alhava works as a professor of architecture in Helsinki University of technology. Most other doctors work either in industry or college-level schools, including Satu Miettinen. Of professors, Turkka Keinonen spent a year at National University of Singapore. Q. Are the professors and other senior researchers at the Unit active in international learned societies, editorial boards of international journals, tenure and doctoral committees etc.? A. Professor Keinonen is book reviewer for Springer, and reviews regularly for several conferences and journals. He has supervised 1 doctoral degree to finish, examined or pre-examined 4 doctoral theses, and evaluated one professorship. He has 8 patents between Professor Korvenmaa is in two editorial boards (Design Journal 1997-, Arkkitehti 2007-) and is associate editor in Journal of Design and Culture (2009-). Currently he evaluates the tenure of Clive Dilnot at Parsons the New School of Design in New York. He has supervised 5 doctoral degrees to finish, done 11 examinations or pre-examinations, out of which 2 abroad (Estonia, Austria). Prof. Koskinen is editor-in-chief of Knowledge, Technology and Policy (publisher Springer, formerly Transaction Publishers). He has evaluated two professorships, including one tenure evaluation for Carnegie Mellon University. Between , he has supervised 4 doctoral degrees to

6 6(25) finish, and either examined or pre-examined 13 doctoral theses, including 5 abroad (Denmark 2, Norway, Holland, Spain). He has reviewed book proposals for several publishing companies, and edited a series of design books for IT Press. Dr. Mattelmäki is program chair in Nordes 2009, and is currently reviewing a professorship for Chalmers University of Technology, Sweden. Prof. Priha is in one editorial board, has examined one doctoral thesis, is in the board of directors of one foundation, All these people have functioned as referees, workshop organizers, and program committee members in numerous conferences. They have chaired three conferences (data in Appendix 2). Q. Have the members of research active staff received notable international research awards or other research-related honors in recent years? A. Not that we know. Q. What are the most relevant research projects the Unit has been engaged in during the Assessment Period jointly with units from other universities? A. Projects. Professors at SoD have been scientific leaders in 21 projects in (out of which professor Keinonen 10). With the exception of one or two, these have been cooperative efforts with other, mostly Finnish universities. In terms of scientific production, the most important ones have been The Academy of Finland funded Muotoilija: synty kasvu ja kehitys by professor Korvenmaa (with the University of Helsinki); and Tekes funded Proomu and Luotain projects run by prof. Keinonen with the University of Helsinki and a host of companies. European Union. SoD has made a conscious decision not to get involved in EU funding, due to lack of senior research personnel combined with their heavy admin duties, and teaching load. Q. Has the Unit been the main organizer of major international conferences? A. Five in Helsinki, two abroad. Data is in Appendix 2. Q. Does the Unit host a national or international Center of Excellence? A. No. 4. Societal Impact of the Unit s Research in Research at the SoD impacts via published material and through its personnel and post-doctoral alumni. The active senior research staff serves as members in several conferences, working groups, and collaborative university-industry projects. Recent doctors impact industry and design education design; mostly, industrial designers belong to the former, culturally oriented designers to the latter group. Some are also engaged in university activities and link between the re-

7 7(25) search community and industry. Publications, such as dissertations almost all published by Taik, but have a wide international distribution. As Appendix 2 suggests, SoD s impacts on science can be measured at three levels: at national and international levels, but also in policy terms. Being the oldest and largest school of its kind in Finland, located in the capital, means that a good deal of professors activity goes to policy and the third task. The most important societal impact is no doubt the way in which professor participated in creating and running the Design 2005 program. Q. What are the main channels through which the Unit interacts (in both ways) with the society at large? A. Normal academic means: participating in the boards of foundations; boards of research and policy-making bodies; publications. Q. Doctors in industry A. These include Simo Säde (2001) CEO of Etnoteam; Katja Battarbee (2004), a design specialist in IDEO, Palo Alto; Raija Siikamäki (2005) research manager in Iittala, Helsinki; Esko Kurvinen (2007), research manager in Elisa; Anna Valtonen (2007) design manager in Nokia. Q. What are the most important research projects the Unit has carried out with non-university partners from the public or private sector during the Assessment Period? A. In the Design 2005 program, there was plenty of collaboration with companies. 1. Luotain, Design for user experience a method development project, which produced one doctoral dissertation and text book about probes that has received plenty of attention also internationally; textbooks in Finnish and internationally about concept design; textbook (international) about applying video in design; well over 20 conference papers and articles; collaboration with main export industries, Nokia and GE Healthcare mostly. 2. Proactive design with University of Helsinki, Unit for Activity Theory and Developmental Work Research. This project studied the impact and integration of industrial design in business-to-business metal industry. It involved collaboration with basic industries (Metso and Kone Corps.), and produced two textbooks in Finnish (pro oeconomia honorary mention) as well as several journal articles and conference papers. Q. Has the research of the Unit produced spin-off companies? A. No. Q. Have the members of the Unit been able to secure national or international patents?

8 8(25) A. Professor Keinonen has 8 patents. Q. Are the members of research active staff preferred experts also outside the academia? A. Due to staff shortage, professors participate little to activities outside the academia. They do policy work, though, esp. through Designium (prof. Nieminen); several foundations (profs. Korvenmaa, Priha); government (prof. Koskinen); and innovation funding organizations (prof. Keinonen). 5. Research Environment at the Unit of Assessment Infrastructure is not an issue. SoD has been able to secure all resources it needs for research either through its educational infrastructure, or through its network. The main problem lies with the faculty expertise profile. Out of about 30 teaching faculty, only 3 people have been recruited on scientific merit. The ratio has not change to more scientific direction during ten last years. The ratio of 15 doctoral students / faculty is not sustainable. Accordingly, the main structural obstacle in developing research is personnel. The lack of senior research personnel makes it difficult to achieve excellence. 6. Future Potential of the Units of Assessment SoD research strategy still works, and its history has proven that it is robust but flexible enough to accommodate new openings. However, it is currently being structured from four research areas into a hierarchy of two main areas and auxiliary areas (Section 1). 1. User-centered design research has been based on working on the interface of traditional industrial design, design of interactive technologies and social sciences. The traditions have their own backgrounds, methods and values, which means that the interface in between is a fruitful environment for transferring and reinterpreting approaches and theories. Many of the most interesting results of SoD s research have grown from these kind of crossover projects. The development of user centered design research requires updates in interactive prototyping competencies and facilities. The first steps have been taken, but continuing investment and competence development is needed. 2. Design studies continue on its traditional, humanistic basis with no specific research groups, but continuing in trusting on individual initiative and ambition. The research on the culture of design participates in a worldwide trend. The impact design has through the cultural industries is a rich field of future

9 9(25) research especially in the global realm. This field, known as World Design, ranges from crafts in developing countries to activities of global corporations. This research field will have a mainstay at SoD, providing policy tools and new economic opportunities. Significant development is taking place in artbased research (often though misleadingly called practice-based or practice-led research). Here, SoD is developing an active international research community with Chelsea School of Art and Design, London. Aalto University will open a plenty of new opportunities in design-engineering collaboration. However, the early plans of research platforms in Aalto University fail in concentrating the existing expertise in user centered design and technology development. This may lead to university internal fight for the resources, unless a solution for consolidating the research will be found. It is unclear what kinds of opportunities Aalto University will create for other research areas. Q. How is the Unit s recruitment strategy designed to strengthen the future potential of the Unit and its staff? A. In 2004, SoD has approved a recruiting strategy that is committed to increasing the number of professors recruited on scientific, not professional or artistic merits. However, the recruitment strategy has never been followed. The research competence within the faculty has not been improved. Personnel structure is the greatest obstacle for improving research. Q. What is the present age profile of the senior research staff? A. AVE=50,6 yrs, stdev=7,31. Q. What were the Unit s most important research recruitments in and how does the Unit plan to attract the best international talent to join the Unit in the future? A. During only temporary research positions with external funding have been fulfilled. Q. Is there notable emerging talent among the Unit s post-doctoral students (please give examples of exceptional publications, national and international prizes won etc)? A. With the exception of Dr. Mattelmäki, current post-doc researchers are yet untested what comes to independent research work. On the other hand, the best doctoral students are clearly very talented, and maybe about 30% of doctorates are capable of filling professor jobs. Ultimately, the responsibility for research lies in researchers.

10 10(25) 7. SWOT Internal origin External origin Helpful in achieving the objectives Strengths 1. Strong basis in UCD and design studied 2. Extensive and hi-quality international network and decent-to-high international reputation 3. Tradition in innovation in research (see Appendix 2): courage to explore new initiatives 4. Solid support from SoD and UIAH 5. Solid publishing record Opportunities 1. Aalto brings new opportunities in particular to UCD 2. Collaboration with architecture (now at TKK) may help finding new research areas in design studies 3. SoD is aging: when professorships open, they may be opened on scientific basis 4. A generation of skilled postdocs is gaining experience in industry 5. Design research is coming of age internationally...harmful in achieving the objective Weaknesses 1. Research personnel is too small, creating bottlenecks and exhaustion esp. among active teachers and researchers 2. Professors workload: on average, professors are able to devote less than 10% of their time to research 3. Constant university and admin reforms direct attention inwards 4. In an university dominated by design and art, research is still expendable and suffers from category errors: applied research and even consulting is constantly taken for research 5. Uneven workloads Threats 1. SoD still chooses to fill vacant positions on professional and artistic grounds, against its strategy 2. Extra teaching, admin and evaluation load from Aalto allocated to the most active researchers 3. Design has a small international research community, which makes the assessment of impact difficult to measure and small by definition 4. In UCD, outdated technological basis 5.

11 11(25) Appendices Appendix 1: 3-page Curricula Vitæ of SoD Professors (N=4) 1. Keinonen, Turkka Degrees Doctor of Arts 1998 University of Art and Design Helsinki Dept. of Product and Strategic Design Licentiate of Arts 1994 University of Art and Design Helsinki Bachelor of Arts 1990 University of Art and Design Helsinki Positions Professor of industrial design University of Art and Design Helsinki, School of Design , Head of Design Connections Doctoral School 2007 Responsible for Usability School co-operation with Helsinki University of Technology and University of Helsinki , 2009 head of design research projects Luotain1,2,3 and Luotain Design for user experience Gaze path research supporting the user and designer , Design and domestication of technology , Thumb - Research on mobile ergonomics 2005, Studio 'n' Site , Design with Plastic www-education development project , Proomu 1,2,3 - Proactive design , Systematic product concept development initiative , Perception of Design , Ecological design of intelligent environment Visiting associate professor National University of Singapore, Department of Architecture Professor of design research University of Art and Design Helsinki Principal scientist Nokia Research Center, Usability group Researcher University of Art and Design Helsinki Interaction designer Muodos (present Desigence) Interaction designer Research and development center for welfare and health STAKES several periods Industrial designer Creadesign Industrial designer Valmet Paper Machines (present Metso Paper) several periods Expert posts FIMECC User Experience Group Steering group member FIMECC R&D council member 2008 ACM CHI03 Miami, co-chair 2003 Finnovation chair 2003 NordiCHI04 program committee 2004 In the making conference program committee 2005 MobileHCI2006 program committee 2006 co-chair Designing Pleasurable Products and Interfaces 2007 Nordes09 program committee IASDR09 program committee Reviews opponent Tuomo Tuikka s PhD Uniersity of Oulu 2002 pre-examiner Tanja Kotro s DA Taik 2003 pre-examiner Harri Kiljander s PhD, Eng. Helsinki University of Technology 2003 pre-examiner Raija Siikamäki s DA TaiK 2005 Design research pro-

12 12(25) fessorship at University of Lapland 2004 Design Start program review 2005 Springer reviewer 2007 International Journal of Design reviewer 2008 Articles in refereed scientific journals ( ) Keinonen, T., Jääskö, V. & Mattelmäki, T. (2008) Three-in-One User Study for Focused Collaboration. International Journal of Design, 2(1), Keinonen, T. (2008). Designing Business from Nucleus and Periphery. Design Management Review. 19(3) Keinonen, T. (2009). Immediate and Remote Design of Complex Environments. Design Issues. Spring 2009 Keinonen, T. (2009) Design Contribution Square. Advanced Engineering Informatics. In print. Articles in refereed edited book and conference proceedings ( ) Hulkko S, Keinonen T, Mattelmäki T and Virtanen K (2004). Mobile Probes. NordiCHI 2004 conference. Tampere, Finland October 2004 Sorvari A., Jalkanen J., Jokela R., Black A., Koli K., Moberg M. and Keinonen T. (2004). Usability Issues in Utilizing Context Metadata in Content Management of Mobile Devices. NordiCHI 2004 conference. Tampere, Finland October 2004 Keinonen, T., Kukkonen, S. & Vienamo, T. (2006). Conjoint analysis in evaluation of physical rapid prototypes. Design and Emotion conference. Gothenburg, October 2006 Keinonen, T. (2007). Node in the Ecology of Emerging Dispositions. Proceedings of IASDR07 Conference, Hong Kong, Keinonen, T. (2007). Immediate, Product and Remote Design. Proceedings of IASDR07 Conference, Hong Kong, Keinonen, T. and Koskinen, I. (2007). Research Driven Design Education. Proceedings of IASDR07 Conference, Hong Kong, Keinonen, T., Jääskö, V. and Mattelmäki, T. (2007). Three in One User Study. Proceedings of IASDR07 Conference, Hong Kong, Vaajakallio, K., Vehmas, K., Keinonen, T. and Mattelmäki, T. (2008).Design Research as Industry-University Collaboration. EUROMOT 2008 Conference in September 2008, Nice, France. Keinonen, T. (2008). Design Innovation in the Margin Industrial Design in Finnish Engineering Industry. EUROMOT 2008 Conference in September 2008, Nice, France. Keinonen, T. (2008). User Centered Design and Fundamental Need. NordicCHI08, Lund, Sweden, October Edited books ( ) Lindholm, C., Keinonen, T. & Kiljander, H. (eds.)(2003). Mobile Usability - How Nokia Changed the Face of the Mobile Phone, McGraw-Hill, New York Keinonen, T. & Jääskö, V. (eds.)(2004) Tuotekonseptointi [Product Concept Design]. Teknologiateollisuus, Helsinki [in Finnish] Hasu, M., Keinonen, T., Mutanen, U.-M., Aaltonen, A. Hakatie, A ja Kurvinen, E. (eds.)(2004) Muotoilun muutos - Näkökulmia muotoilutyön organisoinnin ja johtamisen kehityshaasteisiin 2000-luvulla [The Change of Design Views towards Development

13 13(25) Challenges in Organising and Managing Design in 2000s]. Teknologiateollisuus, Helsinki [in Finnish] Keinonen, T. & Takala, R. (eds.)(2006). Product Concept Design - A review of the Conceptual Design of Products in Industry. Springer. Mutanen, U-M., Virkkunen, J. & Keinonen, T. (eds.)(2006). Muotoiluosaamisen kehittäminen teknologiayrityksissä [Development of the Design Competence in Technology Companies]. Teknologiateollisuus Helsinki [in Finnish] Keinonen, T. (ed.)(2008). Design Connections Knowledge, Value and Involvement through Design. Working Papers F34, University of Art and Design Helsinki. Selected other research related publications ( ) Räihä, K-J., Koivunen, K., Rantala, H., Sharmin, S., Keinonen, T., Kukkonen, S. and Lahtinen, S. (2006). Perception of Design Tekes project Final report. Department of Computer Sciences, University of Tampere, D Tampere. Keinonen, T. (2007). Fields and act of art and research in Mäkelä, M. & Routarinne, S. (eds.) Art of research. University of Art and Design Helsinki, Helsinki. Kuutti, K., Keinonen, T., Norros, L. & Ylirisku, S. (2007). Johdanto [Introduction] In Kaasinen, E. & Norros, L. (eds.). Älykkäiden ympäristöjen suunnittelu Kohti ekologista systeemiajattelua [Design of Intelligent Environments Towards Ecological System Approach]. Teknologiateollisuus, Helsinki Kaasinen, E., Keinonen, T., Ylirisku, S. & Plomp, J.(2007). Älykkäiden ympäristöjen piirteitä [Characteristics of Intelligent Environments] In Kaasinen, E. & Norros, L. (eds.). Keinonen, T. & Kaasinen, E. (2007). Älykkään ympäristön suunnittelun työtapoja [Design Approaches for Intelligent Environments] In Kaasinen, E. & Norros, L. (eds.). Selected patents ( ) Keinonen, T; Hemanus, J (2003) EP A2: Mobile Emotional Notification Application Keinonen, T; Wikberg, H; Piippo, P; Valtonen, A (2004) EP A1: Salience- Sensitive Image-Based Presentation Of A Contact Directory Silfverberg, M; Wikberg, H; Keinonen, T (2004) WO A1: Method And User Interface For Entering Text Baur, R; Valtonen, T; Keinonen, T; Koppinen, A; Kirjavainen, A; Roque-Cerna, M;Lehn, K; Pazina, M; Theimer, W; Kespohl, K; Buth, P; Conrady, C; Rastuttis, S; Fuhrmann, T; Asikainen, M (2004) EP A3: Electronic appointment scheduler Haaramo, V; Keinonen, T; Korhonen, P; Wikberg, H; Fraki, J; Backstrom, R; Rauhala, J; Tahkokallio, T (2006) NC18141US: Group communication device and method Silfverberg, M; Wikberg, H; Keinonen, T (2005). US Method and user interface for entering text Silfverberg, M; Wikberg, H; Keinonen, T (2006). NC Predictive text input using a roller Keinonen, T; Wikberg, H; Piippo, P; Valtonen, A (2007): Salience-Sensitive Image- Based Presentation Of A Contact Directory

14 14(25) 2. Korvenmaa, Pekka Name: Pekka Korvenmaa (male) Date of birth: Present position: Professor in Design and Culture, MA and DA Programme in Industrial and Strategic Design, School of Design, University of Art and Design Helsinki (full tenure) Docent (adjunct professor), history of art, University of Helsinki Education and degrees awarded: PhD, history of art, University of Helsinki (eximia cum laude) 1991 Expertise tasks in research Doctoral disserations pre-examined: 7 Doctoral dissertations supervised: 4(U. of Art and Design, design research); under supervision 6 (U. of Art and Design, design research); 1 (U. of Helsinki, Consumer Economics); 1 (Turku University, Cultural History); 1 (Robert Gordon U; Aberdeen, design research); 1 (Universitat de Barcelona, design research) Examiner in acts of defense of doctoral degree: 6 (U. of Helsinki, history of art, architecture, design); 2 (Helsinki University of Technology, architectural history); 1 (U. of Jyväskylä, history of art); 1 U. of Tampere, general history); 1 (Estonian Academy of art, art history); 1( Technische Universität Graz, Designforschung) Research projects led: Designer: Birth, Growth, Development. The professionalization of design In Finland after WWII, Academy of Finland, 4 researchers (U. of Art and Design), ; 1 compl. dissertation Grants awarded (major) J.Paul Getty Trust Collaborative Res. Grant 2004 Memberships in scientific societies, boards: International Committee for Design History and Studies ICDHS; board member

15 15(25) World Design Congress 2005/ERA 05; Executive Committee Member (Finnish representant) Research and Educational Center for Communities (YTK), Helsinki U. of Technology; board member Nordic Institute of Asian Studies NIAS; board member Trust positions, U. of Art and Design Helsinki: University board; member Vice Rector (research) Trust positions, other: Alfred Kordelin Fund; evaluator Nordic Cultural Fund (Copenhagen); evaluator Ranks awarded: Knight of the Royal Order of the Polar Star, First Class (awarded by King of Sweden Carl XVI Gustaf; 2003) The Finnish Order of the White Rose Cross of Merit, First Class (awarded by President of Republic of Finland, 2006) Miscellania: Plenary talks, papers, lecture, committee memberships, advisory board memberships, chairmanships in international conferences Member of the group preparing the Finnish Governmental 1999 Design Policy Program Member of the group preparing the Estonian Design Policy 2002 ground document Organizer and chairman in international conferences in design and architectural research: Joining Forces - International Conference on Design Research (U. of Art and Design, 2005); Connecting - Conference on the Multivocality of Design History and Studies (U. of Art and Design, August 2006) Publications Publication - Publication in the series of the University Authors: Illman, Johanna; Latva-Ranta, Sanna; Harteveld Becker, Melanie; Korvenmaa, Pekka; Koskinen, Ilpo; Huhtamaa, Inkeri; Júdice, Marcelo Ortega; Júdice, Andrea Title: Design Your Action. Social Design in Practise. Editors: Miettinen, Satu Publisher: Taideteollinen korkeakoulu Location of publisher: Helsinki Publishing year: 2007

16 16(25) Authors: Korvenmaa, Pekka Title: Eero Saarinen muodon mestari (Eero Saarinen master of form) Series/Journal: Arkkitehti Publishing year: 2006, Number: 5, Pages: Title: Universal Versus Individual. The architecture of the 1960s. Editors: Korvenmaa, Pekka; Laaksonen, Esa Publisher: Alvar Aalto Academy Location of publisher: Helsinki Publishing year: 2004 Authors: Korvenmaa, Pekka Title: Yksilö ja yleistys. Anonymiteetistä 1960-luvun muotoilussa ja arkkitehtuurissa. Compilation: For love of the city, festschrift to Riitta Nikula. Publisher: Taidehistorian seura Location of publisher: Helsinki Publishing year: 2004, Pages: Authors: Korvenmaa, Pekka Title: Modern Architecture Serving Modern Production Compilation: Alvar Aalto Architect. Vol. 7. Sunila Pekka Korvenmaa (ed.) Publisher: Alvar Aalto Foundation / Alvar Aalto Academy Research areas: Architecture/Spatial design, Design Title: Alvar Aalto Architect. Vol. 7. Sunila Editors: Korvenmaa, Pekka Publisher: Alvar Aalto Foundation / Alvar Aalto Academy Publishing year: 2004 ISBN/ISSN: Other info: International Authors: Korvenmaa, Pekka Title: To be seen or to serve? Finnish design in the 1960s. Compilation: Eero Aarnio and the 60s. Publisher: Kunsthalle Helsinki Publishing year: 2003, Pages: 28-50

17 17(25) 3. Koskinen, Ilpo ACADEMIC WORK EXPERIENCE special researcher, National Consumer Research Center 2003, 2004, 2005 docent (adjunct professor) of consumer economics, University of Helsinki, 2005 professor, University of Art and Design, Dept. of Product and Strategic Design (Industrial Design) vice dean for research, School of Design, UIAH, EXPERT POSTS membership in the managerial group of the new Dept. of Industrial Design, UIAH, (vice member); expert and chairman roles in developing studios and laboratories; main responsibility for developing and systematizing doctoral education at UIAH, School of Design, from 1999-; member: the managerial group of the School of Design, 2007-; vice member: Research Council, University of Art and Design, 2007-; vice chair, School of Design Board, UIAH, 2008-; Board member: National Consumer Research Center. 2008; Member in ethical committee: Helsinki Institute for Information Technology, 2008-; Board member: Service Factor of Aalto University, Member in steering groups of interaction studies in Sovako, national doctoral school in sociology (2006-), Design Connections, the doctoral school for industrial design (2006-), UCIT, User-centered Information Technology, a national school for user-centered information technology (2006-) EDITORIAL TASKS AND CONFERENCE ORGANIZATIONS Editor of Knowledge, Technology & Society by Transaction Publishers, New Jersey, USA. From 2007-, a Springer publication. Book series Coeditor with Thomas Binder (Center for Design Research, Royal Academy of Fine Arts, Copenhagen): Nordic Design Research Series published by IT Press, Helsinki. Member in the editorial board of The Mobile Communication Research Annual, Transaction Books, New Jersey, General editor James E. Katz. Program chair in Nordes, The Second Nordic Design Research Conference, May 27-30, 2007, Stockholm, Sweden. Conference Chair: DPPI 2007: Designing Pleasurable Products and Interfaces, University of Art and Design Helsinki, September Visiting scholar at the Art Center College of Design Pasadena, California October January TEACHING 12 different lecture series from , 8 in English, 4 in Finnish. 1 at BA level, 8 at MA level, 3 at Ph.D. level. Doctoral students (a) finished: Simo Säde 2001, Riina Hyytiä 2004, Katja Battarbee 2004, Esko Kurvinen 2007, Heli Rantavuo 2009 (b) 7 on-going (c) examinations: Giulio Jacucci U of Oulu 2004, Jarmo Sarkkinen U of Jyväskylä 2006, Martin Ludvigsen U of Aarhus 2007, Oscar Tomico TU/Barcelona 2007, Lin Pröitz U of Uslo 2007, Brendon Clarke U of S Denmark 2008, Andres Lucero TU/Eindhoven ; (d) pre-examinations: Jouko Aaltonen UIAH 2006, Virve Peteri U of Tampere 2006, Risto

18 18(25) Sarvas HUT 2006, Sonja Bäckman U of Helsinki 2007, Kaisa Still U of Oulu ACADEMIC EVALUATIONS Associate professorship, Jodi Forlizzi, Carnegie Mellon University, School of Computer Science, Human-Computer Interaction Institute, 2006; professorship in fashion design, University of Lapland, Faculty of Art, Referee in about 20 conferences, journals, etc. GRANTS/RESEARCH PROJECTS (a) Project leader: The Domestication of Design, funded by the Academy of Finland, A CAD Environment for Media and Design. A Grant for developing an integrated CAD environment for media and design departments, granted for the University of Art and Design, (b) Project co-leader: Morphome: Living in Metamorphosis Control and Awareness in a Proactive Home Environment. Funded by the Academy of Finland, co-leadership with Prof. Frans Mäyrä (University of Tampere) and Prof. Jukka Vanhala (Tampere University of Technology), Project co-leader: extreme Design. Funded by National Technological Research Agency, Co-leader with prof. Marko Turpeinen, Helsinki Institute for Information Technology; Project coleader: MenoMaps. Funded by National Technological Research Agency, Project leader prof. Tapani Sarjakoski, Finnish Geodetic Institute; Project co-leader: Novel Agents for Fibre Processing. Funded by the Academy of Finland, project leader prof. Liisa Viikari, University of Helsinki, Dept of Applied Chemistry and Microbiology, SELECTED MONOGRAPHS AND EDITED BOOKS 1. Koskinen, Ilpo Mobile Multimedia in Action. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Publishers. 2. Koskinen, Ilpo, Tuuli Mattelmäki and Esko Kurvinen (eds.) Proceedings of Designing Pleasurable Products and Interfaces DPPI 07. Helsinki: University of Art and Design Helsinki and New York: ACM Library. 3. Koskinen Ilpo, Pertti Alasuutari ja Tuomo Peltonen Kvalitatiiviset menetelmät kauppatieteissä. Tampere: Vastapaino. [Qualitative Methods in Business Studies.] (In Finnish, but also refereed for Sage, London in 2003) 4. Koskinen, Ilpo, Katja Battarbee and Tuuli Mattelmäki Empathic Design. User Experience for Product Design. Helsinki: IT Press. SELECTED SCIENTIFIC ARTICLES (ALL REFEREED) 1. Koskinen, Ilpo Semiotic Neighborhoods. Design Issues 21(2): Koskinen, Ilpo and Esko Kurvinen Mobile Multimedia and Users: The Domestication of Mobile Multimedia. Telektronikk 101 (3-4): Vanhala, Jukka, Frans Mäyrä, Ilpo Koskinen Living in Metamorphosis - Proactive Computing in the Home Environment. <interactions>, Vol. XII (4): July-August 2005, ACM Press, NY, pp Koskinen, Ilpo Two Solitudes: Design as an Approach to Media Studies. Nordicom Review Vol. 27(2), Nov. 2006, pp Koskinen, Ilpo and Petteri Repo WAP and Accountability: Shortcomings of the Mobile Internet as an Interactional Problem. Journal of Usability Studies 2(1): Koskinen, Ilpo Is it Fun to Go to Sydney? WAP and Accountability. Psychnology 5(1): 7-32.

19 19(25) 7. Nugent, Lisa, Sean Donahue, Mia Berberat, Yee Chan, Justin Gier, Ilpo Koskinen and Tuuli Mattelmäki How Do You Say Nature? Opening the Design Space with a Knowledge Environment. Knowledge, Technology & Policy 20:4. 8. Kurvinen, Esko, Katja Battarbee, and Ilpo Koskinen Prototyping Social Interaction. Design Issues 21:2. 9. Frans Mäyrä, Anne Soronen, Jukka Vanhala, Jussi Mikkonen, Mari Zakrzewski, Ilpo Koskinen, Kristo Kuusela Probing a Proactive Home: Challenges in Researching and Designing Everyday Smart Environments. Human Technology. 10. Koskinen, Ilpo, Thomas Binder and Johan Redström Lab, Field, Gallery, and Beyond. Artifact: Journal of Virtual Design. 11. Battarbee, Katja and Ilpo Koskinen Co-Experience: User Experience as Interaction. Co-design, Vol. 1(1): SELECTED BOOK CHAPTERS AND CONFERENCE PAPERS 1. Koskinen, Ilpo 2005a. Seeing with Mobile Images. In Nyíri, Kristof (ed.) A Sense of Place. Vienna: Passagen-Verlag. 2. Koskinen, Ilpo Managing Banality in Mobile Multimedia. In Pertierra, Raul (eds.). The Social Construction and Usage of Communication Technologies: European and Asian Experiences. Manila: The University of Philippines Press. 3. Battarbee, Katja and Ilpo Koskinen Product Experiencing as Social Interaction: Co-Experience. In Hekkert, Paul and Rick Schifferstein (eds.) Product Experience. London: Springer. 4. Koskinen, Ilpo Design and Convergence. In Storsul, Tanja and Dagny Stuedahl (eds.) The Ambivalence of Convergence. Oslo: Nordicom. 5. Koskinen, Ilpo Mobile Multimedia: Uses and Social Consequences. In Katz, James (ed.) Handbook of Mobile Communications. Cambridge. MA: The MIT Press. Pp Fulton Suri, Jane, Katja Battarbee and Ilpo Koskinen Designing in the Dark Empathic Exercises to Inspire Design for our Non-Visual Senses. Include 05, Royal College of Art, London, England, 5 8 April, Koskinen, Ilpo Representing Cities in Aesthetic Discourse: Semiotic Neighborhoods in Helsinki. Proceedings of L Association internationale de sémiotique, 8ème World Congrés, Lyon, July 10, Koskinen, Ilpo How People Use Sound in Mobile Multimedia. Proceedings of DPPI 2005: Designing Pleasurable Products and Interfaces, TU/Eindhoven, Oct , Eindhoven, the Netherlands. 9. Heiskanen, Eva, Ilpo Koskinen, Petteri Repo, and Päivi Timonen Involving Users in Service Design. User Experience vs. User Expectations. European Advances in Consumer Research, Vol Ilpo Koskinen, Kristo Kuusela, Katja Battarbee, Anne Soronen, Frans Mäyrä, Jussi Mikkonen, Mari Zakrzewski The Home in Metamorphosis: A Field Study of Proactive Information Technology at Home. Proceedings of Designing Information Systems, DIS, Penn State University, June MISC CONFERENCE ACTIVITIES 25 unpublished conference presentations 3 plenary presentations: The 17th Nordic Conference on Media Research, 2005, Aalborg. The Global and the Local in Mobile Communications Budapest 2004; Communications in the 21 st Century. Budapest workshop and session organizations.

20 20(25) 4. Priha, Päikki Doctor of Arts. Professor of the School of Design (Fashion and Textile design) at the University of Art and Design, Helsinki BORN , Helsinki STUDIES Degree at the Textile Art Department of the Institute of Industrial Arts 1972, Master of Arts at the University of Industrial Arts 1984, Licentiate of Arts 1990 and Doctor of Arts 1991 WORK HISTORY Private studio from 1972 University of Art and Design, Helsinki: part-time teacher since 1974, deputy lecturer in printed fabric design , assistant ; senior assistant from 1992 (teacher of research); deputy professor of the Department of Textile Art 1994; Professor since ( Guest lecturer in Finland and abroad PUBLICATIONS Numerous articles in different publications since 1976 EXHIBITIONS Private exhibitions: Numerous since 1977: Helsinki 2005; Oslo Group exhibitions: Taken part in numerous exhibitions in Finland and abroad since 1973: Sweden, Norway, Island, Denmark, Hungary, Switzerland, Netherlands, Belgium, Poland, Germany, Japan, Mexico, USA. Latest: Kankaanpää 2003; Brandenburg Berlin 2005; Helsinki 2005; Designmuseum, Helsinki 2006; Tampere TEXTILE ART PIECES OWNED BY: The City Authorities of Helsinki, Pori, and Kouvola; Kanazawa in Japan; the Museum of Applied Arts, Helsinki; The Finnish Designers' Association, Helsinki, the State Authorities of Finland; Morelia Modern Art Museum, Mexico; several private enterprises Latest: Hospital District of Helsinki and Uusimaa, the Institute of Pathology, MeilahtiHospital 2007 ECCLESIASTICAL TEXTILES Specialized in the design of and research in ecclesiastical textiles. Since 1982 designs of ecclesiastical textiles by Priha have been realized in about fourty localities, ao. bishop s cope for Tampere (2004) and Espoo (2004, 2008) dioceses ACADEMIC GOWNS

21 21(25) Design of robes for vice-chancellors, doctoral and other academic ceremonial gowns from 1982 OTHER ACTIVITIES Member of the board of directors of Jenny and Antti Wihuri foundation since ( ) PRIZES Cultural prize of Finnish Church, 2004 MEMBERSHIP OF JOURNAL EDITORIAL BOARDS (Finland) Leikkauksia Member of the editorial board , University of Helsinki, Faculty of Theology, Department of Practical Theology EXTERNAL DOCTORAL PRE-EXAMINER (Finland) University of Helsinki, Institute for Art research, Faculty of Arts 2008 PUBLICATIONS: Books: Since 1979 Articles in Refereed Journals (published in Finland) Kilpailut suomalaisen kirkkotekstiilitaiteen edistäjinä. Uskon tilat ja kuvat. Moderni suomalainen kirkkoarkkitehtuuri ja taide. (Competitions as Promoters of Ecclesiastical Textile Art. - The Rooms and Pictures of Faith. Modern Finnish Ecclesiastical Art and Architecture.) Suomalaisen Teologisen Kirjallisuusseuran julkaisuja 260, 2008 Other Scinetific / Scholarly Articles (published in Finland) Kirkkotekstiilit juhlistavat jumalanpalvelusta (Ecclesiastical Textiles Dignify the Service). - SOLI DEO GLORIA AETERNA. Turun Mikaelinkirkko 100vuotta. Turun ja Kaarinan seurakuntayhtymä 2005 Pyhä Henrik ja kirkkotekstiilit (Saint Henry and Ecclesiastical Textiles). - SATAKUNTA. Kotiseutututkimuksia XXII. Satakunnan Historiallinen Seura 2005 Teologiaa, tekstiilitaidetta ja tarkoituksenmukaisuutta. Kirkkotekstiilien hankinta Helsingin seurakuntayhtymässä (About Theology, Textile Art and Appropriateness. The Aqcuisition of Ecclesiastical Textiles by the Helsinki Parish Union).. Kyyhky ja Karitsa. Pyhä design Helsingin kirkoissa. Helsingin seurakuntayhtymä 2006 Kirkollisten toimitusten uudet tekstiilit (New Textiles for Ecclesiastical Services). Ego Sum Qui Sum. Jouko Martikaisen juhlakirja. Studier i systematisk teologi vid Åbo Akademi Nr

22 22(25) Miksi tekstiilitaidetta pitäisi tutkia? (Why Should We Study Textile Art?) Ryijyistä kyborgeihin. Lapin yliopiston taiteiden tiedekunnan julkaisuja B: Tutkimusraportteja ja selvityksiä. Rovaniemi 2007 Päämääränä muotoaistin kehittäminen. Muotoilukoulutusta ennen ja nyt. (The Aim is to Develop the Sense of Form. The Training of Designers Before and Now.) Suomalainen muotoilu. Espoo: Weilin + Göös 2008.

23 23(25) Appendix 2. Addenda to Section 2 Number and title of the Research Achievement: 1. Making research legitimate in practical discipline 4.Studies on mobile multimedia Year : (1995 -) Over 200 scientific publications 3. Establishing usercentered design into a discipline (1995 -) (2000 -) Type of Achievement: Social innovation. Institutionalizing research into a practical discipline. Establishing design and design researchers as credible partners in research collaboration. Social innovation. Publishing has become an established part of practically oriented design. Social innovation. Research has changed how industrial design is done. Other types of additions have enriched this research. Scientific. Studies on mobile multimedia have become standard references in software design and the social science. Title and publication information for verification: Authors: - Turkka Keinonen, Juhani Salovaara, Markku Rajala, Simo Säde, Ilpo Koskinen, Pekka Korvenmaa, Päikki Priha, Tuuli Mattelmäki, Katja Battarbee, Esko Kurvinen + two cohorts of doctoral students List of publications available from research secretary Johanna Rauhaniemi (at Taik.fi) Key books are: Keinonen, Keinonen, Säde, T. and Takala, Koskinen, Mat- R. (2006). Product telmäki, Battarbee, Concept Design. Kurvinen + a few Springer. London; doctoral students Koskinen et al. (2003) Empathic Design. IT- Press; Ylirisku, S. and Buur, J. (2007). Design with Video. Springer, London; Mattelmäki, Tuuli Design Probes, UIAH. Key monographs: Koskinen, Ilpo et al. Mobile Image, IT Press 2002; Battarbee, Katja, Co-Experience, UIAH 2004;

24 24(25) 5. Nurturing international research communities in design Social innovation. SoD has been active in establishing and maintaining several international research networks in its strategic areas. 1. User-centered design: Nordes (Nordic focus), and DPPI (Holland, USA, France, Italy). These have become key conferences in usercentric design research. 2. Design studies. SoD has organized two conferences, Joining Forces and Connecting (the 4 th ICDHS International Committee of Design History and Studies conference), helping to diversify design studies from its American basis into something known as World Design. Example. Currently, SoD is in key position in establishing an international research community in Kurvinen, E., Prototyping Social, UIAH 2007; Koskinen, I. Mobile Multimedia in Action, Transaction www2.uiah.fi/~ikoski ne/dppi07/index.html. Koskinen, Ilpo, Tuuli Mattelmäki and Esko Kurvinen (eds.) Proceedings of Designing Pleasurable Products and Interfaces DPPI 07. Helsinki: University of Art and Design Helsinki and New York: ACM Library rces/ Connecting does not have Web presence anymore. Web site for Art of Research 2009 will be set up in late March. For 2005 conference, see Mäkelä, M. & Routarinne, S. (2006). Art of Research. University of Art and Design Helsinki. Ilpo Koskinen, Tuuli Mattelmäki