1 TAXING AND PLEASING: THE RHETORIC AND REALITY OF VERTICAL EQUITY IN THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE NEW ZEALAND INCOME TAX ON EMPLOYEES, 1891 TO 1984 A thesis submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the University of Canterbury by Robert J. Vosslamber University of Canterbury 2010
2 ii NOTE NEW ZEALAND CURRENCY New Zealand adopted decimal currency from 1 July Previously, New Zealand s currency was as follows: One pound ( 1) equaled 20 shillings (20s.) One shilling equaled 12 pence (12d.) On adoption of decimal currency, section 5(4) of the Decimal Currency Act 1964 provided that: One pound ( 1) equaled two dollars ($) One shilling (1s.) equaled 10 cents (c) One penny (1d.) equaled 5 /6 cent. To convert amounts denominated in pounds to dollars, multiply by two.
3 iii ABSTRACT Taxation equity may be classified into horizontal equity, where people who are in the same economic position should be taxed the same, and vertical equity, where those who differ economically should be treated differently. In the New Zealand income tax, the vertical equity norm has primarily been achieved by progressive tax rates, and by family-friendly adjustments. Given that the income tax intentionally discriminates between taxpayers on the basis of taxpayerspecific characteristics such as income level and domestic situation, the question arises as to how the New Zealand income tax in its successive manifestations has been justified as fair; that is, what vertical equity in the New Zealand income tax looked like and how it was justified. This thesis considers the practice of the New Zealand income tax since its introduction in 1891 until By illuminating an employee s lived experience of the income tax, it illustrates what taxation fairness actually looked like in practice, and contrasts this with the rhetoric of those responsible for the tax. It concludes that the reality of external events, rather than the rhetoric of taxation fairness, appears to have been the main driver of taxation practice. By focusing attention on the experience of the taxpayer, rather than merely on aggregated taxation data, legislative provisions or political discussion, the thesis permits the political rhetoric or fairness to be assessed against the fiscal impact on personal taxpayers. The thesis commences by reviewing certain influences on New Zealand income tax thought: from religion, antiquity, and more particularly from certain key British philosophers. It finds that despite their importance, these do not provide a clear direction for taxation policy. The thesis then shifts from philosophical discussions of what constitutes a fair tax to look at what the income tax actually looked like in the case of a wage or salary earner. It adopts an inductive approach by calculating the effect of the income tax legislation on employees at three income levels and in three domestic situations. The resulting nine cases demonstrate how taxpayers were distinguished for the purposes of vertical equity. Returning to the sources, this thesis then reviews contemporary Parliamentary Debates and Reports for evidence of how Parliament justified the practice of vertical equity in the income tax. Despite frequent appeals to fairness or equity, no clear basis was found. Rather, significant changes to the income tax, and thus to the practice of vertical equity, largely reflected pragmatic responses to political or economic events. Yet once such crises had passed, the income tax, and
4 iv vertical equity in that tax, did not revert to the pre-crisis shape, but rather conformed to a new paradigm.
5 v DEDICATION This thesis is dedicated to my wonderful wife, Andy. Without her encouragement and support this thesis would never have been started, let alone completed. Even if this tome merely gathers dust on a shelf at the University of Canterbury library, she, at least, will be a little wiser about the history of New Zealand and of its income tax. Thank you, Duzzy a woman of valour, whose price is above rubies.
7 vii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Reviewing the genesis and progress of a significant project such as this only serves to confirm the advice of the ancient sage that wisdom is found in an abundance of counsellors. Such counsellors provide insight when the lights seem to have dimmed, encouragement when the engine has died, and strength when the body is failing. Thanks to my supervisors, Professor Adrian Sawyer and Professor Philippa Mein Smith. Your on-going help and encouragement were invaluable, and our meetings were always insightful. Many thanks to Fulbright New Zealand for providing the opportunity to spend a year as a Visiting Student Researcher at Boston University. The change of scene not only provided a peaceful venue in which to devote uninterrupted time to my thesis; it also provided a wonderful opportunity to drink deeply of American culture. To the staff at Fulbright: Keep up the good work! Finally, thanks be to God for his daily blessings, not the least of which are the privilege of living in a beautiful, peaceful, and largely non-corrupt country like New Zealand, and the joy of having spent more than half my life with his gift of a wife in Andy.
9 ix Note: New Zealand Currency Abstract Dedication Acknowledgements Table of Contents List of Figures List of Tables TABLE OF CONTENTS ii iii v vii ix xix xxiii Chapter 1: Introduction 1.1 Background 1.2 Research Question 1.3 Methodology and Method Methodology Method 1.4 Structure of the Thesis PART A SETTING THE SCENE 17 Chapter 2: Concepts of Justice and Taxation 2.1 Introduction 2.2 The Meaning of Justice Definitions of justice Approaches to justice 2.3 The Meaning of Taxation 2.4 Tax Fairness Distributive justice Taxation equity Horizontal equity Vertical equity 2.5 Justifications for Vertical Equity in Taxation Benefits theory
10 x Ability to pay theory Sacrifice theory State s prerogative The nature of property Summary 2.6 Conclusion Chapter 3: Historical Context of the New Zealand Income Tax 3.1 Introduction 3.2 General Context The state Taxation The taxpayer Summary 3.3 Philosophical Thought Religion Antiquity: Aristotle The British inheritance Thomas Hobbes Role of the state Property rights Apportionment of taxation John Locke Property rights Apportionment of taxation Adam Smith John S. Mill Fabian socialism 3.4 Conclusion
11 xi PART B THE PRACTICE OF THE INCOME TAX IN NEW ZEALAND 89 Chapter 4: Vertical equity in the New Zealand Income Tax Legislation: Introduction 4.2 The Law of Personal Income Taxation Legislation Differentiation between taxpayers Changes in the balance between direct and indirect taxes Changes in the tax rates structure Changes in the rates of progression Applying a discount or surcharge to the rates structure Enacting supplementary taxes on income Changes in the base of the income tax Changes related to the source of the income Tax expenditures Exemptions a. General Exemption b. Child/Dependent Exemption c. Spouse Exemption d. Insurance Exemption Rebates Negative taxes 4.3 Summary Chapter 5: Income Taxation on Wage and Salary Earners to Introduction 5.2 Scope 5.3 Incomes and Domestic Situations Income Low income earner Middle income earner High income earner
12 xii Family situation 5.4 Effect of the Income Tax on Taxpayers Effect of income level on taxation Effect of domestic situation on taxation 5.5 Identification of Key Episodes The increasing significance of the income tax Splitting into episodes Governments Selection of episodes 5.6 Summary PART C VERTICAL EQUITY IN THE NEW ZEALAND INCOME TAX Chapter 6: The Introduction of the Income Tax in Introduction 6.2 Background 6.3 Equity Considerations in the Debates Legitimacy of taxation Unit of assessment Class Town and country Maori and Pakeha Absentees Moral characteristics Graduation 6.4 Summary Chapter 7: : Bedding in the Income Tax 7.1 General Context 7.2 Taxation Context 7.3 Income Tax Legislation
13 xiii 7.4 Effect on Taxpayers 7.5 Vertical Equity How to tax: Basis of assessment How to tax: The practice of graduation What to tax: Tax base Whom to tax: Relativities between groups Why tax: The role of government 7.6 Summary Chapter 8: : World War One and Its Aftermath 8.1 General Context 8.2 Taxation Context 8.3 Income Tax Legislation Tax rates Adjustments Income source 8.4 Effect on Taxpayers Income level Domestic situation 8.5 Vertical Equity How to tax: Basis of assessment Benefits theory Ability to pay theory Sacrifice theory How to tax: The practice of graduation What to tax: Tax base Whom to tax: Relativities between groups Why tax: Role of government 8.6 Summary Chapter 9: : Interlude 9.1 General Context 9.2 Taxation Context
14 xiv 9.3 Income Tax Legislation Tax rates Adjustments 9.4 Effect on Taxpayers Income level Domestic situation 9.5 Vertical Equity 9.6 Summary Chapter 10: :The Great Depression and the Labour Party Response 10.1 General Context 10.2 Taxation Context 10.3 Income Tax Legislation Tax rates Adjustments 10.4 Effect on Taxpayers Income level Family circumstances 10.5 Vertical Equity How to tax: Basis of assessment Reform Party Labour Party How to tax: The practice of graduation What to tax: Tax base Why tax: Role of government 10.6 Summary Chapter : World War Two and Security 11.1 General Context 11.2 Taxation Context 11.3 Income Tax Legislation Tax rates Adjustments
15 xv 11.4 Effect on Taxpayers Income level Family circumstances 11.5 Vertical Equity General Effect of war How to tax: Basis of assessment Sacrifice theory Ability to pay theory Benefits theory How to tax: The practice of graduation What to tax: Tax base Why tax: Role of government Report of the Taxation Committee 11.6 Summary Chapter 12: : Steady Does It! 12.1 General Context 12.2 Taxation Context 12.3 Income Tax Legislation Tax rates Adjustments 12.4 Effect on Taxpayers Income level Family circumstances 12.5 Vertical Equity The normal post-war tax structure The Black Budget How to tax: The practice of graduation Progression Rates scale Economic development Families
16 xvi Rebates PAYE and the Social Security Levy 12.6 Report of the Ross Taxation Committee 12.7 Summary Chapter 13: : Economic Malaise 13.1 General Context 13.2 Taxation Context 13.3 Income Tax Legislation Tax rates Adjustments 13.4 Effect on Taxpayers Income level Family circumstances 13.5 Vertical Equity Vertical equity, politics, and the economy Report of the McCaw Task Force 13.6 Conclusion PART D PATTERNS AND IMPLICATIONS 339 Chapter 14: Discussion and Review 14.1 Introduction 14.2 General Patterns 14.3 Process of Change Changes in philosophical understandings of vertical equity Role of government Politics 14.4 The New Zealand Experience 14.5 Vertical Equity
17 xvii 14.6 Summary 356 Chapter 15: Conclusions, Limitations, and Future Research 15.1 Introduction 15.2 Significance of the Study 15.3 Limitations of the Study Range of cases Tax types Scope of the study 15.4 Recommendations for Further Study Extension of the study Extension to other tax types Review of specific episodes Extend interdisciplinarity 15.5 Conclusion Appendices Appendix 1: Parliamentary careers of Members of Parliament referred to in the thesis Appendix 2: Membership of Committees convened to investigate into New Zealand taxation References Government Publications Cases Legislation Books, Articles, and Theses Reference Works
19 xix LIST OF FIGURES Structure of historical activity Income vs. non-income sourced taxation ( ) Tax on 100 stated in 1894 pounds (adjusted by nominal wages index) Matrix of taxpayer situations Rate of tax on a single income earner at three income levels Rate of tax on a married income earner with no children at three income levels Rate of tax on a married income earner with three children at three income levels Rate of tax on a low income earner in three household situations Rate of tax on a medium income earner in three household situations Rate of tax on a high income earner in three household situations Total tax revenue as a percentage of GDP Income tax revenue as a percentage of total tax revenue Personal income tax for a high income taxpayer ( ) Personal income tax for taxpayers on a high income ( ) Personal income tax for taxpayers on a medium income ( ) Personal income tax for medium and high income earners who were married but had no children ( ) Personal income tax for medium and high income earner married taxpayers with three children ( ) Personal income tax for taxpayers on a medium income ( ) Personal income tax for taxpayers on a high income ( ) Taxation rates scales 1892, 1913, and 1929 (real) for an income earner who was single Personal income tax for single taxpayers at three income levels ( ) Personal income tax for married taxpayers with no children at three income levels ( ) Personal income tax for married taxpayers with three children at three income levels ( )
20 xx Personal income tax for low income earner in three domestic situations ( ) Personal income tax for medium income earner in three domestic situations ( ) Personal income tax for high income earner in three domestic situations ( ) Personal income tax for a single taxpayer at three income levels ( ) Personal income tax for a married (no children) taxpayer at three income levels ( ) Personal income tax for a married taxpayer with three children at three income levels ( ) Personal income tax on a low income earner in three domestic situations ( ) Personal income tax on a medium income earner in three domestic situations ( ) Personal income tax on a high income earner in three domestic situations ( ) Marginal and average tax rates per the Basic Rates scales 1941, 1955, and 1961 Income taxation on a single income earner at three income levels ( ) Income taxation on a married income earner with no children at three income levels ( ) Income taxation on a married income earner with three children at three income levels ( ) Income taxation on a low income earner in three domestic situations ( ) Income taxation on a medium income earner in three domestic situations ( ) Income taxation on a high income earner in three domestic situations ( )
21 xxi Income taxation on a single income earner at three income levels ( ) Income taxation on a married income earner with no children at three income levels ( ) Income taxation on a married income earner with three children at three income levels ( ) Income taxation on a low income earner in three domestic situations ( ) Income taxation on a medium income earner in three domestic situations ( ) Income taxation on a high income earner in three domestic situations ( ) Process of taxation change
23 xxiii LIST OF TABLES Initial rates of the graduated tax on land Principal Income Taxation Acts to 1984 Highest nominal marginal tax rates (excluding surtaxes) ( ) Taxation discounts/surcharges ( ) Additional taxes ( ) Value of General Exemption ( ) Child Exemption ( ) Dependent Spouse Exemption ( ) General Rebate ( ) Governments of New Zealand ( ) Personal income tax rates ( ) Tax rates scale 1914 Income tax surcharges ( ) Summary of taxation on a single person s income 1892, 1913, and 1929 (nominal) Exemptions as a percentage of a low income earner s income Income tax surcharges or reductions ( )
25 Chapter 1 Introduction Here this extraordinary man, then Chancellor of the Exchequer, found himself in great straits. To please universally was the object of his life; but to tax and to please, no more than to love and to be wise, is not given to men. However, he attempted it. Edmund Burke Background Edmund Burke was probably right: to tax and to please rarely, if ever, meet. Yet through the ages, Chancellors of the Exchequer, Colonial Treasurers, and Finance Ministers have tried to do both. And the populations upon whom they levied their taxes have usually decried their efforts. Aside from judicial punishment and war, taxation is one of the few occasions where a person may lawfully be deprived of his or her property without personal consent, recourse, or recompense. By an act of the ruler or state, private property is almost magically reconstituted as public property; the needs and desires of the ruler or community extinguish certain prior property rights and freedoms of the individual. A political power, backed by an exclusive claim on legal violence, 2 ensures that this transfer actually takes place. Since it involves coercion, taxation is unlikely to be pleasant, except perhaps for those who are exempt. However, taxation might be more or less pleasing, depending upon how it is implemented. Writing in 1776, Adam Smith suggested four maxims for the practice of taxation, whose evident justice and utility have recommended them more or less to the attention of all nations. 3 These included convenience to the taxpayer, non-arbitrariness, and economy. However, his first maxim had to do with the distribution of the tax burden among taxpayers: 1 Edmund Burke, Speech of Edmund Burke, Esq., on American Taxation, in Select Works of Edmund Burke. A New Imprint of the Payne Edition, ed. E. J. Payne (Indianapolis, IN: Liberty Fund, 1999), 1: Gianfranco Poggi, The State: Its Nature, Development and Prospects (Cambridge: Polity Press, 1990), 5. 3 Adam Smith, An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations, ed. Edwin Cannan (London: Methuen, 1950),
26 2 The subjects of every state ought to contribute towards the support of the government, as nearly as possible, in proportion to their respective abilities; that is, in proportion to the revenue which they respectively enjoy under the protection of the state. 4 This suggests that the distribution of the tax burden among residents is central to good tax policy. A maldistribution among taxpayers is unlikely to be pleasing. Yet, as the ambiguity of Smith s first maxim suggests, 5 that the tax burden should be distributed fairly does not tell us how this might be done. Taxation highlights and quantifies questions of distributive justice, an issue that has no simple answer. 6 As a social phenomenon, taxation evinces the role and limits of government, the relationship between the individual and the community, and the relationship between the individuals within the community. Assuming that taxation per se is legitimate, how should that tax be distributed between individuals? Despite the significant questions to which taxes give rise, taxation, let alone fairness in taxation, is a missing actor in much writing on history. Perhaps this is a reflection of Benjamin Franklin s agnosticism that, In this world, nothing can be said to be certain, except death and taxes. Or perhaps taxes are so much a part of the scheme of things that they hardly warrant a mention. In the case of New Zealand, general histories touch lightly on taxation. Easton comments that New Zealand general histories tend to ignore the economy and its implications for the evolution of New Zealand; 7 if the economy tends to be ignored, so too is tax. Recent popular general histories mention taxation briefly, if at all. The popular works of Sinclair, 8 Olssen & Stenson, 9 Belich, 10 King, 11 Mein Smith, 12 and Brooking 13 barely refer to taxation: taxation was there, 4 Ibid. 5 Arthur D. Lynn Jr., Adam Smith's Fiscal Ideas: An Eclectic Revisited, National Tax Journal 29 (1976): Richard A. Musgrave, Equity and the Case for Progressive Taxation, in Tax Justice: The On-Going Debate, ed. Joseph J. Thorndike and Dennis J. Ventry Jr. (Washington, DC: Urban Institute Press, 2002), 9. 7 Brian Easton, A New Economic History of New Zealand, (paper presented at the Asia-Pacific Economic and Business History Conference Sydney, Australia, February, 2007), (accessed 19 November 2009), 2. 8 Keith Sinclair, A History of New Zealand (Auckland: Penguin, 1991). 9 Erik Olssen and Marcia Stenson, A Century of Change: New Zealand (Auckland: Longman Paul, 1989). 10 James Belich, Paradise Reforged: A History of the New Zealanders (Auckland: Penguin, 2001). 11 Michael King, The Penguin History of New Zealand (Auckland: Penguin, 2003).
27 3 occasionally it was politically significant, but otherwise it remained as essential and as invisible as air. Indeed the latest edition of the Oxford History of New Zealand continues this trend, focusing on topical social history almost to the exclusion of economic or even political concerns, and taxation barely rates a mention. 14 Economic histories of New Zealand are rarer. Those that have been written, for example by Condliffe, 15 Lloyd Prichard, 16 Hawke, 17 and Gould, 18 tend to focus on the macro-economy, with little specific attention directed to discussions of taxation. The New Zealand economy changed substantially over the twentieth century, and the increasing role of the state must rank as one of the most significant changes. This increase was largely financed by substantial increases in taxation, and particularly of the income tax, yet taxation is hardly discussed. In a chapter specifically devoted to the economy, Dunstall notes that the distribution of income has long been influenced by state activity, 19 and goes on to mention macro-economic activity and social welfare provisioning, but hardly mentions a significant element of both state activity and distribution, namely taxation. In the introduction to his work on the origins of the Australasian income tax, Harris notes that: This study was in some ways born out of frustration. After many years of research into taxation I had not found a publication on the origins of the Australian income tax. The best book I found, an excellent book, was Mills (1925). 20 New Zealand taxation history is scarcely better served. 12 Philippa Mein Smith, A Concise History of New Zealand (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2005). 13 Tom Brooking, The History of New Zealand (Westport, CT: Greenwood Press, 2004). 14 Giselle Byrnes, The New Oxford History of New Zealand (South Melbourne: Oxford University Press, 2009). 15 John B. Condliffe, New Zealand in the Making: A Study of Economic and Social Development (London: George Allen and Unwin, 1959). 16 Muriel F. Lloyd Prichard, An Economic History of New Zealand to 1939 (Auckland: Collins, 1970). 17 Gary R. Hawke, The Making of New Zealand: An Economic History (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1985). 18 John D. Gould, The Rake s Progress? The New Zealand Economy since 1945 (Auckland: Hodder and Stoughton, 1982). 19 Graeme Dunstall, The Social Pattern, in The Oxford History of New Zealand, ed. Geoffrey Rice (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1992), Peter A. Harris, Metamorphosis of the Australasian Income Tax (Sydney: The Australian Tax Research Foundation, 2002), 7.
28 4 Goldsmith s recently published political history of tax in New Zealand since 1840 provides a welcome exception to this void. 21 His work provides a useful general overview of all types of tax, and highlights the growth of taxation in New Zealand. In contrast to this thesis, Goldsmith focuses on taxation aggregates and legislative change, rather than on the actual effect of the tax on individual taxpayers. There is a trade-off between description and analysis; Goldsmith s breadth of vision and intended popular audience necessarily limit the scope for in-depth analysis. Despite Goldsmith s work, Marriott and Fowler s comment that, Historical research on taxation in New Zealand is limited, 22 remains valid. If there is a dearth of historical taxation research in general, considerations of equity or fairness in taxation over time are even rarer. Murphy and Nagel, in their work subtitled Taxes and Justice, suggest that rhetorical appeals to fairness tend to supplant serious discussions of justice: Whatever the reason, there seems to us to be a gap or at least an under-populated area in philosophical discussion of the ethical dimensions of public policy This is especially important at a time when serious public discussion of economic justice has been largely displaced by specious rhetoric about tax fairness. 23 Such philosophical discussion of the ethical dimensions of taxation would be furthered by some understanding of the historical practice and justifications for taxation policy. A cursory review of taxation history suggests that conceptions of fairness in taxation are not static; instead Ventry suggests that there has been a shift in focus from equity concerns to efficiency concerns in taxation policy discussions and practice: Even into the 1950s, the case for steeply progressive taxation could be defended on ethical and moral grounds Over the last two generations, however, the tax pendulum 21 Paul Goldsmith, We Won, You Lost, Eat That! A Political History of Tax in New Zealand since 1840 (Birkenhead: David Ling Publishing, 2008). 22 Lisa Marriott and Carolyn Fowler, From Social Policy to Economic Policy: Taxation Incentives for Retirement Income Savings in New Zealand ( ), Accounting History 12 (2007): Liam Murphy and Thomas Nagel, The Myth of Ownership: Taxes and Justice (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2002), 4.
29 5 has swung from equity to efficiency concerns. Modern day tax discussions avoid unsettling questions of relative burdens and benefits. 24 Taxation equity suggests interpersonal evaluations, and these might be considered in a number of dimensions, including inter-generational, 25 gender, 26 inter-racial, 27 or even international. 28 At a more general level, taxation equity is usually discussed in terms of the taxation of equals (horizontal equity), and of unequals (vertical equity). Thus Holmes comments, Equity falls into two categories: vertical equity and horizontal equity. 29 Similarly, Cooper et al. note that: Equity, or fairness, has two dimensions: Horizontal equity, which means that people in similar economic circumstances should be treated similarly; and Vertical equity, which means that people in different situations should be treated differently, with those who are better off bearing a greater share of the tax burden. 30 Significantly, the focus of both horizontal and vertical equity is the economic well-being of the taxpayer. Other considerations such as race, gender, and inter-generational equity may be subsumed under the umbrella of horizontal equity; that is, all things being equal, no distinction should be made between persons for tax purposes except on economic grounds. Any distinction based on race, gender, or the like provides an exception to the horizontal equity norm that equals 24 Dennis J. Ventry Jr., Equity versus Efficiency and the U.S. Tax System in Historical Perspective, in Tax Justice: The On-going Debate, ed. Joseph J. Thorndike and Dennis J. Ventry Jr. (Washington, DC: The Urban Institute Press, 2002), On the inter-generational implications of New Zealand social policy in general, refer David Thomson, Selfish Generations? How Welfare States Grow Old (Knapwell, Cambridge: White Horse Press, 1996), Claudia D Scott, Women and Taxation, (Wellington: Institute of Policy Studies, The respective treatment of Maori and Pakeha for tax purposes is worthy of its own study. 28 The implications of globalisation for taxation practice are discussed in Adrian J. Sawyer, Developing a World Tax Organisation: The Way Forward (Birmingham: Fiscal Publications, 2009). 29 Holmes thesis is devoted to examining the meaning of income as a surrogate for the underlying features of a person s well-being. However, unlike this thesis, he specifically focused on horizontal rather than vertical equity, and his approach was conceptual rather than historical: Kevin Holmes, The Concept of Income: A Multi-Disciplinary Analysis (Amsterdam: International Bureau of Fiscal Documentation, 2001), ix. 30 Cooper, Graeme S., Richard E. Krever, and Richard J. Vann. Income Taxation: Commentary and Principles. Sydney: Law Book Company, 1989, p. 24. The same two-fold distinction is made in Ross, Stan, and Philip Burgess, Income Tax: A Critical Analysis (Sydney: LBC Information Services, 1996). The question of whether horizontal has any independent significance apart from vertical equity is subject to debate: refer Paul R. McDaniel and James R. Repetti, Horizontal and Vertical Equity: The Musgrave/Kaplow Exchange, Florida Tax Review 1 (1993):
The Elasticity of Taxable Income: A Non-Technical Summary John Creedy The University of Melbourne Abstract This paper provides a non-technical summary of the concept of the elasticity of taxable income,
Guide to Transparency in Public Finances Looking Beyond the Core Budget 2. Tax Expenditures www.openbudgetindex.org Introduction For more than a decade, civil society organizations around the world, as
The Economics of the Welfare State Third edition NICHOLAS BARR Oxford University Press CONTENTS List of figures xxiii List of tables xxiv Abbreviations xxv PART1. CONCEPTS 1. Introduction 3 2. The historical
Corporate Governance Statement The Board of Directors of APN Outdoor Group Limited (APO) is responsible for the overall corporate governance of APO, including establishing the corporate governance framework
Achieving Pay Equity What needs to happen? Report of CLEW seminar from Sue Ryall, Centre Manager, CLEW The current court case on equal pay (Terranova vs Bartlett) has reinvigorated the discussion and debate
Briefing Paper Wealth taxes: problems and practice around the world There has been considerable recent debate, both in the popular press and in more academic circles, 1 about the possibility of introducing
A Submission to the Treasurer on the Funding Status of The Defence Forces Retirement Benefits and Defence Forces Retirement and Death Benefits Funds AIM To Achieve the Reclassification of the DFRB/DFRDB
The government s economic objective of equity in the distribution personal income basically means that it is striving for a fair, but not necessarily equal, share of income to be distributed to all members
Taxing Capital Gains To Build A Better Future For Our Children: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS: WHAT ARE CAPITAL GAINS? Capital gains are profits from the sale of corporate stocks, bonds, investment
International Tax Services EYEcon October 2002 International trends in dividend taxation Implications for Australian Companies and Tax Policy Report prepared for the ASX Table of Contents Overview...ii
Business Levi Evans Democratic Socialism Sponsoring Faculty Member: Professor Cindi Bearden Levi Evans Democratic presidential primary candidate, Bernie Sanders, wants America to adopt the political and
CGT main residence exemption Why removing the tax concession for homes over $2 million is good for the budget, the economy and fairness Policy Brief Matt Grudnoff January 2016 i ABOUT THE AUSTRALIA INSTITUTE
Cost of living The cost of housing is the single biggest cost of living issue in Australia today. Compared to other expenditure items, housing costs comprise the biggest share of household budgets accounting
STEP Code for Will Preparation in England & Wales Introduction The STEP Code for Will Preparation in England & Wales is a set of ethical principles that operate for the benefit of clients and demonstrate
Improve Rhode Island s Earned Income Tax Credit To Help Hard-working Rhode Islanders March 2014 The Earned Income Tax Credit () is widely recognized as one of the most effective policies at keeping low-income
Summaries of the proposal from the Swedish Committee on Corporate Taxation This document contains a two-page executive summary and a sixpage full summary of the main proposal from the Swedish Committee
Australian Current GDP, GDP deflator, CPI, Population and Share Price Index: Data Sources and Methods By Diane Hutchinson Senior Lecturer School of Economics Faculty of Arts and Social Sciences The University
SPEECH BY MINISTER OF FINANCE MR NHLANHLA NENE South Africa s tax system and the tax reform agenda for 2015 and beyond BER Conference VENUE: Balalaika Hotel, Sandton DATE: 12 June 2015 Good morning and
Economic impacts of expanding the National Insurance Contributions holiday scheme Federation of Small Businesses policy paper Overview This research paper sets out estimates for the economic and employment
The Benefits of a Fully Funded Social Security System By Nathan Taulbee I. INTRODUCTION The Social Security system, formally known as Old-Age and Survivors Insurance Disability Insurance (OASDI), began
Journal of Economic and Social Policy Volume 8 Issue 2 Article 5 1-1-2004 The Costs of Claytons Health Insurance Products Clive Hamilton Australian National University, ACT Richard Denniss Australian National
HELP Interest Rate Options: Equity and Costs Bruce Chapman and Timothy Higgins July 2014 Abstract This document presents analysis and discussion of the implications of bond indexation on HELP debt. This
An economic assessment of the Private Health Insurance system Prepared by Econtech Pty Ltd September 2008 ACHR AUSTRALIAN CENTRE FOR HEALTH RESEARCH AUSTRALIAN CENTRE FOR HEALTH RESEARCH LTD ABN 87 116
Health & the economic crisis: the Australian case Country: Australia Partner Institute: Centre for Health, Economics Research and Evaluation (CHERE), University of Technology, Sydney Survey no: (14) 2009
Income Tax Reform: Base Broadening to Fund Lower Rates John Freebairn University of Melbourne Broadening the income tax base, or taxable sum, by removing special exemptions and deductions has been a characteristic
ENLIGHTENMENT THINKERS AND GOVERNMENT MAN IS BORN FREE, BUT EVERYWHERE IS IN CHAINS. Relevant Questions: Are people born good or bad? Are all people born equal? What is government? Why do societies have
Committee Secretariat Joint Standing Committee on Electoral Matters via email: email@example.com RE: Submission to Inquiry into the funding of political parties and election campaigns. Dear Chair, Thank
Trust Deed for National Provident Lump Sum Cash Accumulation Scheme as amended by Deeds of Amendment dated: 30 September 1991 29 May 1992 30 March 1993 21 July 1993 18 November 1993 21 December 1995 29
The Case for a Tax Cut Alan C. Stockman University of Rochester, and NBER Shadow Open Market Committee April 29-30, 2001 1. Tax Increases Have Created the Surplus Any discussion of tax policy should begin
Chapter 15 Social Contract 15.1 Homework Readings EMP 10, RTD 6, SLB 15 Study Questions : 1. What would be our lives in a state of nature according to Hobbes? 2. What are the four basic facts about the
artificialhorizon.org Aristotle and citizenship: the responsibilities of the citizen in the Politics RALPH HARRINGTON Aristotle s Politics is an investigation of how people live in political communities.
AN OVERVIEW OF AUSTRALIAN FAMILY LAW For the information of clients and prospective clients of Kennedy Partners The breakdown of a marriage or de facto (including same sex) relationship can give rise to
Private Health Insurance (PHI) Proposed means testing not consistent with Community Rating 12 July 2011 On 7 July 2011, the Commonwealth government introduced legislation into Parliament to establish a
CONSTITUTION PREAMBLE We, a group of students in local chapters of the Georgia Technology Student Association affiliated with TSA, recognize the need for and benefits to be derived from the promotion and
Ministerial Conference on Gender Mainstreaming, Competitiveness and Growth OECD, Paris 23-24 November 2000 Gender Budget Initiatives as an aid to Gender Mainstreaming Professor Diane Elson University of
GOVERNMENT EXPENDITURE & REVENUE SCOTLAND 2013-14 MARCH 2015 GOVERNMENT EXPENDITURE & REVENUE SCOTLAND 2013-14 MARCH 2015 The Scottish Government, Edinburgh 2015 Crown copyright 2015 This publication is
The Elasticity of Taxable Income and the Implications of Tax Evasion for Deadweight Loss Jon Bakija, Williams College This draft: February 2014 Original draft: April 2011 I. The Elasticity of Taxable Income
Simple Tax is Better Tax Submission to Re:think Better tax system, better Australia By Lorraine May 2015 Executive Summary The current tax system is needlessly complex. To some degree tax needs to be complex
SIUE Mass Communications Graduate Program Guide & Handbook Designed To Educate & Assist Our Prospective & Current Masters Candidates Copyright SIUE Mass Communications Department 2010 Table of Contents
Taxes and the Common Good A CPJ position statement on taxation Approved by the Board of Directors: May 13, 2011 Our Vision CPJ is committed to seek human flourishing and the integrity of creation as our
1 firstname.lastname@example.org. E-mail submission KASPANZ-KIWI SAVER, ANNUITIES AND SUPERANNUATION PROTECTION ASSOCIATION NEW ZEALAND INCORPORATED Reference the 2013 CFLRI Review and the terms of reference.
HR Services Employee Handbook Conditions Of Service (Research Staff) Duties and Hours of Work Full time research staff are contractually required to work a 35 hour week, however all researchers are expected
Submission to the Commonwealth Parliament, Standing Committee on Tax and Revenue Inquiry into the Tax Expenditures Statement (TES) Dr Julie P Smith, A/Professor Julie P Smith ARC Future Fellow, Regulatory
How much does Connecticut spend on health care? Connecticut Health Care Costs In 2009 Connecticut spent $30.4 billion dollars on health care. That is $8,653.57 for every state resident. And those costs
Annex 1 Primary sources for international standards 1. The United Nations The 1948 Universal Declaration of Human Rights Article 20 1. Everyone has the right to freedom of peaceful assembly and association.
The distribution of tax subsidies for health in Australia Julie Smith Number 43 October 2001 THE AUSTRALIA INSTITUTE The distribution of tax subsidies for health in Australia Julie Smith Senior Research
KEY GUIDE Pensions freedom drawing from your pension Radical reform The changes revealed in the 2014 Budget were described by some retirement planning experts as a pensions revolution. The radical proposals
Curriculum Change A Multidimensional Task University of New South Wales Law School Chief Justice Robert French AC 20 October 2014, Sydney This evening's event marks a significant change in direction in
Subject CT7 Business Economics Core Technical Syllabus for the 2016 exams 1 June 2015 Aim The aim of the Business Economics subject is to introduce students to the core economic principles and how these
Citizens for Tax Justice! 202-299-1066! www.ctj.org November 30, 2006 (6 pp.) An Analysis of Eliminating the Cap on Earnings Subject to the Social Security Tax & Related Issues Recently, there has been
ASPG Conference, Perth Jonathan O'Dea - October 2013 "Financial Overseers and their Oversight A NSW Public Accounts Committee Perspective" OVERVIEW Statutory Officers play central roles as financial overseers
Version: 1.7.2013 South Australia Payroll Tax Act 2009 An Act to re-enact and modernise the law relating to payroll tax; to harmonise payroll tax law with other States; and for other purposes. Contents
+ MSW-001 MSW-002 MSW-003 MSW-00 MSW-00 MSW-006 MASTER DEGREE IN SOCIAL WORK (MSW First Year) Assignment: 12-13 Course Titles MSW-001 : igin and Development of Social Work MSW-002 : Professional Social
Investing in Gender Equality: Ending Violence against Women and Girls Investing in Gender Equality: Ending Violence against Women and Girls Violence against women is a global pandemic: Between and 76 per
Group Life Assurance Technical Guide Page 1 of 10 1. AMTRUST LIFE AIMS The information contained in this guide gives an outline of our approach to insuring Group Life business and our Standard Terms and
THE AUSTRALIA INSTITUTE Health insurance tax rort November 2002 This report concludes that private health insurance funds are facilitating and, in some cases, encouraging tax avoidance by providing products
PUBLIC POLICY AND ADMINISTRATION CURRICULUM Master of Arts DEGREE REQUIREMENTS Credits PA8100 Public Admin & Governance 1 PA8101 Policy Analysis and Challenges 1 PA8102 The State & the Economy 1 PA8103
820 First Street, NE, Suite 510, Washington, DC 20002 Tel: 202-408-1080 Fax: 202-408-1056 email@example.com http://www.cbpp.org Revised April 4, 2001 COST OF TAX CUT WOULD MORE THAN DOUBLE TO $5 TRILLION
5. Income tax and National Insurance contributions The Labour manifesto for the 2001 general election promised that we will not raise the basic or top rates of income tax in the next Parliament. 1 This
ACHPER NSW PDHPE HSC Enrichment Day 2009 Core 1 Health Priorities in Australia Concept map of syllabus What role do health care facilities & services play in achieving better health for all Australians?
FACULTY PROFESSOR(S) R. M. Myers, B.A. (Hons), M. A., Ph.D. (Toronto) ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR(S) D. A. Jackson, B.A. (Hons), M.A. (Toronto) ASSISTANT PROFESSOR(S) N. Cruickshank, B.A. (Hons), M.A. (Wilfrid
2003 Midwest Research to Practice Conference in Adult, Continuing, and Community Education Multigenerational Adult Development Research Project in an Online Graduate Course in Adult Learning Henry S. Merrill
Accounting Standard AASB 1030 (12/94) Application of Accounting Standards to Financial Year Accounts and Consolidated Accounts of Disclosing Entities other than Companies Issued by the Australian Accounting
The Tax Benefits and Revenue Costs of Tax Deferral Copyright 2012 by the Investment Company Institute. All rights reserved. Suggested citation: Brady, Peter. 2012. The Tax Benefits and Revenue Costs of
STAGE 1 STANDARD FOR PROFESSIONAL ENGINEER ROLE DESCRIPTION - THE MATURE, PROFESSIONAL ENGINEER The following characterises the senior practice role that the mature, Professional Engineer may be expected
Compulsory Health Insurance: Should government still be the health insurer of first resort? Prepared by Matthew Crane, Kris McCullough, Jamie Reid and Collin Wang Presented to the Actuaries Institute Actuaries
WATER AND SEWERAGE FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT PLANNING ABSTRACT Chris Adam, Cardno MBK (Qld) Pty Ltd In recent years, the utilities industries have been subject to far greater commercial scrutiny than ever before.
Lifeplan NextGen Investments Essential Guide to Investment Bonds Adviser Use Only Everything you wanted to know about Lifeplan NextGen Investments. March 2014. Is the PDS FoFA compliant? The Lifeplan NextGen
CHAPTER 13 FINANCE General Financial Matters National Revenue Fund 213. (1) There is a National Revenue Fund into which all money received by the national government must be paid, except money reasonably
SUBMISSION TO STATE TAXATION REVIEW April 2015 INTRODUCTION The Australian Hotels Association South Australian Branch (AHA SA) welcomes the opportunity to provide its submission to the SA State Government
The Expatriate Financial Guide to Germany German Tax Facts Introduction Tax Year Assessment Basis Income Tax Taxation in Germany occurs at a national and municipal level. The Ministry of Finance controls
1. Executive Summary For many Australians, their main form of savings over their lifetime is their home. Directing savings towards a home provides two benefits:- Ø A place to live, with security of tenure.
An Evaluation of the Possible Macroeconomic Impact of the Income Tax Reduction in Malta Article published in the Quarterly Review 2015:2, pp. 41-47 BOX 4: AN EVALUATION OF THE POSSIBLE MACROECONOMIC IMPACT
Background Paper 79-1 PROPERTY TAX RELIEF PROPERTY TAX RELIEF Introduction For at least the past decade, demands to reform the property tax have increased in strength and volume. There are several reasons
Citizens for Tax Justice December 11, 2009 Would the Senate Democrats proposed excise tax on highcost employer-paid health insurance benefits be progressive? Summary Senate Democrats have proposed a new,
Property Council of Australia Stamp Duty and the GST A Submission to the Tasmanian Government: May 2000 Table of Contents 1.0 Summary 3 2.0 Introduction 4 3.0 Reasons Against Imposing Stamp Duty on GST
National Small Business Network WRITTEN STATEMENT FOR THE RECORD US SENATE COMMITTEE ON FINANCE U.S. HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES COMMITTEE ON WAYS AND MEANS JOINT HEARING ON TAX REFORM AND THE TAX TREATMENT
Remarks by Dr. N. Gregory Mankiw Chairman Council of Economic Advisers at the National Bureau of Economic Research Tax Policy and the Economy Meeting National Press Club November 4, 2003 My remarks today