1 Demand-side Issues of the Service Economy Pascal Ughetto To cite this version: Pascal Ughetto. Demand-side Issues of the Service Economy. Review of Political Economy, Taylor & Francis (Routledge): SSH Titles, 2004, 16 (4), pp <halshs > HAL Id: halshs https://halshs.archives-ouvertes.fr/halshs Submitted on 28 Oct 2008 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of scientific research documents, whether they are published or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers. L archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.
2 Demand-side issues of the service economy Paru dans : Review of Political Economy, Vol. 16, No. 4, Oct Pascal Ughetto Institut de recherches économiques et sociales 16, boulevard du Mont-d Est F Noisy-Le-Grand Cedex France Abstract. This paper examines the relevance of the demand-side approach to the development of a service economy. Its starts by addressing some concerns about the possibility of creating a growth regime based on services. Discussion has mainly focused on the increasing share of services in consumer spending; but equally important is the fact that most products goods and services alike integrate a significant service-to-the-client dimension. The paper considers the costs incurred by strategies that aim to create value for the client and that require the existence of a purchasing power likely to validate them.
3 2 1. Introduction Since the 1980s, most interpretations of the economic difficulties encountered by the developed countries have highlighted supply-side problems posed by globalisation. A number of European countries have suffered from persistent unemployment that is widely attributed to obstacles that hinder the adaptability of enterprises in the face of increased international competition. Less attention has been paid to demand-side problems: few economists nowadays defend the necessity of Keynesian remedies. This article explores the issue of demand in the current environment. The aim is not to provide a classical justification for Keynesian policies in Europe today. The arguments in favour of such policies are already well-known (although they have been too rarely put forward). The removal of supply-side constraints on European growth in the 1980s has proved in the 1990s to have been too successful in certain respects: liberalisation policies have had the effect of suppressing demand and thereby excessively curbing growth (Fitoussi, 1993). This conventional analysis favours more flexible monetary policies and, in the longer term, the organisation of concerted budgetary stimulation in Europe. Without contradicting this analysis, the present paper suggests that the relevant demand-side issues today arise out of the structural transformations of our economy, and that the focus of attention should be on the possibility of a shift to a growth regime based on services. This analysis is somewhat unconventional. Indeed, the defenders of demand-side policies rarely establish a connection with the structural transformations of our economies and even less with the shift to a service economy even if some of the Post-Keynesian literature has considered the implications of structural change (see, for example, Pasinetti, 1993). Conversely, those who do acknowledge this shift to a service economy tend either to point out the limits of "tertiary-based growth" or to encourage a clearer understanding of the nature of services and then to identify the obstacles that need to be removed to allow their development. In both these cases, the focus is not on demand-side problems per se. Our approach to the question of demand is intended to complement the research which has highlighted the specific nature of services and its implications for a tertiary growth regime. It actually constitutes an extension of that work. Accordingly, our first step will be to examine the conditions likely to favour a service-based growth regime. However, our second step will be to adopt the analysis that the services sector could lead to reorganising all our economies further still. This being the case, the questions of demand will become the major questions to be dealt with. This analysis is to be considered as a new path to explore, bearing in mind moreover, that it is examined in its French context, both from the viewpoint of the lines of the analyses considered and from the field of applicability.
4 3 1. Towards a Growth Regime Based on Services The idea of a growth regime based on services has been a source of concern for some economists. It is thus necessary to address those worries and to start by reviewing the analyses which demonstrate that services are not, in themselves, insusceptible of increases in the efficiency of their production; rather, services have distinct characteristics that require a different outlook on certain categories of economic analysis (such as productivity). These analyses suggest a number of institutional reforms to promote the development of the service sector The Possibility of Tertiary Growth Not all economists view the development of services as favourable to economic growth. Some argue that, as these activities are not highly productive, "tertiary growth" (Petit, 1986) tends to be slower than when manufacturing prevails, and can be maintained only at the cost of rising class tensions, in particular by the emergence of a low-wage workforce in the service sector. Kaldor (1966) had already developed this argument when he attempted to explain the slow rate of economic growth in the United Kingdom relative to other industrialised countries from 1953 to In the 1980s, the debate over the quality of jobs created by the American "job machine" was a central element in discussions of the tertiary economy (Meisenheimer, 1998). By what seems to be a paradox, this development of services drew attention to the importance of industry (Cohen & Zysman, 1987) inasmuch as that sector would be more than ever obliged to create value for the rest of the economy. This line of argument has been challenged by some "defenders" of the service sector, who contend that the apparent weak productivity gains in services may be due not to any intrinsic insusceptibility of services to productivity growth, but rather to the difficulties of measuring efficiency improvements in the production of services (Gadrey, 1988). Inasmuch as the product of a service rendered lacks the objective visibility of the production of a good, the measurement of a service frequently involves methods that amount to assimilating the service considered as a process to the service considered as a product: the product is identified by the resources used to create it. It is therefore not surprising that the productivity calculated is nil. In the question of productivity, one characteristic that prevails in the provision of services arises from the overlap between the latter and quality. The transaction conditions governing services differ in a significant way from transactions involving manufactured goods. A transaction relating to a service does not result in a transfer of property rights: the aim of the transaction is not to acquire a tangible object which has been manufactured and displayed on the market before changing hands. The purpose of the transaction is a promise, an undertaking to achieve a result which the contracting parties have more or less precisely defined but which, in the extreme case, may never become a reality (1). The quality of the product is not immediately apparent and the product may not be delivered in completed form. The outcome depends on the process required for the provision of the service. Productivity and quality are closely related issues in that the quest for greater productivity may have an
5 4 adverse effect on the quality of the product, if cost-saving measures prevent the service provider from giving the product all its defining attributes. One of the particular characteristics of services is that the quality of the product depends not only on the provider but on the degree of co-operation (or level of involvement and competence) forthcoming from the purchaser. The quality of the product will result not only from the skills of the service provider but also from the quality of what is termed the service relationship (Gadrey, 1988) between the provider and the beneficiary. A service constitutes a very specific activity with its own production conditions and constraints which are not always properly captured by statistical methods which were designed primarily to measure the output of tangible objects. The question of quality, which is difficult to dissociate from the efficiency of the service rendered, is very inadequately addressed. Purely quantitative indicators, when they are conceivable (such as recording the number of transactions in banks) supply no information on the differences in the quality of the service rendered (for example, the presence or the absence of a financial advisor). This point is made by some economists in order to explain that expansion of the service sector per se need not impede economic growth: as shall be stressed in section 2.3., the problem may rather be that wealth of nations is more and more a matter of quality and of the service rendered by commodities, and not of the mere volume of the latter. Though the productivity and output of services are still poorly measured we cannot conclude that services are incompatible with growth (2). Moreover these economists also argue that the same specificities may also impede service activities in their development. This could prevent them from expanding even more and, as a consequence, from exerting bandwagon effects on the whole productive-system growth The Need to Structure Certain Service Markets One fundamental issue is that uncertainty as to product and productivity that is the relation of quality to price may hinder the development of markets for certain services. This uncertainty is due to the fact that the product does not exist when a contract is signed, in such a way that failures comparable to those set out in the economics of information (Akerlof, 1970; Stiglitz, 1987) can occur in the functioning of the markets. The lack of transparency of the market can prevent potential buyers from expressing their demand. Furthermore, since this uncertainty makes comparisons between offers difficult, there is limited scope for competition and price cuts. From this point of view, the uncertainty factor means that services cannot, at this stage, exert all the positive effects on economic growth that could be expected of them. These effects stem from the fact that services fulfil needs that are expected to increase. These needs arise firstly from the complexity of contemporary societies and economies: from the diversity and increasing technical complexity of the products among which consumers may choose; and from complex production systems and corporate environment (highly developed and sophisticated legal systems, constant innovation, economic globalisation), resulting in needs for related services such as assistance, counsel, maintenance, repair work. A second reason
6 5 for this explosion is the unpredictability and risk factors in everyday life, both for companies and for individuals, resulting in a need for services geared to risk-prevention, risk-reduction and insurance. Such needs triggered a rise in demand for services, arise that started during the Fordist growth period following the Second World War. A second wave of increased demand for services began in the early 1980s. It paved the way for a significant development of supply which counterbalanced, to some extent, job losses in industry. Nevertheless, the persistent high level of unemployment in most European countries reflects insufficient job creations. Some economists, reasoning that industry no longer drives employment, advocate a thorough review of the obstacles which limit the development of service markets; the focus has been on supply-side obstacles relating to particular characteristics of services, notably the uncertainty factors (du Tertre, 1999). This approach has much in common with New Keynesian Economics. Some policy recommendations point to the need for safety devices to regulate the terms of service contracts (for example, collective measures providing for quality certification). Others deal with the provision, either directly or through financial assistance, of services such as child care and elder care, the need for which has grown significantly in the past several decades An Intangible Growth Regime? The point of view just described is based on the idea that economic growth and job creation could be stimulated by the development of services. The main impediments to growth along this line are problems of organisation of the service markets. But once these obstacles have been overcome, we might witness the emergence of a new growth regime, which would fully benefit from the opportunities provided by the needs for services (du Tertre, 1995); this new growth regime would replace the Fordist regime that prevailed in the 1950s and 1960s (Boyer, 1994). The latter regime was characterised by production methods that generated high productivity gains, the benefits of which were in turn allocated in a broadly equitable manner among employers and employees through collective bargaining. A virtuous circle of economic growth emerged in which the production methods allowed firms to produce goods on a large scale in response to a demand resulting from high wages. Under the Regulation Theory associated with Boyer and du Tertre, among others, the current crisis is a structural crisis expressing the limits of this Fordist growth regime. When a growth regime is in crisis, not only do the main institutions undergo a reorganisation, but shifts occur in certain sectors of activity. In the current crisis, the automobile industry, which was one of the main focuses of economic growth and a key player in the Fordist compromise, is in relative decline. The services sector could take the place of such sectors; in other words, it could constitute the core of a new consumer standard. However, the expansion of services is subject to particular constraints that need to be explained. Services may be classified either as time saving (the provider carries out a task that the beneficiary could have carried out himself) or as time consuming (for example, training
7 6 courses) (Gadrey, 1992). The latter category includes services in which the relationship between provider and purchaser is particularly important; in a sense such services are coproduced since the beneficiary is obliged to find time to take part in the production of the service. There are two theoretical models of the links among services: social organisation of time and economic growth (Ughetto, 1998). On the one hand, the services sector may develop if one part of the population, pressed for time due to hyper-activity, has recourse to timesaving services offered by the other part of the population. This model implies a considerable degree of income inequality between the two portions of the population since the first group will find it worthwhile to consume time-saving services only if they cost less than what these persons can earn by devoting time to the generation of income. This model partly corresponds to the American job machine described in the 1980s. The other model requires the development of time-consuming services. It supposes that the beneficiaries can find time to take part in the production of the service. It therefore requires an extensive reorganisation of social time and working hours to provide time for activities such as meetings with financial advisors in banks, training courses for employees, interaction between the providers and the representatives of the company benefiting from the service, etc. More than the first model, the second model raises the question of the obstacles to the reorganisation of markets. In view of the involvement of the beneficiary in the co-production of the service, ex ante uncertainty as to the product is more likely to constitute a major characteristic of the services on which economic growth would be based. In this case, the analysis points to the need for an institutional reorganisation of markets, whereas the first model would focus on the difference between the income levels. In view of the focus of the present paper, it is interesting to note that, if this second model is to deal with demand issues, it will be through market-organisation issues. This brings us back to the question of making demand solvent through shared financing mechanisms and through drops in relative prices in more transparent markets. However, as demand is limited by the time necessary to co-produce the service, any growth in demand would require that periods of time be made available prior to using certain services. This requirement raises the question of reducing and reorganising working hours within the framework of renewed collective bargaining agreements and a new wage compromise with a view to encouraging economic growth (du Tertre, 1995). Such reforms would no doubt require active governmental intervention. By contrast, in the model based on time-saving services, no intervention seems necessary as the demand for these services depends mainly on the difference in income levels and a laissez faire policy can generally be counted upon to preserve or exacerbate income inequalities. In sum, current analysis of service-oriented economics suggests that the full development of a growth regime based on services would be limited by obstacles preventing services from structuring the consumption standard. Services therefore would not yet be able to play the full role that was played by standardized goods in the Fordist regime; such
8 7 standardized goods were at the centre of the articulation of the production standard and the consumption standard, and, as such, sustained growth. However, the literature has mainly focused on the organisation of markets, leaving open the question of the level of global demand in the economy. Here we shall argue that this question can only be solved by defining the characteristics of the consumer standard that could provide the basis for a new growth regime. From this point of view, what matters is not just that services account for a larger share of consumer spending, but more precisely that most products goods or services alike integrate a significant service-to-the-client dimension. From this point of view, expansion of the service dimension within consumption and production standards may still remain at a stage at which a logic of standardized production is simply amended by quality strategies providing limited tailored aspects. This would not be sufficient notably in Europe to produce durable effects of self-sustaining economic growth. 2. Service to Client as a New Consumer Standard 2.1 From Services to the Service Model Services are not just sectors occupying a central position in a new potential growth regime; they also imply that a productive model extends to most sectors of the economy. More and more producers view their business as rendering a service, even in industry. This means that the products tend to become tailor-made solutions for the client given their conditions of use. This tendency is of course expressed in different forms in different sectors and can be more limited in manufacturing. However in all industries can there be a shift towards an increased service to client dimension, due to the producer's growing awareness that the consumer is not just buying a good but more precisely its condition of use. From this point of view, theory was ahead of reality when Lancaster (1966, 1975) suggested a new approach to the neoclassical theory of consumer choice by arguing that the level of demand for a good is based on all of its characteristics, and when Gershuny (1983) suggested that consumers, concerned primarily with a need or function to be fulfilled, choose between self-service and external provision of services. Supply strategies no longer limit themselves to the production of a type of good but now take into consideration the needs and the uses expressed by the consumer for that good. The role of the service provider is then to provide a global solution to the problems relating to the conditions of the use of the good rather than of merely providing the good and letting the customer solve the problems. For example, computer manufacturers no longer simply manufacture computer hardware but try to offer a package of services: they start by assessing the client's specific needs; then they propose reorganisational solutions; finally, they evaluate the material needs of the client. The field of industrial cleaning provides another example. Certain service providers do not simply "clean up" after their client: they consult the client about how to limit the volume of dirt, thereby improving the quality of their service. This is a sector, which, by developing new strategies, has increased the service aspect of its activity: it takes into
9 8 consideration the use of the product and the situation of the client. However, in such cases the "service model" (Veltz, 1996) implies the existence of a significant relational dimension. The service is not rendered in an abstract context, which disregards the relationship between the service provider and a client who has specific problems and conditions of use. This service model could structure the production and consumption standards in most sectors of the economy and, as such, be the basis of a growth regime. However, the model has significant demand-side consequences in view of the resources that it requires for the production process and which have to be paid for by the client Neither Extensive nor Intensive Growth As stated, the emergence of the service dimension implies taking client needs and concerns into consideration. As a result, creating value requires that producers adopt the client s point of view. This is what current management theories refer to when they define value in terms of the attributes or the functions of the product for which the consumer is prepared to pay the price necessary to obtain the product (Porter, 1985). The price, when paid, validates the costs incurred to use the product. These theories actually rediscover the Marxist concept of value realisation (Marx, 1867, Vol. II, Chap. I); that is, the fact that a sale implies the validation (and the risk of non-validation) of the costs incurred to create a certain value. In the new supply strategies the products use value becomes significant. In the case where production is standardised (or simply differentiated) and aims at certain categories of consumers considered as a whole and not as individuals, the prevailing logic is to rationalise production, that is, to manufacture a good without taking into account the individual characteristics of the consumer and then to launch it on the market. The aim is to increase the chances of selling it in a given market segment by reducing production costs in order to cut the price of the good (3). Conversely, in the case of products implying a significant relational dimension, the cost-cutting aspect, while not disappearing, will only become relevant once the question of creation of value for the client has been solved. The chances of selling the product are first increased by creating a value, which, by arousing the clients interest, is likely to be realised. Indeed, the priority is to capture a demand that tends to play one producer against another. When consumers endeavour to obtain high quality products and at low prices, offering services to a client means offering more and more product attributes while forging a more personal relationship with the client. Such a relationship tends to restore the balance between the producer and the client to the advantage of the producer. Indeed, by offering his services to the client (thereby appearing to be the subordinate party in the relationship), the producer in fact "captures" the client who becomes the dependent party (4). This aspect of competition, described by Chamberlin (1933), is consistent with the adoption of strategies that tend first to create useful effects for the client and relegate cost-cutting measures to a position of secondary importance.
10 9 Consequently, the increase in the service component of the products offered requires not only an increase in the cost of production, but also additional investment expenditures, without which the new value-enhancing attributes to the product cannot be created: value creation requires investment. An international comparison of large-scale retail distribution systems will illustrate the point (Gadrey et al., 2001). Statistics appeal to indicate that retail trade in the United States and Japan is less productive than in France. This is a puzzle, since French retailers have access to the same technology and practices as American and Japanese retailers. The puzzle is solved by considering that the quality of the services rendered varies significantly from one country to another. The products are not the same: in the United States and Japan the services rendered include sales advice, a wide variety of goods, fresh food counters, free product samples, long opening hours. In France, retailors favour strategies based on price competition and therefore seeks to avoid costs. But American and Japanese retailers do not hesitate to incur costs (notably in terms of personnel) in order to provide a high level of service and increase the value of the product to the client. This has a negative effect on the productivity statistics (inasmuch as they are unsuited to measure the differences in product quality) but not on profitability which is higher in the US and Japan than in France. From a historical point of view, a growth regime based on the generalisation of the service model would be rather original. Contrary to what the productivity statistics lead us to believe, we can conclude that it is difficult to qualify the corresponding accumulation as extensive that is to say growth would arise from using an increasing volume of the labour force. Such productions use higher volumes of labour force not because they are not efficient (or unlikely to be rationalized) per se and as a consequence not because they would necessarily correspond to an extensive growth. Rather it is because they use more employees (than in a strict intensive growth) to improve the quality of the service rendered, these employees being at the origin of an outcome that is for some part intangible as regards output and productivity statistics Price, Income Distribution and Demand Now that we have examined the costs issues at the heart of potential new supply strategies, we can address the issue of a new growth regime from the point of view of Keynesian or Kaleckian macroeconomics. For Keynes and Kalecki, aggregate output, the price level and growth are determined primarily by the level of spending of entrepreneurs or capitalists. Within the economic circular flow, the decision made by different categories of agents to spend is triggered by the decision of entrepreneurs to invest (spend in investment goods), thereby exerting considerable influence on the level of effective demand. We propose to examine the spending behaviour of producers in the context of new supply strategies corresponding to new production methods and a new consumer standard. From this point of view, the typically Keynesian issue of how spending supports aggregate economic activity should be addressed in connection with structural changes in production and consumer standards due to the emergence of a service model throughout the economy.
11 10 Service-intensive production processes are indeed production processes with high value-added, incurring costs, which means that they will be highly priced productions. In order to create value for the client these processes incur costs exceeding those incurred for standard products. These costs increase the exchange value of the product as well as its use value. The question arises as to who will meet these costs. There seem to be three possibilities. The first is that the company will bear this cost by accepting relatively low margins. If we discard this possibility (5), the costs will have to be borne by the firm clients and employees. If the clients are unwilling to pay a high price to validate the costs incurred in the creation of value the costs are borne by the employees. Inasmuch as the additional service rendered to the client is the result of additional working hours the firm will have a strong incentive to control labour costs. Gadrey, Jany-Catrice and Ribault (2001) show that this method is partly used in Japan and the United States to manage the costs of value-added products in retail trade. Although Japanese distributors bear staff costs 35 to 40% higher than in France for a comparable range of products, the hourly wage and the social security contributions are lower, which means that for the same amount of staff costs more working hours can be hired. Hence, the balance of power among firms, clients and employees determines the allocation of the costs of producing high-value products. If the market situation is such that producers are obliged to differentiate themselves from their competitors and the requirements of consumers are such that the producers cannot hope to base their strategies on the price issue alone, then it is likely that the effects of client pressure will be transferred to those firms whose activities add to costs. In a context where the purchasing power is limited, so that consumers are not able to pay the full cost of the service offered, the supply strategies for service-intensive products can be justified only if the producers can control the price by reducing the related costs. The costs needed to pay the employees notably to provide an additional service would have to be reduced. While these cost-controlling strategies may be individually justified, in the aggregate such behaviour can have negative repercussions on the level of effective demand. The decline in consumption demand would discourage business investment. Without any outside intervention the market cannot be expected to end the crisis all the more so at a time of structural change (Driver, 1996). State intervention is required. In Europe, a common initiative to adopt a demand policy (Drèze & Malinvaud, 1993) would help entrepreneurs to reverse the trend of negative expectations which hinders the development of service-intensive production and consumer standards. However such standards require that purchasing power be fuelled by sources more powerful and permanent than public spending, which raises the question of wages. What is required is something analogous to the Fordist wage compromise not the re-establishment of this compromise per se, but the recognition of the legitimacy of workers claims on a portion of the gains from productivity growth, within the context of new supply strategies. This is an even trickier question than that of concerted Keynesian action taken at the level of the European Union. The European governments and central banks share the same analysis of the crisis centred on the issue of firms competitiveness, in which there is an implicit consensus that having corporate policies of high wages is unncessary either to buttress demand or to control
12 11 inflation. Demand-side issues of the service economy state new justifications for the macroeconomic effects of such policies. Conclusion Although largely neglected, demand-side issues are particularly relevant today in view of the structural changes that have taken place in the global economy in particular the emergence of a significant service dimension in consumer and production standards. The proliferation of service-intensive products may have macroeconomic repercussions, partly because of the investment expenditure required to provide high-cost services leading to self-sustained growth (either directly or as auxiliaries to other products or services). Keynesian policies and a new wage compromise may be required to sustain the demand for such services. Such issues should be investigated in more detail than they are presently: this requires from Keynesian economists to deepen their concern for structural change and from service economics not to focus too exclusively on market-organisation issues.
13 12 Footnotes (1) In the field of services, the intangible nature of the product is not due to the fact that once the service has been rendered there is no objective result (this is not usually the case) but to the fact that the finished product cannot be displayed at the time of the signing of the contract. The intangibility is ex ante and not ex post. (2) Baumol (1967) s argument that it will always take four musicians to play a string quartet is too restrictive to infer any more general conclusion about services. It refers to a peculiar type of product, namely art, which is definitively non reducible to a commodity. Services per se are not incompatible with some sort of rationalization: for instance, in medicine, professionals draw from experience knowledge and methods making them more efficient without damaging the quality of their acts. (3) This does not exclude the possibility of seeking profits through monopolistic positions or product differentiation, which would justify higher prices. However, in the current competition conditions, the cost-cutting measures prevail. (4) Consider the relationship between a patient and his physician: the more the relationship becomes personal (acquaintance, trust) the more difficult and costly it is for the patient to go to a new physician. (5) Let us suppose that efforts to promote service strategies tend to be provided by producers preferably in order to gain high margins.
14 13 References Akerlof, G., (1970) The market for lemons : quality uncertainty and the market mechanisms, Quarterly Journal of Economics, vol. LXXXIV, no. 3 Baumol, W. (1967) Macroeconomics of unbalanced growth: the anatomy of the urban crisis, American Economic Review, vol. LVII, no. 3. Boyer, R. (1994) Régulation, in Eatwell, J., Murray, M., Newman, P., 1987, The New Palgrave. A Dictionary of Economics, vol. 4, reprint Chamberlin, E.H. (1933) The Theory of Monopolistic Competition. A Re-orientation in the Theory of Value, 8 th ed. (Cambridge (Mass.), Harvard University Press). Cohen, S., Zysman, J. (1987) Manufacturing Matters. The Myth of the Post-Industrial Economy (New York, Basic Books). Drèze, J., Malinvaud, E. (1994) Growth and employment: The scope for a European initiative, European Economic Review, vol. 38, no. 3-4 Driver, C. (1996) Stagnation as a problem of transition: arguments and proposals, Cambridge Journal of Economics, vol. 20, no. 5 Fitoussi, J.P. (1993) Competitive Disinflation : the Mark and Budgetary Politics in Europe (Oxford, Oxford UP). Gadrey, J. (1988) Rethinking Output in Services, Service Industries Journal, vol. 8, no. 1 Gadrey, J. (1992) L économie des services (Paris, La Découverte), 2 nd ed., 1996 Gadrey, J., Jany-Catrice, F., Ribault, T. (2000) Levels and Systems of Employment in the Japanese Retail Trade: A comparison with France, Cambridge Journal of Economics, vol. 25, no. 2. Gershuny, J. (1983) Social Innovation and the Division of Labour Oxford UP, Oxford Kaldor, N. ( ) Alternative Theories of Distribution, Review of Economic Studies, vol. XXIII, no. 60 Kaldor, N. (1966) Causes of the Slow Rate of Economic Growth in the United Kingdom, reproduced in Targetti, F., Thirlwall, A.P., (ed.), The Essential Kaldor (London, Duckworth), Lancaster, K. (1966) A new approach to consumer theory, Journal of Political Economy, vol. LXXIV, no. 2 Lancaster, K. (1975) Socially Optimal Product Differenciation, American Economic Review, vol. LXV, no. 4 Marx K. (1867) Capital (Harmondsworth, Penguin), 1978.
15 14 Meisenheimer, J. (1998) The services industry in the good versus bad jobs debate, Monthly Labor Review, Febr. Pasinetti, L.L. (1993) Structural Economic Dynamics. A Theory of the Economic Consequences of Human Learning (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press). Petit, P. (1986) Slow Growth and the Service Economy (London, Frances Pinter). Porter, M. (1985) Competitive advantage, Free Press, New York, London Stiglitz, J. (1987) The Causes and Consequences of the Dependence of Quality on Price, Journal of Economic Literature, vol. XXV, no. 12 Tertre (du) C. (1995) Le changement du travail et de l emploi : le rôle majeur des relations de service, Les cahiers de Syndex, no. 4 Tertre (du) C. (1999) Intangible and Interpersonal Services : Towards New Political Economy Tools. The French Case, Service Industries Journal, vol. 19, no. 1 Ughetto, P. (1998) A la recherche d un nouveau modèle d emploi. Dynamique des changements structurels et institutionnels affectant le travail et l emploi, Doctorate thesis, university Paris-IX, Jan. Veltz, P. (1996) Mondialisation, villes et territoires. L économie d archipel (Paris, PUF).
Virginia Woolf, Comment devrait-on lire un livre? ou le théoricien du commun François-Ronan Dubois To cite this version: François-Ronan Dubois. Virginia Woolf, Comment devrait-on lire un livre? ou le théoricien
Mobility management and vertical handover decision making in heterogeneous wireless networks Mariem Zekri To cite this version: Mariem Zekri. Mobility management and vertical handover decision making in
La mort du narrateur et l interprétation du roman. L exemple de Pedro Páramo de Juan Rulfo Sylvie Patron To cite this version: Sylvie Patron. La mort du narrateur et l interprétation du roman. L exemple
Analyse échographique de la cicatrisation tendineuse après réparation arthroscopique de la coiffe des rotateurs Martin Schramm To cite this version: Martin Schramm. Analyse échographique de la cicatrisation
ibalance-abf: a Smartphone-Based Audio-Biofeedback Balance System Céline Franco, Anthony Fleury, Pierre-Yves Guméry, Bruno Diot, Jacques Demongeot, Nicolas Vuillerme To cite this version: Céline Franco,
A usage coverage based approach for assessing product family design Jiliang Wang To cite this version: Jiliang Wang. A usage coverage based approach for assessing product family design. Other. Ecole Centrale
1 Supplemental Unit 5: Fiscal Policy and Budget Deficits Fiscal and monetary policies are the two major tools available to policy makers to alter total demand, output, and employment. This feature will
Territorial Intelligence and Innovation for the Socio-Ecological Transition Jean-Jacques Girardot, Evelyne Brunau To cite this version: Jean-Jacques Girardot, Evelyne Brunau. Territorial Intelligence and
A graph based framework for the definition of tools dealing with sparse and irregular distributed data-structures Serge Chaumette, Jean-Michel Lepine, Franck Rubi To cite this version: Serge Chaumette,
Faut-il des cyberarchivistes, et quel doit être leur profil professionnel? Jean-Daniel Zeller To cite this version: Jean-Daniel Zeller. Faut-il des cyberarchivistes, et quel doit être leur profil professionnel?.
Expanding Renewable Energy by Implementing Demand Response Stéphanie Bouckaert, Vincent Mazauric, Nadia Maïzi To cite this version: Stéphanie Bouckaert, Vincent Mazauric, Nadia Maïzi. Expanding Renewable
Discussion on the paper Hypotheses testing by convex optimization by A. Goldenschluger, A. Juditsky and A. Nemirovski. Fabienne Comte, Celine Duval, Valentine Genon-Catalot To cite this version: Fabienne
FP-Hadoop: Efficient Execution of Parallel Jobs Over Skewed Data Miguel Liroz-Gistau, Reza Akbarinia, Patrick Valduriez To cite this version: Miguel Liroz-Gistau, Reza Akbarinia, Patrick Valduriez. FP-Hadoop:
Knowledge based tool for modeling dynamic systems in education Krassen Stefanov, Galina Dimitrova To cite this version: Krassen Stefanov, Galina Dimitrova. Knowledge based tool for modeling dynamic systems
Information Technology Education in the Sri Lankan School System: Challenges and Perspectives Chandima H. De Silva To cite this version: Chandima H. De Silva. Information Technology Education in the Sri
Les identités féminines dans le conte traditionnel occidental et ses réécritures : une perception actualisée des élèves Sarah Brasseur To cite this version: Sarah Brasseur. Les identités féminines dans
Additional mechanisms for rewriting on-the-fly SPARQL queries proxy Arthur Vaisse-Lesteven, Bruno Grilhères To cite this version: Arthur Vaisse-Lesteven, Bruno Grilhères. Additional mechanisms for rewriting
1 Module C: Fiscal Policy and Budget Deficits Note: This feature provides supplementary analysis for the material in Part 3 of Common Sense Economics. Fiscal and monetary policies are the two major tools
ANIMATED PHASE PORTRAITS OF NONLINEAR AND CHAOTIC DYNAMICAL SYSTEMS Jean-Marc Ginoux To cite this version: Jean-Marc Ginoux. ANIMATED PHASE PORTRAITS OF NONLINEAR AND CHAOTIC DYNAMICAL SYSTEMS. A.H. Siddiqi,
Auto-Scaling, Load Balancing and Monitoring in Commercial and Open-Source Clouds Eddy Caron, Luis Rodero-Merino, Frédéric Desprez, Adrian Muresan To cite this version: Eddy Caron, Luis Rodero-Merino, Frédéric
1 CHAPTER 11. AN OVEVIEW OF THE BANK OF ENGLAND QUARTERLY MODEL OF THE (BEQM) This model is the main tool in the suite of models employed by the staff and the Monetary Policy Committee (MPC) in the construction
ANALYSIS OF SNOEK-KOSTER (H) RELAXATION IN IRON J. San Juan, G. Fantozzi, M. No, C. Esnouf, F. Vanoni To cite this version: J. San Juan, G. Fantozzi, M. No, C. Esnouf, F. Vanoni. ANALYSIS OF SNOEK-KOSTER
Interlibrary loan and document supply in France the Montpellier meeting Joachim Schöpfel To cite this version: Joachim Schöpfel. Interlibrary loan and document supply in France the Montpellier meeting.
Minkowski Sum of Polytopes Defined by Their Vertices Vincent Delos, Denis Teissandier To cite this version: Vincent Delos, Denis Teissandier. Minkowski Sum of Polytopes Defined by Their Vertices. Journal
Use of tabletop exercise in industrial training disaster. Alexis Descatha, Thomas Loeb, François Dolveck, Nathalie-Sybille Goddet, Valerie Poirier, Michel Baer To cite this version: Alexis Descatha, Thomas
Remarks by Gordon Thiessen Governor of the Bank of Canada to the Chambre de commerce du Montréal métropolitain Montreal, Quebec 4 December 2000 Why a Floating Exchange Rate Regime Makes Sense for Canada
)LQDQFLDO$VVXUDQFH,VVXHV RI(QYLURQPHQWDO/LDELOLW\ ([HFXWLYH6XPPDU\ %\ 3URI'U0LFKDHO*)DXUH//0 DQG 0U'DYLG*ULPHDXG Maastricht University and European Centre for Tort and Insurance Law (ECTIL) Final version
Study on Cloud Service Mode of Agricultural Information Institutions Xiaorong Yang, Nengfu Xie, Dan Wang, Lihua Jiang To cite this version: Xiaorong Yang, Nengfu Xie, Dan Wang, Lihua Jiang. Study on Cloud
Potential GDP and Economic Growth CHAPTER17 C H A P T E R C H E C K L I S T When you have completed your study of this chapter, you will be able to 1 Explain the forces that determine potential GDP and
From Microsoft Word 2003 to Microsoft Word 2007: Design Heuristics, Design Flaws and Lessons Learnt Yin-Leng Theng, Eng Kiat Ting, Xuehong Tao To cite this version: Yin-Leng Theng, Eng Kiat Ting, Xuehong
QASM: a Q&A Social Media System Based on Social Semantics Zide Meng, Fabien Gandon, Catherine Faron-Zucker To cite this version: Zide Meng, Fabien Gandon, Catherine Faron-Zucker. QASM: a Q&A Social Media
Online vehicle routing and scheduling with continuous vehicle tracking Jean Respen, Nicolas Zufferey, Jean-Yves Potvin To cite this version: Jean Respen, Nicolas Zufferey, Jean-Yves Potvin. Online vehicle
The Development of Self-Employment in Russia Theodore February 2001 PONARS Policy Memo 186 University of Arizona Despite the important economic, social, and political roles the self-employed can potentially
Advantages and disadvantages of e-learning at the technical university Olga Sheypak, Galina Artyushina, Anna Artyushina To cite this version: Olga Sheypak, Galina Artyushina, Anna Artyushina. Advantages
HW 2 Macroeconomics 102 Due on 06/12 1.What are the three important macroeconomic goals about which most economists, and society at large, agree? a. economic growth, full employment, and low interest rates
7 The labour market, I: real wages, productivity and unemployment 7.1 INTRODUCTION Since the 1970s one of the major issues in macroeconomics has been the extent to which low output and high unemployment
Preparation of the Informal Ministerial Meeting of Ministers responsible for Cohesion Policy, Milan 10 October 2014 Cohesion Policy and economic governance: complementing each other Background paper September
Employment and Unemployment A2 Economics, Autumn 2010 Measuring Unemployment A Working Definition of Unemployment People able, available and willing to find work and actively seeking work but not employed
Physicians balance billing, supplemental insurance and access to health care Izabela Jelovac To cite this version: Izabela Jelovac. Physicians balance billing, supplemental insurance and access to health
What Development for Bioenergy in Asia: A Long-term Analysis of the Effects of Policy Instruments using TIAM-FR model Seungwoo Kang, Sandrine Selosse, Nadia Maïzi To cite this version: Seungwoo Kang, Sandrine
Overview of model-building strategies in population PK/PD analyses: 2002-2004 literature survey. Céline Dartois, Karl Brendel, Emmanuelle Comets, Céline Laffont, Christian Laveille, Brigitte Tranchand,
HAS FINANCE BECOME TOO EXPENSIVE? AN ESTIMATION OF THE UNIT COST OF FINANCIAL INTERMEDIATION IN EUROPE 1951-2007 IPP Policy Briefs n 10 June 2014 Guillaume Bazot www.ipp.eu Summary Finance played an increasing
June 23, 2016 Bank of Japan Recent Developments in Economic Activity, Prices, and Monetary Policy Speech at a Meeting with Business Leaders in Ishikawa Takahide Kiuchi Member of the Policy Board (English
MACROECONOMIC AND INDUSTRY ANALYSIS VALUATION PROCESS BUSINESS ANALYSIS INTRODUCTION To determine a proper price for a firm s stock, security analyst must forecast the dividend & earnings that can be expected
Working Paper No. 549 Excess Capital and Liquidity Management by Jan Toporowski Economics Department, School of Oriental and African Studies, University of London and the Research Centre for the History
Economic Systems The way a country s resources are owned and the way that country takes decisions as to what to produce, how much to produce and how to distribute what has been produced determine the type
An update on acoustics designs for HVAC (Engineering) Ken MARRIOTT To cite this version: Ken MARRIOTT. An update on acoustics designs for HVAC (Engineering). Société Française d Acoustique. Acoustics 2012,
Paris, June 2013 FBF position paper on the European Commission's proposal for a Directive on bank accounts The French Banking Federation (FBF) is the professional body that represents all banks operating
Strategies and Methods for Supplier Selections - Strategic Sourcing of Software at Ericsson Mobile Platforms Caroline Raning & Johanna Vallhagen February 2007 Department of Industrial Management and Logistics,
In Defense of Destabilizing Speculation * by Milton Friedman In Essays in Economics and Econometrics, edited by Ralph W. Pfouts, pp. 133-141. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 1960. University
EUROPEAN COMMISSION Brussels, XXX [ ](2013) XXX draft COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION of XXX on relevant product and service markets within the electronic communications sector susceptible to ex ante regulation
EUROPEAN COMMISSION Brussels, 9.10.2014 C(2014) 7174 final COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION of 9.10.2014 on relevant product and service markets within the electronic communications sector susceptible to ex ante
Project LINK Meeting New York, - October 1 Country Report: Australia Prepared by Peter Brain: National Institute of Economic and Industry Research, and Duncan Ironmonger: Department of Economics, University
Chapter 11 Keynesianism: The Macroeconomics of Wage and Price Rigidity Chapter Outline Real-Wage Rigidity Price Stickiness Monetary and Fiscal Policy in the Keynesian Model The Keynesian Theory of Business
Unemployment AS Economics Presentation 2005 Key Issues The meaning of unemployment Different types of unemployment Consequences of unemployment Unemployment and economic growth Recent trends in UK unemployment
Discussion Paper No. 730 THE KEYNESIAN MULTIPLIER EFFECT RECONSIDERED Yoshiyasu Ono January 2009 The Institute of Social and Economic Research Osaka University 6-1 Mihogaoka, Ibaraki, Osaka 567-0047, Japan
Agenda Advancing economics in business Assessing energy supply profitability: does a margins approach make sense? How profitable should a competitive energy supply business be? Companies need to know this
VR4D: An Immersive and Collaborative Experience to Improve the Interior Design Process Amine Chellali, Frederic Jourdan, Cédric Dumas To cite this version: Amine Chellali, Frederic Jourdan, Cédric Dumas.
FROM TERRIBLE TO TERRIFIC UNDERGRADUATE ECONOMICS CURRICULA: An evidence- based assessment of an intellectual disaster, and a proposal for an alternative approach to economics teaching 1 PEPS- Économie
Managing Risks at Runtime in VoIP Networks and Services Oussema Dabbebi, Remi Badonnel, Olivier Festor To cite this version: Oussema Dabbebi, Remi Badonnel, Olivier Festor. Managing Risks at Runtime in
CHAPTER 7 EQUILIBRIUM NATIONAL INCOME Chapter in a Nutshell Two very different groups of people are always at work making decisions concerning spending, saving, and investment that affect each other. The
MEALEY S TM International Asbestos Liability Asbestos In France: One Step Forward, Two Steps Back by Sylvie Gallage-Alwis and Delphine Lapillonne Hogan Lovells A commentary article reprinted from the June
Macroeconomic Issues Macroeconomic Issues Monetary Neutrality, Home Mortgages, and the Phillips Curve Alan Day Haight State University of New York, Cortland Standard mortgage borrowing practices are incorporated
Unraveling versus Unraveling: A Memo on Competitive Equilibriums and Trade in Insurance Markets Nathaniel Hendren January, 2014 Abstract Both Akerlof (1970) and Rothschild and Stiglitz (1976) show that
Food & Farming Focus on Market Safety Nets December 215 Agriculture and Rural Development 1 AGRICULTURAL MARKETS AS A DRIVER FOR EUROPEAN AGRICULTURE The agricultural markets and their prices have evolved
RESEARCH PAPER BY RICHARD ATTIAS & ASSOCIATES PLENARY SESSION Scheduled for: August 29, 17.30 REVERSE INNOVATION: AFRICA S BIG OPPORTUNITY We have an abundance of genius; we just need trust and support!
Pricing access to the Internet with partial information Ilaria Brunetti, Eitan Altman, Majed Haddad To cite this version: Ilaria Brunetti, Eitan Altman, Majed Haddad. Pricing access to the Internet with
The Business Impact of the Cloud According to 460 Senior Financial Decision-Makers March 2012 Contents Summary of key findings 4 Finance decision-makers have a high awareness of cloud computing 4 The majority
The Case for a Tax Cut Alan C. Stockman University of Rochester, and NBER Shadow Open Market Committee April 29-30, 2001 1. Tax Increases Have Created the Surplus Any discussion of tax policy should begin
New Keynesian Theory Graduate Macroeconomics I ECON 309 Cunningham New Classical View of Keynesian Economics Failure on a grand scale. Made up of ad hoc assumptions, not built on a strong foundation of
Competitive Assessment of the Spanish Food Supply Chain José Antonio García Juan Delgado The Brattle Group, Ltd. Sucursal en España Torre Europa Paseo de la Castellana 95, Planta 15 28046 Madrid, Spain
Demand Readiness Level (DRL), a new tool to hybridize Market Pull and Technology Push approaches. Introspective analysis of the new trends in Technology Transfer practices. Florin Paun To cite this version:
January 2010 Frontier Economics 1 The economic contribution of sport to Australia This note summarises the findings of the longer Frontier Economics report Why is it important to understand the economic
2 Economic Growth, Poverty and The Child* INTRODUCTION In spite of rapid economic growth in many Third World countries, a disturbingly high rate of death due to child malnutrition continues. The physical
How Income Contingent Loans could affect Return to Higher Education: a microsimulation of the French Case Pierre Courtioux To cite this version: Pierre Courtioux. How Income Contingent Loans could affect
Double Master Degrees in International Economics and Development Detailed Course Content 1. «Development theories and contemporary issues for development» (20h) Lectures will explore the related themes
The Treasury 2015 Loan-to-Value Ratios/Macroprudential Policy Information Release Release Document June 2015 www.treasury.govt.nz/publications/informationreleases/financialsector/lvr www.rbnz.govt.nz/research_and_publications/official_information/lvr-restrictions
Preliminary draft Comments are welcome Institutional Entrepreneurs 1 David Daokui Li Tsinghua University Hong Kong University of Science and Technology Junxin Feng Hongping Jiang Tsinghua University December
NOTES O N FORMALIZATION Evolution of informal employment in the Dominican Republic According to official estimates, between 2005 and 2010, informal employment fell from 58,6% to 47,9% as a proportion of
Mexico Rodolfo Trampe, Jorge Díaz, José Palomar and Carlos López Market overview 1 What kinds of outsourcing take place in your jurisdiction? In Mexico, a subcontracting regime (understood as the regime
Employment Relations Comment The productivity challenge and what the next government should do about it February 2015 Employment Relations Comment will be distributed free of charge via email. Copies can
2 nd EUA Funding Forum: Strategies for efficient funding of universities Bergamo, 9-10 October 2014 Forum report Liviu Matei, General rapporteur Table of contents I. Executive Summary 3 II. What is the
ESRI Research Note The Irish Electricity Market: New Regulation to Preserve Competition Valeria di Cosmo and Muireann Á. Lynch Research Notes are short papers on focused research issues. They are subject
Project Management Organization Article Info:, Vol. 3 (2008), No. 1, pp. 003-009 Received 12 Januar 2008 Accepted 24 April 2008 UDC 005.8 Summary In our work we will try to show, according to recent and
International Economics, 8e (Krugman) Chapter 8 The Instruments of Trade Policy 8.1 Basic Tariff Analysis 1) Specific tariffs are A) import taxes stated in specific legal statutes. B) import taxes calculated
REVIEW of Marxian Political Economy: Theory, History and Contemporary Relevance by Bob Milward. London: Macmillan. 2000. 219 pages. by Fred Moseley, Mount Holyoke College This book is intended as a textbook
Investing in the Infrastructure for Energy Markets Executive Summary: The European Commission, energy ministers and energy regulatory authorities have recognised that, if the European electricity and gas