Up or Down? A Male Economist s Manifesto on the Toilet Seat Etiquette


 Lilian Davis
 1 years ago
 Views:
Transcription
1 Up or Down? A Male Eonoist s Maniesto on the Toilet Seat Etiquette By Jay Pil Choi* Mihigan State University Noveber 2002 Abstrat This paper develops an eonoi analysis o the toilet seat etiquette, that is, whether the toilet seat should be let up or down. I investigate whether there is any eiieny justiiation or the presuption that en should leave the toilet seat down ater use. I ind that the down rule is ineiient unless there is a large degree o asyetry in the inonveniene osts o shiting the position o the toilet seat aross genders. I show that the selish or the status quo rule that leaves the toilet seat in the position used doinates the down rule in a wide range o paraeter spaes inluding the ase where the inonveniene osts are the sae. The analysis an be applied to other shared ailities that an be ustoized to eah user s preerene. JEL Classiiation: D7, H4. Keywords: gender, eonoi eiieny, soial nor. Correspondent: Jay Pil Choi Departent o Eonois, Mihigan State University East Lansing, MI Eail: * I thank Carl Davidson and Roger Laguno or helpul disussions and any olleagues or sharing their experienes. I a solely responsible or the views expressed in this paper.
2 Dear Annie: I read with interest the letters about putting down the toilet seat. I've been browbeaten by various woen or the past 60 years about proper seat etiquette, starting with y other. I I orget to put the seat down even one, y wie reinds e or hours about this liethreatening situation. I know you said the last olun was the inal word on the subjet, but I hope you'll reopen the issue. I want to ask woen: Who gave you exlusive ownership o the bathroo? I en are nie enough to put the lid down, why an't you ladies lit it up when you are done? When I suggested this to y wie, she wanted to have e taken out and shot. It's tie to rebel! Fed Up in Sale, Ore. Dear Fed Up: What is it about toilet seats that exites people? We reeived hundreds o letters on this subjet and deided the "last word" would have to wait Kathy Mithell and Mary Sugar Introdution Should the toilet seat be let up or down ater use? This is a question that arises when ebers o the opposite sex share the sae toilet. For soe reason, this seeingly trivial question eliits passion ro all sorts o people. It has beoe a topi o national debates in popular syndiated oluns by Ann Landers and TV sitos suh as ABC s Hoe Iproveent and NBC s 3 rd Rok ro the Sun. It is lear that this ageold debate is divided by the gender. 2 Woen oplain that it should be the an s responsibility to lower the toilet seat ater use. Men see to question why woen should be the reeriders all the tie. Despite high eotions in the debate, sientii inquiries into this issue are sparse. In at, it is not obvious why there should be a presuption that en are expeted to leave the toilet seat down ater use. 3 In this paper, I investigate whether there is any 1 Annie s Mailbox by Kathy Mithell and Mary Sugar, Otober 29, Annie's Mailbox is written by Kathy Mithell and Mary Sugar, long tie editors o the Ann Landers syndiated olun. 2 To quote Larry Jaes, a personal relationship ounsellor, The ost hotly ontested battleield in the gender wars ay not be neessarily be in the bedroo. It ay be the bathroo. The seatup vs. seatdown debate rages on 3 Leaving the toilet seat up is oten desribed as a proble and there is even a toilet seat that goes down autoatially ater about two inutes, laiing that it has the peret solution to the proble. 2
3 justiiation or the down rule based on eonoi eiieny. 4 I ind that the down rule is ineiient unless there is large asyetry in the inonveniene osts o shiting the position o the toilet seat aross genders. I show that the selish or the status quo rule that leaves the toilet seat in the position used doinates the down rule in a wide range o paraeter spaes inluding the ase where the inonveniene osts are the sae. The intuition or this result is easy to understand. Iagine a situation in whih the aggregate requeny o toilet usage is the sae aross genders, i.e., the probability that any visitor will be ale is ½. With the down rule, eah ale visit is assoiated with liting the toilet seat up beore use and lowering it down ater use, with the inonveniene osts being inurred twie. With the selish rule, in ontrast, the inonveniene osts are inurred one and only when the previous visitor is a eber o dierent gender. The worst ase under the selish rule would our when the sex o the toilet visitor stritly alternates in eah usage. Even in this ase, the total inonveniene osts would be the sae as those under the down rule i the osts are syetri. I there is any possibility that onseutive users are ro the sae gender, the selish rule stritly doinates the down rule sine it keeps the option value o not inurring any inonveniene osts in suh an event. This logi an be extended to the ase o asyetri aggregate requeny o toilet usage aross genders. The reainder o the paper is organized in the ollowing way. In setion II, I opare three plausible rules or the toilet seat position up, down, and selish on an 4 Internet searh generated the ollowing noneonoi/sientii reasons or the down rule. First, there is an arguent that being onsiderate to one s love partner s needs supports things going well in and out o the bedroo. To quote a phrase in the internet (available at Foreplay begins with putting the toilet seat down without being asked! Seond, it is not good FengShi to leave the toilet seats up. Third, a toilet is not the ost attrative household appliane. Closing the lid iproves its appearane and prevent s things ro alling into the bowl. The last arguent, however, proposes not only the seat down but also the lid down. 3
4 eiieny riterion. I show that the selish rule always doinates the other two i the inonveniene osts o hanging the toilet seat position are the sae aross genders. In setion III, I haraterize the optial rule or the toilet seat position. It turns out that the selish rule is the ost eiient rule in a wide range o paraeter spaes. I also derive the ondition that the down rule an be the ost eiient one when the inonveniene osts are asyetri. Setion IV extends the analysis to the ase where the inonveniene osts are heterogeneous even within the sae gender. Setion V ontains onluding rearks II. The Basi Model I onsider the usage o a toilet that is shared by ebers o the opposite sex. Assue that the proportion o ale to all users o a ertain toilet is given by. Let e assue the requeny o using a toilet by ale and eale is the sae without loss o generality. I one gender uses the toilet ore oten, this asyetry an be releted in. Thus, the paraeter represents the relative aggregate requeny o ale using the toilet. 5 I analyze an ininite horizon disrete tie raework where the toilet is used one in eah period. The disount ator is given by δ. With the assuption about the relative requeny o the toilet usage by eah gender, the probability that the user is ale in eah period is given by. 6 The inonveniene ost o lowering the toilet seat or woen is given by w. The orresponding ost o liting the toilet seat or en is given 5 The relative requeny o en going nuber 1 vs. nuber 2 an be also inorporated in the paraeter. 6 Equivalently, I ould envision a ontinuous tie odel in whih the arrival rate is given by a Possion proess with the arrival rate being a untion o the nuber o total users. The probability that a partiular arrival is ale is given by. I derive essentially the sae results with this ontinuous odel. 4
5 by. My goal in this setion is to opare the expeted aggregate inonveniene osts o three rules down, up, and selish onerning the position o the toilet seat. 7 In this oparative analysis, I abstrat ro other onsiderations suh as being onsiderate to ebers o the opposite sex, aestheti aspets, the wear osts o the seat hinge, et. The Down (FealeFriendly)Rule This is a rule that leaves the position o the seat down ater one is done with the bathroo task. In partiular, this rule iplies that eah visit by a ale eber will be assoiated with the inonveniene osts o 2 whereas eale ebers will inur no osts. Let V and V denote the value untions with the down rule when the partiular user in the urrent period is ale and eale, respetively. Then, these value untions satisy the ollowing reursive relationships. V = 2 + δ[v + (1 ) V ] (1) V = δ[v + (1 ) V ] (2) By solving these two equations, we an get δ V = 1 (2 ) (3) 1 δ δ V = (2 ) (4) 1 δ 7 Even though I use the ter inonveniene osts, and an enopass other types o osts suh as unwittingly plaing one s botto diretly on the porelain and risk o alling in by sitting down without looking when the seat is up or leaving sprinkles on the seat when it is down, respetively. 5
6 Sine the probability o a partiular arrival being ale is, the value untion assoiated with the down rule is: V = V + (1 ) V = (2 ) (5) 1 δ The Up (MaleFriendly)Rule This is a rule that leaves the position o the seat up ater one is done with the bathroo task. In this ase, all the inonveniene osts are inurred by eales. The ase is a irror iage o the down rule and the value untion o this rule an be derived in an analogous way. Let V and V denote the value untions when the partiular user is ale and eale, respetively. Then, these value untions satisy the ollowing relationships. V = δ[v + (1 ) V ] (6) V = 2 + δ[v + (1 ) V ] (7) By solving these two equations, I an derive V = δ (1 ) (2 ) (8) 1 δ δ (1 ) V = 1 (2 ) (9) 1 δ Sine the probability that a partiular arrival is ale is, the value untion assoiated with the down rule is: V = V (1 ) + (1 ) V = (2 ) (10) 1 δ A oparison o equations (5) and (10) yields the ollowing proposition. 6
7 Proposition 1. The down rule is ore eiient than the up rule i and only i > 1. The Selish (Status Quo) Rule This is a rule that leaves the position o the seat as it was used. Let SQ V and SQ V denote the value untions when the partiular user is ale and eale, respetively under the selish rule. Then, these value untions satisy the ollowing relationships. SQ V = (1 ) + δ[v SQ + (1 ) V ] (11) SQ V = + δ[v SQ + (1 ) V ] (12) SQ By solving these two equations, I get SQ V = (1 )(1 δ (1 )) δ (1 ) + 1 δ 1 δ SQ δ (1 ) (1 δ ) V = + 1 δ 1 δ (13) (14) Sine the probability that a partiular arrival is ale is, the value untion assoiated with the down rule is: SQ V = V SQ SQ (1 ) + (1 ) V = ( + ) 1 δ (15) Coparisons o equations (5), (10), and (15) give e the ollowing result. See also igure 1. 7
8 Proposition 2. I the inonveniene osts are the sae aross genders ( = 1), the selish rule doinates both the up and down rules. Perperiod average osts 2 Average Costs with the Up Rule ( 2(1 ) ) Average Costs with the Down Rule ( 2 ) 2 Average osts with the selish rule ( 2 (1 ) ) = 0 = 1 Average osts with the selish rule ( 2 (1 ) ) Figure1. Coparisons o the Up, Down, and Selish Rule or the Syetri Inonveniene Costs ( = 1= ) 8
9 The intuition or Proposition 2 is easy to understand. With either up or down rule, eah eber o one gender group has to inur the inonveniene osts two ties with eah usage. This pratie an be obviously ineiient in the event that onseutive users are ro the sae gender to whih the inonveniene osts are attributed. This ineiieny an be avoided by using the selish rule sine the inonveniene osts are inurred only when the onseutive users are ro dierent genders. Even in suh a event, the aggregate osts would be the sae as those under the up or down rule i the inonveniene osts are the sae aross genders. I annot rule out the optiality o, say, the down rule i the inonveniene osts are asyetri aross genders. My analysis, however, suggests that to justiy the down rule on eiieny grounds, the inonveniene osts or eale should be very high relative to those or ale. More preisely, the ondition or the down rule to doinate the selish rule is γ = 1+ > 1. For instane, i ale and eale users visit the toilet with the sae requeny ( =1/2), the inonveniene osts or eale should be three ties higher than the orresponding osts or ale to justiy the down rule. Up to now, I have onsidered only three potential ehaniss. These three rules, however, are not the only rules we an entertain. For instane, I an iagine a rule suh that the position o the seat should be restored to the prior position beore use. Alternatively, I an also onsider a utually onsiderate rule in whih ale users leave the seat down whereas eale users leave the seat up ater use. In the next setion, however, I show that all these rules are doinated by one o the three rules I have onsidered. Thus, restriting y attention to the three rules does not entail any loss o generality in the analysis. 9
10 III. Charaterization o the Optial Rule: A Mehanis Design Approah In the previous setion, we opared three siple rules that an be used or the toilet seat position. The task o this setion is to derive the ost eiient rule aong all possible ehaniss. I show that one o the three rules disussed in the previous setion is always optial. Thus, restriting y attention to the three rules does not entail any loss o generality i the only onern is to iniize the aggregate inonveniene osts o toilet users. The general rule an be onsidered a olletion o our nubers (σ u, σ d, σ u, σ d ) where σ ij denotes the probability that the seat be down ater use when the position o the seat beore use is i and the visitor is j, where i =u, d and j =,. The irst subsripts u and d denote up and down, respetively and the seond subsripts and denote ale and eale, respetively. The objetive is to searh or the best ehanis that iniizes the aggregate inonveniene osts. In the Appendix, I prove that the position o the seat beore one s use should not ount in the optial rule. Lea. The optial rule should depend only on the gender o the user, not the position o the seat beore one arrives. With the help o lea, I an restrit y searh or the optial ehanis to a lass o rules that an be written as (σ,σ ), where σ and σ are the probabilities that the toilet seat should be in the down position ater usage by a ale and a eale, respetively. 10
11 Let V (σ,σ ) and V (σ,σ ) be the orresponding present disounted value when a partiular user in the urrent period is ale and eale, respetively. V (σ,σ ) = [σ + (1 )σ ] σ + δ[v + (1 ) V ] V (σ,σ ) = [(1 σ ) + (1 )(1 σ ) ] (1 σ ) + δ[v + (1 ) V ] Then, the orresponding value untion or the rule (σ,σ ) an be written as V(σ,σ ) = V (σ,σ ) + (1 ) V (σ,σ ) = M + ( 1 ) F 1 δ, where M = [σ + (1 )σ ] + σ and F= [(1 σ ) + (1 )(1 σ ) ] + (1 σ ) The searh or the optial ehanis is equivalent to solving Min M + (1 )F σ, σ Proposition 3. The optial toilet etiquette is given by the ollowing: Let γ = be the relative ost o hanging the toilet seat position or ale and eale. Then, the optial rule is haraterized by two ritial values o γ (γ and γ ) suh that: (1)The toilet should be down i γ > γ = 1+ 1 (2) The toilet should be let as it was used i (3) The toilet should be up i γ < γ = 2 =γ <γ <γ =
12 Proo. Sine the objetive untion M + (1 )F is a linear untion o σ and σ, I have orner solutions exept the knieedge ases. By dierentiating M + (1 )F with respet to σ and σ, the optial rule is given by: σ σ 1 = any nuber between 0 and1 0 1 = any nuber between 0 and i γ > 11+ i γ = 11+ i γ < 1 i γ > 2  i γ = 2  i γ < 2  Sine 1+ =γ < γ =, we have the desired result. Figure 2 suarizes the 2 1 optial oniguration or dierent values o and γ =. Q.E.D. My analysis an be easily extended to the ase o tievarying γ and. These values, or instane, an hange depending on the tie o the day. The istake osts o unwittingly plaing one s botto diretly on the porelain or risk o alling in are presuably higher during the nighttie when the light is turned o. I this is the ase, the optial rule ould be tiedependent, with the selish rule during the daytie and the down rule during the nighttie. 8 8 A ountervailing arguent against the down rule during the nighttie is that noturia (needing to urinate requently during the night tie) is ore oon with en due to BPH (benign prostati hyperplasia). I thank Carl Davidson or this observation. 12
13 γ = RULE 1+ γ = 1 γ = 1 (Syetri ost) SELFISH RULE γ = 2 RULE 0 1 Figure 2. The Optial Rules with Asyetri Inonveniene Costs 13
14 IV. Heterogeneous Costs within the Sae Gender In the previous setions, I assued that the inonveniene osts are the sae within the sae gender. I extend the analysis to the ase where dierent users have dierent inonveniene osts even within the sae gender. Let e assue that and are distributed aording to ontinuous distribution untions G(.) and H(.), respetively on [0, ). Let and denote the ean values o the inonveniene osts or ale and eale, respetively: = dg = E( ), = dh = E( ) 0 0 It is lear that with heterogeneous inonveniene osts, the optial rule should be haraterized with two ritial values * and * suh that a ale visitor should put the toilet seat down i and only i his * and a eale visitor should put the toilet seat up i and only i her *. Then, σ = G( *) and σ = 1 H( *) using our previous notation. The value untion with the ritial values o * and * an be written as V( *, * ) = M + ( 1 ) F 1 δ, where M = [G( *) + (1 )(1 H( *))] + G( *) E *) and F= [(1 ( G( *)) + (1 ) H( *)] + H( *) E( *) With this observation, the optial ritial values or * and * an be derived by solving Min M + (1 )F *, * The irst order ondition with respets to * and * an be written as: * = + (1 ) 14
15 * = (1 ) (= *) Sine inonveniene osts are nonnegative, the two irst order onditions annot be satisied as interior solutions siultaneously. Taking the boundary onditions into onsideration, I an state the ollowing result. Proposition 4. With the heterogeneous inonveniene osts, the optial toilet rule is given by the ollowing: (1) I >, woen should leave the seat as it was used and a ale visitor 1 should put the toilet seat down ater use i * + (1 ) the selish rule otherwise. and use (2) I <, en should leave the seat as it was used and a eale visitor 1 should put the toilet seat up ater use i * = (1 ) selish rule otherwise. and use the V. Conluding Rearks In this paper, I onduted an eonoi analysis o the ost eiient rule onerning the position o the toilet seat when the objetive is solely to iniize the aggregate osts o inonveniene. This researh is in line with an arguent that soial nors are instruents o olletive optiization when the prie syste is in appliable. 9 The ain result is that unless there is a large degree o asyetry in the inonveniene 9 See Arrow (1971). 15
16 osts o hanging the seat position aross users, the selish rule is the ost eiient one. 10 In addition, the selish rule is inentiveopatible in that it an be selenoring without any outside santions or violating the rule. The analysis has appliability to a wide variety o irustane in whih a aility is used by dierent people and the aility an be ustoized aording to the preerene o eah user. For instane, a ar an be shared by aily ebers who need dierent onigurations o the driver seat. The sae logi iplies that it would be ost eiient to leave the seat position as it was used last i the inonveniene osts o reoniguring the position is the sae aross aily ebers. A oputer shared by dierent people is another exaple. 10 This result, however, should not be onstrued as iplying that selish behavior is optial in other bathroo etiquettes. My analysis will apply only to the ases where dierent users have onliting preerenes. For instane, every user preers lean toilets. In this ase, leaning ater use or the next visitor should be the proper etiquette. This is espeially so sine leaning one s own is less unpleasant than the previous user s. 16
17 Appendix: Proo o Lea To derive the optial rule, I allow the possibility that a visitor s deision an depend on the toilet position prior to one s use. The general rule an be onsidered a olletion o our nubers (σ u, σ d, σ u, σ d ) where σ ij denotes the probability that the seat be down ater use when the position o the seat beore use is i and the visitor is j, where i =u, d and j =,. Suppose that the visitor in a partiular period is ale. At the tie o his arrival, the toilet seat ould be either up or down. Let V u and V d be the value untions when the position o the toilet is up and down at the tie o visit, respetively. I also denote orresponding value untions by V u and V d when the visitor is eale. Then, I an write V u = V d = Max σ u Max σ d σ u [ + δ{v d + (1 ) V d + σ d [ + δ{v d + (1 ) V d }] + (1 σ u )[ δ{v d + (1 ) V d }] }] + (1 σ d )[ δ{v d + (1 ) V d }] Coparison o V u and V d reveals that the optial values or σ u and σ d should be the sae (σ u = σ d ), that is, the optial rule should be orwardlooking and not ontingent on the position prior to the visit. untions as Siilarly, when the visitor in a partiular visit is eale, we an write the value V u = V d = Max σ u Max σ d + σ u [δ{v d + (1 ) V d σ d [δ{v d + (1 ) V d }] + (1 σ u )[ + δ{v d + (1 ) V d }] }] + (1 σ d )[ + δ{v d + (1 ) V d }] One again, oparison o V u and V d reveals that the optial values or σ u and σ d should be the sae (σ u = σ d ). 17
18 Reerenes Arrow, Kenneth, Politial and Eonoi Evaluation o Soial Eets and Externalities, in Intriligator, M., ed., Frontiers o Quantitative Eonois, Asterda: North Holland, 1971, pp Jaes, Larry, Put the Toilet Seat! For Men Only, available at 18
How can firms profitably give away free products? This paper provides a novel answer and articulates
MANAGEMENT SCIENCE Vol. 5, No. 0, Otober 005, pp. 494 504 issn 005909 eissn 56550 05 50 494 informs doi 0.87/mns.050.0400 005 INFORMS TwoSided Network Effets: A Theory of Information Produt Design Geoffrey
More informationThere are only finitely many Diophantine quintuples
There are only finitely many Diophantine quintuples Andrej Dujella Department of Mathematis, University of Zagreb, Bijenička esta 30 10000 Zagreb, Croatia Email: duje@math.hr Abstrat A set of m positive
More informationON THE ELECTRODYNAMICS OF MOVING BODIES
ON THE ELECTRODYNAMICS OF MOVING BODIES By A. EINSTEIN June 30, 905 It is known that Maxwell s eletrodynamis as usually understood at the present time when applied to moing bodies, leads to asymmetries
More informationON THE ELECTRODYNAMICS OF MOVING BODIES
ON THE ELECTRODYNAMICS OF MOVING BODIES By A. EINSTEIN June 30, 905 It is known that Maxwell s eletrodynamis as usually understood at the present time when applied to moing bodies, leads to asymmetries
More informationRandom Walk Inference and Learning in A Large Scale Knowledge Base
Random Walk Inferene and Learning in A Large Sale Knowledge Base Ni Lao Carnegie Mellon University 5000 Forbes Avenue Pittsburgh, PA 15213 nlao@s.mu.edu Tom Mithell Carnegie Mellon University 5000 Forbes
More informationSteering User Behavior with Badges
Steering User Behavior with Badges Ashton Anderson Daniel Huttenlocher Jon Kleinberg Jure Leskovec Stanford University Cornell University Cornell University Stanford University ashton@cs.stanford.edu {dph,
More informationABSTRACT KEYWORDS. Comonotonicity, dependence, correlation, concordance, copula, multivariate. 1. INTRODUCTION
MEASURING COMONOTONICITY IN MDIMENSIONAL VECTORS BY INGE KOCH AND ANN DE SCHEPPER ABSTRACT In this contribution, a new easure of coonotonicity for diensional vectors is introduced, with values between
More informationTHE FIVE DO S AND FIVE DON TS OF SUCCESSFUL BUSINESSES BDC STUDY. BDC Small Business Week 2014
BDC STUDY THE FIVE DO S AND FIVE DON TS OF SUCCESSFUL BUSINESSES BDC Sall Business Week 2014 bdc.ca BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT BANK OF CANADA BDC Sall Business Week 2014 PAGE 1 Executive suary 
More informationA Puzzle about Ontology
NO ^US 39:2 (2005) 256 283 A Puzzle about Ontology THOMAS HOFWEBER University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill 1 Ontology Ontology is the philosophical discipline that tries to find out what there is:
More informationHealth Insurance Coverage
Protecting Your Health Insurance Coverage This booklet explains... Your rights and protections under recent Federal law How to help maintain existing coverage Where you can get more help For additional
More informationSelling assets: When is the whole worth more than the sum of its parts?
Selling assets: When is the whole worth more than the sum of its parts? Robert Marquez University of California, Davis Rajdeep Singh University of Minnesota October, 214 Abstract When is it better to sell
More informationGross Worker Flows over the Business Cycle
Gross Worker Flows over the Business Cycle Per Krusell Toshihiko Mukoyama Richard Rogerson Ayşegül Şahin November 2012 Abstract We build a hybrid model of aggregate labor supply with predictions for gross
More informationCan Anyone Be "The" One? Evidence on Mate Selection from Speed Dating
DISCUSSION PAPER SERIES IZA DP No. 2377 Can Anyone Be "The" One? Evidence on Mate Selection from Speed Dating Michèle Belot Marco Francesconi October 2006 Forschungsinstitut zur Zukunft der Arbeit Institute
More information
Is There NonInferential Justification? James Pryor Princeton University Draft 9 10/13/03. Justification
Is There NonInferential Justification? James Pryor Princeton University Draft 9 10/13/03 I Justification I want to talk about a certain epistemic quality that I call justification,
More informationCritical analysis. Be more critical! More analysis needed! That s what my tutors say about my essays. I m not really sure what they mean.
Critical analysis Be more critical! More analysis needed! That s what my tutors say about my essays. I m not really sure what they mean. I thought I had written a really good assignment this time. I did
More informationRevised Version of Chapter 23. We learned long ago how to solve linear congruences. ax c (mod m)
Chapter 23 Squares Modulo p Revised Version of Chapter 23 We learned long ago how to solve linear congruences ax c (mod m) (see Chapter 8). It s now time to take the plunge and move on to quadratic equations.
More informationSample Attrition Bias in Randomized Experiments: A Tale of Two Surveys
DISCUSSION PAPER SERIES IZA DP No. 4162 Sample Attrition Bias in Randomized Experiments: A Tale of Two Surveys Luc Behaghel Bruno Crépon Marc Gurgand Thomas Le Barbanchon May 2009 Forschungsinstitut zur
More informationMOST DIFFICULT INTERVIEW QUESTIONS
MOST DIFFICULT INTERVIEW QUESTIONS When preparing for an interview, go through the following list of questions and write down appropriate responses. Don t memorize your answers; review them for content
More informationDo Democratic Institutions Constrain or Inform? Contrasting Two Institutional Perspectives on Democracy and War
Do Democratic Institutions Constrain or Inform? Contrasting Two Institutional Perspectives on Democracy and War Kenneth A. Schultz How do domestic political institutions affect the way states interact
More informationFocus Groups as Qualitative Research
Focus Groups as Qualitative Research PLANNING AND RESEARCH DESIGN FOR FOCUS GROUPS Contributors: David L. Morgan Print Pub. Date: 1997 Online Pub. Date: Print ISBN: 9780761903437 Online ISBN: 9781412984287
More informationAn Introduction to Regression Analysis
The Inaugural Coase Lecture An Introduction to Regression Analysis Alan O. Sykes * Regression analysis is a statistical tool for the investigation of relationships between variables. Usually, the investigator
More informationPrice discrimination through communication
Price discrimination through communication Itai Sher Rakesh Vohra May 26, 2014 Abstract We study a seller s optimal mechanism for maximizing revenue when a buyer may present evidence relevant to her value.
More informationRisk Attitudes of Children and Adults: Choices Over Small and Large Probability Gains and Losses
Experimental Economics, 5:53 84 (2002) c 2002 Economic Science Association Risk Attitudes of Children and Adults: Choices Over Small and Large Probability Gains and Losses WILLIAM T. HARBAUGH University
More informationMarch 2005 Estimating the Need By Martha R. Burt and Carol Wilkins CSH Evidence Series
March 2005 Projecting from PointinTime to Annual Estimates of the Number of Homeless People in a Community and Using this Information to Plan for Permanent Supportive Housing By Martha R. Burt and Carol
More informationIs Piketty s Second Law of Capitalism Fundamental?
Is Piketty s Second Law of Capitalism Fundamental? Per Krusell Institute for International Economic Studies, CEPR, and NBER Anthony A. Smith, Jr. 1 Yale University and NBER April 27, 2015 (first version:
More informationAll you need is LATE Primary Job Market Paper
All you need is LATE Primary Job Market Paper Clément de Chaisemartin November 2012 Abstract Instrumental variable (IV) is a standard tool to measure the effect of a treatment. However, it relies on a
More informationDiscovering Value from Community Activity on Focused Question Answering Sites: A Case Study of Stack Overflow
Discovering Value from Community Activity on Focused Question Answering Sites: A Case Study of Stack Overflow Ashton Anderson Daniel Huttenlocher Jon Kleinberg Jure Leskovec Stanford University Cornell
More informationCommon Core State Standards for Mathematical Practice 4. Model with mathematics. 7. Look for and make use of structure.
Who Sends the Most Text Messages? Written by: Anna Bargagliotti and Jeanie Gibson (for ProjectSET) Loyola Marymount University and Hutchison School abargagl@lmu.edu, jgibson@hutchisonschool.org, www.projectset.com
More informationManual on CloseOut Procedures. Third Edition January 1985
Manual on CloseOut Procedures Third Edition January 1985 Manual on CloseOut Procedures Third Edition January 1985 Municipal Securities Rulemaking Board 1900 Duke Street, Suite 600 Alexandria, VA 22314
More information3Session. Why Do Children Do What They Do? Positive Solutions for Families. The Center on the Social and Emotional Foundations for Early Learning
Why Do Children Do What They Do? 3Session Positive Solutions for Families The Center on the Social and Emotional Foundations for Early Learning Learner Objectives Suggested Agenda Examine why children
More information