How Control Systems Influence the Salesperson s Objective Performance: An Empirical Investigation Vincent Onyemah, Boston University, USA Erin Anderson, INSEAD, France Boston University School of Management Working Paper #2005-06
ABSTRACT Based on the analyses of archival performance data matched with a survey of 1,290 salespeople working in Africa, Europe, and North America, this paper demonstrates the existence of a curvilinear relationship between salesperson performance and sales force control system. Contrary to expectations informed by extant literature, there is evidence of situations where behavior-based control systems yield better sales performance than outcome-based control systems. Further, mixed control systems-- offshoots of outcome- and behavior-based control philosophies have both strengths and weaknesses which directly reflect on salesperson performance. Analysis using a varying parameter model shows that the above relationships remain after controlling for the moderating influence of sales manager s personal and professional investment orientation toward the salesperson. The consequences of steering a middle ground with the aid of mixed control systems are investigated and discussed. This paper closes with a discussion of its findings and the implications of these for research and management practice. 1
SELECTED REFERENCES Armstrong, Scott J. and Terry S. Overton (1977), Estimating Nonresponse Bias in Mail Surveys, Journal of Marketing Research, 14 (August), 396-402. Anderson Erin and Oliver Richard (1987), Perspectives on Behavior-Based Versus Outcome-Based Salesforce Control Systems, Journal of Marketing, 51 (October), 76-88. Argyris, Chris (1957), Personality and Organizations: The Conflict between the System and the Individual. New York: Harper. Bennis, W. G. (1966), Changing Organizations. New York: McGraw-Hill. Bergen M, Dutta S and Walker, Jr. O (1992), Agency Relationships in Marketing: A Review of the Implications and Applications of Agency and Related Theories, Journal of Marketing, 56 (July), 1-24. Challagalla Goutam and Shervani Tasadduq (1996), Dimensions and Types of Supervisory Control: Effects on Salesperson Performance and Satisfaction, Journal of Marketing, 60 (January), 89-105. Churchill, Gilbert A., Jr., Neil M. Ford, Steven W. Hartely, and Orville C. Walker, Jr. (1985), The Determinants of Salesperson Performance: A Meta-Analysis, Journal of Marketing Research, 22 (May), 103-18. Coughlan, Anne T. and Subrata K. Sen (1986), Salesforce Compensation: Insights from Management Science, Working Paper 86-101, Marketing Science Institute. Cravens David, Ingram Thomas, LaForge Raymond and Young Clifford (1993), Behavior-Based and Outcome-Based Salesforce Control Systems, Journal of Marketing, 57 (October), 47-59. Futrell Charles M and Patrick L Schul (1978), Sales Management Control and Job Performance, Industrial Marketing Management, 7(5), pg. 311. Gatignon, Hubert (2003), Statistical Analysis of Management Data. Kluwer Academic Publishers. ---------------- and Dominique Hanssens (1987), Modeling Marketing Interactions with Application to Salesforce Effectiveness, Journal of Marketing Research, 24, 247-57. Gibson, James L., Jihn M. Ivancevich, and James H. Donelly (1973), Organizations: Structure, Proceses, Behavior. Dallas: Business Publications, Inc. 32
Gulick, L., and L. Urwick (1937), Papers on the Science of Administration. New York: Institute of Public Administration. Jackson, Donald W., Jr., Janet E. Keith, and John L. Schlacter (1983), Evaluation of Selling Performance: A Study of Current Practices, Journal of Personal Selling and Sales Management, 3 (November), 42-51. Jaworski, B J (1988), Toward a Theory of Marketing Control: Environmental Context, Control Types, and Consequences, Journal of Marketing, 52, 23-39. Jaworski, Bernard J., Vlasis Stathakopoulos, and H. Shanker Krishnan (1993), Control Combinations in Marketing: Conceptual Framework and Empirical Evidence, Journal of Marketing, 57 (January), 57-69. Joshi A W and S Randall (2001), The Indirect Effect of Organizational Controls on Salesperson Performance and Customer Orientation, Journal of Business Research 54, 1-9. Kerin Roger A., Eric N. Berkowitz, Steven W. Hartley, and William Rudelius (2003), Marketing. 7 th Edition: McGraw-Hill Irwin. Lataif E Louis (1993), We Must Manage Process Not Function, The MBA Newsletter, Vol 2 (7). Leigh W Thomas, Ellen B Pullins, and Lucette B. Comer (2001), The Top Ten Sales Articles of the 20 th Century, Journal of Personal Selling and Sales Management, 21 (3), 217-227. Lusch R F and B J Jaworski (1991), Management Controls, Role Stress and Retail Store Manager Performance, Journal of Retailing (Winter), 67(4), 397-419. McMahon Tomothy J and G. W. Perritt (1971), The Control Structure of Organizations: An Empirical Examination, Academy of Management Journal, Vol 14 (Dec), 327-340. Merchant A. Kenneth (1985), Control in Business Organizations, Pitman series in the role of accounting in organizations and society. Oliver Richard L and Anderson Erin (1994), An Empirical Test of the Consequences of Behavior- and Outcome-Based Sales Control Systems, Journal of Marketing 58 (October), 53-67. -------- and -------- (1995), Behavior- and Outcome-Based Sales Control Systems: Evidence and Consequences of Pure-Form and Hybrid Governance, Journal of Personal Selling & Sales Management, Volume XV, Number 4 (Fall 1995), 1-15. 33
Ouchi, William Z. (1979), A Conceptual Framework for the Design of Organizational Control Mechanisms, Management Science, 25 (September), 833-47. Ouchi, William Z. and Maryann McGuire (1975), Organizational Controls: Two Functions, Administrative Science Quarterly, 20 (December), 559-569. Piercy F. Nigel, David W. Cravens, and Neil A. Morgan (1998), Salesforce Performance and Behaviour-Based Management Processes in Business-to-Business Sales Organizations, European Journal of Marketing Vol 32, No. 1/2, 79-100. Stathakopoulos, Vlasis (1996), Sales Force Control: A Synthesis of Three Theories, Journal of Personal Selling and Sales Management, 16 (Spring), 1-12. Urwick L. (1944), The Elements of Administration. New York: Harper. Weber M. (1947), The Theory of Social and Economic Organizations. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Williamson, Oliver E. (1981), The Economics of Organization: The Transaction Cost Approach, American Journal of Sociology, 87 (3), 548-77.